1 Getting Published Ed Diener Smiley Professor of Psychology University of Illinois
2 Submission Suggestions 1. The right journal? 2. Persevere, be tough 3. Frame the intro with your study in mind 4. Get the paper to the right reviewers 5. Do reviews yourself 6. Expect long lags 7. Hooray for the chance to revise
3 How to Publish Nora S. Newcombe Temple University
4 My Editorial Experience Invited Co-Editor, Special Issue on Interactions among Scientists and Policy Makers; Challenges and Opportunities, American Psychologist, March Editor, Journal of Experimental Psychology: General, Guest Editor, Special Issues on Early Memory, Journal of Experimental Child Psychology, Associate Editor, Psychological Bulletin, Consulting Editor, Developmental Psychology, , Child Development, , Journal of Experimental Child Psychology, , Psychological Bulletin, , Journal of Cognition and Development, 2002-, Psychological Science, 2004-, Perspectives on Psychological Science, 2005-, Psychonomic Bulletin and Review, Reviewer for many other journals, e.g., Behavioral and Brain Sciences, Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition, Psychological Review, Science.
5 Do You Have Something to Say? There is no substitute for a good idea You also need compelling data and a clear take-home message Bem (1995) wrote that an article: tells a straightforward tale of a circumscribed question in want of an answer. It is not a novel with subplots and flashbacks but a short story with a single, linear narrative line.
6 OK, I Have Something to Say Now What? Get a pre-review From yourself (learn to role play) From colleagues (remember that they are almost always right) Neatness counts Did you check spelling and grammar? Did you follow APA style?
7 Sending Out the Article Pick the right journal Remember that editors differ they are people not machines. American Psychologist has annual information on APA journals ISI has citation counts Write a good cover letter Blind review? Set your expectations for review appropriately
8 Varieties of the Rejection Experience When is rejection not rejection? Any time revision is invited. Do not procrastinate about revision What if you disagree with the reviewers? Say so, but politely.
9 Which is Right? (from Bem, 1995) I have left the section on the animal studies unchanged. If Reviewers A and C can t even agree on whether the animal studies are relevant, I must be doing something right. You will recall that Reviewer A thought the animal studies should be described more fully, whereas Reviewer C thought they should be omitted. A biopsychologist in my department agreed with reviewer C that the animal studies are not really valid analogs of the human studies. So I have dropped them from the text but cited Snarkle s review of them in an explanatory footnote on page 26.
10 Advice to young writers from an old editor Robert V. Kail Purdue University
11 Caveat emptor regarding my advice Except for the past four months, my editorial experience is limited to developmental journals Given the choice between stunning data and elegant theory, I d always pick the former My comments apply to empirical pieces that would be submitted to a specialty journal My advice assumes that you have something worth publishing!
12 Turning a thesis/dissertation into a manuscript suitable for publication Dissertations and manuscripts meet different needs Signs that a manuscript originated in a dissertation Too long, particularly the introduction Includes marginal experiments Write clearly Avoid jargon (J.Williams Style: Lessons in clarity and grace) Have others read the manuscript Framing a study effectively What is unknown? Why is it important to know it? How does your study help us to know it better?
13 Determining authorship APA Publication Manual: Authorship encompasses not only those who do the actual writing but also those who have made substantial scientific contributions [including] formulating the problem or hypothesis, structuring the experimental design, organizing and conducting the statistical analysis, interpreting the results, or writing a major portion of the paper. Blackwell Publishers-- Publication Ethics Some recommend that agreements be put in writing
14 Strategies for submitting Selecting a journal Where are articles on this topic published? What are relevant professional societies? Read information for contributors Impact factor Submitting Follow guidelines in information for contributors Follow APA guidelines regarding cover letter
15 The action or decision letter It will not be accepted. Read everything; the action letter is not a simple unweighted summary of reviews. Revise and resubmit: Follow the instructions carefully. Rejected: Join the crowd we all have manuscripts filed away that should be thrown away! Appeal? Only when a review is factually incorrect and that error influenced the editorial decision Submit elsewhere? Maybe.
16 Why are manuscripts rejected? Topic is not timely or interesting Flaws in method Data are flawed or, at least, are not compelling (weak effects).
17 Conclusion Being a successful scientist takes a thick skin good journals reject the majority of submissions. But hang in there the rewards of discovery are immense.
18 Telling Your Story Susan Nolen-Hoeksema Hoeksema,, Ph.D. Department of Psychology Yale University
19 You ve Finished Your Project!
20 Now It s s Time to Write Your Article
21 Which Article Do You Write? (a) (b) The article you planned to write when you designed your study, or The article that makes the most sense now that you know your results Correct answer: b Bem,, 2003; dbem.ws/writingarticle.pdf
22 For Whom Do You Write?
23 For Whom Do You Write? Colleagues who know a fair amount about your subject matter, but often not as much as you know Reader-based prose: - think about what the reader needs to know to understand your argument and your study - what will capture the reader s s interest - organize conceptually
24 Where Do You Start? In the Middle.
25 The Methods Section Lead the reader through the procedures as if he/she was a participant. Provide enough detail for replication. Avoid multiple abbreviations. Describe your participants thoroughly. Discuss technical details as necessary. Discuss problems as necessary.
26 The Results Section Make clear what type of analyses you conducted. Begin with the central findings then move on to the more peripheral findings. Remind readers of the hypotheses motivating your analyses. Interpret results in clear prose. Summarize at the end of major sections. Use figures and tables as necessary.
27 The Introduction: An Inverted Triangle The Big Picture Supporting Detail Your Study
28 The Introduction Talk about people, processes, and problems not researchers and chronology. Use examples. Avoid jargon. Discuss and cite only previous work directly relevant to your study. Don t t list studies. Avoid being unnecessarily critical of other researchers (who will likely be your reviewers).
29 The Introduction Provide a clear rationale for all your major hypotheses. State your hypotheses clearly as you move through the introduction. Use sections with headers to divide up the intro conceptually. End with a summary of your main hypotheses.
30 The Discussion: Another Triangle Your Results Connection to Literature Conclusions and Implications
31 More on Discussion Organization 1. Introductory paragraph summarizing main results 2. Main results grouped conceptually and integration with the literature 3. Limitations 4. Conclusions and implications
32 10 Common Discussion Section Mistakes 1. Starting with limitations 2. Going overboard with limitations 3. Not acknowledging limitations 4. Simply restating the results without interpretation or integration with literature 5. Presenting new results
33 10 Common Mistakes cont cont d 6. Making strong claims about weak results 7. Not differentiating strong and weak results in conclusions 8. Lapsing into causal language about correlational data 9. Repeating the introduction 10. No concluding statements; end with limitations
34 Keeping Yourself Motivated Social learning theory (Bandura)) has taught us: Break the tasks of writing into proximal goals - 5 minute tasks - 1 hour tasks - 1 afternoon tasks
35 If You Get Overwhelmed or Stuck
36 Take a Break
37 Ask for Help When You Need It
38 Resources Baumeister, R.F., & Leary, M.R. (1997). Writing narrative literature reviews. Review of General Psychology, 1, Bem, D.J. (2004). Writing the empirical journal article. In J.M. Darley, M.P. Zanna, H.L. Roediger III (Eds.), The compleat academic: A guide for the beginning social scientist (2 nd ed.). (pp ). Washington, DC: American Psychological Association. (dbem.ws/online_pubs.html#writing) Bem, D.J. (1995). Writing a review article for Psychological Bulletin. Psychological Bulletin, 118, Rosenthal, R. (1995). Writing meta-analytic reviews. Psychological Bulletin, 118, (dbem.ws/online_pubs.html#writing) Sternberg, R.J. (Ed.). (2000). Guide to publishing in psychology journals. Cambridge, England: Cambridge University Press. Strunk, Jr., W., & White, E.B. (2000). The elements of style, 4 th edition. New York: Longman Publishers.
Writing the Empirical Social Science Research Paper: A Guide for the Perplexed Josh Pasek University of Michigan January 24, 2012 Correspondence about this manuscript should be addressed to Josh Pasek,
Running head: SAMPLE FOR STUDENTS 1 Sample APA Paper for Students Interested in Learning APA Style 6th Edition Jeffrey H. Kahn Illinois State University Author Note Jeffrey H. Kahn, Department of Psychology,
Compass Interdisciplinary Virtual Conference 19-30 Oct 2009 10 Things New Scholars should do to get published Duane Wegener Professor of Social Psychology, Purdue University Hello, I hope you re having
Guidelines for Writing An APA Style Lab Report Research articles in psychology follow a specific format as set forth by the American Psychological Association (APA Style). The following sections describe
Research Proposal Guidelines: APA Style - 1 Running head: RESEARCH PROPOSAL GUIDELINES: APA STYLE APA Style: An Example Outline of a Research Proposal Your Name School of Health & Applied Human Sciences
Getting Your Research Published in Peer Reviewed Journals Shawn O. Utsey, Ph.D., Associate Professor of Counseling Psychology, Department of Psychology, Virginia Commonwealth University Starting with Three
A graduate students guide to involvement in the peer review process APA Science Student Council 2007 For more information about the APA Science Student Council, please visit http://www.apa.org/science/leadership/students/
Appalachian State University Master of Public Administration Program Writing Guide Introduction Students should use the following guidelines to complete written assignments in the Appalachian State University
Publishing in Psychology: An Overview for Undergraduate Students This article relies on the expertise of current and former journal editors in order to introduce undergraduate students to important issues
Getting Published in Rehab Nursing September 9, 2014 Elaine T. Miller, PhD, RN, CRRN, FAAN FAHA Editor, Rehabilitation Nursing Objectives 1. Identify your potential contributions to the expansion of nursing
Running head: WRITING AN APA REPORT Writing an APA Paper 1 Writing an APA Style Report Author s Name California State University, Northridge (don t include the information below) Originally prepared by
Writing Essays for Psychology MScs Martin Corley October 21, 2009 This is a brief guide to essay writing, originally written for the the MSc Psycholinguistics Handbook. 1 Section 2 covers the issues in
Guidelines for Authors of Research Proposals, Prospectuses, Theses, and Research Reports Claudia J. Stanny Beginning writers encounter similar problems and make similar errors when preparing manuscripts.
Preparing Manuscripts for Publication in Psychology Journals: A Guide for New Authors American Psychological Association Washington, DC Copyright 2010 by the American Psychological Association. All rights
The Scientific Literature page 1 The Scientific Literature In Psychology As we saw in the reading on science and the scientific method, falsifiability and replication are aspects of the scientific method
Section Three Nursing Research Procedures Page 25 Research Competency Nursing majors are expected to develop their research skills throughout the program and demonstrate this skill in the final research
AUTHOR SUBMISSION GUIDELINES FOR THE INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF INDIGENOUS HEALTH The following guidelines apply to authors writing articles for the Aboriginal Health Research Networks Secretariat s International
M.S. Degree Prospectus Guidelines Department of Biological Sciences The signature page should include all information on this page. A copy of the Prospectus Guidelines should be attached to the copy of
The Journals of Gerontology, Series B: Psychological Sciences and Social Sciences The Journals of Gerontology: Series B is a bimonthly journal of The Gerontological Society of America, The Social Sciences
WRITING A RESEARCH PAPER FOR A GRADUATE SEMINAR IN POLITICAL SCIENCE Ashley Leeds Rice University Here are some basic tips to help you in writing your research paper. The guide is divided into six sections
COMPREHENSIVE EXAMINATION Adopted May 31, 2005/Voted revisions in January, 2007, August, 2008, and November 2008 and adapted October, 2010 All students are required to successfully complete the Comprehensive
Department of Psychology GRADUATE PROGRAM OFFICE MEMORANDUM To: Experimental Students (1 st & 2 nd year) From: Debra Titone, Graduate Program Director Subject: MASTER S THESIS / FAST TRACK / QUALIFYING
What you need to know about NIH grant writing 2 NIH grant preparation: Know your resources 3 Understanding the NIH grant process 4 Study sections, peer review and the importance of the cover letter 6 Writing
From Paper, Poster, or Presentation to Publication Josie Howard-Ruben, MS, RN, APN-CNS, AOCN, CHPN Advocate Health Care April, 2012 Josie Howard-Ruben has nothing to disclose. This program has not received
Formatting & Editing Your Thesis or Dissertation: A Workshop Checklist for Thesis & Dissertation Writers* Submit Application for Degree (pay $90 graduation fee) and Graduation Checklist forms to the Graduate
American Journal of Preventive Medicine Sponsored by the American College of Preventive Medicine and the Association for Prevention Teaching and Research Reviewer Information The American Journal of Preventive
Psychology 270: Community Psychology Spring 2005 Critical Analysis Paper Assignments Overview of the Paper Assignments In this class, you are required to write two short papers, each 5-7 pages long. In
How to Get a Good Review Mordechai Ben-Ari Department of Science Teaching Weizmann Institute of Science Rehovot 76100 Israel email@example.com 1 Introduction For several years I have been reviewing
Writing 1 Running head: USING APA STYLE Writing a Successful Paper: Using APA Style Your Name Here Arizona State University Writing 2 Abstract The second page usually contains your abstract, which is a
St Patrick s College Maynooth Faculty of Theology Essay Writing Guidelines for Students in BD, BATh, BTh, and Higher Diploma in Theological Studies Academic Year 2014-15 Introduction This brief essay is
Secure Computer Systems Syllabus MCIS - 0683 Fall 2007 Glenn Allan Stout, Ph.D. Graduate School of Computer and Information Sciences Nova Southeastern University Fort Lauderdale, FL Course Syllabus MCIS
Parts of a Paper Before you even begin a paper you have to imagine who your audience will be: your nurse peers? The general public? a sixth grade class? The graduate school admission committee? Then when
Tips for Publishing Success Eleanor Krassen Covan, PhD Editor-in-Chief Health Care for Women International & Professor Emerita, of Gerontology University of North Carolina Wilmington Advice from An Editor
Overview and Purpose Fall 2011 ~ Writing 20: Academic Writing on Ocean Acidification MP3: Research Project This project will give you the opportunity to practice the broad genre of research paper a piece
How Theses Get Written: Some Hot Tips Dr Steve Easterbrook NASA/WVU Software Research Lab 1 Outline Part 1: Writing your thesis (1) Context: What is a thesis (for)? (2) How Do I Get Started? (3) What Should
Office of Research and Graduate Studies Duncan Hayse, MA, MFA Coordinator Theses, Doctoral Projects, and Dissertations CONTACT: http://www.uiw.edu/orgs/writing/index.html firstname.lastname@example.org APA review for
SIXTH EDITION APA GUIDELINES 1 THE UNIVERSITY OF AKRON COLLEGE OF NURSING American Psychological Association (APA) Style Guidelines Sixth Edition The following information is provided as the highlights
Publishing in Nature journals John Plummer Senior Editor Nature Materials November 2015 By the end of this talk I hope you will: Appreciate the key editorial differences between Nature journals. Better
How to get published in Nature (and its sister journals) Ed Gerstner / 印 格 致 Executive Editor Nature Communications March 2014 My background Joined Nature in April 2002. Moved to Shanghai in November 2012
School Psychology Doctoral Program Dissertation Outline 1 Final Version 6/2/2006 Instructions: Double Underline means the item should be a title or heading in your dissertation. Do not deviate from the
Thesis Guidelines Master of Arts in General Psychology Program University of North Florida PSYCHOLOGY 2 Thesis Guidelines The purpose of this document is to provide you with important information, requirements,
Bates College Department of Biology PEER REVIEW FORM Reviewer s Bates ID#: Authors Bates ID# s: Guidelines: This peer review is to be done anonymously. Your task is to help the author to write a better,
50 Writing Tips For Commercial Lawyers Robert E. Crotty Good legal writing is clear, concise, candid, and cogent. Robert E. Crotty is a partner with the New York office of Kelley Drye & Warren. He focuses
Guidelines for Contributors Scope International Organization seeks to publish the best and most innovative scholarly manuscripts available on international political and economic relations. A study that
Robotics Research Proposal Michael Herrmann University of Edinburgh (slides adapted from earlier versions by Alan Bundy, Alex Lascarides, Victor Lavrenko, Stratis Viglas, Mark van Rossum) RRR RRP RRR RRP
APA Style Citations & References A Guide for Psychology Undergraduates 1 Why Cite? Whenever you report something that you have read, you have an ethical and a practical responsibility to cite where you
EDITING AND PROOFREADING Use this sheet to help you: recognise what is involved in editing and proofreading develop effective editing and proofreading techniques 5 minute self test Read the following statements
THIS IS THE RUNNING HEAD IN UP TO 50 CHARACTERS 1 (The running head is what gets printed across the top of journal pages. The 50 characters include spaces. It usually contains as much as the title that
Accounting Review (The) 1 ADDRESS FOR SUBMISSION: Terry Shevlin, Editor Accounting Review (The) University of Washington Business School Department of Accounting Box 353200 Seattle, WA 98195-3200 USA Phone:
How to write a technical paper Mohamed A. El Sharkawi Smart Energy Lab (SEL) Department of Electrical Engineering University of Washington Seattle, WA 98195 2500 e mail: email@example.com web:
COM207: CREATIVE WRITING: FICTION SYLLABUS LECTURE HOURS/CREDITS: 3/3 CATALOG DESCRIPTION Prerequisite: ENG101 English Composition I Students study a variety of short fiction for story structure and write
NORTHERN VIRGINIA COMMUNITY COLLEGE PSYCHOLOGY 211 - RESEARCH METHODOLOGY FOR THE BEHAVIORAL SCIENCES Dr. Rosalyn M. King, Professor DETAILED TOPICAL OVERVIEW AND WORKING SYLLABUS CLASS 1: INTRODUCTIONS
PSYCHOLOGY PROGRAM LEARNING GOALS AND OUTCOMES BY COURSE LISTING Psychology 1010: General Psychology Learning Goals and Outcomes LEARNING GOAL 1: KNOWLEDGE BASE OF PSYCHOLOGY Demonstrate familiarity with
North Carolina Agricultural and Technical State University Thesis and Dissertation Digital Handbook This style guide outlines the thesis/dissertation formatting requirements at NC A&T. The Graduate School
How to Write and Publish an Academic Research Paper 101 Tips from JournalPrep.com Planning your Manuscript 1. The research paper topic should be unique and there should be a logical reason to study it.
Public Safety Management Degree Program Syllabus for Community Risk Reduction for the Fire and Emergency Services UST 427, 3 Credit Hour Course, Spring Term 2014 PROFESSOR Bernard W. Becker, III, MS, EFO,
195 32 Teaching Writing Skills That Enhance Student Success in Future Employment James P. Coyle University of Windsor The ability to write well is often critical for effective work performance. Although
School of Medical Sciences Introductory Program Thesis Writing David Allen Physiology Acknowledgement based on notes originally prepared by Brett Hambly The thesis should be a substantial, original contribution
Running head: NEUROSCIENCE TERM PAPER 1 Format, Style, and Suggested Topics for Neuroscience Term Paper W. Jeffrey Wilson Albion College NEUROSCIENCE TERM PAPER 2 Abstract A term paper on any topic concerning
How to Write a Good Technical Paper This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution Non Commercial 4.0 International License Objectives Give tips for writing good abstracts Give tips for writing
How to Create Effective Training Manuals Mary L. Lanigan, Ph.D. How to Create Effective Training Manuals Mary L. Lanigan, Ph.D. Third House, Inc. Tinley Park, Illinois 60477 1 How to Create Effective Training
Summer Program 2014 Course Syllabus PSY 301G The Psychology of Group Dynamics Contact Details John Taverniers, Dr. Ing. Office: 0032 (0)2 742 6600 Mobile: 0032 (0)472 440567 E-mail: firstname.lastname@example.org
DEPARTMENT OF PSYCHOLOGY CHECKLISTS FOR WRITING ESSAYS & PRACTICAL REPORTS September 2014 These checklists provide a summary of the style requirements typical for undergraduate assignments in psychology
Library, Teaching and Learning Writing Essays and other assignments 2013 Lincoln University Writing at University During your degree at Lincoln University you will complete essays, reports, and other kinds
9/06 History Department Junior Research Paper Guidelines The Junior Research Paper is a graduation requirement for all history and history/social science majors beginning with students who entered Wheaton
Check in and introductions Reading academic articles - strategies Essay Basics : The assignment fulfilling requirements Three prewriting strategies & the dynamic outline Genre types of writing: anecdotal
APA Style: The Basics Dr. Robert T. Koch Jr., Dr. Kat Richards, Ms. Katie Sanders, Mr. Ash Taylor, Ms. Cayla Buttram Center for Writing Excellence University of North Alabama June 2013 Citation & Documentation
TOWSON UNIVERSITY EXPERIMENTAL PSYCHOLOGY PROGRAM STUDENT GUIDE FOR COMPLETING A THESIS Last updated: October 22, 2012 Purpose This guide is intended to supplement, but not replace, the Towson University
Literacy Design Collaborative LDC Template Task Collection 2.0 December 2013 The Literacy Design Collaborative is committed to equipping middle and high school students with the literacy skills they need
GUIDELINES FOR FORMAT AND CONTENT OF THE DISSERTATION CHAPTER 1 INTRODUCTION TO THE STUDY Background This section should be approximately 2-5 pages of background narrative, citing literature as appropriate
1 Writing Competitive Research Grant Proposals Suggestions from Program Managers of the Outline of Topics Proposal Writing Rules Funding Sources and Agency Information Selecting a Topic Writing the Proposal
GUIDE TO WRITING YOUR RESEARCH PAPER Ashley Leeds Rice University Here are some basic tips to help you in writing your research paper. The guide is divided into six sections covering distinct aspects of
MANUAL for Dissertation Writers Doctor of Psychoanalysis (Psya.D.) Doctor of Psychoanalysis (Psya.D.) in Psychoanalysis and Culture INTRODUCTION The doctoral dissertation is an integral part of both Psya.D.
SOE GUIDELINES FOR APA STYLE SOE PD 32 FOR PAPERS, THESES AND DISSERTATIONS School of Education Colorado State University This document has three major sections: differences between APA and SOE styles,
RUNNING HEAD: Five or Six Word Phrase from Title Though Not Whole Subtitle This is Where the Title Goes Date Author Name Department Affiliation University Affiliation ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS For their help and
CSE543 - Introduction to Computer and Network Security Module: Security Research Methods Professor Patrick McDaniel Fall 2011 1 Reading papers What is the purpose of reading papers? How do you read papers?
COMPONENTS OF A RESEARCH ARTICLE Beth A. Fischer and Michael J. Zigmond Survival Skills and Ethics Program Title Purpose: To attract readers interested in this field of study. The importance of the title
Tips for Writing a Research Manuscript for the Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research According to Dr. William J. Kraemer, Editor-In-Chief of the Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research, the
APA Style This handout is based on the 6 th edition of the Publication Manual of the American Psychological Association (APA), but is not a comprehensive guide. For all rules and requirements of APA citations,
Journals in Developmental Psychology Developmental Journals What makes a journal developmental? What makes your research developmental? Examples of appropriate content as defined by the journal Child Development
AP Psychology Course Syllabus and Survival Guide Mr. Koch email@example.com 651 982 8550 Course website: http://hs.forestlake.k12.mn.us/staff_sites/dan_koch_home/koch_ap_psychology/ Wiki page:
Writing Essays A GOOD ESSAY CONTAINS: 1. An introductory paragraph 2. A clear thesis statement 3. A body consisting of supporting paragraphs 4. A concluding paragraph Step 1: Review Assignment Read the
BCMB 496: BIOCHEMISTRY/MOLECULAR BIOLOGY SENIOR RESEARCH Course Description Biochemistry/Molecular Biology senior research is a two-semester long independent research project that culminates in the submission
Lesson Plan 1: Research paper Writing: An Overview Objectives: -SWBAT identify parts that comprise a scientific research paper -SWBAT understand some different ways scientists develop ideas for their research
The Psychology Lab Checklist By: Danielle Sclafani 08 and Stephanie Anglin 10; Updated by: Rebecca Behrens 11 1. Title Page My title is informative, mentioning both the independent and dependent variable(s).
Publishing, Presenting, and Building your Professional Reputation Dr. Lynn Mazzoleni, Dept. of Chemistry Dr. Shari Stockero, Dept. of Cognitive & Learning Sciences Dr. Aurenice Oliveira, School of Technology
BACKGROUND OF THE PROBLEM SECTION WHAT DO YOU NEED TO CONSIDER? This section is like the free style competition in gymnastics. While there are certain things that you must do, the manner in which you prepare
University of Connecticut Writing Center Writing a Psychology Literature Review There are two main approaches to a literature review in psychology. One approach is to choose an area of research, read all