1 KULT 11: Made in Denmark, December 2013 Department of Culture and Identity, Roskilde University 45 The Danish African: Wolle Kirk, whiteness and colonial complicity. Lene Bull Christiansen* & Ashleigh Harris** Abstract The article analyses the racial self-representation of Wolle Kirk in his memoir Paradis i frit fald til helvede? En tilstandsrapport fra Zimbabwe (2008). Kirk bought a farm from the Rhodesian apartheid government in 1973 and ran it with his sons until he was violently attacked on the farm in 2002 as part of Zimbabwe s fast-track land reform program. The article reads the signs of race produced in the memoir as located both in the context of the violent land disputes in Zimbabwe in the 2000s, and in terms of Danish development aid and solidarity discourses, which produce a claim to Danish exceptionalism that Kirk accepts wholesale. We argue that the text exemplifies how claims of Danish exceptionalism may not only de-historicise whiteness and deny colonial accountability, but also produce complicity with, and tacit acceptance of, colonial structures of race. Introduction In this article we analyse the memoirs of Wolle Kirk: Paradis i frit fald til helvede? En tilstandsrapport fra Zimbabwe (A paradise in free fall towards hell? A status report from Zimbabwe) which he published in Denmark in Wolle Kirk, who variously referred to himself as a West-Jutlandic African and as a white-negro, 1 was born in 1937 in Hanstholm in the Nordjylland region of Denmark. He first travelled to Africa in 1968, when he was employed by the NGO Mellemfolkeligt Samvirke on a DANIDA project as 1 Jacob Stenz, De vestjyske afrikanere in Morsø Folkeblad. 11 June 2008, p. 12. Based on his interview with Wolle Kirk, the author, Jacob Stenz, has published a number of similar articles, with roughly the same wording in a number of local papers in Jutland (e.g. Midtjyllands Avis 24 May 2008, Jyske Vestkysten 25 May 2008, Dagbladet Vestjyske 24 May 2008) giving the interview a wider dissemination beyond the narrow local readership of Morsø Folkeblad. * Lene Bull Christiansen is assistant professor in Cultural Encounters at Roskilde University, Denmark. She is currently working on a research project, which deals with representations of Africa in Danish development aid promotion campaigns. Her publications have predominantly focused on gender and nationalism in Zimbabwe. **Ashleigh Harris is senior lecturer in English Literature at Uppsala University, Sweden. She is currently working on a book on African fiction of the 2000s. Her recent research publications have focused on ethics and postcolonial literature and theory in/of Africa.
2 46 The Danish African: Wolle Kirk, Whiteness and Colonial Complicity Lene Bull Christiansen & Ashleigh Harris an agricultural expert in Zambia for two years. Kirk and his family then immigrated to Zimbabwe (then Rhodesia) in 1973, apparently as a protest against Denmark s inclusion in the European community. 2 In Rhodesia, he bought farmland from Ian Smith s apartheid government which heavily subsidised white-owned farms to support Rhodesian economic growth and entice European immigration into the country despite international sanctions against the rogue state. Between the years 1973 and 2002, Kirk built up and operated a major dairy, cattle and tobacco farm Zengea Farms owned by his company, Red Dane Dairy. In 2002, Kirk s farm was invaded in Zimbabwe s notorious land grabs, where white-owned land was seized for reclamation by supposed war veterans of the liberation struggle against the Rhodesian state. Robert Mugabe saw this as the last struggle for the complete decolonization of our country and continent as a whole. 3 While many of the attackers were indeed impoverished peasants and perhaps even veterans of the liberation war in reality, Zimbabwe s land redistribution program was poorly administered and rife with corruption and cronyism. The result was violent land grabs, rather than systematic land redistribution. The seizure of Kirk s farm was violent, too (he lost his left eye in the attack) and although his farm was ultimately protected by Robert Mugabe s agreement to uphold bilateral investment promotion and protection agreements with Denmark, Kirk and his wife returned to Denmark after the attack. 4 Back in Denmark, Kirk quickly formed a public profile as commentator and expert on the Zimbabwean situation. In 2008 he published an account of his time in Africa, paying particular attention to what he portrays as Zimbabwe s descent into complete breakdown in its postcolonial years. The memoir, Paradis i frit fald til helvede? En tilstandsrapport fra Zimbabwe, 5 culminates in the scene of the attack on Kirk s farm; a scene that consolidates his narrative of Zimbabwe s plummet into hell. The book is published by Kirk s own publishing house Piraten (the pirate) a clear reference both 2 This information is included in almost all the obituaries published in Danish newspapers after Kirk s death in a car accident in Denmark in Robert Mugabe, Inside the Third Chimurenga, The Department of Information and Publicity, Harare, 2001, p Kirk s sons took over the management of the land. A renewed attempt at reclamation occurred in 2006, despite Mugabe s agreement with Denmark. Once again this was unsuccessful and Zengea farms remains in the hands of the Kirk family s company, Red Dane Dairy. 5 Wolle Kirk, Paradis i frit fald til helvede? En tilstandsrapport fra Zimbabwe, Piraten, Hurup, 2008.
3 KULT 11: Made in Denmark, December 2013 Department of Culture and Identity, Roskilde University 47 to the distinctive eye-patch that Kirk wore after losing his eye in the farm attack and to his self-perception as an anti-establishment figure. The event of land reclamation in the Zimbabwean postcolony, and the representational strategies used to depict it, is a complex and dense discursive site, both in Zimbabwe, where the land issue has been at the heart of political struggles over the last two decades, 6 and internationally, where the land issue has been interpreted, largely as a black on white issue. 7 The racial meanings pervading the scene are multiple and contested from every side, evoking intense conflict and recalling violent colonial history. The fact that Kirk enters this representational fray, in Danish to a Danish audience, in his book and in his varied and multiple statements about Zimbabwe in the Danish media, is our key site of analysis in this article. Kirk s presentation of his Danish national identity, and his configuration of his whiteness as specifically Danish, is linked, throughout his writing and interviews, to his investment in developing the skills of his workers and educating their children on his farms. While this self-perception position, even complicates the meanings of Kirk s whiteness in the Zimbabwean context, we wager that it does not counter his complicity with colonial formations of race. Kirk is not only complicit in the colonial and apartheid past as a beneficiary of Rhodesian subsidies which supported white ownership of farms at the cost of and in direct competition with black farming initiatives. More than this, we read his complicity in colonial models of race in ways that have been theorized by various commentators on Nordic colonial imaginaries. Ulla Vuorela s discussion of the ways in which tacit acceptance in our everyday practices can be transformed into colonial complicity 8 is instructive, as is Christina Petterson s reading of this complicity as constituting both symbolic and systemic violence in Slavoj Žižek s sense. 9 6 e.g. Brian Raftopoulos, Nation, race and history in Zimbabwean politics. In: Raftopoulos & Savage (eds.) 2004: Zimbabwe. Injustice and Political Reconciliation. Institute for Justice and Reconciliation. Cape Town. 2004, pp e.g. Wendy Willems, Remnants of Empire? British media reporting on Zimbabwe. In: Westminster Papers in Communication and Culture. Special Issue November pp Ulla Vuorela, Colonial complicity: The postcolonial in a Nordic context in Suvi Keskinen, Sari Irni and Diana Mulinari (eds.) Complying with Colonialism: Gender, Race and Ethnicity in the Nordic Region, Ashgate, Surrey, 2009, p Christina Petterson, Colonialism, racism and exceptionalism in Kristín Loftsdóttir and Lars Jensen (eds.) Whiteness and Postcolonialism in the Nordic Region, Ashgate, Surrey, 2012, p.30. See also Slavoj Žižek, Violence, Picador, New York, 2008, p
4 48 The Danish African: Wolle Kirk, Whiteness and Colonial Complicity Lene Bull Christiansen & Ashleigh Harris A key question for us is: to what extent does Kirk s memoir and his subsequent stylizing of his public persona in Denmark tacitly accept the privileges of his whiteness in the Zimbabwean context? Since this whiteness does not carry the same meanings in the Danish context, how does one find critical leverage in addressing the ways Kirk represents the historically and racially fraught scene of land reclamation in Danish to a Danish audience, as though he and that audience are positioned as innocent bystanders to colonial history? These questions raise broader concerns as to how notions of Nordic exceptionalism might collude with colonial racial meanings that continue to circulate in and about Africa today. Danish Exceptionalism The question of the Nordic region s involvement in and complicity with the long and violent history of European colonisation has come under intense scholarly scrutiny in recent years. This scholarship, exemplified in the two volumes Complying with Colonialism: Gender, Race and Ethnicity in the Nordic Region (2009) and Whiteness and Postcolonialism in the Nordic Region (2012), as well as a special edition of the journal Kult entitled The Nordic Colonial Mind (2010), 10 has interrogated the notion that Nordic countries are exempt from both European colonial history and the racial meanings that that history has left in its wake. Scholars have questioned the idea of Nordic exceptionalism by identifying multiple and complex sites of Nordic colonial activity, 11 as well as by analysing the extent to which colonial imaginaries have shaped Nordic perceptions of belonging and nationhood, 12 family and culture, 13 and gender, 14 class and race S.K Maurer, K Loftsdóttir et al. (eds.) Kult en temaserie, (Special issue: Nordic Colonial Mind) vol. 7, See, Mai Palmberg, The Nordic Colonial Mind in Complying with Colonialism, pp ; Erlend Eidsvik, Colonial discourse and ambivalence: Norwegian participants on the colonial arena in South Africa in Whiteness and Postcolonialism, pp ; and Petterson, Colonialism, racism and exceptionalism, pp Suvi Keskinen, Honour related violence and Nordic nation-building in Complying with Colonialism, pp ; Kirstín Loftsdóttir, Belonging and the Icelandic others: situating Icelandic identity in a postcolonial context in Whiteness and Postcolonialism, pp Bolette B. Blaagaard, The Flipside of my Passport: Myths of Origin and Genealogy of White Supremacy in the Mediated Social Genetic Imaginary in Complying with Colonialism, pp ; Johanna Latvala, Stranger or family member? Reproducing postcolonial power relations in Complying with Colonialism, pp ; Linda Lund Pedersen, Intimacy with the Danish state: my partner, the Danish state and I a case study of family reunification policy in Denmark in Whiteness and Postcolonialism, pp.
5 KULT 11: Made in Denmark, December 2013 Department of Culture and Identity, Roskilde University 49 Yet, Mai Palmberg usefully cautions us, in our readiness to discover sites of colonial complicity in the Nordic region, not to flatten the historical nuances of the variable degrees with which European nations invested in and benefited from colonial projects. 16 Indeed, she makes the important claim that the discourse of exceptionalism emerges, in the first instance, precisely because the Nordic region does enjoy a different relationship to European colonial history than that of the Imperial superpowers. This difference is not only because of the Nordic region s relatively minor (though by no means non-existent) involvement in colonization, but also because of its solidarity and development aid credentials. In our view, it is precisely these solidarity initiatives instituted in the Nordic relationship with southern independence movements that promoted a will to exceptionalism, in which an anti-colonial stance erased critical scrutiny of Nordic complicity in colonialism. This will to exceptionalism was then woven into the Nordic development aid tradition, which is characterized by notions of global responsibility, equality and ideals of peace and security through the eradication of poverty. 17 Like its Nordic neighbours, Denmark supported liberation struggles in the global south, particularly in Southern Africa, where bilateral support to humanitarian organizations and liberation movements went hand-in-hand with aid initiatives, setting the Nordic countries apart from their western allies during the cold war. 18 Furthermore, Danish bilateral aid via the state agency DANIDA as well as various NGO groups, developed aid initiatives that were often tied in with solidarity initiatives. 19 As such, a ; Leena-Maija Rossi, Licorice boys and female coffee beans: representations of colonial complicity in Finnish visual culture in Complying with Colonialism, pp Suvi Keskinen, Transnational influences, gender equality and violence in Muslim families in Whiteness and Postcolonialism, pp ; Jana Sverdljuk, Contradicting the prostitution stigma : narratives of Russian migrant women living in Norway in Complying with Colonialism, pp ; Salla Tuori Postcolonial and queer readings of migrant families in the context of multicultural work in Complying with Colonialism, pp ; Jaana Vuori, Guiding migrants to the realm of gender equality in Complying with Colonialism, pp ; Chia-Ling Yang Whose feminism? Whose emancipation? in Complying with Colonialism, pp Lars Jensen Danishness as whiteness in crisis: emerging post-imperial an development aid anxieties in Whiteness and Postcolonialism, pp ; Tobias Hübinette and Carina Tigervall When racism becomes individualized: experiences of racialization among adult adoptees and adoptive parents of Sweden in Complying with Colonialism, pp ; Tobias Hübinette, Words that wound : Swedish whiteness and its inability to accommodate minority experiences in Whiteness and Postcolonialism, pp Palmberg The Nordic Colonial Mind, p Espen Brunbech, Annette Skovsted Hansen, and Kristine Midtgaard, Historier om dansk udviklingsbistand in Den Jyske Historiker, no. 120, 2008, pp Palmberg The Nordic Colonial Mind 36; Christopher Munte Morgenstierne, Denmark and National Liberation in Southern Africa. Nordiska Afrikainstitutet. Uppsala, 2003, p Brunbech, Skovsted Hansen and Midtgaard, Historier om dansk udviklingsbistand, pp. 8-9.
6 50 The Danish African: Wolle Kirk, Whiteness and Colonial Complicity Lene Bull Christiansen & Ashleigh Harris Danish self-image as the defenders of Human Rights and global equality emerged from development aid 20 and solidarity politics, both of which were held as proof of a Danish anti-racist stance. 21 The early Danish development aid initiatives in Africa in the s were driven by a post-world War II idea of helping third world countries evolve in a teleological development trajectory. Danish experts were placed into various sectors with the explicit aim of enlightening locals on how to run agriculture, industry, education, government, and so forth. It is worth noting that this category of expert, into which Kirk falls when he first travels to Zambia on a DANIDA initiative, consisted of nothing more than having non-skilled farming experience from Denmark. Kirk, for example, had not received any form of formal training either in farming or development aid. However, owing to the thinking of the time, Danes with practical knowledge of superior Danish farming methods automatically placed them in the role of expert. It is also worth noting that the organization Mellemfolkeligt Samvirke, (The Danish Association for International Cooperation, MS) which employed Kirk as an agricultural expert, had cross-cultural exchange and solidarity at the core of their ideology. As such, cultural exchange was part of the idea behind sending a Danish farmer to Zambia as an expert.. In this understanding development aid becomes a double mission: both technological/educational and cultural. In such figurations of development aid Danishness itself is understood as having development potential, an idea that pervades Kirk s narrative of his private farming adventure in Rhodesia/Zimbabwe too. We therefore view the discursive dialectic between solidarity and aid as having brought with it a set of meanings that structure Danish (Nordic) relationships with Africa along paternalistic lines. 22 Moreover, we illustrate the ways in which this paternalism generates racial meanings, attaching Danishness inevitably to whiteness in the African 20 Christian Friis Bach, Foregangslandet under forandring in Bach, Olsen, Kaur-Pedersen and Pedersen (eds.) Idealer og Realiteter. Dansk Udviklingspolitisk Historie , Gyldendal, Copenhagen, 2008, p Morgenstierne, Denmark and National Liberation in Southern Africa, p. 17. For postcolonial critiques of the assumption that Denmark s anti-colonial stance was equivalent to non-racism see Lars Jensen, Provincialising Scandinavia in Kult, no. 7, 2010, pp. 7-21; Birgitta Frello, Dark Blood in Kult, no. 7, 2010, pp ; May-Britt Öhman, Sweden Helps : efforts to formulate the white man s burden for the wealthy and modern swede in Kult, no. 7, pp See Sunniva Engh The conscience of the world? Swedish and Norwegian provision of development aid in Itinerario, vol. 33, no. 2, 2009, pp ; Jensen, Danishness as whiteness in crisis, 2012; and Palmberg, The Nordic Colonial Mind, 2009.
7 KULT 11: Made in Denmark, December 2013 Department of Culture and Identity, Roskilde University 51 context. In this sense, we build on Lars Jensen s argument in Danishness as Whiteness in Crisis: Emerging Post-Imperial and Development Aid Anxieties, that development aid discourse is a key feature in demonstrating the infallibility of the naturalised majority self. The self that is constructed as white, but at the same time rendered invisible, as a naturalised norm. 23 In our discussion, such whiteness an invisible, naturalised norm is not an available social position in the context of postcolonial Zimbabwe. While Kirk falls back on precisely this idea of his own Danish whiteness, we raise questions as to the political implications of such an effacing of racial meaning in this African postcolony. Wolle Kirk in a Zimbabwean context In Paradis i frit fald til helvede?, Kirk recalls his search for suitable land to farm in 1973 when he first arrived in Rhodesia. He writes I was on the lookout for a farm that would provide both opportunities and challenges and, at the same time, form the basis of a new life: a farm that would lie in the midst of Africa s fertile plateau and that would be a good investment so that I could afford to go home and fetch Birthe and the five children. 24 What Kirk leaves out here is that his investment was a privilege of his race: the Rhodesian government s generous subsidising of white-owned farms at the time was a strategy to keep the land in the hands of a white minority as well as to attract a new generation of white farmer-settlers to the country. Kirk purchases his land, then, at a critical moment in Zimbabwe s history. Even with the inevitability of the country s move towards democracy, Rhodesian premier Ian Smith worked hard in his final years of rule to ensure that white Zimbabweans would retain their social and economic privileges in the time after liberation. The interim contract (the Lancaster House Agreement of 1979) drawn up to mediate the handover of power from Smith s regime to Robert Mugabe s newly democratic Zimbabwe in Jensen, Danishness as whiteness in crisis, pp Jeg var på udkik efter en farm, der både kunne give muligheder og udfordringer og samtidig danne grundlaget for en ny tillværelse. En farm, der skulle ligge midt på Afrikas frugtbare højslette og samtidig være en passende investering, så der kunne blive råd til at rejse hjem og hente Birthe og de 5 børn.' Kirk, Paradis i frit fald til helvede? p. 20.
8 52 The Danish African: Wolle Kirk, Whiteness and Colonial Complicity Lene Bull Christiansen & Ashleigh Harris specifically denied the new president the right to redistribute white-owned land to black farmers within the first decade of democracy. All land transfers had to be conducted under a willing-seller, willing buyer agreement at full market prices. Mugabe s acceptance of these conditions was, in part, an attempt to ensure economic stability at the time of political transition. Yet, the compromise was intensely felt: at the time that Mugabe came into power about 70 percent of Zimbabwe s total landmass, including communal areas, was owned by the state and 24 percent owned by large-scale commercial farmers. 25 This meant that of the country s arable land, around 40% was owned by a small minority of white farmers (approximately 6000), whilst a population of about 4 million black Zimbabweans were living in state-owned communal areas without economic resources to become land-owners. The aftermath of white privilege and the continued protection of white farmers by the Lancaster House Agreement, as well as corruption and mismanagement within Zimbabwe s ruling party, ZANU(PF), meant that by the late 1990s, Mugabe still had not made good on his promises of the 1970s to redistribute land to the Zimbabwean people. Indeed, in 1996, only 71,000 farm families were re-settled on 3.6 million hectares of land, a far cry from the initial goal of resettling 162,000 families on 8.3 million hectares by In the middle to late 1990s around 70% of the country s most arable land remained in the hands of white farmers. By the end of the 1990s a tide of economic, social and political disintegration had put the Zimbabwean government at its most vulnerable. In a ploy to retain political support by mobilising Mugabe s old promise of returning the land to the people, the Zimbabwean government instituted their fast-track land reform program, which was neither programmatic nor reformist: land was, as we ve already stated, seized, often violently, without any financial compensation whatsoever, and in most cases also without any systematic redistribution. What transpired was well documented in the global media. Yet, despite widespread news coverage, the land seizures were largely analysed in the global press as only a symptom of the failure of the Zimbabwean nation state; that is, as 25 James S. Juana, A quantitative analysis of Zimbabwe's land reform policy: An application of Zimbabwe SAM multipliers in Agrekon: Agricultural Economics Research, Policy and Practice in Southern Africa, vol. 45, no. 3, 2006, p Juana, A quantitative analysis of Zimbabwe s land reform policy, p. 298.
9 KULT 11: Made in Denmark, December 2013 Department of Culture and Identity, Roskilde University 53 an entirely postcolonial problem without reference to, or interrogation of, the colonial structures underpinning the clearly racialised distribution of land as it stood in the mid- 1990s. 27 What followed was a rhetorical war between Zimbabwe s ruling party and the international media that quickly solidified into an absolutist semiotics of race from both sides. Wendy Willems illustrates this through an analysis of British media reporting on Zimbabwe. She argues that the British media, through strategies of simplification, ethnicisation and maginalisation sought to frame and represent events in Zimbabwe in terms of a racial conflict between black and white. 28 Furthermore, the Zimbabwean government successfully managed to exploit these discourses on what they termed Britain s kith and kin [i.e. whites, which] enabled them to present and frame the crisis in Zimbabwe as a bilateral disagreement over land with imperial power Britain. 29 Zimbabwe s ruling party thus mobilised the reclamation of land in overtly racial terms, as is evident in Mugabe s rhetoric at the time, when statements such as Africa is for Africans. [Our] Land is ours by birth, ours by right; and, we call on all blacks to stand together to isolate these whites, were commonplace. 30 The global media and publishing industries were similarly invested in the racial meanings of land reclamation, even at the same time as they claimed racial neutrality in their representation of the events. 31 What this means is that the discourses of race pervading the events of land reclamation in Zimbabwe in the 2000s were dense and complex: no claim to exemption from the colonial meanings of whiteness seems possible in such a context, yet it is precisely this claim that gets mobilized in Kirk s various accounts of the Zimbabwean 27 See Wendy Willems, Remnants of Empire? British media reporting on Zimbabwe in Westminster Papers in Communication and Culture (Special Issue), 2005, pp Willems discusses how the British media inadequately contextualised the Zimbabwean crisis, thereby presenting Robert Mugabe as solely responsible for the crisis in Zimbabwe (100), a rhetorical move that effaces colonial accountability altogether. 28 Willems, Remnants of Empire?, p Willems, Remnants of Empire?, p.104. Emphasis ours. 30 Zimbabwe President: Fight Whites, The Associated Press, 14 December Available URL: <http://www.zimbabwesituation.com/dec15.html#link3> (05 November 2007). 31 In the years immediately following the land grabs, dozens of white memoirs and autobiographies about Zimbabwe and the Zimbabwean situation emerged. Some key examples include Alexandra Fuller s Scribbling the Cat (2004); Peter Godwin s When a Crocodile Eats the Sun (2005), Douglas Rogers s The Last Resort: A Memoir of Zimbabwe (2008), Lauren St John s Rainbow's End: A Memoir of Childhood, War and an African Farm (2008); Wendy Kann s Casting with a Fragile Thread: A Story of Sisters and Africa (2007); Christina Lamb s House of Stone: The True Story of a Family Divided in War-Torn Zimbabwe (2009).
10 54 The Danish African: Wolle Kirk, Whiteness and Colonial Complicity Lene Bull Christiansen & Ashleigh Harris situation for a Danish audience. Wolle Kirk seen from a Danish point of view Since Paradis i frit fald til helvede? is written in Danish (and in Denmark), we also need to consider the discursive context of its reception if we are to interrogate the (double) racial meanings that pervade and are produced by the book To illustrate this we want first to draw attention to the media representations surrounding the publication of the book as well as Kirk s role as a local celebrity. A journalist in the nation-wide newspaper Jyllands-Posten, for example, framed an interview with Kirk with the following introduction: For 32 years he ruled his African farm without feeling like a colonial master but Wolle Kirk was eventually squeezed out by violence and corruption. Now, the Kirks are back in that Denmark, which they once could not stand. 32 It seems inevitable that a Danish farmer in Africa will be depicted with references to the nation s famous child, Karen Blixen here via the phrase sin afrikanske farm which paraphrases the Danish title of Blixen s autobiography Out of Africa: Den Afrikanske Farm. Indeed other journalists also depicted Kirk via references to Blixen. 33 This framing places Kirk both in a particular literary tradition and in the context of narratives that depict Danish relations with Africa. Blixen s Out of Africa has been important in shaping both. Indeed, Jensen has argued that Out of Africa has probably meant more for Danish perceptions in the 20 th century of Africa than any other single book. 34 In this tradition, the Danish narrator/protagonist places her-/himself in an ambivalent position vis-à-vis the colonial projects, which they on the one hand benefit from and on the other hand see 32 Frits Christensen, Piratens tredje liv in Jyllands-Posten. 10 December 2006, p. 4. The original quote reads: I 32 år herskede han over sin afrikanske farm uden at føle sig som koloniherre men Wolle Kirk blev til sidst presset ud af vold og korruption. Nu er ægteparret Kirk tilbage i det Danmark, de engang ikke kunne holde ud. 33 See, for example, Lena Jeppesen, Bedstefar og Førstekonen har Zimbabwe i blodet, in Ringkøbing Amts Dagblad, 14 April 2003; and Niels Rohleder Portræt: Den danske farmer in Information, 01 November Lars Jensen, The historiography of Danish representations of Africa: From Blixen to Development aid in Brugioni et.al. (eds.) Áfricas Contemoprâneas Contemporary Africas. Universidade do Minho, Centro de Estudos Humanisticos, 2011, p. 38.
11 KULT 11: Made in Denmark, December 2013 Department of Culture and Identity, Roskilde University 55 themselves as not participating in. 35 Blixen is of course the most prominent Danish example of this literary tradition and also the most controversial. The postcolonial backlash against Blixen, 36 and the way in which this was received in a Danish context, is telling of how Danish exceptionalism is extended to include even those who actively participated in colonialism as settlers (having bought his farm in 1973, we propose to place Kirk in this same category). In Danish literary debates, even critics who claim to understand postcolonial critiques of Blixen are prone to understand the backlash against Blixen as a product of proximity and distance. That is, the African critic is read as biased by his proximity to the political and cultural ramifications of colonial rule and simultaneous distance from the self-perceived anti-racism of the Danes. Thus, to their minds, African critics have missed Blixen s intended goodwill towards the Africans in her work: the perception being that while she may have been a product of her time, she nevertheless loved her natives and fought their case against the British. 37 Likewise, when representing himself to a Danish audience, Kirk explicitly places himself in opposition to the British farmers (the former Rhodesian settlers/colonizers) in Zimbabwe. In the following extract from an interview published in a local Danish newspaper following the publication of Paradis i frit fald til helvede? Kirk depicts his management philosophy in opposition to his white peers and as something distinctly Danish/Jutlandic: As employer of close to 1000 workers, Wolle Kirk favoured what he calls west-jutlandic management. The leader is not placed on a pedestal. He walks amongst his workers on an equal footing. And he is capable of performing the same tasks as the others. When we started the butchery, I had to learn how to be a butcher. When we started the dairy, I had to learn that, he says. His attitude meant a departure from the racial divides that were predominant among the British farmers. Wolle Kirk paid a black worker exactly the same as a white worker, if he had the same qualifications. That may be the reason that he was never truly accepted 35 Lasse Horne Kjældgaard, En af de farligste bøger, der nogen sinde er skrevet om Afrika? Karen Blixen og kolonialismen in TijdSchrift voor Skandnavistiek, vol. 30, no. 2, 2009, pp Most notably framed by Ngũgĩ wa Thiong'o, Moving the Centre. The Struggle for Cultural Freedoms. James Currey, London, 1993; see also Kirsten Holst Petersen, Blixen-igen-igen: Nationalt ikon, national stolthed in Kult (Special issue: Jagten på det eksotiske), no. 3, 2006, pp See Kjældgaard, En af de farligste bøger, 2009.
12 56 The Danish African: Wolle Kirk, Whiteness and Colonial Complicity Lene Bull Christiansen & Ashleigh Harris by the other white farmers. He did join their country club, but he did not play golf or drove a large Mercedes, like the others. 38 Like Blixen, who saw herself as an extraordinarily benevolent landlord on her Kenyan farm, 39 Kirk also paints a picture of himself as the better employer as compared to the British white farmers; his peers. Kirk bases this difference on both his non-britishness and on his rootedness in western Jutland. This is, then, interpreted by the journalist as an anti-racist stance, which becomes the backdrop against which the violent racially motivated attack on Kirk is then narrated. Without attempting to draw any further literary similarities between Blixen and Kirk, they do share a positionality that is complicated by the fact that their writings are aimed at an outside (not African) audience: A Danish (and in Blixen s case also American) reader, whom the texts are intended to enlighten about the plight of Africans. As such, their narratives of self-involvement in Kenya/Zimbabwe are audience specific, and their descriptions of the natives / the blacks are invested with preconceived Danish (western) ideas of the other onto which the narrative attempts to add new (enlightening) perspectives. Paradis i frit fald til helvede? very directly represents this mode of writing; writing exclusively for a Danish audience, Kirk takes a lot of trouble to educate his readers about Zimbabwe and the blacks. Thus, Kirk depicts himself as a missionary in both contexts: in Zimbabwe he represents Danishness as progress with his introduction of west-jutlandic management methods, while in Denmark he becomes the expert on Africa, an expertise he inscribes onto himself in his claim to having become, as a result of his time and experience in Africa, a west-jutlandic negro : I have become a white negro, Wolle Kirk squeezes out the words through a rusty laugh that becomes muffled in an itchy cough. His white beard has a yellow discoloring around the mouth caused by 38 Stenz, De vestjyske afrikanere, p Original quote: Som arbejdsgiver for op mod 1000 ansatte gik Wolle Kirk ind for det, han kalder»vestjysk management«. - Lederen står ikke oppe på en piedestal. Han går rundt mellem sine medarbejdere på lige fod. Og han kan selv udføre det arbejde, de andre er sat til. Da vi startede slagteriet, så måtte jeg lære at være slagter. Da vi startede mejeriet, så måtte jeg lære det, siger han. Hans indstilling betød et opgør med de raceskel, som især var fremherskende hos de britiske farmere. Wolle Kirk betalte en sort medarbejder nøjagtigt det samme som en hvid, hvis han havde de samme kvalifikationer. Måske var det derfor, han aldrig rigtigt blev accepteret af de andre hvide farmere. Han var godt nok med i deres country club, men han spillede ikke golf eller kørte rundt i en stor Mercedes, som de andre. 39 See, for example, Jensen, The historiography of Danish representations of Africa, 2011.
13 KULT 11: Made in Denmark, December 2013 Department of Culture and Identity, Roskilde University 57 tobacco. A screwd, peasant-cunny smile points up towards the leather eye-patch, which covers his missing eye, the one the robbers took out. Before, I was a Scandinavian, now, I m a white negro. 40 Kirk clearly favours these exotic depictions of his persona, not only does he refer to himself as a negro in the Danish context, he also repeatedly calls himself the Pirate 41 He positions himself in an outsider position both in the Zimbabwean context, where he depicts himself as distinct from his British farmer neighbours, particularly on the issue of race-relations, 42 but also because he is the common man who does not fit in well in the country club, and is not partial to materialistic goods. In the Danish context, which he originally abandoned (or, in his words, could not stand ), 43 he is positioned as the westjutlandic negro ; a double outsider position, owing to the outback referencing of western Jutland, and the exotic figure of the negro. Although, economically he has very clearly been positioned as colonial/white landowner in Zimbabwe; culturally, socially and in terms of his image, Kirk styles himself as an oppositional figure; the voice of common sense a person who can speak truth to power in Zimbabwe, and in Denmark enlighten the Danes about facts as seen from the ground in Zimbabwe. Re-enacting colonial whiteness Given that Kirk self-presents as being different to the other white farmers by virtue of his Danishness, it is unsurprising that he details the other Scandinavians in his (white) community in Zimbabwe. He dedicates an entire chapter to a figure he calls Røde Erik, a Dane who had already lived and farmed in Rhodesia for a number of years when Kirk 40 Stenz, De vestjyske afrikanere, p.12. Original quote: Jeg er blevet hvid neger, klemmer Wolle Kirk ud i et rustent grin, der kvæles af en kras hoste. Hans hvide skæg er let gulnet omkring munden efter snaddens tobakssovs. Et skævt, bondesnu smil peger op mod læderlappen, der dækker for det manglende øje, som røverne stak ud. Før var jeg skandinav, men nu er jeg hvid neger. 41 See also: Christensen, Piratens tredje liv, 2006, p. 13; and Jens Kirk Pedersen, Afrikas blødende hjerte in Dagbladet Holstedbro Struer, 01 April Kirk describes himself explicitly as an anti-racist in his heart-of-hearts; see: Kirk, Paradis i frit fald til helvede? p It is worth noting here that there is some dispute as to Kirk s relation to the Danish State. Having taken DANIDA funding (via the private sector program), Kirk has been accused of misrepresenting himself as a Dane, owing to the fact that DANIDA funding was conditioned on his being Zimbabwean. The journalist who raised these allegations, Niels Rohleder, is one of the few critical voices in the Danish media, with regard to Kirk s self-representation as the Danish African. See Rohleder, Portræt: Den danske farmer, 2002.
14 58 The Danish African: Wolle Kirk, Whiteness and Colonial Complicity Lene Bull Christiansen & Ashleigh Harris first arrives there in Also, Kirk repeatedly notes the fact that the first farmer to be killed in the land invasions, David Stevens, was svenskegifte, which is to say, married to a Swede 45 the relevance of this observation is never elaborated. However, Kirk connects this detail to the fact that the priest presiding over Stevens s funeral, one Terje Berkholdt, is Norwegian. Kirk notes in regard to Berkholdt that we Scandinavians are apt at sounding the alarm, in such situations, 46 which leads to added international pressure on the Mugabe government after the murder of Stevens and his farm manager. 47 We are lead to believe, then, that detailing these white characters Nordic backgrounds or connections, is a rhetorical gesture that re-enacts this group s difference to the rest of the white community. To its Danish audience, such observations may summon readers identification with these farmers (precisely through the prism of Nordic exceptionalism); farmers who are presented not only as the vestiges of white colonial Rhodesia, but as a community of mixed-white origins with differing political and ideological persuasions. It is clear that Kirk sees himself as exempt from the racial meanings that pervade this context, by virtue of his being both white and not entirely of the white community. Erlend Eidsvik s analysis of the ways in which early Norwegian immigrants to South Africa inhabited an indistinct position between the British and the Boers is instructive. For Eidsvik, these Norwegian settlers not only adhered to the colonial discourse, but also reconstituted and reinforced this discourse through explorations and exploitations of their own ambivalent position. 48 Similarly, while Kirk positions himself as different to the other Zimbabwean whites as rhetorical leverage for why we should read his narrative as racially neutral, his articulation of his own racial exceptionalism turns out to reconstitute and reinforce colonial discourses of race. To stage this argument more concretely it is worth noting that Kirk s identification with a Scandinavian community in Zimbabwe not only bolsters his claims to a whiteness exempt from colonial structures of race, but also allows him to present a black other in racial terms with no acknowledgement (or even awareness) of the racist implications of 44 Røde Erik s nickname, referring as it does to Erik the Red, an archetypal colonial figure, is, of course, significant. Kirk, Paradis i frit fald til helvede? p Kirk, Paradis i frit fald til helvede? p Original quote: Er der noget, vi skandinaver er skrappe til, så er det at råbe vagt i gevær i en sådan situation (44). 47 Kirk, Paradis i frit fald til helvede? p. 44; Eidsvik, Colonial discourse and ambivalence, p. 13.
15 KULT 11: Made in Denmark, December 2013 Department of Culture and Identity, Roskilde University 59 his own language. An example from Paradis i fri fald til helvede? illustrates the point: Kirk describes what he sees as an unfair and unreasonable charge of racism by the political commissioner of the region where he has his farms. The charge is based on the fact that Kirk gives the nickname Orangutan to a young worker on his farm. Kirk writes: The political commissioner, a new position that we had been saddled with after independence, approached me very formally and pointed out that it was pure and plain racism to call a man Orangutan. I explained to him, very carefully, that it was precisely to highlight the boy s unique strength and agility and even that he was the district s fastest runner, that I had given him this nickname. The commissioner seemed to chew on this for some time, but did not pass the matter on to a higher office. 49 The racial implications of a white farmer calling his black employee Orangutan in a context where the residues of racist colonial terms such as Ape or Monkey to refer to black Africans are painfully present are considerable. While the performative act of naming this young man Orangutan cannot be so easily excised from this entanglement of racist language, Kirk uses the term as though he stands before its colonial history as an innocent, thereby rendering the charge of racism absurd. This incident illustrates the ways in which the claim of exceptionalism operates to efface an awareness of and accountability for a tacit agreement with the colonial structures that pervade the meanings of race in Zimbabwe. Indeed, Kirk portrays the attack on his farm as racist, precisely because his whiteness is (to his mind) not a marker of colonial complicity. Kirk seems genuinely surprised when he is told by a ZANU(PF) representative that For us, the revolution is to wrest all property and power from the whites 50 a claim he sees as racist because of his 49 Den politiske kommissær, en ny institution, som vi jo efter uafhængigheden var blevet belemret med, henvendte sig meget formelt til mig, og gjorde opmærksom på, at det var den rene skinbarlige racisme at kalde et menneske for Orangutang. Jeg forklarede ham så, meget omstændeligt, at det netop var for at fremhæve at knægten var helt enestående både stærk og adræt of tilmed distriktets hurtigste løber, at jeg havde givet ham dette kælenavm. En forklaring hans velærvædighed kommissæren tyggede noget på, men dog ikke viderebragte på højere sted. Kirk, Paradis i frit fald til helvede? p Kirk, Paradis i frit fald til helvede? p. 61.
16 60 The Danish African: Wolle Kirk, Whiteness and Colonial Complicity Lene Bull Christiansen & Ashleigh Harris self-perception as being different to the other white Zimbabwean farmers in his vicinity. 51 Indeed, the attack might be seen to violently re-inscribe the significance of Kirk s whiteness, a significance he wishes to deny, upon his own body. Interestingly, it is at this point, a point where Kirk is forced to confront the history of race in Zimbabwe as a white man, that his own language collapses into a base colonial repertoire of racial meaning. Describing the farm invaders intensifying agitation outside his farmhouse in the 24 hours leading up to the attack, Kirk writes: the choir began to sing revolutionary songs to a thundering accompaniment of drums. Singing is perhaps an understatement. They screamed and shouted and spat obscene names at us across the garden. The motifs of Mugabe s infallibility, the central committee s righteousness and wisdom and the white wrongdoers evil deeds and land theft, were repeated amidst powerful slogans such as Throw the white bandits and land thieves down into the flames of hell. 52 While the singing of the songs of revolution during the land grabs was certainly an expedient mobilisation of the discourses of struggle, one cannot dismiss the value of these songs, for the singers, at this particular juncture in the nation s history, as mere false consciousness. Indeed, whether we see the evocation of the struggle past at this moment of Zimbabwean history as the use of war-time tragedy for party purposes [which has] had the effect of cheapening liberation history 53 or not, the fact remains that white-owned land remains, for dispossessed black Zimbabwean peasants, a site of colonial violence. It is this reality that Mugabe used so well in his own 51 Such self-perception urges us to ask more significant critical questions about what it means, then, to read the slogan We will not be colonised again, (a common slogan during the land seizures) mediated by Kirk and translated into Danish: Vi vil ikke koloniseres igen! Kirk, Paradis i frit fald til helvede? p. 36. The translation linguistically stages the author s non-accountability to the very colonial history he is referring to: in English, the line calls a complex history of colonial meanings of power and land into a discursive sphere, in ways that force the reader to reflect on the histories of colonisation that lead to this particular historical juncture. In Kirk s translation, the phrase is represented as anachronistic, and even absurd. 52 Så begyndte koret at synge revolutionære sange med dundrende tromme akkompagnement. Synge er måske en underdrivelse. De råbte og skreg og spyttede sjofle uforskammetheder ud over hele haven. Motiverne var alt fra Mugabes ufejlbarlighed, central komiteens retfærdighedssans og visdom. De Hvide forbryderes onde handlinger og jordtyveri for 100 år siden, kraftigt iblandet slagord som: Afrikas jord på sorte hænder! Smid de hvide banditter og jordtyve ned i Helvedes flammer! Kirk, Paradis i frit fald til helvede? p Terence Ranger, The Zimbabwe Elections: A Personal Experience A presentation given at the Oxford Centre for Mission Studies on March Available URL: (28 March 2008)
17 KULT 11: Made in Denmark, December 2013 Department of Culture and Identity, Roskilde University 61 rhetorical manipulation of the situation at the time. 54 But in Kirk s description, the songs become emptied of their dense layers of historical significance and the singers themselves become reduced to a frenzied mass, unthinkingly shouting out the slogans of the ruling party, without a will of their own. This confirms postcolonial theorist Achille Mbembe s observation that, in the west, it is assumed that, although the African possesses a self-referring structure that makes him or her close to being human, he or she belongs, up to a point, to a world we cannot penetrate. At bottom, he/she is familiar to us. We can give an account of him/her in the same way we can understand the psychic life of the beast. We can even, through a process of domestication and training, bring the African to where he or she can enjoy a fully human life. 55 We are not denying that Kirk was a victim of extreme violence in this attack and it would be unfair to expect the physical violence that he suffered not to influence his later writing of the scene. Yet, it is interesting that at the point Kirk becomes the victim of violence (and before that, a victim of the systemic violence of racism itself) that he should revert to an unapologetic colonial repertoire of race to describe that violence. Kirk s attackers, as Mbembe put it, unfold under the sign of the beast 56 even in their very racism while the well-meaning European, cleansed of all colonial responsibility by virtue of his birthright as a Dane, unfolds under the signs of rational humanity and political neutrality. 57 Later, Kirk reiterates the very colonial logic Mbembe is describing: How often have I and other well-meaning Europeans been forced to accept the fundamental difference between Africans and ourselves in the perception of life. 58 Thus, the presentation of a well-meaning whiteness detached from colonial history inevitably redoubles to produce the irrational, savage and bestial black other. It is perhaps no surprise that such stereotypes of African blackness slip into overt and 54 See, for example, Mugabe Inside the Third Chimurenga Achille Mbembe, On the Postcolony, University of California Press, Berkley, 2001, p Kirk, Paradis i frit fald til helvede? p And even martyrdom: It is worth noting that Kirk compares himself to the Danish martyr Kaj Munk. Kirk, Paradis i frit fald til helvede? p Hvor ofte er jeg selv og andre velmenende europæere ikke blevet tvunget til at indse den fundamentale forskel, der er mellem afrikanerne og os i livsopfattelse. Kirk, Paradis i frit fald til helvede? p. 177.
18 62 The Danish African: Wolle Kirk, Whiteness and Colonial Complicity Lene Bull Christiansen & Ashleigh Harris unapologetic idealizing of and support for the Rhodesian government 59 and Ian Smith (whom Kirk is an apologist for and hails as a son of Africa 60 ) by the close of the text. This championing of a racist regime, taken in isolation, would be considered incendiary to most readers. But the text justifies the position by virtue of Kirk s claim to want the best for Zimbabwe s black majority and in the context of his broader narration of the terrible violence he himself has suffered. He writes In retrospect, one would naturally have chosen a faster path towards majority rule, but had this constitution continued unhindered Rhodesia would today have a black majority in parliament based on a solid middle class, probably a strong economy and a great deal more humanity and democracy than under Mugabe s dictatorship. 61 Conclusion We read Kirk s final statements in Paradis i frit fald til helvede? as instructive as to his discursive positionality, both in a Zimbabwean and a Danish context: I have no academic schooling, I only have my experiences and observations throughout a life in Africa and Zimbabwe to attach my suggestions to, and also I have left my one eye in Africa, but perhaps that gives me an eye to things, which wiser people have overlooked 62 The position as the common man, who speaks truth to power (academics and wiser people ), whom, he suspects, would charge him with racism, because of his support for the Smith regime, is carefully constructed throughout Paradis i frit fald til helvede? as a life-long project; from leaving Denmark in protest over the European community, his 59 Kirk, Paradis i frit fald til helvede? p Kirk, Paradis i frit fald til helvede? p Set i bakspejlet skulle man selvfølgelig have valgt en hurtigere vej frem mod flertals styre; men havde denne forfatning forsat uhindrat, ville Rhodesia i dag have haft sort flertal i parlamentet baserat på en solid middelklasse, sandsynligvis en stærk økonomi samt en god portion mere menneskeret og demokrati end under Mugabes diktatur. Kirk, Paradis i frit fald til helvede? p Jeg har ingen akademisk skoling, kun mine erfaringer og iagttagelser gennem mit liv i Afrika og Zimbabwe at hænge mine forslag på, og så har jeg efterladt mit ene øje i Afrika, men måske jeg derfor får øje på ting, som klogere folk har overset. Kirk, Paradis i frit fald til helvede? p. 189.
19 KULT 11: Made in Denmark, December 2013 Department of Culture and Identity, Roskilde University 63 anti-racist management of the farms, to his final opposition to Mugabe s dictatorship; Kirk is placed as an anti-establishment figure. There is a distinctive aesthetic to this position: Kirk represents himself as rooted in the soil that of Africa and of western Jutland. Kirk s references to western Jutland with its relatively harsh living conditions and peasant traditions are brought forth throughout the narrative as a continual source of inspiration. Kirk s position as a genuine son of the soil functions to authenticate his narrative as a disinterested account based on real-life experience, untainted by the upper-class sensibilities and/or left-wing politics otherwise associated with development practitioners and academic Africanists. The peasant inspirations of Kirk s youth are woven into the narrative as an astatic association between western Jutland and the Zimbabwean countryside, for example in his description of designing the school on his farm: The school stands out as a three-winged west-jutlandic marsh farmhouse with a thatched roof. The reason that I chose this model, when I drew up and projected the school, was the flat area, where the school should be built, and that I have always been impressed by, how thoroughly the old marsh farmhouses with their mighty thatched roofs creates a fine contrast in a flat landscape. 63 Furthermore, Kirk s self-styled persona as the white negro pirate functions to lend his descriptions of Zimbabwe, its land, people and politics, the authentication of a disinterested party. Throughout his polemic, he remains the Dane/Scandinavian innocent and well-meaning bystander to colonial and postcolonial conflicts and power relations. By first placing himself and other Scandinavian whites in opposition to British whites and aesthetically associating his Zimbabwean countryside with the landscapes of western Jutland, he places himself outside the violent history of colonialism and its political legacies. This discursive move is partly made possible by the context of the Mugabe/British discourse of the land distribution issue as a racist-postcolonial problem; 63 Skolen fremtræder som en trelænget, vestjysk marskgård med stråtag. Grunden til at jeg valgte denne model, da jeg tegnede og projektrede skolen, var det meget flade område, hvorpå skolen skulle bygges, og at jeg altid har været imponeret af, hvor gedigent de gamle marskgårde med deres gevaldige stråtag skaber en fin kontrast i et fladt landskab. Kirk, Paradis i frit fald til helvede? p. 114.
20 64 The Danish African: Wolle Kirk, Whiteness and Colonial Complicity Lene Bull Christiansen & Ashleigh Harris thus placing Danes and other Scandinavians as exempt from complicity even involvement in the racial inequality and racist history of land-distribution in Zimbabwe. Kirk s acceptance of white privilege in the violent colonial context of the 1970s, where he purchased his land, is overwritten in his narrative by the fact of the violent attack on his farm in By accepting an opposition between British whiteness as colonialist and Danish whiteness as anti-racist, Kirk renders his own white privilege and collusion with the colonial past irrelevant; a manoeuvre that exemplifies the ways that the very claims to exceptionalism are themselves complicit with colonialism.
Paper presented to the British Society of Criminology Conference, Liverpool 10-12 July, 2014 and the European Group for the Study of Deviance and Social Control Annual Conference, Liverpool 3-6 September
Global civil society beyond the good and the bad Håkan Thörn and Heidi Moksnes What is global civil society? And what is the meaning of global civil society? A few years ago, there was a debate on whether
Vol. 4, No. 1, Fall 2006, 139-145 www.ncsu.edu/project/acontracorriente Florencia E. Mallon, Courage Tastes of Blood: The Mapuche Community of Nicolás Ailío and the Chilean State, 1906-2001. (Durham, NC:
Claus B. Jensen IT Auditor, CISA, CIA I am employed in Rigsrevisionen, Denmark. (Danish National Audit Office) I have worked within IT Audit since 1995, both as internal and external auditor and now in
PORTFOLIO E T H M All images (courtesy MACK). Kissing the Stone ROSALIND FOX SOLOMON 10 11 Jerusalem Syndrome Untitled 12 13 Untitled Wall 14 15 Priest with Flock Independence of Sierra Leone Celebration
Research on the Danish heroin assisted treatment programme Katrine Schepelern Johansen Anthropologist, PhD Post.doc, Department of Anthropology, University of Copenhagen Treatment with heroin in Denmark
Structure of the Danish phrase The key to the understanding of the Danish phrase is the relative position of verb (in present or past), v, subject, s, and adverbs like ikke (not), a in the first part of
The following course units will be offered: Research Methodology Textual Analysis and Practice Sociolinguistics: Critical Approaches Life writing World Englishes Digital Cultures Beyond the Post-colonial
Southern Culture and Slavery Chapter 16 Early Emancipation in the North Missouri Compromise, 1820 1 Characteristics of the Antebellum South 1. Primarily agrarian. 2. Economic power shifted from the upper
Graduate Courses 700 INTRODUCTION TO RESEARCH AND THEORY IN COMMUNICATION STUDIES I (3). Prerequisite, admission to graduate program or permission of the chair. Considers theory and philosophy in the study
Sawyer 1 Kyra Sawyer Feminist/Gender Criticism Literary Theory & Writing Dr. Pennington 25 October 2013 Freeing a Songbird in the Strong of Arm of Patriarchy: Inklings of First Wave Feminism in Susan Glaspell
Adult Learning in the Digital Age. Information Technology and the Learning Society by Selwyn, N., Gorard, S. and Furlong, J. London: Routledge, 2006. Reviewed by Stephen Dobson Senior lecturer in Education
Humanities Department Telephone (541) 383-7520 FA 101: Introduction to Film Outcome 1: Will be able to identify and explain the different languages of filmmaking, including cinematography, editing, mise-en-scene
The Good Shepherd My family lived in a house on my grandfather s farm. My grandfather raised sheep. Many a morning I would awaken to the bleating of sheep in the field. Every spring we would go through
God s mission and our mission Leader Conference Mission in Denmark Kolding 21st March 2015 When the time had fully come, God sent his son, Deus misit filium suum born of a woman, born under law, to redeem
1 af 7 06-05-2010 23:43 Introduction Povl Kjøller's "Do you want to sing together?" In this session we are going to listen to a Danish song from the 1970s. "Cykelsangen", as it is known, was written and
Proceedings from the 2005 Sho Sato Conference in Honor of Takao Tanase Comments on Professor Takao Tanase s Invoking Law as Narrative: Lawyer s Ethics and the Discourse of Law Norman Spaulding Stanford
Göteborg university Department of Journalism and Mass Communication English summary of the dissertation: En tidning i tiden? Metro och den svenska dagstidningsmarknaden [A Paper for Its Time? Metro and
INTEGRATING GENDER INTO SUSTAINABLE TOURISM PROJECTS BY LUCY FERGUSON AND DANIELA MORENO ALARCÓN FOR EQUALITY IN TOURISM: CREATING CHANGE FOR WOMEN OCTOBER 2013 INTRODUCTION In recent years, a number of
Proposed Minor in Media Studies Department of Communication University of Utah The minor in Media Studies is designed to serve students who have interests and/or needs to develop enhanced knowledge related
1 Sample Student Essay and Prompt Directions for applicant: Imagine that you are teaching a class in academic writing for first-year college students. In your class, drafts are not graded. Instead, you
Standards Addressed by The Choices Program National Standards for the Social Studies National Standards for Social Studies are available online at cnets.iste.org/currstands. Strand I: Culture and Cultural
Devotion NT298 CHILDREN S DEVOTIONS FOR THE WEEK OF: LESSON TITLE: Paul s First Missionary Journey THEME: God has a calling on the lives of every one of His children! SCRIPTURE: Acts 12:25 13:52 Dear Parents
Religious education Programme of study (non-statutory) for key stage 3 and attainment targets (This is an extract from The National Curriculum 2007) Crown copyright 2007 Qualifications and Curriculum Authority
Table of Contents Executive Summary 1 Part I: What the Survey Found 4 Introduction: American Identity & Values 10 Year after September 11 th 4 Racial, Ethnic, & Religious Minorities in the U.S. 5 Strong
92 A Study of Anti-heroism: A Character Analysis of Holly Martins from the film The Third Man (1949) Yoshiya Nishi INTRODUCTION One of the ways to compare two cultures is to focus on the idea of heroism.
Learning outcomes Students will sharpen their analytical abilities Students will develop an understanding of the impact of the use of imagery Students will explore the treatment of controversial issues
Bridging the Common Law Civil Law Divide in Arbitration by SIEGFRIED H. ELSING * AND JOHN M. TOWNSEND * * INTERNATIONAL ARBITRATION has evolved as a system for resolving disputes among parties from different
Teaching about race and prejudice: key issues Teacher skill Expertise and appropriate teaching approaches can be built up within a team over time. Teaching about race and prejudice takes courage and practice!
2012 Anderson University School of Theology Dr. Gilbert Lozano, Associate Professor of Biblical Studies [ BIBLICAL RECONCILIATION AS GOD S ONE-ITEM AGENDA : BROAD REFLECTIONS ON THE DOCTRINE AND PRACTICE
REMARKS BY THE MINISTER OF SMALL BUSINESS DEVELOPMENT AT THE GALA DINNER HOSTED BY SBDI AS PART OF THE NATIONAL SMME POLICY COLLOQUIUM 21 October 2014 I am delighted to be speaking to you once again after
Abstract: Australian Values, Immigration and Identities Integrating or Belonging? Recent public debates about a migrant s right to live permanently in Australia have focused on the need to integrate into
controversial issues: guidance for schools Conflict and controversy is a fact of life In an age of mass media and electronic communication, children and young people are regularly exposed to the conflicts
Mission English 2 - Journalism Mitch Martin: email@example.com To educate students to be self-directed learners, collaborative workers, complex thinkers, quality producers, and community contributors
COMMUNICATION STUDIES Department Office: MUSIC 104 Phone (323) 343-4200 Fax (323) 343-6467 The Department of Communication Studies offers undergraduate programs leading to Bachelor of Arts degrees in TV,
RUSRR048 COURSE CATALOG DETAIL REPORT Page 1 of 16 CRM 100 Course ID 000650 Canadian Criminal Justice Introduction to Canadian Criminal Justice This course introduces students to the administrative and
A Partnership of the American Bar Foundation and the University of Illinois College of Law FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE Contact: Lucinda Underwood E-mail: firstname.lastname@example.org Phone: 312.988.6573 Fax: 312.988.6579
Student evaluation form Back Number of respondents: 17 1. Multiple choice question Percentage Name of course: [Insert name of course here!] Course Objectives: [Insert course objectives (målbeskrivelse)
Approaches to Apologetics By John McClean Matthias Media (The Briefing #119; www.matthiasmedia.com.au/briefing). Used with permission. A poverty stricken student reaches the end of her financial resources
Immigration: Australia s changing face By Megan Wood LEARNING AREAS: History EDUCATION LEVEL: 7-12 Since 1788 people have flocked to Australia from both near and far. We have a rich history of immigration,
ON EXTERNAL OBJECTS By Immanuel Kant From Critique of Pure Reason (1781) General Observations on The Transcendental Aesthetic To avoid all misapprehension, it is necessary to explain, as clearly as possible,
Media Studies / 6th 7th Grade MARY ENGLER HAGEN FYI I have set up these lessons/unit on media studies for a 6th or 7th grade class. I have not intended to make these lessons a surface study only of media,
0What do you think are the themes in Heart of Darkness? Heart of Darkness Themes Civilization vs. Savagery (Darkness in Man) 0 The book implies that civilizations are created by the setting of laws and
Immigration and the Next America Most Reverend José H. Gomez Archbishop of Los Angeles Rotary Club of Los Angeles Los Angeles, California January 10, 2013 My friends, I am honored to be here with you this
GOOD SAMARITAN The Good Samaritan 1 The Good Samaritan Lesson Text: Luke 10:25-37 INTRODUCTION: A. Luke 10:25-37 is known to Bible readers as the story of the Good Samaritan. Although the Bible never calls
Graz Declaration on Principles of Human Rights Education and Human Security 5 th Ministerial Meeting of the Human Security Network Graz, 8 10 May 2003 Preamble We, the Members of the Human Security Network
San José State University Writing Center www.sjsu.edu/writingcenter Written by Jacqueline Goodwin Personal Narrative Essays This handout will help you begin your personal narrative essay assignment with
Norwegian media: Free, but dependent How can the press be subsidized by the state, and still be free? Norway is tied with Iceland for first place on the 2007 Reporters Without Borders Press Freedom Index.
RUSRR048 COURSE CATALOG DETAIL REPORT Page 1 of 15 CRM 100 Course ID 000650 Canadian Criminal Justice Introduction to Canadian Criminal Justice This course introduces students to the administrative and
Table of Contents Part One: Social Studies Curriculum Chapter I: Social Studies Essay Questions and Prewriting Activities 1. Western Political Thought 1 2. The Age of Revolution 6 3. The Age of Napoleon
Nonprofit welfare and active citizenship in Scandinavia In Scandinavia welfare services are mainly funded by the public sector. However, there are increasing differences when it comes to who provides the
Arizona Supreme Court Judicial Ethics Advisory Committee ADVISORY OPINION 94-13 (September 20, 1994) Judicial Membership in a Junior League or a Boys Chorus Auxiliary Issue 1. May a judge be a member of
IN THE HIGH COURT OF SOUTH AFRICA (WESTERN CAPE HIGH COURT, CAPE TOWN) Case No. 6887/09 In the matter between: HELMAN KAGAN Applicant and RUTH KAGAN First Respondent LIBERTYLIFE GROUP LIMITED Second Respondent
DEFINITIONS AND KEY CONCEPTS Race: A social construct that artificially divides people into distinct groups based on characteristics, such as physical appearance (particularly color), ancestral heritage,
Group Members: Leslie-Ann Bolden, Michela Bowman, Sarah Kaufman, Danielle Jeanne Lindemann Selections from: The Marx-Engels Reader Karl Marx s broad theoretical and political agenda is based upon a conception
Debating the Church Street Bombing Christine Devine 11/15/12 HIST3377 The Church Street bombing was one of the more memorable attacks of many against the apartheid state that was carried out by UmKhonto
1/9 Locke 1: Critique of Innate Ideas This week we are going to begin looking at a new area by turning our attention to the work of John Locke, who is probably the most famous English philosopher of all
Boletín de Public la Asociación interest in de political Geógrafos philosophy. Españoles A necessary N.º 53-2010, ethical págs. and regulatory 381-386 concept for territorial planning I.S.S.N.: 0212-9426
Good Practice Briefing What does Imkaan mean by community engagement? Contents Introduction.. 3 References. 20 Resources... 20 2 Introduction ASCENT - Support services to organisations Ascent is a partnership
1 The Gospel & The Scholars William K. Lewis Fairmont Presbyterian Church College Ministry Team For most of us, our college days are a time in our lives centered around study, research, and learning. We
Social Imaginings: A Rhetorical Analysis of the text Alcoholics Anonymous Kevin Kardos Rhetoric Dr. David Franke Fall 2003 One could as well describe writing as an imagination of a relationship. -George
LINA AND HER NURSE. SUNDAY-SCHOOL UNI0 N, 200 MULBERRY-STREET, N. Y. LINA AND HER NURSE. SUNDAY-SCHOOL UNION, 200 MULBERRY-STREET, NEW YORK. LINA AND HER NURSE. L INA lived away in that land of the East
2013 Consumer Perspectives on Advertising summary Everyone has something to say about advertising. But what do Canadians really think? What do they find acceptable in advertising? What concerns them and
The modal verbs A modal verb can, may must, shall or will is an auxiliary it modifies the verb and expresses whether the action described is seen as plan, intention, necessity, possibility, prediction,
Azfar Bassir Developer at SHFT email@example.com Summary I consider myself as a positive, happy, energetic and responsible person. I love challenges because I always want to improve my skills. I am ambitious
Practice Test Civic Responsibilities in American Democracy -1- 1. Voting in American Democracy is legally a: A. Right B. Privilege C. Obligation D. Burden 2. What type of responsibility is voting? A. Civic
SOCIAL STUDIES MODERN WORLD HISTORY GRADE 9 Curriculum Map and Standards 2015-2016 Aligned with Ohio s Learning Standards for Social Studies and the Common Core State Standards for Literacy in History/Social
Turkey, Islamists and Democracy: Transition and Globalization in a Muslim State, by Yildiz Atasoy. London, UK and New York: I. B. Tauris, 2005.190pages. References to p. 214. Index to p. 227. $ In Turkey,
Burundi Development Partners Conference October 29-30 Geneva, Switzerland Session: Interventions by the Sponsors of the Conference Remarks by Philippe Dongier Country Director: Burundi, Tanzania, Uganda
The importance of Teaching History as a Compulsory Subject Until the lions have their own historians, the history of the hunt will always glorify the hunter Chinua Achebe (Things Fall Apart, 1958) These
DEFINITE AND INDEFINITE FORM In Norwegian, a noun can appear either in the indefinite form or in the definite form. There are some absolute rules that determine which form is correct, but three important
Communication Classes 100. Introduction to Communication and Rhetoric. (3h) Introduction to the theories, research, and analysis of verbal and nonverbal processes by which human beings share meanings and
J. T. M. Miller, Department of Philosophy, University of Durham 1 Methodological Issues for Interdisciplinary Research Much of the apparent difficulty of interdisciplinary research stems from the nature
Challenges in relation to assessment of prior learning Paper NERA, 2013 Work in progress Vibe Aarkrog, Associate professor Ph.D, firstname.lastname@example.org & Bjarne Wahlgren, professor, email@example.com, University of
MOVING MARRIAGE FORWARD BUILDING MAJORITY SUPPORT FOR MARRIAGE A REPORT FROM FREEDOM TO MARRY Our nation is engaged in a crucial conversation about why marriage matters. More than 100 million Americans
Interview Interview by Thomas Caron In your artistic practice you carry out in-depth research into the relationship between matter and void. Would you give us a brief explanation of this? It s true that
Student Handout #1: A Brief History of Canadian Citizenship Section One: Citizenship The concept of citizenship goes all the way back to ancient Greece. In the Greek city states, citizens were people who
INDEX OF TEMPLATES INTRODUCING WHAT THEY SAY A number of sociologists have recently suggested that X s work has several fundamental problems. It has become common today to dismiss X s contribution to the
Executive Doctorate in Higher Education Management Curriculum Guide The Executive Doctorate in Higher Education Management Program consists of six consecutive terms, starting with a late summer term and
BIBLE STUDY (Genesis 2:15-17; 3:1-18) What s This Passage All About? The book of Genesis is about beginnings the beginning of the world, the beginning of humankind, and the beginning of our relationship
THE DEPARTMENT OF SOCIAL AND BEHAVIORAL SCIENCES SOCIOLOGY PROGRAM HANDBOOK MAY 2015 Sociology The program requires a minimum of 120 semester hours for a Bachelor of Arts Degree in Sociology. This includes
Literature in the Romantic Age «Poetic visions» Poetry again becomes one of the most vital forms of literary expression The main characteristics of Romanticism are intensity and imagination. In the Romantic
Study program International Communication (120 ЕCTS) Faculty Cycle Languages, Cultures and Communications Postgraduate ECTS 120 Offered in Skopje Description of the program The International Communication
1 THE FEDERAL THEOLOGICAL SEMINARY OF SOUTHERN AFRICA An ecumenical witness to contextual theological education and ministerial formation during the Apartheid era The Federal Theological Seminary of Southern
Citizenship Programme of study for key stage 4 (This is an extract from The National Curriculum 2007) Crown copyright 2007 Qualifications and Curriculum Authority 2007 Curriculum aims Learning and undertaking
Case 1:08-cv-06957 Document 45 Filed 10/19/2009 Page 1 of 7 IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF ILLINOIS EASTERN DIVISION ROBERT F. CAVOTO, ) ) Plaintiff, Counter-Defendant,
FACULTY PROFESSOR(S) R. M. Myers, B.A. (Hons), M. A., Ph.D. (Toronto) ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR(S) D. A. Jackson, B.A. (Hons), M.A. (Toronto) ASSISTANT PROFESSOR(S) N. Cruickshank, B.A. (Hons), M.A. (Wilfrid
NO. COA13-614 NORTH CAROLINA COURT OF APPEALS Filed: 3 December 2013 STATE OF NORTH CAROLINA v. Buncombe County No. 11 CRS 59792 DANNY DALE GOSNELL 1. Homicide first-degree murder not guilty verdict jury
1 2 3 4 5 Specialized Knowledge Broad and Integrative Knowledge Intellectual Skills Applied and Collaborative Learning Civic and Global Learning The Degree Qualifications Profile (DQP) provides a baseline