1 28 Alcohol consumption and life insurance Dr. Kevin Somerville, MD Swiss Reinsurance Company Global Life & Health Underwriting, London Dr. sc. nat. Beatrice Baldinger Swiss Reinsurance Company Life & Health Products, Zürich Abstract Alcohol use is common. The culture of drinking differs substantially between societies and the mortality and morbidity risk depends upon the circumstances in which alcohol is taken as well as the quantity and pattern of consumption. There are two defined excess alcohol use syndromes, alcohol abuse (DSMIV)/harmful use (ICD10) and the more severe alcohol dependence (DSMIV and ICD10). The additional concept of hazardous drinking is frequently used to describe excessive alcohol use which is potentially injurious to health; in this the morbidity and mortality risks are increased but there is none of the physical, social or psychological effects associated with alcohol abuse/harmful use or dependence. Clinical and epidemiological studies show that the acute effects of alcohol excess (intoxication) are of particular importance in the young and that episodic heavy alcohol use (binge drinking) is more problematic than regular modest to high alcohol intake. Obtaining evidence about such a pattern of alcohol use is not straightforward and insurance application forms often do not ask. Alcohol intake is not without its benefits. The incidence of ischaemic heart disease (IHD) appears to be lowered by regular modest alcohol use and this is of particular relevance in high cardiovascular disease risk areas. This has an impact on critical illness risk assessment especially in older men where increased cancer and neuropsychiatric risk is offset, at least in part, by the lower IHD risk. Furthermore, modest alcohol intake is also used as part of social discourse and even business deals. Risk assessment needs to be placed in the context of the individual as well as society particularly as alcohol abuse/ dependence may be difficult to identify. However, once alcohol dependence has been diagnosed the mortality and morbidity risks are very high and only those with a well documented and sustained
2 29 recovery will be eligible for an offer of insurance. Introduction Alcohol use is widespread and common. Excessive alcohol use is regarded as a major health public hazard. The World Health Organisation (WHO) ranks harmful use of alcohol as the fifth leading risk factor for premature death and disability in the world. It estimated that worldwide in 2002 at least 2.3 million people died of alcohol-related causes (3.8% of global mortality) and that alcohol consumption caused 4.6% of the global burden of disease. The Institute for Alcohol studies in the UK estimates that the estimated social costs of alcohol are between 1% and 3% of GDP and for the European Union in 1998 are between $65 and $195 billion at 1990 prices, comparable to government expenditures on social security and welfare, and approximating to 25% of health service expenditure. The acute and chronic unwanted effects of high alcohol intake affect society, the family and the individual and these have been subdivided into: 1. Acute intoxication: accidents, suicide, inappropriate behaviour, family and social impact, and poor work performance. 2. Chronic excessive use: liver disease, neurological disorders, cardiomyopathy, family and social impact, unemployment, and poor work performance. In general, unintentional injuries associated with acute intoxication contribute most to alcohol-attributable mortality while neuropsychiatric disorders caused by chronic alcohol use contributed most to alcohol-attributable disease. The two defined clinical syndromes that reflect these problems are alcohol abuse/harmful use and alcohol dependence. Both the DSM IV and ICD 10 have similar definitions for alcohol dependence but the criteria for the less severe category of alcohol abuse (DSM IV) or harmful use (ICD 10) differ. The ICD10 category of harmful use is not specific to alcohol but is used for all psychoactive substances where use or excessive use causes harm. Broadly, alcohol dependence equates to the problems of chron-
3 30 ic use and alcohol abuse/harmful use to the acute effects of repeated overuse although there is considerable overlap. None of the definitions include the quantity of alcohol consumed as a guide or one of the essential criteria for diagnosis. The emphasis is upon the effects of alcohol use upon the health, performance and social network of the affected individual. Rehm et al (2004) provide a broad diagrammatic representation of the acute and chronic effects of alcohol consumption. However, the effects of alcohol consumption and its role in society are not universally deleterious; alcoholic beverages are ubiquitous and have a major role in social discourse as well as a cardioprotective effect in those at risk of ischaemic heart disease (IHD). How is alcohol consumption measured? Because there is a broad relationship between the pattern of alcohol use and the development of adverse effects, authorities have attempted to categorise both the acceptable and the potentially injurious levels of alcohol use in terms of the average drink or quantity of alcohol consumed. However, the social circumstances in which alcohol is used (taken with meals or standing at a bar, emphasis on drinking as distinct from emphasis on socialisation) appear to have a major modifying effect. The amount of alcohol consumed can be quantified by weight (grams) or by volume (litres of pure alcohol). However, this is not straightforward as the concentration of alcohol varies between and within drink classes (beer, wine, spirits); there is no easy linear relationship between the type of alcohol consumed along with the volume served with the quantity of alcohol consumed. The variation within typical different drink classes for a standardised serving is shown in the table (Table 1, P. 31). To compound the difficulty the average or standard drink volume varies between countries; this is frequently set by the average serving in the country concerned. No internationally recognised set of standards has been adopted. The table below shows the average or standard drink in a range of countries (Table 2, P. 31).
4 31 Table 1 Alcohol type Alcohol serving Metric measure Grams of alcohol Wine 1 glass 125 ml 8 12 Wine 1 bottle 750 ml Mid strength beer 1 pint 587 ml 16 Spirits 1 measure (1/5 gill) 30 ml 8 10 Spirits 1 bottle 750 ml Table 2 Country Alcohol measure Grams of alcohol United Kingdom, Ireland Unit 8 Netherlands Standard drink 9.9 Australia, Austria, Italy, New Zealand, Standard drink 10 Poland, Spain Finland Standard drink 11 Denmark, France, South Africa Standard drink 12 Canada Standard drink 13.6 USA, Portugal Standard drink 14 Japan (males) Standard drink There are substantial differences between countries when average per capita consumption of alcohol is measured. In some predominantly Islamic countries the restricted availability of alcohol and the prevailing social and religious mores mean that alcohol intake is uncommon. Even in Europe the area that has the highest per capita alcohol intake in the world there are major inter-country differences ranging from Norway 4.4 l to Luxemburg at 11.9 l in However, particularly in Eastern European countries, a substantial amount of alcohol consumption is unrecorded. These differences bedevil observational studies of the effect of alcohol on acute
5 32 and chronic disease particularly as they usually rely upon self report; there are no randomised controlled trials! Broadly, those who abstain from alcohol are compared with those who use alcohol. There are inherent problems with such observational studies and questionnaires which include: 1. As noted above, different alcoholic beverages have variable concentrations of alcohol so quantification is difficult. 2. Studies use different standards of measurement of consumption such as blood alcohol concentration or estimates of the amount of alcohol consumed. The same term eg drink or unit can be used for different amounts of pure alcohol; authors are not always consistent. 3. Alcohol use is frequently assessed by very few questions; frequently the pattern of use is not measured despite binge drinking appearing to be particularly hazardous. Insurance companies use non-standardised questionnaires which ask about average intake over days or weeks. 4. Alcohol use may change over time. 5. Recall bias may occur amongst those questioned about their drinking hab- its. Asked to recall a typical day an interviewee is apt to state the intake on an atypical (low volume ) day. 6. The effect of alcohol could theoretically vary by beverage type eg does red wine have a greater beneficial effect on CVD than other types of alcoholic beverage? 7. Those who abstain belong to a heterogenous group which contains lifelong abstainers, reformed alcoholics, and those who have been advised to abstain for other health reasons (eg to avoid alcohol/pharmaceutical interactions). Few studies have attempted to correct for this unhealthy abstainer bias. 8. Societal differences in the type and quantity of alcohol consumed; cultural influences seem to modify whether alcohol related health & social problems occur. 9. Alcohol use may be associated with other potentially confounding factors. The most important of these are: a. Smoking: alcohol abuse/harmful use and alcohol dependence are strongly correlated with cigarette smoking and without accounting for smoking the morbidity and mortality risk estimates for alcohol will
6 33 be inflated. b. Social class: alcohol consumption especially moderate alcohol intake is more common amongst the middle classes. c. Diet: This influences both average intake and pattern of alcohol use (Breslow et al, 2006). d. Cardiovascular risk factors: blood pressure is higher in those who take excessive amounts of alcohol. A different and sometimes lowered prevalence of other associated cardiovascular risk factors such as obesity, diabetes mellitus, and physical activity can also act as confounding factors, ie it is these rather than the alcohol intake that are directly responsible for the ill health (Naimi et al, 2005). 10. The poor reliability of the diagnosis of the alcohol abuse (DSMIV) and harmful use (ICD10) syndromes; this correlates with the poor reliability of the current risk stratification systems. Alcohol: beneficial and harmful effects Moderate alcohol use has been shown to have beneficial effects on many cardiovascular diseases although some of this may be artifactual, a result of poor recognition of and control for important confounding factors (Jackson R et al, 2005). In part this is because alcohol use appears to be associated with a lower prevalence of important cardiovascular risk factors such as obesity, diabetes mellitus, physical activity although hypertension is more common (Naimi et al, 2005). However, studies in many countries, some of which have controlled for the unhealthy alcohol abstainer effect, have consistently shown that modest alcohol use reduces cardiovascular mortality. By contrast, the association of alcohol excess with acute and chronic problems such as accidents, suicide, psychosis, various types of cancer, liver disease, pancreatitis, cardiomyopathy, and brain disorders is well documented and of major public health and societal concern. Rehm et al (2004) produced an outline of the protective and adverse effects of alcohol. What are the safe levels of alcohol intake? Research comparing countries in North America and Europe has produced a classic subdivision into wet and dry
7 34 cultures. In the former, alcohol is integrated into daily life, in particular wine at meal times, and abstinence is uncommon. In the latter, access to alcohol is less integrated, use of alcohol is more frequently associated with excess and intoxication, and beer rather than wine is the beverage of choice. However, this distinction is disappearing with harmonisation of drinking patterns within Europe apart from the recent notable exception of Eastern Europe where excessive alcohol intake has become a major social problem. This phenomenon is occurring to a lesser extent within the remnants of the dry culture in Northern European countries such as the UK and Ireland. Other measures of alcohol use to average daily intake such as the pattern of drinking especially binge drinking and the frequency of drunkenness have also been introduced into some national guidelines. In dry cultures binge drinking is more common, beer and spirits predominate, and the risk to the population per unit of alcohol appears greater (Rehm, 2001). or desirable levels of consumption based upon grams of alcohol have been produced. Published risk level recommendations by the amount of alcohol consumed include the following: World Health Organisation (WHO, 2000): Criteria for risk of consumption on a single drinking day WHO recommend that this be used for comparative research purposes only Category Males Females Low Risk 1 to 40g 1 to 20g Medium Risk 41 to 60g 21 to 40g High Risk 61 to 100g 41 to 60g Very High Risk 101+g 61+g The number of standard drinks corresponding to these thresholds varies (see above). In both the academic literature and publications issued by a number of government agencies in many countries safe
8 35 The WHO criteria appear to be based upon a paper by Rehm et al in the International Journal of Epidemiology in This group have published extensively on the subject of alcohol risk, their criteria are as follows: Category Males Females Abstention and very light drinking Low Risk Hazardous drinking Harmful drinking g pure ethanol per day g pure ethanol per day 2.6 to 40g 2.6 to 20g 40.1 to 60g 60g 20.1 to 40g 40g Hazardous drinking is regarded as putting the user at risk for adverse effects whereas harmful drinking is associated with physical, mental or social damage and conforms more closely to the alcohol abuse/harmful use syndromes defined by DSM IV and WHO respectively. Harmful/ hazardous drinking Males 50 g, 7 days per week or 70 g, 4-6 days per week or 120 g, 2 3 days per week Binge drinking 70 g no more than 1 day per week Heavy drinking Moderate drinking 50 g usually Less than those above Females 30 g, 4 days per week or 50 g, 2 3 days per week or 60 g, 2 days per week 50 g no more than 1 day per week 30 g usually Less than those above Makkai & McAllister (Australia), 1998 produced a set of recommendations which include binge drinking and also took the pattern of drinking into account:
9 36 The National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism (NIAAA), USA, has adopted the following guidelines: Heavy drinking: Males ( 65 years) Females or males ( 65 years) 5 drinks (60 g) in one day or 14 drinks (168 g) in one week ie an average of 2 drinks (24 g) per day 4 drinks (48 g) in one day or 8 drinks (96 g) in one week ie an average of 1.2 drinks (14 g) per day In the United Kingdom the recommended safe limits are 3 4 units (24 32 g) per day for a man and 2 3 units (16 24 g) per day for a woman. In summary, there are substantial differences to recommendations about safe limits of alcohol intake in the approach taken by governments and pub- lic health bodies and no clear relationship between the pattern or volume of alcohol consumed and the diagnosis of the alcohol syndromes. Screening for alcohol abuse Alcohol questionnaires The NIAAA recommends either a single screening question: How many times in the past year have you had 5 or more drinks (4 or more for a woman) on a single occasion or the more comprehensive AUDIT screening questionnaire before asking further questions about pattern of alcohol use or symptoms indicating abuse or dependence. The AUDIT (Alcohol Use Disorder Identification Test) produced by WHO in 1989 has ten questions about the quantity as well as pattern and experience of alcohol use. Two supplementary questions are asked about alcohol related injury (self or others) and advice to cut-down alcohol intake. While it has reasonable sensitivity and specificity for the detection of hazardous drinking or alcohol abuse, it is predominantly used in research settings or in specialty clinics rather than as a population screening
10 37 tool. A simpler more practical form of the AUDIT using 3 questions (AUDIT- C) has been produced and preliminary studies suggest that there is little loss of utility but it has not been well studied. These questions are How often did you have a drink containing alcohol in the past year? How many drinks did you have on a typical day when you were drinking in the past year? How often did you have 6 or more drinks on one occasion in the past year? A short questionnaire alternative is the CAGE questionnaire; an acronym based upon the 4 questions asked: Have you ever felt the need to Cut down on drinking? Have you ever felt Annoyed by criticism of your drinking? Have you ever had Guilty feelings about your drinking? Do you ever take a morning Eye opener (a drink first thing in the morning to steady your nerves or get rid of a hangover)? Although commendably short, it has been criticized as lacking sensitivity. The unsatisfactory role of and difficul- ty with questionnaire based screening is apparent from the number of screening instruments available with a wide variety of title or acronyms: MAST; TWEAK, T-ACE, CRAFFT However, insurance application forms which typically contain just one question about average alcohol intake have not been formally studied as to their sensitivity or specificity. The positive and negative predictive value of screening questionnaires depends upon the prevalence of hazardous drinking and alcohol abuse/ dependence in the population being asked and information about this in turn mostly comes from the questionnaires themselves. Evidence that should raise the suspicion of an alcohol problem include convictions for drunk driving, martial breakdown, job loss or frequent absenteeism, arrest by the police for an alcohol related offence, repeated falls with or without fracture, and physical problems which raise the possibility of alcohol excess. These last include such as pancreatitis or cardiac problems including paroxysmal atrial fibrillation.
11 38 As screening tests in insurance applicants routine blood tests have a very low yield and in a population at low risk of alcohol abuse the potential for a high false positive rate. However, these can be useful if there is a feature suspicious for excessive alcohol use in the past or current history. Routine laboratory tests which increase the likelihood of an alcohol problem include unexplained macrocystosis, a high HDL cholesterol, elevated triglycerides and elevated liver function tests, in particular the gamma glutamyl transpeptidase (GGT). While all of these tests are non-specific, in a context where alcohol abuse has been considered they help to raise or lower the possibility. In the past GGT has been discounted as a major mortality risk factor but recent research from insurance laboratories in the USA suggest that it is a better mortality marker than ALT or AST; some of this could be related to alcohol abuse increasing the level of the enzyme. Alcohol markers such as carbohydrate deficient transferrin (CDT) and haemoglobin acetaldehyde (HAA) are extensively used as reflex tests for heavy alcohol use by insurance applicants in North America. The sensitivity of CDT for alcohol problems is about 70% and the false positive rate is about 15% which is not good enough for a population of low prior probability of alcohol abuse. The performance of the HAA is not as good as the CDT but the latter is a better reflex screening test than GGT or HDL cholesterol. Chronic Effects of alcohol There are numerous summaries of the relative risks for individual diseases in the clinical literature for given levels of alcohol intake. That of Corrao et al (1999) is widely quoted; these authors also produced a follow up report in 2004 where their database was extended to publications up until The table below gives a summary of the relative risks (RRs) for IHD, stroke and various cancers for various levels of average alcohol intake estimated from the 1999 Corrao report by Britton & McPherson (2001) for average alcohol intake up to 50 grams per day. The full list of Corrao et al (1999 & 2004) estimates is too extensive to be reproduced in this paper.
12 39 Alcohol consumption Disorder None 1 10 g/day* g/day g/day g/day g/day IHD men 1 (referent) IHD women Colon cancer Breast cancer Haemorrhagic stroke *Midpoint in each category used to calculate relative risks. Taken from Britton A and McPherson K 2001 and based upon Corrao et al, 1999 The relative risk estimates given by Corrao et al, 2004, include measures up to 100g of alcohol per day: RR and 95% CI compared to non-drinkers 25g/day 50g/day 100 g/day RR 95%CI RR 95%CI RR 95%CI Colon Rectum Liver Breast IHD Ischaemic stroke Haemorrhagic stroke Cirrhosis An extensive overview on chronic alcohol use and individual diseases was included in the original article. The full version can be obtained from the authors.
13 40 Summary of the acute adverse effects of alcohol: There is a substantial and verified increase in the risk of trauma and traumatic death and disability as a result of heavy drinking and there is some evidence that even modest intakes reduce reaction times and increase in motor vehicle accident rates. Drowning, sudden cardiac death and dysrhythmia are more common after episodic heavy drinking especially if on a background of low average use of alcohol. However in many cultures, episodes of heavy drinking are common especially in young adults which reduces the discriminatory power of this phenomenon. It is only when alcohol intake either as a high daily intake or a pattern of binge drinking, affects the individual s health and social discourse including the ability to work satisfactorily that an alcohol related problem can be identified. Alcohol syndromes and all cause mortality Insurance studies Alcohol abuse and liver enzymes: results of an intercompany study of mortality (Cliff Titcomb) JIM 2001; 33: This is a pooled study of (after exclusions; 131'394 were originally considered) policies issued between 1989 and 1995 with exposure until the 1997 anniversary. Maximum exposure was 8 years; average years. The Medical Insurance Bureau (MIB) database was searched for one of 4 diagnostic codes: alcohol use significant to health and longevity; adverse driving record or multiple moving violations; abnormal transaminases; and abnormal GGT. As exposure in females was low (9.5% of claims) the analysis was restricted to males. Because the numbers of those with both abnormal LFTs, and alcohol and/or driving problems were low an analysis of individuals with both was not carried out (it is likely that most of these had been declined an offer of insurance). The basis for expected mortality was the Basic Table (BT). For those men with a rating of either abnormal alcohol use or driving problems (and normal LFTs), a standard rating was associated with a mortality ratio (MR) of 217, a substandard 175- there was no age gradient. Mortality ratios were highest when the face amount was less than $50,000 and in smokers:
14 41 Smoker status: Actual deaths Expected Deaths MR Unknown % Non % Smoker Smoker % Total % Although not stated BT had a smoker/non-smoker split so that the expected deaths recorded above are unlikely to be based upon aggregate mortality data. The MIB codes do not correlate absolutely with either of the clinically defined alcohol syndromes but the cases above represent a combination of alcohol abuse and alcohol dependence. Titcomb commented that the observed high MRs with low face amount and smoking probably represented behavioural and socio-economic factors; in addition those with larger sums assured were more likely to be medically scrutinised. These data suggest that the risk in non-smokers is substantially lower than in smokers. Unfortunately there is no age stratification for the alcohol syndromes; but there is an age breakdown for the entire group (abnormal LFTs and alcohol). There was no clear reduction in the MR with increasing age. This may represent a differential pattern of alcohol associated mortality with acute intoxication predisposing to accidental death in the young and chronic alcohol abuse/dependence causing physical and mental disorders in older people. Single Medical Impairment Study (SMIS) and Multiple Medical Impairment Study (MMIS), 1983 Unfortunately there is no smoker / nonsmoker stratification in this dataset and as female exposure to major alcohol misuse is about 4% of the whole, only MR for males were reported. For those rated standard the MR was 208%; for substandard lives the MR was 243%. Alcohol misuse was defined as persons who misused alcohol by regular heavy use, but who are not obvious or admitted alcoholics. A small number of dry former alcoholics were included. The importance of confounding by smoking is suggested by the MRs of 149 and 197 for heart/circulatory disease in the SMIS and MMIS respectively.
15 42 A trend to reducing MR with age was observed in both studies: Issue age SMIS MMIS % 533% % 380% % 288% % 240% % 206% A further analysis of the SMIS with weighting the combined standard & substandard policies in the ratio of 4 to 1 to reflect the proportions of the insurance issued showed MRs for all durations and ages of 226% in males and 334% in females (Medical Risks: abstract 327). Issue age Males Females % 254% % 280% % 632% % % Total Summary insurance studies: The studies are heterogenous and not well defined. Risk estimates vary from no increase to a modest increase in the mortality ratio. Smoking is a confounder which has been poorly controlled for. Clinical studies: Alcohol dependence and alcohol abuse/ harmful use (alcoholism) and mortality have not been extensively studied. The one exception is the alcohol dependent admitted to hospital. Alcohol dependence Although individual studies do not have large numbers of patients these studies show that alcoholics abstaining from alcohol have a lower mortality than those who relapse or continue to drink. All of these studies show a high mortality rate amongst alcoholics. For example Gerdner & Berglund (1997) showed an 8.5 year cumulative mortality of 76% (annualised mortality of 32 per mille) in male alcoholics (average age 41 years) who were treated as inpatients. None of those who abstained from alcohol died during follow up. A similar finding of improved outcomes in treated male alcoholics abstaining (stable abstainers) from alcohol comes from the VA Center in San Diego (Bullock et al, 1992). Stable abstainers had similar 11 year mortality (HR 1.25) as a cohort of age & race matched men from the general population whereas relapsers had a significant mortality ratio of 5.
16 43 Alcohol abuse Unfortunately, mortality associated with the recently defined syndrome of alcohol abuse/harmful use has not been well studied. In general, clinical studies tend to be based upon average alcohol use rather than the clinical syndromes of alcohol abuse/dependence. Useful reviews of all cause mortality and levels of alcohol use have been carried out by the Australian Institute of Health and Welfare (Single at al, 1999), and by Rehm et al (2003). In addition, White et al, 2002, modelled alcohol consumption and mortality for both sexes by age. A longitudinal study of male doctors in the UK compared lifelong abstainers with quitters (ie controlled for stopping alcohol because of illness which might confound the all cause mortality and disease specific mortality rates) (Doll et al, 2005) and is worth considering as are a mathematical modelling study (Bagnardi et al, 2004), a report from the cancer prevention study in the USA (Thun et al, 1997), There are few studies which investigate the pattern of alcohol intake, intermittent vs binge drinking vs sustained excessive use. An extension of the Whitehall II cohort study (Brit- ton & Marmot, 2004) investigated the pattern of use as did a report from the US National Alcohol survey (Rehm et al, 2001). Mortality Studies based upon the volume of Alcohol Consumption While there is considerable heterogeneity between the studies there is consensus that the all cause mortality risk curve is J shaped in most populations and that the nadir of the J is lowest in populations where the cardiovascular risk is high so that any protective effect of alcohol is higher in men and in older individuals. Episodic heavy drinking despite a low or modest background intake of alcohol also increases the mortality risk. Summary of the clinical mortality studies These are heterogenous but show limited increases in risk up to an intake of 60 g per day in males and 40 g per day in females. Heavy episodic drinking appears to as, if not much more, important than average intake especially in the young with high accident rate and
17 44 A paper from the same authors showed that the probability of receiving a disability pension and sickness absence in young men is directly related to criminal behaviour and drink driving convica significant increase in mortality which is independent of the average daily consumption. How much of this is already included in the baseline pricing is uncertain but a substantial amount of such risk taking behaviour is. Disability There are few formal studies of levels of alcohol intake and disability rates. Both the alcohol syndromes are defined in disability terms so that the presence of these equates to a diagnosis of disability. Upmark et al (1999) found that increasing levels of alcohol intake were associated with higher rates of disability pension uptake and more days off work. Their study was based upon data from the Stockholm Health of the Population Study and used 3 different measures of alcohol habits: usual alcohol consumption, consumption during the previous week, and answers to the four CAGE questions on problem drinking. Information from the health survey and data from a subsequent health examination were related to information from the National Swedish Social Insurance Board for the year 1984 and the years 1986 to 1991 concerning sick leave and disability pensioning. The study population was aged 20 to 52 years in 1984 and comprised 985 women and 870 men fulfilling the criteria for inclusion out of 6217 subjects aged 18 years and over randomly drawn. In both sexes, a consistent pattern of increased sickness absence was seen for high alcohol consumers and for those with indications of problem drinking. In most comparisons, a clearly increased relative risk, although not always statistically significant, for an average of at least 60 sick days per year or for a disability pension during follow up was found. In multivariate analysis, controlling for age, socioeconomic group, smoking habits, and self reported health, a small reduction in the relative risks was found, suggesting that these factors could explain only a small part of the relative risks. The risks for abstainers were higher than for low and moderate consumers.
18 45 tions. In bivariate regression analysis, drink driving implied a relative risk (RR) of a disability pension/high sickness absence of 3.4 (95% CI: ), and criminality a RR of 3.6 (95% CI: ). In multivariate logistic regression analysis, controlling for psychosocial factors from conscription and for criminality, drink driving remained a strong predictor (RR 2.1, 95% CI: ) (Upmark et al, 1999). Conclusion The risk associated with alcohol excess is complex, heterogenous and difficult to quantify. Alcohol use is almost ubiquitous and in some cultures heavy episodic drinking (binge drinking) is common. Furthermore there are social benefits as well as health benefits such as a lower incidence of IHD so that the background levels of risk are impor- tant. However excessive use of alcohol is an important cause or mortality and morbidity. The syndrome of alcohol dependence is now well established but the disorder may go unrecognised. Using self reported alcohol intake can be unreliable and the diagnosis of alcohol abuse/harmful use is often one of inference. However, despite these difficulties broad conclusions about the risks associated with alcohol excess can be made. The choice of comparator is of interest. Traditionally the reference group has been abstainers but except in some societies abstention from alcohol is uncommon and the nadir of mortality and morbidity risk is about to 10 g alcohol per day especially if the incidence of cardiovascular disease is high. Abstainers are not representative of the insured or general population.
19 46 References: 1. Rehm J, Room R, Monteiro M, Gmel G, Graham K, Rehn N, Sempos C T, Frick U, Jernigan D, Alcohol use. In: Ezzati M, Lopez AD, Rodgers A, Murray CJL (eds). Comparative Quantification of Health Risks: Global and Regional burden of disease due to selected Major Risk Factors. Volume 1 Geneva. World Health Organisation 2004, pp Breslow R A, Guenther P M, Smothers B A. Alcohol Drinking Patterns and Diet Quality: The National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey Am J. Epidemiol. 2006; 163: ) 3. Naimi TS, Brown DW, Brewer RD, et al. Cardiovascular risk factors and confounders among nondrinking and moderate-drinking U.S. adults. AmJ Prev Med 2005; 28: Jackson R, Broad J, Connor J, Wells S, Alcohol and ischaemic heart disease: probably no free lunch Lancet 2005; 366(9501): Rehn N et al, Alcohol in the European Region consumption, harm and policies. World Health Organization Regional Office for Europe WHO; International Guide for monitoring Alcohol Consumption and Related Harm; Geneva: WHO, Department of Mental Health and Substance Dependence, Health Survey for England 1998 Cardiovascular Disease (available at doh/survey98/hse98.htm) accessed 9 May, Rehm J Greenfield TK, Walsh G, Xie X, Robson L, Single E Assessment methods for alcohol consumption, prevalence of high risk drinking and harm: a sensitivity analysis. Int J Epidemiol. 1999; 28: Makkai, T. and McAllister, I. (1998) Patterns of drug use in Australia Canberra: National Drug Strategy, Commonwealth Department of Health and Family Services, Commonwealth of Australia 10. National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism (1999) NIAAA-recommended year 2000 alcohol guidelines Binge.html (accessed 9 May, 2006)
20 (accessed 8 May 2006) 13. American Psychiatric Association Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (4th ed.) (DSM-IV). Washington, D.C.: APA. 14. Corrao et al, Bagnardi V, Zambon A, Arico S Exploring the dose-response relationship between alcohol consumption and the risk of several alcohol-related conditions: a meta-analysis. Addiction Oct; 94(10): SOA/AAIM/HOLUA-IHOU Mortality and Morbidity Liaison Committee and MIB I. Medical Impairment Study: volume 1. 1 ed: CNAS books of, MIB INC; SOA/AAIM/HOLUA-IHOU Mortality and Morbidity Liaison Committee and MIB I. Multiple Medical Impairment Study. Westwood, MA: CMAS Books of MIB; Gerdner A, Berglund M, Mortality of treated alcoholics after eight years in relation to short-term outcome Alcohol Alcohol. 1997; 32: Britton A and McPherson K Mortality in England and Wales attributable to current alcohol consumption J Epidemiol Community Health 2001; 55: Corrao G, Bagnardi V, Zambon A, La Vecchia C A meta-analysis of alcohol consumption and the risk of 15 diseases. Prev Med. 2004; 38: Titcomb C Alcohol abuse and liver enzymes: results of an intercompany study of mortality JIM 2001; 33: Bullock KD, Reed RJ, Grant I. Reduced mortality risk in alcoholics who achieve longterm abstinence, JAMA. 1992; 267: Single E, Ashley MJ, Bondy S, Rankin J, Rehm J Evidence regarding the level of alcohol consumption considered to be low-risk for men and women. Final report submitted to the Australian Commonwealth Department of Health and Aged Care, October Rehm J, Gmel G, Sempos C T, Trevisan M Alcohol-related morbidity and mortality. Alcohol Res Health. 2003; 27(1):39-5 (2003b)
21 White I, Altmann D, Nanchahaet K Alcohol consumption and mortality: modelling risks for men and women at different ages BMJ 2002; 325; Doll R, Doll R, Peto R, Boreham J, Sutherland I Mortality in relation to alcohol consumption: a prospective study among male British doctors. Int J Epidemiol Feb;34(1): Bagnardi V, Zambon A, Quatto P, Corrao G Flexible meta-regression functions for modeling aggregate dose-response data, with an application to alcohol and mortality.am J Epidemiol Jun 1;159(11): Thun, M.J., Peto, R., Lopez, A.D., Monaco, J.H., Henley, S.J., Heath, C.W.J. and Doll,R. (1997) Alcohol consumption and mortality among middle-aged and elderly U.S. adults. The New England Journal of Medicine 1997; 337: Rehm J, Greenfield T, Rogers J Average volume of alcohol consumption, patterns of drinking, and all-cause mortality: results from the US National Alcohol Survey.Am J Epidemiol. 2001; 153: Upmark M, Möller J, Romelsjö A Longitudinal, population-based study of self reported alcohol habits, high levels of sickness absence, and disability pensions. J Epidemiol Community Health 1999; 53: Upmark M, Karlsson G, Romelsjö A. Drink driving and criminal behaviours as risk factors for receipt of disability pension and sick leave: a prospective study of young men. Addiction 1999; 94: Britton A & Marmot M Different measures of alcohol consumption and risk of coronary heart disease and all-cause mortality: 11-year follow-up of the Whitehall II Cohort Study. Addiction Jan;99(1):109-16
Alcohol Units A brief guide 1 2 Alcohol Units A brief guide Units of alcohol explained As typical glass sizes have grown and popular drinks have increased in strength over the years, the old rule of thumb
Key trends nationally and locally in relation to alcohol consumption and alcohol-related harm November 2013 1 Executive Summary... 3 National trends in alcohol consumption and alcohol-related harm... 5
Risk of alcohol Peter Anderson MD, MPH, PhD, FRCP Professor, Alcohol and Health, Maastricht University Netherlands Zurich, 4 May 2011 Lifetime risk of an alcoholrelated death (1/100) 16.0 14.0 12.0 10.0
guideline for identification and treatment of alcohol abuse/dependence in primary care This guideline is informational in nature and is not intended to be a substitute for professional clinical judgment.
Screening Patients for Substance Use in Your Practice Setting Learning Objectives By the end of this session, participants will Understand the rationale for universal screening. Identify potential health
Alcohol Overuse and Abuse ACLI Medical Section CME Meeting February 23, 2015 Daniel Z. Lieberman, MD Professor and Vice Chair Department of Psychiatry George Washington University Alcohol OVERVIEW Definitions
Consumption of alcoholic beverages; evaluation of cancer hazards Robert A Baan PhD The IARC MONOGRAPHS International Agency for Research on Cancer Lyon, France The IARC Monographs The IARC Monographs are
http://nurse practitioners and physician assistants.advanceweb.com/features/articles/alcohol Abuse.aspx Alcohol Abuse By Neva K.Gulsby, PA-C, and Bonnie A. Dadig, EdD, PA-C Posted on: April 18, 2013 Excessive
How to keep health risks from drinking alcohol to a low level: public consultation on proposed new guidelines January 2016 2 How to keep health risks from drinking alcohol to a low level: public consultation
Alcohol Facts and Statistics Alcohol Use in the United States: Prevalence of Drinking: In 2012, 87.6 percent of people ages 18 or older reported that they drank alcohol at some point in their lifetime;
Policy Brief Tackling Harmful Alcohol Use Economics and Public Health Policy May 2015 Directorate for Employment, Labour and Social Affairs OECD s new flagship report examines the economic and public health
ARTICLE #1 PLEASE RETURN AT THE END OF THE HOUR Alcoholism By Mayo Clinic staff Original Article: http://www.mayoclinic.com/health/alcoholism/ds00340 Definition Alcoholism is a chronic and often progressive
NHS Swindon and Swindon Borough Council Executive Summary: Adult Alcohol Needs Assessment Aim and scope The aim of this needs assessment is to identify, through analysis and the involvement of key stakeholders,
The cost of physical inactivity October 2008 The cost of physical inactivity to the Australian economy is estimated to be $13.8 billion. It is estimated that 16,178 Australians die prematurely each year
NORTHERN TERRITORY VIEWS ON CGC STAFF DISCUSSION PAPER 2007/17-S ASSESSMENT OF ADMITTED PATIENT SERVICES FOR THE 2010 REVIEW OCTOBER 2007 ADMITTED PATIENT SERVICES Key Points: The Territory supports the
TAJIKISTAN SOCIOECONOMIC CONTEXT Total population 6,640,000 Annual population growth rate 1.3% Population 15+ years 61% Adult literacy rate 99.5% Population in urban areas 25% Income group (World bank)
Statistical Bulletin National Life Tables, United Kingdom, 2011-2013 Coverage: UK Date: 25 September 2014 Geographical Area: Country Theme: Population Key Points A newborn baby boy could expect to live
AZERBAIJAN SOCIOECONOMIC CONTEXT Total population 8,406,000 Annual population growth rate 0.6% Population 15+ years 76% Adult literacy rate 98.8% Population in urban areas 52% Income group (World bank)
Alcohol Screening and Brief Interventions of Women Competency #2 Midwest Regional Fetal Alcohol Syndrome Training Center Competency 2: Screening and Brief Interventions This competency addresses preventing
Does referral from an emergency department to an alcohol treatment center reduce subsequent emergency room visits in patients with alcohol intoxication? Robert Sapien, MD Department of Emergency Medicine
ONS - Defining alcohol-related deaths Note: This document was used for discussion with selected topic experts between November 2005 and January 2006. Release on National Statistics website: 18 July 2006
C o n s u m e r Q & A 1 California Society of Addiction Medicine (CSAM) Consumer Q&As Q: Is addiction a disease? A: Addiction is a chronic disorder, like heart disease or diabetes. A chronic disorder is
Southern Grampians & Glenelg Shires COMMUNITY PROFILE Contents: 1. Health Status 2. Health Behaviours 3. Public Health Issues 4. References This information was last updated on 14 February 2007 1. Health
4 MORTALITY Bridget Robson, Gordon Purdie Key points There were 2,650 deaths a year on average among Màori during 2000 2004. A third occurred in middle age (45 64 years) and 40% among those aged 65 years
. Alcohol Focus Scotland. Response to Tackling poverty, Inequality and deprivation in Scotland Introduction Problem drinking and social groupings. Alcohol prob.lems affect people from all social groups.
Alcohol And Your Health Psychological Medicine Introduction Alcohol, when used in moderation and as part of a healthy lifestyle, can have beneficial effects for some people, particularly in the prevention
The Goal of Substance Abuse Screening The goal of substance abuse screening is to identify individuals who have or are at risk for developing alcohol or drug-related problems, and within that group, identify
CAGE In the past have you ever: C tried to Cut down or Change your pattern of drinking or drug use? A been Annoyed or Angry because of others concern about your drinking or drug use? G felt Guilty about
ALCOHOLISM, ALCOHOL DEPENDENCE AND THE EFFECTS ON YOUR HEALTH. Alcoholism also known as alcohol dependence is a disabling ADDICTIVE DISORDER. It is characterized by compulsive and uncontrolled consumption
Substance Abuse In The Elderly David Meshorer, Ph.D. Psychological Health Roanoke The Invisible Epidemic Substance abuse in the elderly is one of the fastest growing health problems facing the county Even
IAS Factsheet Young people and alcohol Updated May 2013 Young people and alcohol Factsheet Institute of Alcohol Studies Alliance House 12 Caxton Street London SW1H 0QS Tel: 020 7222 4001 Email: email@example.com
Risk factors and public health in Denmark Summary report Knud Juel Jan Sørensen Henrik Brønnum-Hansen Prepared for Risk factors and public health in Denmark Summary report Knud Juel Jan Sørensen Henrik
Alcohol consumption 6 Elizabeth Fuller Summary This chapter presents adults alcohol consumption in several ways: frequency; the maximum amount drunk on any day in the last week; and usual weekly consumption.
Alcohol Guidelines Review Report from the Guidelines development group to the UK Chief Medical Officers January 2016 2 Alcohol Guidelines Review Report from the Guidelines development group to the UK Chief
Ass Professor Frances Kay-Lambkin NHMRC Research Fellow, National Drug and Alcohol Research Centre UNSW Frances Kay-Lambkin PhD National Health and Medical Research Council Research Fellow Substance Use
Alcohol Screening, Brief Intervention and Referral: A Clinical Tool Dr. Ryan Sommers Family Physician Medical Officer of Health, NSHA Dalhousie Family Medicine Refresher Nov 27 th 2015 Disclosures None
Alcohol Quick Facts ALCOHOL FACTS New Zealand s drinking patterns The proportion of New Zealanders aged 15 years or more who drank alcohol in the past year dropped from 84% in 2006/07 to 80% in 2011/12
Economic recession and alcoholrelated harm Peter Anderson Barcelona, 15 June 2010. On the one hand, as incomes reduce, you might expect alcohol consumption to go down But, on the one hand, as dislocation
Facts About Alcohol Addiction Prevention & Treatment Services Table of Contents Facts about alcohol: What is harmful involvement with alcohol?... 2 What is alcohol dependence?... 3 What Is BAC?... 4 What
Alcohol Indicators Report A framework of alcohol indicators describing the consumption of use, patterns of use, and alcohol-related harms in Nova Scotia NOVEMBER 2005 Nova Scotia Health Promotion Addiction
Questions and Answers on Alcohol Consumption What is alcohol? Ethyl alcohol, or ethanol, is a psychoactive drug found in beer, wine, and hard liquor. It is produced by the fermentation of yeast, sugars,
The Adverse Health Effects of Cannabis Wayne Hall National Addiction Centre Kings College London and Centre for Youth Substance Abuse Research University of Queensland Assessing the Effects of Cannabis
Alcohol Guidelines Review Report from the Guidelines development group to the UK Chief Medical Officers (published January 2016 with the consultation on the language and understanding of the UK Chief Medical
Drinking patterns 6 Linda Ng Fat and Elizabeth Fuller Summary This chapter presents data on frequency of drinking alcohol, the amount consumed on the heaviest drinking day in the previous week, and regular
Presents Understanding and Managing Addiction in the Workplace October 8 th, 2013 Mani Alcaide, RN, CPMHN(c) Manager of Intake & Assessment Services Bellwood Health Services Inc. These materials may not
AUSTRALIAN VIETNAM VETERANS Mortality and Cancer Incidence Studies Overarching Executive Summary Study Study A u s t ra l i a n N a t i o n a l S e r v i c e V i e t n a m Ve t e ra n s : M o r t a l i
H E A LT H SURVEY Alcohol Consumption 7 Alcohol Consumption N AT I O N A L Introduction Excessive alcohol consumption is associated with inflammation of the pancreas and damage to the an increased risk
Chapter 7 Screening and Assessment Screening And Assessment Starting the dialogue and begin relationship Each are sizing each other up Information gathering Listening to their story Asking the questions
IAS Factsheet Older people and alcohol Updated May 2013 Older people and alcohol Factsheet Institute of Alcohol Studies Alliance House 12 Caxton Street London SW1H 0QS Tel: 020 7222 4001 Email: firstname.lastname@example.org
Statistical bulletin National Life Tables, United Kingdom: 2012 2014 Trends for the UK and constituent countries in the average number of years people will live beyond their current age measured by "period
Assessment of depression in adults in primary care Adapted from: Identification of Common Mental Disorders and Management of Depression in Primary care. New Zealand Guidelines Group 1 The questions and
Alcohol Awareness: An Orientation Alcohol Facts The most commonly used addictive substance in the United States o 17.6 million people (1 in 12 adults) suffer from alcohol abuse or dependence o Millions
Alcohol Abuse and Liver Enzymes (AALE): Results of an Intercompany Study of Mortality From the Mortality and Morbidity Liaison Committee of the Society of Actuaries (SOA), the American Academy of Insurance
Coronary Heart Disease (CHD) Brief What is Coronary Heart Disease? Coronary Heart Disease (CHD), also called coronary artery disease 1, is the most common heart condition in the United States. It occurs
Comorbidity of mental disorders and physical conditions 2007 Comorbidity of mental disorders and physical conditions, 2007 Australian Institute of Health and Welfare Canberra Cat. no. PHE 155 The Australian
Brief Screening, Intervention, and Referral for Alcohol and Opiate Disorders An Effective Three-Step Process Provider Guidelines The Problem According to the National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism,
A number of studies have attempted to calculate the cost of alcohol to society. This is tricky for two reasons. First, because many of the costs are difficult to estimate accurately. Second, because there
Quick reference guide for health professionals Absolute cardiovascular disease risk assessment This quick reference guide is a summary of the key steps involved in assessing absolute cardiovascular risk
Executive Summary The issue of ascertaining the temporal relationship between problem gambling and cooccurring disorders is an important one. By understanding the connection between problem gambling and
Statistical Bulletin Drinking Habits Amongst Adults, 2012 Coverage: GB Date: 17 December 2013 Geographical Area: Region Theme: Health and Social Care Correction A minor error was found in table 11 of the
HIGH SUCCESS RATE OF BUTTERY REHABILITATION PROGRAMS By treating addiction and helping people live productive, fulfilling lives, The Buttery addresses a major social and economic problem facing our society.
Social inequalities in all cause and cause specific mortality in a country of the African region Silvia STRINGHINI 1, Valentin Rousson 1, Bharathi Viswanathan 2, Jude Gedeon 2, Fred Paccaud 1, Pascal Bovet
Goals of This Course Be able to understand a study design (very basic concept) Be able to understand statistical concepts in a medical paper Be able to perform a data analysis Understanding: PECO study
Aligning action with aims: Optimising the benefits of workplace wellness Dr Michael McCoy Medibank Health Solutions Strategy & Corporate Development Health & Wellbeing September 2011 Aligning action with
Alcohol abuse and smoking Important risk factors for TB? 18 th Swiss Symposium on tuberculosis Swiss Lung Association 26 Mach 2009 Knut Lönnroth Stop TB Department WHO, Geneva Full implementation of Global
Chapter 3 The American Cancer Society Cancer Prevention Study I: 12-Year Followup of 1 Million Men and Women David M. Burns, Thomas G. Shanks, Won Choi, Michael J. Thun, Clark W. Heath, Jr., and Lawrence
Risk Factors for Alcoholism among Taiwanese Aborigines Introduction Like most mental disorders, Alcoholism is a complex disease involving naturenurture interplay (1). The influence from the bio-psycho-social
ALCOHOL CONSUMPTION 399 2.4.7 Effect modification The combined effects of smoking and alcoholic beverage consumption on the development of cancer of the oesophagus have been examined in several studies
COPD IN THE UK Peter Barnes FRS, FMedSci National Heart & Lung Institute Imperial College London, UK MRC-ICMR Workshop on Chronic Diseases Delhi November 2009 Imperial College Royal Brompton Hospital Ischaemic
UK Chief Medical Officers Alcohol Guidelines Review Summary of the proposed new guidelines January 2016 2 UK Chief Medical Officers Alcohol Guidelines Review Summary of the proposed new guidelines 1. This
The Economic Benefits of Risk Factor Reduction in Canada Tobacco Smoking, Excess Weight, Physical Inactivity and Alcohol Use Public Health 2015 May 26, 2015 Risk Factors in High-Income North America Ranked
HEALTH SCRUTINY PANEL 8 TH FEBRUARY 2011 Patterns of Alcohol Consumption Debating Paper The Health Scrutiny Panel agreed the following terms of reference for the review into patterns of alcohol consumption:
Priority Areas of Australian Clinical Health R&D Nick Pappas* CSES Working Paper No. 16 ISSN: 1322 5138 ISBN: 1-86272-552-7 December 1999 *Nick Pappas is a Henderson Research Fellow at the Centre for Strategic
3.2 Leading causes of death in Australia Examining leading causes of death can help us to understand health in different populations and population groups. Exploring changes over time can help us to evaluate
FAQ' s on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism It is important to understand that these answers are not meant to provide specific medical advice, but to provide information to better understand the health consequences
HEALTH EVIDENCE REVIEW COMMISSION (HERC) COVERAGE GUIDANCE: DIAGNOSIS OF SLEEP APNEA IN ADULTS DATE: 5/9/2013 HERC COVERAGE GUIDANCE The following diagnostic tests for Obstructive Sleep Apnea (OSA) should
Page 1 of 5 Alcohol and Sensible Drinking See your doctor or practice nurse if you are drinking above the safe limits and are finding it difficult to cut down. What are the recommended safe limits of alcohol
Doc 2 Doc Dial-in Discussion Series Session 3: Universal Screening for Unhealthy Alcohol and Other Drug (AOD) Use Learning Objectives: (1) Understand the concept of universal screening (2) Learn how to
Presentation to Imperial College London Wednesday 10 th December 2014 Screening and brief intervention for alcohol use in general practice and the potential role of digital technologies in optimising delivery
Health Survey for England 2013 Trend tables 2 A survey carried out on behalf of the Health and Social Care Information Centre Joint Health Surveys Unit Department of Epidemiology and Public Health, UCL
An estimated 25% of the medically underwritten, assured population can be classified as smokers Does smoking impact your mortality? Introduction Your smoking habits influence the premium that you pay for
Type 1 Diabetes W ( Juvenile Diabetes) hat is Type 1 Diabetes? Type 1 diabetes, also known as juvenile-onset diabetes, is one of the three main forms of diabetes affecting millions of people worldwide.
BRIEF SCREENING, INTERVENTION, AND REFERRAL The Problem According to the National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism 3 in 10 adults drink at levels that elevate their risk of physical, mental health,
Big Data for Population Health and Personalised Medicine through EMR Linkages Zheng-Ming CHEN Professor of Epidemiology Nuffield Dept. of Population Health, University of Oxford Big Data for Health Policy
08/09 Locally Enhanced Service for a practice-based Alcohol Monitoring, Withdrawal and Detoxification Service Reference: LES24 Contents: 1. Finance Details 2. Service Aims 3. Service Criteria 4. Ongoing
Your consent to our cookies if you continue to use this website.