A Cost Effective Approach to Better Estimating Tourism s Regional Economic Contribution Presented by: Marion Joppe School of Hospitality, Food & Tourism Management
Province of Ontario and RTO4
Background Ontario s Tourism Competitiveness Strategy calls for Strategic investment Maximizing return on investment (ROI) 13 Regional Tourism Organizations (RTOs) Monitoring and benchmarking progress against performance measurements Province s Tourism Regional Economic Impact Model (TREIM)
TREIM A multi-region input-output model with 49 Census Divisions, 14 Census Metropolitan Areas / Census Agglomerations, 13 Travel Regions, and The entire province. TREIM produces estimates of: Direct, Indirect and Induced impacts of tourismrelated activities on GDP, Labour Income and Employment Direct and Total impacts of tourism-related activities on Federal, Provincial and Municipal Tax Revenues.
TREIM s shortcoming Visitor spending comes from 1. Travel Survey of Residents of Canada (TSRC) (sub-set of the Labour Force Survey) 2. International Travel Survey (ITS). Both are voluntary surveys Both require imputation of trip expenditures and trips. Spending allocated on per night/main destination basis Distortion in values assigned to some regions, particularly those more rural or more remote
RTO4 One of 13 Ontario Regional Tourism Organizations Established in 2010 Population of 800,000 people - 6,600 km 2 Best known: Stratford Shakespearean Festival St. Jacobs village and market Amish sub-culture To coordinate the diverse interests of the tourism industry to build and support a competitive tourism region through marketing and destination management
Objective 1. To challenge accuracy of projected final demand for its region 2. Search for way that final demand can be calculated from the ground up cost effectively
Meridian Reservation Systems E-marketing and online booking capabilities Accommodation Attractions Events Metrics produced by the system provide data for ongoing monitoring of progress Conversion rate ROI indicators
Methodology 3 data sources for triangulation: 1. Web traffic to individual portals portals for RTO4, the counties and Stratford total RTO4 website visitors into the reservation system website sales conversion rate = 10% 2. Meridian Reservation Systems booking information Total number of nights sold by origin per night spending total number of visitors = total number of room nights sold x av. party size x room nights sold proportions by origin used to weight the data
3. Survey data from bookers RTO4 sub-licenses Reservation System to accommodations, attractions, events On-line survey sent to individuals who booked via system to obtain trip characteristics and spending Target of 200 surveys per segment (Ontario, Rest of Canada, Foreign) Participating operators asked to provide occupancy and revenue data at end of season Very low response rate by operators Smith Travel Accommodations Report (STAR) RTO4 s share of the overall supply used to determine revenue generated in region
Data Analysis 805 surveys returned = 24.04% response rate 679 usable surveys for analysis Regrouped Ontario + rest of Canada = Canada Foreign (US) = 32% of respondents Profile: 60% women skewed to higher education, esp. for US Almost exclusively pleasure travel (>90%) vast majority travelled by car very high % of prior experience with region planning to return length of stay: Canada 1.48 / US 2.03 nights
Expenditures based on survey booking data Accommodation $ data from the survey booking $ from reservation system actual reservation data + share of expenditures by category as determined by survey = total expenditure When total expenditure is input into TREIM model, results are significantly different by category
Hotel performance STAR report RTO4 has 83 hotels, motels and inns ranging from 10 to 202 rooms = 5821 Represents 30.3% of accommodation base in SW Ontario. Same share of revenues by month = $37,286,500 for 2013
Expenditures based on regional hotel data Shares of the spending categories determined by reservation system using the hotel revenues derived for RTO4 from STAR report When inputting total spending into TREIM: accommodation, recreation & entertainment = underestimated. Transportation, food & beverage, other (retail) expenses = overestimated
Conclusion Regions are unique In RTO4, theatre is a major attraction higher than average entertainment expenditures Not fully captured by macro statistics In rural destinations, local transport, food and beverage prices may be much less than in urban centers Economic impact models are built using macro level statistics and thus do not adequately reflect local realities.
Questions Budget: $10,000 (including survey development and testing) Repeat in 2-3 years: $5,000