Purdue University From the SelectedWorks of Peter J. Aschenbrenner October, 2013 Table Annexed to Article: Hamilton and Madison Deploy stitution In The Federalist Papers: Semantic Values Surveyed Peter J. Aschenbrenner, Purdue University Available at: http://works.bepress.com/peter_aschenbrenner/69/
TABLE ANNEXED TO ARTICLE: HAMILTON AND MADISON DEPLOY CONSTITUTION IN WORKS DATED TO 1787/88, 1790/91 AND 1817-1836 SEMANTIC VALUES SURVEYED 2 OCL 331 TABLE 331A SEMANTIC VALUES SURVEYED IN THE FEDERALIST BY WORD, BY ESSAY, BY AUTHOR {WITH WORD COUNTS PER ESSAY} Proposed Federal Federalist Ancient tinental Author stitution stitutions No. s s f n Misc Hits Words 1 Hamilton 2 6 1 9 1,594 2 Jay 0 1,654 3 Jay 0 1,445 4 Jay 0 1,639 5 Jay 0 1,346 6 Hamilton 1 1 2,204 7 Hamilton 1 1 2,267 8 Hamilton 2 1 2 5 2,020 9 Hamilton 1 2 1 4 1,996 10 Madison 1 1 1 3 3,003 11 Hamilton 0 2,523 12 Hamilton 0 2,156 13 Hamilton 0 968 14 Madison 1 1 2 2,157 15 Hamilton 3 1 2 1 7 3,100 16 Hamilton 5 1 2 8 2,042 17 Hamilton 2 2 1,589 18 Madison 2 2 2,109 19 Madison 4 4 2,045 20 Madison 9 9 1,520 21 Hamilton 1 1 2 5 9 1,994
Proposed Federal Federalist Ancient tinental Author stitution stitutions No. s s f n Misc Hits Words 22 Hamilton 2 3 5 3,554 23 Hamilton 3 1 1 5 1,826 24 Hamilton 8 1 9 1,996 25 Hamilton 2 2 1 5 1,980 26 Hamilton 2 3 5 2,382 27 Hamilton 1 3 4 1,475 28 Hamilton 1 1 1,599 29 Hamilton 4 4 2,228 30 Hamilton 2 1 1 4 1,965 31 Hamilton 1 2 1 1 5 1,729 32 Hamilton 1 4 2 7 1,484 33 Hamilton 4 10 1 15 1,678 34 Hamilton 1 1 2 4 2,208 35 Hamilton 1 1 2,266 36 Hamilton 2 1 3 2,818 37 Madison 3 1 1 5 2,726 38 Madison 9 1 3 2 15 3,333 39 Madison 1 11 1 5 18 2,613 40 Madison 3 4 3 2 2 14 3,021 41 Madison 11 5 3 19 3,558 42 Madison 4 4 2,778 43 Madison 6 12 2 1 2 23 3,438 44 Madison 3 17 10 30 2,916 45 Madison 4 1 5 2,134 46 Madison 1 1 2,636 47 Madison 2 1 8 17 28 2,765 48 Madison 2 15 17 1,859 49 Madison 3 5 1 1 10 1,648 50 Madison 4 1 3 1 9 1,111 51 Madison 2 3 1 1 7 1,921 52 Madison 2 2 3 7 1,868 53 Madison 2 5 7 2,177 54 Madison 9 1 10 2,005 55 Madison 4 1 5 2,047
Proposed Federal Federalist Ancient tinental Author stitution stitutions No. s s f n Misc Hits Words 56 Madison 0 1,588 57 Madison 4 1 1 6 2,226 58 Madison 5 5 3 1 3 17 2,099 59 Hamilton 3 3 6 1,907 60 Hamilton 1 2 3 2,254 61 Hamilton 1 8 9 1,519 62 Madison 4 3 7 2,417 63 Madison 3 1 2 2 1 9 3,057 64 Jay 2 6 1 9 2,311 65 Hamilton 1 2 1 4 2,037 66 Hamilton 1 1 3 5 2,259 67 Hamilton 1 6 7 1,644 68 Hamilton 1 1 1 1 4 1,506 69 Hamilton 1 2 3 4 10 3,021 70 Hamilton 1 1 1 2 4 9 3,107 71 Hamilton 3 1 4 1,753 72 Hamilton 2 1 3 2,044 73 Hamilton 4 3 1 8 2,369 74 Hamilton 1 1 2 1,009 75 Hamilton 2 1 3 1,927 76 Hamilton 2 2 1,908 77 Hamilton 1 1 3 5 2,010 78 Hamilton 7 14 4 3 28 3,069 79 Hamilton 1 5 6 1,049 80 Hamilton 5 9 14 2,454 81 Hamilton 7 7 3 17 3,907 82 Hamilton 2 2 4 1,542 83 Hamilton 4 13 5 22 5,538 84 Hamilton 3 13 2 2 15 35 4,158 85 Hamilton 2 5 3 2 1 13 2,667 Totals 115 255 53 27 19 134 5 4 15 18 3 648 189,469
TABLE 331B SEMANTIC VALUES CUMULATED THROUGH TFP S 85 ESSAYS BY AUTHOR {WITH WORD COUNTS BY AUTHOR} Author Proposed Federal Essays Ancient tinental Total Total stitution stitutions Misc Assigned s s Hits Words f n Jay 5 2 6 1 9 8,395 Hamilton 51 75 139 30 8 11 65 4 1 12 1 346 112,299 Madison 29 38 110 23 19 7 69 1 4 14 6 2 278 68,774 Totals 85 115 255 53 27 19 134 5 4 15 18 3 648 189,469
TABLE 331C SEMANTIC VALUES SURVEYED IN THE FIRST BANK BILL DEBATE BY SPEECH/WORK {WITH WORD COUNTS PER WORK} Writing by Title Hamilton s (Second) Report on Public Credit Hamilton s Report on a National Bank Madison s Speech in the House of Representatives Madison s Speech in the House of Representatives Hamilton s Opinion on the stitutionality of the National Bank [1] Date of Writing Federal stitution Gov Text RC stitutions Gov Text RC Ancient s tinental s f n. Bank Hits Words 12/13/90 0 3,865 12/13/90 2 1 10 13 15,039 2/02/91 22 1 1 24 3,770 2/08/91 12 12 2,048 2/23/91 15 49 1 65 12,759 Totals 17 84 0 0 0 2 0 0 0 0 11 114 37,418 Notes to Table: [1] The use of the term constitution in the title of Hamilton s opinion of February 23, 1791 was ignored.
TABLE 331D SEMANTIC VALUES CUMULATED IN THE FIRST BANK BILL DEBATE BY AUTHOR {WITH WORD COUNTS BY AUTHOR} Author Federal Speeches Ancient tinental. Total Total stitution stitutions Assigned s s Bank Hits Words f n Hamilton 3 17 50 1 10 78 31,663 Madison 2 34 1 1 36 5,818 Totals 5 17 84 0 0 0 2 0 0 0 0 11 114 37,481
TABLE 331E SEMANTIC VALUES SURVEYED IN MADISON S WORKS AFTER 3/3/1817 BY DOCUMENT {WITH WORD COUNTS BY DOCUMENT} Federal State Farrand Ancient tinental Date To/Title stitution stitutions Numeral s s f n Misc Hits Words n/a 3/3/1817 Bonus Bill Veto 12 12 817 320 12/23/1817 John Quincy Adams 0 130 321 12/27/1817 James Monroe 1 1 54 324 11/2/1818 John Quincy Adams 1 1 115 329 6/7/1819 John Quincy Adams 0 102 330 6/27/1819 John Quincy Adams 0 151 331 9/2/1819 Judge Roane 3 3 150 332 11/27/1819 Robert Walsh 9 9 1,099 333 1/11/1820 Robert Walsh 0 117 335 2/10/1820 President Monroe 1 1 160 337 6/13/1820 John Quincy Adams 0 237 339 8/26/1821 Joseph Gales 1 1 345 340 9/15/1821 Thomas Ritchie 3 3 588 341 12/27/1821 J. G. Jackson 1 2 1 4 691 342 1821 Note to Speech on Right of Suffrage 1 1 2,257 343 1821 Genl. Remarks on the vention 1 1 2 294 345 8/23/1823 George Hay 1 1 2 382 347 1/14/1824 Thomas Jefferson 1 1 113 350 4/17/1824 Edward Livingston 3 3 310 351 6/25/1824 Henry Lee 2 2 115 352 1/14/1825 Henry Lee 2 2 207 356 3/25/1826 Andrew Stevenson 1 1 382 357 12/26/1826 Thomas Cooper 1 1 2 368 358 2/2/1827 S. H. Smith 1 1 212 359 6/3/1827 Edward Everett 1 1 151 361 12/29/1827 George Mason 1 1 93 363 5/13/1828 Martin Van Buren 0 155
Federal State Farrand Ancient tinental Date To/Title stitution stitutions Numeral s s f n Misc Hits Words 364 9/18/1828 J. C. Cabell 4 4 163 365 2/2/1829 J. C. Cabell 0 261 366 2/13/1829 J. C. Cabell 0 139 370 5/1830 M. L. Hurlbert 0 91 371 5/1830 James Hillhouse 2 2 62 372 11/17/1830 Andrew Stevenson 36 1 37 4,777 373 12/3/1830 J. K. Teft 0 98 374 1/6/1831 Reynolds Chapman 1 1 264 375 2/2/1831 C. J. Ingersoll 2 2 188 376 2/12/1831 Theodore Sedgewick Jr 0 450 377 3/27/1831 James Robertson 0 192 379 4/8/1831 Jared Sparks 2 2 798 380 4/1831 J. K. Paulding 1 1 174 381 4/1831 J. K. Paulding 1 1 254 382 6/6/1831 J. K. Paulding 0 157 383 6/27/1831 Jared Sparks 1 1 675 384 6/27/1831 J. K. Paulding 0 67 385 6/1831 On the Pinckney Plan 6 6 3,311 387 11/25/1831 Jared Sparks 2 2 764 388 12/1831 N. P. Trist 5 5 996 389 2/6/1832 James T. Austin 0 153 390 1832 Professor Davis 7 7 1,098 391 10/21/1833 W. C. Rives 2 2 4 1,536 392 1833 John Tyler 1 20 1 1 23 3,021 393 1/6/1834 Thomas S. Grimke 4 4 764 394 3/10/1834 William Cogswell 1 1 52 396 10/15/1834 Edward Coles 1 1 30 397 6/5/1835 W. A. Duer 7 1 1 9 1,446 398 1835-6 On Nullification 4 4 185 399 2/27/1836 Joseph Wood 1 1 68 400 3/1836 Unknown 0 174 Preface to Debates in the 401 1836 vention of 1787 / 2 5 1 8 5,417 Sketch Never Finished n/a 1818 The Detached Memoranda 4 4 955 n/a 4/19/1835 Will of James Madison 1 1 289 Totals 6 166 7 0 0 5 0 0 0 0 1 185 38,864
Document Group / Author Works Assigned TABLE 331F GRAND TOTALS: ALL SEMANTIC VALUES {PREVIOUSLY SURVEYED] CUMULATED Proposed/ Federal stitution BY DOCUMENT GROUP / AUTHOR {WITH WORD COUNTS PER GROUP / AUTHOR} stitutions Ancient s tinental s f n. Bank Misc. Total Hits Total Words The Federalist 85 115 255 52 27 20 134 4 4 15 18 3 648 189,469 Jay 5 2 6 1 9 8,395 Hamilton 51 75 139 30 8 11 65 4 1 12 1 346 112,299 Madison 29 38 110 23 19 7 69 1 4 14 6 2 278 68,774 Bank Bill 5 17 84 2 11 114 37,481 Debate Hamilton 3 17 50 1 10 78 31,663 Madison 2 34 1 1 36 5,818 Madison Writings Post 3/1817 61 6 166 7 5 1 185 38,864
TABLE 331G GRAND TOTALS FOR THE FEDERALIST SEMANTIC VALUES {PREVIOUSLY SURVEYED} CUMULATED BY AUTHOR Author Proposed/ Federal Works Ancient tinental. Total Total stitution stitutions Misc. Assigned s s Bank Hits Words f n Jay 5 2 6 1 9 8,396 Hamilton 54 92 189 29 8 11 66 4 1 12 10 1 423 143,962 Madison 89 44 310 30 19 7 75 1 4 14 6 1 3 499 107,783 Totals 148 138 505 59 27 19 141 5 4 15 18 11 4 931 260,141