Uzmanlık eğitiminde tez var mı? Dr. M. Umut Akyol TTB UDEK ATUB Temsilcisi

Transcription

1 Uzmanlık eğitiminde tez var mı? Dr. M. Umut Akyol TTB UDEK ATUB Temsilcisi

2 ATUB Is there a necessity to prepare a thesis (any kind) during or the end of medical specialist training in your country, specialty or section?

3 Bir çok ülkede cevap HAYIR Germany,, Netherlands, Austria, Malta, France, Greece, UK, Switzerland.

4 İsviçre Switzerland there used to be. At the moment some specialties ask for a publication in a Swiss or International medical journal.

5 BK UK not in Surgery, but in a small number of specialties a designated Master s program might be required and this would usually include a thesis, but this is unusual. For example a masters thesis for all trainees in nuclear medicine in the UK is recommended but, It is not presently an absolute requirement.

6 BK After the first 2-3 years of training in most specialties including general practice, there is some sort of exam eg the MRCP(UK) for medical specialties. In later postgraduate training, and depending on the specialty, there may be further designated Diplomas and/or specialist certificate examinations to pass, together with different components of continuous assessment of competencies throughout training, but no thesis.

7 Hırvatistan In Croatia, in all specialty training programmes a designated master s programme is required as an obligatory part of the education. Master's programme may end with a master thesis if the trainees opt to write and defend the thesis and obtain the master's diploma. This is, however, not a PhD thesis, which is the result of a performed research within a separate PhD study. All specialty training programmes include the obligatory final examination.

8 Bazı ülkelerde cevap EVET Italy (At the end of the specialisation the trainee prepares a thesis, which is then discussed during a public debate in front of a Commission composed by the Director of the Specialisation School and four members of the Faculty. Turkey (similar but no public debate), Lithuania, Slovenia, Croatia

9 Toplum Sağlığı I am adding the data for the trainees in occupational medicine - yes, they need to prepare a thesis but not as demanding as PhD but of very similar structure. They need to use the knowledge of statistics, epidemiology, collect references and learn to achieve a critical view on the data.

10 Bazı ülkelerde mecburi bir tez olmamasına rağmen bir cins master tezi hazırlanması, ve/veya bir bilimsel projenin ulusal veya uluslar arası bir yazı/bildiri halinde sunulacak şekilde yürütülüp sonlandırılması beklenmekte. Swedan, Belgium, Israel

11 İsveç In Sweden you don't have to write a thesis to become a specialist but you have to perform "an individual project according to scientific principles". This can be a scientific paper, a presentation at a national or intenational meeting or something similar. A thesis in Sweden is four year of full time research which is then presented and defended at a public dissertation. I successful you get the academic degree Doctor of medical Science.

12 Belçika Not a thesis, but yes and obligatory for everyone, a master thesis, at the level of publication in a peer reviewed journal. This written contribution should be started at the latest in the period of the last two years of clinical specialist training. ( Conform the Bologna rulings : Ba Ba Ma Ma )

13 Hollanda In order to become a medical specialist afterwards a thesis is not necessary. However, my people in the Netherlands enrolled in a PhD programme before or in order to start a specialist training afterwards.

14 İsrail a kind of thesis presenting the results, at the end of a 6 months Basic Sciences (research) rotation.

15 But none of these so called thesis is similar or equivalent to a PhD thesis in any country or specialty.