Reference scenario Transport PROLIBIC workshop 18/9/12 Structure Main assumptions of Reference Scenario (REF) Evolution of transport emissions in Belgium in REF Decomposition analysis CO 2 Evolution external cost of transport Conclusions 2
Description of Reference Scenario (REF) PLANET model (v3.2) Update REF scenario (SFP Mobility & Transport / PROLIBIC) Macroeconomic and socio-demographic hypotheses Transport data: calibration on a more recent year (8). Update of origin and destination matrix for passenger and freight transport Freight transport, the use of the NST 7 classification; Costs of vehicles Emission factors and environmental costs E-motion model 3 Description of Reference Scenario (REF) E-motion model Penetration of alternative motor fuel and vehicle technologies LIMOBELproject / Milieuverkenning 3 Biofuels minor adjustments updated historic numbers up to 1 Update NO x emission factors of euro 5 en 6 diesel cars NO x euro 5 = average of euro 2 and 3 NO x euro 6 =.8 g/km Update energy consumption factor electric cars Correction factor 1.25 4
Description of Reference Scenario (REF) Indirect emissions LIMOBEL / BIOSES project IEA projection gas supply in EU Drop of EU gas from 7 (5) to 25 (3) Biofuels only first generation Electricity production gradual phasing out of nuclear energy 3: 4 gas, 32 coal, 25 renewable energy and 3 gasoil 5 Repartition types of cars in vehicle-km (REF) 1 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 8 1 12 14 16 18 22 24 26 28 3 Petrol Diesel GASHYBRID_CS DIESHYBRID_CS GASHYBRID_PHEV DIESHYBRID_PHEV Electric hydrogen CNG LPG 6
Evolution exhaust emissions transport (REF) CO BKG NOx NH3 PM2,5 Pb SO2 NMVOS Transport : road, rail, IWW 7 Evolution total emissions transport in REF Total CO 2, NO x and PM2,5 emissions of passenger and freight transport in Belgium (road, rail, IWW) 1 Share of exhaust, non exhaust and indirect emissions in total CO 2, NO x and PM2,5 emissions 1 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 CO2 NOx PM2,5 8 3 8 3 8 3 CO2 NOx PM2,5 Exhaust Non-exhaust Indirect 8
CO 2 exhaust emissions transport in REF Evolution of CO 2 exhaust emissions of passenger and freight transport in Belgium (road, rail, IWW) Evolution of the modal share of CO 2 exhaust emissions of passenger and freight transport 1 1 1 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 8 3 8 3 8 3 Passenger Freight Totaal Rail (P) Cars Motorcycle Bus IWW Rail (FR) Truck Van 9 NO x exhaust emissions transport in REF Evolution of NO x exhaust emissions of passenger and freight transport in Belgium (road, rail, IWW) Evolution of the modal share of NO x exhaust emissions of passenger and freight transport 1 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 8 3 8 3 8 3 Rail (P) Cars Motorcycle Bus IWW Rail (FR) Truck Van 1
PM 2.5 exhaust emissions transport in REF Evolution of PM 2.5 exhaust emissions of passenger and freight transport in Belgium (road, rail, IWW) Evolution of the modal share of PM 2.5 exhaust emissions of passenger and freight transport 1 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 8 3 8 3 8 3 Rail (P) Cars Motorcycle Bus IWW Rail (FR) Truck Van 11 Decomposition analysis Evolution of CO 2 exhaust emissions in REF 5 effects: changes in transport demand (demand) changes in the modal choice (modal shift) changes in the number of persons or tonnes per vehicle (occupation/load); technological changes (technology) Changes in the share of biofuels (biofuel). For passenger cars technological changes decomposed into: the changes in fuel technology (fuel shift) changes in engine size (size shift) changes in emission abatement technology/fuel efficiency. 12
Decomposition analysis Average growth rate in order to enable comparison with historic figures Contribution of the different effects in percentage points 13 Decomposition analysis Evolution of CO 2 exhaust emissions by passenger transport (8-3) Evolution of CO 2 exhaust emissions by passenger cars (8-3) rail bus motorcycle car car total -2. -1.5-1. -.5..5 1. 1.5 2. total demand modal shift occupancy technology biofuel -.6 -.4 -.2..2.4.6.8 total demand occupancy fuel shift size shift fuel efficiency biofuel 14
Decomposition analysis Evolution of CO 2 exhaust emissions by freight transport (8-3) IWW rail van truck total -2-1 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 total demand modal shift load technology biofuel 15 Evolution external cost of transport in REF Evolution external cost of total emissions 2 1 1 1 LOW CENTRAL HIGH Evolution of the pollutant s share in external cost of total emissions LOW 1 8 6 4 2-2 -4 8 3 8 3 8 3 CO2 NOx NMVOC N2O CH4 SO2 PM2,5 16
Conclusions REF Decrease of most pollutants CO 2 & Pb Increasing importance indirect emissions (CO 2, NO x, PM 2.5 ) Increasing importance non-exhaust emissions (PM 2.5 ) CO 2 : Passenger transport: technological changes and increased biofuel blending counter increasing transport demand and decreasing occupancy Freight transport: not the case NO x /PM 2.5 : technological changes and increased biofuel blending counter increasing transport demand and decreasing occupancy 17 Conclusions REF External cost Depends on the valuation of damage cost of CO 2 Increase by 85-115 In 3 CO 2 main pollutant 18