Present: The Honourable Mr.Justice P.A. Mohammed Tuesday, the 24th day of June, 1997/3rd Ashadha, P.No.711 of

Size: px

Start display at page:

Download "Present: The Honourable Mr.Justice P.A. Mohammed Tuesday, the 24th day of June, 1997/3rd Ashadha, 1919. 0.P.No.711 of 1991-1"

Ellen Collins
8 years ago
Views:

1 ,, IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM Present: The Honourable Mr.Justice P.A. Mohammed Tuesday, the 24th day of June, 1997/3rd Ashadha, ~-~-~~-~~~--~-~ P.No.711 of Petitioner:- N. John, s/o. Nalla Thampi, aged 55 years, residing at Joby Bhavan, Vallyapoyil, p.o.r.e.c. Kozhikode Vs. Respondents:- 1. The Board of Governors of the Regional Engineering College, Kozhikode represented by the Principal and Secretary, Engineering College, Kozhikode Addl.R3 2. The Principal, Regional Engineering College, Kozhikode Additional R3 & R4 impleaded. & R4 Addl.R3. M.P. Sahadevan, Workshop Foreman Regional Engineering College, Kozhikode-1. n R4. V.M. Joseph, Workshop Foreman, Regional Engineering College, Kozhikode-1. Impleaded as per order dt in CMP.1768/91. By Advocate Mr. K.P. Dandapani for R1 & 2 By Advocate Sri. T.V. Ajayakumar for R3 & R4 This Original Petition having been finally heard on the court on the same day delivered the following:- p.t.o.

The Board of Governors of the Regional Engineering College, Kozhikode represented by the Principal and Secretary, Engineering College, Kozhikode-673 601. Addl.R3 2.

2 . ':>! P.A. MOHAMMED, J O.P.~D. 711 of _ JUDGMENT petitioner was an em?loyee under the Board of Governors of the Regional Engineering college, KOzhikode. On an earlier occasion a writ petition came before this Court in O.P.NO of That writ petition was disposed of by Ext.p12 judgment directing as follows: 1n view of the various factors mentioned above. I dispose of this Origin~l petition with a direction that the Board of Governors of the Regional Engineering college, Calicut may consider the request EkE of the petitioner for review of Ext.p5 order in disposing of Ext.p6 revision petition which he has filed pursuant to the said judgment the Board of Governors passed Ext.p14. The order is thus: The Board considered the recommendation of the standing & Finance committee(1tem NO. SE 14.02) dated 23rd October, 1989 and resolved that the revision petition of Shri N.John be rejected. The underlying complaint of the petitioner is that is this orderlpassed without due application of the mind.

That writ petition was disposed of by Ext.p12 judgment directing as follows: 1n view of the various factors mentioned above.

3 - 2 - Nothing is revealed from the order in what manner they have applied their maind. The application of the mind can be gauged only when the order reflects sufficient material which shows the application of mind. Of course. the order is cryptic and it cannot be sustained. Ext.P14 is set aside. I direct the first respondent to consider the entire question in xxx pr9per perspective applying their mind in view of the direction given by this court in Ext.p12 judgment. Original petition is disposed of as above. 3X~RKX Since the Original petition is of the year 1991, I think, it would be proper for the Board of GOvernors to take a final decision within three months from the date 24th JUne, 1997 kvm/

the order is cryptic and it cannot be sustained. Ext.P14 is set aside.

4 ~' Petitioner's Ext.P1 n P2 P3 P4 P5 n p6 P7 APPENDIX True copy of Resolution No.57:19 issued by the 1st respondent dt True copy of order No.MED/Ws/85 dated to the petitioner. True copy of Report of Transfer of charges dated True copy of memoramdum issued by the 1st respondent to the petitioner dt : True' copy of proceedings No.P1-4618/85 issued by the 1st respondent dt True copy of revision petition submitted by the petitioner before the 1st respondent dated True copy of proceedings issued by the 1st respondent to the petitioner No.P2/7692/87 dated ~~ P8 True copy ofprpceedings issued by the 1st respondent No.P2-210/86-88/dated P9 True copy of Office order No.MED-21/EST/79 dated to the petitioner. P10 True copy of letter No.19099/G3/88/H.Edn. dated from the Commr. to the 2nd respondent. P11 True copy of proceedings No.P3/4117/89 dated issued by the 1st respondent to the peti~ioner. P12 P13 n P14 P15 P16 True copy of judgment of O.P.6645 of 1985 dated True copy of representation filed by the petitioner before the 1st respondent dt True copy of resolution No dt sent by the 1st respondent. True copy of the proceedings dated issued by the Caltcut Regional Engineering College. True copy of the Circular dated issued by the Regional Engineering College,Calicut. Exts:- MT/- P.A. to The Honourable Judge.

P1-4618/85 issued by the 1st respondent dt. 8-7-85. True copy of revision petition submitted by the petitioner before the 1st respondent dated 12-8-85.

5 P.A. MOHAMMED;, J. ----_.. _---_.. _... _ O.P.No. 711 of _ JUDGMENT 24th JUne, 1997 I

v/s. Western India Art Litho Works Pvt. Ltd.

1 cp1096.2000 IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY ORDINARY ORIGINAL CIVIL JURISDICTION COMPANY PETITION NO. 1096 of 2000 Solar Printing Inks v/s. Western India Art Litho Works Pvt. Ltd....Petitioner...Respondent