The Third Certainty: How and Why New York City s Property Taxes Increase Consistently Addressing The Many Misconceptions
|
|
- Lambert Cameron
- 8 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 Real Estate Forefront Emerging Developments in the NYC Marketplace, #22 The Third Certainty: How and Why New York City s Property Taxes Addressing The Many Misconceptions February 2013
2 2 Everyone knows the two certainties in life: death and taxes. In New York City, there is a third certainty which is that real property taxes increase every year regardless of market conditions. In fact, from 2009 to 2011 when the market value of all New York City properties declined, property tax collections increased by 17%. The data shows that since 1995 total billable assessed values have increased every year in every borough with the exception of the Bronx that showed a slight decline in While most would assume that wealthier neighborhoods would be assessed higher taxes, a close look at three neighborhoods shows that there is a wide disparity in property taxes paid within these neighborhoods, and there is no rule as to why some properties are taxed more than others. In short, this report aims to upend the reader s preconceived notions on property taxes. The results of this study suggest that coop buildings do not necessarily have a favorable tax structure over rental buildings in some neighborhoods; townhouses are not always taxed lower than a coop; and the likelihood that property taxes will continue to increase every year is nearly a sure thing. Some of the specifi c fi ndings are as follows: Real property tax collections have increased consistently from 2005 through 2012; however, the increase in tax collections (56%) was in line with the net rate of increase in market values during this seven-year period (51%). Of 111 buildings surveyed for this analysis on the Upper East Side, the Upper West Side and the West Village, coop buildings did not necessarily pay less in property taxes per square foot than rentals, despite the generally held perception that they have been. Real property taxes levied varied widely across and within the three neighborhoods reviewed. Property taxes on single family homes were generally lower on a per-square-foot basis for buildings on the Upper West Side and West Village, but they were higher on the Upper East Side. The overall market value of properties in the outer boroughs increased at a faster rate than in Manhattan from 2003 through 2009; however, the billable assessed values increased more in Manhattan during this period. These and other fi ndings discussed below demonstrate why property taxes generate so much controversy. As per Chairman and CEO Peter Hauspurg, as a former tax lawyer, I am confounded by the City s tax code. Researching these numbers was akin to a Law & Order episode: every new piece of information generated more and more questions. Real property taxes increased over the last fi ve years on an aggregate level for a number of reasons, some more obvious than others. One could argue that, fi rst and foremost, property taxes increased because the City was adding new properties during those years, and as a result, was expanding the tax base. The chart below shows the new housing built in Manhattan alone from 2000 through this year and includes the housing expected through 2015.
3 3 New Units Per Year 7,000 6,000 5,000 4,000 3,000 2,000 1,000 0 New Housing Units in Manhattan New Units in Manhattan Cumulative Units ,000 60,000 50,000 40,000 30,000 20,000 10,000 0 Cumulative Units Source: Eastern Consolidated and CoStar As shown in the table below, all of the boroughs saw a signifi cant increase in housing stock, and as a result, an increase in its property tax base. New Housing Units From 2000 To Added Units Percentage Change New York City 3,200,912 3,371, ,150 5% Manhattan 798, ,090 48,946 6% Bronx 490, ,896 21,237 4% Brooklyn 930,866 1,000,293 69,427 7% Queens 817, ,127 17,877 2% Staten Island 163, ,656 12,663 8% Source: Census Bureau Market Values These added properties and expanded base would suggest that the overall market value 1 of New York City properties has increased. The charts below show that, indeed, while the growth in Manhattan looks to dwarf the other boroughs, the outer boroughs actually experienced a much higher rate of market value growth from 2005 through In other words, property values on the existing building stock increased across the City. From 2008 through 2012, however, all four of the outer boroughs saw market values decline while Manhattan s market value increased 22% during that time (brown line). 1 The New York City Department of Finance (DOF) determines the market value of a property using one of three approaches: the sales prices of comparable properties sold that year, the net income based on rent revenue less operating expenses or on the cost to replace that property which is based on construction costs.
4 4 (in millions) $300,000 $250,000 $200,000 $150,000 $100,000 $50,000 New York City Property Market Values By Borough Manhattan Bronx Brooklyn Queens Staten Island Percentage Change Since % 200% 150% 100% 50% 0% Growth in Property Market Values By Borough Manhattan Bronx Brooklyn Queens Staten Island -50% Source: Eastern Consolidated and NYC Department of Finance With its signifi cant offi ce, hotel, retail and wealthy residential base, Manhattan s total market value has generally accounted for 32% of 38% of the overall New York City market value. The chart below, however, shows how New York City s overall market value (yellow line) stayed fl at from 2008 through 2012 largely because of the outer boroughs. New York City Historic Market, Actual And Billable Assessed Property Values NYC Total Property Value (in millions) $180,000 $150,000 $120,000 $90,000 $60,000 $30,000 Taxable Actual Assessed Value Taxable Billable Assessed Value Market Value (right axis) 900, , , , , ,000 0 Source: Eastern Consolidated and NYC Department of Finance
5 5 Assessed Values The chart above clearly shows how assessed values 2 (brown line) increased steadily during these years. More specifi cally, in 2010, the overall market value for New York City properties declined by 1.9% over 2009, but the total assessed 3 value increased by 3.9% that year. In other words, the other reason why property taxes increased most years is because assessed values increased these years. By law 4, the City s Department of Finance (DOF), which is empowered to make property assessments, cannot raise assessed values or property taxes beyond a certain rate per year; therefore, they phase assessed increases over a period of fi ve years. For commercial buildings or residential buildings with 11 or more units, the DOF adjusts the assessment (downward) even further to calculate the transitional assessed value. This transitional value often becomes the billable taxable assessed value 5 on which the tax rate is applied. For residential properties with fewer than 11 units, the tax rate is applied to the actual assessed value. Because transitional assessed values are often lower than actual assessed values, the taxable billable value line (orange) in the chart above is smoother and fl atter than the assessed value line. In short, because these phased-in increases are carried out over five years, billable values increased from 2008 through 2012 even though market values declined. While this stabilization policy eases the tax burden in the frothy years, it adds to the tax burden when property values start to decline which is why the property taxes collected increased from 2008 to The lines below show how taxable values increased for most boroughs when overall market values did not 6. 2 The DOF then determines the assessed value based on a set percentage of market value, called the level of assessment or assessment ratio, which is 6% for Class 1 buildings and 45% for tax classes 2, 3 and 4 as per the DOF website. However, the data below suggests that the assessment ratio can be much lower for Class 1 buildings. 3 The NYC DOF mails property owners a Notice of Property Value (NOPV) once a year that includes information about both the property s market and assessed values which are used to calculate property taxes for that tax year. According to the DOF, assessed values cannot go up by more than a certain rate per year and over a fi ve year period (depending on the building class) unless there was new construction or renovations took place. Therefore, it may take several years for the assessed value to adjust to a large increase in market value. This explains why assessments go up even when market value goes down. 4 Assessed Value (AV) cannot increase more than 6 percent each year or more than 20 percent in fi ve years. Class 2: AV cannot increase more than 8 percent each year or more than 30 percent in fi ve years. 5 Note how from 1993 to 1999, property values changed very little; hence the billable, or transitional values, were the same as the assessed values. But when market values soared, assessed values increased proportionately, but at a far more stable rate. 6 Of the 111 buildings surveyed for the micro analysis, 48, or less than half, showed evidence of increased assessed values in some years when the market value of the property declined. Of these 48 properties, 28 were single family homes.
6 6 Outer Borough Values (in billions) $40 $32 $24 $16 $8 New York City Billable Values By Borough Bronx Brooklyn Queens Staten Island Manhattan (right axis>>) $120 $96 $72 $48 $ Manhattan Values (in billions) Percentage Change Since % 100% 80% 60% 40% 20% 0% Growth In Billable Values By Borough Bronx Brooklyn Queens Staten Island Manhattan -20% Source: Eastern Consolidated and NYC Department of Finance This looks outrageous to the taxpayer, yet a close look at the net increase in market values from to 2012 compared to the net increase in billable values shows that billable value increases have caught up to market value increases for three of the boroughs but not in Manhattan and Brooklyn over this seven-year period as shown in the table below. This suggests that billable values will continue to grow over the next year. Increase In Property Values 2003 To 2012 New York City Manhattan Bronx Brooklyn Queens Staten Island Market Billable Market Billable Market Billable Market Billable Market Billable Market Billable % 21.6% 39.9% 21.8% 56.5% 23.3% 60.0% 21.8% 44.6% 19.9% 43.7% 23.2% % 24.9% 22.0% 28.9% -7.0% 18.6% -4.1% 21.3% -8.5% 16.6% -9.6% 15.2% % 51.8% 70.7% 56.9% 45.6% 46.2% 53.4% 47.7% 32.3% 39.8% 29.9% 41.9% Property Taxes: A Micro Analysis To complement the macro analysis above, we did a micro analysis of property taxes and downloaded property tax data for a sample of 111 Manhattan properties in three neighborhoods: the Upper East Side, the Upper West Side and the West Village. Of these 111 properties surveyed, all but 18 saw property taxes increase every year from 2008 through The average annual rate of increase for the 111 properties surveyed was 5.3%. 7 Shifting the base year to 2003, however, shows that billable market value increases have not caught up to market value increases in New York City.
7 7 Just as the assessment ratio varies according to the four different classes 8 of properties, so too does the tax rate applied. A thorough look at the data shows that these different tax rates and assessment ratios were not necessarily relevant. That is, in order to do an apples-to-apples analysis of property taxes, we felt we should focus on the tax levied per square foot of the property. We also included only pure residential properties with no retail, offi ce or garage. While there were some general conclusions one could draw from this data, there were many exceptions to every rule. The one general fi nding for all the properties surveyed was that property tax collections did not appear to show much correlation to the age of the building, location, size or overall value except for single family homes. In sum, the data suggests that more analysis is needed to explain the wide disparity in taxes collected in these properties. Rental Properties For the 40 rental properties surveyed in the three neighborhoods, property tax collections on the Upper East Side were consistently higher and showed less variation than in the West Village and the Upper West Side. Collections on the Upper West Side were, on average, lower but showed a far greater range. Finally, collections increased consistently every year in all but seven of the 40 buildings surveyed. A few more showed the same tax levied in two subsequent years. Property Tax Collections for Residential Rental Properties West Village /13 317,171 $2,594,993 $8.18 $13.41 $ /12 $2,457,478 $7.75 $12.34 $ /11 $2,006,825 $6.33 $11.38 $ /10 $1,868,683 $5.89 $10.19 $ /09 $1,424,519 $4.49 $8.64 $ Sample includes 13 elevator and walk-up buildings from West 12th to West 13th Street west of Avenue of the Americas Upper East Side /13 169,762 $1,736,084 $10.23 $14.31 $ /12 $1,646,618 $9.70 $15.00 $ /11 $1,493,562 $8.80 $13.55 $ /10 $1,373,850 $8.09 $14.45 $ /09 $1,197,900 $7.06 $13.67 $ Sample includes 13 elevator and walk-up buildings from East 78th Street to East 81st from Fifth Avenue to York Avenue Upper West Side /13 588,870 $3,663,337 $6.22 $13.64 $ /12 $3,371,860 $5.73 $13.64 $ /11 $3,030,587 $5.15 $12.68 $ /10 $2,796,674 $4.75 $11.89 $ /09 $2,455,497 $4.17 $10.08 $ Sample includes 14 elevator and walk-up buildings from West 80th Street to West 85th Street from Central Park West to Riverside Drive 8 Class 1: Includes most residential property of up to three units (family homes and small stores or offi ces with one or two apartments attached), and most condominiums that are not more than three stories. Class 2: Includes all other primary residential property that is not in Class 1 (rentals, cooperatives and condominiums). Class 3: Includes utility property. Class 4: Includes all commercial and industrial properties, and all other properties not included in classes 1, 2 or 3.
8 8 Cooperative Buildings For the 36 cooperative properties surveyed, property tax collections in all three neighborhoods showed much lower variance than for rental properties. Moreover, coop property tax collections were, on average, higher than rental properties in the West Village and the Upper West Side. This contradicts the general assumption that cooperatives receive a favorable treatment over rentals. Collections on coop buildings on the Upper East Side, however, were 8% to 12% lower than rental properties. Unlike rental buildings, collections in the West Village were slightly higher than on the Upper East Side and Upper West Side. Finally, collections increased consistently every year in all but fi ve of the 36 buildings surveyed. A few more showed the same tax levied in two subsequent years. Property Tax Collections For Cooperative Buildings West Village /13 735,352 $6,950,595 $9.45 $10.94 $ /12 $6,711,080 $9.13 $10.70 $ /11 $6,080,222 $8.27 $10.01 $ /10 $5,602,232 $7.62 $9.04 $ /09 $4,892,653 $6.65 $7.71 $ Sample includes 11 elevator and walk-up buildings from West 12th to West 13th Street west of Avenue of the Americas Upper East Side /13 426,529 $3,829,246 $8.98 $10.55 $ /12 $3,681,539 $8.63 $9.75 $ /11 $3,437,368 $8.06 $9.59 $ /10 $3,175,186 $7.44 $9.29 $ /09 $2,770,238 $6.49 $8.20 $ Sample includes 11 elevator and walk-up buildings from East 78th Street to East 81st from Fifth Avenue to York Avenue Upper West Side /13 768,137 $5,455,968 $7.10 $9.35 $ /12 $5,046,138 $6.57 $8.51 $ /11 $4,651,960 $6.06 $7.82 $ /10 $4,400,141 $5.73 $7.50 $ /09 $3,876,874 $5.05 $6.70 $ Sample includes 14 elevator and walk-up buildings from West 80th street to West 85th Street from Central Park West to Riverside Drive Single Family Homes For the 35 single family homes surveyed, property tax collections on the Upper East Side were consistently higher than the West Village and the Upper West Side. Half of these single family homes, however, were close to Fifth Avenue. The single family homes between Madison and Fifth Avenues were 10% lower than those west of Madison Avenue, and taxes went down considerably east of Madison Avenue. Collections on the Upper West Side and West Village were consistently lower, but variability was nearly as high on the West Side as on the East Side.
9 9 Collections increased consistently every year in all but six of the 35 buildings surveyed. Yet the annual rate of increase in taxes collected was much lower on single value homes from 2008 through 2012 than for rentals or coops (see table below). Property Tax Collections For Single Family Homes West Village /13 35,951 $286,453 $7.97 $10.80 $ /12 $281,292 $7.82 $10.19 $ /11 $260,679 $7.25 $9.64 $ /10 $243,932 $6.79 $9.42 $ /09 $220,741 $6.14 $8.43 $ Sample includes 10 elevator and walk-up buildings from West 12th to West 13th Street west of Avenue of the Americas Upper East Side /13 68,189 $822,797 $12.07 $18.18 $ /12 $785,282 $11.52 $17.16 $ /11 $713,576 $10.46 $15.44 $ /10 $683,045 $10.02 $15.07 $ /09 $637,768 $9.35 $14.57 $ Sample includes 12 buildings from East 78th Street to East 81st from Fifth Avenue to York Avenue Upper West Side /13 71,752 $527,855 $7.36 $13.82 $ /12 $498,876 $6.95 $13.81 $ /11 $428,141 $5.97 $12.42 $ /10 $407,060 $5.67 $11.53 $ /09 $404,374 $5.64 $10.19 $ Sample includes 14 from West 76th Street to West 85th Street from Central Park West to Riverside Drive Average Annual Increase In Property Tax Collections ( ) Rental Buildings Cooperative Buildings Single Family Homes West Village 6.9% 6.4% 3.8% Upper East Side 7.4% 2.9% 3.8% Upper West Side 6.3% 6.4% 4.2% Source: Eastern Consolidated, Property Shark and New York City Department of Finance Note in the table above that the increase in tax collections in rental buildings and single family homes was consistent across all three neighborhoods but was lower for Upper East Side coops than for West Village and Upper West Side coops.
10 Conclusion Few topics draw the ire of landlords, coop and condo owners more than property taxes. Because taxes are assessed based on property values, they are often the only downside to a fl ourishing real estate market. And as shown above, because assessments are phased in over a fi ve-year period, they can be an added drain to property owners in a declining market. The analysis above compared property taxes on a per square foot basis to determine if there is a neighborhood or property type that is unfairly overtaxed more than another. The overall conclusion to be drawn is that while property taxes show a wide disparity within a neighborhood and across every property type, the data does not show a consistent distortion in taxes levied. Of course, one major property type condominiums was not included in this analysis because taxes on condominiums are assessed on an individual property basis. Indeed, many very critical reports have been written on the convoluted system by which the City s properties are taxed. This report provided an overview of the situation with samples and charts, but did not attempt to explain the myriad of exemptions, abatements and labyrinthine methodology for tax levies. While the report illustrates how broad the range of tax collections for various properties is, the only conclusion to be drawn from this analysis is that it warrants further research on property taxes looking at differences by building classifi cation, age, borough, etc. But the general assumption in New York City real estate circles that some residential property types are unfairly taxed more than others does not seem to be supported by the analysis above. Many in the real estate industry have argued that the City tax collectors have gotten more and more dependent on real estate taxes over the last few years, but a look at the historic data shows that the ratio of all real estate taxes 9 collected to total taxes collected has varied within a narrow range of 40% to 49%. In 2012, it was 47.5%. 10 Total NYC Taxes Collected (in billions) $50 $40 $30 $20 $10 New York City Tax Collections $25 $20 $15 $10 Total Real Estate-Related Taxes Collected (in billions) 60% 50% 40% 30% Total City Tax Collections $5 Total Taxes Derived from Real Estate Industry* 20% 1994 Real Estate Tax Collections As A % Of Total Tax Collections Source: Eastern Consolidated and NYC Department of Finance 9 Includes property taxes, commercial rent taxes, real property transfer taxes and mortgage recording taxes
11 FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION CONTACT: Barbara Byrne Denham Chief Economist Eastern Consolidated 355 Lexington Avenue New York, NY T: F: ABOUT EASTERN CONSOLIDATED Founded in 1981, Eastern Consolidated is one of the country s preeminent full-service real estate investment services firms, combining an unrivaled expertise in the greater New York marketplace with a worldwide roster of institutional and private investor clients. Over the years, it has been responsible for the acquisition, disposition and finance of all types of properties, including office and apartment buildings, lofts, factories, hotels, shopping centers, commercial and residential development sites, taxpayers, parking garages and lots, retail condominiums and air rights transfers. Visit us at Copyright 2011 by Eastern Consolidated. All rights reserved.
NYC RESIDENTIAL. property taxes. coops. condos. rentals. 4+ units. class two
NYC RESIDENTIAL class two property taxes coops condos rentals 4+ units niform Agencies (Police, Fire, Sanitation, Corrections) WHERE DO YOUR tax dollars go? Education Health and Welfare 28% 20% U32% In
More informationNYC RESIDENTIAL. property taxes. class one. one. two. three. family. homes
NYC RESIDENTIAL class one property taxes one two three family homes niform Agencies (Police, Fire, Sanitation, Corrections) WHERE DO YOUR tax dollars go? Education Health and Welfare 28% 20% U32% In New
More informationWhy Effort to Reform NYC Property Taxes Has Stalled
Why Effort to Reform NYC Property Taxes Has Stalled By Ruth Ford June 10, 2015 Reform of the city's property tax would have to tackle, among other things, the different weights given to assessments of
More informationJ-51 Property Tax Exemptions and Abatements June 4, 2003
THE CITY OF NEW YORK INDEPENDENT BUDGET OFFICE 110 WILLIAM STREET, 14 TH FLOOR NEW YORK, NEW YORK 10038 J-51 Property Tax Exemptions and Abatements June 4, 2003 OVERVIEW New York City provides owners of
More informationFOR REAL ESTATE & URBAN POLICY
FURMAN CENTER N E W Y O R K U N I V E R S I T Y FOR REAL ESTATE & URBAN POLICY S C H O O L O F L A W W A G N E R S C H O O L OF P U B L I C S E R V I C E 139 MacDougal Street, 2 nd Floor, New York, NY
More informationNew York City Property Taxes
New York City Property Taxes An Unbalanced Burden Assemblymember Dan Quart 1 HISTORY Until 1975, property assessment in New York City was subject to the discretion of local property assessors who used
More informationFORM TC201 INSTRUCTIONS FOR 2015
TAX COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF NEW YORK 1 Centre Street, Room 2400, New York, NY 10007 INCOME AND EXPENSE SCHEDULE FOR RENT PRODUCING PROPERTIES FORM TC201 INSTRUCTIONS FOR 2015 TC201INS 2015 Attachment
More informationNew York s Real Estate Market A Decade After 9/11
New York s Real Estate Market A Decade After 9/11 1 New York s Real Estate Market A Decade After 9/11 Table of Contents Introduction Office Market l Asking Rents l Vacancy Rates l New Development Residential
More information2015 Mortgage Survey Report
New York City Rent Guidelines Board 2015 Mortgage Survey Report April 2, 2015 Board Members Chair: Rachel D. Godsil Public Members: Steven Flax Cecilia Joza K. Sabeel Rahman Helen Schaub Owner Members:
More informationChanges to the Rent Stabilized Housing Stock in New York City in 2012
New York City Rent Guidelines Board Changes to the Rent Stabilized Housing Stock in New York City in 2012 May 30, 2013 Board Members Chair: Jonathan L. Kimmel, Esq. Public Members: Tanya Levy-Odom Courtney
More informationIBO. Supply & Demand: City and State May Be Planning Too Much Office Space. An Analysis of The Plan for Financing Hudson Yards. Also Available...
IBO Also Available... An Analysis of The Plan for Financing Hudson Yards...at www.ibo.nyc.ny.us New York City Independent Budget Office Background Paper August 2004 Supply & Demand: City and State May
More informationNEW YORK MANHATTAN RESIDENTIAL REVIEW & THE LUXURY MARKET. luxury & style in. by Deanna Kory
luxury & style in NEW YORK by Deanna Kory Review of Manhattan s Uptown Luxury Real Estate Market MANHATTAN RESIDENTIAL REVIEW & THE LUXURY MARKET The residential real estate market in New York City has
More informationUnderstanding the NYC 421-a Property Tax Exemption Program How Can it Be Reformed to Create Affordable Housing?
Pratt Center for Community Development Understanding the NYC 421-a Property Tax Exemption Program How Can it Be Reformed to Create Affordable Housing? Summary Most newly-constructed housing development
More informationThe State of Mortgage Lending in New York City
The State of Mortgage Lending in New York City Mortgage lending trends provide an important window into the housing market and the changing availability of credit, both of which have been profoundly affected
More informationCLACLS. Trends in Poverty Rates among Latinos in New York City and the United States, 1990-2011
com CLACLS Center for Latin American, Caribbean & Latino Studies Trends in Poverty Rates among Latinos in New York City and the United States, 1990-2011 Center for Latin American, Caribbean & Latino Studies
More informationFAQ s (FOREIGN INVESTORS)
FAQ s (FOREIGN INVESTORS) WHAT IS FIRPTA? Foreign Investment in Real Property Tax Act, a statute that requires that a seller who is a foreign person permit a withholding of a part of the selling price
More informationChanges to the Rent Stabilized Housing Stock in New York City in 2015
New York City Rent Guidelines Board Changes to the Rent Stabilized Housing Stock in New York City in 2015 May 26, 2016 Board Members Chair: Hon. Kathleen A. Roberts (Ret.) Public Members: Steven Flax Cecilia
More informationTenure by Household Size - 2009
NEIGHBORHOOD APARTMENT MARKET ANALYSIS CITY OF CHICAGO Market Composition & Distribution The neighborhood apartment market consists of a range of properties developed from the early 1900s to more modern,
More information2014 Income and Expense Study
New York City Rent Guidelines Board 2014 Income and Expense Study April 24, 2014 Board Members Chair: Rachel D. Godsil Public Members: Steven Flax Cecilia Joza Carol J. Shine, Esq. David H. Wenk Owner
More informationDistribution of the Burden of New York City s Property Tax
Distribution of the Burden of New York City s Property Tax This section examines how different types of property are assessed in the city, and finds significant disparities in the effective tax rates of
More informationThe Benefits of Business Improvement Districts: Evidence from New York City
F u r m a n C e n t e r f o r r e a l e s t a t e & u r b a n p o l i c y N e w Y o r k U n i v e r s i t y s c h o o l o f l aw wa g n e r s c h o o l o f p u b l i c s e r v i c e j u l y 2 0 0 7 F u
More information2016 Mortgage Survey Report
New York City Rent Guidelines Board 2016 Mortgage Survey Report April 14, 2016 Board Members Chair: Hon. Kathleen A. Roberts (Ret.) Public Members: Steven Flax Cecilia Joza K. Sabeel Rahman Helen Schaub
More informationBASIC FACTS ABOUT THE FAMILY EVICTION PREVENTION SUPPLEMENT (FEPS) PROGRAM
Brooklyn Neighborhood Office 111 Livingston Street - 7th Fl. T (718) 722-3100 www.legal-aid.org Blaine (Fin) V. Fogg President BASIC FACTS ABOUT THE FAMILY EVICTION PREVENTION SUPPLEMENT (FEPS) PROGRAM
More informationhousing answers for residents of public housing falling behind in the rent Benefits Plus Learning Center Fighting Poverty Strengthening New York
housing answers for residents of public housing falling behind in the rent Benefits Plus Learning Center Fighting Poverty Strengthening New York The Community Service Society of New York (CSS), a non-partisan
More informationEnrollment Projections. New York City Public Schools. 2012-13 to 2021-22. Volume II
Enrollment Projections for the New York City Public Schools 2012-13 to 2021-22 Volume II Prepared for the New York City School Construction Authority February 2013 2 TABLE OF CO TE TS Page Executive Summary...
More informationA LETTER FROM THE CEO
2014 A LETTER FROM THE CEO Kushner Companies is a diversified real estate organization headquartered in New York City. Our Company is responsible for the ownership, management, development and redevelopment
More informationCBRE LENDERS SURVEY LOOKING AT 2015 LENDING TRENDS IN CANADA FINANCING DEBT COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE BOND TERM DEBT YIELDS MORTGAGE ACQUISITION
CBRE LENDERS SURVEY LOOKING AT 2015 LENDING TRENDS IN CANADA COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE DEBT FINANCING TERM DEBT YIELDS MORTGAGE ACQUISITION REFINANCING BOND INTEREST RATE ABOUT CBRE CBRE Group, Inc. (NYSE:CBG),
More informationAdvertising Rates Effective January 1, 2015. Real Estate
2015 Advertising Rates Effective January 1, 2015 Real Estate Agate (800) 458-5522 1 The New York Times Display and Display on classifieds inside NY area (212) 556-1581 / outside NY area (800) 843-3113
More informationMarch 13, 2006. Hon. Scott M. Stringer Manhattan Borough President 1 Centre Street New York, NY 10007. Dear Borough President Stringer:
THE CITY OF NEW YORK INDEPENDENT BUDGET OFFICE 110 WILLIAM STREET, 14 TH FLOOR NEW YORK, NEW YORK 10038 (212) 442-0632 FAX (212) 442-0350 EMAIL: ibo@ibo.nyc.ny.us http://www.ibo.nyc.ny.us Hon. Scott M.
More informationEconomic Impact and Development Analysis. Proposed Sports Entertainment District
THE LONDON GROUP Economic Impact and Development Analysis Proposed Sports Entertainment District Prepared For: The City of Escondido November 2010 The London Group 2010 Report Prepared by: Gary H. London,
More informationGENERAL INFORMATION. INSTITUTION'S CRA RATING: This institution is rated ASatisfactory@.
GENERAL INFORMATION The Community Reinvestment Act (CRA) requires each federal financial supervisory agency to use its authority when examining financial institutions subject to its supervision, to assess
More informationPreqin Research Report. Employment and Compensation in the Private Equity Real Estate Industry December 2009
Preqin Research Report Preqin Research Report: Total Employment within the Private Equity Real Estate Industry Fig. 1: The number of fi rms active in private equity real estate has grown consistently year
More informationChanges to the Rent Stabilized Housing Stock in New York City in 2014
New York City Rent Guidelines Board Changes to the Rent Stabilized Housing Stock in New York City in 2014 May 28, 2015 Board Members Chair: Rachel D. Godsil Public Members: Steven Flax Cecilia Joza K.
More informationMidwest Region. Chicago Cincinnati Cleveland Columbus Detroit Indianapolis Kansas City Milwaukee Minneapolis Omaha St.
Midwest Region Chicago Cincinnati Cleveland Columbus Detroit Indianapolis Kansas City Milwaukee Minneapolis Omaha St. Louis Toledo MidwestMarketSnapshot Trusted Advice. Proven Performance. CBRE/Torto Wheaton
More informationStep 1: Determine the Size, Parameters and Construction Timeline for the Property
The Real Estate Development Process While real estate development models may look complex, the actual concepts are simpler than what you see for normal companies. Real estate development modeling is different
More informationNew 46 33 28 24.5-29.7-12.7 Resale 92 88 89 4.0-3.9 0.9. New 22 26 30-4.1 19.4 15.1 Resale 148 159 157-4.0 7.4-1.1
OBSERVATION TD Economics March 1, 214 HOUSING IN THE GREATER TORONTO AREA SEVERAL MARKETS, SEVERAL TALES Highlights While robust GTA existing home price growth has been grabbing attention, headline numbers
More informationDUBAI HOUSE PRICE INDEX REPORT FIRST QUARTER 2013. Accelerating success.
DUBAI HOUSE PRICE INDEX REPORT FIRST QUARTER 13 Accelerating success. HOUSE PRICE INDEX Q1 13 DUBAI TABLE OF CONTENTS Executive Summary 3 Dubai Overall House Price Index 4 Alternative Analysis 6 Apartment
More informationOFFICE MARKET ANALYSIS SUBURBAN CHICAGO. According to Costar Property, the Suburban Chicago office market is distributed as follows:
OFFICE MARKET ANALYSIS SUBURBAN CHICAGO Market Composition & Distribution According to Costar Property, the Suburban Chicago office market is distributed as follows: Office Submarket Cluster Distribution
More informationSetting the standard for quality. leasing, management and ownership. of commercial real estate.
Setting the standard for quality leasing, management and ownership of commercial real estate. K AUFMAN O RGANIZATION History of the Kaufman Organization A cornerstone of New York s Fashion Center, the
More informationRenovating and Reselling
Renovating and Reselling North Metro Atlanta Contact: John Marion Mobile: 703 371 9548 Email: johnmarion.com@gmail.com Project Description Alpha Dog Investments is buying, renovating, and reselling single
More information2014 Housing Supply Report
New York City Rent Guidelines Board 2014 Housing Supply Report May 29, 2014 Updated July 20, 2015 Board Members Chair: Rachel D. Godsil Public Members: Steven Flax Cecilia Joza Carol J. Shine, Esq. David
More informationREAL ESTATE DEVELOPERS ASSOCIATES TURNING VISION INTO REALITY
REAL ESTATE DEVELOPERS ASSOCIATES TURNING VISION INTO REALITY ASSOCIATES ABOUT THE PARTNERS Paul Slayton has been an active real estate developer for over 40 years. His accomplishments include the development
More information26 East 63rd Street, 10AB
RP Miller Realty Group, Inc. Licensed Real Estate Broker 135 East 65th Street Suite 5W New York, New York 10065 www.rpmillergroup.com EXCLUSIVE PRESENTATION OF 26 East 63rd Street, 10AB LIVING ROOM 26
More informationMarket Segmentation: The Omaha Condominium Market
Market Segmentation: The Omaha Condominium Market Page 1 Market Segmentation: The Omaha Condominium Market Roger P. Sindt Steven Shultz Department of Economics and Real Estate University of Nebraska at
More informationNew York City Rental Guide
New York City Rental Guide Welcome to New York City Searching for an apartment in Manhattan is a unique experience. The most desirable and affordable apartments rent quickly and most are available for
More informationEQUITY OFFICE ANNOUNCES FIRST QUARTER 2004 RESULTS
Two North Riverside Plaza, Suite 2100 Chicago, Illinois 60606 phone 312.466.3300 fax 312.454.0332 www.equityoffice.com Equity Office (Investors/Analysts): Diane Morefield 312.466.3286 Equity Office (Media):
More informationIf You Build It : The Impact of Street Improvements on Commercial Office Space
If You Build It : The Impact of Street Improvements on Commercial Office Space J.LIFF CO. 11 Fifth Avenue 9H New York, New York 10003 JUNE 2012 Location, location, location is the real estate mantra. So
More informationBuyer s Guide BENEFITS OF HOMEOWNERSHIP TOP 5 TIPS FOR BUYERS
Congratulations on your decision to purchase a home in New York City! While this decision is an exciting one, the steps required to purchase a home are numerous and can become confusing. This guide has
More informationPeeling The Onion on Capitalization Rates
The compression in cap rates during the 2005-2007 commercial real estate (CRE) bubble led to miscalculations on the part of many sophisticated investors in regards to exit valuations. As we quantitatively
More informationMay 16, 2011. Hon. Brad Lander Council Member New York City Council 250 Broadway, Suite 1776 New York, New York 10007. Dear Council Member Lander:
THE CITY OF NEW YORK INDEPENDENT BUDGET OFFICE 110 WILLIAM STREET, 14 TH FLOOR NEW YORK, NEW YORK 10038 (212) 442-0632 FAX (212) 442-0350 EMAIL: iboenews@ibo.nyc.ny.us http://www.ibo.nyc.ny.us May 16,
More informationbudget brief On Tuesday, August 3, legislative leaders proposed a new budget plan, including a tax swap that would increase some
UNDERSTANDING THE TAX SWAP budget brief AUGUST JUNE 2010 2005 On Tuesday, August 3, legislative leaders proposed a new budget plan, including a tax swap that would increase some of the state s personal
More informationPROFILE OF CHANGES IN COLORADO PUBLIC SCHOOL FUNDING
PROFILE OF CHANGES IN COLORADO PUBLIC SCHOOL FUNDING 988-89 TO 998-99 Prepared for THE COLORADO SCHOOL FINANCE PROJECT Colorado Association of School Boards Colorado Association of School Executives Colorado
More informationHOW TO APPEAL A TENTATIVE ASSESSMENT
TAX COMMISSION OF THE R CITY OF NEW YORK 1 Centre Street, Room 2400, New York, NY 10007 TC600 2016 HOW TO APPEAL A TENTATIVE ASSESSMENT ASSESSMENT 1. Tentative assessment. A real property tax assessment
More informationReal Estate Investment Trusts (REITs) The International Standard for Property Investment
Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs) The International Standard for Property Investment What is a Real Estate Investment Trust (REIT)? A REIT is a listed company, used to hold rental investment properties.
More informationThe Obama Administration s Efforts To Stabilize the Housing Market and Help American Homeowners
The Obama Administration s Efforts To Stabilize the Housing Market and Help American Homeowners February 2015 U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development Office of Policy Development and Research
More informationThe Obama Administration s Efforts To Stabilize The Housing Market and Help American Homeowners
The Obama Administration s Efforts To Stabilize The Housing Market and Help American Homeowners April 2014 U.S. Department U.S Department of Housing of Housing and Urban and Urban Development Development
More informationPolicy Brief: Property Tax Relief for Low- and Middle-Income Property New Yorkers Must Remain a Priority
Policy Brief: Property Tax Relief for Low- and Middle-Income Property New Yorkers Must Remain a Priority May 27, 2015 Of the two competing property tax relief plans the Legislature is expected to consider
More informationThe Obama Administration s Efforts To Stabilize The Housing Market and Help American Homeowners
The Obama Administration s Efforts To Stabilize The Housing Market and Help American Homeowners July 2014 U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development Office of Policy Development and Research U.S
More informationOutline for March 12, 2013 Disaster Preparedness Seminar
Outline for March 12, 2013 Disaster Preparedness Seminar Emphasis on the Administrative Side of Disaster Preparedness Watch corresponding video on YouTube, see link >> http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kawtn9pk8jq
More informationNew York City Office Market Report, Second Quarter 2013
New York City Office Market Report, Second Quarter 2013 2013 NAI Global The contents of this report are intended for the individuals to whom it is presented or delivered and their company associates. Any
More informationHow are automatic rent reductions calculated?
Automatic Rent Reductions and Tax Decreases When are rents automatically reduced? Most tenants do not pay property taxes separately from their rent. In most situations, the rent a landlord charges a tenant
More informationQuestions and Answers on United Synagogue s Plan to Sell Its New York Office Space
Questions and Answers on United Synagogue s Plan to Sell Its New York Office Space Overview: The sale of office space is part of a three pronged strategic financial plan that includes cutting expenses,
More informationLife Insurance Companies and Products
Part B. Life Insurance Companies and Products The current Federal income tax treatment of life insurance companies and their products al.lows investors in such products to obtain a substantially higher
More informationLEE NYC Retail is the retail division of Lee & Associates NYC (Lee NYC), an affiliate of Lee &
LEE NYC Retail LEE NYC Retail is the retail division of Lee & Associates NYC (Lee NYC), an affiliate of Lee & Associates, a national real estate company with over 700 real estate professionals in 46 offices
More informationApartment Housing in Hampton Roads
Apartment Housing in Hampton Roads APARTMENT HOUSING IN HAMPTON ROADS Do you live in an apartment? If not, chances are that you know people who do. Approximately 35 percent of Hampton Roads residents do
More informationBicycle Crash Data 2012
Bicycle Crash Data 2012 Local Law 13 of 2011 requires the NYC Department of Transportation (NYCDOT) to report on the total number of bicycle crashes, injuries, and fatalities that are reported to city
More informationNYCIDA PROJECT COST/BENEFIT ANALYSIS January 8, 2015
NYCIDA PROJECT COST/BENEFIT ANALYSIS January 8, 2015 APPLICANT 5 Bay Street LLC 30-56 Whitestone Expressway Suite 300 Whitestone, NY 11354 PROJECT LOCATION 5 Bay Street Staten Island, NY 10301 A. Project
More informationPerceptions of Homelessness in Chicago and New York City
Perceptions of Homelessness in and City an ICPH Poll Comparison February 2011 Page 2 Perceptions of Homelessness in and City Perceptions of Homelessness in and City ICPH Poll Comparison In order to gauge
More informationFirst Half 2014 Taiwan Life Insurance Market Overview
First Half 2014 Taiwan Life Insurance Market Overview I. Life Insurance Industry Business and Financial Overview A. Business Statistical Overview The life insurance industry in Taiwan delivered NTD1,340.5
More informationHUD PD&R Housing Market Profiles
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania Quick Facts About Philadelphia By Timothy D. McNally Current sales market conditions: slightly soft. Current apartment market conditions: balanced. Of the top 10 employers in
More informationTo Our Shareholders A Message from the CEO
To Our Shareholders A Message from the CEO Overview of Fiscal 2007 Performance Looking at consolidated performance during fiscal 2007, or the year ended March 31, 2007, ORIX achieved an 18% rise in net
More informationRegional Markets for Office and Industrial Space
Regional Markets for Office and Industrial Space FEELING PAIN: REGIONAL MARKETS FOR OFFICE AND INDUSTRIAL SPACE I ve never seen anything like this in 36 years. Sharon Ryals-Taylor, Thalhimer Commercial
More informationNational Small Business Network
National Small Business Network WRITTEN STATEMENT FOR THE RECORD US SENATE COMMITTEE ON FINANCE U.S. HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES COMMITTEE ON WAYS AND MEANS JOINT HEARING ON TAX REFORM AND THE TAX TREATMENT
More informationMarket Report MANHATTAN OFFICE 2Q 2015. Leasing Activity MSF. Absorption SF. Availability Rate 10.1% -0.6pp -0.9pp N/A. Average Asking Rent ($/SF/YR)
Market Report MANHATTAN OFFICE 2Q 2015 Accelerating success. 2Q 2015 Quarter-to- Quarter Change Year-to- Year Change YTD 2015 ± % $ Leasing Activity MSF Absorption SF 8,087,659-2.8% -8.0% 16,409,154 2,890,076
More informationDALLAS CENTRAL APPRAISAL DISTRICT DCAD VALUATION PROCESSES
DALLAS CENTRAL APPRAISAL DISTRICT DCAD VALUATION PROCESSES DALLAS CENTRAL APPRAISAL DISTRICT PRESENTATION OVERVIEW The goals and objectives of this presentation is to provide Property Owner s an overview
More informationThe Process of Taxation
The Process of Taxation The property taxes you pay fund services provided by the combination of taxing entities within the tax district you reside. Property taxes are also known as real estate taxes and
More informationNYC Hurricane Sandy Loan & Grant Program FAQs
As part of the City of New York s ongoing effort to assist New York City businesses damaged by Hurricane Sandy, a new loan and grant program has been made available. This program is one of the business
More informationU.S. Tax Benefits for Exporting
U.S. Tax Benefits for Exporting By Richard S. Lehman, Esq. TAX ATTORNEY www.lehmantaxlaw.com Richard S. Lehman Esq. International Tax Attorney LehmanTaxLaw.com 6018 S.W. 18th Street, Suite C-1 Boca Raton,
More informationDate 1/2/2014. Prepared for. Virginia Land Investments 10001 Patterson Ave., Suite 200 Richmond, VA 23238. Cleveland, Ohio. Richmond, Virginia
Date 1/2/2014 The Economic and Fiscal Impact of Carmel Church Station on Virginia The completed Carmel Church Station development is expected to support 20,670 jobs and $3.3 billion in annual economic
More informationNAR Frequently Asked Questions Health Insurance Reform
NEW MEDICARE TAX ON UNEARNED NET INVESTMENT INCOME Q-1: Who will be subject to the new taxes imposed in the health legislation? A: A new 3.8% tax will apply to the unearned income of High Income taxpayers.
More informationResidential Market. Downtown Houston
Downtown Houston The Houston Market Houston s residential market represents one of the best values in the United States. The city ranks third in the 2010 Forbes list of best housing markets, and second
More informationAn Overview of Job Quality and Discretionary Economic Development Subsidies in New York City
An Overview of Job Quality and Discretionary Economic Development Subsidies in New York City May 2010 Fiscal Policy Institute, Good Jobs New York & National Employment Law Project How does New York City
More informationThe Urgent Need to Bring Fairness to the Taxation of Multi-Residential Properties in Ontario
The Urgent Need to Bring Fairness to the Taxation of Multi-Residential Properties in Ontario by October, 2001 About FRPO FRPO is the largest association in Ontario representing those who own, manage, build
More informationAdditional information >>> HERE <<< Getting Start new york city apartment names - ebook
Additional information >>> HERE http://urlzz.org/uslease/pdx/fph1 Tags:
More informationHPD Supportive Housing Loan Program:
A Guide to Eligibility and Rent Setting HPD Supportive Housing Loan Program: A Guide to Eligibility and Rent Setting April 2014 Version Supportive Housing Loan Program: A Guide to Eligibility and Rent
More information1998 Tax Expenditures Report
1998 Tax Expenditures Report EXECUTIVE SUMMARY New York City furthers its social and economic objectives through a variety of programs. Some programs are funded by direct governmental appropriations; others
More informationPrecise Leads White Paper. 6 Best Practices: How Insurance Agents Can Use the Web to Build Long-term Customer Relationships
Precise Leads White Paper 6 Best Practices: How Insurance Agents Can Use the Web to Build Long-term Customer Relationships Copyright 2013 by Precise Leads All rights reserved. No part of this report may
More informationNew Home Market Single starts highest since 1987
Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation www.cmhc.ca New Home Market Single starts highest since 1987 CMHC is forecasting 850 singledetached housing starts for 2006, the highest number of single starts
More informationNew York City Office Market Report, First Quarter 2013
New York City Office Market Report, First Quarter 213 Q1-213 New York City Office Market Report, First Quarter 213 OFFICE MARKET # BLDGS. TOTAL RBA DIRECT SUBLET TOTAL TOTAL AVERAGE UNDER (SF) AVAILABLE
More informationStock Market Rotations and REIT Valuation
Stock Market Rotations and REIT Valuation For much of the past decade, public real estate companies have behaved like small cap value stocks. ALTHOUGH PUBLIC debate over the true nature of real estate
More informationThe Obama Administration s Efforts To Stabilize The Housing Market and Help American Homeowners
The Obama Administration s Efforts To Stabilize The Housing Market and Help American Homeowners August 2013 U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development Office of Policy Development Research U.S Department
More informationAn Overview of Job Quality and Discretionary Economic Development Subsidies in New York City
An Overview of Job Quality and Discretionary Economic Development Subsidies in New York City Fiscal Policy Institute Good Jobs New York National Employment Law Project February 2011 An Overview of Job
More informationNEWS RELEASE NASDAQ Symbol: STRS Stratus Properties Inc. 98 San Jacinto Blvd. Suite 220 William H. Armstrong III Austin, Texas 78701 (512) 478-5788
NEWS RELEASE NASDAQ Symbol: STRS Stratus Properties Inc. 98 San Jacinto Blvd. Suite 220 William H. Armstrong III Austin, Texas 78701 (512) 478-5788 Financial and Media Contact: STRATUS PROPERTIES INC.
More informationSTATE OF NEW JERSEY OFFICE OF THE STATE COMPTROLLER INVESTIGATIVE REPORT INEQUITABLE TAX ASSESSMENTS BOROUGH OF EDGEWATER
STATE OF NEW JERSEY OFFICE OF THE STATE COMPTROLLER INVESTIGATIVE REPORT INEQUITABLE TAX ASSESSMENTS BOROUGH OF EDGEWATER A. Matthew Boxer COMPTROLLER November 15, 2011 TABLE OF CONTENTS I. Introduction
More information155 East 79th Street New York, NY
155 East 79th Street 155 East 79th Street is located in the middle of Manhattan s Upper East Side. Central Park, many of New York s finest cultural institutions, restaurants, high end shopping and some
More informationManhattan 2014 Year-End Sales Report by Ariel Property Advisors Released January 2015
Manhattan 2014 Year-End Sales Report by Ariel Property Advisors Released January 2015 Join Our Network: e-mail join@arielpa.com or visit arielpa.com 212.544.9500 I arielpa.com 122 East 42 nd Street, Suite
More informationMansion Tax - Frequently Asked Questions
CB Title Agency of NY, LLC 140 Mountain Avenue Suite 101 Springfield, NJ 07081 P: 973-921-0990 F: 973-921-0902 www.cbtitlegroup.com Date: February 19, 2010 To: All Clients and Friends From: Cliff Bernstein
More informationDEFINITIONS FOR THE CODES FOR CLASSIFICATION OF REAL PROPERTY
COOK COUNTY ASSESSOR J O S EPH BE R RIOS COOK COUNTY ASSESSOR S OFFICE 118 NORTH CLARK STREET, CHICAGO, IL 60602 PHONE: 312.443.7550 FAX: 312.603.3616 WWW.COOKCOUNTYASSESSOR.COM DEFINITIONS FOR THE CODES
More informationHigher Education Employment Report
Higher Education Employment Report First Quarter 2015 / Published May 2015 Executive Summary The number of jobs in higher education noticeably declined in 2015. This is in contrast to the past two years
More informationKaled Management, Corp. :: 7001 Brush Hollow Rd :: Westbury, NY 11590 Ph: 516.876.4800 :: Fax: 516.876.6812 :: Email: info@kaled.com www.kaled.
NEW YORK Kaled Management, Corp. :: 7001 Brush Hollow Rd :: Westbury, NY 11590 Ph: 516.876.4800 :: Fax: 516.876.6812 :: Email: info@kaled.com www.kaled.com An Equal Housing Opportunity. Copyright All rights
More information