JOINT FAO/IAEA DIVISION OF NUCLEAR TECHNIQUES IN FOOD AND AGRICULTURE PROPOSED DRAFT REVISION OF THE LIST OF METHODS FOR PESTICIDE RESIDUE ANALYSIS INCLUDING METHODS OF DETERMINATION FOR DITHIOCARBAMATES COMMONLY USED METHODS FOR PESTICIDE RESIDUE ANALYSIS IN FOOD SUMMARY In the following Article commonly applicable methods for the determination of residues of pesticides, including dithiocarbamates, bromide ion derived from methyl bromide and PCB, analysis in food are described. The analytical methods compiled here represent official and validated methods. Abstracts with short descriptions of the scope and applicability including the respective sources of procurement are given. Some of them are available as full methods and can be downloaded directly as pdf, as far as possible in terms of copyright protection, or download links are given to external URLs. Updates on analytical methods were submitted by Canada, Germany, The Netherlands and the USA. EDITOR'S NOTE Most of the analytical methods used in pesticide residue analysis worldwide utilize similar principles of extraction, clean-up and determination. In the scientific literature a multitude of publications can be found. However, for food control laboratories there are certain practical limitations to apply methods, particularly in terms of the national and international recognition of results obtained with that. Only export certificates issued by accredited laboratories using fully validated and officially recognized methods will easily meet import requirements and can be a strong support in food trade. In that regard, IAEA's webpage and the INFOCRIS database provide a comprehensive overview about the most widely used methods to guide interested laboratories towards appropriate methods for any analytical problem related to the determination of pesticides and several pesticide metabolites, as well as other potential contaminants like PCBs. The following gives an overview and makes reference to the original methods and literature sources. It is intended to provide a traceable path towards applicable methodologies. The information given here provides a short summary. For utilizing the detailed procedures the reader is referred to the original methods which are available from the cited references. Text and tables used here were taken from the following sources: CL 2005/52 PR, December 2005, CX 4/40.2, Proposed Draft Revision of the List of Methods for Pesticide Residue Analysis at Step 3. CX/PR 03/10, March 2003, CODEX COMMITTEE ON PESTICIDE RESIDUES Thirtyfifth session, DISCUSSION PAPER ON THE REVISION OF THE LIST OF METHODS OF ANALYSIS FOR PESTICIDE RESIDUES, prepared by The Netherlands. German Comments on CL 2001/29 PR; Methods of Analysis for the Determination of Pesticide Residues. CX/PR 99/10 1, February 1999, CODEX COMMITTEE ON PESTICIDE RESIDUES Thirty-first Session, RECOMMENDATIONS FOR METHODS OF ANALYSIS AND SAMPLING, REVISION OF THE LIST OF METHODS OF ANALYSIS FOR 1 For CX/PR 99/10 see (http://www-infocris.iaea.org/download/reprint-pr99_10e.pdf) - 1 -
PESTICIDE RESIDUES AND OTHER MATTERS RELATED TO METHODS OF ANALYSIS FOR PESTICIDE RESIDUES (Prepared by The Netherlands). In order to facilitate reading the compiled information the text and tables were edited and supplemented as necessary. It has to be noted that many of the published methods are protected by international copyright. Others can be downloaded (see URLs given on this webpage). Therefore detailed methods are not displayed here. However, with the given abstracts and descriptions a reasonable choice of methods is facilitated for interested parties. METHODS FOR PESTICIDE RESIDUE ANALYSIS AVAILABLE TO THE CODEX COMMITTEE FOR PESTICIDE RESIDUES (CCPR) BACKGROUND From the responses on CL 1998/30-PR it became clear that the majority of the laboratories use modifications of methods published in either one of the following manuals: Official Methods of AOAC INTERNATIONAL; published in Journal of AOAC INTERNATIONAL (JAOAC), http://www.aoac.org/pubs/pubjaoac.html; Pesticide Analytical Manual, Food and Drug Administration, USA; Vol. 1, 3rd Edition, 1994, Revised, October 1999, http://www.cfsan.fda.gov/~frf/pami1.html; Vol. 2, Updated January, 2002; Manual of Pesticide Residue Analysis, Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (German or English edition); VCH 2 Weinheim, Vol. 1 (1987) and Vol. 2 (1992) (for details see also the European Norms referenced below); Analytical Methods for Residues of Pesticides, Inspectorate for Health Protection of the Netherlands, see Analytical Methods for Pesticide Residues in Foodstuffs, 6th edition (1996), Ministry of Public Health, Welfare and Sport, Rijswijk, The Netherlands Part I, Multi-Residue Methods 1-3. The majority of the responses referred to pesticides amenable to gas chromatography or the analysis of carbamates by liquid chromatography with fluorescence detection. These methods cover approximately 75% of the compounds in the Codex system. In CL 2002/16-PR requested Member governments and interested organizations to provide descriptions of their analytical methods together with their scope and available validation data. In previous discussions it was stressed that methods included in the list should reflect current rather that past practices in pesticide residue analysis. The responses to CL 2002/16-PR yielded more recent information on validated methods that are currently in use 3. Moreover in its 35 th session the Committee was informed by the Delegation of Germany on a new LC/MS multi-method 4 that covers many pesticides that were not covered by multi-residue methods before. The Committee decided that older references for these compounds are to be deleted. The Delegation of The Netherlands offered to review the list of methods and to identify the pesticides for which MRLs have been set but for which no suitable methods were made available to the Committee during the last 5 years. 2 Books cannot be ordered anymore. Methods and supplements are now integrated in "Lebensmittel-, Bedarfsgegenstaende- und Futtermittelgesetzbuch (LFGB), Amtliche Sammlung von Untersuchungsverfahren nach Paragraph 64" (Official collection of test procedures according to paragraph 64 LFGB for food surveillance and testing institution), method collection available from Beuth Verlag, Berlin, Germany, http://www.beuth.de. However, some of the "old" multi-residue and single methods can be downloaded at http://www.bfr.bund.de/cd/1637 and http://www.bfr.bund.de/cd/1652 3 CX/PR 03/10 4 J. Klein and L. Alder: Application of Gradient Liquid Chromatography with Tandem Mass Spectrometry to the Simultaneous Screening for About 100 Pesticides in Crops. J. Assoc. Off. Anal. Int. 86 (2003) 1015. For the abstract see in (http://www-infocris.iaea.org/download/germany-en-methods.pdf) - 2 -
SUMMARY OF METHODS AVAILABLE TO THE COMMITTEE AT PRESENT Analytical methods for the determination of pesticides, including dithiocarbamates, bromide ion derived from methyl bromide and PCBs. The procedures are summarized and referenced below. In addition to the abstracts complete methods are provided for downloading, as far as possible with regard to copyright protection. CANADA Canada submitted descriptions of ten methods currently used in their country. These methods were also made available for downloading. References to, abstracts and download addresses of the methods as submitted by Canada are given in (http://www-infocris.iaea.org/download/canada- Methods.pdf). GERMANY Germany submitted a number of European standardized methods and provided information on their scope, principle validation data and further aspects, where appropriate 5. The methods submitted cover both pesticide residues as well as contaminants. The resulting European Standards were elaborated by CEN/TC 275 "Food analysis - Horizontal methods" as proposed by the German delegation to be endorsed as CODEX-methods by the CCFAC. References to and abstracts of the methods as submitted by Germany are given in (http://wwwinfocris.iaea.org/download/germany-en-methods.pdf). UNITED STATES OF AMERICA The United States of America submitted brief descriptions of the methods together with validation data utilized in their USDA Pesticide Data Program (PDP) http://www.ams.usda.gov/science/pdp/quick.htm. References to and abstracts of the methods as submitted by the USA are given in (http://www-infocris.iaea.org/download/usa-methods.pdf). THE NETHERLANDS The Netherlands submitted brief descriptions of methods. References to and a brief listing of the methods as submitted by The Netherlands are given in (http://wwwinfocris.iaea.org/download/dutch-methods.pdf). PREVIOUS INPUTS FOR ANALYTICAL METHODS TO CCPR Inputs to Codex provided by other countries are from 1999. As this information needs updating it was not listed here. The country information provided for the 31 st session of the CCPR can be found under http://www-infocris.iaea.org/download/reprint-pr99_10e.pdf. PESTICIDES FOR WHICH NO METHODS ARE AVAILABLE TO THE CCPR YET Governments and International Organizations are invited to submit information on methods of analysis and their performance characteristics on the following pesticides: 5 34 th session of the CCPR, CRD5-3 -
abamectine (177), amitraz (122), anilazine (163), azocyclotin (129), benalaxyl (155), benomyl (69), bentazone (172), bioresmethrin (93), bitertanol (144), buprofezin (173), cadusofos (174), cartap (97), chinomethionat (80), chlormequat (15), ciprodinil (207), clofentezine (165), cycloxydim (179), cyhexatin (67), cyromazine (169), dimethipin (151), diquat (31), dithianon (180), dodine (84), esfenvalerate (204), ethephon (106), ethoxyquin (35), etofenprox (184), etrimfos (123), famoxadone (208), fenbutatin oxide (109), fenpyroximate (193), fentin (40), fipronil (202), flusilazole (165), flutolanil (205), glufosinate ammonium (175), glyphosate (158), guazitine (114), hexaconazole (170), hexathiazox (176), hydrogen phosphide (46), maleic hydrazide (102), methacrifos (125), methoprene (147), methoxyfenozide (209), methyl bromide (52), metiram (186), paclobutrazol (161), paraquat (57), penconazole (182), phentoate (128), 2-phenylphenol (56), pyraclostrobin (210), piperonyl butoxide (62), procloraz, (142), spinozad (203), thiophanate-methyl (77), trifloxystrobin (213) and triforine (116). Furthermore governments and international organizations are invited to give information on validated methods for the determination of individual dithiocarbamates 6. Note: Some of the above listed active ingredients may be found in one of the tables shown elsewhere. However, this compilation reflects the current state regarding active ingredients for which analytical methods were available. Further inputs and new methods to be submitted should minimize this list in the future. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The input of Dr. Piet van Zoonen of the National Institute of Public Health and the Environment, Bilthoven, The Netherlands, who compiled the information to the present state (March 2006) is appreciated. Many thanks for providing analytical methods also to Donna J. Grant, Calgary Laboratory - Canadian Food Inspection Agency, Steven Lehotay, USDA Agricultural Research Service Eastern Regional Research Center, and Lutz Alder, BFR, Berlin, Germany. Descriptions of further methods should also be submitted to IAEA for publication on the IAEA Training and Reference Centre (TRC) website: mailto:josef.brodesser@iaea.org, FAO/IAEA Joint Division for Food and Environmental Protection (http://www-naweb.iaea.org/nafa/fep/index.html). 6 such as: H. van Lieshaut, W. Schwack: Selective Trace Determination of Dithiocarbamate Fungicides in Fruits and Vegetables by Reversed-Phase Ion-Pair Liquid Chromatography with Ultraviolet and Electrochemical Detection. Journal of AOAC International, Vol. 83 (2000), 720-727 - 4 -
PESTICIDES WITH REFERENCE TO THEIR METHODS OF ANALYSIS The following table makes references to the respective methods of analyses discussed in the documents linked to German and USA methods. Canadian methods and references are covered in a separate listing (see http://www-infocris.iaea.org/download/canada-methods.pdf). No Active ingredient EN 1528 EN 12393 EN 12396 EN 13191 CFDA PDP LCMS 177 Abamectine 95 Acephate X X X X 117 Aldicarb X X 1 Aldrin and Dieldrin X X X X 134 Aminocarb 122 Amitraz 79 Amitrole 163 Anilazine X 68 Azinphos-ethyl X 2 Azinphos-methyl X X X 129 Azocyclotin 155 Benalaxyl 137 Bendiocarb X* 69 Benomyl 172 Bentazone 178 Bifentrin X X 3 Binapacryl 93 Bioresmethrin 144 Bitertanol 47 Bromide ion EN 13191 4 Bromophos X X 5 Bromophos-ethyl X X 70 Bromopropylate X 173 Buprofezin 139 Butocarboxim 174 Cadusofos 71 Camphechlor X 6 Captafol X 7 Captan X X X 8 Carbaryl X X X 72 Carbendazim X* 96 Carbofuran X X* 9 Carbon disulfide 10 Carbon tetrachloride 11 Carbophenothion X X 145 Carbosulfan 97 Cartap 80 Chinomethionat - 5 -
No Active ingredient EN 1528 EN 12393 EN 12396 EN 13191 CFDA PDP LCMS 12 Chlordane X X 13 Chlordimeform 14 Chlorfenvinphos X X 15 Chlormequat 16 Chlorobenzilate X 81 Chlorothalonil X X 201 Chlorpropopham X 17 Chlorpyrifos X X X 90 Chlorpyrifos-methyl X X X X 207 Ciprodinil 187 Clethodim X 156 Clofentezine 18 Coumaphos X 19 Crufomate 91 Cyanofenphos X 179 Cycloxydim 157 Cyfluthrin X X 146 Cyhalothrin X X 67 Cyhexatin 118 Cypermethrin X 207 Cyprodinil X* 169 Cyromazine 104 Daminozide X* 20 2,4-D X* 21 DDT X X X X 135 Deltamethrin X X 92 Demeton X X 73 Demeton-S-methyl X X 164 Demeton-S- X X methylsulphon 98 Dialofos X 22 Diazinon X X X 23 1,2-Dibromoethane 82 Dichlofluanid X 24 1,2-Dichloroethane 25 Dichlorvos X X X X 83 Dicloran X 26 Dicofol X X 130 Diflubenzuron X* 151 Dimethipin 27 Dimethoate X X X 87 Dinocap 28 Dioxathion X 29 Diphenyl - 6 -
No Active ingredient EN 1528 EN 12393 EN 12396 EN 13191 CFDA PDP LCMS 30 Diphenylamine X 31 Diquat 74 Disulfoton X X X 180 Dithianon 105 Dithiocarbamates EN 12396 84 Dodine 99 Edifenphos 32 Endosulfan X X X 33 Endrin X X 204 Esfenvalerate 106 Ethephon 107 Ethiofencarb X 34 Ethion X X X 149 Ethropophos X 35 Ethoxyquin 108 Ethylenethiourea (ETU) 184 Etofenprox 123 Etrimfos 208 Famoxadone 85 Fenamiphos X X X 192 Fenarimol X 109 Fenbutatin oxide 36 Fenchlorphos X X 37 Fenitrothion X X 185 Fenpropathrin X X 188 Fenpropimorph X* 193 Fenproxymate 38 Fensulfothion X 39 Fenthion X X X 40 Fentin 119 Fenvalerate X X X 202 Fipronil 152 Flucythrinate X 211 Fludioxonil X* 165 Flusilazole 205 Flutolanil 41 Folpet X X 42 Formothion X 175 Glufosinateammonium 158 Glyphosate 114 Guazatine 194 Haloxyfop X* - 7 -
No Active ingredient EN 1528 EN 12393 EN 12396 EN 13191 CFDA PDP LCMS 43 Heptachlor X X X X 44 Hexachlorobenzene X X 170 Hexaconazole 176 Hexathiazox 45 Hydrogen cyanide 46 Hydrogen phosphide 110 Imazalil X X X 206 Imidaclopride X 111 Iprodione X X X 131 Isophenphos X 88 Leptophos 48 Lindane X X X 49 Malathion X X X X 102 Maleic hydrazide 50 Mancozeb 124 Mecarbam X X 138 Metalaxyl X X X 212 Metalaxyl-M 125 Methacrifos 100 Methamidophos X X X X 51 Methidathion X X 132 Methiocarb X X 94 Methomyl X X X 147 Methoprene 209 Methoxyfenozide 52 Methyl bromide 186 Metiram 53 Mevinphos X X 54 Monocrotophos X X X X 181 Myclobutanil X 140 Nitrofen X 55 Omethoate X X 126 Oxamyl X X X 166 Oxydemeton-methyl X 161 Paclobutrazol 57 Paraquat 58 Parathion X X X X 59 Parathion-methyl X X X 182 Penconazole 120 Permethrin X X X 128 Phenthoate 56 2-Phenylphenol 112 Phorate X X - 8 -
No Active ingredient EN 1528 EN 12393 EN 12396 EN 13191 CFDA PDP LCMS 60 Phosalone X X 102 Phosmet X X X 61 Phosphamidon X X 141 Phoxim X 210 Pyraclostrobin 62 Piperonyl butoxide 101 Pirimicarb X 86 Pirimiphos-methyl X X X 142 Prochloraz 136 Procymidone X X 171 Profenofos X 148 Propamocarb X* 113 Propargite X 183 Propham X 160 Propiconazole X X 75 Propoxur X X X 150 Propylenethiourea (PTU) 153 Pyrazophos X 63 Pyrethrins X 64 Quintozene X X X 89 Sec-butylamine 203 Spinozad 121 2,4,5-T 189 Tebuconazole X X X 196 Tebufenozide X X 115 Tecnazene X X 190 Teflubenzuron X* 167 Terbufos X 65 Thiabendazole X X 154 Thiodicarb X 76 Thiometon X 77 Thiophanate-methyl 191 Tolcophos-methyl X 162 Tolylfluanid X 133 Triadimefon X 168 Triadimenol X 143 Triazophos X 66 Trichlorfon X 213 Trifloxystrobin 116 Triforine 78 Vamidothion X X* 159 Vinclozolin X X - 9 -
Glossary: PDP USDA Pesticide Data Program (http://www.ams.usda.gov/science/pdp/quick.htm) CDFA California Department of Food and Agriculture (http://wwwinfocris.iaea.org/download/usa-methods.pdf). LCMS Liquid Chromatography Mass Spectrometry (http://wwwinfocris.iaea.org/download/germany-en-methods.pdf). EN 1528, EN 12393, EN 12396 (http://www-infocris.iaea.org/download/germany-en- Methods.pdf). - 10 -