2016/26 Date of Vote: 18 February, 2016 roposition: Rule 13(6) That the amendment goes further than the original propositions and debate on it should therefore be postponed. LOST: our: 19 ontre: 23 Ne vote pas: 0 Absent: 5 St. eter ort South astel Deputy eter A. Harwood Deputy Darren J. Duquemin Deputy Jan Kuttelwascher Deputy hristopher J. Green Deputy Barry L. Brehaut Deputy Mark H. Dorey Deputy Roger Domaille Deputy Barry J. E. aint Deputy Allister H. Langlois Deputy Jonathan. Le Tocq Deputy Robert A. Jones Deputy Sandra A. James, MBE St. eter ort North Deputy Michelle K. Le lerc West Deputy John A. B. Gollop Deputy Roger A. errot Deputy eter A. Sherbourne Deputy Alvord H. Brouard Deputy Richard onder Deputy Arrun M. Wilkie Deputy harles arkinson Deputy David de G. De Lisle Deputy Elis G. Bebb Deputy Yvonne Burford Deputy Lester. Queripel Deputy David A. Inglis Deputy Gavin A. St. ier Deputy Heidi J. R. Soulsby Deputy Kevin A. Stewart Deputy Robert W. Sillars Deputy eter L. Gillson Deputy aul A. Luxon Deputy aul R. Le elley A Deputy Michael G. O Hara Deputy Scott J. Ogier Deputy Francis W. Quin Deputy Lyndon S. Trott A Deputy Michael. J. Hadley Deputy Matthew J. Fallaize Alderney Representative Louis E. Jean Deputy David B. Jones A Alderney Representative S. D. Graham McKinley, OBE A Deputy Andrew R. Le Lièvre Deputy Garry M. ollins
2016/27 Date of Vote: 18 February, 2016 roposition: Amendment roposed by: Deputy A M Wilkie Seconded by: Deputy J Green To add a proposition as follows: 4. To direct the ommittee for Home Affairs to lay before the States by no later than December 2017 a detailed proposal concerning the formation of an automatic electoral roll ". LOST: our: 12 ontre: 31 Ne vote pas: 0 Absent: 4 St. eter ort South astel Deputy eter A. Harwood Deputy Darren J. Duquemin Deputy Jan Kuttelwascher Deputy hristopher J. Green Deputy Barry L. Brehaut Deputy Mark H. Dorey Deputy Roger Domaille Deputy Barry J. E. aint Deputy Allister H. Langlois Deputy Jonathan. Le Tocq Deputy Robert A. Jones Deputy Sandra A. James, MBE St. eter ort North Deputy Michelle K. Le lerc West Deputy John A. B. Gollop Deputy Roger A. errot Deputy eter A. Sherbourne Deputy Alvord H. Brouard Deputy Richard onder Deputy Arrun M. Wilkie Deputy harles arkinson Deputy David de G. De Lisle Deputy Elis G. Bebb Deputy Yvonne Burford Deputy Lester. Queripel Deputy David A. Inglis Deputy Gavin A. St. ier Deputy Heidi J. R. Soulsby Deputy Kevin A. Stewart Deputy Robert W. Sillars Deputy eter L. Gillson Deputy aul A. Luxon Deputy aul R. Le elley A Deputy Michael G. O Hara Deputy Scott J. Ogier Deputy Francis W. Quin Deputy Lyndon S. Trott A Deputy Michael. J. Hadley Deputy Matthew J. Fallaize Alderney Representative Louis E. Jean Deputy David B. Jones A Alderney Representative S. D. Graham McKinley, OBE Deputy Andrew R. Le Lièvre Deputy Garry M. ollins
2016/28 roposition: Amendment roposed by: Deputy L Gillson Seconded by: Deputy M Lowe To delete all of the propositions and substitute: 1. That for the term following the 2020 General Election, all deputies shall be elected on an island-wide basis and all voters shall have the same number of votes as there are deputies seats. 2. That with effect from the 2024 General Election, unless the States shall have resolved that the same or an alternative system of election on an island-wide basis shall be continued, all deputies shall again be elected in electoral districts, as at present. 3. To direct the States Assembly and onstitution ommittee to report to the States as expeditiously as possible with the changes necessary, including changes to legislation, to give effect to ropositions 1 and 2..
2016/28 ARRIED: our: 26 ontre: 18 Ne vote pas: 0 Absent: 3 St. eter ort South astel Deputy eter A. Harwood Deputy Darren J. Duquemin Deputy Jan Kuttelwascher Deputy hristopher J. Green Deputy Barry L. Brehaut Deputy Mark H. Dorey Deputy Roger Domaille Deputy Barry J. E. aint Deputy Allister H. Langlois Deputy Jonathan. Le Tocq Deputy Robert A. Jones Deputy Sandra A. James, MBE St. eter ort North Deputy Michelle K. Le lerc West Deputy John A. B. Gollop Deputy Roger A. errot Deputy eter A. Sherbourne Deputy Alvord H. Brouard Deputy Richard onder Deputy Arrun M. Wilkie Deputy harles arkinson Deputy David de G. De Lisle Deputy Elis G. Bebb Deputy Yvonne Burford Deputy Lester. Queripel Deputy David A. Inglis Deputy Gavin A. St. ier Deputy Heidi J. R. Soulsby Deputy Kevin A. Stewart Deputy Robert W. Sillars Deputy eter L. Gillson Deputy aul A. Luxon Deputy aul R. Le elley A Deputy Michael G. O Hara Deputy Scott J. Ogier Deputy Francis W. Quin Deputy Lyndon S. Trott Deputy Michael. J. Hadley Deputy Matthew J. Fallaize Alderney Representative Louis E. Jean Deputy David B. Jones A Alderney Representative S. D. Graham McKinley, OBE Deputy Andrew R. Le Lièvre Deputy Garry M. ollins
2016/29 roposition: Amendment roposed by: Deputy M J Fallaize Seconded by: Deputy H J R Soulsby To delete propositions 1-3 and to substitute therefor: 1. That for the 2020 General Election and thereafter, all deputies shall be elected on an island-wide basis and all voters shall have the same number of votes as there are deputies seats provided that such a system shall first have been approved in an island wide referendum. 2. To direct the States Assembly and onstitution ommittee to report to the States as expeditiously as possible detailing the proposals to give effect to roposition 1 including the methodology of the election and the holding of a referendum.. ARRIED: our: 22 ontre: 21 Ne vote pas: 0 Absent: 4 St. eter ort South astel Deputy eter A. Harwood Deputy Darren J. Duquemin A Deputy Jan Kuttelwascher Deputy hristopher J. Green Deputy Barry L. Brehaut Deputy Mark H. Dorey Deputy Roger Domaille Deputy Barry J. E. aint Deputy Allister H. Langlois Deputy Jonathan. Le Tocq Deputy Robert A. Jones Deputy Sandra A. James, MBE St. eter ort North Deputy Michelle K. Le lerc West Deputy John A. B. Gollop Deputy Roger A. errot Deputy eter A. Sherbourne Deputy Alvord H. Brouard Deputy Richard onder Deputy Arrun M. Wilkie Deputy harles arkinson Deputy David de G. De Lisle Deputy Elis G. Bebb Deputy Yvonne Burford Deputy Lester. Queripel Deputy David A. Inglis Deputy Gavin A. St. ier Deputy Heidi J. R. Soulsby Deputy Kevin A. Stewart Deputy Robert W. Sillars Deputy eter L. Gillson Deputy aul A. Luxon Deputy aul R. Le elley A Deputy Michael G. O Hara Deputy Scott J. Ogier Deputy Francis W. Quin Deputy Lyndon S. Trott Deputy Michael. J. Hadley Deputy Matthew J. Fallaize Alderney Representative Louis E. Jean Deputy David B. Jones A Alderney Representative S. D. Graham McKinley, OBE Deputy Andrew R. Le Lièvre Deputy Garry M. ollins
2016/30 roposition: 1 (as amended) That for the 2020 General Election and thereafter all deputies shall be elected on an island-wide basis and all voters shall have the same number of votes as there are deputies seats provided that such a system shall first have been approved in an island wide referendum. ARRIED: our: 26 ontre: 16 Ne vote pas: 0 Absent: 5 St. eter ort South astel Deputy eter A. Harwood Deputy Darren J. Duquemin A Deputy Jan Kuttelwascher Deputy hristopher J. Green Deputy Barry L. Brehaut Deputy Mark H. Dorey Deputy Roger Domaille Deputy Barry J. E. aint Deputy Allister H. Langlois Deputy Jonathan. Le Tocq Deputy Robert A. Jones Deputy Sandra A. James, MBE St. eter ort North Deputy Michelle K. Le lerc West Deputy John A. B. Gollop Deputy Roger A. errot Deputy eter A. Sherbourne Deputy Alvord H. Brouard Deputy Richard onder Deputy Arrun M. Wilkie Deputy harles arkinson Deputy David de G. De Lisle Deputy Elis G. Bebb Deputy Yvonne Burford Deputy Lester. Queripel Deputy David A. Inglis Deputy Gavin A. St. ier Deputy Heidi J. R. Soulsby Deputy Kevin A. Stewart Deputy Robert W. Sillars Deputy eter L. Gillson Deputy aul A. Luxon A Deputy aul R. Le elley A Deputy Michael G. O Hara Deputy Scott J. Ogier Deputy Francis W. Quin Deputy Lyndon S. Trott Deputy Michael. J. Hadley Deputy Matthew J. Fallaize Alderney Representative Louis E. Jean Deputy David B. Jones A Alderney Representative S. D. Graham McKinley, OBE Deputy Andrew R. Le Lièvre Deputy Garry M. ollins
2016/31 roposition: 2 (as amended) To direct the States Assembly and onstitution ommittee to report to the States as expeditiously as possible detailing the proposals to give effect to roposition 1 including the methodology of the election and the holding of a referendum ARRIED: our: 35 ontre: 7 Ne vote pas: 0 Absent: 5 St. eter ort South astel Deputy eter A. Harwood Deputy Darren J. Duquemin A Deputy Jan Kuttelwascher Deputy hristopher J. Green Deputy Barry L. Brehaut Deputy Mark H. Dorey Deputy Roger Domaille Deputy Barry J. E. aint Deputy Allister H. Langlois Deputy Jonathan. Le Tocq Deputy Robert A. Jones Deputy Sandra A. James, MBE St. eter ort North Deputy Michelle K. Le lerc West Deputy John A. B. Gollop Deputy Roger A. errot Deputy eter A. Sherbourne Deputy Alvord H. Brouard Deputy Richard onder Deputy Arrun M. Wilkie Deputy harles arkinson Deputy David de G. De Lisle Deputy Elis G. Bebb Deputy Yvonne Burford Deputy Lester. Queripel Deputy David A. Inglis Deputy Gavin A. St. ier Deputy Heidi J. R. Soulsby Deputy Kevin A. Stewart Deputy Robert W. Sillars Deputy eter L. Gillson Deputy aul A. Luxon A Deputy aul R. Le elley A Deputy Michael G. O Hara Deputy Scott J. Ogier Deputy Francis W. Quin Deputy Lyndon S. Trott Deputy Michael. J. Hadley Deputy Matthew J. Fallaize Alderney Representative Louis E. Jean Deputy David B. Jones A Alderney Representative S. D. Graham McKinley, OBE Deputy Andrew R. Le Lièvre Deputy Garry M. ollins