Exhibit 1: Hedge Fund Style Returns During Increasing and Decreasing Correlation Environments



Similar documents
Portfolio Strategy. Trading Less Competitive Markets is Costly

PORTFOLIO STRATEGY. Exhibit 2: S&P s End of Day Moves Last Week. Market Commentary 19 August Exhibit 1: ETF Trading Spikes Up

Risk Budgeting: Concept, Interpretation and Applications

Capturing Equity Risk Premium Revisiting the Investment Strategy

Investment Portfolio Management and Effective Asset Allocation for Institutional and Private Banking Clients

Defensive equity. A defensive strategy to Canadian equity investing

Investment Insight Diversified Factor Premia Edward Qian PhD, CFA, Bryan Belton, CFA, and Kun Yang PhD, CFA PanAgora Asset Management August 2013

The Merits of Absolute Return Quantitative Investment Strategies

Hedge funds: the case for trading strategies

Asset Management. Why Cidel? Our risk approach.

Assessing the Risks of a Yield-Tilted Equity Portfolio

Bonds: A Solution for Yield-Starved Insurance Companies?

Single Manager vs. Multi-Manager Alternative Investment Funds

Algorithmic Trading Session 1 Introduction. Oliver Steinki, CFA, FRM

S&P 500 Low Volatility Index

Hedge funds: the case for trading strategies

How To Take Advantage Of The Coming Rise In Volatility

High Yield Bonds in a Rising Rate Environment August 2014

Absolute return investments in rising interest rate environments

NEW STRATEGIC INSIGHT US MUTUAL FUND OBJECTIVES ROLLOUT IN SIMFUND MF

The Dual Advantage of Long/Short Equity

SEI Japan Equity Fund As at 30th June, 2009

Liquid Alternative Investments MAPS. Market Analysis & Performance Summary Year-End

NorthCoast Investment Advisory Team

Hedge Funds: A Preamble. Michael F. Percia

Commodity Trading Advisors. AQF 2005 Nicolas Papageorgiou

What Level of Incentive Fees Are Hedge Fund Investors Actually Paying?

A Snapshot of Active Share

Equity Market Neutral: Diversifier Across Market Cycles

Long/Short Equity Investing Part I Styles, Strategies, and Implementation Considerations

Russell Low Volatility Indexes: Helping moderate life s ups and downs

Commodities. Precious metals as an asset class. April What qualifies as an asset class? What makes commodities an asset class?

THE ROLE OF LIQUID ALTERNATIVES IN WEALTH MANAGEMENT

Holding the middle ground with convertible securities

Portfolio Margining. Welcome

Alpha Preservation. Using Valuations to Identify Style Risk. Benjamin Graham

Implementing Point and Figure RS Signals

Olympia Capital Management

Probabilities Long/Short

DISCLAIMER. A Member of Financial Group

Fixed Income Investing: What s an Investor to Do?

McKinley Capital U.S. Equity Income Prospects for Performance in a Changing Interest Rate Environment

SPDR S&P 500 Low Volatility UCITS ETF

INSIGHT. Do we need corporate bonds? Credits in competition with treasuries and equities. For professional use only. Not for re-distribution.

The Morningstar Category TM Classifications for Hedge Funds

Re-Assessing Multi-Strategy Hedge Funds Aaron Mirandon, Associate Portfolio Manager

The recent volatility of high-yield bonds: Spreads widen though fundamentals stay strong

Long Term Investment Pool (LTIP) Investment Policy Statement Level 1

Absolute return: The search for positive returns in changing markets

Pricing and Strategy for Muni BMA Swaps

U.S. SHORT TERM. Equity Risk Model IDENTIFY ANALYZE QUANTIFY NORTHFIELD

Crisis Alpha and Risk in Alternative Investment Strategies

Purpose of Selling Stocks Short JANUARY 2007 NUMBER 5

Exchange Traded Funds

Rethinking Fixed Income

Institutional Trading of Equity Derivatives

Fixed Income Update Portfolio Positioning

High Yield Bonds A Primer

INVESTMENT POLICY STATEMENT Valued Client

CALVERT UNCONSTRAINED BOND FUND A More Expansive Approach to Fixed-Income Investing

SSgA CAPITAL INSIGHTS

Managing Risk/Reward in Fixed Income

Practical aspects of implementing MiFID requirementsin GIPS compositereports

ETF Total Cost Analysis in Action

corrected transcript FactSet Research Systems Inc. MANAGEMENT DISCUSSION SECTION

Sophisticated investments. Simple to use.

The Risk in Fixed-Income Hedge Fund Styles. William Fung And David A. Hsieh. August 2002

How To Invest In High Yield Bonds

A Pared-Down Approach to Stock Picking. That is Market-Neutral and Results-Driven

Portfolio Management Consultants Perfecting the Portfolio

Smart beta: 2015 survey findings from U.S. financial advisors

The active/passive decision in global bond funds

Risk Control and Equity Upside: The Merits of Convertible Bonds for an Insurance Portfolio

The Need for Speed: It s Important, Even for VWAP Strategies

Forum. Protection Strategies: Thinking beyond the VIX. A meeting place for views and ideas. Thomas Gillespie PhD, Director, Investment Risk Advisory

PERFORMING DUE DILIGENCE ON NONTRADITIONAL BOND FUNDS. by Mark Bentley, Executive Vice President, BTS Asset Management, Inc.

THE IMPORTANCE OF SECTORS IN GLOBAL EQUITY INVESTING

STATEMENT OF INVESTMENT BELIEFS AND PRINCIPLES

Fixed Income Liquidity in a Rising Rate Environment

OIC Options on ETFs

FTIF Templeton Global Bond Fund

Portfolio Management. Bertrand Groslambert. Skema Business School

LONG/SHORT EQUITY: Choosing Alpha over Beta SEPTEMBER 2014

Is It Time to Give Up on Active Management?

About Hedge Funds. What is a Hedge Fund?

Over a barrel: Causes and consequences of the fall in oil prices

Does the Number of Stocks in a Portfolio Influence Performance?

Dual Listing of the SGX EURO STOXX 50 Index Futures in Singapore

Maximizing Your Equity Allocation

Hedge Funds: Risk and Return

r a t her t han a s a f e haven

An Unconventional View of Trading Volume

Ten reasons to be invested in European Listed Real Estate

Systematic Approach in Global and Regional Markets

Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta Financial Markets Conference Hedge Fund: An Industry in its Adolescence

Designing The Ideal Investment Policy Presented To The Actuaries Club of the Southwest & the Southeastern Actuarial Conference

Why own bonds when yields are low?

David C. Reilly, CFA President - Decision Critical Resources, Inc.

Markaz Volatility Indices (MVX)

EVENT DRIVEN KNOCKED WITH FEW HEAVY-WEIGHT FUNDS

Transcription:

ve Equity Derivatives Strategy CSFB Quantitati CSFB SFB Equity Derivatives Strategy Global Market Commentary October, 6, 24 Mika Toikka (212) 325-5798 Ed Tom (212) 325-3584 Martin Boldt-Christmas 44 2 7888 8696 Stanislas Bourgois 44-2-7888-459 Alpha Pains Why It s a Tough Market The recent market environment has turned out to be a tough one for stock pickers. Not only is equity market volatility at very low levels but also correlation among stock returns is at historically high levels. This is the first time in 25 years that we are seeing an environment where correlations and volatility have been moving in opposite directions in a meaningful way. See Exhibit 6. Low volatility environments make it difficult to generate differentiated returns but this is made much worse when there is a tendency for stock returns to be highly correlated. High stock return correlations imply that stock returns are being pushed around in unison by big picture related issues (macro) and that single stock related issues (idiosyncratic risks) on aggregate are having less of an impact on returns than usual. We show historically how the correlation environment makes a big difference in the expected performance of various investment styles. We examine the 14 sub investment categories of the CSFB Tremont hedge fund index during increasing and decreasing correlation environments. As Exhibit 1 shows, there tends to be a strong relationship between a fund s style performance and the correlation environment. Funds that are focused on idiosyncratic risk (stock pickers) tend to do much better in decreasing correlation environments (e.g. long short strategies). Funds that focus on bigger picture macro issues (e.g. emerging markets and managed futures) historically tend to do much better in increasing correlation environments. Many funds have inherent and often substantial correlation exposure without fully realizing it. The derivatives markets are currently pricing in a decrease in correlation going forward although levels on an absolute basis are still expected to remain high. Bigger picture (macro) related issues are most likely going to continue to dominate market concern, which implies that it might not be the best of environments for stock pickers. One of our favourite trades continues to be the selling of correlation especially during market shocks where macro fears surge. Call us for details. Exhibit 1: Hedge Fund Style Returns During Increasing and Decreasing Correlation Environments Average Return.14.12.1.8.6.4.2 -.2 -.4 Hedge Fund Index Convertible Arbitrage Dedicated Short Emerging Markets Rising Falling Equity Mkt Neutral Event Driven New York London Tokyo Mika Toikka (212) 325-5798 Sri Moorthy +44-2-7888-853 Stephen Chadwick +81-3-5777-7183 Peter Tannenbaum (212) 325-6255 Martin Boldt-Christmas +44-2-7888-8696 Edmund Ching +852 211 7296 Edward K. Tom (212) 325-3584 Hon Wai Lai +44-2-7888-9637 Ken Feng +81-3-5777-7183 Cem Hocaoglu (212) 325-722 Stanislaus Bourgois +44-2-7888-459 Ryan Renicker (212) 325-1621 Colin Goldin +44 2 7888-9637 Distressed E.D. Multi-Strategy Risk Arbitrage Fixed Income Arb Global Macro Long/Short Equity Managed Futures Multi-Strategy

Exhibit 2: S&P 5: Current Trading Range 16 15 14 13 12 11 1 9 8 7 1/3/ 7/3/ 1/3/1 7/3/1 1/3/2 7/3/2 1/3/3 7/3/3 1/3/4 7/3/4 1/3/5 The Year of the Trading Range The S&P 5 has spent all of 24 in a narrow 1% trading range (i.e. less than 1 S&P 5 points). See Exhibit 2. Narrow trading ranges of the duration that we have seen thus far in 24 are a highly unusual phenomenon. Since the late 197 s there have been three instances where we have experienced a trading range this narrow that has lasted longer than the current 191 business days. See Exhibit 3 where we graph distributions of trading ranges. A natural consequence of the extended narrow trading range has been a collapse in both implied and realized volatility. Three month implied volatility on the S&P 5 has fallen 16 points whereas realized volatility has declined almost 5 points since the start of the year. If we take a longer-term perspective (Exhibit 4), volatilities on the S&P 5 are fast approaching the extreme lows that we experienced in the middle of the 199 s. Note that the last two instances of trading ranges as narrow as what we are currently experiencing occurred in 1992 and 1993. Exhibit 3: Distribution of Trading Ranges Instances 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 Frequency 2 4 6 8 1 12 14 16 18 2 22 24 Trading Range Days Consequences of Low Volatility In Exhibit 5 we show the relative returns of single stocks versus the overall market in absolute terms. It s clear that we have had a significant contraction in market relative returns as overall equity volatilities have declined. Naturally, this contraction in relative returns makes outperforming benchmarks by picking stocks a more difficult exercise. However, what really makes the current environment exceptional and very different from other low volatility environments such as the early 199 s is that not only have volatilities collapsed but also stock return correlations Exhibit 4: Three Month S&P 5 Volatility is Close to the Lows Last Seen in Early 199 s 6 5 4 87 Crash 199 Iraqi Invasion O f K u w a it LTCM A s ia C ris is M a r k e t Bottom 22 Sep 11 2 nd Ira q W a r 3 2 1 12/3/1983 12/3/1986 12/3/1989 12/3/1992 12/3/1995 12/3/1998 12/3/21 12/3/24 2

Exhibit 5: Relative Returns (Absolute) 3 25 2 15 1 5 1/23/ 3/23/1 5/23/2 7/23/3 9/23/4 have increased (i.e. cross sectional stock returns). This is the first time in 25 years that we are seeing an environment where correlations and volatility have decoupled in a meaningful way. That is, correlation and volatility have moved in opposite directions. Please see Exhibit 6. Note how there is a general tendency for volatility and correlation to move together (as one would expect). However, the recent environment clearly stands out as an exception. The Role of Correlation A market environment with high stock return correlations implies that stock returns are being driven by big picture (macro) related issues and stocks have a tendency to move in unison (at least more so than traditionally). In other words, during these high correlation environments systematic risk dominates over idiosyncratic (stock specific) risk. Alpha Pains Naturally if stock returns are moving in unison (high correlation environment), it is more difficult to pick stocks. Even though one picks the right stocks so to speak, the market is not rewarding one (at least not to the degree that it would in a low correlation environment) for picking these right stocks. In Exhibit 7 we display cross sectional returns for a large U.S. equity universe. As the Exhibit 7 clearly shows since 2, we have a significant contraction in single stock cross sectional variation. Exhibit 7: Cross Sectional Return Variation Returns 18 13 8 3-2 -7-12 -17 1% 5% 9% -22 9/23/99 9/23/ 9/23/1 9/23/2 9/23/3 9/23/4 During these environments of high stock return correlations, adding value at the single stock level becomes much more difficult and the bigger picture asset allocation decisions tend to dominate. Hence, the current environment with both low volatility and high correlation is the worst of all worlds for stock pickers. Exhibit 6: Significant Divergence in Correlation and Volatility 7 % 6 % S ix M o n t h A v e r a g e C o r r e l a t io n 6 M R e a l iz e d V o la t il it y 5 % 4 % 3 % 2 % 1 % % 9 / 2 4 / 7 9 9 / 2 4 / 8 4 9 / 2 4 / 8 9 9 / 2 4 / 9 4 9 / 2 4 / 9 9 9 / 2 4 / 4 3

Exhibit 8: Correlation Environments 7% 6% 5% 4% 3% 2% 1% % 9/24/79 9/24/84 9/24/89 9/24/94 9/24/99 9/24/4 Implicit Correlation Bets Correlation permeates most equity trading strategies because implicitly any strategy that has a portfolio of stocks in it is taking on correlation risk. To empirically show the impact of correlation, we divide the past into increasing and decreasing correlation environments. We use 6- month realized correlations on the S&P 5 going back to 1979 for our analysis. See Exhibit 8. Observe how the lowest levels of stock return correlations were reached back in the early 199 s (when volatility was also exceptionally low) and the top of the bubble in 2. In 2, correlation was low as there was a high degree of dispersions in returns. That is, the new economy stocks were going in one direction and the old economy stocks were going in another. During this period volatility was also exceptionally high, making for a stock pickers market. The last several years have been a period of relatively high correlation as the market has Exhibit 1: Impact of Correlation on Market Direction 5 D e c lin in g C o r r e la tio n been driven by macro issues, for example, Sep 11, the war with Iraq, market bottom of 22 and more recently terrorism fears, oil shocks, etc. Note the sharp decline in correlation following the initial war with Iraq back in March of 23. However, since then correlations have refused to decline back to normalized levels as macro concerns have continued to dominate. The Impact of Correlation on Equity Strategies First we explore the impact of market direction on correlation. As Exhibit 1 indicates, there is a clear tendency to see more positive returns in decreasing correlation environments. In other words when stock specific risk dominates (high degree of return dispersion), the market tends to be higher. However, during periods of increasing correlation (i.e. increasing macro fear), there is more of a negative bias to the market (correlations between stock returns tend to increase in down markets). That said, there are still more positive return instances than negative ones in our sample of increasing correlation environments 1. See Exhibit 1. Next, we explore the impact of these increasing and decreasing correlation environments on various investment strategies. We examine the 14 sub investment categories of the CSFB Tremont hedge fund index going back to 1994. As Exhibit 1 shows, there tends to be a strong relationship between a fund s style performance and the correlation environment. Although by no means perfect, strategies such as Long/Short, Event Driven, Risk Arbitrage and R is in g C o r r e la tio n 4 3 2 Return 1-1 -2 1 However keep in mind that our samples of increasing -3 3 /2 5 / 19 8 1 3 /2 5 / 19 8 1 2 /2 4 / 19 8 2 2 /2 4 / 19 8 2 6 /2 9 / 19 8 2 6 /2 9 / 19 8 2 2 /1 5 / 19 8 3 2 /1 5 / 19 8 3 1 1 /2 9 /1 9 8 4 1 1 /2 9 /1 9 8 4 4 /2 / 19 8 8 4 /2 / 19 8 8 2 /1 4 / 19 9 1 2 /1 4 / 19 9 1 1 2 /1 5 /1 9 9 4 1 2 /1 5 /1 9 9 4 9 /9 / 1 99 6 9 /9 / 1 99 6 3 /1 2 / 1 9 9 8 3 /1 2 / 1 9 9 8 1 /2 / 1 9 9 8 1 /2 / 1 9 9 8 6 /2 2 / 2 6 /2 2 / 2 7 /2 4 / 2 3 7 /2 4 / 2 3 8 /1 1 / 19 8 1 8 /1 1 / 19 8 1 and decreasing correlation environme nts hav e unequal lengths. 8 /1 7 / 19 8 2 8 /1 7 / 19 8 2 8 / 1 98 4 2 / 8 / 1 98 4 1 9 / 19 8 5 9 / 1 9 / 19 8 5 3 2 7 / 19 8 6 3 / 2 7 / 19 8 6 3 2 / 19 8 7 3 / 2 / 19 8 7 3 /1 9 9 8 / 3 /1 99 3 /1 9 9 4 2 / 3 /1 99 4 1 5 1 2 / 1 8 /1 9 9 5 2 1 2 / 19 9 7 2 / 1 2 / 19 9 7 7 2 3 / 1 9 9 8 7 / 2 3 / 19 9 8 1 / / 2 1 2 / 7 / 2 3 / 2 2 5 / 3 / 2 2 4

Distressed Securities clearly seem to do better in environments where correlation is decreasing. These strategies are highly stock specific in their focus and hence it makes sense that managers of these strategies are adding the most value in environments that favour stock picking. On the other hand strategies such as Managed Futures and Emerging Markets do the best in environments that are macro driven (i.e. during increasing correlation environments). What to Expect Going Forward To get a sense as to what the market is currently expecting with regards to correlation risk (macro risk), we turn to the derivatives markets. By comparing the relative price of index versus single stock options, we can compute implied correlation. Implied correlation is similar to implied volatility in that it is forward looking and incorporates the markets expectations. However, instead of volatility, implied correlation is the market forecast of pairwise stock return correlations (i.e. macro risk). In Exhibit 11, we graph three month implied versus realized correlation for the S&P 5. Note that there is a tendency for implied correlation to lead the market. This can be most clearly seen in the period immediately prior to the war with Iraq in early 23 (middle of the chart). At this point the market was assuming that the vast majority of equity risk going forward was going to be macro focused. This also turned out to be the case as can be seen by the lagging realized correlations series. However, since approximately mid 23, we have seen a significant divergence between what the market has expected versus what has actually been realized. That is, for the last 18 months, the option markets have continuously priced in excess macro risk. Macro fear has dominated. After the Olympics and political conventions earlier this summer, implied correlations have started to decline. However, they still remain above current historically high realized correlations. This suggests that the market continues to emphasize macro risk. The Ebb and Flow of Macro Risk Ultimately, correlation, just like volatility, tends to be a mean reverting process. That is historically, periods of abnormally low or high correlation environments do not tend to last. As we have shown, if correlations do start to decrease from their current relative high levels (i.e. macro issues begin to wane), it is likely going to be a positive for the market overall and especially for market strategies that focus on stock picking. 2 For Derivatives Users The high spread between implied versus realized correlation, although it has narrowed recently, still remains a potential source of trading opportunities. Short correlation trades have remained one of our favourite trades for the past two years, and we continue to recommend these trades especially if implied correlations spike due to market shocks. The market is obsessed with macro fears and the option markets continue to price in a premium for macro risk. By selling correlation to the market, one is a supplier of macro insurance and the market seems to be willing to pay an excessive premiums for this type of insurance. Call us for details. Exhibit 11: S&P 5: Current Trading Range.7.6.5.4.3.2.1 Avg.Correlation Implied.Correlation 3/24/1 9/24/1 3/24/2 9/24/2 3/24/3 9/24/3 3/24/4 9/24/4 2 Other potential structured developments in the market (besides macro risk) could be contributing to increased correlation levels, namely increased usage of ETFs and program trading. Although, in our view, the impact on overall stock return correlations from these products is minor. 5

Mika Toikka Sri Moorthy, Ph.D Stephen Chadwick Global Head, Quantitative Equity Derivatives Strategy Head, Portfolio Trading Strategy Derivatives Strategist 212-325-5798 44 27 888 853 81 3 455 7183 mika.toikka@csfb.com sri.moorthy@csfb.com stephen.chadwick@csfb.com Peter Tannenbaum Martin Boldt-Christmas Edmund Ching Head, Equity Trading Strategy Derivatives Strategist 212-325-6255 44-2-7888-8696 852 211 7296 peter.tannenbaum@csfb.com martin.boldt-christmas@csfb.com edmund.ching@csfb.com Edward K. Tom Stanislas Bourgois Ken Feng Derivatives Strategist Derivatives Strategist 212-325-3594 44 2 7888 459 81 3 455 7189 ed.tom@csfb.com stanislas.bourgois@csfb.com ken.feng@csfb.com Cem Hocaoglu, Ph.D Colin Goldin 212-325-722 +44 2 7888 9637 cem.hocaoglu@csfb.com colin.goldin@csfb.com Phil Mackintosh 212-325-5263 phil.mackintosh@csfb.com Ryan Nolan Renicker, CFA Relative Value 212-325-1621 ryan.renicker@csfb.com Victor Lin 212-325-5362 victor.lin@csfb.com CSFB Quantitative Equity Derivatives Strategy Mika Toikka, Global Head, 212-325-5798, mika.toikka@csfb.com North America Europe Asia Options involve risk and are not suitable for all investors. Prior to investing in options, you should have read and understand the "Characteristics and Risks of Standardized Options" publication, which can be viewed on the Web by going to the following link: http://www.optionsclearing.com/publications/risks/riskstoc.pdf Because of the importance of tax considerations to many option transactions, the investor considering options should consult with his/her tax advisor as to how taxes affect the outcome of contemplated options transactions. Strategies involving the purchase of calls or puts have a risk of loss of the entire amount of the premium paid. Strategies that include selling uncovered calls or uncovered puts have unlimited risk and may result in losses significantly greater than the premium received." This material has been prepared by individual traders or sales personnel of Credit Suisse First Boston LLC (CSFB) and not by the CSFB research department. It is provided for informational purposes, is intended for your use only and does not constitute an invitation or offer to subscribe for or purchase any of the products or services mentioned. The information provided is not intended to provide a sufficient basis on which to make an investment decision. It is intended only to provide observations and views of individual traders or sales personnel, which may be different from, or inconsistent with, the observations and views of CSFB research department analysts, other CSFB traders or sales personnel, or the proprietary positions of CSFB. Observations and views expressed herein may be changed by the trader or sales personnel at any time without notice. Past performance should not be taken as an indication or guarantee of future performance, and no representation or warranty, expressed or implied is made regarding future performance. The information set forth above has been obtained from or based upon sources believed by the trader or sales personnel to be reliable, but each of the trader or sales personnel and CSFB does not represent or warrant its accuracy or completeness and is not responsible for losses or damages arising out of errors, omissions or changes in market factors. This material does not purport to contain all of the information that an interested party may desire and, in fact, provides only a limited view of a particular market. CSFB may, from time to time, participate or invest in transactions with issuers of securities that participate in the markets referred to herein, perform services for or solicit business from such issuers, and/or have a position or effect transactions in the securities or derivatives thereof. The most recent CSFB research on any company mentioned is at https://s.research-and-analytics.csfb.com/login.asp. 6