ROI ELICO Final Results

Size: px

Start display at page:

Download "ROI ELICO Final Results"

Jean Hunt
7 years ago
Views:

1 ROI ELICO Final Results

3 EPEF: 2010 From EPEF to ELICO ROI Value perspective Evidence about usage of big deals in France Evidence about french journal usage specificities % % % Elsevier IOP Springer Wiley TOTAL

4 From EPEF to ELICO ROI Value perspective ROI ElICO : 2012 New research question How e-journals usage impacts researchers publication activity? A french contribution to ROI studies Lib-Value ; Ciber Agenda Submitted in June 2012 Started in September 2012 Final report : December 2013

5 Study objectives Any evidence of relationship between journal usage and impact (publication, citations)? Variation by subject? By institution type? Any evidence of causality phenomena? Evolution in time?

6 Shaping the study ROI defined as Publication and impact Articles and citation Sample longitudinal perspective Combine 2 complementary approaches Descriptive: Bibliometry Explicative: Econometry 6

7 The partners and the data Couperin The national consortium JR1 reports (Elsevier, Springer, Wiley, IOP) Big Deals costs: no comprehensive and reliable data on expenditures Elsevier Scopus for bibliometric data Coverage: more exhaustif for french academic institutions HSS fields Language Affiliations issue Scopus Index reliability» ((AF-ID("Universite Claude Bernard Lyon 1" ) OR AF-ID("Universite de Lyon 1 Faculte de Medecine Alexis Carrel" ))) OR ((AFFIL(«lyon AND 1») OR AFFIL(«lyon1») OR AFFIL(«lyon AND i») OR AFFIL(«lyoni») OR AFFIL(ucbl)) OR ((AFFIL(ucb) OR AFFIL(«claude AND bernard»)) AND AFFIL(lyon))) AND (LIMIT-TO(PUBYEAR, 2007))

8 Exploratory approach Two level analysis Macro Analysis: national level, 68 institutions Micro Analysis: sample level, 13 institutions Different variables, Proxys Usage, production, citation, scientific domain, ESGBU library statistics Develop indicators to understand the mechanisms of ROI Based on h-index method 8

9 BIBLIOMETRIC ANALYSIS AND RESULTS 9

10 10 Universities by usage

11 Cross the variables LP SMM STM HSS LEM Groupe 1 Paris 5 Paris 6 Lyon 1 Groupe 2 Nantes Poitiers Groupe 3 Metz Angers Groupe 4 La Rochelle Perpignan Savoie Le Havre Total 13 Paris 10 Toulouse 1 11

12 Thematic indexation 12 Thematics Journals % Cumulated Medecine Biomedical and Life Sciences Engineering Earth and Environmental Sciences Chemistry and Material Sciences Mathematics and Statistics Social Sciences and Law Physics and Astronomy Politics Business and Economics Computer Science, pro &applied comp Behavioral Sciences Humanities Architecture and Design

13 Usage Concentration

14 Publication Concentration

15 The Indicators Based on the mathematic calculation principle of the h- Index => Publication: Notoriety Impact Factor (RIn) => Usage: Usage Impact Factor (RIc) For every institution, two indicators are calculated 15

RIn 2003 Correlation in 2003 60 Paris 6 50 40 Paris 5 Lyon1 30 Nantes 20 Angers Poitier 10 Paris 10 Le Havre

16 RIn 2003 Correlation in Paris Paris 5 Lyon1 30 Nantes 20 Angers Poitier 10 Paris 10 Le Havre Toulouse 1 Perpignan Savoie La Rochelle Metz y = 0,1567x - 3,0386 R² = 0, RIc

17 RIn Correlation in 2005 Paris 6 50 Paris 5 40 Nantes Lyon Angers Poitier 10 Paris 10 Le Havre Toulouse 1 Perpignan Savoie La Rochelle Metz y = 0,1566x - 5,546 R² = 0, RIc

18 RIn 2007 Correlation in Paris 6 Paris 5 60 Nantes Lyon Savoie Perpignan Angers Poitier y = 0,2507x - 9,8414 R² = 0, Paris 10 La Rochelle Le Havre Toulouse 1 Metz RIc

19 RIn 2009 Correlation in Paris Paris Nantes Lyon Perpignan Savoie Le Havre Paris 10 La Rochelle Angers Metz Poitiers y = 0,2017x - 9,6047 R² = 0, Toulouse RIc

20 THEMATIC ANALYSIS 20

21 Standard Publication rate 2,5 Medicine 2 Engineering 1,5 Politics Business and Economics Physics and Astronomy 1 0,5 Behavioral Sciences Biomedical and Life Sciences 0 Social Sciences and Law -1,5-1 -0,5 0 0,5 1 1,5 2 2,5 Humanities Architecture Mathematics and and Statistics Earth Design and Environmental -0,5 Sciences Standard Usage rate Chemistry and Materials Sciences Computer Science, pro & applied comp. -1-1,5 21-2

22 Perspectives Extending the study by a qualitative approach Perceptions and representations Individual Interviews and focus group Extending impact definition to social impact Social media STM domains What did Mendeley to downloads on ScienceDirect

ScienceDirect JR1 decreasing 16000000 14000000

0-11% 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008

23 ScienceDirect JR1 decreasing % Diversification (Larsen, 2010) (Solomon, 2013)

The French Higher Education System. Embassy of France in Canada Science and Technology Office http://www.ambafrance-ca.

The French Higher Education System. Embassy of France in Canada Science and Technology Office http://www.ambafrance-ca. he French Higher ducation System mbassy of France in Canada Science and echnology ffice http://www.ambafrance-ca.org/scientific France An age-old university tradition (the University of Paris was founded