NEUROFUZZY NETWORK MODELING OF DATA CENTRE ENERGY PERFORMANCE


 Theodora Lorraine Powell
 1 years ago
 Views:
Transcription
1 Chapter 6: Neurofuzzy Network Modeling of Data Centre Energy Performance CHAPTER 6 NEUROFUZZY NETWORK MODELING OF DATA CENTRE ENERGY PERFORMANCE 6.1 Introduction An exploratory study of the wholesystem based neurofuzzy network modeling for data centre energy performance is conducted as part of the efforts to understand an empirical energy use pattern of data centres in Singapore. The models developed integrates energy consuming constituents contributing to the energy consumptions of data centres, and analyzes various factors such as physical parameters of space and environment control facilities, design and operation strategies of HVAC, UPS, IT equipment and lighting systems. Neurofuzzy network presents itself a desired and applicable candidate of modeling energy performance of complex systems by taking advantages of mimicking human decision and selftraining by existing data sets. A well structured and trained neurofuzzy model can serve as evaluation tool kits at both design and postdiagnostic stages of data centres. Energy saving potential can also be estimated quantitatively. FuzzyTech 5.5 is employed as the modeling software in this study. In this study, the neurofuzzy network models are established based on the energy performance benchmarking of the six data centres studied. Due to the small data base, these models cannot provide highly accurate evaluation of data centre energy performance and prediction of data centres energy saving potential. However, they can serve as efficient and effective tools, prior to the further and detailed measurement and verification (M&V) or energy simulation for the evaluation of data centre energy 146
2 Chapter 6: Neurofuzzy Network Modeling of Data Centre Energy Performance performance and estimation of energy saving potential. 6.2 Application of neurofuzzy network in modeling data centre energy performance Fuzzy logic is a technology that enhances modelbased system design by using both intuition and engineering heuristics. This provides an efficient way of designing, optimizing, and maintaining highly complex systems and results in robust and fault tolerant systems. The use of linguistic modeling, instead of mathematical modeling, greatly enhances system transparency and modification potential. It leads to quick development cycles, easy programming and accurate control. Fuzzy logic principle is especially advantageous for problems that cannot be easily represented by mathematical modeling because data is either unavailable, incomplete, or the process is too complex to use a traditional approach [FuzzyTech, 2001]. There are a number of reasons for neurofuzzy network to be employed as modeling approach in this study. Firstly, data centres energy consumption is a complex system. A typical data centre contains various energy consuming systems including IT equipment, UPS, HVAC system, lighting, office equipment, building control system, fire suppression system, current transformer and standby power generator. The interactions among energy consuming systems also make this system more complex. Energy performance of data centres is also affected significantly by physical variables such as space usage, indoor temperature, humidity, as well as the design and operation strategies. While it is possible to develop a deterministicnamely precise mathematical or empiricalmodel, the complexity of the data centre energy performance makes it 147
3 Chapter 6: Neurofuzzy Network Modeling of Data Centre Energy Performance difficult to be modeled using conventional modeling approach such as multiple regression. Energy simulation, the popular tool of modeling building system and predicting energy consumption, is another possible solution for modeling data centre. However, simulation is highly time and cost consuming. By comparison, neurofuzzy network with the capability of modeling complex system can be a suitable solution in this study. Secondly, the term energy performance is by nature a fuzzy concept. It not only associates with the energy consumption and power demand, but also the operational energy efficiencies of various systems and total data centre. A precise definition of energy performance does not exist. Traditional indicators such as annual energy consumption (kwh/m 2 /year) and power demand density (W/m 2 ) per unit gross floor area are not sufficient for describing data centres energy performance. For example, the total data centre power demand densities of data centre 4 and data centre 6 are 348 W/m 2 and 231 W/m 2 respectively. This does not mean that data centre 6 is more energy efficient than data centre 4, as data centre 6 may have a sparse equipment distribution over a large area, and also resulting in significant amount of energy spent on space cooling. Besides, it is found that the UPS system in data centre 6 is the least efficient among all the data centres studied. It is evident that energy efficiencies of HVAC and UPS systems, area occupancy, overdesigning of the supporting systems, designed power demands, and environmental setting put significant impact on data centres energy performance. For the reasons above, fuzzy logic which mimics human logic by combining various parameters or rules for making description or decision is suitable for the application of modeling data centre energy performance. 148
4 Chapter 6: Neurofuzzy Network Modeling of Data Centre Energy Performance Thirdly, classification of energy performance involves the usage of fuzzy concept. For example, assuming the actual total data centre power density is categorized into 3 classes, which are less than 300 /m 2, 300 W/m 2 to 410 W/m 2 and higher than 410 W/m 2 respectively, a data centre of 301 W/m 2 will be classified under Class 2, and a data centre of 299 W/m 2 will be classified under Class 1. This could be an unreasonable classification since the difference of power demand between these two data centres is very slight. This reflects the fact that the defined power demand range of each class should not be a crisp range. There should be a buffer area between each class. In this case, fuzzy logic is particularly suited for addressing this issue. 6.3 Knowledge background of neurofuzzy network Structure of fuzzy logic model A typical fuzzy logic based approach involves three modules: a fuzzifier, a fuzzy interference engine, and a defuzzifier as illustrated in Figure 6.1. Input linguistic variables Fuzzy inference Output linguistic variables Linguistic Level Technical Level Fuzzification Input real variables Defuzzification Output real variables Figure 6.1 Typical structure of rulebased fuzzy logic model (Source: FuzzyTech, 2001; Gouda et al., 2001; Krarti, 2003) A fuzzifier is used to map input vectors into fuzzy sets defined by linguistic variables 149
5 Chapter 6: Neurofuzzy Network Modeling of Data Centre Energy Performance such as Bad, Average and Good and membership functions. The inference engine associates fuzzy sets to other fuzzy sets using a rule library of IFTHEN fuzzy rules that highly intuitive and easily understood by human users. Finally the defuzzifier is used to map fuzzy sets to output vectors. Further information of fuzzy logic is provided following in section Principles of neural network For the purpose of enhancing fuzzy logic systems with learning capacities, neural network (NN) is introduced. The objective of a neural net is to process information in a manner that has been previously trained into the net. Training uses either sample data sets of inputs and corresponding outputs, or an expert who rates the performance of the neural net. A neural network can be any model in which the output variables are computed from the input variables by compositions of basic function or connections. However, one of the most commonly used neural network models is the multilayer perception [Krarti, 1998]. Figure 6.2 shows a schematic diagram of the structure of a neural network. Figure 6.2 Neural network schematic diagram (Source: Krarti, 2003) 150
6 Chapter 6: Neurofuzzy Network Modeling of Data Centre Energy Performance The first and last layers of neurons are called input and output layers; between them are one or more hidden layers. The neuron depicted by the small circles is the fundamental building block of a network. Each element of the input set, INPUT i, is multiplied by a weight, W ij, and the products are summed to provide the output at the neuron, OUTPUT j : OUTPUT j = Σ i INPUT i W ij +B j Eqn (6.1) where, B j is the bias at the neuron j. The bias is the activation threshold for the neuron j. This bias avoids the tendency of an activation function to get stuck in the saturated, limiting value area of the activation function described below. After each OUTPUT j is calculated, an activation function is applied to modify it. The activation function is typically a bounded monotonic function. Sigmoid function is the most common one. ƒ(x)= 1/ (1+exp(x)) Eqn (6.2) The weights W ij of the neural network are adjusted iteratively so that application of a set of inputs produces the desired set of outputs. If the computed outputs do not match the known values during network training, the NN model is in error. The error, E, is typically calculated as the sum of squared differences between computed and target values: E= Σ j (OUTPUT j TARGET j ) 2 Eqn (6.3) 151
7 Chapter 6: Neurofuzzy Network Modeling of Data Centre Energy Performance If the error E is large, then the neural network weights, W ij are adjusted to reduce this error. The most commonly used approach to adjust the weights is the gradient descent method. Using this approach, the weights is changed from W ij to (W ij a de/dw ij ), where parameter a is called the learning rate. This procedure of weight adjustment is called backpropagation. A simplified procedure for the learning process of neural network is summarized below: Provide the network with training data consisting of patterns of input variables and target outputs. Assess how closely the network output matches the target outputs. Adapt the connection strengths (i.e., weights) between the neurons so the network produces better approximations of the desired target outputs. Continue the process of adjusting the weights until some desired accuracy level is achieved. Analyse the results to assess the validity of the parametric relationships Neurofuzzy network [FuzzyTech, 2001] The key benefit of fuzzy logic is that it allows design consultant to describe desired system behaviour with simple IFTHEN relations. However, this is at the same time its major limitation. In many applications, knowledge that describes desired system behaviour is contained in data sets. The design consultant must derive the IFTHEN rules from the data sets manually. In this case, a neural network presents a solution since it can train the model itself from the data, while the fuzzy logic model provides 152
8 Chapter 6: Neurofuzzy Network Modeling of Data Centre Energy Performance the rules which governs the paradigm relationships. On the other hand, neural network itself is limited by a number of reasons. Firstly, neural network solution stands as a black box. Design consultant can neither interpret what derive a certain behaviour, nor modify a neural network manually to influence a certain behaviour. Secondly, neural network require prohibitive computational effort, and numbers of sample data during the modeling process. Thirdly, selection of the appropriate net model and setting the parameters of the learning algorithm is still a tough job which requires extensive experience. Among the mentioned reasons, inadequacy of data base and experience, as well as the lack of an easy way to verify and optimize a neural network solution are probably the major limitations of neuro network. For this application, combined use of neural network and fuzzy logic might provide a powerful technique which compensates individual method s weakness. Neural network can learn from data sets, while fuzzy logic solutions are easy to verify and optimize. Neurofuzzy network combines the advantages of fuzzy systems, the explicit knowledge representation of knowledge, and the ability to cope with uncertainties with the learning power of neural network Method of neurofuzzy network modeling using FuzzyTech 5.5 FuzzyTech 5.5 is powerful software using neurofuzzy technology, with which models describing complex systems can be established easily and clearly. As shown in Figure 6.3, the basic neurofuzzy network model typically consists of input variables, rule blocks and output variables. 153
9 Chapter 6: Neurofuzzy Network Modeling of Data Centre Energy Performance Fuzzification Fuzzy Inference Defuzzification Figure 6.3 Basic structure of fuzzy logic model Fuzzification The fuzzification interface consists of the following operations [Gouda et al., 2001]: 1) Perform a scale mapping that transfers the input variable ranges into a corresponding universe of discourse (quantization/ normalization). 2) Performs the fuzzification strategy that converts crisp input data into suitable linguistic variables, which may be viewed as labels of fuzzy sets. Firstly, in the fuzzification interface, real values are transformed into linguistic variables. In this study all the input and output variables are defined correspondingly to three classes within the full range of observed values. For example, Total data centre energy consumption is converted into fuzzy sets such as low, medium and high. 154
10 Chapter 6: Neurofuzzy Network Modeling of Data Centre Energy Performance The degree to which the crisp value belongs to a set is represented by a value between 0 and 1, called the degree of membership µ. Fuzzy logic describes degree of membership by a function known as a membership function (MBF). Standard membership functions are used in most practical applications with types of Z, Lambda, Pi and S, as shown in Figure 6.4. Figure 6.4 Standard membership function types Figure 6.5 below shows the fuzzification of term total data centre energy consumption. Based on the data collected during the measurements in the 6 data centre studied, the details of the ranges of defined input and output variables are given in Appendix H. Degree of Membership Range of real value 4100 kwh/m 2 /year Figure 6.5 Fuzzification of variable 155
11 Chapter 6: Neurofuzzy Network Modeling of Data Centre Energy Performance For example, energy consumption at 4100 kwh/m 2 /year is a member of the fuzzy sets for the terms: Low to the degree of 0.00 Medium to the degree of 0.30 High to the degree of Fuzzy inference Once all input variable values are translated into the respective linguistic variable values, the socalled fuzzy inference step evaluates the set of IFTHEN rules that define system behaviour. IFTHEN rules always describe the reaction to a certain situation as: IF <situation> THEN <action>. The inference is a calculus consisting of the steps: aggregation, composition and, if necessary, result aggregation. First, aggregation determines the degree to which the complete IF part of the rule is fulfilled. Special fuzzy operators are used to aggregate the degrees of support of the various preconditions. There are in Min operator, which corresponds with the linguistic AND, is most common and has been employed for the study. Equation below shows the principle of this method. Figure 6.6 shows the dialog of input fuzzy operator. AND: µ (A^B)=min {µ(a), µ(b)} Eqn (6.4) 156
12 Chapter 6: Neurofuzzy Network Modeling of Data Centre Energy Performance Figure 6.6 Operator of input aggregation Each rule defines an action to be taken in the THEN part. The degree to which the action is valid is given by the adequacy of the rule to the current situation. This adequacy is computed by the aggregation as the degree of truth of the IF part. In the composition step, the degree of truth of the IF part of the rule is multiplied by a weighting factor, named Degree of Support (DoS). This factor represents the individual significance of the rule. By this way, rules themselves can be fuzzy, with a support between 0 and 1. The support of a consequence is calculated by linking the support of the entire condition with the DoS by composition operator. See the equation below. µ THEN =µ IF * DoS Eqn (6.5) 157
13 Chapter 6: Neurofuzzy Network Modeling of Data Centre Energy Performance Figure 6.7 shows an example of the defined rules. Input variables Degree of support (DOS) Output variables Figure 6.7 Definition of fuzzy rules A result aggregation step determines the maximum degree of support for each consequence which is used for all further processing. Also shown in Figure 6.6, there are two methods of result aggregation, the maximum method (MAX) and the bounded sum method. If more than one rule produces the same consequence, an operation must aggregate the results of these rules. MAX operator takes the maximum of the Dos values as final result. The BSUM method takes the bounded sum. In this study, MAX method is employed to aggregate the results of these rules, as presented by the equation below. MAX result aggregation: µ RESULT = max i (µ THEN, RULEi ) Eqn (6.6) With the application of neurofuzzy network in this study, all the fuzzy rules were formulated automatically from the training data. Firstly, a full range of possible rules is generated. For example, say, there are two input variables and one output variable; and each variable has three classes low, medium, high. The total number of possible 158
14 Chapter 6: Neurofuzzy Network Modeling of Data Centre Energy Performance rules is 3x3x3=27. After the neural network training, weight of each fuzzy rule is determined through Dos. The insignificant rules will be removed from the rule block. Further discussion of neurofuzzy training is provided in Section Defuzzification The result produced from the fuzzy rules are linguistic values, namely fuzzy, for the output variables. The defuzzification step translates the linguistic results into real values. There are several methods of defuzzification. CentreofArea (CoA), sometime also called CentreofGravity (CoG) is the most frequently used defuzzification method. This method is based on taking the aggregate of the fuzzy outputs from each rule, weighted by their grades of fuzzy input set membership, see Figure 6.8. Figure 6.8 Deffuzification with CentreofArea The CentreofMaximum (CoM) is another commonly used method of defuzzification. It computes a crisp output as a weighted average of the term membership maxima, weighted by the inference results (Figure 6.9). The locations of the individual term membership maxima are indicated by the gray arrows and the inference result is shown 159
15 Chapter 6: Neurofuzzy Network Modeling of Data Centre Energy Performance by the height of the black bar in the arrows. Figure 6.9 Deffuzification with CentreofMaximum Most CoA implementations are only approximations since they neglect overlapping and can be represented with methods such as CoM. Note that, since the quality of approximation has proved to be fair enough for the vast majority of applications, and CoA defuzzification is significantly slower than the approximated CoA methods, most hardware and software implementations of fuzzy logic algorithm only support CoM and others rather than the real CoA [FuzzyTech, 2001]. For this reason, CoM is employed in this study Neurofuzzy training i) Training of fuzzy rules The basic idea of neurofuzzy approach is to set up a complete fuzzy rule base, not by entering the rules, but by presenting a set of training samples and selecting the set of rules that represent the samples [FuzzyTech, 2001]. In the neurofuzzy model, neural network training function is used to evaluate the significances or weights of the 160
16 Chapter 6: Neurofuzzy Network Modeling of Data Centre Energy Performance predefined fuzzy rules. Unlike early neurofuzzy network approaches, this study employs restricted training, which requires a given rule base, to restrict the number of rules used and save apriori knowledge that was entered into the system before training. This is due to the fact that if a huge unrestricted rule base does not provide a good match to the given sample distribution, the training may not converge. Configuration of neural training is shown in Figure The definitions of the terms in this dialog are shown in Appendix I. Figure 6.10 Configuration of neural training (Source: FuzzyTech, 2001) ii) Training of fuzzification and defuzzification In a fuzzy system, membership function of these parameters found in the fuzzification (input variables) and defuzzification (output variables) can also be trained. The manner in which neurofuzzy model treats the parameters of the membership functions of variables is similar to the training of fuzzy rules. Figure 6.11 shows an example of the 161
17 Chapter 6: Neurofuzzy Network Modeling of Data Centre Energy Performance variable after training. Figure 6.11 Training of output variable Summary of settings of neurofuzzy network modeling Fuzzyification Membership function (MBF) Standard membership function Fuzzy inference Input aggregator Min operator (linguistic AND) Result aggregator Max operator (maximum of the degree of support (DoS) value) Defuzzification Method of defuzzification Centre of Maximum (CoM) Neurofuzzy training Learning method Batch Random 162
18 Chapter 6: Neurofuzzy Network Modeling of Data Centre Energy Performance Winner neurons 1 Step Width (DoS) 0.1 Step Width (Term) 1% Stop criteria Max. Steps from 4000 to Max. Deviation from 50% to 1%, factor 0.75 Avg. Deviation 0.1% 6.4 Objectives of neurofuzzy network modeling of data centre energy performance Data centre energy performance involves a complex system of energy consuming components and elements. It comprises various energy consuming components and environmental and design variables. Neurofuzzy network combining the advantages of fuzzy systems, the explicit knowledge representation of knowledge, and the ability to cope with uncertainties with the learning power of neural network is a powerful technique for developing desired solution of integrating all these systems and variables into a whole system. The objectives of neurofuzzy network modeling in this study are as follows: a. To develop wholesystem based models for data centre energy performance. b. To provide efficient and effective evaluation of data centre energy performance, and accurate estimation of energysaving potential of data centres based on the models developed. 163
19 Chapter 6: Neurofuzzy Network Modeling of Data Centre Energy Performance 6.5 Modeling methodology In this study, neurofuzzy network modeling consists of four steps. Figure 6.12 shows the systematic diagram of the modeling procedure. Parameter analysis Establish fuzzy logic model Neural network training Model verification Figure 6.12 Systematic diagram of modeling procedure Parameter analysis & establishment of fuzzy logic model Based on parameter analysis conducted in Chapter 5, variables that affect overall data centre energy performance are determined; linking those (input variables) to the key indicators (output variables) of data centre energy performance by fuzzy rule blocks, the structure of the model is determined. The results of parameter analysis are summarized as follows. The key indicators of total data centre energy performance are the total data centre energy consumption per unit gross floor area in term of kwh/m 2 /year and the energy consumption of IT equipment as a percentage of total data centre energy consumption. The significant energy consuming system of data centres are HVAC system and IT equipment. Physical variables gross floor area (m 2 ), IT footprint as a percentage of gross floor area, and total overdesigning of data centre power demand plus energy consumptions of HVAC and IT equipment in terms of kwh/m 2 /year are set as the 164
20 Chapter 6: Neurofuzzy Network Modeling of Data Centre Energy Performance significant variables of total data centre energy consumption. On the other hand, relative energy effectiveness of HVAC system which is denoted by the ratio of HVAC energy consumption to IT equipment energy consumption seems to be positively correlating to IT equipment energy consumption as a percentage of total data centre energy consumption. Based on the results of parameter analysis, model of total data centre energy performance is shown in Figure Figure 6.13 Model of overall data centre energy performance where, Grss_area is gross floor area of data centre (m 2 ) HVAC_energy is HVAC energy consumption per unit gross floor area (kwh/m 2 /year) IT_energy is IT equipment energy consumption per unit gross floor area (kwh/m 2 /year) ITfootprint is IT equipment footprint area as percentage of gross floor area (%) Total_overdesign is overdesigning of total data centre power demand () Total_energy is total data centre energy consumption per unit gross floor area (kwh/m 2 /year) HVAC_Vs_IT is the ratio of HVAC energy consumption to IT equipment energy consumption () IT_Vs_Total is the IT equipment energy consumption as percentage of total data centre energy consumption (%) 165
21 Chapter 6: Neurofuzzy Network Modeling of Data Centre Energy Performance As shown in section 5.2, affecting variable IT equipment energy consumption in terms of kwh/m 2 /year is affected by the overdesigning of IT equipment power demand and IT equipment footprint area as percentage of gross floor area. These relationships are described in the model of IT equipment energy performance (Figure 6.14). Figure 6.14 Model of IT equipment energy performance where, IT_overdesign is the overdesigning rate of IT equipment power demand Based on the results of parameter analysis in Section 5.4, variables such as energy consumptions of HVAC and the ratio of HVAC energy consumption to IT equipment energy consumption, which indicate energy performance of HVAC system, are also affected by other variables. Figure 6.15 depicts that HVAC energy consumption (kwh/m 2 /year) is affected by IT equipment energy consumption (kwh/m 2 /year), gross floor area (m 2 ), IT equipment footprint area as percentage of gross floor area and the overdesigning of HVAC system. The ratio of HVAC energy consumption to IT equipment energy consumption is determined by the overdesigning of HVAC system. 166
22 Chapter 6: Neurofuzzy Network Modeling of Data Centre Energy Performance Figure 6.15 Model of HVAC system energy performance Moreover, as shown in Figure 5.12 and Figure 5.21, overdesigning of HVAC system power demand and total data centre power demand are both affected by the overdesigning of IT equipment power demand. Figure 6.16 Integrated model of total data centre energy performance 167
23 Chapter 6: Neurofuzzy Network Modeling of Data Centre Energy Performance As stated earlier, neurofuzzy network is suitable for the purpose of modeling complex systems. Based on the models above, it is practical to integrate all the affecting variables and systems to a wholesystem based model of total data centre energy performance (Figure 6.16). In this model, the preliminary input variables are gross floor area (m 2 ), overdesigning of IT equipment power demand, and IT equipment footprint as a percentage of gross floor area. Rule block level 1 acts as the intermediate level collecting the information from input variables and transmit it to the next level defined as rule block level 2. On this step, the information that overdesigning of IT equipment power demand determines the overdesigning of HVAC cooling capacity and the overdesigning of total data centre power demand is input to the model and passed to the next level of rule block. Rule block level 2 also acts as the intermediate level collecting the information from input variables and transmitting it to the next level defined as rule block level 3. Rule blocks 2and 4 (RB2 & 4) together illustrate the structure of HVAC system energy performance. Rule block 3 describes the significant variables that affect IT equipment energy consumption. Rule block level 3 is defined as the same as that in the previous model of total data centre energy performance (Figure 6.13). It receives the information transmitted from rule block level 2 and other independent significant variables including gross area, IT equipment footprint as percentage of gross floor area. Based on the information 168
24 Chapter 6: Neurofuzzy Network Modeling of Data Centre Energy Performance received, the values of the output variables can be determined Neural network training Data obtained from investigations conducted in the data centres studied are then used to train the model. This training data consist of both the observed values of input variables and output variables. Based on the correlationship analysis conducted in Chapter four, data centre 6 seems often the disturbing point of the analysis. This can be explained by its significantly larger area than other facilities and the low occupancy rate of the floor area. For this reason, the data of data centre 6 is excluded from the training. However, this data centre will be used to as a new data to test the validity of the trained model and evaluate the energy saving potential. Appendix J shows the training data of the model Model verification After the training, the information of the data is learned and stored into the model, and the significance levels of the various fuzzy rules are determined. Those rules have minor influences on output variables that are removed from the rule blocks. The trained model can then be used to predict the energy performance of a data centre. Moreover, by changing one or more values of the input variables, the influences of that or those variables can be examined. 169
25 Chapter 6: Neurofuzzy Network Modeling of Data Centre Energy Performance However, sometime the neural training may not converge, which may lead to inaccurate prediction and analysis. This is due to many reasons. The main reason is the constraint of sample size. In this study, only 6 sets of data obtained from the selected data centres are available for the training and testing of the model. Moreover, there are significant variations among data centres in terms of energy consumption, power demand and systems efficiencies. These can lead to a poor convergence of the model developed. Improper model structure and unrestricted and great number of fuzzy rules can also result in improper model. In this case, further reexamination of model structure and more sample data are needed. Figure 6.17 Training result in 3D plot Figure 6.17 depicts the trained model of total data centre energy performance in a 3Dimensional plot. Relationships between HVAC energy consumption (vertical axis) and Gross area and Overdesigning of IT equipment power demand (horizontal axes) are depicted graphically. 170
Data Quality Assessment: A Reviewer s Guide EPA QA/G9R
United States Office of Environmental EPA/240/B06/002 Environmental Protection Information Agency Washington, DC 20460 Data Quality Assessment: A Reviewer s Guide EPA QA/G9R FOREWORD This document is
More informationPUE : A COMPREHENSIVE EXAMINATION OF THE METRIC
WHITE PAPER #49 PUE : A COMPREHENSIVE EXAMINATION OF THE METRIC EDITORS: Victor Avelar, Schneider Electric Dan Azevedo, Disney Alan French, Emerson Network Power PAGE 2 The Green Grid Association would
More informationELECTRICITY DEMAND PREDICTION OF LARGE COMMERCIAL BUILDINGS USING SUPPORT VECTOR MACHINE
ELECTRICITY DEMAND PREDICTION OF LARGE COMMERCIAL BUILDINGS USING SUPPORT VECTOR MACHINE N.G. Indika Sujeewa Samarawickrama (108863K) Thesis/Dissertation submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements
More informationCalculating Space and Power Density Requirements for Data Centers
Calculating Space and Power Density Requirements for Data Centers White Paper 155 Revision 0 by Neil Rasmussen Executive summary The historic method of specifying data center power density using a single
More informationProfiling Deployed Software: Assessing Strategies and Testing Opportunities. Sebastian Elbaum, Member, IEEE, and Madeline Diep
IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON SOFTWARE ENGINEERING, VOL. 31, NO. 8, AUGUST 2005 1 Profiling Deployed Software: Assessing Strategies and Testing Opportunities Sebastian Elbaum, Member, IEEE, and Madeline Diep Abstract
More informationResource Estimation in Software Engineering
Resource Estimation in Software Engineering Lionel C. Briand Carleton University Systems and Computer Engineering Dept. Ottawa, ON K1S 5B6 Canada briand@sce.carleton.ca Isabella Wieczorek Fraunhofer Institute
More informationIEEE TRANSACTIONS ON NETWORK AND SERVICE MANAGEMENT, ACCEPTED FOR PUBLICATION 1. Cloud Analytics for Capacity Planning and Instant VM Provisioning
IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON NETWORK AND SERVICE MANAGEMENT, ACCEPTED FOR PUBLICATION 1 Cloud Analytics for Capacity Planning and Instant VM Provisioning Yexi Jiang, ChangShing Perng, Tao Li, and Rong N. Chang,
More informationMinto Asset Management Plan
Minto Asset Management Plan 1. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 1.1 What the Municipality Provides The Town of Minto has a significant portfolio of community assets under its care and control. These assets form an integral
More informationAssisting Public Organizations in Their Outsourcing Endeavors: A Decision Support Model
NASA/TM 2006213809 Assisting Public Organizations in Their Outsourcing Endeavors: A Decision Support Model Tibor Kremic Glenn Research Center, Cleveland, Ohio Oya Tukel Cleveland State University, Cleveland,
More informationSummary of VIKING results
(Vital Infrastructure, NetworKs, INformation and Control System ManaGement) Summary of VIKING results Project cofunded by the European Community within the 7 th Framework Programme. Table of Contents
More information8 INTERPRETATION OF SURVEY RESULTS
8 INTERPRETATION OF SURVEY RESULTS 8.1 Introduction This chapter discusses the interpretation of survey results, primarily those of the final status survey. Interpreting a survey s results is most straightforward
More informationPROJECT FINAL REPORT
PROJECT FINAL REPORT Grant Agreement number: 212117 Project acronym: FUTUREFARM Project title: FUTUREFARMIntegration of Farm Management Information Systems to support realtime management decisions and
More informationHere is Your Money: Using the Standard Cost Model to Measure Regulatory Compliance Costs in Developing Countries
Here is Your Money: Using the Standard Cost Model to Measure Regulatory Compliance Costs in Developing Countries Investment Climate Advisory Services I World Bank Group Here Is Your Money! Using the Standard
More informationGeneric Statistical Business Process Model
Joint UNECE/Eurostat/OECD Work Session on Statistical Metadata (METIS) Generic Statistical Business Process Model Version 4.0 April 2009 Prepared by the UNECE Secretariat 1 I. Background 1. The Joint UNECE
More informationReport to Congress on Server and Data Center Energy Efficiency Public Law 109431. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency ENERGY STAR Program
Report to Congress on Server and Data Center Energy Efficiency Public Law 109431 U.S. Environmental Protection Agency ENERGY STAR Program August 2, 2007 Table of Contents Table of Contents... i Executive
More informationRisk assessmentbased decision support for the migration of applications to the Cloud
Institute of Architecture of Application Systems University of Stuttgart Universittsstrae 38 D 70569 Stuttgart Diplomarbeit Nr. 3538 Risk assessmentbased decision support for the migration of applications
More informationEnergy Efficiency in the Data Center
Energy Efficiency in the Data Center Maria Sansigre and Jaume Salom Energy Efficieny Area Thermal Energy and Building Performance Group Technical Report: IRECTR00001 Title: Energy Efficiency in the Data
More informationDATA CENTER EFFICIENCY AND IT EQUIPMENT RELIABILITY AT WIDER OPERATING TEMPERATURE AND HUMIDITY RANGES
WHITE PAPER #50 DATA CENTER EFFICIENCY AND IT EQUIPMENT RELIABILITY AT WIDER OPERATING TEMPERATURE AND HUMIDITY RANGES EDITOR: Steve Strutt, IBM CONTRIBUTORS: Chris Kelley, Cisco Harkeeret Singh, Thomson
More informationPASIF A Framework for Supporting Smart Interactions with Predictive Analytics
PASIF A Framework for Supporting Smart Interactions with Predictive Analytics by Sarah Marie Matheson A thesis submitted to the School of Computing in conformity with the requirements for the degree of
More informationGeneral Principles of Software Validation; Final Guidance for Industry and FDA Staff
General Principles of Software Validation; Final Guidance for Industry and FDA Staff Document issued on: January 11, 2002 This document supersedes the draft document, "General Principles of Software Validation,
More informationR&M Data Center Handbook
R&M Data Center Handbook R&M Data Center Handbook Preface The modern data center, along with the IT infrastructure, is the nerve center of an enterprise. Of key importance is not the data center's size
More informationHarpur Hill, Buxton, SK17 9JN Telephone: +44 (0)1298 218000 Facsimile: +44 (0)1298 218590
Harpur Hill, Buxton, SK17 9JN Telephone: +44 (0)1298 218000 Facsimile: +44 (0)1298 218590 An Asset Management Model for UK Railway Safety Literature Review and Discussion Document HSL/2005/34 Project Leader:
More informationSMART METERING & INFRASTRUCTURE PROGRAM BUSINESS CASE
SMART METERING & INFRASTRUCTURE PROGRAM BUSINESS CASE 1 TABLE OF CONTENTS Executive Summary... 1 Introduction................................................... 3 What is the Smart Metering Program?............................
More informationA DECISION SUPPORT SYSTEM FOR REGIONAL SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT: THE FLAG MODEL
A DECISION SUPPORT SYSTEM FOR REGIONAL SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT: THE FLAG MODEL Peter Nijkamp Hans Ouwersloot Dept. of Economics Free University De Boelelaan 1105 1081 HV Amsterdam Abstract This paper presents
More informationAudit Manual PART TWO SYSTEM BASED AUDIT
Audit Manual PART TWO SYSTEM BASED AUDIT Table of content 1. Introduction...3 2. Systems based audit...4 2.1. Preparing for & planning the audit assignment...5 2.2. Ascertaining and recording the system...7
More information1. Adaptation of cases for casebased forecasting with neural network support
1. Adaptation of cases for casebased forecasting with neural network support Corchado J. M. Artificial Intelligence Research Group Escuela Superior de Ingeniería Informática, University of Vigo, Campus
More informationTHE LYTX ADVANTAGE: USING PREDICTIVE ANALYTICS TO DELIVER DRIVER SAFETY
THE LYTX ADVANTAGE: USING PREDICTIVE ANALYTICS TO DELIVER DRIVER SAFETY BRYON COOK VP, ANALYTICS www.lytx.com 1 CONTENTS Introduction... 3 Predictive Analytics Overview... 3 Drivers in Use of Predictive
More informationSUPPORTING PAPER FOR THE OPERATIONAL SECURITY NETWORK CODE 31.08.2012 FOR PUBLIC CONSULTATION
SUPPORTING PAPER FOR THE OPERATIONAL SECURITY NETWORK CODE 31.08.2012 FOR PUBLIC CONSULTATION 1 1 PURPOSE AND OBJECTIVES OF THIS DOCUMENT...3 1.1 PURPOSE OF THE DOCUMENT... 3 1.2 1.3 STRUCTURE OF THE DOCUMENT...
More informationA KnowledgeBased Decision Support System for Computer Disaster Prevention In IT Centres
The University of Newcastle upon Tyne Department of Computing Science A KnowledgeBased Decision Support System for Computer Disaster Prevention In IT Centres by Tawfig Y. Danish PhD Thesis December 1994
More informationBEST PRACTICES. Data Center Best Practices Guide Energy efficiency solutions for highperformance data centers
BEST PRACTICES Data Center Best Practices Guide Energy efficiency solutions for highperformance data centers Table of Contents Introduction...1 1. Information Technology (IT) Systems...3 2. Air Management...10
More information