Pension Risk Management with Funding and Buyout Options


 Gerard Poole
 1 years ago
 Views:
Transcription
1 Pension Risk Management with Funding and Buyout Options Samuel H. Cox, Yijia Lin, Tianxiang Shi Department of Finance College of Business Administration University of NebraskaLincoln FIRM 2015, Beijing July 45, 2015 Tianxiang Shi (University of NebraskaLincoln) FIRM /24
2 Outline Introduction 1 Introduction Pension Derisking Securitization of Pension Risk with Options 2 Basic Framework 3 Example: Hypothetical Pension Options Sensitivity Analysis Tianxiang Shi (University of NebraskaLincoln) FIRM /24
3 Pension Derisking Introduction Pension Derisking Securitization of Pension Risk with Options In recent years, there has been a surge of interest from defined benefit pension plan sponsors in derisking their plans. Strategies include, longevity hedges and pension buyouts (Lin et al., 2015). Driven by growing pension deficits unprecedented market swings to sustained declines in interest rates; Milliman 100 Pension Funding Index (PFI) decreased to 79.6%, down from 83.5% in December 2014 (Milliman, 2015) unanticipated improvements in mortality rates Tianxiang Shi (University of NebraskaLincoln) FIRM /24
4 Key Pension Derisking Tools Pension Derisking Securitization of Pension Risk with Options Buyout: each individual pensioner is issued a policy so that their pension is provided directly by an insurance company; pension liabilities are completely removed from the pension firm s balance sheet. Longevity hedge: such as a longevity swap, allows a pension plan to transfer its highend longevity risk to a third party, whilst retaining direct control of the assets. Buyouts are more effective in improving firm value under the enterprise risk management framework (Lin et al. 2015). Tianxiang Shi (University of NebraskaLincoln) FIRM /24
5 Challenge of the Buyout Market Pension Derisking Securitization of Pension Risk with Options Buyouts generally have had lower business volume than Longevity swaps in recent years, even though buyouts can create greater value: capital intensive and relatively expensive: In December 2014, the price of a buyout annuity transaction across US, UK, Ireland and Canada was 14% higher on average than the equivalent accounting liability (Mercer LLC, 2014). expensive for firms with underfunded plans: firms have to satisfy a minimum funded status by infusing cash to cover their funding deficits. Tianxiang Shi (University of NebraskaLincoln) FIRM /24
6 Objective and Methodology Pension Derisking Securitization of Pension Risk with Options Objective: to explore welldesigned structures that make buyouts easier, especially for underfunded plans Methodology: propose two gap type options that provide buyout financing. pension funding option and pension buyout option create a transparent pension funding index based on market indices and publicly available mortality tables Tianxiang Shi (University of NebraskaLincoln) FIRM /24
7 Pension Funding Index Pension Derisking Securitization of Pension Risk with Options To increases market liquidity and reduce moral hazard and adverse selection. pension funding index at time t, PFI t, PFI t = PAI t PLI t PLI t : pension liability index based on N(0) retired life cohort aged x 0 at time 0, PLI t = N(t) Pa x0+t t = 1, 2,, where N(t) is the number of survivors at t, P is the annual payment, and a x0+t is the immediate life annuity factor. PAI t : pension asset index Tianxiang Shi (University of NebraskaLincoln) FIRM /24
8 Pension Asset Index Introduction Pension Derisking Securitization of Pension Risk with Options PAI t : determined by the value of a market portfolio composed of I indices at time t. I PAI t = A i,t 1 (1 + r i,t ), i = 1, 2,, I ; t = 1, 2, i=1 A i,t 1 : amount invested in index i at time t 1 r i,t : return of index i in period t PAI 0 : predetermined pension asset with investment weights w i Periodic portfolio adjustment (when t = 1, 2, ) PA t = I A i,t = PAI t + k UL t 1 {ULt>0} N(t)P i=1 UL t : funding deficit UL t = PLI t PAI t + N(t)P k: amortization factor Portfolio rebalance can be easily incorporated. Tianxiang Shi (University of NebraskaLincoln) FIRM /24
9 Pension Options for Fully Funded Plans Pension Derisking Securitization of Pension Risk with Options Pension funding option: to make up funding deficits and reduce external financing cost in order to satisfy a minimum funding requirement for a buyout transaction Pension funding option payoff: F w t = NA PLI 0 for t = 1, 2,..., n. NA: notional amount n: option period/term z: trigger funding index level K: strike funding level { PLI t (K PFI t ) if PFI t < z 0 if PFI t z, Tianxiang Shi (University of NebraskaLincoln) FIRM /24
10 Pension Derisking Securitization of Pension Risk with Options Pension Options for Fully Funded Plans Cont d Pension buyout option: not only fill the funding gap (up to K), but also cover the required buyout risk premium. Pension buyout option payoff: B w t = NA PLI 0 { PLI t (K PFI t + R t ) if PFI t < z 0 if PFI t z, for t = 1, 2,..., n. R t : estimated buyout risk premium at time t (Lin et al, 2015) Tianxiang Shi (University of NebraskaLincoln) FIRM /24
11 Pension Derisking Securitization of Pension Risk with Options Pension Options for UnderFunded Plans Pension funding option payoff: Ft u = NA 0 if PFI t K PLI PLI t (K PFI t ) if z < PFI t < K 0 0 if PFI t z Pension buyout option payoff: Bt u = NA PLI t R t if PFI t K PLI PLI t (K PFI t + R t ) if z < PFI t < K 0 0 if PFI t z Tianxiang Shi (University of NebraskaLincoln) FIRM /24
12 Pension Asset Index model Basic Framework Pension fund assets: S&P 500 index A 1,t, Merrill Lynch corporate bond index A 2,t and 3month Tbill A 3,t. S&P 500 index A 1,t : Merton s jumpdiffusion process (Merton, 1976) A 1,t = A 1,0 exp (α 1 1 N 1t 2 σ2 1 λ 1 k 1 )t + σ 1 W1t P + α 1 : instantaneous expected return σ 1 : instantaneous volatility W1t P : standard Brownian motion with mean 0 and variance t N 1t : Poisson process with arrival of λ 1 per unit of time Y 1j : standard normal with mean m 1 and s.d. s 1 k 1 : expected percentage change in the S&P 500 index Risk neutral Esscher measure is selected (Gerber and Shiu, 1994) Tianxiang Shi (University of NebraskaLincoln) FIRM /24 j=1 Y 1j
13 Pension Asset Index model Cont d Basic Framework Processes of A i,t, i = 2, 3, as a geometric Brownian motion: da i,t A i,t = α i dt + σ i dw P it, i = 2, 3 α i : instantaneous expected return σ i : instantaneous volatility of asset i : standard Brownian motion with mean 0 and variance t W P it S&P 500 index A 1,t and Merrill Lynch corporate bond index A 2,t are correlated with Cov(W P 1t, W P 2t) = ρσ 1 σ 2 t, Monthly data from 1988 to 2010 are used to estimate parameters Tianxiang Shi (University of NebraskaLincoln) FIRM /24
14 Pension Valuation Rate Basic Framework Interest rate risk in pension risk management should be carefully considered. Incorporate the dynamics of pension valuation rate into pension options pricing. CoxIngersollRoss (CIR) model (Cox et al., 1985) dr p,t = ν (θ r p,t ) dt + σ p rp,t dw P p,t, ν: meanreversion rate θ and σ p : longterm mean and instantaneous volatility W P p,t: standard Brownian motion Equally weighted average of US funding yield curve segment rates from August, 2008 to March, 2015 are used to estimate parameters. Tianxiang Shi (University of NebraskaLincoln) FIRM /24
15 Basic Framework Lee and Carter (1992) s Mortality Model Oneyear death rate q x,t for age x (x = 0, 1, 2, ) in year t (t = 1, 2,, K) ln q x,t = κ x + b x γ t + ɛ x,t, γ t = γ t 1 + g + e t, e t N(0, σ γ ) κ x and b x : agespecific parameters g: drift rate ɛ x,t and e t : normal errors with mean zero U.K. male population mortality tables from 1950 to 2003 are used Tianxiang Shi (University of NebraskaLincoln) FIRM /24
16 Basic Framework Option Pricing Formulas For Fully Funded Pensions Funding option for nyear term, in terms of the percentage of the nominal amount: PF w = 1 PLI 0 E Q [ e rτw N (τ w ) Pa x0 +τ w (K PFI τw ) +] N (t): survival evolution based on transformed mortality rates τ w = inf {t : PFI t < z, t {1, 2,..., n}} ( if the option is not triggered) Buyout option for nyear term: PB w = 1 PLI 0 E Q [ e rτw N (τ w ) Pa x0 +τ w ( (K PFIτw ) + + R τw )] = PF w + PR w Tianxiang Shi (University of NebraskaLincoln) FIRM /24
17 Basic Framework Option Pricing Formulas For UnderFunded Pensions Funding option for nyear term: PF u = 1 PLI 0 E Q [ e rτu N (τ u ) Pa x0 +τ u (K PFI τu ) +] where τ u = inf {t : PFI t > z, t {1, 2,..., n}} ( if the option is not triggered) Buyout option for nyear term: PB u = 1 PLI 0 E Q [ e rτu N (τ u ) Pa x0 +τ u ( (K PFIτu ) + + R τu )] = PF u + PR u Tianxiang Shi (University of NebraskaLincoln) FIRM /24
18 Risk Parameters and Assumptions Example: Hypothetical Pension Options Sensitivity Analysis Pension Funding Index The pension cohort has the same mortality experience as the U.K. male population At time 0, all plan participants reach the retirement age x 0 = 65 At time 0, 10,000 pensioners with annual survival benefit 60,000 per pensioner Pension asset weights (w 1, w 2, w 3 ) = (0.5, 0.45, 0.05), rebalanced annually amortization factor k = 1/5.95 Pension valuation rate: ν = , θ = 4.78%, σ p = 0.03, r p,0 = 4.8% Riskfree interest rate: r = 4% Market price of longevity risk (using Wang transform): λ EIB = , based on the European Investment Bank (EIB) bond issued in November 2004 Tianxiang Shi (University of NebraskaLincoln) FIRM /24
19 Example: Hypothetical Pension Options Sensitivity Analysis Pension Option Premiums for Fully Funded Plans Table 1: LifeTime Funding and Buyout Option Premiums for Fully Funded Plans Initial Funding Ratio Trigger Strike Funding Option Premium Buyout Addon PFI 0 z K PF w PR w % 3.23% % 100% % % 1.65% % % Tianxiang Shi (University of NebraskaLincoln) FIRM /24
20 Example: Hypothetical Pension Options Sensitivity Analysis Pension Option Premiums for UnderFunded Plans Table 2: LifeTime Funding and Buyout Option Premiums for UnderFunded Plans Initial Funding Ratio Trigger Strike Funding Option Premium Buyout Addon PFI 0 z K PF u PR u % 4.99% % 80% % % 3.79% % % 3.77% % 75% % % 2.87% % Tianxiang Shi (University of NebraskaLincoln) FIRM /24
21 Sensitivity Analysis Result Example: Hypothetical Pension Options Sensitivity Analysis Impact of Option Maturity: the longer the tenor of a pension option, the higher the price of the option. Impact of RiskFree Rate For fully funded plans, PF w is negatively associated with r. For underfunded plans, positive relation found between PF u and r. Buyout addon premiums decrease significantly when r increases for both cases. Tianxiang Shi (University of NebraskaLincoln) FIRM /24
22 Sensitivity Analysis Result Cont d Example: Hypothetical Pension Options Sensitivity Analysis Impact of Pension Valuation Rate Compare to a constant pension valuation scenario r p = 4.78%. both the funding and buyout options for fully funded plans require lower premiums at the constant pension valuation rate. Similar trend for PR u. For underfunded plans, most PF u s are actually higher at the constant pension valuation rate scenario. Impact of Longevity Risk For fully funded plans, PF w and PR w increase as λ increases. For underfunded plans, PF u decreases as λ increases. For underfunded plans, PR u increases as λ increases, even if the chance of triggering the option is lower. Tianxiang Shi (University of NebraskaLincoln) FIRM /24
23 Conclusion Introduction Example: Hypothetical Pension Options Sensitivity Analysis We provided new ways to reduce pension risk with buyouts. We introduced a transparent pension funding index based on market indices and publicly available mortality tables to increase market liquidity and reduce moral hazard and adverse selection problems. We illustrated how to price these new pension derisking securities while recognizing investment risk, longevity risk, and interest rate risk. Tianxiang Shi (University of NebraskaLincoln) FIRM /24
24 Example: Hypothetical Pension Options Sensitivity Analysis Thank You! Tianxiang Shi (University of NebraskaLincoln) FIRM /24
When to Claim Social Security Retirement Benefits
When to Claim Social Security Retirement Benefits David Blanchett, CFA, CFP Head of Retirement Research Morningstar Investment Management January 10, 2013 Morningstar Investment Management Abstract Social
More informationEffect on Net Worth of 15 and 30Year Mortgage Term
Effect on Net Worth of 15 and 30Year Mortgage Term John R. Aulerich 1, The choice between a 15year and 30year fixedrate mortgage term is evaluated considering the borrower s income tax rate, ability
More informationThe Bright Start College Savings Program DirectSold Plan. Supplement dated January 30, 2015 to Program Disclosure Statement dated November 12, 2012
The Bright Start College Savings Program DirectSold Plan Supplement dated January 30, 2015 to Program Disclosure Statement dated November 12, 2012 This supplement amends the Program Disclosure Statement
More informationA comparative analysis of current credit risk models q
Journal of Banking & Finance 24 (2000) 59±117 www.elsevier.com/locate/econbase A comparative analysis of current credit risk models q Michel Crouhy a, *, Dan Galai b, Robert Mark a a Canadian Imperial
More informationPension scheme example financial statements guide 2015. www.kpmg.ie
Pension scheme example financial statements guide 2015 www.kpmg.ie Contents Introduction 1 Example financial statements 4 Additional guidance 27 Appendix: Note on Irish Legal Requirements 35 Pension scheme
More informationCorporate Plan 20142017
Corporate Plan 20142017 May 2014 Contents Foreword 3 page Executive summary 5 Introduction 10 The Pensions Regulator The Corporate Plan Other public bodies concerned with pensions Regulatory approach
More informationEVALUATING THE PERFORMANCE CHARACTERISTICS OF THE CBOE S&P 500 PUTWRITE INDEX
DECEMBER 2008 Independent advice for the institutional investor EVALUATING THE PERFORMANCE CHARACTERISTICS OF THE CBOE S&P 500 PUTWRITE INDEX EXECUTIVE SUMMARY The CBOE S&P 500 PutWrite Index (ticker symbol
More informationAssessment of the 2015 Stability Programme for FINLAND
EUROPEAN COMMISSION DirectorateGeneral Economic and Financial Affairs Brussels, 27 May 2015 Assessment of the 2015 Stability Programme for FINLAND (Note prepared by DG ECFIN staff) CONTENTS 1. INTRODUCTION...
More informationFinanceability and financing the asset base a discussion paper
Water today, water tomorrow Financeability and financing the asset base a discussion paper www.ofwat.gov.uk About this document This document focuses on two of our primary duties, which are to: further
More informationFiscal Sustainability of an Independent Scotland
Fiscal Sustainability of an Independent Scotland Michael Amior Rowena Crawford Gemma Tetlow Copyedited by Judith Payne Institute for Fiscal Studies 7 Ridgmount Street London WC1E 7AE Published by The
More informationA healthier way to derisk
A healthier way to derisk The introduction of medical underwriting to the defined benefit derisking market A Pensions Institute report for insurance companies, advisers to DB schemes, regulators, trustees,
More informationValuing Financial Service Firms
1 Valuing Financial Service Firms Aswath Damodaran April 2009 Valuing banks, insurance companies and investment banks has always been difficult, but the market crisis of 2008 has elevated the concern to
More informationLIMITING RISK EXPOSURE WITH S&P RISK CONTROL INDICES
March 215 CONTRIBUTORS Alka Banerjee Managing Director Head of Equity Indices alka.banerjee@spdji.com Vinit Srivastava Senior Director Strategy Indices vinit.srivastava@spdji.com Tianyin Cheng Product
More informationAbstract 1. INTRODUCTION
45 ON BECOMING AN ACTUARY OF THE THIRD KIND STEPHEN P. D'ARCY Abstract The growing importance of investment performance in insurance operutions, the increusing volutility in finnnciul markets und the emergence
More informationWhy insurers differ from banks
Why insurers differ from banks October 2014 About Insurance Europe Insurance Europe is the European insurance and reinsurance federation. Through its 34 member bodies the national insurance associations
More informationHow we invest your money. AADr Ann McNeill, the University of Adelaide. also known as Investing for the future
How we invest your money also known as Investing for the future The information in this document forms part of the following UniSuper Product Disclosure Statements (as supplemented from time to time):
More informationAmerican Retirement Savings Could Be Much Better
AP Photo/Jae C. Hong American Retirement Savings Could Be Much Better By Rowland Davis and David Madland August 2013 www.americanprogress.org American Retirement Savings Could Be Much Better By Rowland
More informationThe Relative Costs and Benefits of Multiyear Procurement Strategies
INSTITUTE FOR DEFENSE ANALYSES The Relative Costs and Benefits of Multiyear Procurement Strategies Scot A. Arnold Bruce R. Harmon June 2013 Approved for public release; distribution is unlimited. IDA
More informationUnderstanding Leverage in ClosedEnd Funds
ClosedEnd Funds Understanding Leverage in ClosedEnd Funds The concept of leverage seems simple: borrowing money at a low cost and using it to seek higher returns on an investment. Leverage as it applies
More informationDOES IT MATTER WHAT TYPE OF PENSION SCHEME YOU HAVE?
The Economic Journal, 110 (February), F46±F81.. Published by Blackwell Publishers, 108 Cowley Road, Oxford OX4 1JF, UK and 350 Main Street, Malden, MA 02148, USA. DOES IT MATTER WHAT TYPE OF PENSION SCHEME
More informationNEED TO KNOW. Hedge Accounting (IFRS 9 Financial Instruments)
NEED TO KNOW Hedge Accounting (IFRS 9 Financial Instruments) 2 HEDGE ACCOUNTING (IFRS 9 FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS) TABLE OF CONTENTS Table of contents 2 1. Introduction 4 2. Existing guidance and the rationale
More informationBINOMIAL OPTION PRICING
Darden Graduate School of Business Administration University of Virginia BINOMIAL OPTION PRICING Binomial option pricing is a simple but powerful technique that can be used to solve many complex optionpricing
More informationProgram Fundamentals: Fidelity Portfolio Advisory Service
Program Fundamentals: Fidelity Portfolio Advisory Service Strategic Advisers, Inc. 245 Summer Street, V5D Boston, MA 02210 18005443455 March 30, 2015 On behalf of Fidelity, we thank you for the opportunity
More informationQuantitative Strategies Research Notes
Quantitative Strategies Research Notes March 999 More Than You Ever Wanted To Know * About Volatility Swaps Kresimir Demeterfi Emanuel Derman Michael Kamal Joseph Zou * But Less Than Can Be Said Copyright
More informationHow Much Should I Save for Retirement? By Massi De Santis, PhD and Marlena Lee, PhD Research
How Much Should I Save for Retirement? By Massi De Santis, PhD and Marlena Lee, PhD Research June 2013 Massi De Santis, a senior research associate at Dimensional, is a financial economist with more than
More informationBuy and Maintain: A smarter approach to credit portfolio management
FOR INSTITUTIONAL/WHOLESALE OR PROFESSIONAL CLIENTS ONLY NOT FOR RETAIL USE OR DISTRIBUTION INVESTMENT GLOBAL INSURANCE SOLUTIONS Buy and Maintain: A smarter approach to credit portfolio management SEPTEMBER
More informationCOMPANY VALUATION METHODS. THE MOST COMMON ERRORS IN VALUATIONS. Pablo Fernández
CIIF Working Paper WP no 449 January, 2002 Rev. February, 2007 COMPANY VALUATION METHODS. THE MOST COMMON ERRORS IN VALUATIONS Pablo Fernández IESE Business School University of Navarra Avda. Pearson,
More informationInternational Comparison of Mortgage Product Offerings. Dr. Michael Lea
S P E C I A L R E P O R T International Comparison of Mortgage Product Offerings Dr. Michael Lea International Comparison of Mortgage Product Offerings Dr. Michael Lea Director, Corky McMillin Center for
More informationBasel Committee on Banking Supervision. Principles for the Management and Supervision of Interest Rate Risk
Basel Committee on Banking Supervision Principles for the Management and Supervision of Interest Rate Risk July 2004 Requests for copies of publications, or for additions/changes to the mailing list, should
More informationNo Portfolio is an Island
No Portfolio is an Island David Blanchett, CFA, CFP Head of Retirement Research Morningstar Investment Management david.blanchett@morningstar.com Philip Straehl Senior Research Consultant & Portfolio Manager
More information