Dark Pool Trading Strategies, Market Quality and Welfare. Online Appendix
|
|
- Darrell Berry
- 8 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 Dark Pool Trading Strategies, Market Quality and Welfare Online ppendix Sabrina Buti Barbara Rindi y Ingrid M. Werner z December, 015 Uniersity of Toronto, Rotman School of Management, sabrina.buti@rotman.utoronto.ca y Bocconi Uniersity and IGIER, barbara.rindi@unibocconi.it z Fisher College of Business, Ohio State Uniersity, werner.47@osu.edu
2 ppendix B B.1. Extension 1: and small traders Under this framework we allow for two di erent types of traders: at each trading round t, a trader may arrie either with a two-share (large) order with probability, or with a one-share (small) order with probability 1. s arriing with a large order can trade up to two shares, j = f0; 1; g, and we call them large traders (LT), whereas traders arriing with a small order can only trade one share and we call them small traders (ST). B.1.1. The benchmark framework ( B) The strategies aailable to traders in this framework are presented in Table B1. s in the original model, both large and small traders can submit market orders to the rst two leels of the price grid, ' M (j; p z i ); they can post limit orders to the rst leel, ' L(j; p z 1 ), and they can choose not to trade, '(0). In addition, a large trader can split his order and combine the two di erent strategies, ' ML (1; p z i ; 1; pz 1 ), taking adantage of the better execution probability of a one-unit limit order. 1 In this case, only part of the large trader s pro ts depends on the probability of the order being executed in the following trading rounds: e t [' ML (1; p z i ; 1; p z 1)] = t [' M (1; p z i )] + e t [' L (1; p z 1)] : (44) Moreoer, the large trader can submit marketable orders that are large market orders walking up or down the book in search of execution, ' M (; p z ): For example, pro ts from a marketable sell order for the large trader are gien by: t [' M (; p B )] = (p B 1 + p B ) t : (45) s in the preious framework, at each trading round t the arriing risk-neutral trader selects the optimal order submission strategy which maximizes his expected pro ts, conditional on the state of the LOB, b t, on his type represented by his personal aluation of the asset, t, and on whether he is a small or a large trader. The large trader chooses: max ' and the small trader still soles problem (7). e t [' M (j; p z i ); ' M (; p z ); ' ML (1; p z i ; 1; p z 1); ' L (j; p z 1); '(0) j t ; b t ] ; (46) [Insert Table B1 here] B.1.. Limit order book and continuous dark pool ( L&C) In this framework only large traders hae access to the CDP and their action space includes, in addition to the dark pool orders presented for the original model, the possibility to split the order between the LOB and the CDP, by combining a one-unit dark pool order with either a market order, ' MD (1; p z i ; 1; ep Mid;t), or a limit order, ' LD (1; p z 1 ; 1; ep Mid;t): ' MD (1; p z i ; 1; ep Mid;t ) = t [' M (1; p z i )] + e t [' D (1; ep Mid;t )]; (47) ' LD (1; p z 1; 1; ep Mid;t ) = e t [' L (1; p z 1)] + e t [' D (1; ep Mid;t )] : (48) 1 Because small traders trade only one unit, the execution probability of the rst unit of a limit order is higher. We omit the subscript i for the leel of the book since the order will be executed at di erent prices. 1
3 t each trading round the fully rational risk-neutral large trader chooses the optimal order submission strategy which maximizes his expected pro ts, conditional on his aluation of the asset, t, and his information set, t, respectiely: max ' e t ['M (j; p z i ); 'M (; pz ); 'ML(1; p z i ; 1; p z 1); 'MD(1; p z i ; 1; ep Mid;t ); (49) 'D(j; p Mid;t ; p z i ); 'D(j; ep Mid;t ); 'LD(1; p z 1; 1; ep Mid;t ); 'L(j; p z 1); '(0) j t ; t ] : s before, small traders sole problem (7), and shape their strategies depending on the expected state of the CDP. B.1.3. Results In commenting the results from the model with both large and small traders and a CDP, we focus only on those ndings which di er from our initial framework with only one-share trades. Oerall the results from the original model concerning order ows, market quality and welfare continue to hold. Note that by comparing books with one and two shares on the best ask price, we can now di erentiate between the e ects of spread and depth. Moreoer, we de ne a new order ow indicator, olume creation (V C), as the aerage LOB plus dark pool olume, V L&C t V B t : V C = 1 T, in excess of the total LOB olume in the B framework, P (Vt L&C t V B t ) ; (50) where we measure olume in each period t by weighing the ll rate, F R t ; by the order size, q t : Z V L&C;B P t = Pr(a)E t q t ' n a f ( t ) d t : (51) a=w ;N Notice that with a unitary trade size, T C and V C coincide. Order ows. When a CDP is introduced along side a LOB, we obsere OM and T C (Fig. B1). Moreoer, since orders may di er in size, we can also di erentiate T C from olume creation (V C) (Fig. B). The e ects of the introduction of a dark pool on order ows are all weaker when traders can choose between large and small size than when all orders were one share. The reason is that starting from both an empty book and an empty dark pool, it takes longer to obsere a book with two rather than one share at the best ask or bid price. For this reason traders hae less incentie to opt for dark trading. 3 Consider the new framework ealuated at t with three periods remaining, and compare books with di erent amounts of liquidity, b t = [00], [10], and [0]. Fig. B1 shows that OM at t is strongly increasing in the depth of the book. Dark orders become more attractie not only when depth increases, but also when spread becomes smaller. ll else equal, a smaller spread increases competition for the proision of liquidity and makes the dark pool option more attractie for limit orders. smaller spread also decreases the market order price improement in the dark pool which reduces the incenties to send market orders to the dark, but this e ect is compensated by the increased execution probability generated in the dark pool by the migration of the limit orders. [Insert Fig: B1 and Fig: B here] 3 Comparing Tables and B it is eident that starting from b t1 = [00], the probability to obsere b t = [10] in the framework with small (N and W ) traders is equal to a' L (1; p 1 )+(1 a)' L (1; p 1 ) = 1 0: :4066 = 0:4066, whereas the probability to obsere b t = [0] in the framework with large and small traders is equal to a' L (; p 1 ) = 1 0:1791 = 0:
4 While OM increases as liquidity builds, T C and V C decrease when either spread narrows or depth builds up in the book with one or two shares on the best ask side. s we measure olume by weighing the ll rates by the size of the orders executed, V C has a pattern similar to T C, howeer, because the aerage size of the orders that migrate from the LOB to the dark pool is larger than the aerage size of the orders executed on the LOB, all the e ects generated by the migration of orders to the dark pool are magni ed when measured by olume rather than by ll rate, and so is the change in V C compared to the reduction in T C. Market quality. s in the initial framework, our results show that the introduction of a dark pool has a negatie e ect on the liquidity of an empty LOB as both the inside spread and the depth at the best bid and o er worsen (Fig. B3, Panel ). The e ects at work are ery much similar to those discussed for the original model. t the beginning of the trading game when both the book and the dark pool open empty, the introduction of a dark pool makes traders switch from limit to market orders anticipating a future reduction in the execution probability of limit orders (Table B). 4 s before, the resulting increased liquidity demand and reduced liquidity supply widen spread and reduce depth at the inside quotes. Howeer, we note that the magnitude of the e ect is smaller with large and small traders compared to the original model where all traders were small. Consider again the new framework ealuated at t with three periods remaining, and compare books with di erent amounts of liquidity, b t = [00], [10] and [0]. Fig. B3 shows that while the negatie e ect on spread decreases with the liquidity of the book, the e ect on depth rst improes and then, as traders more heaily moe to the dark pool, further deteriorates. [Insert Fig: B3 and Table B here] When liquidity builds up in the LOB and the book opens with one or two shares at the best ask price, two e ects occur. On the one hand, when the book becomes deeper traders generally tend to use more market than limit orders and so fewer traders switch from limit to market orders when a dark pool is introduced. This rst e ect attenuates the negatie impact on liquidity of the switch from limit to market orders. On the other hand, howeer, as liquidity builds up and the queue at the top of the LOB becomes longer, more limit orders are attracted to the dark pool and this e ect reduces liquidity of the LOB, especially depth. When the book moes from being empty to haing one share at the best ask price, the rst e ect dominates and both spread and depth improe (the impact of the dark pool introduction is less negatie). When instead depth builds up substantially and the book opens with two shares at the best ask price, the second e ect dominates and while spread improes, depth drops due to the migration of limit orders. The reason for why spread improes but depth deteriorates when the book opens with two shares at the best ask price is that a minimum of two shares at the best ask is required for the introduction of the dark pool to generate a migration of limit orders -not only a switch from market to limit orders. So the intense migration of the two-unit limit orders from the ask side does not impact spread heaily as the book already has two shares at p 1, whereas it does impact depth substantially. Welfare. In this new framework small traders play the role of N traders of the initial model, and large traders play the role of W traders with the di erence that they may submit orders of two shares. The conclusions are therefore ery similar to the ones of the preious model and are illustrated in Fig. B3, Panel B. s before, the e ect of the introduction of a dark pool on the welfare of small traders is mainly drien by the ariation in the spread. traders also do not bene t from the introduction of a dark pool when both the book and the dark pool open empty because both spread and depth deteriorate. 4 More precisely, traders switch from two-unit limit orders to two-unit market orders, and from two-unit limit orders to one-unit limit and one-unit market orders. 3
5 Finally, consider the new framework ealuated at t with three periods remaining, and compare books with di erent amounts of liquidity, b t = [00], [10] and [0]. Fig. B3, Panel B, shows that the negatie e ect on the welfare of small traders declines as book liquidity at t increases. The reason is that spread deteriorates and then partially recoers due to the introduction of the dark pool. Howeer, as the book becomes deeper and at the same time some liquidity builds up in the dark pool, large traders start using the dark pool intensiely and they now bene t from the access to dark pools so that een aggregate welfare increases. Yet note that in this new model large traders gains from trade outweigh small traders losses only when liquidity builds up substantially and the book opens with two shares on the ask side. B.. Extension : LOB and periodic dark pool ( L&P ) We extend the framework with large and small traders by assuming that the dark enue has periodic execution. P DP is organized like an opaque crossing network where time priority is enforced. In this trading enue, orders are crossed at the end of the trading game only if a matching number of orders on the opposite side has been submitted to the dark pool prior to the cross. The execution price is the spread mid-quote preailing on the LOB at the end of period which we indicate with ep Mid. Similarly to the L&C framework, the large traders action space includes, in addition to the orders presented for the benchmark model, the possibility to submit orders to buy or to sell the asset on the P DP, as shown in Table B1. In particular, large traders can split their orders between the LOB and the P DP, or they can submit their entire order to the P DP. Their optimal trading strategy is determined by soling at each round the following optimization problem: max ' e t ['M (j; p z i ); 'M (; pz ); 'ML(1; p z i ; 1; p z 1); 'MD(1; p z i ; 1; ep Mid ); (5) 'D(j; ep Mid ); 'LD(1; p z 1; 1; ep Mid ); 'L(j; p z 1); '(0) j t ; t ] : traders still sole problem (7), howeer they now condition their strategies not only on their own t and on the state of the LOB but also on the inferred state of the P DP. The game is soled as before by backward induction starting from. B.3 Proof of Proposition 4 We rst proide an example of how the extended ersion of the model with both small and large traders is soled, and then we discuss the results obtained. B.3.1. B framework n example of the extensie form of the game is presented in Fig. B4. Because the model is similar to the one with unitary trade size, for breity we proide an example of how the model is soled only for the last two periods of the trading game. From now onwards, we assume that for large traders the optimal order size is j = max [' j b t ], e t (')=@j 0 due to agents risk neutrality. j Following Fig. B4, at we present as an example b t4 = [0], and focus on large trader s pro ts: t4 [' M (; p B )] = (p B t4 ) = (1 3 t4 ) (53) t4 [' M (; p 1 ) ] = ( t4 p 1 )= ( t4 1 ) (54) t4 ['(0)] = 0 : (55) 4
6 >< ^P DP t4 = It is straightforward to show that all strategies are optimal in equilibrium (N t4 = 3): ' 1 LT;b t4 = ' M (; p B ), ' LT;b t4 = '(0), and ' 3 LT;b t4 = ' M (; p 1 ). We refer to the proof of Proposition 1, ppendix, for the optimal strategies of small traders. Still as an example, and continuing to follow Fig. B4, we consider the opening LOB b t3 = [1]. traders pro ts are as follows: t3 [' M (1; p B 1 )] = (p B 1 t3 ) (56) [' L (1; p 1 )] = t3 ['(0)] = 0 (57) [' L (1; p B 1 )] = ( t3 p B 1 ) Pr (' M (; p B 1 ) j b t4 = []) (58) t3 [' M (1; p 1 )] = ( t3 p 1 ) : (59) traders strategies are similar, the only di erence being that j = for a market sell order, and that conditioning on b t3 = [1] now traders willing to buy can combine market and limit orders, and traders willing to sell can walk down the book ia a marketable order: [' ML (1; p 1 ; 1; p B 1 )] = ( t3 p 1 )+( t3 p B 1 ) Pr (' M (; p B 1 ) j b t4 = [1]) (60) t3 [' M (; p B )] = (p B 1 t3 ) + (p B t3 ) : (61) Pro ts for periods t 1 and t are similar and are omitted, the main di erence being that limit orders hae additional periods to get executed. B.3.. L&P framework n example of the extensie form of the game is presented in Fig. B5. The solution of the L&P framework follows the same methodology, but now the large trader soles Eq. (5). For breity, we proide again examples only for the last two periods of the trading game. The remaining two periods are soled in a similar way. Following Fig. B5, at we consider again the book b t4 = [0] with the following information set, t4 = [0; ' L (; p 1 ); ' L(1; p B 1 ); ' M(1; p B 1 )]. Notice that when at t 3 traders obsere ' M (1; p B 1 ), they don t know whether a small trader submitted a one-unit market order to sell, or whether a large trader submitted a market order combined with a dark pool order. Similarly, at t when traders obsere ' L (1; p B 1 ) it could be a one-unit limit order to buy or a combination of a limit and a dark pool order. s coming at Bayesian update their expectations on the state of the dark pool as follows (we omit that all probabilities are conditional to t4 ): 8 >: +1 with prob = 0 with prob = 1 with prob = [Pr t ' LD (1;p B 1 ;+1;ep Mid)+(1 (1 ) Pr t ' LD (1;p B 1 ;+1;ep Mid) Pr t 3 ' M (1;p B 1 ) ) Pr t ' L (1;p B 1 )][(1 ) Pr ' M (1;p B 1 )+ Pr ' MD (1;p B 1 ; t 3 t 3 Pr t ' LD (1;p B 1 ;+1;ep Mid) Pr t 3 ' MD (1;p B 1 ; 1;ep Mid)+(1 ) Pr t ' L (1;p B 1 ) Pr t 3 ' M (1;p B 1 ) [Pr t ' LD (1;p B 1 ;+1;ep Mid)+(1 [Pr t ' LD (1;p B 1 ;+1;ep Mid)+(1 ) Pr t ' L (1;p B 1 )][(1 (1 ) Pr t ' L (1;p B 1 ) Pr t 3 ' MD (1;p B 1 ; ) Pr t ' L (1;p B 1 )][(1 ) Pr ' M (1;p B 1 )+ Pr ' MD (1;p B 1 ; t 3 t 3 1;ep Mid) 1;ep Mid)] 1;ep Mid)] ) Pr ' M (1;p B 1 )+ Pr ' MD (1;p B 1 ; 1;ep Mid)] : t 3 t 3 (6) 5
7 We refer to the proof of Proposition 1 in ppendix for the pro ts of the small trader, and discuss the large trader s pro ts. We omit regular market orders that we hae already presented in the B framework, Eqs. (53) (55), and focus only on orders that inole the use of the P DP : e [' MD (1; p B ; 1; ep Mid )] = (p B t4 ) + ( p 1 +pb t4 ) Pr(^P DP t4 = +1) (63) e [' D ( 1; ep Mid )] = ( p 1 +pb t4 ) Pr(^P DP t4 = +1) (64) e [' D (+1; ep Mid )] = ( t4 e [' MD (1; p 1 ; +1; ep Mid )] = ( t4 p 1 ) + ( t4 p 1 +pb ) Pr(^P DP t4 = 1) (65) p 1 +pb ) Pr(^P DP t4 = 1) : (66) To determine the equilibrium strategies ' n a; t4 at for n N t4, the model has to be soled up to period t 1. We anticipate that because in equilibrium Pr t ' LD (1; p B 1 ; +1; ep Mid) = 0 and Pr t3 ' MD (1; p B 1 ; 1; ep Mid) > 0, N t4 = 5 and the strategies of the large trader are as follows: ' 1 LT; t4 = ' M (; p B ), ' LT; t4 = '(0), ' 3 LT; t4 = ' D (+1; ep Mid ), ' 4 LT; t4 = ' MD (1; p 1 ; +1; ep Mid), and ' 5 LT; t4 = ' M (; p 1 ). s for the B framework, we now consider the case b t3 = [1] with the following information set, t3 = [1; ' L (; p 1 ); ' L(1; p B 1 )]. The expected state of the PDP is: 8 Pr >< +1 with prob = t ' LD (1;p B 1 ;+1;ep Mid) Pr t ' LD (1;p ^P 1 DP t3 = Mid)+(1 ) Pr t ' L (1;p B 1 ) (1 )Pr >: 0 with prob = t ' L (1;p B 1 ) Pr t ' LD (1;p B 1 ;+1;ep Mid)+(1 ) Pr t ' L (1;p B 1 ) : (67) Compared to the B framework, the large trader has now additional strategies. market and dark orders: He can combine [' MD (1; p 1 ; +1; ep Mid)]= ( t3 p 1 ) + Pr(^P DP t3 = +1)( t3 Pr (' D ( p 1 +pb 1 ) ; ep Mid ) j t4 ) + Pr(^P DP t3 =0)[( t3 p 1 +pb 1 ) (68) Pr (' D ( ; ep Mid )j t4 ) + ( t3 p 1 +pb ) Pr (' MD (1; p B 1 ; 1; ep Mid)j t4 )] ; where t4 = [11; ' L (; p 1 ); ' L(1; p B 1 ); ' M(1; p 1 )]; [' MD (1; p B 1 ; 1; ep Mid)]= (p B 1 t3 ) + Pr(^P DP t3 = +1)f( p 1 +pb t3 ) [(1 ) + (1 Pr (' M (; p 1 )j ))] + ( p +pb t3 ) Pr (' M (; p 1 )j )g + Pr(^P DP t3 =0)( p 1 +pb t3 ) [Pr (' D (+1; ep Mid ) j t4 ) + Pr (' MD (1; p 1 ; +1; ep Mid) j t4 )] ; (69) where t4 = [0; ' L (; p 1 ); ' L(1; p B 1 ); ' M(1; p B 1 )]. 6
8 lternatiely, he can combine a limit and dark order on the bid side of the market: [' LD (1; p B 1 ; +1; ep Mid)]= ( t3 p B 1 ) Pr (' M (; p B 1 ) j ) + ( t3 [Pr (' MD (1; p B 1 ; 1; ep Mid)j t4 ) + Pr (' D ( ; ep Mid )j t4 )] +Pr(^P DP t3 = +1) Pr (' D ( ; ep Mid )j t4 )g ; p 1 +pb 1 )fpr(^p DP t3 =0) (70) where t4 = [; ' L (; p 1 ); ' L(1; p B 1 ); ' L(1; p B 1 )]. Finally, he can submit a pure dark pool order to sell or buy: [' D ( ; ep Mid )]= Pr(^P DP t3 = +1)f( p 1 +pb 1 t3 )[( Pr (' MD (1; p 1 ; +1; ep Mid)j t4 ) + Pr (' D (+; ep Mid )j t4 ) + Pr (' D ( ; ep Mid )j t4 ) + Pr ('(0)j t4 )) + (1 ) (Pr (' s (0)j t4 ) + Pr (' M (1; p 1 )j ))] + ( p 1 +pb t3 )[(1 ) Pr (' M (1; p B 1 )j ) + (Pr (' M (1; p B )j t4 ) + Pr (' MD (1; p B 1 ; 1; ep Mid)j t4 ))] (71) +( p +pb 1 t3 ) Pr (' M (; p 1 )j )g + Pr(^P DP t3 =0)( p 1 +pb 1 t3 ) [Pr (' MD (1; p 1 ; +1; ep Mid)j t4 ) + Pr (' D (+; ep Mid )j t4 )] [' D (+; ep Mid )]= Pr(^P DP t3 = +1)( t3 p 1 +pb 1 ) Pr (' D ( ; ep Mid )j t4 ) +Pr(^P DP t3 =0)[( t3 p 1 +pb ) Pr (' MD (1; p B 1 ; 1; ep Mid)j t4 ) (7) +( t3 p 1 +pb 1 ) Pr (' D ( ; ep Mid )j t4 )] ; where in both cases t4 = [1; ' L (; p 1 ); ' L(1; p B 1 ); '(0)]. B.3.3. L&C framework n example of the extensie form of the game is presented in Fig. B6. For consistency, we consider again the example of the book b t4 = [0] with the following information set, t4 = [0; ' L (; p 1 ); ' L (1; p B 1 ); ' M(1; p B 1 )]. In this case when at t 3 a trader obseres ' M (1; p B 1 ), he doesn t know whether a small trader submitted a one-unit market order, or whether a large trader submitted a market order combined with a dark pool order or a two-unit IOC dark pool order that was partially executed on the CDP. Therefore, traders coming at Bayesian update their expectations on the state of the dark pool by using an extended ersion of Eq. (6) which takes into account that ^CDP t4 = 0 with the additional probability Pr ' LD (1; p B 1 ; +1; ep Mid;t) Pr ' D ( ; p Mid;t3 ; p B 1 ). s coming at t 3 instead face the same t t 3 uncertainty as for the L&P framework. 7
9 Compared to the L&P framework, the large trader can now submit a IOC dark pool order with the following pro ts: e [' D (+; p Mid;t4 ; p 1 )]= t4 p 1 [1 + Pr(^CDP t4 = +1; 0)] p 1 +pb Pr(^CDP t4 = 1) (73) e [' D ( ; p Mid;t4 ; p B )]= p B [1 + Pr(^CDP t4 = 1; 0)] + p 1 +pb Pr(^CDP t4 = +1) t4 (74) To determine the equilibrium strategies ' n a; t4 at for n N t4, the model has again to be soled up to period t 1. We anticipate that because in equilibrium Pr t ' LD (1; p B 1 ; +1; ep Mid;t) = 0 and Pr t3 ' MD (1; p B 1 ; 1; ep Mid;t) > 0, N t4 = 4 and the strategies of the large trader are as follows: ' 1 LT; t4 = ' M (; p B ), ' LT; t4 = '(0), ' 3 LT; t4 = ' D (+1; p Mid;t4 ), ' 4 LT; t4 = ' D (+; p Mid;t4 ; p 1 ). s for the other two frameworks, we now consider the case b t3 = [1] with the following information set, t3 = [0; ' L (; p 1 ); ' L(1; p B 1 )]. We refer to Eq. (67) for the probabilities of the expected state of the CDP, ^CDP t3 = f0; +1g. The large trader can now submit a IOC dark pool order to sell (the execution probability on the CDP of a IOC dark order to buy is zero, so traders neer select this strategy): [' D ( ; p Mid;t3 ; p B )]= p B 1 + p B Pr(^CDP t3 = 0) + p 1 +pb 1 Pr(^CDP t3 = + 1) t3 (75) Notice that the pro ts of the combined market and dark orders, limit and dark orders and pure dark pool orders are similar to the ones presented for the L&P framework. The main two di erences are that rst in this framework the order is executed as soon as liquidity is aailable on the CDP and not at the end of the trading game; second that traders can use IOC dark pool orders. For example pro ts for a dark pool sell order are: [' D ( ; ep Mid;t )]= Pr(^CDP t3 = +1)( p 1 +pb 1 t3 )f1 + [Pr (' D (+; p Mid;t4 ; p 1 )j ) +Pr (' D (+; p Mid;t4 )j t4 )]g + Pr(^CDP t3 =0)( p 1 +pb 1 t3 ) [Pr (' D (+; p Mid;t4 ; p 1 )j ) + Pr (' D (+; p Mid;t4 )j t4 )]g ; (76) where, as for the L&P, t4 = [1; ' L (; p 1 ); ' L(1; p B 1 ); '(0)]. B.3.4. OM Results for OM presented in Fig. B1 are deried by straightforward comparison of the equilibrium strategies for the three frameworks: B, L&P and L&C. In Figs. B7 B1 we proide plots at t for the large trader s pro ts as a function of ; for both the L&P and L&C frameworks. Following the exposition in the main text, we focus on selling strategies. Each gure proides a graphical representation of the traders optimization problem. Fig. B7 shows how the introduction of a P DP changes the optimal order submission strategies of large traders by crowding out both market and limit orders, and generating OM. Consider rst OM in the L&P : compare Figs. B7 and B9 for the e ect of market depth, B7 and B11 for the e ect of spread. For the L&C, compare instead Figs. B8 and B10, and B8 and B1, respectiely. 8
10 B.3.5. TC and VC Results for T C and V C presented in Figs. B1 and B, respectiely, are obtained by comparing ll rates and olumes for the B, L&P and L&C frameworks, as shown in Eqs. (14) and (50) respectiely. s an example, we consider period t 1 of the B model and specify formulas for the estimated ll rate and olume in this period. Equilibrium strategies at t 1 for a large trader are as follows: ' 1 LT = ' M(;p B ), ' LT = ' ML(1; p B ; 1; p 1 ), '3 LT = ' L(; p 1 ), '4 LT = ' L(; p B 1 ), '5 LT = ' ML(1; p ; 1; pb 1 ) and '6 LT = ' M(;p 1 ). The ones for a small trader are: ' 1 ST = ' M(1;p B 1 ), ' ST = ' L(1; p 1 ), '3 ST = ' L(1; p B 1 ) and '4 ST = ' M(1;p 1 ). F R B t 1 ;[] = 1 (Pr t 1 V B t 1 ;[] = 1 (Pr ' 1 ST + Pr t 1 B.3.6. Spread, depth and welfare t 1 ' 4 ST )+ 1 (Pr t 1 ' 1 ST + Pr ' 4 ST )+ 1 t 1 ( Pr t 1 ' 1 LT + Pr t 1 ' 1 LT + Pr t 1 ' LT + Pr ' 5 LT + Pr ' 6 LT ) (77) t 1 t 1 ' LT + Pr ' 5 LT + Pr ' 6 LT ) : (78) t 1 t 1 Results for spread and depth (Fig. B3, Panel ), and for welfare (Fig. B3, Panel B) are obtained by comparing, respectiely, the two market quality measures and welfare alues for the B, L&P and L&C protocol. We refer to the proofs of Proposition and Proposition 3 for an example of how to compute these measures. 9
11 Table B1 Order submission strategies. This table reports the trading strategies, ', aailable to large (LT) and small traders (ST) for the three di erent frameworks considered: a benchmark model (B) with a limit order book (LOB), and either a continuous (L&C) or a periodic dark pool (L&P ) competing with a LOB. The LOB is characterized by a set of four prices, denoted by p z i, where z = f; Bg indicates the ask or bid side of the market, and i = f1; g the leel on the price grid. In the L&C, epmid;t indicates the spread mid-quote on the LOB preailing in period t. In the L&P, epmid indicates the spread mid-quote on the LOB preailing at the end of period t4, when the dark pool crosses orders. IOC indicates Immediate-or-Cancel orders. The LT trades up to two shares, j = f0; 1; g, while the ST trades up to one share. Strategies LT (B) Notation Strategies ST /(B L&C L&P ) Notation Market order of j shares ' M (j; p z i ) Market order of 1 share ' M(1; p z i ) Limit order of j shares ' L (j; p z 1 ) Limit order of 1 share ' L(1; p z 1 ) No trading '(0) No trading '(0) Market & limit order of 1 share each ' ML (1; p z i ; 1; pz 1 ) Marketable order of shares ' M (; p z ) dditional Strategies LT (L&C) Market & dark pool order of 1 share each ' MD (1; p z i ; 1; ep Mid;t) Limit & dark pool order of 1 share each ' LD (1; p z 1 ; 1; ep Mid;t) Dark pool order of j shares ' D (j; epmid;t) IOC on dark pool or market order of j shares ' DM (j; epmid;t; p z i ) dditional Strategies LT (L&P ) Market & dark pool order of 1 share each ' MD (1; p z i ; 1; ep Mid) Limit & dark pool order of 1 share each ' LD (1; p z 1 ; 1; ep Mid) Dark pool order of j shares ' D (j; epmid) 10
12 Table B Order submission probabilities at t1 and t: This table reports the submission probabilities of large (LT) and small traders (ST) for the orders listed in column 1 for the benchmark framework (B), for the model with a limit order book and a periodic dark pool (L&P ) and for the model with a limit order book and a continuous dark pool (L&C). We consider the t1 equilibrium strategies from the four-period model that opens with an empty book at t1, bt1 = [00], and the t equilibrium strategies from the three-period models that open at t according to the three equilibrium opening books (at t) from the four-period model, and that di er for the number of shares at the rst leel of the ask side of the book: bt = [00], b = [10], and b t t = [0]. Results are computed assuming that the tick size is equal to = 0:08 and the probability that a large trader arries is = 0:5. Panel - ST bt1 = [00] b = [00] b = [10] b = [0] t t t Trading Strategy B L&C L&P B L&C L&P B L&C L&P B L&C L&P ' M 1; p B ' L 1; p ' L 1; p B ' M 1; p ' M 1; p Panel B - LT bt1 = [00] b = [00] b = [10] b = [0] t t t Trading Strategy B L&C L&P B L&C L&P B L&C L&P B L&C L&P ' M (; p B ) ' ML (1; p B ; 1; p 1 ) ' D ( ; epmid) ' D ( ; epmid;t ) ' L (; p 1 ) ' L (; p B 1 ) ' ML (1; p 1 ; 1; pb 1 ) ' ML (1; p ; 1; pb 1 ) ' M (; p 1 ) ' M (; p ) ' M (; p )
13 Panel : Order migration Panel B: Trade creation Fig. B1. Order migration and trade creation, small and large traders. This gure presents results for the two frameworks, L&P and L&C. The rst one combines a limit order book (LOB) and a periodic dark pool (P DP ); the second combines a LOB and a continuous dark pool (CDP ). For each framework we report in Panel order migration which is the aerage probability that an order migrates to the dark pool, and in Panel B trade creation that is the sum of two components. The rst one is the aerage ll rate in the dark pool. The second one is the di erence between the aerage LOB ll rate in the L&P or L&C, and the aerage LOB ll rate in the benchmark. We report results for both the four-period model that opens with an empty book at t1, bt1 = [00], and for the three-period models that open at t according to the three equilibrium opening books (at t) from the four-period model, and that di er for the number of shares at the rst leel of the ask side of the book: bt = [00], b = [10], and b t t = [0]. Results are computed assuming a tick size equal to = 0:08 and a probability that a large trader arries = 0:5. 1
14 Fig. B. Volume creation, small and large traders. This gure presents results for the two frameworks, L&P and L&C. The rst one combines a limit order book (LOB) and a periodic dark pool (P DP ); the second combines a LOB and a continuous dark pool (CDP ). For each framework we report olume creation (V C) that is the sum of two components. The rst one is the aerage olume in the dark pool, V (DRK P OOL). The second one is the di erence between the aerage LOB olume in the L&P or L&C, V (LOB), and the aerage LOB olume in the benchmark, V (B). We report results for both the four-period model that opens with an empty book at t1, bt1 = [00], and for the three-period models that open at t according to the three equilibrium opening books (at t) from the four-period model, and that di er for the number of shares at the rst leel of the ask side of the book: bt = [00], bt = [10], and b t = 0:5. = [0]. Results are computed assuming a tick size equal to = 0:08 and a probability that a large trader arries 13
15 Panel : Market quality Panel B: Welfare Fig. B3. Market quality and welfare, small and large traders. This gure presents results for spread, depth and welfare in the two frameworks, L&P and L&C. L&P combines a limit order book (LOB) and a periodic dark pool (P DP ); L&C combines a LOB and a continuous dark pool (CDP ). ll measures are computed as the aerage percentage di erence between their alue for the L&P or L&C framework and the benchmark framework. s spread and depth are exogenous in the initial period we do not include it in the aerage, while for welfare we consider three measures: the welfare of a small trader (ST ), the welfare of a large trader (LT ), and aggregate welfare.we report results for both the four-period model that opens with an empty book at t1, bt1 = [00], and for the three-period models that open at t according to the three equilibrium opening books (at t) from the four-period model, and that di er for the number of shares at the rst leel of the ask side of the book: bt = [00], b = [10], and b t t = [0]. Results are computed assuming a tick size equal to = 0:08 and a probability that a large trader arries = 0:5. 14
16 , j= b t3 = [00] Market & Limit Buy b t3 = [11], j = b t = [00] Limit Buy, j = b t3 = [] Market & Limit Buy Limit Buy, j = Limit Sell, j= b t = [01] b t = [0] b t = [0] Limit Sell, j= Market & Limit Sell, j= b t3 = [40] b t3 = [30] b t3 = [0], j= Market & Limit Buy Limit Buy, j =1 b t4 = [01] b t4 = [1] b t4 = [], j= No Trading, j= Market & Limit Sell b t = [10] 1, j=1 b t4 = [0] b t1 = [00] 1, j = Limit Buy Limit Sell b t = [00] b t = [00] b t = [01] b t = [10] Limit Buy Limit Sell b t3 = [10] b t3 = [1] b t3 = [30] b t3 = [0] 1 Marketable Sell Limit Buy b t4 = [0] b t4 = [11] b t4 = [] 1 No Trading b t = [00] b t4 = [0] Fig. B4. Benchmark model of limit order book (B), small and large traders. Example of the extensie form of the game for the benchmark model when the opening book at t1 is bt1 = [00]; where j indicates the number of shares traded by the large trader. We only present the equilibrium strategies. 15
17 , j= b t3 = [00] Market & Limit Buy b t3 = [11], j = Market & Limit Buy Limit Buy, j = Limit Sell, j= b t = [00] b t = [01] b t = [0] b t = [0] Limit Buy, j = Limit Sell, j= Dark Pool Sell, j=, j= b t3 = [] b t3 = [40] b t3 = [0] b t3 = [0], j= Market & Limit Buy Limit & Dark Pool Buy Dark Pool Sell b t4 = [01] b t4 = [1] b t4 = [] b t4 = [1], j= Market & Dark Pool Buy Dark Pool Buy, j=1 No Trading Market & Limit Sell b t = [10] 1 Market & Dark Pool Sell b t4 = [0], j= b t1 = [00] 1, j = Limit Buy Limit Sell b t = [00] b t = [00] b t = [01] b t = [10] Limit Buy Limit Sell b t3 = [10] b t3 = [1] b t3 = [30] b t3 = [0] 1 Marketable Sell Limit Buy b t4 = [0] b t4 = [11] b t4 = [] 1 No Trading b t = [00] b t4 = [0] Fig. B5. Limit Order Book and Periodic Dark Pool (L&P), small and large traders. Example of the extensie form of the game for the model with a periodic dark pool when the opening book at t1 is bt1 = [00], where j indicates the number of shares traded by the large trader. Books that belong to the same information set, and hence are undistinguishable, are in squared dashed boxes and hae the same line format. For example, bt4 = [] can be obsered when at t 3 either a small trader arries and submits a limit buy, or a large trader arries and submits a combined limit and dark order to buy. We only present the equilibrium strategies. 16
18 , j= b t3 = [00] Market & Limit Buy b t3 = [11], j= b t4 = [01], j = Market & Limit Buy Limit Buy, j = Limit Sell, j= b t = [00] b t = [01] b t = [0] b t = [0] Limit Buy, j = Limit Sell, j= Dark Pool Sell, j=, j= b t3 = [] b t3 = [40] b t3 = [0] b t3 = [0] Market & Limit Buy Dark Pool Buy Limit Buy, j=1 Dark Pool Sell b t4 = [1] b t4 = [1] b t4 = [] b t4 = [1] IOC &, j= Dark Pool Buy, j=1 No Trading Market & Limit Sell b t = [10] 1 Market & Dark Pool Sell b t4 = [0], j= b t1 = [00] 1, j = Limit Buy Limit Sell b t = [00] b t = [00] b t = [01] b t = [10] Limit Buy Limit Sell b t3 = [10] b t3 = [1] b t3 = [30] b t3 = [0] 1 Marketable Sell Limit Buy b t4 = [0] b t4 = [11] b t4 = [] 1 No Trading b t = [00] b t4 = [0] Fig. B6. Limit order book and continuous dark pool (L&C), small and large traders. Example of the extensie form of the game for the model with a continuous dark pool when the opening book at t1 is bt1 = [00], where j indicates the number of shares traded by the large trader. Books that belong to the same information set, and hence are undistinguishable, are in squared dashed boxes and hae the same line format. For example, bt4 = [1] can be obsered when a large trader arries at t 3 and submits either a dark pool order to sell or to buy. We only present the equilibrium strategies. 17
19 OrderType OrderType L&P and B: M,p B L&C and B: M,p B 0.8 t L&P: L&P: ML 1,p B ;1,p 1 L,p t L&C: L&C: ML 1,p B ;1, p 1 L,p L&P: D,p Mid B: ML 1, p B ;1, p L&C: D,p Mid,t B: ML 1, p B ;1, p B: L, p B: L, p t t Fig. B7. Order migration on the L&P - b t =[0] Fig. B8. Order migration on the L&C - b t =[0] OrderType OrderType L&P and B: M,p B L&C and B: M,p B 0.8 t L&P: L&P: ML 1,p B ;1,p 1 L,p t L&C: L&C: ML 1,p B ;1, p 1 L,p L&P: D,p Mid B: ML 1, p B ;1, p L&C: D,p Mid,t B: ML 1, p B ;1, p B: L, p B: L, p t t Fig. B9. Order migration on the L&P - b t =[10] Fig. B10. Order migration on the L&C - b t =[10] OrderType OrderType L&P and B: M,p B L&C and B: M,p B 0.8 t L&P: L&P: ML 1,p B ;1,p 1 L,p t L&C: L&C: ML 1,p B ;1, p 1 L,p L&P: D,p Mid B: ML 1, p B ;1, p L&C: D,p Mid,t B: ML 1, p B ;1, p B: L, p B: L, p t t Fig. B11. Order migration on the L&P - b t =[00] Fig. B1. Order migration on the L&C - b t =[00] 18
Closed form spread option valuation
Closed form spread option aluation Petter Bjerksund and Gunnar Stensland Department of Finance, NHH Helleeien 30, N-5045 Bergen, Norway e-mail: petter.bjerksund@nhh.no Phone: +47 55 959548, Fax: +47 55
More informationQuality differentiation and entry choice between online and offline markets
Quality differentiation and entry choice between online and offline markets Yijuan Chen Australian National University Xiangting u Renmin University of China Sanxi Li Renmin University of China ANU Working
More informationEconS 503 - Advanced Microeconomics II Handout on Cheap Talk
EconS 53 - Advanced Microeconomics II Handout on Cheap Talk. Cheap talk with Stockbrokers (From Tadelis, Ch. 8, Exercise 8.) A stockbroker can give his client one of three recommendations regarding a certain
More informationOptimal insurance contracts with adverse selection and comonotonic background risk
Optimal insurance contracts with adverse selection and comonotonic background risk Alary D. Bien F. TSE (LERNA) University Paris Dauphine Abstract In this note, we consider an adverse selection problem
More informationOn the incentives of an integrated ISP to favor its own content
On the incentives of an integrated ISP to favor its own content Duarte Brito y UNL and CEFAGE-UE dmb@fct.unl.pt Pedro Pereira z AdC and CEFAGE-UE pedro.br.pereira@gmail.com. João Vareda x European Commission
More informationOn the maximum average degree and the incidence chromatic number of a graph
Discrete Mathematics and Theoretical Computer Science DMTCS ol. 7, 2005, 203 216 On the maximum aerage degree and the incidence chromatic number of a graph Mohammad Hosseini Dolama 1 and Eric Sopena 2
More informationHow To Model The Effectiveness Of A Curriculum In Online Education Using Bayesian Networks
International Journal of adanced studies in Computer Science and Engineering Modelling the Effectieness of Curriculum in Educational Systems Using Bayesian Networks Ahmad A. Kardan Department of Computer
More informationThe FitzHugh-Nagumo Model
Lecture 6 The FitzHugh-Nagumo Model 6.1 The Nature of Excitable Cell Models Classically, it as knon that the cell membrane carries a potential across the inner and outer surfaces, hence a basic model for
More informationChapter 1: The Modigliani-Miller Propositions, Taxes and Bankruptcy Costs
Chapter 1: The Modigliani-Miller Propositions, Taxes and Bankruptcy Costs Corporate Finance - MSc in Finance (BGSE) Albert Banal-Estañol Universitat Pompeu Fabra and Barcelona GSE Albert Banal-Estañol
More information1 Economic Application of Derivatives
1 Economic Application of Derivatives deriv-applic.te and.pdf April 5, 2007 In earlier notes, we have already considered marginal cost as the derivative of the cost function. That is mc() = c 0 () How
More informationBidding with Securities: Auctions and Security Design.
Bidding with Securities: Auctions and Security Design. Peter M. DeMarzo, Ilan Kremer and Andrzej Skrzypacz * Stanford Graduate School of Business September, 2004 We study security-bid auctions in which
More informationHerding, Contrarianism and Delay in Financial Market Trading
Herding, Contrarianism and Delay in Financial Market Trading A Lab Experiment Andreas Park & Daniel Sgroi University of Toronto & University of Warwick Two Restaurants E cient Prices Classic Herding Example:
More informationInterlinkages between Payment and Securities. Settlement Systems
Interlinkages between Payment and Securities Settlement Systems David C. Mills, Jr. y Federal Reserve Board Samia Y. Husain Washington University in Saint Louis September 4, 2009 Abstract Payments systems
More informationEXERCISES FROM HULL S BOOK
EXERCISES FROM HULL S BOOK 1. Three put options on a stock have the same expiration date, and strike prices of $55, $60, and $65. The market price are $3, $5, and $8, respectively. Explain how a butter
More informationHow To Calculate The Price Of A Dollar
Exchange Rates Costas Arkolakis teaching fellow: Federico Esposito Economics 407, Yale January 2014 Outline De nitions: Nominal and Real Exchange Rate A Theory of Determination of the Real Exchange Rate
More informationOur development of economic theory has two main parts, consumers and producers. We will start with the consumers.
Lecture 1: Budget Constraints c 2008 Je rey A. Miron Outline 1. Introduction 2. Two Goods are Often Enough 3. Properties of the Budget Set 4. How the Budget Line Changes 5. The Numeraire 6. Taxes, Subsidies,
More informationLecture Notes: Basic Concepts in Option Pricing - The Black and Scholes Model
Brunel University Msc., EC5504, Financial Engineering Prof Menelaos Karanasos Lecture Notes: Basic Concepts in Option Pricing - The Black and Scholes Model Recall that the price of an option is equal to
More informationAuctioning Keywords in Online Search
Auctioning Keywords in Online Search Jianqing Chen The Uniersity of Calgary iachen@ucalgary.ca De Liu Uniersity of Kentucky de.liu@uky.edu Andrew B. Whinston Uniersity of Texas at Austin abw@uts.cc.utexas.edu
More informationOptimal Pricing for Multiple Services in Telecommunications Networks Offering Quality of Service Guarantees
To Appear in IEEE/ACM Transactions on etworking, February 2003 Optimal Pricing for Multiple Serices in Telecommunications etworks Offering Quality of Serice Guarantees eil J. Keon Member, IEEE, G. Anandalingam,
More informationESSENTIAL S&OP SOFTWARE REQUIREMENTS
ESSENTIAL S&OP SOFTWARE REQUIREMENTS Essential S&OP Software Requirements 1 Your Forecast Essential S&OP Software Requirements By Harpal Singh Software Support for the S&OP Process The focus of S&OP is
More informationTarget Tracking with Monitor and Backup Sensors in Wireless Sensor Networks
Target Tracking with Monitor and Backup Sensors in Wireless Sensor Networks Md. Zakirul Alam Bhuiyan, Guojun Wang,andJieWu School of Information Science and Engineering Central South Uniersity, Changsha
More informationMarket Power, Forward Trading and Supply Function. Competition
Market Power, Forward Trading and Supply Function Competition Matías Herrera Dappe University of Maryland May, 2008 Abstract When rms can produce any level of output, strategic forward trading can enhance
More informationIBM Marketing Operations OnDemand November 17, 2014. Project Manager's Guide
IBM Marketing Operations OnDemand Noember 17, 2014 Project Manager's Guide Note Before using this information and the product it supports, read the information in Notices on page 63. IBM Marketing Operations
More informationMaximizing Revenue with Dynamic Cloud Pricing: The Infinite Horizon Case
Maximizing Reenue with Dynamic Cloud Pricing: The Infinite Horizon Case Hong Xu, Baochun Li Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering Uniersity of Toronto Abstract We study the infinite horizon
More informationVehicle-based Sensor Networks for Traffic Monitoring
Vehicle-based Sensor Networks for Traffic Monitoring Xu Li, Wei Shu, Ming-Lu Li and Min-You Wu Department of Computer Science and Engineering, Shanghai Jiao Tong Uniersity, Shanghai, China Department of
More informationEvolutionary Undersampling for Imbalanced Big Data Classification
Eolutionary Undersampling for Imbalanced Big Data Classification I. Triguero, M. Galar, S. Vluymans, C. Cornelis, H. Bustince, F. Herrera and Y. Saeys Abstract Classification techniques in the big data
More informationLecture 39: Intro to Differential Amplifiers. Context
Lecture 39: Intro to Differential Amplifiers Prof J. S. Smith Context Next week is the last week of lecture, and we will spend those three lectures reiewing the material of the course, and looking at applications
More information4 Impulse and Impact. Table of contents:
4 Impulse and Impact At the end of this section you should be able to: a. define momentum and impulse b. state principles of conseration of linear momentum c. sole problems inoling change and conseration
More informationOPTIMIZING RAILCAR MANAGEMENT
OPTIMIZING RAILCAR MANAGEMENT Optimizing Railcar Management 1 Optimizing Railcar Management By Harpal Singh Time to Take a Second Look at Railcar Planning The cost required to distribute bulk products
More informationTechnology Licensing by Advertising Supported Media Platforms: An Application to Internet Search Engines
No 23 Technology Licensing by Advertising Supported Media Platforms: An Application to Internet Search Engines Geza Sapi, Irina Suleymanova June 2011 IMPRINT DICE DISCUSSION PAPER Published by Heinrich
More informationAsset Price Dynamics and Reputation
Asset Price Dynamics When Traders Care About Reputation Amil Dasgupta and Andrea Prat London School of Economics and CEPR October 2004; Revised December 2006 Abstract What are the equilibrium features
More information1 Volatility Trading Strategies
Brunel University Msc., EC5504, Financial Engineering Prof Menelaos Karanasos Lecture Notes: Volatility Trading Strategies 1 Volatility Trading Strategies As previously explained, volatility is essentially
More informationHow To Design A Physical Data Warehouse
IBM DB2 for Linux, UNIX, and Windows Best Practices Physical database design for data warehouse enironments Authors This paper was deeloped by the following authors: Maksym Petrenko DB2 Warehouse Integration
More informationFinancial Market Microstructure Theory
The Microstructure of Financial Markets, de Jong and Rindi (2009) Financial Market Microstructure Theory Based on de Jong and Rindi, Chapters 2 5 Frank de Jong Tilburg University 1 Determinants of the
More informationPaid Placement: Advertising and Search on the Internet
Paid Placement: Advertising and Search on the Internet Yongmin Chen y Chuan He z August 2006 Abstract Paid placement, where advertisers bid payments to a search engine to have their products appear next
More informationEvolutionary Undersampling for Imbalanced Big Data Classification
Eolutionary Undersampling for Imbalanced Big Data Classification I. Triguero, M. Galar, S. Vluymans, C. Cornelis, H. Bustince, F. Herrera and Y. Saeys Abstract Classification techniques in the big data
More informationThe E ect of Trading Commissions on Analysts Forecast Bias
The E ect of Trading Commissions on Analysts Forecast Bias Anne Beyer and Ilan Guttman Stanford University September 2007 Abstract The paper models the interaction between a sell-side analyst and a risk-averse
More informationRobust Portfolio Control with Stochastic Factor Dynamics
OPERATIONS RESEARCH Vol. 6, No. 4, July August 203, pp. 874 893 ISSN 0030-364X print) ISSN 526-5463 online) http://dx.doi.org/0.287/opre.203.80 203 INFORMS CONTEXTUAL AREAS Robust Portfolio Control with
More informationGetting Prices Right: Mobile Phone Di usion, Market E ciency and Inequality 1
Getting Prices Right: Mobile Phone Di usion, Market E ciency and Inequality 1 Francis ANDRIANARISON 2 CSAE Conference 2010 Economic Development in Africa. 21st - 23rd March 2010, Oxford. Abstract: In this
More informationBlack-Scholes model under Arithmetic Brownian Motion
Black-Scholes model under Arithmetic Brownian Motion Marek Kolman Uniersity of Economics Prague December 22 23 Abstract Usually in the Black-Scholes world it is assumed that a stock follows a Geometric
More informationHedging Using Forward Contracts
10 CHAPTER 1 Business Snapshot1.1 Hedge Funds Hedge funds have become major users of derivatives for hedging, speculation, and arbitrage. A hedge fund is similar to a mutual fund in that it invests funds
More informationOligopoly and Trade. Notes for Oxford M.Phil. International Trade. J. Peter Neary. University of Oxford. November 26, 2009
Oligopoly and Trade Notes for Oxford M.Phil. International Trade J. Peter Neary University of Oxford November 26, 2009 J.P. Neary (University of Oxford) Oligopoly and Trade November 26, 2009 1 / 11 Oligopoly
More informationSecurities market structure, trading fees and investors welfare.
Securities market structure, trading fees and investors welfare. Jean-Edouard Colliard Paris School of Economics 48 boulevard Jourdan 75014 Paris, France colliard@ens.fr Thierry Foucault HEC, Paris 1 rue
More informationIn ation Tax and In ation Subsidies: Working Capital in a Cash-in-advance model
In ation Tax and In ation Subsidies: Working Capital in a Cash-in-advance model George T. McCandless March 3, 006 Abstract This paper studies the nature of monetary policy with nancial intermediaries that
More informationThe Prison S Dilemma and Its Connections
Games Played in a Contracting Environment V. Bhaskar Department of Economics University College London Gower Street London WC1 6BT February 2008 Abstract We analyze normal form games where a player has
More information1 Further Pricing Relationships on Options
1 Further Pricing Relationships on Options 1.1 The Put Option with a Higher Strike must be more expensive Consider two put options on the same stock with the same expiration date. Put option #1 has a strike
More informationMarkus K. Brunnermeier
Institutional tut Finance Financial Crises, Risk Management and Liquidity Markus K. Brunnermeier Preceptor: Dong BeomChoi Princeton University 1 Market Making Limit Orders Limit order price contingent
More informationRelative prices and Balassa Samuleson e ect
Relative prices and Balassa Samuleson e ect Prof. Ester Faia, Ph.D. Johann Wolfgang Goethe Universität Frankfurt a.m. March 2009 rof. Ester Faia, Ph.D. (Johann Wolfgang Goethe Relative Universität prices
More informationUnemployment Insurance in the Presence of an Informal Sector
Unemployment Insurance in the Presence of an Informal Sector David Bardey, Fernando Jaramillo and Ximena Peña May 014 bstract We study the e ect of UI bene ts in a typical developing country where the
More informationFebruary 2013. Abstract
Marking to Market and Ine cient Investments Clemens A. Otto and Paolo F. Volpin February 03 Abstract We examine how mark-to-market accounting a ects investment decisions in an agency model with reputation
More informationLINES AND PLANES IN R 3
LINES AND PLANES IN R 3 In this handout we will summarize the properties of the dot product and cross product and use them to present arious descriptions of lines and planes in three dimensional space.
More informationIn-Memory Database User Guide
IBM soliddb Version 7.0 In-Memory Database User Guide SC27-3845-05 Note Before using this information and the product it supports, read the information in Notices on page 41. First edition, fifth reision
More informationA Theory of Intraday Patterns: Volume and Price Variability
A Theory of Intraday Patterns: Volume and Price Variability Anat R. Admati Paul Pfleiderer Stanford University This article develops a theory in which concentrated-trading patterns arise endogenously as
More informationInformation Gatekeepers on the Internet and the Competitiveness of. Homogeneous Product Markets. By Michael R. Baye and John Morgan 1.
Information Gatekeepers on the Internet and the Competitiveness of Homogeneous Product Markets By Michael R. Baye and John Morgan 1 Abstract We examine the equilibrium interaction between a market for
More informationClimate control of a bulk storage room for foodstuffs
Climate control of a bulk storage room for foodstuffs S. an Mourik, H. Zwart, Twente Uniersity, K.J. Keesman*, Wageningen Uniersity, The Netherlands Corresponding author: S. an Mourik Department of Applied
More informationFinancial Markets. Itay Goldstein. Wharton School, University of Pennsylvania
Financial Markets Itay Goldstein Wharton School, University of Pennsylvania 1 Trading and Price Formation This line of the literature analyzes the formation of prices in financial markets in a setting
More informationAdverse selection and moral hazard in health insurance.
Adverse selection and moral hazard in health insurance. Franck Bien David Alary University Paris Dauphine November 10, 2006 Abstract In this paper, we want to characterize the optimal health insurance
More informationThe Effect of Short-selling Restrictions on Liquidity: Evidence from the London Stock Exchange
The Effect of Short-selling Restrictions on Liquidity: Evidence from the London Stock Exchange Matthew Clifton ab and Mark Snape ac a Capital Markets Cooperative Research Centre 1 b University of Technology,
More informationAsymmetric Information (2)
Asymmetric nformation (2) John Y. Campbell Ec2723 November 2013 John Y. Campbell (Ec2723) Asymmetric nformation (2) November 2013 1 / 24 Outline Market microstructure The study of trading costs Bid-ask
More informationCompeting for Consumers Online: The Advertising Strategies of. Vertically Di erentiated Firms
Competing for Consumers Online: The Advertising Strategies of Vertically Di erentiated Firms Taylan Yalcin Harvard Business School, Harvard University tyalcin@hbs.edu Elie Ofek Harvard Business School,
More informationAdverse Selection. Chapter 3
Chapter 3 Adverse Selection Adverse selection, sometimes known as The Winner s Curse or Buyer s Remorse, is based on the observation that it can be bad news when an o er is accepted. Suppose that a buyer
More information4. Only one asset that can be used for production, and is available in xed supply in the aggregate (call it land).
Chapter 3 Credit and Business Cycles Here I present a model of the interaction between credit and business cycles. In representative agent models, remember, no lending takes place! The literature on the
More informationResearch Division Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis Working Paper Series
Research Division Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis Working Paper Series Comment on "Taylor Rule Exchange Rate Forecasting During the Financial Crisis" Michael W. McCracken Working Paper 2012-030A http://research.stlouisfed.org/wp/2012/2012-030.pdf
More informationA Welfare Criterion for Models with Distorted Beliefs
A Welfare Criterion for Models with Distorted Beliefs Markus Brunnermeier, Alp Simsek, Wei Xiong August 2012 Markus Brunnermeier, Alp Simsek, Wei Xiong () Welfare Criterion for Distorted Beliefs August
More informationA mathematical analysis of the influence of wind uncertainty on MTCD efficiency
A mathematical analysis of the influence of wind uncertainty on MTC efficiency Jean-Marc Alliot (SNA/R&) Nicolas urand (SNA/R&) Abstract A large part of the controller s workload comes from conflict detection
More informationDynamic Pricing of Enterprise Software with Value Uncertainty: Motivation for Selling Software as a Service
Dynamic Pricing of Enterprise Software with Value Uncertainty: Motivation for Selling Software as a Service November 26, 2011 Abstract This paper studies a software vendor s decision to o er perpetual
More informationA Portfolio Insurance Strategy for Volatility Index (VIX) Futures
A Portfolio Insurance Strategy for Volatility Index (VIX) Futures Young Cheol Jung * This paper proposes a dynamic asset allocation strategy for portfolio insurance of which underlying risky asset is the
More informationCustomer Value-based Management: Competitive Implications
Customer Value-based Management: Competitive Implications Upender Subramanian, Jagmohan S. Raju, Z. John Zhang The Wharton School 700 Jon M. Huntsman Hall 3730 Walnut Street Philadelphia, PA 19104-6340
More informationLiquidity Cycles and Make/Take Fees in Electronic Markets
Liquidity Cycles and Make/Take Fees in Electronic Markets Thierry Foucault HEC School of Management, Paris rue de la Liberation 7835 Jouy en Josas, France foucaulthec.fr Eugene Kandel School of Business
More informationIBM Tivoli Storage Manager for Linux. Quick Start. Version 5 Release 1 GC23-4692-00
IBM Tioli Storage Manager for Linux Quick Start Version 5 Release 1 GC23-4692-00 IBM Tioli Storage Manager for Linux Quick Start Version 5 Release 1 GC23-4692-00 Note! Before using this information and
More informationSub-Penny and Queue-Jumping
Sub-Penny and Queue-Jumping Sabrina Buti Rotman School of Management, University of Toronto Francesco Consonni Bocconi University Barbara Rindi Bocconi University and IGIER Ingrid M. Werner Fisher College
More informationMathematics. Rosella Castellano. Rome, University of Tor Vergata
and Loans Mathematics Rome, University of Tor Vergata and Loans Future Value for Simple Interest Present Value for Simple Interest You deposit E. 1,000, called the principal or present value, into a savings
More informationRepresentation of functions as power series
Representation of functions as power series Dr. Philippe B. Laval Kennesaw State University November 9, 008 Abstract This document is a summary of the theory and techniques used to represent functions
More informationIBM SPSS Custom Tables 22
IBM SPSS Custom Tables 22 Note Before using this information and the product it supports, read the information in Notices on page 97. Product Information This edition applies to ersion 22, release 0, modification
More informationTracking Object Positions in Real-time Video using Genetic Programming
Tracking Object Positions in Real-time Video using Genetic Programming W. Smart and M. Zhang School of Mathematics, Statistics and Computer Science, Victoria Uniersity of Wellington, P. O. Box 600, Wellington,
More informationSSE/EFI Working Paper Series in Economics and Finance, No. 644
econstor www.econstor.eu Der Open-Access-Publikationsserver der ZBW Leibniz-Informationszentrum Wirtschaft The Open Access Publication Server of the ZBW Leibniz Information Centre for Economics Salomonsson,
More informationUNCORRECTED PROOF. Avoiding loss of fairness owing to failures in fair data exchange systems. Peng Liu a,), Peng Ning b,1, Sushil Jajodia b,2
Ž. Decision Support Systems 892 2000 xxx www.elseier.comrlocaterdsw Abstract Aoiding loss of fairness owing to failures in fair data exchange systems Peng Liu a,), Peng Ning b,1, Sushil Jajodia b,2 a Department
More informationSharing Online Advertising Revenue with Consumers
Sharing Online Advertising Revenue with Consumers Yiling Chen 2,, Arpita Ghosh 1, Preston McAfee 1, and David Pennock 1 1 Yahoo! Research. Email: arpita, mcafee, pennockd@yahoo-inc.com 2 Harvard University.
More informationLecture 11: The Design of Trading Platforms (Alos-Ferrer et al. 2010)
Lecture 11: The Design of Trading Platforms (Alos-Ferrer et al. 2010) 1. Introduction Lecture 10: selection between exogenously given market institutions now: emergence of new institutions 2 possibilities
More information. In this case the leakage effect of tax increases is mitigated because some of the reduction in disposable income would have otherwise been saved.
Chapter 4 Review Questions. Explain how an increase in government spending and an equal increase in lump sum taxes can generate an increase in equilibrium output. Under what conditions will a balanced
More informationModeling Insurance Markets
Modeling Insurance Markets Nathaniel Hendren Harvard April, 2015 Nathaniel Hendren (Harvard) Insurance April, 2015 1 / 29 Modeling Competition Insurance Markets is Tough There is no well-agreed upon model
More informationOnline shopping and platform design with ex ante registration requirements
Online shopping and platform design with ex ante registration requirements Florian Morath Johannes Münster y December 5, 2014 Abstract We study platform design in online markets in which buying involves
More informationHow To Calculate The Price Of A Motel
Competitie Outcomes in Product-Differentiated Oligopoly Michael J. Mazzeo * Abstract This paper analyzes price and quantity outcomes of firms operating in differentiated product oligopoly markets. Unlike
More informationEmployee Stock Options, Financing Constraints, and Real Investment
Employee Stock Options, Financing Constraints, and Real Investment Ilona Babenko Michael Lemmon Yuri Tserlukevich Hong Kong University of Science and Technology and University of Utah March 2009 Our goals
More informationBene ts and Costs of Organised Trading for Non Equity Products
Bene ts and Costs of Organised Trading for Non Equity Products Thierry Foucault, HEC, Paris I Background I Market Transparency I Electronic Trading I Conclusions Introduction Background I "We rea rm our
More informationNo 139. Consumer Flexibility, Data Quality and Location Choice. Irina Baye, Irina Hasnas
No 139 Consumer Flexibility, Data Quality and Location Choice Irina aye, Irina Hasnas April 014 IMPINT DICE DISCUSSION PAPE Published by düsseldorf university press (dup) on behalf of Heinrich Heine Universität
More informationNormalization and Mixed Degrees of Integration in Cointegrated Time Series Systems
Normalization and Mixed Degrees of Integration in Cointegrated Time Series Systems Robert J. Rossana Department of Economics, 04 F/AB, Wayne State University, Detroit MI 480 E-Mail: r.j.rossana@wayne.edu
More informationCHAPTER 15: THE TERM STRUCTURE OF INTEREST RATES
Chapter - The Term Structure of Interest Rates CHAPTER : THE TERM STRUCTURE OF INTEREST RATES PROBLEM SETS.. In general, the forward rate can be viewed as the sum of the market s expectation of the future
More informationRisk Aversion. Expected value as a criterion for making decisions makes sense provided that C H A P T E R 2. 2.1 Risk Attitude
C H A P T E R 2 Risk Aversion Expected value as a criterion for making decisions makes sense provided that the stakes at risk in the decision are small enough to \play the long run averages." The range
More informationROBUST CONTENT-BASED VIDEO WATERMARKING EXPLOITING MOTION ENTROPY MASKING EFFECT
ROBUST CONTENT-BASED VIDEO WATERMARKING EXPLOITING MOTION ENTROPY MASKING EFFECT Amir Houmansadr, Hamed Pirsiaash Department of electrical engineering, Sharif Uniersity of Technology, Azadi Ae., Tehran,
More informationKey Stage 2 Mathematics Programme of Study
Deeloping numerical reasoning Identify processes and connections Represent and communicate Reiew transfer mathematical to a ariety of contexts and eeryday situations identify the appropriate steps and
More informationOptimal Auctions. Jonathan Levin 1. Winter 2009. Economics 285 Market Design. 1 These slides are based on Paul Milgrom s.
Optimal Auctions Jonathan Levin 1 Economics 285 Market Design Winter 29 1 These slides are based on Paul Milgrom s. onathan Levin Optimal Auctions Winter 29 1 / 25 Optimal Auctions What auction rules lead
More informationOn the Interaction and Competition among Internet Service Providers
On the Interaction and Competition among Internet Service Providers Sam C.M. Lee John C.S. Lui + Abstract The current Internet architecture comprises of different privately owned Internet service providers
More informationIBM Tealeaf CX Version 9 Release 0.2 June 18, 2015. Tealeaf Databases Guide
IBM Tealeaf CX Version 9 Release 0.2 June 18, 2015 Tealeaf Databases Guide Note Before using this information and the product it supports, read the information in Notices on page 111. This edition applies
More informationVectors. Vector Multiplication
Vectors Directed Line Segments and Geometric Vectors A line segment to which a direction has been assigned is called a directed line segment. The figure below shows a directed line segment form P to Q.
More informationTiered and Value-based Health Care Networks
Tiered and Value-based Health Care Networks Ching-to Albert Ma Henry Y. Mak Department of Economics Department of Economics Boston Univeristy Indiana University Purdue University Indianapolis 270 Bay State
More informationUCLA. Department of Economics Ph. D. Preliminary Exam Micro-Economic Theory
UCLA Department of Economics Ph. D. Preliminary Exam Micro-Economic Theory (SPRING 2011) Instructions: You have 4 hours for the exam Answer any 5 out of the 6 questions. All questions are weighted equally.
More informationPortfolio selection based on upper and lower exponential possibility distributions
European Journal of Operational Research 114 (1999) 115±126 Theory and Methodology Portfolio selection based on upper and lower exponential possibility distributions Hideo Tanaka *, Peijun Guo Department
More informationCommon sense, and the model that we have used, suggest that an increase in p means a decrease in demand, but this is not the only possibility.
Lecture 6: Income and Substitution E ects c 2009 Je rey A. Miron Outline 1. Introduction 2. The Substitution E ect 3. The Income E ect 4. The Sign of the Substitution E ect 5. The Total Change in Demand
More informationA Two-Sided Market Analysis of Provider Investment Incentives With an Application to the Net-Neutrality Issue.
A Two-Sided Market Analysis of Proider Inestment Incenties With an Application to the Net-Neutrality Issue. JOHN MUSACCHIO Technology and Information Management, Uniersity of California, Santa Cruz GALINA
More information