Inheritance and Complementation: A Case Study of Easy Adjectives and Related Nouns
|
|
- Posy Baker
- 8 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 Deutsches Forschungszentrum für Künstliche Intelligenz GmbH Research Report RR Inheritance and Complementation: A Case Study of Easy Adjectives and Related Nouns Dan Flickinger and John Nerbonne September 1991 Deutsches Forschungszentrum für Künstliche Intelligenz GmbH Postfach Kaiserslautern, FRG Tel.: + 49 (631) Fax: + 49 (631) Stuhlsatzenhausweg Saarbrücken, FRG Tel.: + 49 (681) Fax: + 49 (681)
2 Deutsches Forschungszentrum für Künstliche Intelligenz The German Research Center for Artificial Intelligence (Deutsches Forschungszentrum für Künstliche Intelligenz, DFKI) with sites in Kaiserslautern and Saarbrücken is a non-profit organization which was founded in The shareholder companies are Atlas Elektronik, Daimler-Benz, Fraunhofer Gesellschaft, GMD, IBM, Insiders, Mannesmann-Kienzle, Sema Group, Siemens and Siemens- Nixdorf. Research projects conducted at the DFKI are funded by the German Ministry for Research and Technology, by the shareholder companies, or by other industrial contracts. The DFKI conducts application-oriented basic research in the field of artificial intelligence and other related subfields of computer science. The overall goal is to construct systems with technical knowledge and common sense which - by using AI methods - implement a problem solution for a selected application area. Currently, there are the following research areas at the DFKI: 2Intelligent Engineering Systems 2Intelligent User Interfaces 2Computer Linguistics 2Programming Systems 2Deduction and Multiagent Systems 2Document Analysis and Office Automation. The DFKI strives at making its research results available to the scientific community. There exist many contacts to domestic and foreign research institutions, both in academy and industry. The DFKI hosts technology transfer workshops for shareholders and other interested groups in order to inform about the current state of research. From its beginning, the DFKI has provided an attractive working environment for AI researchers from Germany and from all over the world. The goal is to have a staff of about 100 researchers at the end of the building-up phase. Dr. Dr. D. Ruland Director
3 Inheritance and Complementation: A Case Study ofeasyadjectives and Related Nouns Dan Flickinger and John Nerbonne DFKI-RR-91-30
4 This work has been supported by a grant from The Federal Ministry for Research and Technology (FKZ ITWM-ITW ). cdeutsches Forschungszentrum für Künstliche Intelligenz 1991 This work may not be copied or reproduced in whole of part for any commercial purpose. Permission to copy in whole or part without payment of fee is granted for nonprofit educational and research purposes provided that all such whole or partial copies include the following: a notice that such copying is by permission of the Deutsche Forschungszentrum für Künstliche Intelligenz, Kaiserslautern, Federal Republic of Germany; an acknowledgement of the authors and individual contributors to the work; all applicable portions of this copyright notice. Copying, reproducing, or republishing for any other purpose shall require a licence with payment of fee to Deutsches Forschungszentrum für Künstliche Intelligenz. ISSN X
5 InheritanceandComplementation:ACaseStudyofEasy AdjectivesandRelatedNouns DeutschesForschungszentrumfurKunstlicheIntelligenz PaloAlto,California Hewlett-PackardLaboratories 1501PageMillRoad JohnNerbonne DanFlickinger D-6600Saarbrucken11,Germany Stuhlsatzenhausweg3 volume.ourstudyservestohighlightsomeofthemostusefultoolsavailableforstructuredlexical guagehavebeenunderactivedevelopment,asisevidentintherecentstudiescontainedinthis Abstract Mechanismsforrepresentinglexicallythebulkofsyntacticandsemanticinformationforalan- November4,1994 illustratesthevalueofthesemechanismsinilluminatingonecornerofthelexiconinvolvingan unusualkindofcomplementationamongagroupofadjectivesexempliedbyeasy.thevirtues extendtheanalysisofadjectivalcomplementationinseveraldirections.thesefurtherillustrate howtheuseofinheritanceinlexicalrepresentationpermitsexactandexplicitcharacterizations ofthestructuredlexiconareitssuccinctnessanditstendencytohighlightsignicantclustersof ofphenomenainthelanguageunderstudy.wedemonstratehowtheuseofthemechanismsemployedintheanalysisofeasyenableustogiveauniedaccountofrelatedphenomenafeaturing nounslikepleasure,andeventheadverbs(adjectivalspeciers)tooandenough.alongthewaywe motivatesomeelaborationsofthehpsg(head-drivenphrasestructuregrammar)frameworkin whichwecouchouranalysis,andoerseveralavenuesforfurtherstudyofthispartoftheenglish lexicon. representation,inparticular,(multiple)inheritance,defaultspecication,andlexicalrules.itthen linguisticproperties.fromitssuccinctnessfollowtwopracticaladvantages,namelyitseaseof maintenanceandmodication.inordertosuggesthowimportantthesemaybepractically,we undtechnologietothedfkidiscoproject. workwaspartiallysupportedbyaresearchgrant,itw90020,fromthegermanbundesministeriumfurforschung forfrequentconversationsaboutthisanalysis.wearealsogratefultoanthonykroch,theparticipantsatthe TilburgWorkshoponInheritanceinNaturalLanguageProcessing,andthreerefereesforfurthercomments.This 1Introduction Thelexiconisalargeandcomplexsetofinformationaboutthewordsusedinagrammaror naturallanguageprocessingsystem.itsimportancehasbecomemorecentralintheresearchof WeareindebtedtoMarkGawron,MasayoIida,BillLadusaw,JoachimLaubsch,CarlPollardandTomWasow 1
6 thepastdecade,whichhasseentheriseofradicallylexicalizedtheoriessuchashead-driven phrasestructuregrammar(hpsg),inwhichphrasestructurerulesplayavestigialrole. Newertheoriesplaceincreasinglyhighdemandsonlexicalrepresentation.Asimplecalculation mayillustratethequandaryoflexicalrepresentation:featuresystemsforcontemporarysystems normallydistinguishatleast30features(while40or50isnotrare).thenumberofvaluesa featuretakesrangesfrom2tothenumberofcategories(moreexactly,tothenumberofsequences orsetsofasmallsize,whereallthemembersofthesequence,etc.arecategories).underthe undoubtedlyoptimisticassumptionthatfeaturevaluerangescouldbereducedtobooleans,westill arefacedwith230=109featurecombinations whoseindividualrepresentationisclearlytobe avoided,not\solved".1thenaturaltackiscertainlytorepresentjustthecategoriesactuallyused inthevocabulary,butthiscouldincuragooddealofredundancyifitmeantthateachfeature combinationwererepresentedseparatelyoneachword. Thestructuredorhierarchicallexiconsolvesthisdiculty(cf.Flickinger,Pollardand Wasow,1985andFlickinger,1987).Instructuredlexicons,wordclassesmaystandinarelationship ofinheritancetooneanother,inwhichcasethepropertiesofthebequeathingclassaccrueautomaticallytotheinheritingclass.onceweallowthatasingleclassmaybeheirtomorethanone bequeathingclass,weallow,inprinciple,thatnowordclasspropertyeverneedbeexaminedmore thanonce.thusweeliminateonecentralsourceofredundancyinlexicalspecication.oneofthe goalsofthispaperistomotivatetheuseofinheritanceinlexicalspecication.todothis,wetake anarrowlycircumscribedphenomenoninenglishgrammar thatofvp-complement-takingadjectives,asinhard+todeliver andspelloutthelexicalspecicationswhichathoroughtreatment demands.thesheercomplexityofthesespecicationscriesoutforaredundancy-eliminatingapproach,andweproposeastructuredlexicontreatment.thegrammaticalanalysisnotonlyserves tomotivatethegeneralapproach,italsoillustratesseveralkeyissuesinthedesignofstructured lexicons,suchastheuseofdefaultinheritance,theneedforlexicalrules,andtherangeof phenomenaamenabletothissortoftreatment. Thegoalsofthispaperaretointroducethestructuredlexiconinafairlysimpleform,to motivateitsbasictheoreticaldevice,thatofinheritance,witharealexampletakenfromanexisting system,andnallytoshowhowtheeliminationofredundancyachievedwiththestructuredlexicon aidsinmaintainingthelexicon.weargueforimprovedmaintainabilitybyexaminingconcrete extensionsandpotentialmodicationsofthegrammaticaldescriptionprovided.weturnnowto abriefcharacterizationofthisphenomenon. Therichcollectionofsyntacticandsemanticphenomenaexhibitedbyafamiliargroupof adjectivesliketoughandeasypresentachallengetothosewhoseektoprovideexplicitformal characterizationsoflinguisticproperties.weoerhereadetaileddescriptionoftheproperties oftheseadjectives,involvingoptionalandobligatorycomplementation,control,long-distance dependence,optionalmodication,andspecication.thepurposeofthisdescriptionhereis notthelinguisticanalysisitself(whichwendinteresting,nonetheless),butratheritsusein demonstratingthepracticalutilityofinheritanceasatoolforlinguisticdescription,andalsothe predictiveanalyticalpowerthatinheritanceaordsinthestudyofthelexicon.inillustrationofthe latter,weextendouranalysisofeasyadjectivestoasimilargroupofnounssuchaspleasure,and thentotheunusualadverbstooandenough,whichfunctionasspeciersinadjectivalgradation. Thefundamentaldataareillustratedin(1);examplessuchasthesehavenotattractedattention incomputationallinguistics,eveniftheyhaveoftenappearedinstudieswithinthegenerative framework.anearlydiscussionofthemisfoundinmillerandchomsky(1963),withascoreand moreofadditionalstudiespublishedintheyearssince.mostofthesalientpropertiesofthese adjectiveshavealreadybeenbroughttolight,butinpiecemealfashionandmostoftenaspartofa largerdebateaboutthenatureofunboundeddependencies,wheredetailedsyntacticandsemantic characterizationsofthesemissingobjectconstructionsprovedlessimportant.2wereturntothe 1Cf.Gazdaretal.,1985,Appendixforasmallgrammarwhichnonethelessexceedsthesizespeculatedonhere. 2RelatedworkintheoreticalanddescriptivelinguisticsincludesChomsky(1965),Rosenbaum(1967),Ross (1967),Postal(1971),Bresnan(1971),Chomsky(1973),LasnikandFiengo(1974),Jackendo(1975),Chomsky (1977),Fodor(1978),Brame(1979),Nanni(1980),Schachter(1981),Jacobson(1982,pp ),Sag(1982),Maling andzaenen(1982,pp ),kaplanandbresnan(1982,pp ),culicoverandwilkins(1984),jacobson 2
7 characteristicpropertiesoftheseadjectivesinsection3,wheretheyarecataloguedandgiven formalrepresentation. (1)a.Billiseasytotalkto. b.itiseasytotalktobill. c.billiseasyformarytotalkto. d.itiseasyformarytotalktobill. Wechosethisphenomenonasavehicletorecommendlexicalinheritancebecauseitillustrates awiderangeofgrammaticalphenomena,allofwhichmakedemandsonlexicalresources(at leastinthelexicalizedgrammarinwhichtheanalysisisframed).inadditiontothegrammatical demands,thedatajustifytheuseofalexicalrule(derivationalrule)torelatepairssuchas(a)and (b)in(1) soweshallargueatanyrate thusillustratingafurtherinheritance-likerelationship inthelexicon. Theremainderofthepaperisstructuredasfollows:Section2summarizestheaspectsof HPSGwhichareimportanttoourproposal,andSection3developsthefundamentalanalysis, whichsection4illustratesinaseriesofanalytical\snapshots"ofasingleexample.section5 suggestsextensionsofthefundamentalanalysis,especiallytofurtherlexicalclasses(developing theargumentthatstructuredlexiconsareeasilymaintainedandextended),andanalsection summarizesandsuggestsdirectionsforfuturework.appendixapresentstheframeworkfor lexicaldescriptiondevelopedinflickingeretal.(1985)andflickinger(1987).theframeworkis convenientforfeature-basedgrammars,butitallowsthespecicationofotherlexicalproperties aswell.thisappendixpresentsanotationwhichisprecisewhileavoidingredundancy,e.g., incharacterizingthekindsofcomplementsthattheseadjectivespermit,andinexpressingthe relationshipsthatholdbetweenpairsliketheeasyof(1a)andthatof(1b).sinceafundamental claimofhierarchicallexiconsisthattheyeliminateredundancyandthusimprovemodiability, thereisasecondappendix,appendixb,whichdemonstratesthemodiabilityofthestructured lexicon. 2GrammaticalTheory Thephenomenainvolvedintheanalysisoftheeasyadjectiveclassillustrate(obligatoryandoptional)subcategorization,control,long-distancedependence,optionalmodication,andspecication (thelastinitsinteractionwithadjectivalgradationwithtooandenough).assuch,itrepresents anexcellentdemonstrationvehicleforthelexicaldemandsofgrammaticalanalysis.ouranalysisisformulatedwithinhead-drivenphrasestructuregrammar(hpsg),thegrammatical theorydevelopedbycarlpollardandivansagduringthemidandlate1980's.seepollard(1984), Pollard(1985),PollardandSag(1987),Pollard(1988),PollardandSag(1988),Pollard(1989), andpollardandsag(1991).asthelengthylistofpublicationsmightsuggest,thisgrammatical theoryiswellenoughdocumentedsothatwemayrestrictourremarksheretothedistinctive characteristicsoftheassumptionsusedhere.weassumefamiliaritywithfeature-basedgrammars andbasicfamiliaritywithhpsgaswell. Inalllinguistictheoriesthereisadivisionoflaborbetweengrammaticalrulesandthelexicon, andthisconcernstheamountofinformationcontainedineach.attherule-basedextremelie non-feature-basedcontext-freegrammars,wherethelexiconmerelylinkslexicalitemstononterminals;inthesegrammarsitisindeedcustomarytoviewthelexiconasasetofunaryrules.the grammaticalrulesthusencodeeectivelyalllinguisticinformation.atthelexicalextremewe (1984),Gazdar,Klein,Pullum,andSag(1985,pp )(hence:GKPS),Jacobson(1990),Jones(1990),Bayer (1990),andHukariandLevine(1991).Noneoftheseworkshaveattemptedathoroughdescriptiveanalysisofthe rangeofdataweaddresshere,thoughweareofcourseindebtedtothesestudiesformuchofthedataandmanyof thegeneralizationsweseektoexpress.inparticular,ouraccountisconsistentwiththebriefgeneralizedphrase structuregrammar(gpsg)analysisoftheseadjectivesgiveningkps(1985,pp.150-2)thoughweembracea largerrangeofdataandextendtheanalysistorelatednouns,atopicrarelydiscussedsinceitsintroductionby LasnikandFiengo(1974). 3
8 ndfeature-basedcategorialgrammars,whichallowfunction-argumentapplicationastheonly grammaticalrule.herethelexiconbearstheburdenofencodinglinguisticinformation,andthe contributionofrulesismarginal.weemphasizethathpsgisfoundveryclosetothelexicalextreme,becausethishighlightsthesignicanceofthepresentwork HPSGisaframeworkwhose lexicaldemandsareverynearlymaximal. SubcategorizationinformationislexicallybasedinHPSG,muchasitisinCategorialGrammar(Bach,1988).Grammaticalheadsspecifythesyntacticandsemanticrestrictionstheyimpose ontheircomplementsandadjuncts.forexample,verbsandverbphrasesbearafeaturesubcat whosecontentisa(perhapsordered)setoffeaturestructuresrepresentingtheirunsatisedsubcategorizationrequirements.thusthefeaturestructuresassociatedwithtransitiveverbsinclude theinformation: subcat:hnp case:acc;np case:nomi (wherenpabbreviatesasubstantialfeaturestructure.)appliedtoadjectivalvpcomplementation,thistreatmentofsubcategorizationleadsnaturallytothepostulationofadjectiveswhich subcategorizeforvp's,etc.(detailsbelow). Thesignicanceofsubcategorizationinformationisthatitrepresentsa(perhapsordered)set ofgrammaticalcategorieswithwhichasubcategorizercombinesinforminglargerphrases.when asubcategorizercombineswithasubcategorizedelement,theresultantphrasenolongerbearsthe subcategorizationspecication ithasbeendischarged.cf.pollardandsag(1987,p.71)fora formulationofthehpsgsubcategorizationprinciple. Weshallingeneralpresentsubcategorizationspecicationsinaslightlydierentwayfromthat above,i.e.,notasasinglefeaturewhosevalueisalist,butratherasacollectionofcomplement featureswithcategoryvalues.cf.borsley(1989)foradevelopmentofthisapproach,which weshallnotattempttojustifyhere.wewillthereforereorganizetheinformationaboveinthe followingway: 264subject:NP case:nom object:np case:acc375 Wechoosethisrepresentationhereonlybecausewendthekeywordingofgrammaticalfunctions, subject,etc.,moreperspicuousthananencodingintermsoflistpositions,butnothinginthe analysishingesontheoneortheotherrepresentation. Weshallfurthermoreallowthatsubcategorizedelementsbeeitherobligatorilysubcategorized oroptionallysubcategorized.optionallysubcategorizedelementsneednotbedischargedfrom subcategorizationspecications.(thisnecessitatesanobviouschangetotheprinciplethatsubcategorizationmustbesatisedinindependentutterances.)incaseanelementisnotdischarged, somethingmustbesaidaboutitssemantics.hereweborrowanideafromsituationtheory,and specifythatunsaturatedpredicate-argumentstructures(orinfons,seedevlin,1991)mayhold whenthereissomewayofllingouttheunlledargumentpositionssothattheresultholds.this hastheeectofexistentiallyquantifyingoverunlledargumentpositions.linguistically,there aremanyotherwaysinwhichargumentsmaybeomitted(cf.fillmore1985),butthisseemsto sucefortheadjectivesunderexaminationhere. Controlandmodification,thelatterbeingtherelationbetweenanadjunctandahead,are bothlexicallyrealizedinthecaseoftheeasyadjectives.weregardthereasbeingacontrolrelation betweenforsmithandtogetincomplexadjectivalssuchaseasyforsmithtoget(cf.gkps1985: 83).Modicationplaysarolewhencomplexadjectivalsappearinconstructionwithnominal heads,asineasyjobforsmithtoget.thesearecommonassumptionsintheanalysesofcontrol andmodication. Long-distancedependenceistreatedinHPSGinmuchthesamewayitwastreatedin GPSG(cf.GKPS,1985),andweassumebasicfamiliaritywiththistypeofanalysis.Werecall 4
9 isaspecicationoftheexpectedmaterial.theslashspecicationispropagatedbygeneral thatthesiteofamissingelementina\gappy"constituentbearsafeatureslash,whosevalue astallerthanitiswide.weshallrequirelexicalspecicationsthatleadtofeaturestructures principles(whichweshallnotelucidate)tothehigherlevelconstituents,untilitismatchedby ofthefollowingform: withannpinslash.itisunusualtondasubcategorizationspecicationforslash,butnot unique:comparativeslikewisesubcategorizeforgappycomplements,asinseeninexamplessuch exploitthisintheanalysisofseveralwordclassesbelow,viz.,theoneswhichsubcategorizeforavp a\ller"orasubcategorizingelement.whenthegappyconstituentisadjoinedtoalleror subcategorizingelement,theresultnolongerbearstheslashvalue. containagap.(cf.gkps,1985,pp fortherstmentionofthissuggestion.)weshall Importantforourpurposesisthepossibilityofalexicalentryspecifyingthatadependentmay 264 sem:easy(1;^2) stem:easy syn.loc.subcat:2 6 4 subj: pp-for:hsem:1i xcomp:264syn:vp-inf syn:np-nom sem:3 slash:hsem:3i375 sem:2 subjectsemanticshavebeenidentied.thus,onceavp/nphascombinedwiththisadjective, thesemanticcontributionoftheslashelementisassumedbythesubject.figure1showsan Thetag3inthediagramaboveshowsthatthesemanticsoftheSLASHvalueandtheadjectival analysistreeforanexamplecontainingalong-distancedependency. Thevarietyoflinguisticphenomenaexempliedintheeasy-classofadjectivesguaranteesthat 75 Thefundamentaldataweshallbeconcernedwitharerepeatedin(2): follow,butweprovideanoverviewofthesemechanismsforlexicalrepresentationinappendixa. Weassumefamiliaritywiththemechanismsoflexicalinheritanceandlexicalrulesintheanalysisto 3AdjectivalVPComplementation itisademandingtestinggroundfortheoriesoflexicalrepresentation.3 (2)a.Billiseasytotalkto. b.itiseasytotalktobill. c.billiseasyformarytotalkto. thetheoreticalliterature:proudianandpollard(1985),nerbonneandproudian(1987),franz(1990),emeleand Zajac(1990),andCarpenter,PollardandFranz(1991). safelyreferthereadertodocumentationsofthoseimplementations,evenifthesearelessgenerallyavailablethan StanfordUniversity,CarnegieMellonUniversity,TheOhioStateUniversity,SimonFraserUniversity,University pastseveralyears;weknowofimplementationsathewlett-packardlaboratories,thegermanaicenter(dfki), ofedinburgh,icot,universityofstuttgart,theibmlilogprojectinstuttgart,andatr.wemaytherefore 3ItisalsoworthmentioningthatHPSGhasalsobeenthesubjectofintensiveimplementationactivityduringthe Otheradjectivesthatshowthissamedistributionincludethefollowing: d.itiseasyformarytotalktobill. 5
10 NP S These Det LLLLN????@@@@VP books Vare JJJJAdjP easy TTTT Vto TTTT VP/NP VVP/NP have TTTTS/NP Bob AAAA VVP/NP read LLLL NP/NP \slashed"np,i.e.,avpmissingannp(whoseexpectedpositionmaybearbitrarilydeep). Figure1:ComplexadjectivalssuchaseasysubcategorizeforacomplementVPcontaininga t 6
11 amusingdepressinggreat nice annoyingdiculthard painful boring exhaustingimportanttiresome comfortablefun impossibleterrible confusinggood impressivetough (3)Givenpairslike(2a,b)and(2c,d),twoclustersofpropertiesbegintosuggestthemselvesaspart ofthedenitionsoftherelevantlexicalentries.therstoftheseclusterswewillassociatewith theclassofwordscontaininglexicalentriesfortheeasyof(2a,c)anditscounterpartsin(3),aclass wetermslash-easy.theotherclusterofpropertiesweassociatewithasecondclasstermed IT-EASY,containingthelexicalentriesforthevariantofeasyin(2b,d)anditscounterpartsin (3).Webeginbysimplyidentifyingtherelevantpropertiesineachofthesetwoclasses,supported byexamplesasnecessary;thenweprovidemotivationforfactoringthesepropertiesintoseveral wordclasseslinkedbyinheritance. AdjectivesintheIT-EASYclasshavetwoobligatorycomplements,anNPsubjectandaverbal complement;inadditiontheyhaveoneoptionalcomplement,appheadedbytheprepositionfor. Asseenin(4),theverbalcomplementcanbeeitherinnitivalorgerundive,and(5)showsthat thiscomplementcanbeavpevenwithapp-forpresent,oraninnitvals,againwithorwithout theoptionalpp-forcomplement.thesubjectnpmustbetheexpletiveit. (4)a.ItwasgreatworkingforBill. b.itwasgreattoworkforbill. (5)a.It'seasiestforthedogstofeedthematnoon. b.forthedogs,it'seasiesttofeedthematnoon. c.it'seasiestforthedogstobechainedupallday. d.*forthedogs,it'seasiesttobechainedupallday. e.it'seasiestformeforthedogstobechainedupallday. f.forme,it'seasiestforthedogstobechainedupallday. (5e,f)demonstratethatnotonlyVPcomplementation,butalsoScomplementationisinvolved ineasysubcategorization.notethatscomplementationneverrequiresacontroller,andthat theppphraseinsuchstructuresismobile(5f).inadditiontotheconclusionthatavarietyof complementationschemesareusedwitheasy,thedataabovealsodemonstratethattheexact specicationofthecontroller(theunderstoodsubjectoftheinnitivalvp)isnontrivial.(5a) demonstratesthatthepp-forcomplementneednotcontrolthevp,and(5b)suggeststhat noncontrollingpp'saremoremobilethancontrollers(5d). Weaccommodatethesefactssemanticallybyallowingthateasyandsimilaradjectivesdenote two-placerelationsbetweenindividualsandstatesofaairs.therelationholdsbetweenthepair, roughly,whenitiseasy(orconvenient)fortheindividualwhenthestateofaairsobtains.(5e,f) showthattheindividualinvolvedintheeasyrelationneednotbeinvolvedinthestateofaairs, i.e.thatthereisnonecessarysemanticcontrolinvolvedinthisrelation.4thecontrolfactsare clearenough:whenthiseasyiscombinedwithans,thereisnosemanticcontrol;andwhenit iscombinedwithavp,thereisnogrammaticallyspeciedcontrollerofthevp althoughthere maybepragmaticinferenceabouttheunderstoodsubject. AdjectivesintheSLASH-EASYclassalsohavetwoobligatorycomplements,anNPsubject andaverbalcomplement,aswellasanoptionalpp-forcomplement.incontrasttotherstclass, thisclassspeciesthatthesubjectisanormal(non-expletive)np,andthattheverbalcomplement 4Thereisaninterestingpragmaticproblemlurkinginthecontrolspecicationsinvolvedhere.Ifonespecies thecontrolrelationshipsexactly,thenoneneedstopostulatesystematicstructuralambiguityinexamplessuchas (5c),wherethesequenceofPPandVPmayormaynotbeanalyzedasanSconstituent.Thisseemsplausible, butthenwewouldliketohaveapragmaticaccountofwhythereisnormallynodistinction,i.e.,whythecontrol relationshipisinferred,or,equivalentlyforallintentsandpurposes,whythesreadingissostronglypreferred. 7
12 mustcontainannpgap.moreover,thisverbalcomplementmustbeinnitival,notgerundive,as seenin(6),andmustbeavp,notans,asshownin(7).5 (6)a.Billwasgreattoworkfor. (7)a.Forme,Billwaseasytotalkto. b.*billwasgreatworkingfor. thetwovariantsofeasyintroducedabove,butwhichmustbekeptdistinct.lasnikandfiengo twointermediatewordclassesthatwillstandbetweencontrolandthesetwointhehierarchy. immediatesubclassofcontrol;wedrawonthedataprovidedin(8)and(9)belowtomotivate TROLwhichintroducesaverbalcomplement,andwhichservesasthesuperclassfromwhich bothoftheclassesit-easyandslash-easyinherit.however,neitheroftheseclassesisan TheEnglishlexiconcontainstwomoregroupsofadjectiveswhichhavemuchincommonwith Inthewordclasshierarchyweassume,sketchedinAppendixA,thereisawordclassCON- b.*billwaseasyformeformarytotalkto. (1974:535)identiedasetofadjectivesincludingprettyandmelodious,illustratedin(8). (8)a.Disneylandisprettytolookat. b.sonatasaremelodioustolistento. entrywithanexpletiveitsubject,andsecond,theyassignarealthematicroletotheirsubjects. buthavetwosignicantdierences:rst,asshownby(8c,d),theydonothaveacorresponding MembersofthisclassofadjectivessharemuchincommonwiththeSLASH-EASYadjectives, f.?sonatasaremelodiousforseriousmusicianstolistento. c.*itisprettytolookatdisneyland. d.*itismelodioustolistentosonatas. thevalidityofthisinference,sincethesubjectoftheadjectiveplaysnodirectroleintherelation placerelationsuggestedaboveforit-easyandslash-easyadjectivescouldnotaccountfor Thatis,(8a)entailsthatDisneylandispretty,while(1a)doesnotentailthatBilliseasy.Thetwo- e.?disneylandisprettyforchildrentolookat. whatsoever.adistinctsemanticrelationiscalledforhere,oneinwhichthesubjectdoesplaya role(whicheectivelymakesthisclassakindofequiadjectiveincontrasttotheraisingeasy). easyin(1c),thoughjudgmentsarelessclear.inordertoexpressthesedierences,weintroducea ItalsoappearsthattheseadjectivesdonotpermittheoptionalPP-forcomplementlicensedby adjectivesof(1b,d),butwithnocounterpartsoftheslash-easytype. classslash-compwhichwillincludetheentriesforprettyadjectives,andwhichwillalsoserve astheclassfromwhichslash-easyinherits.6 Similarly,EnglishhasasetofadjectiveswhichhavemuchincommonwiththeIT-EASY (9)a.ItispossibletotalktoBillonlyatbreakfast. b.itisunnecessarytorebill. takeagerundivecomplementinsteadoftheusualinnitivalcomplement,asinthatarticleisnotworthlooking at.theextensionofouranalysistoworthisstraightforward,butnotgivenhere. isthattheformerdonotpermitanoptionalpp-forphrasecomplement;theydoallowtheverbal complementtobeeitheravporans(containingapp-forsubject),but(10)showsthatifa 5HukariandLevine(1991)noteinpassingthatthereisagroupofcloselyrelatedadjectiveslikeworthwhichdo ThesecondprincipaldierencebetweenadjectiveslikepossibleandthoseoftheIT-EASYclass c.*billispossibletotalktoonlyatbreakfast. 6OtheradjectivesofthisSLASH-COMPclassincludedelicious,handsome,attractive,andlovely. d.*billisunnecessarytore. 8
13 PP-forispresent,itmustbecontainedwithintheScomplement. (10)a.ItisunnecessaryforMarytoreBill.(MringB) b.*formary,itisunnecessarytorebill.(mringb) c.*itisunnecessaryformaryforyoutorebill. Again,weexpressthedistinctionbetweenthesetofadjectiveslikepossibleandtheIT-EASY adjectivesbyintroducingafourthclassit-subjparalleltoslash-comp.7 Thesefourclassdenitions,togetherwithonesupportingclass,aregivenin(11-16),withthe Superclassesattributeshowingtherelevantinheritancerelations. (11)IT-SUBJ Superclasses Control Complements Subject-Features(NFormit) Subject-Rolenone XComp-features(VFormInnitival)(Complete+{) Thedisjunctivespecication(Complete+{)overridesthedefault(Complete{)speciedin thecontrolclass,andmeansthattheverbalcomplementmaybeeitheravp(complete{) orans(complete+). (12)SLASH-COMP Superclasses Control Complements XComp-Subj-Semanticsx XComp-features (SLASH(CategoryNoun) (NFormNormal) (Complete+) (Predicative{) (CaseAccusative)) (Semantics Subject-Semantics)) TheSLASHfeatureontheXCompspeciesthattheVPmustcontainagapwhichisfora normal(non-expletive)nounphrasewhichisaccusativecase,andwhichisnotpredicative.this nonpredicativespecicationservestoexcludeexampleslike*billisdiculttobecome.assuming thecomplementofbecomeispredicative,sincethegapforthatcomplementwouldfailtosatisfy therestrictiononslashgivenin(12).theslashspecicationfurthermorenotesthatthe SLASHsemanticvalueisidenticaltothatofSubject-Semantics.AswasexplainedinSection3 above,thisistheformalexicalspecicationofsemanticcoindexingtakes. ThecontrollerofthecontrolledcomplementisspeciedthroughtheattributeXComp-Subj- Semantics;forexample,inCONTROL,thisattributehasthevalueSubject-Semantics,since subjectsaredefaultcontrollers.butthecomplementsofslash-comparenotgrammatically controlled(cf.(8e,f)),afactwhichrequiresanoverwritingspecication.thesemanticvariablex isusedherebecauseitwillnotrepresentthesemanticsofanygrammaticalcomplement,which ensuresthatnogrammaticalcontroliseected(seeexamples(9a,b)).thisisanexampleofa subregularityappearingwithinanexceptionalspecication. Theclassesforthetwovariantsofeasyadjectiveswehavediscussedhavethemselvesonecluster ofpropertiesincommon:theybothlicensetheoptionalpp-forphraseseeninprecedingexamples. Tofurtherreduceredundancy,wedenein(13)theclassFOR-EXPERIENCER,fromwhichthe 7AdditionalmembersofthisIT-SUBJclassincludeessential,necessary,sad,silly,andillegal. 9
14 twoclassesin(14-15)alsoinherit. (13)FOR-EXPERIENCER (14)IT-EASY Superclasses Complements PP-for-Features PP-for-Oblig PP-for-Role PP-for (CategoryPreposition)(Lexical{) No(PFormFor) (15)SLASH-EASY XComp-Features(VFormInnitivalGerund) It-Subj,For-Experiencer classblocksinheritanceofthesubject'sthematicroleassignment(thedefaultvaluehavingbeen nocontrollerisspecied,inkeepingwithremarkson(5).ontheotherhand,theslash-easy Asexpected,theIT-EASYclasseasesonerestrictionontheverbalcomplement;notetoothat Superclasses Complements Subject-Role XComp-Subj-SemanticsPP-For-Semantics Slash-Comp,For-Experiencer relationship(inheritedfromslash-compandultimatelyfromcontrol)sothatthepp-for speciedintheincompleteclassfromwhichcontrolinherits),andaltersthecontrol none representsasubregularitywithinasubregularity(cf.slash-comp). aretwofurtherexamplesofthewayinwhichdefaultoverwritingisemployed;notethatthelatter phraseratherthanthesubjectofeasyisinterpretedasthesubjectofthevpcomplement.these alongwithanexplicitdenitionoftheclassadjective,providedhereforclarityin(16-17),we canintroducethe(sparse)lexicalentriesforthetwovariantsofeasyemployedin(1a,b),asgiven in(17,18) Withreasonableassumptionsaboutthedenitionsofotherrelevantclassesinthehierarchy, (16)ADJECTIVE (17)easy-1a SuperclassesMajor Features SuperclassesAdjective,Slash-Easy Semanticseasy Spelling Phonology/izi/ \easy" (CategoryAdjective)(Predicative+{) Pairsofsparselexicalentrieslikethosein(17,18)arerelatedbyalexicalrulewhichwelabel (18)easy-1b SuperclassesAdjective,It-Easy Semanticseasy Spelling Phonology/izi/ \easy" 10
15 FOR-EXPERIENCER IT-SUBJCONTROL QQQQQQQQQs XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXz +QQQQQQQQs? SLASH-COMP IT-EASY 9? easy-1b SLASH-EASY Figure2:Thestructureofwordclassesdirectlyinvolvedinthedenitionofcomplexadjectival easy-1a?????? ADJECTIVE lexicalentries. LR-EASY,andwhichsimplystatesthatforeachmemberoftheclassIT-EASYthereexistsa willofcoursebequitedistinct,asneededtoensurethedierencesindistributionthatwehave correspondinglexicalentrybelongingtotheclassslash-easy,witheverythingbutthesuperclassespropertyidenticalinthetwo(sparse)entries. Onceeachof(17)and(18)areeshedouttoincludealloftheirinheritedproperties,they LE2-Classes{IT-EASY=LE1-Classes{SLASH-EASY LR-EASYlexicalrule described.figure2summarizestheinheritancerelationshipsthusfar. lexicalspecicationssuggestedonmorefamiliarelementsofgrammaticalanalysis,viz.phrases, Thepurposeofthissectionisprimarilyillustrative wewouldliketodemonstratetheeectofthe 4AnExampleAnalysis parsetrees,andpredicatelogicrepresentations. complements,inthiscasethepp-forphraseandthexcomp.thisclassofadjectivesalsohas thesemanticsofeasy-slashadjectivesforthesubject'sdenotation.toconservespaceinthe individualandastateofaairsistreatedasanormalcaseoflexicallyinheritedsemantics,i.e.one inwhichtherelationdenotedhasanargumentplaceforthedenotationsofeachoftherole-playing asubjectamongitscomplements,butitbearsnorole(aswordclassslash-easyspecies), becausethisisaraisingconstruction.forthisreason,thereisnoargumentplacereservedin diagramsbelow,relationswillbespeciednotusingthekeyword-codingshowninwordclassand lexicalentryspecications(above),butratherinthemorefamiliarorder-coding. Thesemanticsoftheeasy-SLASHconstruction,whichtreatseasyasarelationbetweenan 11
16 eect,weincludeheresomewhatelaborateanalyticalsketchesofthecomplexadjectivalphrase easytogetmarytohirein(19): Tobegin,wenotethatthesparselexicalentryfortheSLASH-EASYversionofeasymaybelled outtoamuchricherstructureifinheritedpropertiesarenotedexplicitly: Inordertomakenotonlythesemanticsbutalsothesyntaxsomewhatclearerinitsintended (19)TomiseasytogetMarytohire. easy-1a Complements PP-for-Features PP-for-Oblig PP-for-Role PP-for-Semantics XComp-Features No(PFormFor) PP-for,Subject,XComp (CategoryPreposition)(Lexical{) (CategoryVerb)(Complete{)(Lexical{) (CategoryAdjective)(Predicative+{) (SLASH(CategoryNoun)(Complete+) (NFormNormal)(Predicative{) Spelling XComp-Subj-SemanticsPP-For-Semantics XComp-Oblig XComp-Semantics XComp-Role Subject-Role Yes State-of-Aairs none XComp-Semantics (CaseAccusative)) Phonology \easy" /izi/(semanticssubject-semantics)) ThefeaturesnotedabovewerespeciedbythelexicalentrytogetherwiththeclassesADJEC- propertieswouldbeinheritedfromincomplete,butforbrevitythesearenotlisted.(of TIVE,SLASH-EASY,SLASH-COMP,FOR-EXPERIENCERandCONTROL.Furthersubject coursemanyotherproperties,includinge.g.,gradationpropertiesandtheapplicabilityoflexical ruleshavelikewisebeensuppressedintheinterestofclarityinpresentation.)thislexicaldescriptiontranslatesfairlydirectly(withsomefurthersimplicationsandabbreviations)intoafeature structureofthesortusedbyhpsggrammars: 12
17 264 syn.loc.head:adj sem:easy(1;^2) syn.loc.subcat: stem:easy2 64 subj: pp-for:syn:pp-for xcomp:2 syn:np-nom sem:3 sem:1 6 4 syn:vp-inf sem:2 subject.sem:1 slash:syn:np-acc sem: lexicallyspeciedandwhichsimplifysubsequent(grammatical)processing.thecoindexingofthe valuewiththesubject'ssemantics,ontheotherhand,derivesultimatelyfromslash-comp. xcomp'ssubjectwiththepp-foriseectedintheslash-easywordclass,andthesemanticcoindexingseenaboveisjustaconsequenceofthat.thecoindexingofthexcomp'sslash'ssemantics Wewouldliketodrawattentiontotwosemanticcoindexingsinthestructure,whichareboth nodeisalwaystobeidentiedwiththesemanticsofaheadinaheadcomplementcombination. ThefactthattheslashvalueofthemotherstructureisemptyfollowsfromtheBindingInheritancePrinciple,whichstatesthatslashvaluesarecollectedgoingupatree unlessahead HPSGprinciples,sothatnothingisspecied,e.g.,ontherulewhichlicenseshead-complement VP/NP.Theverysparsespecicationofthemotherphrase'sfeaturesis,infact,solelyforpurposesoflegibility alloftheinformationspeciedonthemothernodemaybederivedfromgeneraticsfollowsfromthehpsgsemanticsprinciple,whichstatesthatthesemanticsofaphrasal combinations.thefactthatthesemanticsattributeisidentiedwiththesubcategorizer'sseman- InFigure3weexaminethecombinationofatokenfromthisclassofeasyadjectivesanda categorizationrequirement.theidenticationofthefeaturestructurelabeled7,whichisjust subcategorizesforanelementcontainingaslashvalue,inwhichcasetheslashsatisesthesub- therepresentationofthephrasalnodedominatingtogetmarytohire,withoneoftheadjective's subcategorizationspecications,thatlabeled6,isjustaconditionfortheapplicabilityofthe head-complementrule,notanadditionalspecication.ofcourse,thephrasalnodeismassively underspeciedhere,butthesuppressedinformationispredictable,notmerelyhidden. furthercomment,thatislargelybecausethelexiconhasprovidedawealthofrichlystructured thepropertiesofthephrasalcombinationofthisfairlyintricatesyntacticstructurerequireno representation.thiswouldhardlybefeasibleintheabsenceofecientandsophisticatedlexical representationmechanisms. ThisisanintriguingaspectofHPSG,butwedwellonithereforself-servingpurposes.If easyrelationitself.thisisexactlywhatiswantedsemanticallyofaraisingconstruction. argumentpositionoftheverbhire.thistakesplaceeventhoughthesubjectplaysnoroleinthe Figure4.NoteinparticularthatbecausetheslashsemanticsontheVPphraseisidentiedwith theslashsemanticsonthesubcategorized-forvp,whichinturnisidentifedwiththesemantics ofthesubjectforeasy,theresultantphrasewillbinditssubjecttothedeeplyembeddedobject Tocompletethisillustration,wespellouttheeectsofunicationonthestructureabovein 13
18 24sem:5 Adj AdjP slash:;35;where6=7 easy QQQQQQQQ 264 togetmarytohiret SVP/NP SSSSS sem:5easy(1;^2) stem:easy S comps: 2 64xcomp:6264subj:hsem:1i pp-for:hsem:1i subj: hsem:3i sem:2 slash.sem: sem:get(x;m; slash.sem:4 ^hire(m;4)) 375 Figure3:ThecombinationofcomplexadjectiveandslashedVPcomplement. 14
19 264stem:easy comps:hsubj:hsem:3t4ii sem.logic:5easy(x;^get(x;m; Adj^hire(m;T;3t4)) 375 Adj easy SSSSS SVP/NP SSSSS subjectofeasyisstillsemanticallycoindexedwiththemissingvpobject. 5ExtensionsandLexicalMaintenance Figure4:TheresultofcombiningcomplexadjectiveandslashedVPcomplement.Notethatthe togetmarytohirets Thestructuredlexiconaimsideallyataredundancy-freespecicationofalllexicalproperties,and indeed,itachievesthislargelythroughtheuseofinheritance.whilewedoseescienticparsimony asanendinitself,weseetwofurtheradvantagesintheemploymentofthestructuredlexicon,one value,andthatisbecauseastructuredlexiconismoreeasilymaintainedandextendedthan scienticandonepractical.thescienticadvantageofthestructuredlexiconisthatitidenties anonstructuredone.thisadvantagederivesimmediatelyfromthecharacteristicthatlexical andproudian,1987). signicantclassesinthelanguage.inafeaturesystemwithapproximately30atomicfeatures thatweneverseeneedtodistinguish1030classesofitems.infactwedistinguishapproximately 300lexicalclassesinHP-NL,alargesystemwithverybroadgrammaticalcoverage(seeNerbonne (includingsemantics),eachofwhichrangesoverapproximately10values,itiscertainlystriking easierinsystemswithstructuredlexiconstoexperimentwithgrammaticaldescription. propertiesarenormallyspeciedonlyonce.modicationstendthentobeminimal,andextensions lessfrightening.theultimatescienticbenetthismaybringderivesfromthefactthatitisthen VPcomplements tonounswithsimilarsubcategorizations,totheadjectivalspecierstooand extended.weexaminethereforeextensionstotheanalysisaboveofadjectiveswhichgovern Butthepracticaladvantageofthestructuredlexiconmayultimatelyalsobeofscientic enough,andtoadjectiveswhichgovernscomplementsratherthanvpcomplements. 5.1Pleasurenouns Adjectiveslikeeasyhavebeenthemostwidelystudiedgroupoflexicaltypesthatpopulatethe classesintroducedintheanalysisabove,buttheydonothaveexclusiveclaimtothoseclasses. Thefollowingsectionisanattempttobuttresstheclaimthatstructuredlexiconsareeasily LasnikandFiengo(1974:568)observedthattheEnglishlexiconalsocontainsagroupofnouns 15
20 withsimilarproperties,asillustratedin(20-21), (20)a.Nureyevisapleasuretowatch. b.thiscourseisabreezetopass. c.veniceisadelighttovisit. (21)a.ItisapleasuretowatchNureyev. b.itisabreezetopassthiscourse. c.itisadelighttovisitvenice. Liketheadjectivesdiscussedabove,nounssuchaspleasurehavetwovariants,onewhich appearswithanordinarynpsubjectandaninnitivalcomplementcontainingannpgap;and onewhichselectsanexpletiveitsubjectandaninnitivalcomplementwithnogap.giventhe wordclassdenitionsdevelopedonthestrengthoftheadjectivalexamples,anobviousanalysis ofthenominalexamplessuggestsitself:pleasure,likepleasant,hasonelexicalentrybelongingto theslash-easyclass,andasecondentrythatinheritsfromtheit-easyclass.the(sparse) descriptionsofbothentriesaregivenin(22-23),paralleltothoseforeasygivenin(17-18)above, thesalientdierencebeingthatthenounentriesinheritfromtheclasscommon-nounwherethe adjectiveentriesinheritedfromtheadjectiveclass.8 (22)pleasure-1a SuperclassesCommon-Noun,Slash-Easy Spelling \pleasure" Semantics.Predpleasure Phonology /plezhr/ (23)pleasure-1b SuperclassesCommon-Noun,It-Easy Spelling \pleasure" Semantics.Predpleasure Phonology /plezhr/ HavingdeclarednounslikepleasuretohaveentriesthataremembersofSLASH-EASYand IT-EASY,nothingmoreneedstobesaidinordertocapturethesyntacticrelationshipbetween thesetwoformsofpleasure.thelexicalruleweproposedearliertolinkpairsofadjectiveslikethe twovariantsofeasyisdenedasaregularityholdingbetweenthetwoclassesslash-easyand IT-EASY,makingnomentionoftheclassADJECTIVEinitsformulation.Henceitalsoserves tolinkthepairofnounentriesin(22-23). Somefurtherexplanationneedstobeprovidedaboutthesemanticsofthisclassofnouns, sincethenounsdoseemsemanticallyanomalousevenifweshallmaintainthatalloftheapparent anomalyultimatelystemsfromtheirhavingasubject andthusbeingavailableforcontrol(by beandotherraisingverbs).ingeneralacommonnounisinterpretedasarelationbetweena themeargumentandthedenotationofitscomplements,ifthereareany.forexample,friendis interpretedasarelationbetweenathemeargumentandthedenotationofthecomplementpp- OFphrase.Werefertothethemeargumentoftherelationdenotedbythecommonnounasits denotation.anapparentpeculiarityofnounssuchaspleasureisthatthereappearstobeno denotationofthenounintheusualsense,e.g.,in(20a).atissueiswhetherthereisanytheme argumentpositionforthe\pleasure"intherelationdenotedbypleasure.i.e.,doespleasuredenote thesametwo-placerelationbetweenindividualsandstatesofaairsthatpleasantdoes,oristhere athirdargumentpositioninpleasurewhichisoccupiedbyan(abstract)\pleasure"individual? Thesuspicionthatnodenotationisinvolvedlikelystemsfromourintuitionthatwedonot 8Othernounsinthisclassincludedisappointment,ordeal,challenge,joy,inspirationandprivilege. 16
21 noun(phrase)isusedpredicatively,muchasmanynounphrasesareaftertheverbbe.compare Tomisalinguist. oldtopicsemantically(cf.thedenitionofbeinmontague,1973,p.261),therehasbeenessentially morethanwewouldifwehadusedpleasantintheplaceofapleasure.nowthissuggeststhatthe seemtorefertoanobjectwhichisapleasureinutteringeither(20a)or(21a),atleastnotany nosuccessfulattempttotreatpredicativenounsasiftheyhadnodenotation.anyattemptto dososeemstorunafoulofthestandard(iflimited)determinationandadjectivalmodication duplicationasemanticanalysiswouldincurifpredicativenominalshadnodenotation. foundinphrasessuchasnogreatpleasuretowatch;atleastsuchexamplespointouttheinevitable Thisdoesnothelpagreatdeal,however.EventhoughtheanalysisofpredicativeNP'sisan whichobtainsjustincaseeisthepleasurexhasincases.itshouldofcoursealsoturnout thatthisrelationforsomeeholdsipleasant(for:x;soa:y),butwewillnotbeconcerned withshowingthathere.eprovidesadenotationwhichissubjecttodetermination(no)and (intersective)adjectivalmodication(great).underthisanalysis,apleasuretowatchandno pleasuretowatchdenotequantifers,i.e.,ineachcaseasetofpropertiesofpleasures(e'sfrom Wethereforeinterpretpleasureasathree-placerelation betrueorfalse forthatitmustbepairedwithaproperty.inthesecases,therelevantproperty above).ofcourse,aquantierdoesnotbyitselfrepresentaproposition,somethingwhichcould pleasure(theme:e;for:x;soa:s) Wethereforepostulatethatthepredicatebeinthesesentencesdenotestheuniversalproperty.9 semanticswhichthegeneralschemepredicts arelationbetweenathemeandthedenotations incasethereisapleasureoftherelevantkind(andmutatismutandisforthenegativeexistentials). isalwaystheuniversal(existence)property;i.e.utterancesofsentencessuchas(20a)aretruejust ofothercomplements.forthisreason,thewordclassesforpleasurenounsmakenospecial stipulationsaboutsemantics. structurestohighlightthesemanticallyrelevantparts.) andsemanticsprocessingofthewordpleasure.therststructurerepresentsthememberofthe SLASH-EASYclass,andthesecondthememberoftheIT-EASYclass.(Wehavesimpliedthe Whatisstrikingaboutthisproposalisthatitassignsthecommonnounpleasureexactlythe Wethereforederivefeaturestructuressuchasthefollowing,whichareusedinthesyntax 264subcat:264subj:hsem:3i stem:\pleasure" sem.logic:pleasure(e;1;^2) pp-for:hsem:1i xcomp:264subj:hsem:1i i.e.,thatthesubjectoftheverbbeisnotlinkedtoanyargumentpositionintherelationdenotedbythecontrolled relationsinsituationtheory(cf.section2undersubcategorization).note,however,theoneexceptionalaspect, Instead,weallowbetodenotetheidentityrelation,whichholdsofasingleargumentjustincasethereissomewayof llinginthemissingargument i.e.incasetherstexists.thisfollowsfromthegeneraltreatmentofunsaturated complement(inthiscase,pleasure). 9Infact,wedonotstipulateapeculiarsemanticsfortheraisingverbs(suchasbe)whichareinvolvedhere. sem:"logic:2 slash:3#
22 264 stem:\pleasure" sem.logic:pleasure(e;1;^2) comps:264subj:np-it pp-for:hsem:1i xcomp:"subject:hsem:1i e.g.,bytheverbbe onlyunsaturatedphrasesaresubjecttocontrol;(ii)theirinabilitytofunction apropertytheyinherentnallyfromincomplete,intheonecasethroughcontrol,it- SUBJandIT-EASY;andintheotherfromCONTROL,SLASH-COMPandSLASH-EASY.Itis thisproperty,sharedbythenp'stheygiveriseto,whichexplains(i)theirabilitytobecontrolled Ontheotherhand,thenounclassesareexceptionalinthatthenounsinvolvedhavesubjects sem:2 # innormalnp's,e.g.,inthesubjectpositionofanyintransitiveverb;andnally(iii)thefactthat theycanstandinconstructionwiththemainverbbewithoutbeingassertedtobeidenticaltoits subject. entriesfor\pleasure"alsopredictthegrammaticalityjudgmentsseenin(24),analogoustothe examplesgivenaboveforadjectives,andbasedonthedenitionsgivenfortheit-easyand SLASH-EASYwordclasses.10 Weturnnowtofurtherpointsonthesyntaxofthepleasurenouns.Thetwodenitionsof (24)a.Nureyevisapleasureforustowatch. f.itisarealpleasureforusforourparentstowatchnureyev. e.forus,itisarealpleasureforourparentstowatchnureyev. g.*nureyevisapleasurewatching. d.*forus,nureyevisarealpleasureforourparentstowatch. c.forus,nureyevisarealpleasuretowatch. h.itisapleasurewatchingnureyev. b.itisapleasureforustowatchnureyev. and\pleasure",aremorphologicallyrelated.wedonotoerhereaproposalforcapturingnonproductiveregularitiesofthiskind,thoughsomeextensionofthelexicalrulemechanismmightserve,anextensionthatwould dependheavilyontheabilitytospecifynegativeexceptionstolexicalrules,givenexampleslikethefollowing. classes,wemightexpecttondnounsaswellthatbelongtotheothertwoclasses,it-subj andslash-comp.suchinstancesarefoundinenglish,asillustratedforit-subjnounsbythe 10Nothingwehavesaidsofarcapturesthefactthatsomepairsofmembersofthesetwoclasses,like\pleasant" (ii)*itisadicultytohirebill. (i)itisdiculttohirebill. Recallingfurtherthattheadjectiveswelookedatabovefellintonottwobutfourdistinct (iii)*billisadicultytohire. (iv)itisimpossibletoworkwithbill. (vi)*billisanimpossibilitytoworkwith. (v)*itisanimpossibilitytoworkwithbill. 18
23 examplesin(25),andforslash-compnounsbythosein(26),drawnfromlasnikandfiengo.11 (26)a.Thisroomisapigstytobehold. (25)a.ItwouldbeamistaketoreBill. d.*billwasashocktondhere. b.itwasashocktondbillhere. c.*itisapigstytobeholdthisroom. d.*itisamarveltowatchnureyev. b.nureyevisamarveltowatch. c.*billwouldbeamistaketore. theit-subjclass(togetherwithitssuperclasses);andlikethedierencesbetweenpleasureand easy,theirdierencesresultfrommistakebeingamemberofthecommon-nounclasswhile andit-easy,therulecorrectlydoesnotpredicttheexistenceofsimilaralternateentriesfor pleasure(andthetwovariantsofeasy)isdenedtolinkmembersofthetwoclassesslash-easy possibleinheritsfromtheadjectiveclass.sincethelexicalrulerelatingthetwovariantsof nounslikemistakeandpigsty. Thenounmistakeandtheadjectivepossiblehaveincommonjustthosepropertiesspeciedby inheritanceandlexicalruleproducethedesiredresultsfornounswithoutrequiringthatanything beaddedtotheanalysismotivatedfromdataonadjectivesandverbs. InteractionwithLexicalRules Giventhatthedomainoflexicalrulesisalwaysoneormorewordclasses,andthattheLR- IntrapositionruleisdenedontheIT-SUBJclass,wepredictthegrammaticalityofthefollowing exampleswithpleasurenouns,sincetheyalsohaveentriesbelongingtotheit-subjclass,and shouldbeexpectedtoconformtothelr-intrapositionrule.hereagain,thecombineddevicesof (27)a.(Forme)tostayanotherdaywouldbearealpleasure. Todrivehomeourcentralpointabouttheexpressiveandpredictivepowerofinheritancein 5.2Tooandenough d.itmightbeadisappointmentforyoutovisitvenicenow. c.tovisitvenicenowmightbeadisappointmentforyou. b.itwouldbearealpleasure(forme)tostayanotherday. COMPnounsincludebeautyandterror. propertieslikethosewehavealreadyseen.jackendo(1972,p.227)noticedthatthetwowords tooandenoughalsoappearinconstructionswithaninnitivalcomplementthatcontainsannp lexicalrepresentation,weturntoathird,smallclassoflexicalentriesthatshowcomplementation 11AdditionalIT-SUBJnounsincludebattle,disgrace,error,honor,relief,shockandsurprise.OtherSLASH- 19
24 gap,asillustratedin(28)withexamplesdrawnfromlasnikandfiengo(1974:536).12 (28)a.Themattressisthin. thesameasadjectiveslikepretty,entrieswhicharenotrelatedvialexicalruletovariantsthat b.*themattressisthintosleepon. licenseanexpletiveitsubject. Inparticular,theexamplesin(29)suggestthattheseadverbsselectforcomplementsthatare c.themattressistoothintosleepon. (29)a.*Itistoothintosleeponthismattress. d.thefootballissoft. f.*thefootballissofttokick. g.thefootballissoftenoughtokick. orenoughcombineswithanordinaryadjective,theresultingphrase(toothinandsoftenough) exhibitcomplementationpropertiesverymuchlikethoseofprettyadjectives.bydeningthe (30),inheritingbothfromtheADVERBclassandfromtheSLASH-COMPclass;theentryfor lexicalentriesforthesetwoadverbialspeciersasmembersoftheslash-compclass,webegin toprovideanaccountforexamples(28c,g)aswellasthosein(29).theentryfortooisgivenin enoughissimilar,leavingoutofthepresentdiscussionanaccountofthelinearorderdierence b.*itissoftenoughtokickthisfootball.informally,itseemsthatwhentoo betweenthetwoadverbswithrespecttotheadjectivetheymodify. (30)\too" verydierentgrammaticalareasareundertaken.inseveralyearsofdevelopmentathewlett- SuperclassesAdverb,Slash-Comp PackardLaboratories,involvingdetailedanalysesofdozensofconstructions,thenumberofword lexiconapproach.figure5illustratesthemorecompletestructure.itisacuriousfactthatthe numberoflexicalclassesdoesnotgrowenormouslyevenwhilefairlydetailedanalysesinvolving ofslashedvpshasgrowntoapointwhereitsurelydemonstratesthevirtuesofthestructured Withtheinclusionofthisclassofadverbs,ourlexicalsubhierarchyinvolvingcomplementation Spelling Phonology/tu/ \too" thin,nottoo,istheheadofthephrasetoothintosleepon.tomotivatethenecessaryelaboration classesneverexceeded400.thismustbeduenally,nottothelexicalanalysistool,butrather ofouranalysisforthesetwoadverbs,weturntoonemoresetofdatainvolvinggappyinnitival thesyntacticheadofaphrasethatimposesconstraintsonitscomplements;andweassumethat Yetitisclearthatsomethingmoremustbesaidaboutthisconstruction,giventhatinHPSGitis parsing,referringthereadertofullaccountsgiveninpollardandsag(1987)andrelatedreferences. tothetendencyoflanguagetoreusesignicantclasses. complements,onethathasreceivedlittlestudytodate. thecomplementationspecicationsprovidedbytooarepropagateduptothephrasetoothin.13 Wehavesaidlittlehereabouthowlexicallysuppliedsubcategorizationinformationisemployedin Thisanalysisofthesetwounusualadverbshasleftbegginganimportantissueabouthow selectsforavpcomplement.butslightlymorecomplicatedexamplesquicklyrenderthisapproachuntenable. resultweregardasunacceptable. Cf.Thiscountryistoothinlypopulatedtoworryabout(wherewetakethescopeofthespeciertootobethinly populated).here,thelexicalizedformthatselectsforavpcomplementwouldhavetobetoothinlypopulated,a 13Onemightbetemptedtotryalexicalruleapproachwhichwouldtreattoothinasaderivedlexicalitemwhich 12Baltin(1987)presentsamorerecentanalysisofthese\degreecomplements." 20
Secure Mobile Multiagent Systems In Virtual Marketplaces
Deutsches Forschungszentrum für Künstliche Intelligenz GmbH Research Report RR-02-02 Secure Mobile Multiagent Systems In Virtual Marketplaces A Case Study on Comparison Shopping Ina Schaefer March 2002
More informationIntelligent documentation as a catalyst for developing cooperative knowledge-based systems
Deutsches Forschungszentrum für Künstliche Intelligenz GmbH Research Report RR-92-26 Intelligent documentation as a catalyst for developing cooperative knowledge-based systems Franz Schmalhofer, Thomas
More informationIST World. European RTD Information and Service Portal FP6-2004-IST-3 015823. Brigitte Jörg, Language Technology Lab, DFKI GmbH
IST World European RTD Information and Service Portal FP6-2004-IST-3 015823 About the Project [European RTD Information and Service Portal] Duration: 30 Months (April 2005 September 2007) Project Type:
More informationIntegrated Knowledge Acquisition. from Text, Previously Solved Cases. and Expert Memories
Deutsches Forschungszentrum für Künstliche Intelligenz GmbH Research Report RR-90-14 Integrated Knowledge Acquisition from Text, Previously Solved Cases and Expert Memories Franz Schmalhofer, Otto Kühn,
More informationCTL A description logic with expressive concrete domains
Deutsches Forschungszentrum für Künstliche Intelligenz GmbH Research Report RR-96-04 CTL A description logic with expressive concrete domains Gerd Kamp and Holger Wache May 1996 Deutsches Forschungszentrum
More informationSustainable Technology Transfer: The German Way
Transfer of Technology Stream Dublin, Wednesday 8th May Sustainable Technology Transfer: The German Way Prof. Dr. Wolfgang Wahlster CEO and Scientific Director of the German Research Center for AI, DFKI
More informationSmart Data Innovation Lab (SDIL)
Smart Data Innovation Lab (SDIL) Accelerating Data driven Innovation NESSI Summit May 27, 2014 Prof. Dr.-Ing. Michael Beigl Department of Informatics KIT University of the State of Baden-Wuerttemberg and
More informationHow the Computer Translates. Svetlana Sokolova President and CEO of PROMT, PhD.
Svetlana Sokolova President and CEO of PROMT, PhD. How the Computer Translates Machine translation is a special field of computer application where almost everyone believes that he/she is a specialist.
More informationELRC Workshop Report for Germany
(ELRC) is a service contract operating under the EU s Connecting Europe Facility SMART 2014/1074 programme. Deliverable Task 6 ELRC Workshop Report for Germany Author(s): Christian Dugast (DFKI) Dissemination
More informationDeutsches Forschungszentrum. Intelligenz GmbH. The EMS Model. Jürgen Lind. January 1999. Deutsches Forschungszentrum für Künstliche Intelligenz GmbH
Deutsches Forschungszentrum für Künstliche Intelligenz GmbH Research Report TM-98-09 The EMS Model Jürgen Lind January 1999 Deutsches Forschungszentrum für Künstliche Intelligenz GmbH Postfach 20 80 67608
More informationA Review of Three Different Approaches to Occurrence Omniscience - Part One
Deutsches Forschungszentrum for KOnstliche Intelilgenz GmbH Technical Memo TM-90-02 The Myth of Domain-Independent Persistence Jay C. Weber June 1990 Deutsches Forschungszentrum fur Kunstliche Intelligenz
More informationThe MultiHttpServer A Parallel Pull Engine
Deutsches Forschungszentrum für Künstliche Intelligenz GmbH Technical Memo TM-99-04 The MultiHttpServer A Parallel Pull Engine Christoph Endres email: Christoph.Endres@dfki.de April 1999 Deutsches Forschungszentrum
More informationThe MultiHttpServer A Parallel Pull Engine
Deutsches Forschungszentrum für Künstliche Intelligenz GmbH Technical Memo TM-99-04 The MultiHttpServer A Parallel Pull Engine Christoph Endres email: Christoph.Endres@dfki.de April 1999 Deutsches Forschungszentrum
More informationCurriculum Vitae. Personal Data. Professional Experience
Curriculum Vitae Personal Data Name: Dr. Klaus Fischer Address: Lüderitzstraße 1, D-66123 Saarbrücken Phone: +49-681-85775-3917 (office) +49-160-97225454 (mobile) Fax: +49-681-85775-2235 e-mail: Klaus.Fischer@dfki.de
More informationBottleneck Analysis as a Heuristic for Self-Adaption in Multi-Agent Societies
Deutsches Forschungszentrum für Künstliche Intelligenz GmbH Technical Memo TM-98-01 Bottleneck Analysis as a Heuristic for Self-Adaption in Multi-Agent Societies Christian Gerber January 1998 Deutsches
More informationOn Abduction and Answer Generation through Constrained Resolution
Deutsches Forschungszentrum für Künstliche Intelligenz GmbH Research Report RR-92-51 On Abduction and Answer Generation through Constrained Resolution Hans-Jürgen Bürckert, Werner Nutt October 1992 Deutsches
More informationAppendices master s degree programme Artificial Intelligence 2014-2015
Appendices master s degree programme Artificial Intelligence 2014-2015 Appendix I Teaching outcomes of the degree programme (art. 1.3) 1. The master demonstrates knowledge, understanding and the ability
More informationLing 201 Syntax 1. Jirka Hana April 10, 2006
Overview of topics What is Syntax? Word Classes What to remember and understand: Ling 201 Syntax 1 Jirka Hana April 10, 2006 Syntax, difference between syntax and semantics, open/closed class words, all
More informationRost and Arity Constraints of the Feature Tree Model in CFT
Deutsches Forschungszentrum für Künstliche Intelligenz GmbH Research Report RR-94-35 A Complete Axiomatization of a Theory with Feature and Arity Constraints Rolf Backofen December 1994 Deutsches Forschungszentrum
More informationThe Definition of Kernel Oz
Deutsches Forschungszentrum für Künstliche Intelligenz GmbH Research Report RR-94-23 The Definition of Kernel Oz Gert Smolka November 1994 Deutsches Forschungszentrum für Künstliche Intelligenz GmbH Postfach
More informationEvaluation. Research Consulting Education. www.ceval.org
Evaluation Research Consulting Education www.ceval.org CEval The Center for Evaluation (CEval) is a research, service and educational institute that is unique in Germany. Since 2002, it has conducted evaluations
More informationMSc in Production & Operations Management (POM) at the HECTOR School Karlsruhe Institute of Technology Karlsruhe
DAAD Deutscher Akademischer Austauschdienst German Academic Exchange Service Home [//www.daad.de/en/index.html] / Information on Study and Research in Germany [//www.daad.de/deutschland/en/] / International
More informationTechWatch. Technology and Market Observation powered by SMILA
TechWatch Technology and Market Observation powered by SMILA PD Dr. Günter Neumann DFKI, Deutsches Forschungszentrum für Künstliche Intelligenz GmbH, Juni 2011 Goal - Observation of Innovations and Trends»
More informationCombining Sequential and Concurrent Verification - The SMTP Case Study -
Deutsches Forschungszentrum für f r Künstliche K Intelligenz Combining Sequential and Concurrent Verification - The SMTP Case Study - Bruno Langenstein, Werner Stephan (DFKI GmbH) Saarbrücken, Germany
More informationEfficient Techniques for Improved Data Classification and POS Tagging by Monitoring Extraction, Pruning and Updating of Unknown Foreign Words
, pp.290-295 http://dx.doi.org/10.14257/astl.2015.111.55 Efficient Techniques for Improved Data Classification and POS Tagging by Monitoring Extraction, Pruning and Updating of Unknown Foreign Words Irfan
More informationErasmus Exchanges for Informatics Students
Erasmus Exchanges for Informatics Students Aris Efthymiou School of Informatics University of Edinburgh aefthymi@inf.ed.ac.uk September 23, 2010 Aris Efthymiou Erasmus Exchanges for Informatics Students
More informationL130: Chapter 5d. Dr. Shannon Bischoff. Dr. Shannon Bischoff () L130: Chapter 5d 1 / 25
L130: Chapter 5d Dr. Shannon Bischoff Dr. Shannon Bischoff () L130: Chapter 5d 1 / 25 Outline 1 Syntax 2 Clauses 3 Constituents Dr. Shannon Bischoff () L130: Chapter 5d 2 / 25 Outline Last time... Verbs...
More informationCopyright 2013 wolfssl Inc. All rights reserved. 2
- - Copyright 2013 wolfssl Inc. All rights reserved. 2 Copyright 2013 wolfssl Inc. All rights reserved. 2 Copyright 2013 wolfssl Inc. All rights reserved. 3 Copyright 2013 wolfssl Inc. All rights reserved.
More informationChallenges of Automation in Translation Quality Management
Challenges of Automation in Translation Quality Management Berlin, 12.09.2009 Dr. François Massion D.O.G. Dokumentation ohne Grenzen GmbH francois.massion@dog-gmbh.de Overview Quality definition and quality
More informationNew Production Technologies in Aerospace Industry
New Production Technologies in Aerospace Industry Machining Innovations Conference September 18 th and 19 th 2013 in Hannover at the EMO Advanced Technology Carrier: Aerospace Industry Dipl.-Ing. Cord
More informationAppendices master s degree programme Human Machine Communication 2014-2015
Appendices master s degree programme Human Machine Communication 2014-2015 Appendix I Teaching outcomes of the degree programme (art. 1.3) 1. The master demonstrates knowledge, understanding and the ability
More informationLanguage Technology - Where to Search for It?
Where to search for Language Technology (LT) documents? How to retrieve LT documents? Is the extensive experience in LT important for retrieving information? GL14 Fourteenth International Conference on
More informationResolution of the 18th General Meeting of the German Rectors' Conference (HRK) on 12 May 2015 in Kaiserslautern
Resolution of the 18th General Meeting of the German Rectors' Conference (HRK) on 12 May 2015 in Kaiserslautern Franchising Models in Medicine and Medical Schools HRK German Rectors' Conference The Voice
More informationVisualization of Large and Unstructured Data Sets
Hans Hagen, Andreas Kerren, Peter Dannenmann (Eds.) Visualization of Large and Unstructured Data Sets First workshop of the DFG s International Research Training Group Visualization of Large and Unstructured
More informationSyntax: Phrases. 1. The phrase
Syntax: Phrases Sentences can be divided into phrases. A phrase is a group of words forming a unit and united around a head, the most important part of the phrase. The head can be a noun NP, a verb VP,
More informationDATA MANAGEMENT PLAN DELIVERABLE NUMBER RESPONSIBLE AUTHOR. Co- funded by the Horizon 2020 Framework Programme of the European Union
DATA MANAGEMENT PLAN Co- funded by the Horizon 2020 Framework Programme of the European Union DELIVERABLE NUMBER DELIVERABLE TITLE D7.4 Data Management Plan RESPONSIBLE AUTHOR DFKI GRANT AGREEMENT N. PROJECT
More informationIndustry 4.0 Challenges and Opportunities
Industry 4.0 Challenges and Opportunities Institute of Industrial Management and Innovation Research Graz University of Technology 14 th International Conference on Knowledge Technologies and Data-driven
More informationOCRopus Addons. Internship Report. Submitted to:
OCRopus Addons Internship Report Submitted to: Image Understanding and Pattern Recognition Lab German Research Center for Artificial Intelligence Kaiserslautern, Germany Submitted by: Ambrish Dantrey,
More informationConstraints in Phrase Structure Grammar
Constraints in Phrase Structure Grammar Phrase Structure Grammar no movement, no transformations, context-free rules X/Y = X is a category which dominates a missing category Y Let G be the set of basic
More informationPresentation of Arab International University History Present Future
Presentation of Arab International University History Present Future Dipl. Hdl. Thomas Rieke Director International Relations Office Content: 1. History 2. Mission and vision 3. Geographical Location 4.
More informationLearning Mathematics with
Deutsches Forschungszentrum für f r Künstliche K Intelligenz Learning Mathematics with Jörg Siekmann German Research Centre for Artificial Intelligence DFKI Universität des Saarlandes e-learning: Systems
More informationWhat s in a Lexicon. The Lexicon. Lexicon vs. Dictionary. What kind of Information should a Lexicon contain?
What s in a Lexicon What kind of Information should a Lexicon contain? The Lexicon Miriam Butt November 2002 Semantic: information about lexical meaning and relations (thematic roles, selectional restrictions,
More informationGuidelines to the application form Admission of companies to Exchange trading
Guidelines to the application form Admission of companies to Exchange trading Preliminary remarks According to section 19 (1) of the German Exchange Act (Börsengesetz, BörsG), section 12 of the Exchange
More informationWhy major in linguistics (and what does a linguist do)?
Why major in linguistics (and what does a linguist do)? Written by Monica Macaulay and Kristen Syrett What is linguistics? If you are considering a linguistics major, you probably already know at least
More informationCompany Presentation
Company Presentation Content Company Areas of Competence Clients / References Projects Contact 2001-2008 Page 2 Acrys Consult Spin-off from a Leading German Bank Acrys Consult GmbH & Co. KG Market Entry
More informationThe 10 th Asia-Pacific Weeks Berlin 2015
The 10 th Asia-Pacific Weeks Berlin 2015 I. Key Issue: Smart Cities The 10 th Asia-Pacific Weeks (APW) will be taking place in Berlin from the 18 th to the 29 th of May, 2015. The topical framework Smart
More informationCurriculum Vitae. Prof. Dr.-Ing. Jürgen Wiese
1 Curriculum Vitae Prof. Dr.-Ing. Jürgen Wiese University of Applied Sciences Magdeburg-Stendal Department of Water, Environment, Construction and Safety Professor for Urban Water Management Wastewater
More informationPresented to The Federal Big Data Working Group Meetup On 07 June 2014 By Chuck Rehberg, CTO Semantic Insights a Division of Trigent Software
Semantic Research using Natural Language Processing at Scale; A continued look behind the scenes of Semantic Insights Research Assistant and Research Librarian Presented to The Federal Big Data Working
More informationIntelligent Retrieval for Component Reuse in System-On-Chip Design
Intelligent Retrieval for Component Reuse in System-On-Chip Design Andrea Freßmann, Rainer Maximini, Martin Schaaf University of Hildesheim, Data- and Knowledge Management Group PO Box 101363, 31113 Hildesheim,
More informationReview: Innovating E-mobility Ecosystem Forum & April Automotive Reception, April 16, 2014
Review: Innovating E-mobility Ecosystem Forum & April Automotive Reception, April 16, 2014 Participants: 253 Origin of Companies: Origin of Companies 15% Domestic 42% Foreign Joint Venture 43% Participants
More informationText Analytics for Brand Research. Non-reactive Concept Mapping to Elicit Consumer Perception
Text Analytics for Brand Research Non-reactive Concept Mapping to Elicit Consumer Perception 1 Who We Are Background! University of Cologne spin-off" Founded 2011 " at the Department of Information Systems"
More informationExploiting User and Process Context for Knowledge Management Systems
Workshop on User Modeling for Context-Aware Applications at the 8th Int. Conf. on User Modeling, July 13-16, 2001, Sonthofen, Germany Exploiting User and Process Context for Knowledge Management Systems
More informationThe model-based construction of a case-oriented expert system
Deutsches Forschungszentrum für Künstliche Intelligenz GmbH Research Report RR-92-27 The model-based construction of a case-oriented expert system Franz Schmalhofer, Jörg Thoben June 1992 Deutsches Forschungszentrum
More informationAsia-Pacific Weeks Berlin May 18 29, 2015 Smart Cities
Asia-Pacific Weeks Berlin May 18 29, 2015 Smart Cities What s new in 2015? Systemic and holistic consideraton of the topic Smart City Cooperation with Metropolitan Solutions Triad of conference, trade
More informationGIZ s requirements for invoicing under the General Terms and Conditions of Contract 2012
GIZ s requirements for invoicing under the General Terms and Conditions of Contract 2012 This document provides invoicing-specific information that always applies, unless otherwise agreed in your contract.
More informationDomain Knowledge Extracting in a Chinese Natural Language Interface to Databases: NChiql
Domain Knowledge Extracting in a Chinese Natural Language Interface to Databases: NChiql Xiaofeng Meng 1,2, Yong Zhou 1, and Shan Wang 1 1 College of Information, Renmin University of China, Beijing 100872
More informationNatural Language Processing
Natural Language Processing : AI Course Lecture 41, notes, slides www.myreaders.info/, RC Chakraborty, e-mail rcchak@gmail.com, June 01, 2010 www.myreaders.info/html/artificial_intelligence.html www.myreaders.info
More informationHigh Performance Computing within the AHRP http://www.ahrp.info http://www.ahrp.info
High Performance Computing within the AHRP http://www.ahrp.info http://www.ahrp.info The Alliance for HPC Rhineland-Palatinate! History, Goals and Tasks! Organization! Access to Resources! Training and
More informationHow To Develop A Transport System For A Train System
Deutsches Forschungszentrum für Künstliche Intelligenz GmbH Technical Memo TM-99-02 An Intercompany Dispatch Support System for Intermodal Transport Chains Hans-Jürgen Bürckert, Petra Funk, Gero Vierke
More informationOrdering Constraints on Trees
Deutsches Forschungszentrum für Künstliche Intelligenz GmbH Research Report RR-94-12 Ordering Constraints on Trees Hubert Comon and Ralf Treinen March 1994 Deutsches Forschungszentrum für Künstliche Intelligenz
More informationAlfred Freiherr von Oppenheim
PRESS RELEASE Alfred Freiherr von Oppenheim Chairman of the Supervisory Board Alfred Freiherr von Oppenheim will celebrate his 70 th birthday on 5 May 2004. Before the banker, who was born in Cologne in
More informationWWW: http://www.dfki.de
'HXWVFKHV )RUVFKXQJV]HQWUXP I U. QVWOLFKH,QWHOOLJHQ]*PE+ 5HVHDUFK 5HSRUW RR-99-02 6,)7KH6RFLDO,QWHUDFWLRQ)UDPHZRUN 6\VWHP'HVFULSWLRQDQG8VHU V*XLGHWRD0XOWL$JHQW 6\VWHP7HVWEHG 0LFKDHO6FKLOOR- UJHQ/LQG3HWUD)XQN
More informationIndustry 4.0 the German vision for advanced manufacturing
www.smartfactory-kl.de Industry 4.0 the German vision for advanced manufacturing Prof. Dr. Dr. h.c. Detlef Zühlke Director Innovative Factory Systems IFS German Research Center for Artificial Intelligence,
More informationMaintenance of EMU - a new approach for management and technology
RöschConsult Group Maintenance of EMU - a new approach for management and technology Beijing Jiaotong University May, 8th 2013 Prof. Dr.-Ing. Wolfgang Roesch 2 RoeschConsult Group GmbH RöschConsult Group
More informationRenewable Energy Research Association (FVS)
FVS Renewable Energy Research Association (FVS) In the past few years, the general conditions for research into solar and renewables have consistently improved: they have been intensively developed, have
More informationCurrent Changes in German Corporate Tax Law Tax Germany
Current Changes in German Corporate Tax Law Tax Germany Newsletter December 23, 2010 For further information please contact: Duesseldorf: Dr. Stephan Schnorberger stephan.schnorberger@ bakermckenzie.com
More informationBusiness Brief Consolidation Index: Critical Success Factors for Industry Consolidation 1
Business Brief Consolidation Index: Critical Success Factors for Industry Consolidation 1 ESMT No. BB-108-006 ESMT BUSINESS BRIEF Europe and China: Different Stages of Industry Consolidation Marten Büttner,
More informationREFERENCE. Project P&O Ports Antwerpen. ms Neumann Elektronik GmbH. Systemhersteller und Systemintegrator für Informations- und Sicherheitstechnik
ms Neumann Elektronik GmbH Systemhersteller und Systemintegrator für Informations- und Sicherheitstechnik System manufacturer and system integrator for information and safety technology Innovative command-
More informationreviewed paper RADAR Potentials for Supporting Urban Development with a Social Geocontent Hub Martin Memmel, Florian Groß
reviewed paper RADAR Potentials for Supporting Urban Development with a Social Geocontent Hub Martin Memmel, Florian Groß (Dipl.-Math. Martin Memmel, memmel@dfki.de, Deutsches Forschungszentrum für Künstliche
More informationTABLE OF CONTENTS. (2007 and planned).. 9
TABLE OF CONTENTS Section 1. Executive Summary.... 2 Section 2. Survey Coverage and Analysis... 3 Section 3. Ownership and Organization of Airports... 3 Section 4. Ownership and Organization of Air Navigation
More informationBlue Sky. Green City....fresh ideas for our climate
Blue Sky...fresh ideas for our climate InnovationCity Ruhr Model Town Bottrop innovative ideas and solutions for climate protection will be tested in the real world here until 2020 in order to serve as
More informationTrainers. Target Groups of Participants. General background
s The training contents will be presented by representatives of reputable German companies: SMA Solar Technology AG (www.sma.de) Energiebau Solarstromsysteme GmbH (www.energiebau.de) Hoppecke Batterien
More informationEXECUTIVE SUMMARY phase6 hallo Europa - 1 -
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY phase6 hallo Europa - 1 - EDUCATION IS AN INVESTMENT IN THE FUTURE GIVING SOMEONE AN EDUCATION MEANS GIVING THEM A FUTURE. - 2 - phase6 hallo Europa EXECUTIVE SUMMARY The project hallo-app
More informationExperiences from Verbmobil. Norbert Reithinger DFKI GmbH Stuhlsatzenhausweg 3 D-66123 Saarbrücken bert@dfki.de
Experiences from Verbmobil Norbert Reithinger DFKI GmbH Stuhlsatzenhausweg 3 D-66123 Saarbrücken bert@dfki.de Content Overview of Verbmobil project Scientific challenges and experiences Software technology
More informationGermany in Europe: the Europeanization of German politics
Timm Beichelt Germany in Europe: the Europeanization of German politics MA Seminar, Winter Semester 2008/09 Session: 6.11.2008 The Long Road West Seminar schedule 16.10. Accession test 11.12. Intermediary
More informationFlorian M. Federspiel
Florian M. Federspiel McDonough School of Business, Georgetown University Rafik B. Hariri Building, 5th floor, 37th and O Streets, NW, Washington DC, 20057, USA Email: fmf13@georgetown.edu Tel: +1 202
More informationThe Complexity of Existential Quantification. in Concept Languages
Deutsches Forschungszentrum for KOnstliche Intelligenz GmbH Research Report RR-91-02 The Complexity of Existential Quantification in Concept Languages Francesco Donini, Bernhard Hollunder, Maurizio Lenzerini,
More informationPresentation of Arab International University History Present Future
Presentation of Arab International University History Present Future Dipl. Hdl. Thomas Rieke Director International Relations Office Content: 1. History 2. Mission and vision 3. Geographical Location 4.
More informationCyber-Physical Systems, Internet of Things & Industry 4.0 First Technical Prototypes
Cyber-Physical Systems, Internet of Things & Industry 4.0 First Technical Prototypes Johannes Schöning Munich, Germany 10/2013 London Münster Berlin Köln Hasselt Saarbrücken Innovative Retail Lab (IRL)
More informationNAME: DATE: Business: Insurance. Business Insurance
Business Insurance It is not necessary to carry out all the activities contained in this unit. Please see Teachers Notes for explanations, additional activities, and tips and suggestions. Theme Insurance
More informationBusiness Continuity Policy
Business Continuity Policy Software, consultancy and services for global trade and supply chain management Business Continuity Policy Companies using AEB solutions for managing and monitoring their logistics
More informationInvited talks (in Hungary unless marked otherwise)
Invited talks (in Hungary unless marked otherwise) 1972 On the possibility of applying generative Copenhagen, Denmark grammars for contrasting languages 3rd International Congress of Applied Linguistics
More informationERP Goes China Management Summary. Dr. Eric Scherer, Frank Naujoks, Philipp Drack i2s research, Zürich
ERP Goes China Management Summary Dr. Eric Scherer, Frank Naujoks, Philipp Drack i2s research, Zürich Content 1. License agreement and copyright 2. Overview 3. Reasons to move to China 4. Consequences
More informationCSC 742 Database Management Systems
CSC 742 Database Management Systems Topic #4: Data Modeling Spring 2002 CSC 742: DBMS by Dr. Peng Ning 1 Phases of Database Design Requirement Collection/Analysis Functional Requirements Functional Analysis
More informationLehrstuhl für Rechnertechnik und Rechnerorganisation (LRR-TUM) Annual Report 1998/1999
Research Report Series Lehrstuhl für Rechnertechnik und Rechnerorganisation (LRR-TUM) Technische Universität München http://wwwbode.informatik.tu-muenchen.de/ Editor: Prof. Dr. A. Bode Vol. 18 Lehrstuhl
More informationIFRS APPLICATION AROUND THE WORLD JURISDICTIONAL PROFILE: People s Republic of China
IFRS APPLICATION AROUND THE WORLD JURISDICTIONAL PROFILE: People s Republic of China Disclaimer: The information in this Profile is for general guidance only and may change from time to time. You should
More informationIntegration of Time Management in the Digital Factory
Integration of Time Management in the Digital Factory Ulf Eberhardt a,, Stefan Rulhoff b,1 and Dr. Josip Stjepandic c a Project Engineer, Daimler Trucks, Mannheim, Germany b Consultant, PROSTEP AG, Darmstadt
More informationTechnical Memo TM-99-01 SMESPR/1.0. Matthias Fischmann. Deutsches Forschungszentrum für Künstliche Intelligenz GmbH. January 1999
Deutsches Forschungszentrum für Künstliche Intelligenz GmbH Technical Memo TM-99-01 SMESPR/1.0 Matthias Fischmann January 1999 Deutsches Forschungszentrum für Künstliche Intelligenz GmbH Postfach 20 80
More informationComma checking in Danish Daniel Hardt Copenhagen Business School & Villanova University
Comma checking in Danish Daniel Hardt Copenhagen Business School & Villanova University 1. Introduction This paper describes research in using the Brill tagger (Brill 94,95) to learn to identify incorrect
More informationInteractive Dynamic Information Extraction
Interactive Dynamic Information Extraction Kathrin Eichler, Holmer Hemsen, Markus Löckelt, Günter Neumann, and Norbert Reithinger Deutsches Forschungszentrum für Künstliche Intelligenz - DFKI, 66123 Saarbrücken
More informationPeerEnergyCloud Trading Renewable Energies
PeerEnergyCloud Trading Renewable Energies Jochen Frey, Boris Brandherm, and Jörg Baus German Research Center for Artificial Intelligence GmbH, Stuhlsatzenhausweg 3, 66123 Saarbrücken, Germany {frey,brandherm,baus}@dfki.de
More informationistockphoto.com/alex com/alex Slobodkin Fraunhofer ISI
HETEROGENEOUS COOPERATIONS - NEW FORMS OF RESEARCH COLLABORATION IN THE GERMAN INNOVATION SYSTEM Second Sino-German Innovation Forum, Berlin, 26/27.11.2012 Prof. Dr. Knut Koschatzky istockphoto.com/alex
More informationUniversity of Kaiserslautern. International School for Graduate Studies (ISGS)
University of Kaiserslautern International School for Graduate Studies (ISGS) What makes us different? Top ranked departments High ratio of graduate students (50 %) Graduate education & doctoral research
More informationTitelmasterformat durch Klicken bearbeiten
Titelmasterformat durch Klicken www.wattline.de Titelmasterformat durch Klicken WATTLINE November 2012 1 Titelmasterformat Strong Basis durch Klicken Titelmasterformat WATTLINE GmbH durch a subsidiary
More informationGerman Corporate Governance Code
1 German Corporate Governance Code SAF-HOLLAND S.A. is a Luxembourg société anonyme (S.A.) which is listed solely on a stock exchange in Germany. Therefore, we are not required to adhere to the Luxembourg
More informationNon-nominal Which-Relatives
Non-nominal Which-Relatives Doug Arnold, Robert D. Borsley University of Essex The properties of non-restrictive relatives All non-restrictive relative clauses include a wh-word. There are no that or zero
More informationMethod- and Tool-Support for a Customer-Integrated Assembly Process
Overview Reasons for Customer-Integrated Assembly Application Overview Methodical Approaches Shopfloor Information Concept The Contribution is based on work and results achieved in the project MUSKIM Methoden-
More informationTechnical concepts of kopal. Tobias Steinke, Deutsche Nationalbibliothek June 11, 2007, Berlin
Technical concepts of kopal Tobias Steinke, Deutsche Nationalbibliothek June 11, 2007, Berlin 1 Overview Project kopal Ideas Organisation Results Technical concepts DIAS kolibri Models of reusability 2
More informationBusiness Intelligence: Recent Experiences in Canada
Business Intelligence: Recent Experiences in Canada Leopoldo Bertossi Carleton University School of Computer Science Ottawa, Canada : Faculty Fellow of the IBM Center for Advanced Studies 2 Business Intelligence
More information