INTERNATIONAL ORGANISATION FOR STANDARDISATION ORGANISATION INTERNATIONALE DE NORMALISATION ISO/IEC JTC1//WG1 CODING OF STILL PICTURES TITLE: Meeting Report, 50 th Meeting of ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 29/WG 1 2009-10-26 to 2009-10-30, Xian, China SOURCE: WG1 Convener ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 29/WG 1 N5257 Date: 2009-10-30 1 1. Open meeting The 49 th WG1 Maui Meeting was held on October 26 30, 2009, at the Xian Sheraton Hotel, Xian, China. The hosted by the Chinese National Body and organized by Prof. Guangming Shi, School of Electronic Engineering at Xidian of China with support from Xian Hi- Tech Industries Development Zone and MPEG-CHINA: Prof. Wen Gao and Prof. Tiejun Huang. 1.1 Roll call There were 37 delegates from 12 national bodies attended the meeting. The meeting attendance is contained in WG1N5160. 5160 2009-07-17 50th WG1 Xian Meeting, Registration/Attendance List WG1 WG1N5160 2. Approval of agenda The meeting agenda was approved in WG1N5159. 5159 2009-07-17 50th WG1 Xian Meeting, Draft Meeting Agenda WG1 wg1n5159.doc 3. Organisation of this meeting 3.1 Registration and allocation of contributions 5160 2009-07-17 50th WG1 Xian Meeting, Registration/Attendance List WG1 3.2 Nomination of Resolutions/Liaisons Drafting Committee The following committee members were nominated and approved. Japan Dr. Fumitaka Ono (Chair) Korea Dr. Youngseop Kim France Dr. Chaker Larabi Germany Siegfried Foessel Belgium Dr. Peter Schelkens 3.3 Finalize meeting time allocation - 1 -
5159 2009-07-17 50th WG1 Xian Meeting, Draft Meeting Agenda WG1 wg1n5159.doc 2 4. Report on the previous meeting and interim period The following reports were reviewed. 4.1 Reports from after 49 th WG1 Sardinia Meeting Notice of Publications: 5185 2009-10-15 5196 2009-10-15 5197 2009-10-15 Notice of Publication: ISO/IEC 29199-2:2009, Information technology -- JPEG XR image coding system -- Part 2: Image coding specification Notice of Publication: ISO/IEC 15444-4:2004/Cor.1:2009, Conformance testing, TECHNICAL CORRIGENDUM 1 Notice of Publication: ISO/IEC 15444-12:2008/Cor.3:2009, Information technology -- JPEG 2000 image coding system - - Part 12: ISO base media file format, TECHNICAL CORRIGENDUM 3 wg1n5185.zip wg1n5196.zip wg1n5197.zip Summary of Voting: 5188 2009-10-15 5189 2009-10-15 Summary of Voting on Combined CD Registration and CD Consideration Ballot on ISO/IEC CD 24800-2: Information technology -- JPSearch -- Part 2: Registration, identification and management of schema and ontology Summary of Voting on ISO/IEC 15444-1:2004/FPDAM 4: Core coding system, AMENDMENT 4: Profiles for broadcast applications wg1n5188.zip wg1n5189.zip 5190 2009-10-15 5192 2009-10-15 5193 2009-10-15 5198 2009-10-15 5199 2009-10-15 Summary of Voting on ISO/IEC FCD 24800-3: Information technology -- JPSearch -- Part 3: Query format Summary of Response, Systematic Review of ISO/IEC 13818-4:2004 (Ed 2), 14496-2:2004 (Ed 3), 14496-4:2004 (Ed 2), 14496-8:2004, 14496-15:2004, 14496-18:2004, 14496-19:2004, 21000-6:2004, 15444-2:2004 Summary of Response to Request for Appointment of Project Editors, ISO/IEC 29199-2 and 29199-2/Cor.1 Summary of Voting on ISO/IEC FCD 29199-4: Information technology -- JPEG XR image coding system -- Part 4: Conformance testing Summary of Voting on ISO/IEC FCD 29199-5: Information technology -- JPEG XR image coding system -- Part 5: Reference software wg1n5190.zip wg1n5192.zip wg1n5193.zip wg1n5198.zip wg1n5199.zip 5205 2009-10-22 Summary of Voting on Combined CD Registration and CD wg1n5205.zip - 2 -
5206 2009-10-22 5207 2009-10-22 5208 2009-10-22 5209 2009-10-22 Consideration Ballot on ISO/IEC CD 10918-5, Information technology -- Digital compression and coding of continuoustone still images: JPEG File Interchange Format (JFIF) Summary of Response to Proposal of Minor Enhancement to the SC 29 Project, JTC 1.29.14.101.05 (15444-1/AMD5), Core coding system, AMENDMENT 5: Enhancements for digital cinema and archive profiles Summary of Response to Proposal of Minor Enhancement to the SC 29 Project, JTC 1.29.14.02.03 (15444-2/AMD3), Extensions, AMENDMENT 3: Extended ROI boxes, XML boxing, compressed channel definition boxes, representation of floating point data and box-based file format for JPEG- XR Summary of Response to Proposal of Minor Enhancement to the SC 29 Project, JTC 1.29.14.09.05 (15444-9/AMD5), Interactivity tools, APIs and protocols, AMENDMENT 5: UDP transport and additional enhancements to JPIP Summary of Voting on Combined PDAM Registration and PDAM Consideration Ballot on ISO/IEC 15444-11:2007/PDAM 1, Information technology -- JPEG 2000 image coding system: Wireless, AMENDMENT 1: IP based wireless networks 3 wg1n5206.zip wg1n5207.zip wg1n5208.zip wg1n5209.zip 5167 2009-10-15 5168 2009-10-15 5169 2009-10-15 Progression of WG1 work items: Combined CD Registration and CD Consideration Ballot on ISO/IEC CD 10918-5, Information technology -- Digital compression and coding of continuous-tone still images: JPEG File Interchange Format (JFIF) [SC 29/WG 1 N 5106] Proposal of Minor Enhancement to the SC 29 Project, JTC 1.29.14.101.05 (15444-1/AMD5), Information technology -- JPEG 2000 image coding system: Core coding system, AMENDMENT 5: Enhancements for digital cinema and archive profiles [SC 29/WG 1 N 5120] Proposal of Minor Enhancement to the SC 29 Project, JTC 1.29.14.02.03 (15444-2/AMD3), Information technology -- JPEG 2000 image coding system: Extensions, AMENDMENT 3: Extended ROI boxes, XML boxing, compressed channel definition boxes, representation of floating point data and box-based file format for JPEG-XR [SC 29/WG 1 N 5125] - 3 - wg1n5167.zip wg1n5168.zip wg1n5169.zip 5170 2009-10-15 Proposal of Minor Enhancement to the SC 29 Project, JTC wg1n5170.zip
5171 2009-10-15 5172 2009-10-15 1.29.14.09.05 (15444-9/AMD5), Information technology -- JPEG 2000 image coding system: Interactivity tools, APIs and protocols, AMENDMENT 5: UDP transport and additional enhancements to JPIP [SC 29/WG 1 N 5111] Combined PDAM Registration and PDAM Consideration Ballot on ISO/IEC 15444-11:2007/PDAM 1, Information technology -- JPEG 2000 image coding system: Wireless, AMENDMENT 1: IP based wireless networks [SC 29/WG 1 N 5139] Request for Appointment of Project Editors, ISO/IEC 29199-2 and 29199-2/Cor.1 4 wg1n5171.zip wg1n5172.zip 5173 2009-10-15 Request for Appointment of Liaison Representative wg1n5173.zip 5180 2009-10-15 5181 2009-10-15 5182 2009-10-15 5184 2009-10-15 5187 2009-10-15 Disposition of Comments Report on Combined CD Registration and CD Consideration Ballot on ISO/IEC CD 24800-4: Information technology -- JPSearch -- Part 4: File format for metadata embedded in image data (JPEG and JPEG 2000) [SC 29/WG 1 N 4814] ISO/IEC FCD 24800-4: Information technology -- JPSearch - - Part 4: File format for metadata embedded in image data (JPEG and JPEG 2000) [SC 29/WG 1 N 5138] Combined CD Registration and CD Consideration Ballot on ISO/IEC CD 24800-5, Information technology -- JPSearch -- Part 5: Data interchange format between image repositories [SC 29/WG 1 N 5141] Request for JTC 1 Approval of Category C Liaison between SC 29 (WG 1 and WG 11) and World Wide Web Consortium (W3C) [JTC 1 N 9655] Text of ISO/IEC 15444-3:2007/FDAM 1: Information technology -- JPEG 2000 image coding system: Motion JPEG 2000, AMENDMENT 1: Additional profiles for archiving applications [SC 29/WG 1 N 5127] wg1n5180.zip wg1n5181.zip wg1n5182.zip wg1n5184.zip wg1n5187.zip 5183 2009-10-15 5191 2009-10-15 5194 2009-10-15 5195 2009-10-15 Notices and Reports: Meeting Report, the 22nd SC 29 Plenary Meeting, 2009-04- 27, Maui, Hawaii, USA Business Plan of SC 29 to the 24th JTC 1 Plenary Meeting, 2009-10-18/22, Tel Aviv, Israel [JTC 1 N 9714] Liaison Report of ITU-T to the 24th JTC 1 Plenary Meeting, 2009-10-18/22, Tel Aviv, Israel [JTC 1 N 9742] Liaison Report of ITU-T to the 24th JTC 1 Plenary Meeting, 2009-10-18/22, Tel Aviv, Israel [JTC 1 N 9743] - 4 - wg1n5183.zip wg1n5191.zip wg1n5194.zip wg1n5195.zip 5202 2009-10-21 ISO/DIS 26324: Information and documentation -- Digital wg1n5202.zip
object identifier system 5 5. Liaisons, correspondences, etc. 5165 2009-10-15 5166 2009-10-15 5174 2009-10-15 5175 2009-10-15 5176 2009-10-15 5177 2009-10-15 5178 2009-10-15 5179 2009-10-15 5186 2009-10-15 Liaison Statement from Video Services Forum, Inc. (VSF) to SC 29/WG 1 on ISO/IEC 15444-1:2004/FPDAM 4 Liaison Statement from ITU-T SG 16 to SC 29/WG 1 on Image Coding Activities Liaison Statement from SC 29/WG 1 to ISO/TC 42 on Call for Advanced Image Coding of Camera Sensor Data for Archival Purposes [SC 29/WG 1 N 5144, Attachment: WG 1 N 5130] Liaison Statement from SC 29/WG 1 to DICOM on Call for Advanced Image Coding for Medical Imaging [SC 29/WG 1 N 5145, Attachment: WG 1 N 5132] Liaison Statement from SC 29/WG 1 to SMPTE on ISO/IEC 15444-1 [SC 29/WG 1 N 5121, Attachment: WG 1 N 5119, N 5123] Liaison Statement from SC 29/WG 1 to SMPTE on Broadcast Profiles [SC 29/WG 1 N 5122, Attachment: WG 1 N 5134] Liaison Statement from SC 29/WG 1 to WG 11 on ISO/IEC 15444-1 and 15444-12 [SC 29/WG 1 N 5133] Liaison Statement from SC 29/WG 1 to VSF on Broadcast Profiles [SC 29/WG 1 N 5122, Attachment: WG 1 N 5134] Liaison Statement from IEC TC 100 to SC 29/WG 1 on E-Book Reader Format 5200 2009-10-17 SMPTE liaison to WG1 5211 2009-10-23 Liaison letter VSF to WG 1 5240 2009-10-29 SMPTE liaison on Digital Cinema 5241 2009-10-29 SMPTE Liaison on Broadcast Profiles Dolby Labs Analog Devices, Inc Dolby Labs Dolby Labs 5242 2009-10-29 DOCR on FPDAM5 (Broadcast Profiles) Dolby wg1n5165.zip wg1n5166.zip wg1n5174.zip wg1n5175.zip wg1n5176.zip wg1n5177.zip wg1n5178.zip wg1n5179.zip wg1n5186.zip wg1n5211.doc - 5 -
5243 2009-10-29 FPDAM on Broadcast Profiles 5244 2009-10-29 WG1 Liaison to WG11 on PAF 5245 2009-10-29 Liaison from WG 1 to VSF on Broadcast Applications Labs Dolby Labs Dolby Labs Analog Devices, Inc 6 6. Project JTC 1.29.04.03 (10918-1) JPEG Part 1 5167 2009-10-15 5205 2009-10-22 Combined CD Registration and CD Consideration Ballot on ISO/IEC CD 10918-5, Information technology -- Digital compression and coding of continuous-tone still images: JPEG File Interchange Format (JFIF) [SC 29/WG 1 N 5106] Summary of Voting on Combined CD Registration and CD Consideration Ballot on ISO/IEC CD 10918-5, Information technology -- Digital compression and coding of continuoustone still images: JPEG File Interchange Format (JFIF) wg1n5167.zip wg1n5205.zip 7. Project JTC 1.29.12 (14495) JPEG - LS : Lossless Compression of Continuous-tone Still Pictures 8. Project JTC 1.29.03 (11544) JBIG: Progressive Bi-level Image Compression 9. Project JTC 1.29.10 (14492) JBIG2: Lossy/Lossless Coding of Bi-level Images JBIG 2 is looking for contributions to JBIG2, proposed amendment 3. 5221 2009-10-27 Minutes of JBIG telephone conference for JBIG2 AMD4 on Oct.5 and Oct.19, 2009 5222 2009-10-27 Xian JBIG meeting report 5223 2009-10-27 PDAM4 text to ISO/IEC 14492 Tokyo Polytechnic Tokyo Polytechnic Tokyo Polytechnic wg1n5221.doc wg1n5222.ppt wg1n5223.doc 10. Project JTC 1.29.14 (15444) JPEG 2000 Image Coding System 10.1 Report on results from 49 th WG1 Sardinia meeting - 6 -
5164 2009-10-15 5225 2009-10-28 National Bodies/Liaison Comments, correspondences, presentations, etc JNB proposal on enhanced lazy mode for JPEG2000 lossless coding and decoding JPEG2000 Stereoscopic Image Compression for 3D Display Sony Corporation Dankook 7 wg1n5225.ppt 5236 2009-10-29 JPEG2000 Alliance Fraunhofer IIS wg1n5236.pdf 5237 2009-10-29 Presentation on Surveillance Applications Fraunhofer IIS wg1n5237.pdf 5206 2009-10-22 Historical Archive AHG Medical Imaging AHG Digital Cinema AHG Summary of Response to Proposal of Minor Enhancement to the SC 29 Project, JTC 1.29.14.101.05 (15444-1/AMD5), Information technology -- JPEG 2000 image coding system: Core coding system, AMENDMENT 5: Enhancements for digital cinema and archive profiles 5211 2009-10-23 Liaison letter VSF to WG 1 5213 2009-10-26 5215 2009-10-26 Proposed Draft Amendment (PDAM) for 15444-1:2004/Amd3 -Guidelines for digital cinema applications Proposed Draft Amendment (PDAM) for 15444-1:2004/Amd.5 "Enhancements for Digital Cinema and Archive Profiles (Additional Frame Rates)" 5248 2009-10-29 Meeting Report of Part-1/-3 and DCinema AHG wg1n5206.zip Analog Devices, Inc wg1n5211.doc of Poitiers Fraunhofer IIS Fraunhofer IIS wg1n5213.doc wg1n5215.doc 10.3 JPEG 2000 Part 1: Core Coding System 5213 2009-10-26 Proposed Draft Amendment (PDAM) for 15444-1:2004/Amd3 -Guidelines for digital cinema applications of Poitiers wg1n5213.doc 10.4 JPEG 2000 Part 2: Extensions 5161 2009-09-28 AMD3 15444-2: Working Draft 2 for Box File Format for JPEG XR - 7 - Universität Stuttgart wg1n5161.doc 5207 2009-10-22 Summary of Response to Proposal of Minor Enhancement wg1n5207.zip
to the SC 29 Project, JTC 1.29.14.02.03 (15444-2/AMD3), Extensions, AMENDMENT 3: Extended ROI boxes, XML boxing, compressed channel definition boxes, representation of floating point data and box-based file format for JPEG- XR 5227 2009-10-28 Working draft 3 of ISO/IEC 15444-2/AMD 3 WG1 8 10.5 JPEG 2000 Part 3: Motion JPEG 2000 (MJ2) See Digital Cinema AHG. 10.6 JPEG 2000 Part 4: Conformance Testing 10.7 JPEG 2000 Part 5: Reference Software 10.8 JPEG 2000 Part 6: JPM 10.9 JPEG 2000 Part 8: JPSEC 10.10 JPEG 2000 Part 9: JPIP 5208 2009-10-22 Summary of Response to Proposal of Minor Enhancement to the SC 29 Project, JTC 1.29.14.09.05 (15444-9/AMD5), Interactivity tools, APIs and protocols, AMENDMENT 5: UDP transport and additional enhancements to JPIP 10.11 JPEG 2000 Part 10: JP3D 5219 2009-10-27 5235 2009-10-29 Defect Report Draft 1 toward Corrigendum 1 to ISO/IEC 15444-10 JP3D Ad Hoc Group Meeting Report, Xi'an, October 26-30, 2009 10.12 JPEG 2000 Part 11: JPWL 5209 2009-10-22 Vrije Universiteit Brussel - IBBT Vrije Universiteit Brussel - IBBT Summary of Voting on Combined PDAM Registration and PDAM Consideration Ballot on ISO/IEC 15444-11:2007/PDAM 1, Information technology -- JPEG 2000 image coding system: Wireless, AMENDMENT 1: IP based wireless networks 10.13 JPEG 2000 Part 12: ISO Base Media File Format 5097 2009-07-14 Final Text of ISO/IEC 15444-12:2008/Cor.3: Information technology -- JPEG 2000 image coding system -- Part 12: ISO base media file format, TECHNICAL CORRIGENDUM wg1n5208.zip wg1n5235.doc wg1n5209.zip wg1n5097.zip - 8 -
3 10.14 JPEG 2000 Part 13: Entry Level JPEG 2000 Encoder 10.15 JPEG 2000 Part 14, JPXML: Structural Representation and Reference of File Format 5201 2009-10-18 Study Text for JPXML CD (ISO/IEC 15444-14) 5254 2009-10-29 JPXML Xian meeting report JPXML AHG Dankook 9 wg1n5254.ppt 11. Project JTC 1.29.20 (24800) JPSearch: Part 1: System framework and components 5238 2009-10-29 JPSearch ad-hoc meeting report 5239 2009-10-29 Text for the Final Draft International Standard of JPSearch Part 3 Query Format Konkuk Konkuk Project JTC 1.29.20 (24800-1) JPSearch: Part 1 Project JTC 1.29.20 (24800-2) JPSearch: Part 2: Schema and Ontology Registration and Identification 5210 2009-10-23 5214 2009-10-26 JPSearch Part 2: Information provisioning for management process Proposal for JPSearch part 2 Image Identification Representation 5249 2009-10-29 DOCR on 24800-2 JPSearch Part 2 5250 2009-10-29 Technical comment of KNB on JPsearch part 2 CD 5251 2009-10-29 FCD of JPsearch part 2-9 - of Passau Dankook Dankook Dankook Dankook wg1n5210.zip wg1n5214.doc Project JTC 1.29.20 (24800-3) JPSearch: Part 3: System framework and components 5246 2009-10-29 5253 2009-10-29 Disposition of Comment Report on 24800-3 JPSearch Part 3 Query Format DoCR on ISO/IEC CD 29199-3: Information technology -- JPEG XR image coding system: Motion JPEG XR Project JTC 1.29.20 (24800-4) JPSearch: Part 4: Metadata Format Konkuk Apple Inc. wg1n5253.zip 5138 2009-07-16 Tex of ISO/IEC FCD CD 24800-4 : File format for metadata embedded in NEC
image data Project JTC 1.29.20 (24800-5) JPSearch: Part 5: Interchange format 5141 2009-07-16 Text of Committee Draft for JPSearch Part-5 Data Interchange Format (ISO/IEC CD 24800-5) Project JTC 1.29.20 (24800-6) JPSearch: Part 6: Reference Software 5203 2009-10-21 5204 2009-10-21 5247 2009-10-29 Proposal for JPSearch s Reference Software. JPQF Query Processing Over External Metadata Formats Using Semantic Web Technologies Proposal for JPSearch s Reference Software Implementation Plan Draft Workplan for Reference Software of JPSearch Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya Konkuk EPFL 10 wg1n5203.zip wg1n5204.zip 12. Project JTC 1.29.21 (29199) JPEG XR 5161 2009-09-28 5162 2009-10-01 5163 2009-10-05 5207 2009-10-22 5216 2009-10-26 5217 2009-10-26 5218 2009-10-26 5224 2009-10-28 AMD3 15444-2: Working Draft 2 for Box File Format for JPEG XR Ricoh Patent Statement on 29199-2 and 29199-4 (JPEG XR part 2 and 4) Improvements to 29199-5 JPEG XR reference software for consideration toward FDIS Summary of Response to Proposal of Minor Enhancement to the SC 29 Project, JTC 1.29.14.02.03 (15444-2/AMD3), Information technology -- JPEG 2000 image coding system: Extensions, AMENDMENT 3: Extended ROI boxes, XML boxing, compressed channel definition boxes, representation of floating point data and box-based file format for JPEG-XR JPEG XR Ad Hoc Group Opening Plenary Status Report - 50th (Xian) Meeting DoCR on ISO/IEC FCD 29199-4: Information technology -- JPEG XR image coding system Conformance testing DoCR on ISO/IEC FCD 29199-5: Information technology -- JPEG XR image coding system Reference software JPEG XR Ad Hoc Group Mid-Meeting Plenary Status Report - 50th (Xian) Meeting Universität Stuttgart Ricoh Company, Ltd. Microsoft Corp. JPEG XR AHG JPEG XR AHG JPEG XR AHG JPEG XR AHG wg1n5161.doc wg1n5162.pdf wg1n5163.zip wg1n5207.zip wg1n5216.ppt wg1n5217.doc wg1n5218.doc wg1n5218_rev1.doc wg1n5224.ppt - 10 -
11 5226 2009-10-28 Current state of drafting work toward ISO/IEC DTR 29199-1 (JPEG XR technical report) JPEG XR AHG wg1n5226.zip 5228 2009-10-30 JPEG XR Ad Hoc Group Closing Plenary Status Report - 50th (Xi'an) Meeting JPEG XR AHG 5229 2009-10-28 ISO/IEC PDTR 29199-1: JPEG XR image coding system System architecture WG1 5230 2009-10-28 ISO/IEC 29199-2/COR 1: Miscellaneous corrections for JPEG XR image coding specification WG1 5231 2009-10-28 ISO/IEC FCD 29199-3: JPEG XR image coding system Motion JPEG XR WG1 5232 2009-10-28 ISO/IEC FDIS 29199-4: JPEG XR image coding system Conformance testing WG1 5233 2009-10-28 ISO/IEC FDIS 29199-5: JPEG XR image coding system Reference software WG1 5234 2009-10-28 Reply liaison statement to ITU-T SG 16 on coordination of JPEG XR image coding activities WG1 13. JTC 1.29.28 (29170) Advanced Image Coding and Evaluation Methodologies (AIC) 5252 2009-10-29 AIC meeting report of Poitiers 13. WG1 Webmaster Report Report was given via e-mail. 14. Identify hosts and specify dates for future meetings The standing document for hosting WG1 meeting is given in: 3597 2005-03-17 Standing Document #1 - Meeting Requirements (V.4) Elysium Ltd wg1n3597.doc 5212 2009-10-24 51st WG1 Meeting, Boston, MA USA, March 15-19, 2010, Calling Notice and Registration Instructions Analog Devices, Inc WG1 Year Mon Day City, Country Meeting 51 st 2010 Mar 15 19 Boston, MA, USA 52 nd 2010 Jul 12-16 Brussels, Belgium 53 rd 2010 Oct 11-15 Guangzhou, China (co-located with WG11 meeting, October 11-15 or 18-22) 54 th 2011 Mar Japan - 11 -
55 th 2011 Jul 11-15 Berlin, Germany 56 th 2011 Oct USA (co-located with WG11 meeting) 57 th 2012 Mar Korea (to be confirmed) 58 th 2012 Jul Europe 59 th 2012 Nov North America 60 th 2013 Mar Asia 61 st 2013 Jul Europe 62 nd 2013 Mar Rochester, New York, USA (To be confirmed) 12 15. PR AHG The press release is contained in WG1N5255. 5255 2009-10-29 50th WG1 Xian Meeting, Press Release 16. Resolutions The resolutions are contained in WG1N5256. 5256 2009-10-29 50th WG1 Xian Meeting, Resolutions WG1 17. Other Business There was no other business. 18. Close of Meeting The meeting was closed at 11:45am, October 30, 2009. - 12 -