SIMULATION ANALYSIS FOR ERP CONDUCTED IN JAPANESE SMES USING THE CONCEPT OF MFCA. Xuzhong Tang Soemon Takakuwa



Similar documents
Information Systems for Business Integration

Information Systems for Business Integration: EDI, SCM, CRM Systems

HISTORY AND INTRODUCTION

A MANAGER S ROADMAP GUIDE FOR LATERAL TRANS-SHIPMENT IN SUPPLY CHAIN INVENTORY MANAGEMENT

SUPPLY CHAIN MANAGEMENT TRADEOFFS ANALYSIS

Business Proposal: Recommendation for Implementation of the SAGE Enterprise Suite. Debbie Miksiewicz. Elaine Kithcart BSA 375. Mr.

SIMULATION BASED APPROACH TO STUDY THE INTERACTION OF SCHEDULING AND ROUTING ON A LOGISTIC NETWORK

Chapter 11. MRP and JIT

Improve the Agility of Demand-Driven Supply Networks

GXS Active. Orders. Optimizing the Procure-to-Pay Process. Order Planning and Execution. Order Lifecycle Management.

GXS Active. Orders. Optimising the Procure-to-Pay Process. Order Planning and Execution. Order Lifecycle Management.

DSS TO MANAGE ATM CASH UNDER PERIODIC REVIEW WITH EMERGENCY ORDERS. Ana K. Miranda David F. Muñoz

Five Tips to Achieve a Lean Manufacturing Business

Manufacturing. Manufacturing challenges of today and how. Navision Axapta solves them- In the current explosive economy, many

Environmental Management Accounting (Material Flow Cost Accounting :MFCA)

TOOLS OF MONTE CARLO SIMULATION IN INVENTORY MANAGEMENT PROBLEMS

ERP Course: Production and Materials Management Reading: Chapter 6 from Mary Sumner

Seradex White Paper. Engineering Change Process. A Discussion of Issues in the Manufacturing OrderStream

Going Lean the ERP Way

MSD Supply Chain Programme Strategy Workshop

Modeling Stochastic Inventory Policy with Simulation

26/10/2015. Enterprise Information Systems. Learning Objectives. System Category Enterprise Systems. ACS-1803 Introduction to Information Systems

Just-In-Time Manufacturing Management System. Get all your manufacturing operations managed more effectively

What options exist for multi-echelon forecasting and replenishment?

Warehouse and Production Management with SAP Business One

EVERYTHING YOU NEED TO KNOW ABOUT INVENTORY

APPLICATION OF KANBAN SYSTEM FOR MANAGING INVENTORY

Business Challenges. Customer retention and new customer acquisition (customer relationship management)

VALUE STREAM MAPPING FOR SOFTWARE DEVELOPMENT PROCESS. Ganesh S Thummala. A Research Paper. Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the

ISE 421 QUANTATIVE PRODUCTION PLANNING

Appendix O MANUFACTURING YOUTH APPRENTICESHIP PRODUCTION OPERATIONS MANAGEMENT PATHWAY PRODUCTION OPERATIONS MANAGEMENT (UNIT 8)

SUPPLY CHAIN MODELING USING SIMULATION

To Integrate or Stand Alone? Data Collection Solutions for The Small & Medium Size Business

How To Improve Your Business

The Supply Chain in Reverse Component Remanufacturing at Rolls-Royce Corporation

SIMULATION-BASED ANALYSIS OF THE BULLWHIP EFFECT UNDER DIFFERENT INFORMATION SHARING STRATEGIES

Enterprise resource planning Product life-cycle management Information systems in industry ELEC-E8113

4 Key Tools for Managing Shortened Customer Lead Times & Demand Volatility

Inventory management within a food factory

Operational Performance Metrics in Manufacturing Process: Based on SCOR Model and RFID Technology

Material Requirements Planning (MRP)

The Ten Principles of Material Handling

LOGISTIQUE ET PRODUCTION SUPPLY CHAIN & OPERATIONS MANAGEMENT

Enterprise Systems: From Supply Chains to ERP to CRM

Reduce Costly Inventory Errors And Lost Sales Using Audit-Driven Vendor Classification

Top reasons why ekanban should be a key element of your lean manufacturing plan

Proceedings of the 2012 Winter Simulation Conference C. Laroque, J. Himmelspach, R. Pasupathy, O. Rose, and A.M. Uhrmacher, eds

Procedures & program of auditing assets. Section one Procedures & program of Auditing Fixed Assets

Operations/Inventory Excellence

SUPPLY CHAIN (SC) DRIVERS AND OBSTACLES

BEST PRACTICES IN DEMAND AND INVENTORY PLANNING

VISUAL management techniques for optimum INVENTORY form, fit and function

ACCOUNTING MODERNIZATION PREMISE OF AN EFFECTIVE GOVERNANCE SYSTEM OF ENTERPRISE

VALUE STREAM MAPPING ICONS

Inventory Costing in Microsoft

Jon Wesoky is currently Regional Director of Supply Chain Management Practice at Resources Global Professionals. In that role, he supports clients on

Transaction Processing and Enterprise Resource Planning Systems. Goal of Transaction Processing. Characteristics of Transaction Processing

Glossary of Inventory Management Terms

Metals Industry White Paper

Supply Chain Management

Process design. Process design. Process design. Operations strategy. Supply network design. Layout and flow Design. Operations management.

Dependent vs Independent Demand. The Evolution of MRP II. MRP II:Manufacturing Resource Planning Systems. The Modules In MRP II System

Microsoft Axapta Inventory Closing White Paper

Subbu Ramakrishnan. Manufacturing Finance with SAP. ERP Financials. Bonn Boston

BERGHOF Adaptive ERP Tuner makes your ERP simply more efficient. Efficiency through Enterprise Resource Planning

Supply Chain Optimization

RESEARCH NOTE NETSUITE S IMPACT ON MANUFACTURING COMPANY PERFORMANCE

The Logistics Management Information System Assessment Guidelines

NETWORK BUSINESS SYSTEMS SOFTWARE SYSTEM DOCUMENTATION MANUFACTURING SYSTEM FEATURES

Lean Kitting: A Case Study

Oracle SCM. Course duration: 45 Hrs Class duration: 1-1.5hrs

A HYBRID INVENTORY CONTROL SYSTEM APPROACH APPLIED TO THE FOOD INDUSTRY. David Claudio Jie Zhang Ying Zhang

BSCM Sample TEST. CPIM(Certified In Production & Inventory Management) - 1 -

STRESS TESTING A SUPPLY CHAIN USING SIMULATION. Swee Leong

Functional Area Systems Production / Operation Systems

26/10/2015. Functional Area Systems Production / Operation Systems. Examples: Functional Area Info Systems. Functional Area Information Systems

THE SUPPLY CHAIN MANAGEMENT AND OPERATIONS AS KEY TO FUTURE COMPETITIVENESS FOR RESEARCH, DEVELOPMENT AND MANUFACTURE OF NEW VEHICLES

Creating Competitive Advantage with your Supply Chain to Thrive the Economic Earthquake

Supply Chain development - a cornerstone for business success

Holistic Supply Chain Management A Focused Approach to Supply Chain Management through the Lens of Working Capital Management

System-Dynamics modelling to improve complex inventory management in a batch-wise plant

Supply Chain Management

Sales Order Management

Manufacturing Efficiency Guide

The Impact of Inventory Inaccuracy in the Food Manufacturing Industry: A Case Study Thanasak Ruankaew, PhD 1 and Patricia Williams 2

ERP s Automated Workflows Deploy Advanced Business Processes

MANAGEMENT ISSUES-MRP

SWP 58/91 SUPPLY NETWORKS AND THE CHANGING ROLE

Item Master and Bill of Material

Operations Management and the Integrated Manufacturing Facility

Job Manager for Metal Fabrication

Lean Principles by Jerry Kilpatrick

Lean Manufacturers Use the Visible Inventory ibin System to Dramatically Increase Inventory Turns

Logistics, Operations, and Supply Chain Management

Learning Objectives. Supply Chains & SCM Defined. Learning Objectives con t. Components of a Supply Chain for a Manufacturer

COMMUNICATING WITH MANAGEMENT ABOUT THE BENEFITS OF BUSINESS PROCESS SIMULATION

RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN INVENTORY MANAGEMENT AND INDUSTRIES BECOMING SICK, ESPECIALLY IN THIRD WORLD COUNTRIES

12 MRP and ERP. Dr. Ron Lembke

processes 1 This survey report is written within the PWO Project: Production scheduling of batch

Demand Forecast. Actual Orders. Order Forecast Collaboration: Benefits for the Entire Demand Chain. Integrating people, process and IT.

Transcription:

Proceedings of the 2011 Winter Simulation Conference S. Jain, R.R. Creasey, J. Himmelspach, K.P. White, and M. Fu, eds. SIMULATION ANALYSIS FOR ERP CONDUCTED IN JAPANESE SMES USING THE CONCEPT OF MFCA Xuzhong Tang Soemon Takakuwa Graduate School of Economics and Business Administration Nagoya University Furo-cho, Chikusa-ku, Nagoya, Aichi 464-8601, JAPAN ABSTRACT Small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs), which have limited resources, spend the majority of their time on routine business and have difficulty pursuing goals beyond economic efficiency, such as environmental preservation. In this study, using the concept of Material Flow Cost Accounting (MFCA), a simulation model for the Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) business flow of a Japanese electronic related manufacturing SME was constructed, and the hidden problems of stock shortage and dead stock were actualized. By analyzing the causes of these problems and by using a tool called Arena OptQuest, an appropriate materials purchasing plan was determined for the company. This solution will improve production efficiency and reduce the dead stock that causes a negative environmental impact. As a result, an improvement in both economic and environmental performance can be achieved. 1 INTRODUCTION Company activities such as environmental preservation often lead to increased costs. Enterprises, however, focus on profit and economic efficiency. In particular, small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs), which have limited resources, are very busy with routine tasks and have difficulty pursuing goals beyond economic efficiency. Recently, the development of environmental accounting systems has advanced, and these systems have been praised as powerful methods of improving economic efficiency while simultaneously protecting the environment. Material Flow Cost Accounting (MFCA), in particular, has received considerable attention for its effectiveness, and efforts have also been made toward the international standardization, i.e., the International Organization for Standardization (ISO) 14051. In this study, the reduction of deadstock materials (future waste) of the SMEs in Japan is assumed to be a center issue, and by using MFCA through a simulation analysis, the improvement proposal for business process concerning the Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) systems is made, which can improve production efficiency, improve customer satisfaction and optimize enterprise management for both economic and environmental performance. The research related to ERP and the application of ERP mainly advances in large enterprises. The efficiency of the whole supply chain, including small and medium-sized enterprises, is also mainly considered from the perspective of large enterprises, and the so-called coordinated effect of the whole system centers on the management optimization of larger enterprises. Few researchers have analyzed ERP from the perspective of SMEs. A framework for analyzing SME supply chains from the perspective of a vertically integrated raw material supplier was presented by Byrne and Heavy (2004). Mosca et al. (2005) presented a case study related to a project for the optimization of the manufacturing process in a small company produces mechanical components and finished products for awnings. Small and medium-sized manufacturing enterprises in Japan, which are in the lower levels of the keiretsu, take a weak stand on 978-1-4577-2109-0/11/$26.00 2011 IEEE 1084

their partners, namely the strong customers and the powerful parts suppliers. They are not considered in the optimization of the entire SCM system, or even for environmental preservation. The small and medium-sized enterprise that was surveyed in this research is a Japanese electronic related manufacturing enterprise (hereinafter called T Company ), in which a large-scale ERP system partly connected with that of the customers and the supplies was implemented. Customers frequent changes of the unofficial notification orders and frequent delivery delays by the powerful parts suppliers caused critical shortages of the necessary materials and an overstock of the unnecessary materials to happen often. Moreover, manufacturing efficiency decreases significantly when there is shortage of materials, causing not only a considerable cost for management but also a considerable amount of dead stock. Thus, a huge stock scrap occurs, which creates a substantial environmental burden. In this study, a simulation model is constructed by the software ARENA to determine the problems of T Company and to find an improvement solution for the company. As shown in Figure 1, the research is accomplished in four phases. The first phase consists of an investigation of the actual conditions of T Company s ERP system flow, including getting orders, stock control, order confirmation, production, and shipping goods. During the second phase, an AS-IS simulation model (the model represents the current situation) is constructed to determine the problem area from the company. However, the problem cannot be found by using this model. In the third phase, the concept of MFCA is introduced into the model and the stock materials, which have the possibility of being regular waste, are treated as the analyzing targets (in the concept of MFCA, they are called negative products). As a result, the problem was actualized, and the realities, such as an enormous stock and a bad manufacturing efficiency, were shown through the simulation model (AS-IS model using the concept of MFCA). Finally, at the fourth phase, the cause for the above-mentioned problems was analyzed and a tool called Arena OptQuest was used to determine an improvement solution. The effectiveness of the improvement solution was confirmed by running the simulation model with the improvement solution values assigned. Investigation of Actual Conditions of the Japanese SME Phase 1 (Section 2) Construction of AS-IS Simulation Model Construction of AS-IS Simulation Model using the Concept of MFCA Search for Optimal Solution Using Arena Opt-Quest Phase 2 (Section 3) Phase 3 (Section 4) Phase 4 (Section 5) Figure 1: The four research phases 2 INVESTIGATION OF ACTUAL CONDITIONS OF THE JAPANESE SME (PHASE 1) In this study, the research target T Company is an enterprise that manufactures electronic parts in Shizuoka Prefecture, Japan. The company is also a franchising agency for a famous electronic manufacturer. It produces and supplies parts to several large motor manufacturers in Shizuoka Prefecture. The company s business model proposes to stock electronic parts and to sell these parts as shipping products after production or directly to other companies. As a typical Japanese manufacturing SME, T Company has no negotiating power with its big customers and big suppliers, as illustrated in the smile curve shown in Figure 2. Profit & Power Key Parts Makers Manufacturing SMEs Consumer Makers Figure 2: The profit & power of Japanese manufacturing SMEs 1085

During the IT Boom, the selling condition of electronic parts was very good. T Company followed its big suppliers and customers booming activities by constructing a cool "IT" system and by introducing a large-scale ERP without understanding either the contents of the system or its purpose. The mechanism of the production management system for ERP combines the methods of Sequence Number System (SNS) and Material Requirements Planning (MRP). The main business flow is shown in Figure 3 and is as follows. (1) Getting orders ~ Production schedules (SNS method): The production series number and the schedules are decided according to the unofficial notifications or information from the customers. (2) Stock Management (Materials Purchasing ~ Warehousing ~ Materials Allocation ~ Materials Delivered to Production Area): The purchasing quantity of materials is decided according to the unofficial notifications of the commodity orders and the production schedules (MRP method). While the same parts may be sold to a different customer, the company will have the stock as its own property. The materials are allocated to a certain production series number or the sales order by the first in first out (FIFO) rule according to the arrival time of the sales order or the unofficial notification. (3) Order Confirmation ~ Production ~ Shipment: If the necessary materials for production or the sales order that are allocated from the stock and production conditions are ready, the sales staff will confirm with the customers whether the unofficial notification is a real order. If the order is real, production begins. When production is completed, the products are packed and shipped to the customers. When materials are sold directly to the customers, all the processes are the same, except there is no need for production. Unofficial Customer Orders (Parts Sales) Unofficial Customer Orders () (1) Real Parts Sales Orders Unofficial Notification Accuracy Problem Real Orders Master Production Scheduling (MPS) Production Series No. Establishment Stock File Materials Req. Planning (MRP) Stock Shortage and Over Stock Materials Purchasing orders Subcontract Orders Manufacture Orders (2) Materials Warehousing Subcontract Parts Delivery Materials Allocation (3) Order Confirmation Materials to Production Area Production Efficiency Decreasing and Delivery Delaying Manufacturing Commodities Shipment Shipment Figure 3: The ERP system flow of T Company During the IT Boom, production could not meet the market demand, since stocked parts or produced products were sold immediately and since there were not as many problems in stock management. The mechanism of preventing overstock was not included in T Company s ERP system. 1086

Recently, because of the economic depression, unofficial information from the customer has been changed or cancelled frequently, and the lifecycles of the products and parts have been shortened. The following problems have appeared in T Company in recent years. (1) Critical shortages of the necessary materials and overstock of the unnecessary materials happen frequently. (2) The manufacturing efficiency decreases remarkably because of stock shortages of necessary parts and increased production costs. (3) The production lead time becomes longer and customer satisfaction decreases, which has a considerable impact on the company s revenue. (4) The unnecessary stock increases and causes a huge dead stock. At the end of every year, the dead stock must be scrapped, which causes not only a financing problem but also a substantial environmental burden. 3 CONSTRUCTION OF AS-IS SIMULATION MODEL (PHASE 2) Given the above-mentioned problems of T Company, an AS-IS simulation model of business flow in T company s ERP system was constructed by using the simulation package, ARENA (Kelton, Sakowski, and Swets 2010). 3.1 Scenario of the Surveyed Composition and Production Process of AS-IS Simulation In T Company, tens of kinds of products and thousands of kinds of the purchased parts to be sold are handled. In the AS-IS simulation model, two types of products ordered by the two main customers of products makers and two types of parts ordered by the two main customers of trading companies are listed, respectively. The composition of the products and the production process are simplified to facilitate the analysis. All the parameters and values are summarized in Table 1. Table 1: The Parameters and Values Set in the AS-IS Model Orders of Customer A Orders of Customer B Orders of Customer C Orders of Customer D Order Frequency (hours) every 84 every 120 every 36 every 84 Delivery Time (hours) TRIA(84, 96, 120) (*1) TRIA(96, 120, 136) UNIF(48, 84) TRIA(36, 96, 120) Quantity (pieces) UNIF(50, 60) UNIF(40, 60) UNIF(120, 200) UNIF(120, 180) Product Type Product A Product B Part C Part D a (pieces) UNIF(12,36) (*3) 2 Materials Including b (pieces) UNIF(18,36) 3 1 c (pieces) UNIF(18,36) 2 1 d (pieces) UNIF(24,30) 1 1 1 High Speed SMT (hours) (1) UNIF(0.25, 0.30) (*2) (1) UNIF(0.25, 0.30) Production Sequence Manual Mounting (hours) (2) UNIF(0.15, 0.30) Assembly (hours) (3) UNIF(0.30, 0.40) (2) UNIF(0.30, 0.40) Checking (hours) (3) UNIF(0.15, 0.25) (3) UNIF(0.15, 0.25) Packing (hours) (5) TRIA(4, 6, 8) (4) TRIA(4, 6, 8) (1) TRIA(4, 6, 8) (1) TRIA(4, 6, 8) (*1): TRIA = Triangular, UNIF = Uniform (*2): (1), (2), = the production process number (*3): lead time of procurement (hours) 1087

3.2 The Composition and the Logic of AS-IS Simulation Model The model is composed of the following five sub-modules, as shown in Figure 4. (1) Generate Sales Orders: In this sub-module, unofficial notifications for four different customers are generated and addressed with different order numbers, product quantities, structures of materials, delivery times, and so forth. (2) Stock Management: Purchasing orders are generated, addressed with certain quantities of certain materials according to the present inventory level and the total demand of materials calculated in the first sub-module. The process of warehousing with the logic of increasing inventory level is also built. (3) Allocate Materials from Stock: The materials are allocated to a certain order by a certain rule (e.g., the first in first out (FIFO) rule, the low attributed value (LAV) rule) that can be adjusted by changing the program. If the necessary materials for the sales orders are allocated from the stock, the allocation signals will be released. (4) Production & Shipping: The production process of a certain order will be implemented if the order entity receives both an allocation signal sent from the third sub-module and an order confirmation signal sent from the following fifth sub-module. (5) Order Confirmation: An order confirmation signal will be released if a certain order is confirmed to be a real order. A fake order means that the order was cancelled by the customer and that the relative allocated materials should be returned to the stock. Generate Sales Orders Stock Management Allocate Materials from Stock Production & Shipping Order Confirmation Create Sales Orders Create Stock Evaluator Original Original Seperate Order Entities Seperate Order Entities Delay for Order Confirmation Duplicate Orders Duplicate Assign Order Contents Order # # Delivery Time Material Demand Assign Total Demand of Materials Level > Total Demand? NO Issue Purchase Orders YES Purchase Quantity = Total Demand Level+ Allowance Level > Order Material Demand? NO Wait for the Next Materials Warehousing YES Wait for Materials Allocation Signal Wait for Signal of Order Confirmation Product A & B Start Sequence of Production Commodity C & D A Real Order? YES Release Signal of Order Confirmation Dispose Order Entities NO To Sub-module of Allocate Materials Delay (Material Delivery Lead Time) Allocation Product A High Speed SMT Search the Cancelled Warehousing Dispose Entity of Stock Evaluator Level Increased Reduction Level = Level Material Demand of the Certain Order Release Production Signal Product B Manual Mounting Assy Checking Remove the Cancelled Return Materials to the Proper Stock Level Increased To Sub-module of Production & Shipping Dispose Entity Batch & Packing Shipping /Commodities Figure 4: The logic of the AS-IS simulation model 1088

Figure 5 shows the running situation of the AS-IS model by the animation layout. The left part of the illustration labeled Stock Management shows the changing inventory level by giving both the plots and the figures. The middle part and the right part show the implementation of the materials allocation, order confirmation, production and shipping process. The lower right figures show the numbers of the orders that shipped and the delayed shipping orders. Figure 5: The animation of the AS-IS model 3.3 Execution Results and Cause Analysis of AS-IS Simulation Model The AS-IS model was executed for 100 replications with the run length assumed to be one year. The average results (at the 95% confidence level) are shown in Table 2. At this point, the problems cannot be identified. Table 2: The Materials Condition and Shipping Accomplishment Materials at the End Order Lead Time Shipped Orders Delayed Orders of the Year (pieces) (hours) (orders) (orders) 470 312 136 17 As mentioned during phase 1, a mechanism of preventing overstock was not included in T Company s ERP system, so the dead stock was also not reflected in the simulation model. Actually, in T Company, all stock, including the dead stock, are considered assets, and the financial statements do not show the bad situations such as having a huge dead stock during the interim period. At the end of the year, the dead stock showed up and had to be scrapped, and the profits shown in the financial statements worsened; additionally, this wasted stock generates a substantial environmental burden. By the usual accounting method, the dead stock can be called to attention by the concept of cash flow. However, during the routine business activities, the field managers will not consider the materials abandonment or the dead stock. Therefore, some in-process management techniques should be introduced into the model. In recent years, MFCA has received considerable attention for its effectiveness. The concept of MFCA is attempted to be used to reconstruct the model in order to actualize the problems of T Company. 1089

4 CONSTRUCTION OF THE AS-IS SIMULATION MODEL USING THE CONCEPT OF MFCA (PHASE 3) 4.1 The Concept of MFCA MFCA is a system to measure the flow and stock of materials in the manufacturing process (raw materials and energy), in terms of physical and monetary units (Kokubu 2008). The prototype of MFCA was developed in Germany as an environmental protection accounting technique. MFCA was introduced to Japan in 2000, and since then, great progress has been made regarding the introduction and application of MFCA to the activities of Japanese enterprises (Environmental Industries Office 2007). For the international standardization of MFCA, The Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry proposed the New Work Item Proposal to TC207 (environmental management) of the international organization for standardization (ISO) in November 2007. It was adopted in March 2008. As a result, the working group that did the standardization was set up. It began work for the international standard issue, and ISO 14051 was given from the ISO secretariat to the MFCA standard in the spring of 2011. MFCA is attracting not only Japanese but also worldwide attention (Environmental Industries Office 2010). The concept of MFCA is as shown in Figure 6. The manufacturing enterprise stocks the raw materials, produces the products through the production activities, and supplies them to the market. These products are considered to be positive products in MFCA. On the other hand, waste is also generated during the process of stocking and production. When the materials are stocked as inventory, because of the quality deterioration or renewal of parts, the materials or the parts cannot be useable for production any longer. When the materials are processed, residues or shavings may be generated. Under the circumstances mentioned above, these materials are all considered waste. Because they may lead to environmental problems, in the concept of MFCA, these materials are all treated as negative products and are considered a loss. Materials Subsidiary Materials Subsidiary Materials Materials Process 1 WIP Process 2 Waste Waste Waste Waste Waste Materials Quality Deterioration Renewed Yielding Rate Defective Goods Quality Deterioration Yielding Rate Defective Goods Quality Deterioration Figure 6: The concept of MFCA (Environmental Industries Office 2007) Because the main business of T Company is electronic components assembly, the amount of waste generated is minimal during the production process. However, a large amount of immovable stocks are generated every year, and when the end of the term comes, because the parts are not useable any longer, they all become waste. Therefore, in this study, waste from the materials inventory was focused on in T Company and the model was reconstructed by introducing the concept of MFCA. 1090

4.2 The AS-IS Simulation Model Using the Concept of MFCA To use the concept of MFCA, there is a need to grasp the actual situation of waste generated from the raw materials inventory in T Company. The renewal pattern of the raw material a is assumed to be an example, as shown in Figure 7. According to the product composition list from the customer, material a is renewed every 90 days. When parts a1 are renewed to a2, the parts a1 stocked before cannot be used for production any longer, and they become a kind of immovable stock. Because T Company does not treat the immovable stock as waste during the interim period, huge amounts dead stock are not recognized. When the end of the term comes, the volume of the dead stock becomes large, causing a considerable amount of waste that will influence the profit of the company and that will produce a substantial environmental burden. Renewed to a5 a5 Renewed to a4 a4 Renewed to a3 a3 Not valid for production a1 Renewed to a2 a2 a2 Not valid for production Not valid for production 90 days 90 days 90 days The End of 90 days the Term a1 a2 Waste has to be scrapped a3 a4 Figure 7: The actual condition of materials renewal in T Company Considering the reality mentioned above that the immovable stock is caused by a regular renewal of the raw materials, the approach of using the concept of MFCA is attempted in our research. In the routine production activities, the immovable stocks are treated and counted as waste or negative products to actualize the stock problems during the interim period. This concept is shown in Figure 8. Renewed to a5 a5 Renewed to a4 a4 a1 Renewed to a2 a2 Renewed to a3 a3 90 days 90 days 90 days Waste: Waste: Waste: a1 a2 a3 90 days The End of the Term Waste: a4 Figure 8: The method of the stock management using the concept of MFCA The above concept was reflected in the AS-IS simulation model with the addition of the sub-module of Scrap Dead Stock. The logic of model is shown in Figure 9 (the additional parts are enclosed with a red dotted line circle). 1091

Generate Sales Orders Stock Management Allocate Materials from Stock Production & Shipping Order Confirmation Scrap Dead Stock Create Sales Orders Create Stock Evaluator Seperate Order Entities Duplicate Orders Original Seperate Order Entities Duplicate Original Delay for Order Confirmation Create Dead Stock Checker Assign Order Contents Assign Total Demand of Materials To Sub-module of Allocate Materials Order # # Delivery Time Material Demand Level > Total Demand? NO Issue Purchase Orders Purchase Quantity = Total Demand Level+ Allowance Delay (Material Delivery Lead Time) YES Order Arriving Time Trace Level > Order Material Demand? NO Wait for the Next Materials Warehousing YES Wait for Materials Allocation Signal Wait for Signal of Order Confirmation Product A & B Start Sequence of Production High Speed SMT Commodity C & D A Real Order? YES Release Signal of Order Confirmation Dispose Order Entities Search the Cancelled NO Trace Materials Purchase Time Scrap the Dead Stock Level Reduced Dispose Entities Warehousing Level Increased Allocation Reduction Product A Product B Manual Mounting Remove the Cancelled Dispose Entity of Stock Evaluator Level = Level Material Demand of the Certain Order Assy Checking Trace Order Arriving Time Return Materials to the Proper Stock Release Production Signal To Sub-module of Production & Shipping Batch & Packing Shipping /Commodities Dispose Entity Level Increased Figure 9: The logic of the AS-IS simulation model using the concept of MFCA 4.3 The Execution Results and the Analysis of the AS-IS Model Using the Concept of MFCA The model was executed for 100 replications with the run length assumed to be one year. Compared with the results shown from the AS-IS model in 3.3, the average results (at the 95% confidence level) of this model worsened, as shown in Table 3. Through the construction of the simulation model using the concept of MFCA, the useless materials in the stock are reflected as negative products, which are excluded from the orders allocation objectives. The reality of the decrease in the manufacturing efficiency due to stock shortage and the increase of the dead stock are reflected in real time during the interim period. The problem is actualized, and the necessity for an improvement solution is apparent. Materials at the End of the Year (pieces) Table 3: Materials Conditions and Shipping Accomplishment Number of Abandoned Materials (pieces) Order Lead Time (hours) Shipped Orders (orders) Delayed Orders (orders) 452 2584 330 135 26 5 SEARCH FOR OPTIMAL SOLUTION (PHASE 4) In this section, to determine an improvement solution for the problems ascertained from the analysis of the AS-IS model using the concept of MFCA, an optimization program in Arena called OptQuest was used. To use this tool, the optimal objectives and the control conditions through the path analysis should be determined first. 1092

Figure 10 shows an analytical situation in which the execution process of the ERP system in T Company influences both the economic and the environmental performance. Demand forecast influences all the business activities that have consequence for the management results. There is no doubt that positive activities such as negotiations with customers and collections of accurate unofficial notifications by the sales staff are very important. To accomplish the above-mentioned improvements, incentive and evaluation systems to improve the performance of the sales staff are necessary in addition to the improvement solution for the ERP system. During the implementation of the ERP system, materials purchasing planning is very significant and it influences the other activities considerably, as shown in Figure 10. Inaccurate materials purchasing planning causes stock surplus and stock shortage simultaneously, which not only decreases manufacturing efficiency, which causes delivery delays and customers dissatisfaction (a business economic problem), but also generates dead stock, which increase waste (economic funding issues and environmental problems). Demand Forecast accuracy Materials Purchasing Planning 1. Purchasing Quantity 2. Materials Allocation Rule Setting 3. BOM Maintenance ERP Executing System Production Plan Accuracy Overstock Stock Shortage Manufacturing Execution Efficiency WIP Stock Increase Delivery Date Observance level Dead Stock Manufacturing Costs Customer Satisfaction Abandoned Materials Level at the end of the term Order Lead Time Shipped Orders Delayed Orders Environment Problems caused by Scrapped Stock Economic Problems for the Company Figure 10: The analytic situation of the ERP system in T Company Through the interview with the staff members of T Company, for materials purchasing planning in the ERP system, the following two control conditions are very important. (1) Purchasing Quantity Purchasing Quantity = Total Order Demand - Level + Allowance. Here, the lower bound for the allowance was set as the value calculated based on the possible cancelled orders and the upper bound was set as the value based on the biggest order demand quantity in the model. (2) Materials Allocation Rule Setting In the improved model, the allocation rule was changed to a combination of the two factors, (a) delivery time and (b) order priority (according to the percentage of certainty of the unofficial notifications of different customers), of which the expression is Delivery Time + Priority * Priori- 1093

ty Importance, in which the lower bound and the upper bound for the Priority Importance were as 12 (one day) and 136 (the longest order delivery time) respectively. In addition, the procedure of system maintenance such as updating the bill of materials (BOM) should also be considered when the renewal of a certain kind of materials happening. In T Company, it usually takes one week. However, it can be reduced at most to 24 hours. Hence, the program considering of system maintenance was also conducted. Since the improvement of the environmental performance is the main issue in this study, the minimization of the amount of Abandoned Materials which are also called negative products in MFCA is set as the objective. At the same time, the economic improvement should also be considered. Thus, the other indices are set as the constraints detailed as follows (the values are based on the executed results of the AS-IS model). (1) at the end of the year<= 470; (2) Order Lead Time <= 312; (3) Orders that has been shipped delayed <= 17; (4) Orders shipped > = 136. The optimization program Arena OptQuest was executed 1000 times. The average results (at the 95% confidence level) of the best solution are shown in Table 4. Comparing the results of the AS-IS model and the AS-IS model using the concept of MFCA, the values of Environmental Performance and Economic Performance showed balanced results in the improved model using OptQuest. Simulation Models Table 4: The Simulation Executing Results Environmental Performance Materials at the End of the Year (pieces) Number of Abandoned Materials (pieces) Order Lead Time (hours) Economic Performance Shipped Orders (orders) Delayed Orders (orders) AS-IS 470 N/A 312 136 17 AS-IS (MFCA) 452 2584 330 135 26 OptQuest 426 1655 311 141 15 By constructing the simulation model for the T Company s ERP System, using the concept of MFCA and searching the optimal solution with Arena OptQuest, an improvement solution was determined. The proper controlled conditions for setting materials purchasing quantities and for allocating rules will lead to a significant reduction of waste and will surely increase order execution efficiency. Moreover, these improvements facilitate to a better environmental and economic performance. 6 CONCLUSIONS In this study, the effectiveness of the in-process type of management technique of MFCA is confirmed through the construction of the simulation model using the MFCA concept. The abandonment of the dead stock is reflected as the generation of negative products, and the stock problem is actualized during the routine business activities, and thus, measurements can be taken to reduce waste that produces a negative environmental impact. Additionally, by determining an appropriate materials purchasing plan, executable production schedules can be made, which will improve order execution efficiency. As a result, an improvement in both economic and environmental performance can be achieved. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS This research was supported by Grant-in-Aid for Asian CORE Program "Manufacturing and Environmental Management in East Asia" of Japan Society for the Promotion of Science (JSPS). Special thanks should be expressed to Prof. K. Kokubu for his advice on material flow cost accounting. 1094

REFERENCES Byrne, P. and C. Heavy. 2004. Simulation, A Framework for Analysing Supply Chains. In Proceedings of the 2004 Winter Simulation Conference, ed. R.G. Ingalls, M.D. Rossetti, J. S. Smith, and B. A. Peters, 1167-1175. Piscataway, New Jersey: Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers, Inc. Environmental Industries Office, Industrial Science and Technology Policy and Environment Bureau, Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry. 2007. Guide for Material Flow Cost Accounting (Ver.1). http://www.meti.go.jp/policy/eco_business/pdf/mfca%20guide20070822.pdf. Environmental Industries Office, Industrial Science and Technology Policy and Environment Bureau, Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry, Japan. 2010. Material Flow Cost Accounting MFCA Case Examples. http://www.jmac.co.jp/mfca/thinking/data/mfca_case_example_e.pdf. Kelton, W. D., R. P. Sadowski, and N. B. Swets. 2010. Simulation with ARENA. 5th ed. New York, NY: Mc Graw-Hill Co., Inc. Kokubu, K. 2008. Material Flow Cost Accounting. Tokyo: Japan Environmental Management Association for Industry. (in Japanese) Mosca, R., R. Revetria, L. Cassettari and G. Margro. 2005. Simulation as Support for Production Planning in Small and Medium Enterprise: A Case Study. In Proceedings of the 2005 Winter Simulation Conference, ed. M.E. Kuhl, N.M. Steiger, F.B. Armstrong, and J.A. Joines, 2443-2448. Piscataway, New Jersey: Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers, Inc. AUTHOR BIOGRAPHIES XUZHONG TANG is a Ph.D. Student at the Graduate School of Economics and Business Administration at Nagoya University in Japan. He received his M. Sc. degree in management from Chukyo University in 2005. He worked in a Japanese electronic related manufacturing enterprise and had been involved in the ERP improvement project at the same enterprise. His research interests include ERP improvement and the application of MFCA using simulation and other optimal tools. His email address is tangxuzhong@gmail.com. SOEMON TAKAKUWA is a Professor at the Graduate School of Economics and Business Administration at Nagoya University in Japan. He received his B. Sc. and M. Sc. degrees in industrial engineering from Nagoya Institute of Technology in 1975 and Tokyo Institute of Technology in 1977, respectively. His Ph.D. is in industrial engineering from Pennsylvania State University. He holds a Doctorate of Economics form Nagoya University. He holds a P.E. in Industrial Engineering. His research interests include the optimization of manufacturing and logistics systems, management information systems and simulation analysis on these systems in the context of hospitals. He prepared the Japanese editions of both Introduction to simulation using SIMAN and Simulation with ARENA. He serves concurrently as the senior staff of Department of Hospital Management Strategy and Planning at Nagoya University Hospital. His email address is takakuwa@soec.nagoya-u.ac.jp. 1095