The Difference between Hacking & Carving

Transcription

1 Tax issues in Family Law The Difference between Hacking & Carving by Peter Szabo Marshalls & Dent Melbourne

2 Forced Estate Planning Assets must be apportioned between the parties, often with unwanted taxation consequences. Emotional issues a wild card By destroying an asset of one party, the total pool of available assets to be split between both parties is diminished.

3 The Split - Hacking Husband Wife Revenue

4 The Split - Carving Husband Wife Revenue Advisers

5 Investment Potential over years st Year 2nd Year 3rd Year 4th Year 5th Year Husband Wife

6 What are the Net Assets? The Form 17 Financial Statement Take into account assets net of tax, contingent liabilities. Impact of tax changes - Ralph report, GST The Hidden Agenda - Tax evasion issues

7 What are the Net Assets? The relevance of CGT - In placing a value on an asset, is CGT taken into account? Not necessarily! Income Tax - Any tax incurred by either party is a relevant debt to be taken into account. Similarly, any taxation refund is an asset also to be taken into account.

8 Superannuation Dividing up superannuation assets - A financial resource which will become available to one of the parties at some later stage. It must be taken into account in some way. Changing approach to Superannuation. The approach in many cases is to give one party more of the assets and let the other party keep the superannuation asset. But is that fair in the current economic climate?

9 Superannuation A mathematical approach preferred. A trend has been to take into account the years of marriage against the total years in the fund, and adjust for that proportion. Proposed changes to Family Law Act Presumption will be that the contributions relevant to the period of the marriage are to be apportioned equally - but retained until retirement.

10 Other Financial Resources Interests in trusts and companies - These are often treated as the ultimate assets of the parties by the Family Court - but not always. The facts of each particular case is important. Valuing interests in trusts and companies As long as one party is a beneficiary, the Family Court can bring that entitlement into account. The key issue is who controls the resource.

11 Apportioning the Assets Stamp Duty Real Estate Transfers of otherwise dutiable assets are almost always exempt from duty when transferred between spouses as a result of a separation. Rollover relief - Court orders or S87 Agreements only Main residence exemption Minimising CGT on a sale

12 Example 1 - CGT on Investment Property Capital gain on jointly Owned Inestment property $100,000 Amount subject to CGT $50,000 after Ralph = $25,000 each Husband Tax = $12,500 at marginal rate of tax say 50% Wife Tax = $12,500 at marginal rate say 50% Both parties on same tax rate so pay the same tax Total tax payable is $25,000 Net asset $75,000

13 Example 2 - CGT - different tax rates Profit on sale of Jointly Owned Investment property $100,000 Amount subject to CGT Each to equally share gain - $50,000 taxed after Ralph Husband = $25,000 Tax = $12,500 at marginal rate of tax say 50% Wife = $25,000 Tax = $7,000 at marginal rates average say 25% Different Tax for one party - less tax payable Total Tax Payable = $19,500 Net Asset = $80,500

14 Example 3 - CGT transfer to spouse Solely Owned Investment property $100,000 Amount subject to CGT Husband fully liable at top rate would pay $25,000 Husband = Nil Tax = NIL Transferred to Wife Rollover applicable Wife = $50,000 Tax = $16,000 at marginal rates Asset transferred to Wife and THEN sold Rollover relief, duty free transfer to wife Total Tax Payable = $16,000 Net Asset = $84,000

15 Example 4 - impact of Capital losses Jointly Owned Investment property $100,000 Amount subject to CGT Each to equally share gain Husband = $100,000 Tax = NIL Capital losses used Wife = $Nil Tax = Nil at marginal rate Asset transferred to Husband with capital losses Duty free transfer Total Tax Payable = Nil Net Asset = $100,000

16 Capitalising delayed payments Pay $100,000 in 12 months, with interest, at what rate % current rate. Pay $111,300 in 12 months time - capitalised, no tax consequences to payee Haggle over the capitalised amount - eg - pay $107,000 in 12 months as a capital payment. Both parties better off

17 Cost Base of acquired property may include family law costs Property valuations - 100% Accounting fees - possibly 100% Proportion of total Family Law costs relevant to property proceedings These may be taken in proportion to the total assets kept - eg if CGT asset is 50% of asset pool, 50% of above costs is included in costs base

18 Divorcing the Partnership Apportioning the income stream. Is there any flexibility? One person controls that stream, the other gets maintenance. Who pays what tax? Capital assets and trading stock Watch rollover relief as elections are possible. Indemnities with partnerships - Need to cover any contingencies, particularly tax.

19 Divorcing the Discretionary Trust Specific Tax issues involve: Loss Trust Legislation Election to become a Family Trust needed for Franking credits, trust losses Test individual important - where possible choose one of the children to retain distribution potential to spouses

20 Divorcing the Discretionary Trust The income stream - Distributions post separation may be tax effective even after divorce. Dealing with the assets of the trust Real Estate duty free, rollover relief for CGT Loan accounts - Watch debt forgiveness issues. Are they loans or beneficial entitlements?

21 Divorcing the Discretionary Trust Disengaging control involves : Resignation as appointor/guardian transferring shares in trustee company resignation as director of trustee company exclusion from being a beneficiary Where there are losses - watch continuity of control if no family trust election

22 Consequences of Poor Family Trust election No opportunity to effect spousal maintenance payments tax effectively out of the trust. No opportunity to pass control of the trust to spouse as part of a settlement Value of trust asset as tax planning vehicle diminished

23 Divorcing Spouse from Company The income stream - make tax effective adjustments where possible. Transfers of assets from the company Real estate usually subject to stamp duty CGT rollover relief available sometimes - but is the transfer a deemed dividend?

24 Divorcing the Company Companies with losses - Continuity of ownership test relevant to carry forward losses Debt forgiveness/deemed dividend issues Dealing with loan accounts needs particular attention to avoid unwanted revenue issues. FBT issues can arise if the spouse is an empoyee.

25 Divorcing the Company Disengaging a spouse may involve: Resignation as director Transferring shares retiring as an employee Retiring spouse needs tax indemnities remaining spouse should be aware of tax liabilities being covered GST - vendor pays but is this right?

26 Other Aspects to Consider Impact on third parties - Change in shareholding may freshen up assets for CGT purposes. FBT, loss of cost base and inability to use deductions and other losses. Accounting issues - timing of disengagement may necessitate account keeping changes. Try to coordinate these to financial years. Tax issues with spousal maintenance. Consider trust distributions, but watch Family trust election. Termination packages for employee spouse.

27 Retaining Carried forward Losses in a Company The problem is not to fail the continuity of ownership test - otherwise harder tests to pass to satisfy ATAO Solution 1 - retain shareholding Solution 2 - delay transfer of shareholding until losses used Solution 3 - Issue more shares and leave exiting spouse with a share

28 Advance Planning Tax planning structures need flexibility Awareness of consequences of family breakdown will alert the financial adviser or estate planner to some preventative measures. eg - if company involves husband and wife, issue more than 2 shares if you MUST have both spouses involved

29 Advance Planning Other strategies Carefully consider the choice of controllers of the trading entity Consider alternatives to giving external parties equity and control Prepare shareholders and other business agreements in anticipation of disputes Consider pre-nuptial agreements

30 Financial Agreements CGT Time bomb - no rollover relief for transfers of property Bankruptcy protection may be available

31 Tax issues in Family Law The Difference between Hacking & Carving by Peter Szabo Marshalls & Dent Melbourne