UBLAW FORUM OUR STUDENTS: READY FOR THE FUTURE

Transcription

1 UBLAW FORUM Th Mgzn of h Unvy Buffo Lw Shoo Th S Unvy of Nw Yok OUR STUDENTS: READY FOR THE FUTURE Fom h oom o h w off Pung k f Aumn nvovmn Lnng o h xp A dv nvonmn A pofon p o n S P R I N G

2 UB Lw Foum md f o umn, fuy, udn nd fnd of h Unvy Buffo Lw Shoo. Snd you ommn o uggon o In R. Fhmnn fh@buffo.du Unvy Buffo Lw Shoo, Th S Unvy of Nw Yok V Dn fo Aumn nd Communon, nd UB Lw Foum Edo: In R. Fhmnn Cov uon: Dn Zkozmk Pnp Phoogph: Jn Ch, Dond Dnnk, Mk Muv, Nny P Runon Phoogph: Doug Bnz, Shon Cnon, Rob Kkhm, KC K, Rob MEoy, M Muphy P dd opondn o: L Mu: Lw Aumn Aoon mu@buffo.du Amy Aknon: Runon kn@buffo.du Mng dd: UB Lw Foum 310 O Bn H Buffo, NY Don b ng! W wom you pofon nw. C Aon now onn nd w b -md o umn nd fnd p of ou onn quy nw, UB Lw Lnk. Subm you m w.buffo.du/umn o -m Cynh W w@buffo.du. Don fog o nud oo jpg. Kyno pk U.S. Sn. Kn Gbnd pk Commnmn, Sudy, My 21. Fu mumd ovg FOLLOW US ON: fbook.om/ubw w.om/ubw w.buffo.du/nkdn.p youub.om/ubwhoo fk.om/ubw Copygh 2011 by Unvy Buffo Lw Shoo Voum 23, Numb 2. A Rgh Rvd

3 U B L A W F O R U M S P R I N G Conn 1 UBLAW FORUM Th Mgzn of h Unvy Buffo Lw Shoo Th S Unvy of Nw Yok Mg Fom h Dn 2 Tkng UB Lw o h fofon of g duon Aumn Rpo 3 Thom E. Bk J. 79 v h Jk Awd 4 Vn Doy 89 dy o d h Nw Yok S B Aoon 5 Kn Rhdon 97 w d Womn B Aoon 6 Pdn Mngmn Fow f on h xpn 8 Lw Rvw Dnn hono wo umn Sudn of Coo Dnn b hvmn Fou on Lg Sk 9 Ou udn: Rdy fo h fuu 13 F mpovmn h g 14 Moo Cou: Budng udn no dvo 15 Q&A wh Judg Fnzyk nd Ch O Bn 16 Lnng o h xp 17 Nw nuo bud h nd wng ngh Lw Shoo Rpo 18 In h oom wh In Zubd Khn, fom Amny Innon hf 19 Jff P jon dvopmn m Fuy 20 Mhw Sn: Mkng phoophy wok 21 Anhony O Rouk: A fnon fo mn w 22 Mhw Dmk: A ooog y fo bo w 23 Smnh Bb: Png h mov nduy 24 Th nw book by UB Lw fuy mmb 26 Pofo Wnnfd F. Suvn jon pgou poj 27 Pofo Dvd Eng v n honoy dg n hgh Th y 28 Fuy mmb foow h pon fo ommuny v Aumn Aoon 30 Th Wd Ang: Aumn onnon o h non 32 Fv v wd Lw Aumn Aoon 49h nnu dnn Runon Bk o hoo 33 F nnu Nwok h Non 34 Py h Mnon 38 Bh, Mg, In Mmom A W Go o P 40 Vgn Sz 85 nd Dn O Donn 82 nomnd o op fd job Sn. On Hh g Dn O Donn 82 nd Vgn Sz 85, n, hng bfo h Sn Comm on h Judy Thom E. Bk J Hon. Hny Sudd 18 In Zubd Khn Lf o gh, Dvd Mo 03, Donn A. Humphy 83 nd Chng Huy 09

4 2 U B L A W F O R U M S P R I N G Mg fom h Dn Tkng UB Lw o h fofon of g duon Evn hough h png w n omng o Buffo h y, ou p hoo hv nv bn hgh.af muh hd wok, h hoo kng off n nw nd xng wy.l m povd you wh ju fw xmp.ou puon on h, vdnd by v non nkng. In h, w h no n n ou puh fo h Top 50.Th m,w hv hd fou nw fuy wh pon who w h n mpon of nd n ou uuum, nudng mn w nd bo w.w hv vuy don h n f foo nd nn o h Lw Shoo.Addng o h ngy, UB nd fom Povo Sh K. Tph 15h pdn. Ov h p h y, Pdn Tph h bn wondfu boo nd pn o h Lw Shoo.H dpy bou UB Lw.W mpy oud no hv b d fo ou ugu unvy. Th mgzn hghgh om of h wok bhnd on of ou pmy go ou dmnon o podu p-dy ony. Sn umng h mn of dn,i hv bn dvn by ngu ommmn o podu h mo kd wy.to h nd,w hv pd no ffo,o ou,o mk h von om u.w hv hd fuy ommd o g hng, puy n h bk w h n o h g pofon.w hv hd nn hghy kd h nd wng nuo who wokng hd o n ou udn h gh wy fom dy on. I nno y nough bou how uy u h h o h mon of h Lw Shoo. Ou g k uuum nud ny hf of ou offng h nd wng, nd pp dvoy, xnhp, moo ou, w vw nd ADR. Th h fundmn k h mk wy.i mu y h I oud no b mo poud of h job h ou n g k m, und h dhp of SUNY Dnguhd Pofo Ch Ewng, dong o mp o ou udn h uu nd k of g wyng. Smy, w now vmpng ou n g duon pogm und Pofo Km Connoy, nony nownd g nn nd ho. Th nvmn n ou n bouy n bu ky pong of h g k uuum body dfnd. Fny,I wn o y h g w hoo h w udn how o hnk bou ompx g pobm wh mpng p g k.you know w I do h h g pofon undgong dp nfomon. Th Dn Mku W. Muu wh UB 15h pdn, Sh K. Tph. mk nngy dmndng h h w gdu of h fuu h h by o h h gound unnng.lw hoo w hv o oo o pond o h mk fo. Bu hy mu do o n m wy.th why w UB Lw hvy nvng n wyng k wh hng ou udn o bk down h mo ophd g ho. Th wo go hnd n hnd.i bv h h w-oundd w gdu h o b quppd o do boh w.i wn o u you h ou fuy qu o h hng.p jon u n kng UB Lw o p h fofon of g duon. Thnk you. Dn Mku W.Muu

5 Aumnu Honod 3 Snd-up guy Thom E. Bk J. 79 p h Jk Awd wh m nd hng Th wh w fghfu bu h ompny w dghfu UB Lw Shoo umn, dmno nd fnd ghd n Nw Yok Cy o pn h 2011 Edwn F.Jk Awd o Thom E.Bk J. 79. Th Jn. 28 unhon nd wd pnon ook p h gn Unon Lgu Cub, wh h pk ood bnh n o pnng of Abhm Lnon o pn h hgh hono h UB Lw Shoo nd Aumn Aoon n bow. Bk mngng pn of Bk, Mnn & Ghm, LLP, w fm h foundd n 1997.Connng n mogg vng, h fm h ov 130 mpoy wh off n D, Houon nd Fow Mound, Tx. Bk h vd on UB Lw Dn Advoy Coun n 2002 nd h bn hmn n 2007.A mjo gf fom Tom nd h wf, Bdg, w bh nmd pofohp h Lw Shoo. Fmy mmb nd mmb of h fm w pn fo h vn,md by Dnn R.MCoy 77. Dn Mku W.Muu gv n upd on pog h Lw Shoo,Fn M.Lo 79,v h of h Dn Advoy Coun, hd h own wom, nd Unvy Buffo Povo (now Pdn) Sh K. Tph nod h mndou oyy nd uppo h UB Lw umn f owd h hoo. Dn Muu wd-ngng noduon of h hono onvgd on on ky pon. Th on o Tom u, h dn d, nd h h wy h pop, whh b h n,h ogu o h ff.i w h myf whn I vd Tom off n D,wh I oud, Tom wkd Bdg Bk ound wh m o nodu m o vou ff mmb,h h w no ng bo bu ogu. Bk known fo bgnnng h mng of h Dn Advoy Coun wh fuy hon p of humo, nd h dy w no xpon.h od how h hd bn wd by h UB Lw dmon dpmn nd hd dy nod noh w hoo whn, dy bfo w o bgn,h go fom Buffo. I w h vy udn pd off h wng h y, h d. On pp, I w h ngn pon n my. Th nv bohd m un on dy, Dn Advoy Coun mng, fom Dn Tom Hdk pond ou h, on h who, h C of 79 w no vy bgh. H dd h vu of h pn Tom nd C Bk,who w n h udn fo kng hm o f.thy mpd o pu hm nd h boh, Sn, hough No Dm nd UB Lw Shoo, nd hy ugh mpon on, Bk d, bou ngy nd p nd humo nd gnoy nd ompon. Th wd uy ognon of ho vu h hn h ndvdu, h d,hnkng o h hdn,ryn ( un UB Lw udn) nd En,nd my ophy wf of 27 y, Bdg. H uppo, dv nd ov hv md ody pob. Bk hngd h fow umn o b n v p of UB Lw nn, yng, Voun you m, obby you go, w hk. G nvovd. Jon u n h nob u. And h quod Rph Wdo Emon dfnon of u, whh nudd h by o ugh ofn nd muh nd o wn h p of ngn pop. Tody, Bk d, I f ufu. Voun you m, obby you go, w hk. G nvovd. Jon u n h nob u. Mumd:

6 4 U B L A W F O R U M S P R I N G Aumn Nw S of dn Vn Doy 89 o k h n of h Nw Yok S B Aoon Dung h Nw Yok S B Aoon, who pdn h bom on Jun 1, Vnn E. Doy III 89 un gn nd gn o on wod: Enomou. A n, n ognzon wh 77,000 mmb, on-qu of whom v ou of nd vn n oh oun; wh 90-odd omm nd on; wh w of ongong pubon nd oh nfomon-dmnng md; wh pogm of onnung g duon offd o h nd houghou h y. A n,n nomou moun of wok h w. A pdn,you wok p of h m on wh you wn o omph nd o of h m on hng h oh pop wn o omph, Doy y n n nvw n h by of h Buffo w fm Conno & Vdo, wh h pn. I n nomou ognzon of ff nd voun dong n nomou moun of wok.th w b y whn I hv wo fu-m job h wh my hom f.(h nd h wf, Ky Ruowz Doy, hv h young hdn.) I b vy nn nd hngng fo y. In om wy h n f o d h pond o h momn.h mmb h fh Vnn E. Doy J. 56, bd dfn wy nd hf dmnv judg fo h S Supm Cou, 8h Jud D ng hm o B Aoon vn hd.a UB Lw,young Vn w moo ou hmpon, vd on h Lw Rvw nd gdud wh mgn um ud pnd on h dpom. H o h pd o of du wh h B Aoon, hvng vd boh n h Hou of Dg nd on h Exuv Comm. H o vd h of h oon v Cmn Ju Son. H h pn h p y pdn- of h ognzon, wokng oy wh ougong pdn Sphn P.Young of Nw Yok Cy. Now, h pp o k off, Vnn E. Doy III 89 Doy wn o bng h B Aoon ondb ou o b on goup of u.h wn o fou non on po bono wok, nougng ony o n h po bono hou nd hpng o mh hm wh po bono oppoun. Suh wok nougd bu n Nw Yok S no qud p of h pofon,bu Doy py wn o mnd ony oud of w fm,uh govnmn wy nd ho n opo oun off, h hy oo n g n on h. H o wn o k h pnn pobm of mpovng dvy, boh n h B Aoon nd n h pofon who.and h wn o n h pp nd vn of h g pofon o h nx gnon, nudng nvng w udn o g mo nvovd n h wok of h ognzon.th o of w hoo onnung onn; B Aoon po o b d oon w mk ommndon on om hng n g duon nd dd wok-f bn u fo ony n p. A pdn, h v ouny nd py b mng; nd p mng nd onfn of B Aoon on; pnd o of m n Abny, wh h ognzon hdqud, nd Nw Yok Cy; nd nd Amn B Aoon mng nd wo mng ou of h ouny. H pon ou h mo hn 2,000 UB Lw Shoo gdu Nw Yok B Aoon mmb, nudng mmb n Chn, Ind, Ko, Hong Kong, Puo Ro nd h Und Kngdom. H o,h y wh wy gn, h bom gd obby, h b o uppo h ognzon obbyng ffo wh govnmn. Though of h, hough, Doy hod f o h d of w ng,omhng h d o mp upon h wy nwy dmd o h b whn h w d o pk h dmon mony ny. Th n job fo u, h y, nd n bun. I pofon.w v n hng n hnoogy, hng n h bun of w, ny hng n h onomy. A of h hv hngd h p of w,bu hy hv no hngd h pofon.and h pofon no o g ppy bou,bu h ou.w hv n obgon o v h g good, nd w hv duy o mpov h g ym wh w n.and h o of b oon, puy, o po nd nuu h ou.

7 5 On h d of fn Kn Rhdon 97 o d Womn B Aoon of h S of Nw Yok Whn Kn Rhdon 97 won n pdn of h Womn B Aoon of h S of Nw Yok on My 21, h pom h h nugu ph w b ho on. Th ognzon mon? No o m. Wh mo hn 3,800 mmb (10 pn of hm m) n 18 hp o h, h oon pomo h dvnmn of womn n h g pofon nd o oy. A m, Rhdon y, whn womn mn undpnd n dhp poon n h w fo xmp, hn on-hd of fd judg womn, nd hy g pn nd mngng pn n w fm h oon h pny of wok bfo. Rhdon, who wok onfdn w k o h Hon. H. Knnh Shod J., mg judg fo h U.S. D Cou, Wn D of Nw Yok, h om up hough h nk of h b oon, fom h dy whn pop dy nvovd n h ognzon dw m n. I found w n ou o b b o p ou of h w fm p nd hv oh womn you oud boun quon nd u off nd k bou wh n h ommuny do w nd. Sh vd u nd pdn of h oon Wn Nw Yok hp h hd-g n h nd hn u nd v pdn of h ognzon. Sh h pn h p y pdn. Rhdon pvouy wokd n o h Buffo w fm Php Ly, nd h um dhp of n ognzon h nud ony n pub v, pv p, g fm nd m, up nd down. Th o of h womn b vy m o h of h Nw Yok S B Aoon nd h E Kn Rhdon 97 Couny B Aoon, h y. And o, fo xmp, h ognzon k poon on pndng gon n Abny h ff h g pofon, wh p n n u wh n mp on womn v. Rhdon no h h Womn B Aoon w numn n pg of ong-dyd no-fu dvo gon n Nw Yok S, nd h y w onnu o dvo fo fundng fo v g v fo h poo n u mpon o womn, gvn h h popuon n povy hvy wghd owd womn, py ng womn wh hdn. Nong h womn ov hf h gn popuon nd hv bn w ov 40 pn of w hoo udn fo 20 y now, h gu h dvnng womn n n h g pofon no ony m of quy, bu m of pzng on womn unqu gf. Whh n h judy o h md fd o whv, xudng hm dv, Rhdon y. You xudng 50 pn of you ou. In ouoom uon, fo xmp, h y, vy mpon fo pop n ommuny o hv n of onfdn h hy pnd h hy hmv n h ym, o h pn of womn on h bnh, on ju nd h ony b hp bud u n h jud ym. Und h dhp, nd wh h wok of h Womn B Aoon 39 omm, h xp h oon o onn ffo n v. On o nghn pogm o noug womn o un fo v off nd o mk hmv vb fo judghp, o h po p nd on omm w xpnd h von of who h qufd ndd. Anoh o xpnd h oon onnung g duon offng nd o mk mo of hm vb hough wbn, of p hp o wy n mo u of h. I mn buy y n whh Rhdon w jugg h wok bk hom wh v o o hp of h oon, o of -m nd onfn ng, wd wknd mng fv m y, nd m n h ognzon Nw Yok Cy hdqu. JBu, h y, wondfu hng.

8 6 U B L A W F O R U M S P R I N G Aumn Nw Th D.C. onnon Pdn Mngmn Fow f on h nng uv n govnmn v Gduon nd h b xm bhnd hm, nd hy v bn on h job fo h b p of y. So UB Lw mo n Pdn Mngmn Fow fv 2010 gdu who pd off n Whngon, D.C., und h fd govnmn hghy ompv pogm o n nx gnon of d n poon o f b. UB Lw Foum kd h of hm bou h wok, h n of govnmn v nd f n h non p. N Wm wokng wh h Fd Rod Admnon, p of h Dpmn of Tnpoon, fnn ny fo h gny Rod Rhbon & Impovmn Fnnng Pogm. Th h nyz on ppon nd hp mnn h gny on pofoo. Th ubj nw o h A I hd don w d Amk, h y bu h bng o h gny bkgound nd n n fnn. I wod p, h y of wokng n h. I m nng bou h od nduy nd ppyng my fnn k. I y hngng wok, omhng dffn h dy. Th wok nvov vung h dwohn of h ppn, h fnn mn nd hoy, nd pojng fuu fnn o vu boow by o py p on. Mny ppn m od ookng fo mony o y nw k o buy nw. I od my f on ny, Wm y. I w m on, bu o h ompny gng h on vy mpon nd vy vub. I w m od n Mpp, nd h gong o b hug fo hm. I w py fufng o g h ppovd, knowng h gong o hp ou h m od. Ov h Sm Bun Admnon, Mhw P who J.D. w nd wh fnn non onnon o dong fnn ny, n h SBA Off of h Chf Fnn Off. W hnd h budg, gvng ou h mony o h dffn pogm off h mpmnng ou pogm, nd kng h mony o how w h pogm dong nd f hy mng h go, h y. Th o guoy ompn p, fo whh h Lw Shoo nng mo dy ppb. I y k wh I m. I xmy vub f you wn n h fd govnmn, P y of h Pdn Mngmn Fowhp pogm. I v nd o bou how gn op h v. I h ju bn n duon n how h fd govnmn op. Hh Shn gnmn h bn wh h hgh-pof Fd Emgny Mngmn Agny, p of h Dpmn of Homnd Suy. Th h h bn nvovd wh wo dn poj. In h gny humn p dpmn, h h bn wokng on po nd podu fo FEMA PMF pogm, nudng po on how fow n o no oh poon whn h gny. And, wokng wh h hf oun off, h hpng o dvop of pod on g op d o FEMA wok, o b unhd nny nd hn o h wod on h Inn. On of h g hng bou h PMF pogm h wy no h fd govnmn, Shn y. Th d h you om n nd

9 7 hy wn you o b d of h gny n h fuu, o of fuu mngmn upvo k. Th oh omponn, you hv o do on oon oud you gny. Th gv you n oppouny o how oh gn wok nd xpnd on you k. In Jun h w bgn oon n h Humn Rgh Lw Dvon of h Dpmn of Immgon nd Cuom Enfomn. I nng, h y of wokng h v. Th n b o of buuy you hv o go hough o g omhng don. Bu you n wok on po h mp g popuon of pop nd n b y mpon, nd you hv oppoun o m pop you woudn ohw m. I g p o b. Wh Lw Shoo bkgound n fmy w, Mgo Bown bgn h PMF gnmn n h Dpmn of Hh nd Humn Sv, n h Off of Chd Suppo Enfomn of h Admnon fo Chdn nd Fm. Th h wokd n h poy dvon, wokng on wy o mo ffvy h nfomon muh of bou pon o dom von wh oh fd gn, nd ppng n h ongong poy-mkng wok of h dvon. In Jnuy h ook on omhng ompy dffn: h-monh oon h Dpmn of Engy, wokng n h hf oun off of h Advnd Rh Poj Agny-Engy, whh pomo nd fund h nd dvopmn of dvnd ngy hnoog. Af h oon, h un o Hh nd Humn Sv. I wdng o hv p n omhng h you know gong o ff pop down h od, Bown y. I g oppouny, bu you wy ound pop nd mkng onnon. Th how D.C. mpon o know pop. Anoh dvng: h oppouny o wok, on fxm b, fou 10-hou dy, vng h m o do po bono wok. Jnn Mon ndd up Hh nd Humn Sv, oo, bgnnng h PMF n h Non Inu of Hh. H pon UB Lw w bo nd mpoymn w, nd n xnhp E Couny Md Cn mnd h n. Sh h pyd h xpn nd nng no humn ou k NIH. In on gnmn, h wokd on mpmnng pdn mmondum on hng fom. Pdn Obm dv w o hon h hng po fo fd poon, o mk h po mo npn o ppn nd o g gny mng mo nvovd. I bm pon pon my gny o k h pdn mmo nd mpmn no h dy-o-dy funon of ou humn ou off, Mon y. Sh pon ou h h Pdn Mngmn Fowhp pogm nomp no ju w gdu, bu m pop wh nng n dpn uh pub hh, bun nd o wok. Evybody bngng omhng dffn o h b, nd dfny vy dynm p o b, h y. Th g hng bou bng n PMF oho h vyon y nggd nd wn o know mo hn hy ny nd o. Thy y gv u om g oppoun o b nvovd. Th PMF pogm pf fo omon who wn o u h g dg n non-don wy. Th w h pf p fo m o nd up.

10 8 U B L A W F O R U M S P R I N G Aumn Honod LAW REVIEW DINNER Buffo Lw Rvw hono U.S.Cou of App Judg Juo Fun 75 nd pomnn ony Gy Gb 78 Hon. Juo M. Fun 75 Gy M. Gb 78 Th Buffo Lw Rvw Dnn on Ap 21 bd y of hvmn by udn n h pv ognzon nd pd bu o UB Lw umn nd fuy who hv md dffn n w udn v. Th nnu vn, whh w hd n h Pk Cub, n Wmv, w hd by hd-y udn Ryn R. Sh, mngng do of h udnun joun. Th dnn bd y n whh h Lw Rvw, und Edo-n-Chf Hn K. Roo, pubhd fv u nd w nkd hghy mong unvy w joun mud by dhp nd numb of on fom oh dm Ṫwo UB Lw umn w honod h dnn. Hon. Juo M. Fun 75, who v on h U.S. Cou of App, Thd Cu, h hgh-nkng fd judg o gdu fom UB Lw Shoo. H o v on h hoo Dn Advoy Coun. H h hpd h Lw Shoo mndouy, Sh y. Bu of h v o h Lw Shoo nd py h v o h udn, w w dghd o hv hm om pk o u nd o hono hm. Gy M. Gb 78, pn h Buffobd w fm Hodgon Ru nd n djun fuy mmb UB Lw, o w honod h dnn. Gb h ov 30 y of xpn png bnkupy, opo nd fnn uung, do gh, fnn v, omm nd opo gon, nd gn bun w. H, o on of h ogu, py mjo o n vuy vy g Chp 11 fd n up Nw Yok nd mny fd n h Souhn D of Nw Yok nd Dw. M. Gb p pdn of h UB Lw Aumn Aoon, v on h Dn Advoy Coun, h hd numou poon on b omm nd h vy dnguhd od of v, y Sh. Th Lw Rvw ff nd fnd o bd h y unh of Th Dok, n onn xnon of h joun. Th Dok pubh ho pon o pubhd n h Rvw nd o pubh ho ogn wok, uh y. Sy Sh, I mn o b mo of onvon hn noh p of h Rvw. STUDENTS OF COLOR Dnn hono dvy Th Unvy Buffo Lw Shoo honod dvy n h y Lw Shoo Sudn of Coo Dnn, hd Ap 21 h Buffo Ng Mo. Th dnn ognz nd hono h hvmn of dnguhd umn, mnoy bz, pofo nd w udn who o gdu n My. Co-ponod by h An Amn Lw Sudn Aoon, h Bk Lw Sudn Aoon nd h Ln Amn Lw Sudn Aoon, bng ogh gdung udn, onnung udn, umn,fuy nd ho of fnd o b h hvmn of pop of oo who hv bn o od wh h Lw Shoo. Kyno pk h y w John V. Emo, who v no oun Judg Cg Hnnh 95 Abo M. Bnz 86 nd mngng ony fo h Buffo w fm Bown Ch.H o h uho of Fghng fo You Lf: Th Afn Amn Suvv Gud, whh dd h u of young pop nd h mn ju ym. Two Dnguhd Aumn Awd w pnd, on o Buffo Cy Cou Judg Cg Hnnh 95, who h bn n v mmb of h UB Lw Aumn Aoon bod of do.anoh w pnd o Abo M. Bnz 86, pofo of n w, Gog Whngon Unvy Lw Shoo, n Whngon, D.C. Th vn Tbz Awd w pnd o Joph M.Hnn 05, pn png omm gon wh h Buffo w fm Godbg Sg.A pdn of h Mnoy B Aoon, Hnn h dvopd nw khp pogm dgnd o udn of oo o khp n Wn Nw Yok 8h Jud D. Ao honod h dnn wh h Job D. Hymn Pofo of h Y wd w Pofo Sphn Php, who dm fou C R Thoy bu who o h wokd y wh h Bk Lw Sudn Aoon nd v on UB Lw Dvy Comm. Th Monqu E. Emdn Awd, gvn n hono of h 2007 UB Lw gdu who dd of n whn h w 28, w pnd o hd-y w udn Tffny LBon. Th wd oboon bwn Hok & By LLP nd Bhd Wod Hv Innon Chuh.A Lf W Cmb hohp w wdd o hgh hoo udn. Th vn don nd-ghng mony od h vnng. Gdung hd-y udn pd h oh o ho who w foow hm d n UB Lw udn of oo ommuny.

11 Fou on Lg Sk U B L A W F O R U M S P R I N G OUR STUDENTS: dy fo h fuu Fom nw ou o nw oppoun fo udn o mp pofon f, UB Lw Shoo doubng ffo o podu wy dy o p on dy on. Th nw fou ppn o h bod nd dy pyng off. Fom h oom o h w off Wh w pofon f b k fo h wy of h fuu? Th mny opnon bou h u quon h pund ng hm. Wh, hough, h vn wh h mngy d hng n h pofon bng wough by h Infomon Ag nd onnung onom pu, h no ubu fo h k h wy hv wdd fo m mmmo: h o dng, wng nd ny hnkng h vy good ony ok n d. And o,vn h fuu of wyng mn unknowb, UB Lw Shoo h ommd f o mpng o vy udn h k ny o ud n 21 nuy p. Dwng on o onnon wh h bnh nd b, h hoo onnu o k h pu of h g ommuny nd m nd now nd no h fuu.a ph ofn hd ound O Bn H h,ub Lw gdung nw wy who w b dy o p on dy on. Pung k f Th mo ubn hng n h Lw Shoo uuum n y k fu ff h y wh h noduon of h Lg Sk nv. Und h don of V Dn fo Lg Sk Ch Pk Ewng, Lg Sk omp uuum omponn, moo ou nd hnqu xpn, pubhd joun, pofon dvopmn nd g xnhp. Fo y,ub Lw udn hv bn qud o k wo m of h nd wng. Now h Connud on pg 10

12 10 Fou on Lg Sk U B L A W F O R U M S P R I N G W kd wh k ou udn nd on dy on nd wh hy do dung h f wk n w off.w vd mndou moun of fdbk. V Dn fo Lg Sk Ch Pk Ewng nwy nmd Lg Any,Wng nd Rh pogm, o LAWR, h xpndd o qu h m of ouwok, bgun f wh h nng C of 2013.A vo of h fuy ffmd h hng. Lg ny nd g wng h wo fundmn k of ny wy, Ewng y. Th nb u now o no ony gv udn mo nng n h k, bu o gv o hm n p h hy mo b o d wh h v.w don hv o uh udn o g h n. On k ou w b qud n h m of udn f y,wh h hd n h ond y.ub Lw ny hd wo nw nuo ( Pg 17) o hp mpmn h ddon ouwok. Th hng gow ou of of fou goup h h hoo ondud wh judg, jud k nd ony. W kd wh k ou udn nd on dy on nd wh hy do dung h f wk n w off, Ewng y. W vd mndou moun of fdbk.w o ookd vy w hoo n h Und S,foung py on h op 10.W found h nn of hm qud h m of h nd wng. In ddon, h d, udn w b qud o k on oh ou wh mjo wng omponn, uh n xnhp o hnqu ou.abou 160 udn pp n hnqu pogm h y.a nw ou dd h d nd o-xmnon of xp wn n v nd mn, nd h p Sudy pogm h m fo hnqu udn nud h pnon of mud by op o go w u on op uh vdny u n p. Ou f-y udn pnd ondb h of h m n g ny, wng nd h, whh povd h b budng bok fo ou Lg Sk uuum, Ewng y. UB Lw udn n h b p k qud of vy w gdu n h 21 nuy job mk. Sudn n ou LAWR ou no ony n o u h w by nd -ofh- ompu g db, hy dvop h ny nd wng k by hng nd podung of wn gnmn, uh g mmond nd moon.agnmn vwd by mmb of ou fum LAWR fuy, of whom ond wy wh xnv p xpn. LAWR fuy mmb m ndvduy wh f-y udn on gu b nd povd dd qu of h wok. A of h vy, Ewng y, nudng h hoo ufu hnqu pogm nd u n o nd non moo ou ompon, dound o h hoo bnf n m of puon, boh h vby d by hong ompon nd h pfomn of UB Lw udn ompon o h ouny.and u bd u Ewng y h UB Lw h bn b o b mo v n fdng m, mkng h m b ppd o omp on non v. Ao und h Lg Sk umb h hoo pogm of xnhp. Ewng y mny mo udn kng dvng of h unpd, fo-d xpn n jud khp, n w off nd n no-fo-pof nd govnmn gn. Mny mo jud xnhp hv dvopd, h d, und h dhp of Do of Exnhp Pogm L Gn. Admno o wokng o mn nd nddz h wok po of h w joun pubhd UB Lw,und h don of Ao Pofo Rk Su.And h hoo dm uppo pogm, dd by Bb Shk, h bom p of h Lg Sk nv, wh uppo fo udn ppng fo h b xm nd oh pofon dvopmn v. Aumn nvovmn Th Lw Shoo umn oho, who ngy gn ngh of h nuon, h ppd up o nfo h ffo nd o hp nw gdu ngo h ky w of h g hng po. Eh of h fou off umn hp h ubn ng omm, y L M. Mu, n do of h UB Lw Aumn Aoon, nd h um hv om fowd wh mjo nv n uppo of un udn nd nw gdu. A h hp wn o do omhng h

13 11 nvov udn nggmn, h y. Th y bough h ond nmn of Roh Dy h hoo,n whh 14 umn fom h Roh wh h Lw Shoo ondg onnon of umn p gv h-p pogm h nudd ndvdu pnon, pn duon nd hn m-goup mnong on.a m D.C. Dy h nodud udn o h pob fo p n h non p. A mjo nv umm, o b pd h umm, pogm of mok nvw by umn png n Nw Yok Cy.Af h C Sv Off hpd up n nnv ound of nvw fo udn fm n h y,ub Lw umn h w mhd wh udn kng wok n h p. Thy dd om mok nvw, pppng h udn fo h hng nd dung h nxy v of h job h.af h nvw w ov, h w o ghng fo umn nd udn m fo dbfng nd budng pofon onnon. Th p of w, k ny pofon, vy dpndn on onhp, Mu y. Somm ho onhp d o mpoymn, omm hy d o fuh n. Ou umn povd ou udn wh nvub pofon on. Th nv om on op of h hoo nwok h pu popv udn, un udn, udn wokng fo umm n n,n ouh wh umn voun fo om nfom mnong, nd UB Lw fom mnong pogm, n whh fy udn mhd wh pofon mno. Th udn gn on Sond-y udn Fnk Ewng (no on o h pofo), pdn of h Sudn B Aoon, y h h n n nmn gowh n pofon k dvopmn n ju h m h h bn UB Lw. I vy p, h y. W hv wo oo ony: ou wn wok nd whv om ou of ou mouh. To h xn h w n n h k h bo boh of ho, w n good p. Evn n h y g of h mph on k, ng o py off. Th SBA, whh omp 32 ub nd ognzon nudng fv dm joun nd hfdozn moo ou onng f owd k dvopmn w. I h d pk n whh pomnn o ony nd judg k bou wh hy do, hn m nfomy wh m goup of udn. You n g 20 udn ound h vy bgh nd ngn pop n ozy ng, Ewng y. A o of wyng bd on onhp. To h xn h w n f onhp-budng, h wh w gong o do. On Ap 2, h SBA hod h Lw Shoo f Dy of Sv, ndng udn no h ommuny fo voun ffo of o. I hnk omm h y fog h w hv who poo of n nd nu bndwdh h h myb hy no ung muh hy houd, Ewng y. Connud on pg 12 W hv wo oo ony: ou wn wok nd whv om ou of ou mouh. To h xn h w n n h k h bo boh of ho, w n good p. Evn n h y g of h mph on k, ng o py off. Fnk Ewng 12, Sudn B Aoon pdn

14 12 Fou on Lg Sk U B L A W F O R U M S P R I N G W gvng h udn n oppouny o omhng vy p h vydy wokng of ou, how ou k md dpu o un p onfn, how judg. And hy n h hng, k bng punu, how o dd h ou, how o pk o you oppong oun. Thy h hng nd n hm. Joph M. Hnn 05, Mnoy B Aoon pdn A dv nvonmn Rognzng h duon vu of dv udn body, w nung o h S Unvy of Nw Yok ym ony w hoo, o ky o budng g ommuny h f h wd ommuny. In onjunon wh UB Md Fmo Cog nd h Mnoy B Aoon of Wn Nw Yok, h Lw Shoo p of k fo md ung nd nng qufd mnoy udn. Th k fo pogm hv vn hd down o h mny v of h Buffo Pub Shoo ( pnon, Godok on T, o g young hnkng bou w ), pk hgh hoo on g nd w hoo, nd, n h pnnng g, p-w ppoy pogm fo og fhmn nd ophomo, d Expo Lw, h k o xpnd h poo of qufd mnoy ppn o UB Lw. Joph M. Hnn 05, pdn of h Mnoy B Aoon of Wn Nw Yok, y h oon ommd o uppong UB Lw Shoo mnoy udn n p k h w hp hm ud n h g wod. On of my gnd m o onn wh UB Lw Shoo nd onn wh dv udn, y Hnn, pn n h Buffo w fm Godbg Sg. Thy ou fuu d, no ony of h g ommuny bu of Wn Nw Yok. W nd h udn o wok n h ommuny, nd know h w h o mno hm nd hp hm nd p ong p p nd nfomon. Towd h nd, h Mnoy B Aoon h ponod pn h hoo, nd on Ap 5 pnd w-ndd foum d P h B Th F Tm. No w udn om dy fom undgdu hoo, Hnn y. Thy my hv fm o nd kd hom. Aong wh pndng h ny m o udy, hy hv o h hdn. So h pn nudd wy n ju h uon who dd p h b w wy who ddn p h f m, bu pd un hy dd. Th Mnoy B Aoon o h bhd khp pogm fo mnoy udn, png hm n mn, v nd fmy ou houghou Wn Nw Yok. Mo hn 13 judg hv xpd n n h pogm, Hnn y. W gvng h udn n oppouny o omhng vy p h vydy wokng of ou, how ou k md dpu o un p onfn, how judg.and hy n h hng, k bng punu, how o dd h ou, how o pk o you oppong oun. Thy h hng nd n hm. In onjunon wh h Mnoy B Aoon, h Lw Shoo o wokng o u gn o bng 25 o 30 ddvngd o og udn o h mpu n h umm o k v wk of w ou o b ugh by fu-m fuy.

15 13 LOOKING GOOD! Mjo novon nhn h mbn of O Bn H You nv g ond hn o mk f mpon. So h hound of pop who n John Lod O Bn H h dy udn, fuy, dmno, vo, pon udn w fnd fnd, mo pofon nd mo nvng p whn h Lw Shoo ubn novon ompd h y. Th novon, whh onnd on h hghy ffkd f foo, bng fundd by h Unvy Buffo nd by pv donon o h Lw Shoo. Compon xpd by Oob. Th f foo nd nn of ny budng ng mpon on vo nd oupn, y Dn Mku W. Muu. W -ng h f foo o gv pofon ook nd mk omfob nd womng p fo udn, fuy, ff, umn nd vo. On ompd, w nfom h vu mpon of UB Lw. Jm R.Nwon,v dn fo dmnon, y h hv u of h f foo udn y nhu bou. Th y h p; hy pnd 80 pn of h m on h f foo. Epy popu h n novon of h f-foo udn oung, omphd wh bqu fom Mh Don 82 nd mjo gf fom h fmy nd ogu. Th poj nud nw wndow, bnd, png nd funu o omfob fo ovbudnd w udn. Th mn nywy,n h vo, h nw ghng, wood-ook foong nd woodn oumn.a f of oh mpovmn nud nw bnh, budng doy, ng, 30-foo woodn dpy fo fuy hohp nd noh o dpy udn oph fom moo ou ompon, fm gvng w honong op umn dono o h Lw Shoo, nd nw hndppd-b oom offng g py fo fm udn. Two f-n mono w b nd, on fung dmnv nnounmn nd on fo udn u. Php mo gnfny, nw vbu bng nd o v mn nn o h h omhng h nv hd n 38-y hoy.sudn w kd o vo on h dgn of h funhng nd ho n gny uvd woodn pon dk. A ondy poj o n ond-foo oung oppo h nn o h Lw Lby. Th poj n fn puh owd ompon, k ompd by h nd o mnmz onuon no n wokng Lw Shoo. Summ, nudng b vw ou, w b movd ou of h f-foo u h h umm o ommod onuon. Th f-foo h f mpon pop hv vo nd popv udn py, Nwon y. Bu mo mpony, h poj nndd o mpov h quy of f fo udn. In ddon, h f of mjo upgd n hnoog pby omp, wh wo mn f-foo oom Room 106 nd 108 now wd fo on hng hnoog. Th poj om foowng uvy n whh fuy mmb w kd wh hnoog woud hp hm h b, nd f Tn E. MComk,hd of h M.Rob Kon Cn fo Cn Lg Eduon nd nm mng of Lw Shoo hnoogy, vd w hoo nonwd h how h nuon hnoogy ky omponn of h nng xpn. I fu h on wh udn, h y, who ouny u YouTub p nd Pow- Pon n h own pnon. Ou m, h y, o mov owd hng hnoog h funon fo hng nd nng, bu o npn pob. A UB Lw bud wy dy fo h fuu, hy w xp nohng.

16 14 Fou on Lg Sk U B L A W F O R U M S P R I N G Moo Cou: Th mo vub xpn I hd n w hoo, udn y Th fon, bu whn UB Lw Shoo udn pou h nd ou no moo ou ompon, h moon oo. Sudn unfomy h xpn n moo ou, whh hom o on h od, h mo vub xpn I hd n w hoo. Lg knowdg good. Bu wh pupo do v f you no dvnng fo h bnf of n o n fon of judg o juy? y E Couny Cou Judg Thom P. Fnzyk, who wh ony Choph O Bn ov h Lw Shoo dvoy pogm. I h you k, ny k, h by o hnk on you f, o gu. Evn f you nv foo n ouoom wy, nvub nng. Und h don of Pofo Gog Knn, do of moo ou, UB Lw udn ppon n h x boh nmu nd xn. Th Lw Shoo un on moo ou ompon ony fo UB Lw udn: h Ch S. Dmond Moo Cou Compon. I o pono wo ompon h opn o w udn fom o h non: h Ab R. Mug Tx Lw Compon (h f-v x ompon) nd h Wh Cmn Lw Moo Cou (h ony ompon n h non dvod oy o ubnv mn w). In ddon, UB Lw udn v o omp n fu ng of nonwd ompon, nudng vn ponod by h Amn B Aoon, h Fd B Aoon nd h Amn Aoon fo Ju. Pofo Lund M. Fny oh wo of h m. Oh nonwd vn n whh UB Lw m pp nud ompon dng wh Audy Hmn 11 nd Choph Mon 11 won h Ab R. Mug Tx Moo Cou Compon. nnon w nd g h. Th own jw of h pogm h Buffo-Ng Tounmn, hd n h f, on of h g uh ompon n h non. Lo judg nd ony om UB Lw umn, om no voun h m judg fo h ompon hd n Wn Nw Yok. Som hghgh fom h png on: A h Php C. Jup Innon Lw Moo Cou Compon n Fbuy, h UB Lw m ong howng nudd wnnng xh-b bf nd vng wo wd fo o gumn. M Ovbk w ognzd h fouh-b o n h gon nd Angyn Dgo w ognzd h gon nnh-b o. Kvn Epno 09 nd Mh Hk 09 ohd h m. A h Ng Cup Innon Moo Cou Compon, n Toono, whh fou on nnon g dpu bwn Cnd nd h Und S, UB Lw m no ony dvnd o h ompon qufn, bu pd ond ov f h pmny ound. I o bough hom mup wd fo wn nd o dvoy. Knnh Ghm nd Job MNm, ogh wh Rb Gu, won unn-up B Appn Mmo (bf). Jon Ubnk won ondp O Advo, nd Kyn Fu won hd-p O Advo. Chn P. Bhoomw of h UB Lw fuy vd oh. A UB Lw m onng of hd-y udn Choph Mon nd Audy Hmn won h Ab R. Mug Tx Moo Cou Compon, bng m fom John Mh Lw Shoo. Hmn w o nmd h 2011 ompon' hd-b o dvo, nd h wnnng UB m vd n honob mnon fo bf. Ao Pofo Su G. Lz dfd h pobm fo h ompon. Th 13h nnu Hb Wh Non Cmn Lw Moo Cou Compon, hd n y Ap n h downown Buffo Cy Couhou, nudd m fom 23 w hoo o h non, nudng wo m fom UB Lw.Th wnnng m pnd M Unvy W F. Gog Shoo of Lw, wh ondp hono gong o m fom h Apphn Shoo of Lw. Oh m ompng pnd h Unvy of Mhgn, Nw Yok Unvy, h Unvy of Wonn, Wm & My,Amn Unvy nd h Unvy of Cfon Dv.

17 15 Q&A wh Judg Fnzyk nd wy Ch O Bn, o-do of h dvoy pogm E Couny Cou Judg Thom P. Fnzyk nd ony Choph O Bn, of h Buffo w fm O Bn Boyd, o-d h Lw Shoo dvoy pogm. UB Lw Foum ny pok wh h ky fgu n h hoo pogm o dvop gon nd o dvoy k. UB Lw Foum:Th moo ou xpn bou gon k. Bu mo wy don do gon, do hy? O Bn:On hng h I know fom png wy,on you y,you nv gn vw of f h m wy.on you y moo vh, ff how you do you n nk, ff how you do you dpoon, ff you pdng, ff p of, bu now you hnkng,wh gong o hppn f I hv o y h? Fnzyk: You hv o b dy, wng nd b o y f you don g foy off n v o foy p n mn. I hnk o of dm mundnd o mpphnd h who pon of h x. I fo w udn o wy o vu who of f n gh of h w nd b dy o y h f ny o how you opponn you dy, wng nd b o do.and ho h wy who E Couny Cou Judg Thom P. Fnzyk nd ony Choph O Bn gny g h b u. Evn f you don go o, vub of k o hv.and h nun ompn nd h oh wy know f you h yp of wy who n bk up h o h dmnd wh k n h ouoom. Th wh w h h udn.and hy gny h on who g h b nd hv h mo ufu u. UB Lw Foum:Wh k do ppn n h xpn om wy wh? O Bn:L k ook omon who gong o p x w,who g nvovd n hnqu nd hn mov on o ompon.and n om n nd hm bou wh h u, wh h pobm. Thy gong o b hnkng,, on dy I mgh wnd up n h U.S.Tx Cou bou h.and f I m gong o wnd up h,i d b know wh h w.now,i v dy bn ugh h w fom my w pofo n x,bu now wh I m gong o b dong ppyng h w o n of f.so I m gong o k quon h ohw I mgh hv md.a h m m, I m gong o b zng up h n dby.no m wh yp of w you dong, mp gh fom h wh you n nvw of pon n nd you ny. Fnzyk:Th k h w y o h o hp h udn o hnk no ony nuy bu o hnk gy, n m of gng h b pob u fo h n.w uu h ou ound f pn h hy w umy b yng h nd of h m.w h hm f nd fomo how o d h, y, nyy, houghfuy, n m of no ju h w nd h mn of poof,bu wh h hm nd ho of h? How w gong o pp o juy on humn v? Thn w h hm h nu nd bo of wyng.how o gv n opnng mn n m of how o onn wh h juy. How o dvop hm nd ho of h h w onn wh h juy.how o gv pop d xmnon o h you n h wn oy n ompng wy.how o do h mhn of gng n xhb no vdn. How o y h foundon fo n xp o b b o gv h opnon n h ouoom. How o o-xmn wn, whh pobby h mo dffu hng.thn how o pu ogh n ong gumn n ompng wy h don ju hh h f bu gu h u h you yng o g h juy o buy no.so ombnon of w, gy nd yng o undnd nd ommun wh pop. UB Lw Foum: Cn nw wy y b fuy dy o p on dy on? Fnzyk:Th o hy n g.wh hy dong n mok ng u o f you n g. O Bn: I d my f pnff whn I w ju bou fv y ou of w hoo.nobody hd ugh m how o bk down wn mn nd pp wn nd h b wy o onu o-xmnon. I wound up gong hough 10 y of onnung g duon mn. Th udn gng of h CLE bfo hy v v h Lw Shoo.I hnk hy hv mndou dvng ov udn fom oh w hoo. P of h w v hd g d of uppo fom Dn Muu dmnon nd wh h hp of Dn Ewng, yng h w wn h o b don nd w gong o fou on nd w gong o hod you ounb. Fnzyk:Thy v y md poy. Fo fu np of h onvon, v poT.p.

18 16 Fou on Lg Sk U B L A W F O R U M S P R I N G Lnng o h xp Joy Y. Hfd Hon. Hny Sudd Mku W. Muu nd Cg Pon 76 A Lw Shoo dmno fuh fn h hoo uuum nd pogm o mphz pofon k dvopmn, hy n dong o n vuum.two mjo nv n h p dm y hv ough npu fom boh mmb of h Lw Shoo ommuny udn, fuy nd ff nd fom judg n h Wn Nw Yok g ommuny. Gugng ou pog h go of UB Lw ppon n h Lw Shoo Suvy of Sudn Enggmn, non uvy h podud wh of nfomon pf o h hoo. Th uvy xpod uh hm To wh xn do udn dvo m nd ngy o v h fuh h duon? nd Wh po nd p do hoo u o noug udn o ud, boh dmy nd pofony? Th uvy hd phnomn 54 pn pon mong udn. Th u hk book of h, gph nd numb n ndo of wh UB Lw nd gh now,nd php mp fo fuu gowh. Hon. Ro Son 73 Th bgg bnf bnhmkng gn youf, y Jm R. Nwon, v dn fo dmnon, who wh Cn Pofo Suznn E. Tomkn o-hd ff-fuy-udn omm h dmnd h uvy nd nyzd h u. Th omm pnd n noduoy PowPon pnon n wo opn on fo h Lw Shoo ommuny, hn hd of vn fou goup o du h uvy u, gn d nd ugg hng o p nd po n pon o h uvy fndng. Nwon y h hoo ommd o png h uvy h y,boh o mu pog nd o onnu o dnfy oppoun fo mpovmn. Anoh nfomon-ghng ffo ook p n Fbuy, LAWR fuy mmb hd fom ju nd oh od wh h Nw Yok S Supm Cou. Togh h judg nd h nuo bnomd d bou wh k nw wy nd,how w h LAWR pogm hng hm, nd how h Lw Shoo oud mpov fuh owd h go. UB Lw ommd o podung p-dy ony, d Dn Mku W. Muu, who w pn h ghng. Th why I d h mng wh h judg o g h d on how w n nhn ou h nd wng uuum o podu h b wy pob. Rpnng h judy w wo Supm Cou ju: Hon. Hny Sudd, pdng ju of h App Dvon, Fouh Dpmn; nd Hon. Ro Son 73, o of h App Dvon, Fouh Dpmn. Thy w jond by Cg Pon 76, hf App Cou ony; P Mogn, k of h ou fo h App Dvon, Fouh Dpmn; nd, ompnyng Ju Son, Joy Y. Hfd, xuv do of h Fnkn H.Wm Jud Common on Mno, Unfd Cou Sym, Off of Cou Admnon, n Nw Yok Cy. Foun Lw Shoo pofo, dmno nd ff o ook p n h fnk xhng of d. Som ommn vovd ound pu fom ud n h App Dvon: h bnh mmo. Pon dbd k h: W off wh h nu of h, h u h h p ng, gv f pn ovvw of h, gv fy dd ummy of h od wh on o pg n h od,nd hn h w n w dd u h h p hv d.thy go on nd do h own ndpndn g h. Th w b ummzd n duon on. W uon h w n h no w vw.i uppod o ummz h w fo h ou o w n quky g no h u. Eny h wh h wok,h nd wng. Pon nod h w hv hd mny good w n fom h Unvy Buffo.W hv hd mo w n fom h Buffo Lw Shoo hn fom ny oh w hoo, nd w hv bn vy hppy wh hm.

19 17 Nw nuo boo h nd wng Th hgh-pof hng n UB Lw Shoo g k uuum now d LAWR, fo Lg Any, Wng nd Rh h ddon of qud hd m of g h nd wng nng fo udn dung h ond y. In h f wo m of h nd wng, udn n h ub fo how wy ondu h, ognz n gumn nd w y nd puvy n g fom. Th ddon m-ong ou, nd n pon o nvw wh judg, jud k nd ony, w uvy of oh op U.S. w hoo uuum, off udn ddon ohng n h ndpnb k. Th hoo h hd wo nw nuo wh gnfn k nd xpn n h mpon o hp mpmn h ddon ou. Bnd Co un h vd fom 2005 o 2009 h nd wng nuo UB Lw, vng o bom onfdn w k o U.S. D Cou Judg Wm M. Skny. In h khp, h hd myd of mn nd v g u; dfd popod don nd od; nd upvd w k nd nn, nudng nng hm n h nd wng k. Sh um ud gdu of Con Lw Shoo. On of h bg puh omng fom h b, Co y, fo udn o hv mo p xpn wh g k, n pu h nd wng. Th d o gv hm mo xpou o ho k. Th nw ou, h y, w povd mo oppoun fo udn o p h k hy hv dy nd, nd nodu om nw m. I w b uud o gv hm g dph of xpn, Co y. Sudn omm don z how muh hy u h k n p.whh hy nd up n pub v, pv p o govnmn wok, h k w n. Chng n h pofon, h y, hv md vn mo u h w hoo povd h -wod k. A p h bom mo foud on bb hou, h y, nw o no gng h mnong w fm h hy woud g n h p.you no gong o b h b wy you n b n h f y ou of w hoo. Bu on of h g hng bou p h you go ong, h b you g nd h mo xpnd you g. And h xpn nv g dvud. Sh xd bou unng o h oom, h y, py bu hn o oh udn bou h hngng of h pofon. A ong k pogm UB n no ony bnf h hoo bu o hv n mp on h pofon n mnngfu wy, h y. H ogu Mon W 94 n h h nd wng pogm n oppouny o hp hp h nx gnon of UB Lw Shoo gdu nd hp povd hm wh h oo h hy nd o ud. I h pogm vdn h h Lw Shoo ou bou nd fmy ommd o hpng ou gdu m h xodny dmnd of png w. Sh, oo, no h hngng nu of h pofon, puy h m dmnd h ony f. You y qud o b on ound h ok, h y. Th pofon bomng mo of bun n mny wy, nd qu wy o b mo nv o how muh m hy pnd bng h n. Pon who n podu good-quy wok vy ffn fo h n w b wdd. W h vd n 1998 onfdn w k o U.S. D Cou Judg Rhd J. A. In h py, h h pfomd h on ompx g u; nyzd ppb u, gv hoy nd w; ondud p onfn nd mn onfn; nd d wh p of v nd mn bfo h ou. Dwng on ho xpn, w d fom n ympoum on hng dvnd g wng, W xp h hd-m ou w fuh fn h k h udn qu n h f wo on of h nd wng. On of h go of h g wng pogm o hp udn fuh dvop h g wng nd ny k by qung hm o dd mo ompx g u, h y. I bou p n h of o nd wn dvoy, nd h mo oppoun udn h o p, h b. W w do om dp ny of ompx g u h w nvov dffn fom of g dfng wok. W o b nodung udn o how hy houd pn hmv n dng wh n.a wy h o pn h o h hough n, puv, ophd mnn, whh o judg, n o bod of do. H own g wok hoy, whh nud khp h pp ou v nd wok n gon, povd, h y, bod ng of xpn o dw on n h oom. I v ondud h nd ny on ho of ompx v nd mn w u, n on dozn of, vwd hundd of bf, h y. I v n boh oundng nd poo dvoy, nd dvopd om ong k myf. In ddon, h y, h h wokd ouny wh udn nn, nudng ho fom UB Lw, n h D Cou off. P of my job o gn h, gv hm om gudn, hv hm gv m df don o bnh mmo, hn vw nd gv hm fdbk. I y hv njoyd h. Bnd Co, u n Lw, Lg Any, Rh nd Wng Mon W 94, u n Lw, Lg Any, Rh nd Wng

20 18 U B L A W F O R U M S P R I N G Lw Shoo Rpo Th xpn fo In h UB Lw oom wh Amny Innon vo of onn Muh of my y wok w n ounng fug who hd gon hough um xpn nd yng o hp hm bud h v. Pofo In Zubd Khn In UB Lw Shoo vnh-foo mn oom, bgn wh mov. Sxn udn h hoho-hpd b o h pop nd wh h fm podu of h Und Non Off of h Hgh Common fo Rfug oun h nguhd oy of n Indn mn who wf nd nfn hd dd fo k of npoon o hop. Wodwd, mo hn 500,000 womn h y d n hdbh, h no non. Mn moy humn gh u. Whng ong wh hm Vng Pofo In Zubd Khn. Th mn d Humn Rgh nd Povy, nd Khn of-pokn nv of Bngdh who ny ompd gh y y-gn of Amny Innon bngng o h unqu ppv hond n h nh of nnon humn gh dvoy. Th h ooonom u, bu h ky fo bnh gh, h h udn whn h gh om bk on. I kp omng bk o h u. Khn hng wo mn UB Lw h png (h ond Bun nd Humn Rgh) h nvon of Dn Mku W. Muu. Sh y h h found h ondnd hd-y udn n h mn o b nggd, bu wng wh h undon fou of h hng. Wh hy fndng qu hngng h I m pnng u o hm pon, h y. Fo xmp, udn ud o hnkng bou how u g ovd n ou. Bu I hm, wh my u, mo poo pop do no go o ou o fgh fo h gh. Thy do no hv h mony o go o ou, nd hy do no hv fh n h ym. So w du h m of h fom g ym nd ook humn gh n h onx of o of hng: ognzng pop, ppyng pu hough obbyng, whv you hv o do o bng hng. Lw on oo mong mny, nd ofn you u gon you o. I vub ppv udn mny dwn o UB Lw by Humn Rgh Cn nd h dm ound humn gh wok n om of h n of -wod dvoy. I n dvng h Khn hf dd no hv n h own g nng. Whn I w Hvd Lw (h gdud n 1979), hy dd no vn hv ou n humn gh, h y. Humn gh w no ondd pb ubj fo w hoo.a o of my xpou o humn gh wok m fwd. I go h nd fvo fo how humn gh wok n p I w vng fug mp nd nvwng fug. Muh of my y wok w n ounng fug who hd gon hough um xpn nd yng o hp hm bud h v. Th up-o-nd-pon vw on hough h. Fo xmp, h bough bk fom n nnu mng on womn u h Und Non, o h hd womn bou vng wh HIV n oun wh h u n mn fob zon o vn, n h of pgnny, fod boon. I d o om vy vy duon bou, how do you hng h uon fo h womn? h y. Lg duon xmy mpon bu bou ju, h u of w nd uud hnkng. Bu whn h udn bng h dm knowdg o h wod, hy w nd o hnk vy. In h nd, pop bhnd h w h w udy n h book. Gy Img

21 19 Budng h dvopmn m Jff P jon UB Lw Th hoo h ndby omphd umn who hv bn vy womng o m nd who bv n h mpon of gvng bk. W don wn hm o o ouh wh h hoo. Jff P Jff P no ng o v. H h bn od wo fo mo of h h y n n do of dvopmn pogm h Unvy of Roh, h m m. H now jonng h fundng m UB Lw Shoo, wh h w v nony Fod, D.C., Noh Con, Cfon nd Mhu w houghou Nw Yok S, o m umn, bng hm up o d on h Lw Shoo n hvmn nd qu h uppo. I m vy mpd wh h hng Dn Muu h md o h dm pogm, y P. H h d dynm uuum h hng h udn nd pp hm fo f f w hoo. I m onvnd h UB Lw, f h h ny ou, poond o bom on of h b w hoo n h ouny. I ook fowd o hpng omph h go. P gw up n Spngv, m own 25 m ouh of Buffo. An xpon h, h d h mghy Gffn foob m qubk o hmponhp n h no y. H onnud o d on h fd h Unvy of Roh, wh h w h ng qubk fo fou y. I v nd h vu of onhp fom pyng foob, P y. You m o mny g pop nd bud bond wh hm, nd you nv o h.you n how o wok owd ommon go m. Th obov p nd pn vub n h dvopmn wod. Af gdung n 2001 wh bho dg n onom nd onnon n mkng mngmn, h bm n n foob oh h Unvy of Roh. H wokd on wky gm pnnng, ppd hm nd oung po, hpd un p nd ud udn h. H hn pn h y n Buffo wokng fo n nun ompny bfo unng o h Unvy of Roh nd bgnnng h dvopmn wh h Shoo of Engnng nd h Shoo of A nd Sn. H m h Unvy of Roh w w pn, nhnng h bf n h mpon of hgh duon nd hpng hm hon h k n h nw pofon. Fo h wo y P ommud o Roh fom Snyd, ubub of Buffo, wh h v wh h wf, Lun, phy duon h nd h w. Boh ov h Wn Nw Yok ommuny nd P dghd o b wokng n Buffo p of h Lw Shoo m. Th w pf oppouny o wok fo hgh-quy hoo nd f pop n my own bk yd, y P. I wondfu o bng mpv, pov nw o h umn I m vng. W hv bgh udn body, whh bng ugh by nd pofo nd ppng o bom h nx gnon of ong g pofon, h onnu. Th hoo h ndby omphd umn who hv bn vy womng o m nd who bv n h mpon of gvng bk.w don wn hm o o ouh wh h hoo.w wn h npu, nd w wn hm o know bou h dvnmn bng md h. Th ong w mk h Lw Shoo nd h Unvy, h mo vub h w dg w bom. W nno hv ou pon whou hp fom ou umn nd fnd.wh h mg w hv o h, I know w w b ufu. Jff P n b hd (716) o jjp@buffo.du.

22 20 U B L A W F O R U M S P R I N G Nw Fuy Budng knowdg, p by p u fo Sn hough h Phoophy hnkng n ow moon. Th fomu my no hv ognd wh Mhw Sn Ph.D. dv, bu h ung udy of phoophy nd on hough Snfod Lw Shoo nd g. Sn, who jon h UB Lw fuy h f, h don om hnkng n h m.a Mnno nv, h nd h bho dg n phoophy, mgn um ud, h Con Cog, hn wn on o doo pogm n phoophy Nohwn Unvy. Foowng w hoo Snfod nd fd pp khp, h h wokd n gon h Sn Fno off of h Whngon, D.C., w fm Covngon & Bung. Sn found hmf dwn o phoophy, h y, bu ndug h ov of nu puzz. Somm you bv you undnd omhng bou h wod, h y, nd whn you ow down nd xmn why you v om o h onuon you v om o, vyhng o f p. Fo pop who njoy nu nquy nd h f of h mnd, h fng of xpong omhng you hough you undood o w y njoyb. Sn y whn h w dy o mk h p fom p no g hng, h w dwn o UB Lw puon p h vu ndpny hohp. I w vdn, h y, whn h dvd ndd pp h w mo phooph hn w yp g hohp. Th pop who w h up. Th v of nggmn wh h ubn of my k nd wh my bod of n w phnomn. I gong o b g p o On hng h w hoo houd do fo udn, whv h k, o puh hm b. Ao Pofo Mhw Sn my h. O onnu, uy. Sn w n v hng n Nohwn, nd wokd o n oh TA n oom hnqu. I y njoy hng, y Sn, who n ou w b n Conuon w nd v podu. I vy dffn fom p. Whn you povdng v o pyng n, you hv o mov quky. Th no m o - h foundon of h w fom h gound up. In hng, I know wh I wn o go nd I fgu ou of p, nd I n dw ou of udn h vw on n p of h ubj nd kp hm movng n h don I wn hm o mov. No h wy omfob, h knowdg. On hng h w hoo houd do fo udn, whv h k, o puh hm b, Sn y. If you no wokng on dvopng h u of k you om wh, w hoo dong you dv. H g xpn b h ou.a w k o Hon. Km V. Lpz of h U.S. Cou of App, F Cu, n Pond, Mn, h nd o by ng h judg w hough how o ov nd y do h b o h p fy nd pnd gnfn m undndng h fu b of h nd h w. A Covngon & Bung, Sn wokd on wo g : hpng o pn BP n ffo o obn nun ovg fo o ng ou of h Dpw Hozon dn, nd pnng pnff po bono n gng dmnon by Mop Couny, Az., Shff Joph Apo. Th pofo nd h wf, K H Sn, fon w, hv 14-monh-od dugh, W. H y hy ookng fowd o dong om hkng n h nd, bu hy ov h oudoo, gd o b bk n fou-on oy.

23 nof h h ngi y nj oy bou h ng, " yan hony O' Rou k,whoj o n hub L wf u y h f," g ng hoppo un y ob n nf o m m n o.i ywond f u o you ud n pp y ng h g n ng o v h ommun. " Fo x mp,h y,onofh ud n Co umb L ws hoo,wh h n d hj. D. ndwh h v n o n w, d u o ng pub h gh hoo ud n n d n w." To you ud n h ng h du onw ho h, "O' Rou k y," h y f y ng. " A h of g h nd w ng Co umb,o' Rou k yh wo kw h ud n " noon yon h m h n of g w ng,buonhow g on ngwo k,how o n p u ndhow o ng g n gum n b don w ndp d n. Th ow ud n o h nk n g onp hn wyo kf m P u, W,R f k nd, Wh on&g on.i n dd on oh nd ng u f ud nd u m p m, hwo k dp obonoongu n n mo d n ndont x d hp n y nvo v ngm n y d d d f nd n." I w hwo k h d f n oun h odo op o n n, "h y. O Rou k o k df ou. S.D Cou j udg nph d ph." W h d oof m n on hdo k, nd ob xpo d o h m n j u y mf om h p p vw f n ng. H o k df oj udgof hn n hc u Cou ofapp, n P d n,c f o n,b f o u n ng o Co umb L ws hoo o h nd ondu h. Th h,now o on nu nbuf f o, ud h n onof m n p o du nd u u on u on d p y bou hqu on h y on- w." I ' mv y n d nhowpo f on n h ub n v w. nd n u on u u f f h I ' oof o h of h w opof h gh w nj oy,p u y hoo du on. " n h of m n p o du.touno' Rou k,whog wupn D - d ndhow on u on do n o,m h g n,pu u ddoub vo v,i h nk n y o x m n m j o n onom ndph o ophy how h n u on h m k on u hun v yofm h g n,wh on wop np. " hg du dw hh ghhono.h Ahh dup,o' Rou k h n p n woy nw h ng on y B u f f o m n d h m o f h n hi n n h hom ownd o nbo h on Mon yfund,wo k ngon " h h n g h y f u d ohum n gh, bo ndwh ' x ng bou h y. Wh gh ndg nd m n m ng u k m b o u B u f f o, " h y, " h h y n dw h hi MF' o x n o w h h h L w S h o o o m m u nom m on.i n ngw hof f n y ng g d nwo k h mpo n Un dn on g n, o m p o v n g h y. T h u d n h boun on ndnongov nm n h v o m u h p o n o h v n m p o g n z on,h y,h p dh m o o n w h h p p n n g o u n d h m. " und ndb hdyn m of Rou k m d och n po n u on, nd h omp - O' V n d o, w h o w b V n g A n dd m n onof onom po y P o f o o f G n d S u d n U B d b. p m noft n n on S ud. Af w hoo,o Rou kwo k d D A

24 22 U B L A W F O R U M S P R I N G Nw Fuy Tyng ogh n h oom Idon k o b h on wy dong h kng, Mhw Dmk, who jon h UB Lw Shoo fuy n Spmb, y of h hng y. Whn I hnk of h pofo I kd b n Ofn you n mo bou you own ym of w o u whn you udy dffn on. Ao Pofo Mhw Dmk w hoo, hy dd v hng. Thy kd pop quon, bu hy o woud, h nd of h, pnd m yng ogh. Thy uuy bough n b of hoy h o dd om of h wok of pung hng ogh. Dmk, Con Lw Shoo gdu who py bo w, bng wh hm doo dg n ooogy fom h Unvy of Wonn-Mdon. H y udyng bo w fom ompv ppv h don ookd unon dmoy n h Und S nd G Bn n ffv wy o undnd h w n onx. Ofn you n mo bou you own ym of w o u whn you udy dffn on, h y. I hn h h quon om: Why do w do h wy f hy do h wy? I hnk o of good nng n om h wy. H o ondng pobmbd hng mhod n whh h pofo pn f no nd h udn, n ff, wy, wokng hough h p n hndng nd gng goundng n h ny, h nd wng h ony do vy dy. Dmk, who gw up n Cfon By A nd hn n Dnv, w n Engh mjo Bghm Young Unvy.A Momon, h ompd h don wo y of mony wok (n L Vg) f h fhmn y of og, hn und o omp h dg. Boh n hgh hoo nd n my fhmn y, I hdn y fgud ou how o wok dmy, h y. Th mon y wh ugh m how o wok. H w dy hnkng of puung n dm whn h nd Con Lw Shoo, wh n m-wod ondn h w npd o puu bo w py whn h ook n mpoymn nd bo w fom UB Lw Pofo Dnn Avy, who w vng pofo Con h m. Lbo w n n I hd bfo w hoo, h y. My gou bkgound h omhng o do wh. Mny, f no, gon hv onn bou o nd onom ju. I hnk h pu nd on nk n om pon nd mnfd hmv n n n bo. Whn h vd UB Lw, Dmk y, h w mndd of h hoo ho ngh n bo w. Emu pofo Jm Aon Vu nd Aumpon n Amn Lbo Lw w-humbd fn on h bookhf, nd h pon o Pofo Avy nd Rob Snfd oh wh whom h ookng fowd o hng d. Th Lw Shoo uuum o dv h ofn hd o fnd good m of pop n fd, Dmk y. Bu h ogu, nudng pop fom h ooogy dpmn, bng dffn ppv, dffn ngh, nd xpou o d nd hng h you woud nv hv ohw. Dmk nd h wf, Axnd, hv on, Lm, 7, nd dugh, Nomnd, 3.

25 23 Enggng udn fom h Smnh Bb, who jon h UB Lw Shoo fuy h f, y h hng y h bn nfomd by wo xpn on pov, on no o muh. Th no-o-pov on w h xpn bng n wh pofo md h b.a m I hv n pofo py ony o h b, mo dvnd udn nd v vyon bhnd. I m dmnd o h mo b v nd mk u vy udn know h fundmn. Th pov xpn w on y n h hng h ugh hoy, mny Chpmn Unvy n Ong, Cf., bfo gong o w hoo fom w mno who hd on bn n o. H od m h bouy bov, you hv o kp h udn non, Bb oun. H gv m numb of dffn g, uh wkng h of h oom, o bngng n pop o u pon. Epy now h udn ung pop nd h o mny don, I bv h you hv o fnd wy o dw udn n. Tho on w nd h n good d UB Lw, p h w dwn o, h d, by h ndpny wok of h fuy. I w mpd wh h wy UB fogound h wok, h y. Th fuy m o hv Ph.D. o dvnd dg n oh dpn. Bb w dd h own doo o h mx.a S nv, h dd h undgdu wok n po n Wm Cog, hn wn I n fo ny w udn o n how o w fo n udn byond h g ommuny. Ao Pofo Smnh Bb on o n Ph.D. n hoy fom h Unvy of Cfon Bky, nd hn J.D. fom Snfod Lw Shoo. H hohp hon h nd ound h hoy of Amn fm nd jounm, nudng wo book: bogphy of gop qun Lou Pon d Th F Ldy of Hoywood (Unvy of Cfon P, 2005) nd Mov Czy: Fn, S nd h Cu of Cby (Pgv Mmn, 2001). Sh ddd o go o w hoo, h d, bu I hough woud mk m ong hnk. I v wy bn nd n h w, nd I w hng. I hough h I mgh b b o pk o bod udn nd pk n dp wy by knowng p of w. In h wng h h ombnd h k hon wh h ny mnd of g ho. In ddon o wng on h hoy of pvy w, h h o hd h dvopmn of w ound h onuon u of mov f ph. In 1915 don, h no, h U.S. Supm Cou hd h mov w m nnmn unpod by fdom of ph. No un h 1950 dd h ou v f nd knowdg h h mov w ndd pod by h F Amndmn. I dfny hoy nd w omng ogh n my hohp, y Bb, who uny vng k n Honouu fo judg of h Nnh Cu Cou of App. Sh w bng h ynh o h oom w. Th mk of g ho nd w n w, h y, on who n n ompx d no m h vydy pop n undnd nd u. I n fo ny w udn o n how o w fo n udn byond h g ommuny. Th wy h ponby o b pub duo.

26 24 U B L A W F O R U M S P R I N G Fuy Condd opnon In h nw book, UB Lw pofo pu ogh h nd dvoy Pofo Dvd Wbook, f, Pofo Jm A. Gdn, ow f, nd Pofo Ch Pk Ewng, bow. Pm xmp of h Lw Shoo ndpny ngh, h nw book by pomnn UB Lw pofo ng wdy no h o n, nnon poy-mkng nd h n of g udy. Togh hy f h quy of h nd wng h hv om o hz h w fuy nng pomnn n h wod of g hohp. Now ou n ppbk, Pofo Dvd Wbook Dpoyng Ouv: Im Von nd h Rponb Pojon of U.S. Fo (Pdgm Pubh) w, h y, ong m n omng. I v bn wokng on n h bkng p of Yugov n h y 1990, h y. I yzd gh f 9/11, bu oh book go n h wy. In Dpoyng Ouv,Wbook mk h fo vuon of U.S. fogn poy h ognz h of powfu ompng wodvw nd h nd o ponby nd onuvy n h u of my fo. Wh h Und S h ommd f o n Wod W II h on of n ngd gob od, h y. Bu h nno mn U.S.poj.Th U.S.py h o of h non h mo pb of pojng my fo.w do hv pofound ommmn goby. Bu h hng o fnd wy o onvd uy poy n wy h w n fnd pb. Wokng wh om of h d of 19h nuy Gmn my ho C von Cuwz, who pok of w po numn, Wbook dd h ompng dom h hv n on h wod g, nudng n Im po gmm nd doogy h h bn ud vony.th wy of kng bou h wod.bn Ldn pomong dffn od of h modn wod. In pon, h y, h Und S h ponby, whn ond h u o h h of my fo, o ond how h pk on h wod g. Th gumn h, h y, h U.S. von mn hng, nd h onqun of h von mn hng.how w fgh m bu how w fgh how w gn ou von. A g d of h uy onn of h Und S undndb o pop ound h wod.th quon,how do w puu ho onn,nd how do w nvov oh o? Th book, whh ndomn fom hnk n v dpn nd o h po pum, gd no poy-mk n h fd govnmn. I v wokd hd o mk h book m ufu o hm, Wbook y. I vy pn-pokn. Nw Fon of S Conuon Lw: Du Enfomn of Nom h pn-pokn of nw voum of y o-dd by UB Lw Pofo Jm A.Gdn, wh Fod S Unvy w pofo Jm Ro. Th voum, pubhd by Oxfod Unvy P,gw ou of 2006 onfn of judg nd dm

27 25 who nd n onuon w.i f gowng dg n h fd of onuon w: h no n u ound h U.S. Conuon bu n ho ng fom h 50 ndvdu onuon. W houd b hnkng bou ym n whh onuon nom nd vu n b gnd ndpndny wo v, boh nd fd, Gdn y. Th no on founn of onuon vu. Th po y dog. Th h of h voum h h onn, ongong onvon bou onuon vu nd nom. Th movmn n dm hohp h gnd m, h y, h Supm Cou h fd n nngy now undndng of h ndvdu gh gund by h U.S. Conuon. Lg ho puhng mo xpnv vw of gh nngy hv und o onuon, h of whh, Gdn y, onn own b of gh. Th nohng h pvn fom bng mo gnou wh gh hn h fd Conuon, h y. Exhb A fo h p v y h bn gy mg. Th fd ou hv d, fog. Bu ndvdu hv xndd h gh. Gdn h n y n h voum on hn p of onuon npon, h y nd o dd h pnp wok on h noduon. I hnk of ohn wy of hnkng bou h fd. Ju Pvd: Sx Offn Lw, Pyhoogy, nd Pub Poy (Oxfod Unvy P) Pofo Ch Pk Ewng vuon of pub poy ound how h w nd h mn ju ym hnd x offnd. Ewng du h o of mn hh pofon n oy pon o h offnd, ng y on whh punhmn nd mn hy uny dmnd ffv nd,n nd f m, o-ffv w. Th book fou on fou p of h w: v ommmn u, n whh offnd n b onfnd ndfny f h pon nn omp f hy dmd k fo offndng; x offnd gon, nofon nd on w; hd ponogphy w; nd w gn ung h Inn o xuy o mno. I hd no o b pub poy dvo f you wng bou h hng, Ewng y. W pndng on of mony,nd h y no vdn h dong ny good. Fo xmp,h y,h dm u nd h Mgn Lw nwok of w qung h x offnd g wh w nfo nd h h nm b pubzd mk -ny o dffu nd gmz offnd o muh h n mny wy dv hm undgound nd uy n dvm. In ddon, h y, h x offnd g nompng offnd fom fob p o pygo who mud h g of n v young womn ddd wh o nd xpo ho on h o vgn ju. On onuon Ewng dw h o h g houd b md o po nd ho nvovd n hng pop who wok wh hdn. Smy, h y, h hv pd v onfnmn w nudng, ju ny, Nw Yok pndng hug moun of mony o ok up offnd. Th Supm Cou h ud h uh dnon pmb f fo mn pupo. Bu h pogm no bou mn, hy bou non, Ewng y. Cy h no vdn h h guy who n h pogm gng nyhng ou of. I o Nw Yok xpy $175,000 y fo h pon n v onfnmn. Ewng gu nd fo h mo o-ffv ppoh kn by Tx, wh d x offnd oy monod n knd of up po nd d on n oupn b. If hy vo h po, m, nd hy go bk o pon. H mk m gumn ound h fgh gn hd ponogphy n unquond v,bu on h wdy unqu nd dpopoon pn. W ng poon of hd ponogphy h wy w woud mud, Ewng y. I hob, hob m, bu h o of h w ggng.i knd of k h dug pobm w v md ou gun h u nd no o muh h upp. So, fo xmp, fd nnng gudn hv ud n donn nn fo poon of hd ponogphy. Twny-y nn no unhd of, Ewng y. Th nnu o of kpng onvd hd pon dfndn n h fd pon ym md $247 mon, nd w kp gng hgh. Mnwh, h y, fo no dnb on, om offnd d ony n ou nd f muh pn. Wh mo mpon? Ewng k. Pong h young vm.and o h gu fo nw fou on ffo uh h FBI Innon Img Non Inv o hu down h mk of hd pon. Th nv w fundd $60 mon n 2008,h y,nd ud 187 hdn: You k bou bng fo you buk.th wh w n y b ffv.