1 White Paper Getting Real About Big Data: Build Versus Buy By Nik Rouda, Senior Analyst July 2014 This ESG White Paper was commissioned by Oracle and is distributed under license from ESG.
2 White Paper: Getting Real About Big Data: Build Versus Buy 2 Contents Executive Summary... 3 In Search of Big Data Infrastructure... 3 Do-it-yourself Hadoop Can Be Difficult... 3 Save 21% in Costs and Time Using Preconfigured Big Data Appliances... 4 Delivering Big Data s Value Proposition... 4 Introduction: In Search of Big Data Reality... 4 The Enterprise Big Data Value Imperative... 4 Hadoop's Role in an Enterprise Big Data Platform... 5 Debunking Three Common Assumptions of Hadoop Big Data... 6 The Real Costs and Benefits of Big Data Infrastructure... 7 A Model for Hadoop Big Data Infrastructure Cost Analysis: Build Versus Buy... 7 Specific Costs for Build versus Buy Comparison... 8 Oracle Big Data Appliance as an Alternative to "Build"... 9 Looking for Big Data Savings? The Infrastructure Buy Option... 9 Better Time to Market Is the Repeatable Benefit: The Benefit of the Buy Option The Bigger Truth Serious Big Data Requires Serious Commitment Avoid Common Assumptions about Big Data Buy Will Often Trump Build for Both Big Data Infrastructure Costs and Benefits Appendix All trademark names are property of their respective companies. Information contained in this publication has been obtained by sources The Enterprise Strategy Group (ESG) considers to be reliable but is not warranted by ESG. This publication may contain opinions of ESG, which are subject to change from time to time. This publication is copyrighted by The Enterprise Strategy Group, Inc. Any reproduction or redistribution of this publication, in whole or in part, whether in hard-copy format, electronically, or otherwise to persons not authorized to receive it, without the express consent of The Enterprise Strategy Group, Inc., is in violation of U.S. copyright law and will be subject to an action for civil damages and, if applicable, criminal prosecution. Should you have any questions, please contact ESG Client Relations at
3 White Paper: Getting Real About Big Data: Build Versus Buy 3 Executive Summary In Search of Big Data Infrastructure Enterprises of all types are betting on big data analytics to help them better understand customers, compete in the market, improve products and services, tune operations, and increase profits. In a recent ESG survey, 26% of IT and 53% of marketing professionals responsible for their organizations strategies, technologies, and processes considered enhancing analytics a top spending priority. 1 Given the high degree of interest in analytics and the vast quantity of unutilized data, the first step most organizations need to take on the path toward realizing the benefits of big data analytics is to implement an appropriate infrastructure to process big data. Though most enterprises are not starting entirely from scratch, having already developed data warehouses and related business intelligence (BI) solutions, most realize that big data analytics require a different infrastructure than what they have used historically for data warehousing and BI. Many organizations, therefore, plan to invest in a new solution infrastructure to realize the promise of big data. ESG research has found that 56% of respondents responsible for data initiatives expect their investments to increase by more than 10% in 2014 compared with ESG also discovered that buying purpose-built appliances for use on-premises, such as Oracle s Big Data Appliance, will prove to be the preferred option for 22% of organizations seeking to implement a big data infrastructure. 3 Do-it-yourself Hadoop Can Be Difficult Web 2.0 companies, such as Google and Yahoo, have successfully built big data infrastructures from scratch. Those same firms also have been primary participants in the birth and nurturing of Hadoop, the Apache open source project deservedly given credit for catalyzing the big data movement. Hadoop has matured over the past year, due in part to feature enhancements and in part to growing support from a widening range of both startups and more established IT vendors. For many organizations, Hadoop-based solutions will represent the first new explicitly big data investment. However, successful Hadoop implementations put into full production using do-it-yourself infrastructure components may require more time and effort than initially expected. Hadoop lures many big data hopefuls due to its apparent low infrastructure cost and easy access; as an open source technology, anyone can download Hadoop for free, and can spin up a simple Hadoop infrastructure in the cloud or on-premises. Unfortunately, many organizations also quickly find that they lack the time, resources, and expertise to make do-it-yourself Hadoop infrastructure work for big data, with reported shortages of skilled staff in IT architecture and planning, business intelligence and analytics, and/or database administration at approximately 20% of companies. 4 The still somewhat rare and expensive expertise comes in two forms: (1) The Hadoop engineer, who can architect an initial Hadoop infrastructure, feed applicable data in, help the data analyst squeeze useful analytics out from the data repository, and evolve and manage the whole infrastructure over time; and (2) The data scientist or analyst, who knows how to render the tools of statistics in the context of big data analytics, and also can lead the human and business process of discovery and collaboration in order to yield actionable results. Thus, despite the hope and hype, Hadoop on a commodity stack of hardware does not always offer a lower cost ride to big data analytics, or at least not as quickly as hoped. ESG asserts that many organizations implementing Hadoop infrastructures based on human expertise plus a purchased commodity hardware and software infrastructure may experience unexpected costs, slower speed to market, and unplanned complexity throughout the lifecycle. 1 Source: ESG Research Report, 2014 IT Spending Intentions Survey, February Source: ESG Research Report, Enterprise Data Analytics Trends, May Ibid. 4 Source: ESG Research Report, 2014 IT Spending Intentions Survey, February 2014.
4 White Paper: Getting Real About Big Data: Build Versus Buy 4 Save 21% in Costs and Time Using Preconfigured Big Data Appliances Based on ESG validation of an Oracle model for a medium-sized Hadoop-oriented big data project, a "buy" infrastructure option like Oracle Big Data Appliance will yield approximately 21% lower costs than a build equivalent do-it-yourself infrastructure. And using a preconfigured appliance such as Oracle's will greatly reduce the complexity of engaging staff from many IT disciplines to do extensive platform evaluation, testing, development, and integration. For most enterprises planning to take big data beyond experimentation and proofof-concept, ESG suggests exploring the idea of skipping in-house development, on-going management, and expansion of your own big data infrastructure, to instead look to purpose-built infrastructure solutions such as Oracle's Big Data Appliance. Delivering Big Data s Value Proposition Introduction: In Search of Big Data Reality The media bandies about the term "big data" as if it were a fait accompli at most enterprises. To the contrary, many enterprises have only recently begun what will turn into a multi-year commitment and effort toward enhancing the state of data analytics. Similarly, much of the source of the interest in big data springs from the vendors offering products and services based on the continually expanding Apache Hadoop project, which legitimately catalyzed interest in big data, yet their marketing sometimes contributes to the perhaps misleading notion that realizing the promise of big data will come easily and inexpensively. For example, in terms of infrastructure for Hadoop, the predominant delivery model suggests that on-premises or cloud-based commodity servers and storage ("good enough" solutions) will suffice for all environments, while the reality is that there are several viable options. What will be the reality of big data? Assuming many enterprises will invest in new solutions to attain their respective big data goals, will Hadoop become the universal standard and revolutionize how IT departments and their partners in business deliver big data solutions, or will other approaches also have their place? ESG believes that Hadoop will play at least a part in many big data solutions. Assuming Hadoop plays some role in most organizations, what related infrastructure decisions will deliver the best ROI for big data solutions do-it-yourself commodity infrastructures, or more purpose-designed, integrated alternatives? The Enterprise Big Data Value Imperative Viewpoints abound about the importance of big data analytics. ESG holds the strongly optimistic point of view that in the long ESG holds the strongly optimistic point of term, big data will propel significant business value and view that in the long term, big data will innovation across almost all industries. And we don t believe we propel significant business value and are alone, based on recent ESG research where a wide variety of innovation across almost all industries. expected benefits were cited (see Figure 1) by respondents looking at their IT spending priorities in ESG found it particularly telltale that roughly a quarter of respondents ranked enhancing analytics as a top business priority. 5 Ibid.
5 White Paper: Getting Real About Big Data: Build Versus Buy 5 Figure 1. Expected Business Benefits from Data Analytics Investments What business benefits do you expect to gain from your investments in the area of business intelligence, analytics, and big data? (Percent of respondents, N=187, multiple responses accepted) Improved operational efficiency Reduced risk around business decisions and strategy Higher quality products/services Incremental cost savings More insights into future scenarios or outcomes More insights into historical results Faster tactical response to shifting customer views Uncover new market opportunities Quicker time to market for products/services Reduced risk of product defects 42% 41% 39% 36% 35% 34% 31% 30% 26% 59% Source: Enterprise Strategy Group, Big data being of primary importance to organizations might seem like taking a bold position, but it may prove to be an understatement; while many IT initiatives can help organizations do things better, big data helps organizations know what to do better. It is one thing to know that bookings decreased when compared with the same quarter last year (an example of business intelligence), but it is better to know why they decreased (analytics), and it is best to model and predict how they might increase going forward (big data analytics). Despite ESG s belief that big data will eventually deliver on all the promise and hype, ESG does not believe organizations will successful reach their big data goals by cutting corners. In fact, enterprises should avoid falling for the false promise of something earth-shattering for nearly nothing that seems associated with big data why not get real about big data? In order for enterprises to get real, they will need to select the right big data infrastructure. Hadoop's Role in an Enterprise Big Data Platform 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% Based on the aforementioned ESG research survey, many respondents are already using 22% in total MapReduce framework technologies to process large and diverse sets of data for big data analytics. 6 The fact that IT vendors of all types, from start-ups to well-established vendors, have jumped on the Hadoop bandwagon has changed Hadoop's status at most enterprises from a mere curiosity a few years ago to a serious choice for a key element of the big data solution set going forward. The Hadoop MapReduce technology, while a key feature of Hadoop, only tells part of the Hadoop story because if one looks at all of the elements that make up Hadoop, it looks more like a big data platform. What Hadoop has most obviously lacked is the equivalent of integrated systems management software, but vendors like Cloudera, Hortonworks, and MapR have developed such software and support via their respective Hadoop distributions. Enterprises stand at different points in terms of enhancing their data analytics. For example, companies that have successfully implemented data warehouses, which already do a good job at data governance, and that actively use business intelligence and analytics solutions from before the "big data" era definitely have a leg up. Those 6 Ibid.
6 White Paper: Getting Real About Big Data: Build Versus Buy 6 companies will determine how best to leverage and integrate Hadoop into their wider analytics solutions set. Other companies may choose to lean more directly on Hadoop as their primary data platform, moving to build what is now being called a data lake or data hub. Debunking Three Common Assumptions of Hadoop Big Data Hadoop will play a role in the big data efforts of many, perhaps a majority of, larger organizations. However, some myths are associated with big data and Hadoop. ESG believes that these myths present some risks for enterprises. Making a serious investment in big data is not to be entered into lightly, given the potential strategic impact. What are the most important big data and Hadoop assumptions that enterprises should take care to understand beyond the superficial level? Assumption 1: Big data is not mission-critical. If one believes that big data will indeed rank as one of the most critical capabilities to serve the business, then how should IT view big data from an architectural and operational perspective? Simple: Consider big data missioncritical, just like ERP. That means not considering big data experimental or a series of projects, but rather an enterprise-class IT asset that will deliver essential decision-making insight and direction every business day. Organizations will initially play with big data, primarily as a learning experience. But the CIO and the business leaders should plan to architect, build, and operate a big data facility that delivers dependably, yet with flexibility for the entire organizational value chain including customers and partners on an ongoing basis. CIOs already know the mission-critical drill: 24x7x365 reliability, five 9s availability, appropriate performance, scalability, security, serviceability, and quick adaptability to business requirements changes. ESG understands that thinking about big data in a mission-critical context runs counter to much of the way big data has been positioned in the media: The idea that an enterprise-class big data solution can only run effectively on inexpensive, commodity hardware, using purely open source software, simply strikes ESG as a somewhat limited viewpoint. The amount and diversity of data; the number of points of internal and external integration; the wide variety and large quantity of users; and the expertise to ensure the analytic models and results can be trusted suggests that enterprises may want to consider a similar approach to what IT has used to deliver mission-critical solutions for the business in the past. Assumption 2: Hadoop is free. You can visit the Apache website for Hadoop and download all the elements you need for free. Alternatively, you could tap into emerging Hadoop-as-a-service (HaaS) offerings that you find in a variety of public clouds for something only a little more expensive than free, at least initially. Why then isn t Hadoop truly free, or nearly so? First, the expertise required to implement and use Hadoop is expensive, whether you bring in data scientists and Hadoop engineers at several hundreds of dollars per hour, or shift some of your top business analysts and engineers and retrain them on Hadoop, or a combination thereof. Enterprises should ask themselves, "Do I have engineers on staff deeply familiar with configuring, allocating, and managing Hadoop infrastructure?" While the distribution software from vendors like Cloudera certainly helps, enterprises need to realize that big data will not remain an experiment, but in fact become a platform that will support many projects of discovery and analytics applications it requires an enterprise lifecycle viewpoint and requisite infrastructure. Second, ESG does not expect any enterprise to only depend on Hadoop for big data solutions Hadoop is just part of the larger puzzle, and connecting other data sources and tools to Hadoop carries hidden costs on the human, software, networking, and hardware fronts. Existing data warehouses, and related integration and BI solutions, will certainly count as part of the overall big data solution at most companies. In fact, over the course of time, if Hadoop sits somewhere near the middle of an enterprise's big data solution set, connecting to Hadoop for data ingest and analytics visualization purposes may require significant administrative effort.
7 White Paper: Getting Real About Big Data: Build Versus Buy 7 Assumption 3: I already own the infrastructure I need for big data Hadoop or can come by it inexpensively, and am staffed to configure and manage that infrastructure. Consider a scenario where an enterprise recently shifted to a cloud-based Microsoft Exchange implementation (away from a self-managed server farm) and the enterprise thus owns a large number of generic servers and storage that are all paid for and fully depreciated. What a bonanza for big data! Simply repurpose all those nodes for your Hadoop project. Alternatively, you can buy a rack of commodity servers with DAS storage for the data nodes at white box prices. Unfortunately, the inexpensive infrastructure myth may not work for all companies. If you are looking at big data from an enterprise-wide, mission-critical perspective, it can make sense to use purpose built hardware. That is, while generic servers may be fine for smaller projects and proofs-of-concept, for large-scale-production big data solutions you may want to use enterprise-grade servers, storage, and networking specifically designed for big data. ESG believes that one of the primary big data ROI factors involves choosing the right infrastructure. Simply looking at the cost per server of commodity hardware misses much of the expense in a full production deployment. An enterprise-class big data infrastructure requires a robust and reliable architecture, and if your company does not currently possess sufficient personnel with the skills needed to architect and implement all the hardware, network, and systems software necessary for your big data solution, then you should consider an appliance instead. Identification, evaluation, and integration of a complete technology stack carries many hidden costs, not least in many hours of human effort on the project. The Real Costs and Benefits of Big Data Infrastructure A Model for Hadoop Big Data Infrastructure Cost Analysis: Build Versus Buy What would an enterprise experience in terms of costs if (a) it rolled its own Hadoop infrastructure versus (b) it used an appliance that was purpose-designed and integrated for enterprise-class big data? One of the possible myths about Hadoop has been that companies can save money by rolling out and managing their own Hadoop commodity infrastructure. Of course, big data using Hadoop isn't just about clusters, it is about infrastructure: The infrastructure includes, for example, systems management software, networking, and extra capacity for a variety of analytics processing purposes. A very important note is that soft costs of labor time to evaluate, procure, test, deploy, and integrate a full stack of hardware and software is not examined here. These costs in time and money can be extreme, ranging to hundreds of hours or more, and this topic alone is one of the most compelling reasons to consider a purpose-built big data appliance. That said, many organizations look to their existing staff to manage this effort, and would heavily discount or exclude these human costs, real as they may be. ESG conducted a review of the Oracle Big Data Appliance for a three-year total cost comparison with a closely matched commodity "build" infrastructure. While the exact pricing will of course vary by vendor and over time, this model uses the closest directly comparable equipment, including HP Proliant DL-series servers and Infiniband networking, and costs that are publically available at the time of writing. Evaluators should always use this kind of ROI model as a reference while conducting their own calculations based on their specific environmental requirements. This exercise is primarily a validation of the comparable costs and financial calculations provided by Oracle, and a similar comparison may be found at Oracle blog, Price Comparison for Big Data Appliance and Hadoop. Though some readers will argue that lower cost servers and networking components are frequently chosen in realworld deployments, these options can be lacking in performance and reliability features and aren t as directly comparable to the equipment included in the Oracle offering. The reason that the Oracle Big Data Appliance itself works well for this comparison is (a) it would serve well as an infrastructure for a medium-sized big data project, as depicted in Table 1, and (b) the cost and infrastructural details of the "buy" option Oracle Big Data Appliance in this case are publicly disclosed.
8 White Paper: Getting Real About Big Data: Build Versus Buy 8 In order to make such a comparison, we will need a model project, and here are the assumptions for our theoretical medium-size, enterprise-class big data project: Users: 200 end-users: 150 business end-users, 50 data scientist/analysts. Analytics Consumption: 1/3 rd ad-hoc, 1/3 rd daily, 1/3 rd monthly. Servers: Enterprise grade with newer chipsets, backup power supply, high storage density (to ensure, for example, that Hadoop doesn't become storage-bound), plenty of cores to support parallelization with more cores in the name node, plenty of memory to handle complex queries, and columnar-based analytics. Storage: Total raw data capacity of 864 TB, in a balanced mix of refreshes (i.e., monthly, weekly, daily, realtime); note that in the example in Table 1, the math suggests more terabytes (18 nodes * 48 TB/node = 864 TB), but one has to account for replication (3x replication in pure Hadoop for example), peaks, compression, and sharding. We will use a usability rate of 30%, which in this case, rounded up, yields about 260 terabytes. Network: Dedicated and particularly fast bandwidth, with multiple switches to deal with contention; given the amount of replication and data movement associated with, for example MapReduce, a big data infrastructure needs to ensure it doesn't become network-bound. Queries: A set that spans from simple select statements to complex joins. Integration and Information Management: Five new points of integration/transformation; in the process of design, additional data sources will be added in addition to, for example, a data warehouse. Those sources will require integration/transformation and information management work, and related licenses and hardware. Project Time: Six months total running, which includes one month for architecture, design, procurement; one month for hardware/network configuration/implementation; two months for various development elements, MapReduce queries (assuming the use of Hive), statistics, user experience, integration, training, etc.; one month for final integrated/system testing and go live; one month for slack and over-runs. For a full listing of all the resulting elements of cost associated with the theoretical project, see Appendix, Table 5. Specific Costs for Build versus Buy Comparison Table 1 lists those project items where ESG believes there is a pricing choice between build and buy. The table reflects estimated pricing for the "build" consumption option only. Table 1. Medium Big Data Project Three-year TCO Summary of Buy Cost Items Item Cost Notes Build Versus Buy Elements (Using Build Pricing) $22.8k each; enterprise class with dual power Servers $410,500 supplies, 48TB of serial-attached SCSI (SAS) storage, gigabytes memory, 1 rack Networking $40,000 estimated $6k for InfiniBand, $11k for admin switch, $0.6k for cables, looms, patch panels, etc. Hardware support (three years) of list cost Hadoop licensing $388,800 Cloudera: 18 estimated $7.2k each per year Installation $14,000 Licenses and dedicated hardware Build Project Costs $920,900 Those project items where a "buy" option exists
9 White Paper: Getting Real About Big Data: Build Versus Buy 9 Oracle Big Data Appliance as an Alternative to "Build" ESG believes that for a true enterprise-class big data project of medium complexity, the appliance option will deliver nearly 20% cost savings compared with IT architecting, designing, procuring, configuring, and implementing its own big data infrastructure. While it was convenient to use the Oracle Big Data Appliance as a "buy" candidate in this analysis, it is a well-conceived big data infrastructure solution that will serve most enterprises well for both initial big data projects and as organizations grow their big data facility. Reasons for this include: Software: The appliance includes software often required in big data projects, such as Cloudera's Distribution including Apache Hadoop (CDH) and Cloudera Manager for infrastructure administration; Oracle Linux, the Oracle JDK, the Oracle NoSQL Database (Community Edition) to support advanced analytic queries; and the popular open source R statistical development tool. You will need to supply your own visualization tool(s), however. At time of writing, the latest version of CDH 5.0 is included, with additional features such as those from the rebase on Hadoop 2.2GA, MapReduce 2.0 on YARN, with backward compatibility to MapReduce version 1, and new functionality in Impala, Search, Spark, Accumulo, and more. Although beyond the scope of this particular paper, Cloudera s full capabilities are relatively broad and deep as a Hadoop distribution, and should be explored and considered as a preferred option for the data platform. Additionally, security software functionality, including both network and disk encryption, Kerberos-based authentication, and more, is pre-installed and available as check box features, which will make protecting all that sensitive data more easily accomplished. Hardware: Oracle s full rack Big Data Appliance includes 864 TB of raw storage capacity, 288 cores, 64 GB memory per server, and InfiniBand networking between nodes and racks and adding racks is noninvasive. ESG believes that optimized networking throughout a big data infrastructure can be the secret sauce to big data performance: The InfiniBand included in Oracle Big Data Appliance plus the storage and core design of the appliance will enable enterprises to eliminate network bottlenecks for a Hadoop cluster. Again, much more information on the full specifications of the Big Data Appliance is readily available on Oracle s website, but the quality and capacity of the total rack is admirable and will add value over a cheaper commodity hardware-sourced environment. Services: With an Oracle Big Data Appliance, you receive Oracle Premier support; the Automated Service Request (ASR) feature that auto-detects major problems and maintains a heartbeat with Oracle support; configuration and installation support; a warranty; and straightforward options and techniques for expansion or you can do it all yourself with a home-built "commodity" infrastructure. It is worth noting that the appliance is supported as a whole, reducing the risk and finger-pointing of having multiple vendors involved in troubleshooting inevitable problems of a complex multi-component system. And finally, and this is particularly important for primarily Oracle shops, using the same InfiniBand, you can connect the Oracle Big Data appliance to other Oracle engineered systems, such as the Oracle Exadata Database Machine and the Oracle Exalytics In-Memory Machine. But whether your organization is purely an Oracle shop or not, the Oracle Big Data Appliance presents a compelling alternative to do-it-yourself, Hadoop-oriented, big data infrastructures for those companies that are serious about big data. Looking for Big Data Savings? The Infrastructure Buy Option Where can you save in a buy versus build scenario for big data? One big bucket of cost comes from the big data infrastructure. Of that three-year TCO of $920,900 in our theoretical build versus buy project item comparison, using build pricing, well over half of the costs come from hardware and networking plus related support. The other large portion of costs come from software licensing. It is very important to note that the labor times to order, assemble, and manage all the hardware and software were excluded, but will surely be very significant as well. The primary buy option for big data infrastructure considered, being Oracle s Big Data Appliance, would deliver everything in build for approximately $728,150 list for three-year TCO, fully loaded (includes the Hadoop distribution, storage, network/bandwidth, hardware support, etc.).
10 White Paper: Getting Real About Big Data: Build Versus Buy 10 Table 2. Buy Three-year TCO for the Oracle Big Data Appliance (full rack) Item Cost Notes Appliance (18 node) $525,000 Oracle s list price Hardware and Software Support $189,000 $63k/year for 3 years of full support Installation $14,150 By Oracle professional services Total $728,150 Source: Oracle, ESG believes that for a true enterprise-class big data project of medium complexity, the appliance option could deliver roughly 21% cost savings versus IT architecting, designing, procuring, configuring, and implementing its own big data infrastructure. Table 3. Medium Big Data Implementation Three-year TCOs Buy Wins Item Cost Notes Buy Total $728,150 Cost of Oracle Big Data Appliance including installation and three years of support Build Total $920,900 See Appendix for inventory Buy Savings $192,750 Over three-year period ESG Estimated Savings ~21% Oracle BDA appliance lowers costs versus do-it-yourself Source: Enterprise Strategy Group, But the build versus buy big data story doesn't end with a single project: there are additional and longer-term infrastructure costs and concepts to consider. Big Data "Build" Proof-of-concept and Cluster Costs Misleading Some would argue that for proof-of-concept projects, a major investment in a big data appliance, like Oracle s Big Data Appliance, at a list price of $525,000 for the full rack of 18 servers is simply too expensive, but a smaller starter option is available for a $186,406 list price. This entry point may be easier for many organizations, and with six nodes supporting the same software environment, could be a very desirable scale on demand approach. The ultimate costs of expanding from six to 18 nodes would exceed purchasing the fully equipped system at the start, but may help avoid initial overprovisioning for smaller environments. While ESG understands the reticence to make such any such capital investment, the problem with the keep it cheap, it is only a proof-of-concept argument rests with the nature of proof-of-concept: The proof-of-concept for a big data infrastructure must include all the elements of complexity, or it may not represent the true scenario upon enterprise-wide rollout. If IT personnel spin up a commodity cluster, implement Hadoop, load some data into Hadoop, and run a few queries, the primary thing that has been proved is that Hadoop works. Such a proof-of-concept does not necessarily indicate the infrastructure's and the related personnel's ability to reliably support and process enterprise-grade big data analytics over the long-term. In fact, making long-term big data architectural decisions based on a simplistic proofof-concept could engender unforeseen long-term costs. Oracle s Big Data Appliance offers a short cut to many of the integration efforts, with a full software stack including Cloudera s full Enterprise Data Hub edition, with all the latest innovations and updates. The Cloudera distribution is presented as an included perpetual license, not a per-server, ongoing subscription, and this alone has a significant impact on both cost and effort. The functionality of the data platform will be an asset because Cloudera s EDH is recognized as a technology leader in both range and quality of features, offering flexibility, scalability, performance, security, and management tools. Security features including strong authentication, network encryption, and on-disk encryption are an added bonus, if not a necessary consideration for any enterprise. Also included and fully integrated out-of-the-box are Oracle s Linux, JDK, and a NoSQL database license, all of which again increase the value of the offering versus procuring and assembling these software components individually.
11 White Paper: Getting Real About Big Data: Build Versus Buy 11 ESG suggests that customers use references from vendors, rather than relatively simply proof-of-concept projects, for making initial decisions on big data infrastructure. Big Data Longer-term Infrastructure Costs Favor Consistency Though ESG believes that for medium-sized big data projects the buy option can deliver significant savings over build, companies also should consider what will happen with their next project will you reuse the same infrastructure from the initial project, or will you create a series of big data project islands? Let s go back to lessons learned with ERP, a comparably heavy investment for many companies in years past, to consider an approach. One of the key issues many organizations faced in the early days of ERP, and that some still face, was piecemeal ERP implementations, resulting in a variety of infrastructures, databases, schemas, and user experiences. The result was a huge dependency on integration technologies, and a never-ending ERP upgrade lifecycle. The time for IT and the business is now to realize that big data projects ultimately lead to something larger and more complex, and best practices like architectural guidelines should apply to big data just as they do today for ERP and CRM. ESG believes that the customers choosing a consistent infrastructure for multiple big data projects across different departments will enjoy compounded savings due to the elimination of the learning curve associated with managing, maintaining, and tuning the infrastructure, plus the potential for infrastructure reuse. Big Data "Build" Risk Never Disappears Look forward three years from now: Your organization has become a successful big data organization, where IT easily adapts to new big data demands and where your executives, business users, and extended value chain all benefit and compete better due to big data. Will your organization easily reach that goal if every big data project is a build project? The IT department will constantly swim upstream to deal with new demands, constantly tuning and updating custom infrastructures. The buy decision, however, may enable your organization to focus more on value and visualization, versus procurement and deployment. ESG suggests that organizations take infrastructure development and deployment variability out of the pool of risk associated with reaching big data success. The risk of constantly reinventing and managing do-it-yourself infrastructures for big data may grow with the volume and complexity of big data deliverables. Better Time to Market Is the Repeatable Benefit: The Benefit of the Buy Option Beyond costs, determining the benefits is often the hardest part of calculating ROI for big data projects. The difficulty of predicting and detecting big data benefits comes from the fact that big data projects do not end per se, but rather turn into analytics applications, which grow, evolve, and lead to more discovery projects in total, providing benefits in continually learning ways. Unfortunately, making this claim will not satisfy the CFO who is wondering when and from where the big data ESG believes that a "buy" versus "buy" approach will yield roughly one-third faster time-tomarket benefit associated with big data analytics projects for discovery, improved decision making, and business process improvement. benefit will arrive. ESG research found that 67% of respondents wanted to see positive business impact within one year. 7 It needn t be that difficult, however. Usually some kind of basic business metric will offer an acceptable framework for benefit, which may receive tuning over time. For example, Better understanding of what products our customers like best may link to increased product sales and streamlined supply chain. Or, More accurately 7 Source: ESG Research Report, Enterprise Data Analytics Trends, May 2014.
12 White Paper: Getting Real About Big Data: Build Versus Buy 12 predicting energy demand may link to a new premium pricing scenario for peak times or a well-tuned electrical grid bidding scheme. An agreed-upon metric for the benefits side of the equation forms the basis for ROI. But one variable seems to fit neatly into every single big data project and that variable is time. Quite simply, the faster the business and IT is able to deliver the big data solution, the faster the business will realize any associated benefit. The tried and true time-to-market variable applies in every big data project. ESG performed a time-to-market benefit analysis associated with a medium-sized big data project (see Appendix, Table 5 for details), and the analysis unveiled that a buy infrastructure will deliver the project about 30% faster, cutting the medium-sized project time from 24 weeks to 17 weeks. ESG believes that a "buy" versus "buy" approach will yield roughly one-third faster time-to-market benefit associated with big data analytics projects for discovery, improved decision making, and business process improvement.
13 The Bigger Truth White Paper: Getting Real About Big Data: Build Versus Buy 13 Oracle s Big Data Appliance has many advantages over a home-grown solution, and for those considering their deployment options for Hadoop, it is well worth taking the time to evaluate the total picture. Certainly many organizations will be more comfortable working within their existing Oracle relationship and enjoy the confidence of quality services and support that will accompany the fully vetted and pre-integrated appliance. Cost is outlined as one factor, but ultimately the satisfaction of the many users in the enterprise will determine the success of the big data initiative. Serious Big Data Requires Serious Commitment In order for big data to deliver on the promise of helping organizations look forward, just as ERP for example has helped automate business processes and business intelligence has helped organizations look backward, big data will require an enterprise-class facility. Big data carries unique requirements for hardware, networking, software, and human skills. Enterprises should plan to build mission-critical infrastructures to support a series of big data projects and applications, yielding a big data facility that continually benefits the organization over time. Avoid Common Assumptions about Big Data Hadoop has been associated with sometimes over-hyped promises, like you already have the data you need, you already have the people you need, and you can use inexpensive commodity infrastructures, which may not be true for many organizations. Hadoop is a tool that can be used in many ways to help organizations achieve big data results, but meeting end-user expectations of performance and availability often requires costly expertise and an enterprise-class infrastructure that spans the total needs for storage, processing, and lifecycle management. Buy Will Often Trump Build for Both Big Data Infrastructure Costs and Benefits ESG asserts that a shorter path to lowering big data costs for the vast majority of enterprises can involve buying a preconfigured and purpose-built infrastructure such as an appliance. Rolling your own infrastructure often involves a long series of hidden risks and costs, and may undermine your organization s ability to deliver big data in the long term. In addition, the buy option for big data infrastructures compresses project durations. Thus, welldesigned appliances often helps deliver the one common benefit metric for big data: time to market.
14 Appendix White Paper: Getting Real About Big Data: Build Versus Buy 14 Table 4. Elements of a Medium Enterprise Big Data Implementation Cost/Benefit Build Cost Elements Item Value Metrics/Comments Hardware/Network Nodes 18 Servers - each 2 x 8-core processors Cores per node, as above Memory 64 GB/server (with option for expansion) Racks 1 Assumes up to 18 nodes/rack Storage for Nodes 48 TB/node for primary clusters, server-based storage Storage for Information Terabytes; assumes one-fourth of total data in 50 Management motion maximum at any given time Assumes Infiniband, assumes 3x throughput Switches 3 improvement over generic 10GBe; plus an administration switch and assorted cabling Hardware Support 15% Of total hardware costs; third-party support Hadoop License Costs Software $7,200/node Table 5. Medium Big Data Project Build Versus Buy Project Time Analysis Phase Architecture, design, procurement Hardware, network configuration, and implementation Development, integration, training, etc. Integrated system test, go live Slack and over-run Build Time 1 month 1 month 2 months 1 month 1 month Project Totals 6 months (24 weeks) 4.25 months (17 weeks) Buy Time to Market Benefit = 7 weeks or ~30% Typically new licenses during early big data adoption, allow for two more licenses for warm backup Buy Time/Savings (assumes 4 week months) Reason for Reduction 2 weeks/2 week savings Hardware/network pre-designed, single source procurement 2 weeks/2 week savings) Appliance pre-configured; less pieces to implement separately and certify 7 weeks/1 week savings Appliance stability provides more solid foundation for development, testing, etc. 3 weeks/1 week savings Expect smooth system test and go live due to appliance s fewer moving parts 3 weeks/1 week savings More dependable infrastructure will lead to more dependable scheduling What Table 5 suggests is that a medium-sized project will complete nearly one-third sooner due to a "buy" infrastructure decision over "build. The reduced procurement time, reduced configuration and design time,
15 White Paper: Getting Real About Big Data: Build Versus Buy 15 reduced implementation time, and a more dependable infrastructure out of the box, which moves along development and testing time, are all factors that contribute to the idea of "buy" speeding along big data projects. The time-to-market benefit of "buy" keeps giving, too, because the same time savings keeps repeating in every big data project.
White Paper Getting Real About Big Data: Build Versus Buy By Evan Quinn, Senior Principal Analyst February 2013 This ESG White Paper was commissioned by Oracle and is distributed under license from ESG.
White Paper EMC Isilon: A Scalable Storage Platform for Big Data By Nik Rouda, Senior Analyst and Terri McClure, Senior Analyst April 2014 This ESG White Paper was commissioned by EMC Isilon and is distributed
Big Data Big Deal for Public Sector Organizations Hoàng Xuân Hiếu Director, FAB & Government Business Indochina & Myanmar 1 Copyright 2013, Oracle and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved. The following
The Future of Data Management with Hadoop and the Enterprise Data Hub Amr Awadallah (@awadallah) Cofounder and CTO Cloudera Snapshot Founded 2008, by former employees of Employees Today ~ 800 World Class
White Paper EMC s Enterprise Hadoop Solution Isilon Scale-out NAS and Greenplum HD By Julie Lockner, Senior Analyst, and Terri McClure, Senior Analyst February 2012 This ESG White Paper was commissioned
infrastructure (WX 2 and blade server Kognitio provides solutions to business problems that require acquisition, rationalization and analysis of large and/or complex data The Kognitio Technology and Data
Company Brief Data Protection Services Should Be About Services, as Well as Data Protection Date: February 2013 Author: Jason Buffington, Senior Analyst Abstract: Organizations trying to modernize or fix
1 Oracle Big Data Appliance Releases 2.5 and 3.0 Ralf Lange Global ISV & OEM Sales Agenda Quick Overview on BDA and its Positioning Product Details and Updates Security and Encryption New Hadoop Versions
INSIGHT Oracle's All- Out Assault on the Big Data Market: Offering Hadoop, R, Cubes, and Scalable IMDB in Familiar Packages Carl W. Olofson IDC OPINION Global Headquarters: 5 Speen Street Framingham, MA
Delivering Real-World Total Cost of Ownership and Operational Benefits Treasure Data - Delivering Real-World Total Cost of Ownership and Operational Benefits 1 Background Big Data is traditionally thought
WHITEPAPER OPEN MODERN DATA ARCHITECTURE FOR FINANCIAL SERVICES RISK MANAGEMENT A top-tier global bank s end-of-day risk analysis jobs didn t complete in time for the next start of trading day. To solve
White Paper Integrated Computing Platforms: Infrastructure Builds for Tomorrow s Data Center By Mark Bowker, Senior Analyst, and Perry Laberis, Senior Research Associate March 2013 This ESG White Paper
ESG Brief IBM: An Early Leader across the Big Data Security Analytics Continuum Date: June 2013 Author: Jon Oltsik, Senior Principal Analyst Abstract: Many enterprise organizations claim that they already
White Paper Application Virtualization: An Opportunity for IT to do More with Much Less By Mark Bowker, Senior Analyst November 2012 This ESG White Paper was commissioned by DH2i and is distributed under
Introducing Oracle Exalytics In-Memory Machine Jon Ainsworth Director of Business Development Oracle EMEA Business Analytics 1 Copyright 2011, Oracle and/or its affiliates. All rights Agenda Topics Oracle
2010, Enterprise Strategy Group, Inc. All Rights Reserved White Paper The Data Center of the Future By Mark Bowker and Lauren Whitehouse March, 2010 This ESG White Paper was commissioned by Veeam and is
White Paper Closing the Big Data Management and Security Gap By Nik Rouda, Senior Analyst October 2014 This ESG White Paper was commissioned by Zettaset and is distributed under license from ESG. 2 Contents
White Paper Benefiting from Server Virtualization Beyond Initial Workload Consolidation By Mark Bowker June, 2010 This ESG White Paper was commissioned by VMware and is distributed under license from ESG.
Big Data at Cloud Scale Pushing the limits of flexible & powerful analytics Copyright 2015 Pentaho Corporation. Redistribution permitted. All trademarks are the property of their respective owners. For
Oracle Database - Engineered for Innovation Sedat Zencirci Teknoloji Satış Danışmanlığı Direktörü Türkiye ve Orta Asya Oracle Database 11g Release 2 Shipping since September 2009 22.214.171.124 Patch Set now
Research Report Abstract: Enterprise Big Data, Business Intelligence, and Analytics Trends By Nik Rouda, Senior Analyst With Bill Lundell, Senior Research Analyst, and Jennifer Gahm, Senior Project Manager
WHITE PAPER Ubuntu and Hadoop: the perfect match February 2012 Copyright Canonical 2012 www.canonical.com Executive introduction In many fields of IT, there are always stand-out technologies. This is definitely
Database Decisions: Performance, manageability and availability considerations in choosing a database Reviewing offerings from Oracle, IBM and Microsoft 2012 Oracle and TechTarget Table of Contents Defining
Architecting the Future of Big Data Whitepaper Apache Hadoop: The Big Data Refinery Introduction Big data has become an extremely popular term, due to the well-documented explosion in the amount of data
White Paper Extracting the Value of Big Data with HP StoreAll Storage and Autonomy By Terri McClure, Senior Analyst and Katey Wood, Analyst December 2012 This ESG White Paper was commissioned by HP and
SEPTEMBER 2013 Buyer s Guide to Big Data Integration Sponsored by Contents Introduction 1 Challenges of Big Data Integration: New and Old 1 What You Need for Big Data Integration 3 Preferred Technology
Economic Insight Paper Is Hyperconverged Cost-Competitive with the Cloud? An Evaluator Group TCO Analysis Comparing AWS and SimpliVity By Eric Slack, Sr. Analyst January 2016 Enabling you to make the best
David Chappell SELLING PROJECTS ON THE MICROSOFT BUSINESS ANALYTICS PLATFORM A PERSPECTIVE FOR SYSTEMS INTEGRATORS Sponsored by Microsoft Corporation Copyright 2014 Chappell & Associates Contents Business
White Paper Big Data Advisory Service By Julie Lockner& Tom Kornegay September, 2011 This ESG White Paper was commissioned by EMC Corporation and is distributed under license from ESG. 2011, Enterprise
Solution Impact Analysis NEC Powers ServIT's Custom Hosting Solutions By Mark Bowker September, 2011 This ESG publication was commissioned by NEC and is distributed under license from ESG. 2011, Enterprise
Oracle Big Data SQL Technical Update Jean-Pierre Dijcks Oracle Redwood City, CA, USA Keywords: Big Data, Hadoop, NoSQL Databases, Relational Databases, SQL, Security, Performance Introduction This technical
ESG Case Study Primatics Financial Delivers SaaS-based Solution Excellence Using EMC s XtremIO Date: March 2015 Authors: Mark Peters, Senior Analyst; Adam DeMattia, Market Research Analyst; and Monya Keane,
Dell s SAP HANA Appliance SAP HANA is the next generation of SAP in-memory computing technology. Dell and SAP have partnered to deliver an SAP HANA appliance that provides multipurpose, data source-agnostic,
MicroStrategy Cloud Reduces the Barriers to Enterprise BI... MicroStrategy Cloud reduces the traditional barriers that organizations face when implementing enterprise business intelligence solutions. MicroStrategy
White Paper Getting on the Road to SDN Attacking DMZ Security Issues with Advanced Networking Solutions By Bob Laliberte, Senior Analyst March 2014 This ESG White Paper was commissioned by NEC and is distributed
David Chappell October 2012 WINDOWS AZURE DATA MANAGEMENT CHOOSING THE RIGHT TECHNOLOGY Sponsored by Microsoft Corporation Copyright 2012 Chappell & Associates Contents Windows Azure Data Management: A
SAP HANA forms the future technology foundation for new, innovative applications based on in-memory technology. It enables better performing business strategies, including planning, forecasting, operational
Cloud Technologies and GIS Nathalie Smith firstname.lastname@example.org Agenda What is Cloud Computing? How does it work? Cloud and GIS applications Esri Offerings Lots of hype Cloud computing remains the latest, most
Field Audit Report Asigra Hybrid Cloud Backup and Recovery Solutions By Brian Garrett with Tony Palmer May, 2009 Field Audit: Asigra Hybrid Cloud Backup and Recovery Solutions 2 Contents Introduction...
IT CHANGE MANAGEMENT & THE ORACLE EXADATA DATABASE MACHINE EXECUTIVE SUMMARY There are many views published by the IT analyst community about an emerging trend toward turn-key systems when deploying IT
Research Report Abstract: Trends in Private Cloud Infrastructure By Mark Bowker, Senior Analyst and Bill Lundell, Senior Research Analyst With Jennifer Gahm, Senior Project Manager April 2014 Introduction
SAS and Oracle: Big Data and Cloud Partnering Innovation Targets the Third Platform David Lawler, Oracle Senior Vice President, Product Management and Strategy Paul Kent, SAS Vice President, Big Data What
Solution Brief A Checklist when Choosing a Backup Solution for SaaS-based Applications Date: January 2015 Authors: Jason Buffington, Senior Analyst; and Monya Keane, Research Analyst Abstract: What should
Big Data Are You Ready? Thomas Kyte http://asktom.oracle.com The following is intended to outline our general product direction. It is intended for information purposes only, and may not be incorporated
Please give me your feedback Session BB4089 Speaker Claude Lorenson, Ph. D and Wendy Harms Use the mobile app to complete a session survey 1. Access My schedule 2. Click on this session 3. Go to Rate &
Enterprise Strategy Group Getting to the bigger truth. SOLUTION SHOWCASE HGST Object Storage for a New Generation of IT Date: October 2015 Author: Scott Sinclair, Storage Analyst Abstract: Under increased
Enterprise Strategy Group Getting to the bigger truth. White Paper Direct Scale-out Flash Storage: Data Path Evolution for the Flash Storage Era Apeiron introduces NVMe-based storage innovation designed
Executive Summary... 2 Introduction... 3 Defining Big Data... 3 The Importance of Big Data... 4 Building a Big Data Platform... 5 Infrastructure Requirements... 5 Solution Spectrum... 6 Oracle s Big Data
A Kavaii White Paper http://www.kavaii.com Data Analytics Solution for Enterprise Performance Management Automated. Easy to Use. Quick to Deploy. Kavaii Analytics Team Democratizing Data Analytics & Providing
ESG Brief Commvault: Integrating Enterprise File Sync and Share Capabilities with Data Protection and Backup Date: September 2015 Author: Terri McClure, Senior Analyst, and Leah Matuson, Research Analyst
Overview The debate about the advantages of open source versus proprietary data integration software is ongoing. The reality of the situation is that the decision about whether open source or proprietary
Analytics With Hadoop SAS and Cloudera Starter Services: Visual Analytics and Visual Statistics Everything You Need to Get Started on Your First Hadoop Project SAS and Cloudera have identified the essential
ENABLING GLOBAL HADOOP WITH EMC ELASTIC CLOUD STORAGE Hadoop Storage-as-a-Service ABSTRACT This White Paper illustrates how EMC Elastic Cloud Storage (ECS ) can be used to streamline the Hadoop data analytics
ENTERPRISE STRATEGY GROUP POSITION PAPER Virtualization and the Case for Universal Grid Architectures By Steve Duplessie, Founder and Senior Analyst November 2012 Page 2 Contents Abstract... 4 History...
Einsatzfelder von IBM PureData Systems und Ihre Vorteile email@example.com Agenda Information technology challenges PureSystems and PureData introduction PureData for Transactions PureData for Analytics
Cloud Solutions for IT Management WHITE PAPER Project Management Office: Seeing the Whole Picture Project Portfolio Management gives PMOs the tools and techniques to get lean in lean times. Executive Summary
Nexsan and FalconStor Team for High Performance, Operationally Efficient Disk-based Backup Date: August, 2009 Author: Brian Babineau, Senior Consulting Analyst, and Lauren Whitehouse, Senior Analyst Abstract:
W I N T E R C O R P O R A T I O N Executive Report BIG DATA: BUSINESS OPPORTUNITIES, REQUIREMENTS AND ORACLE S APPROACH RICHARD WINTER December 2011 SUMMARY NEW SOURCES OF DATA and distinctive types of
perspective Data Virtualization A Potential Antidote for Big Data Growing Pains Atul Shrivastava Abstract Enterprises are already facing challenges around data consolidation, heterogeneity, quality, and
IBM InfoSphere Guardium Data Activity Monitor for Hadoop-based systems Proactively address regulatory compliance requirements and protect sensitive data in real time Highlights Monitor and audit data activity
WHITE PAPER Get Your Business Intelligence in a "Box": Start Making Better Decisions Faster with the New HP Business Decision Appliance Sponsored by: HP and Microsoft Dan Vesset February 2011 Brian McDonough
White Paper The Modern Network Monitoring Mandate By Bob Laliberte, Senior Analyst April 2014 This ESG White Paper was commissioned by Emulex and is distributed under license from ESG. White Paper: The
White Paper Protecting Big Data Data Protection Solutions for the Business Data Lake Abstract Big Data use cases are maturing and customers are using Big Data to improve top and bottom line revenues. With
White Paper Data Management and Analysis Cisco and Microsoft: Optimal Infrastructure Strategies By Mark Bowker, Senior Analyst February 2015 This ESG White Paper was commissioned by Cisco and is distributed
Microsoft Analytics Platform System Solution Brief Contents 4 Introduction 4 Microsoft Analytics Platform System 5 Enterprise-ready Big Data 7 Next-generation performance at scale 10 Engineered for optimal
News and trends in Data Warehouse Automation, Big Data and BI Johan Hendrickx & Dirk Vermeiren Extreme Agility from Source to Analysis DWH Appliances & DWH Automation Typical Architecture 3 What Business
Benchmarking Large-Scale Data Management Insights from Presentation Confidentiality Statement The materials in this presentation are protected under the confidential agreement and/or are copyrighted materials
HRG Assessment The Cloud Computing Challenge What is Cloud Computing? Cloud Computing can be described as application services provided to end users through the web and managed by a third party. The services
James Serra Sr BI Architect JamesSerra3@gmail.com http://jamesserra.com/ Our Focus: Microsoft Pure-Play Data Warehousing & Business Intelligence Partner Our Customers: Our Reputation: "B.I. Voyage came
Overview... 2 What is the Virtualization Barrier?... 3 Why Should Enterprises Care... 4 Repeatable Practices for Moving Virtualization Forward... 4 Use Case: Running Your Database in the Cloud... 6 Conclusion...
Cloudera Enterprise Reference Architecture for Google Cloud Platform Deployments Important Notice 2010-2015 Cloudera, Inc. All rights reserved. Cloudera, the Cloudera logo, Cloudera Impala, Impala, and
White Paper EMC IT Breaks Ground with SAP HANA By Nik Rouda, Senior Analyst November 2015 This ESG White Paper was commissioned by EMC and is distributed under license from ESG. Contents White Paper: EMC
S CIOs & BIG DATA CIOs & BIG DATA WHAT YOUR IT TEAM WANTS YOU TO KNOW Foreword Today enterprises face an increasingly competitive and erratic global business environment, and Big Data has become more than
HRG Insight: Cloud Computing Keeping apprised of terminology in today s constantly changing IT landscape can be a fulltime job for IT decisionmakers. Some terms lend themselves to a fairly educated guess
An Integrated Big Data & Analytics Infrastructure June 14, 2012 Robert Stackowiak, VP ESG Data Systems Architecture Big Data & Analytics as a Service Components Unstructured Data / Sparse Data of Value
IBM System x reference architecture solutions for big data Easy-to-implement hardware, software and services for analyzing data at rest and data in motion Highlights Accelerates time-to-value with scalable,
BIG DATA TRENDS AND TECHNOLOGIES THE WORLD OF DATA IS CHANGING Cloud WHAT IS BIG DATA? Big data are datasets that grow so large that they become awkward to work with using onhand database management tools.
Proofpoint Email Archiving Whitepaper: A look at the pros and cons of Software-as-a-Service and how they apply to email archiving. threat protection compliance archiving & governance secure communication
The Cloud at Crawford Evaluating the pros and cons of cloud computing and its use in claims management The Cloud at Crawford Wikipedia defines cloud computing as Internet-based computing, whereby shared
The 3 questions to ask yourself about BIG DATA Do you have a big data problem? Companies looking to tackle big data problems are embarking on a journey that is full of hype, buzz, confusion, and misinformation.