VHCC - Legal Aid Agency Clinical Negligence Funding Checklist April 2013 v1 Version: Issue date: Last review date: Owned by: 1 01.04.2013 01.04.2013 Special Cases Unit
Version History Version: Date Reason 1 01.04.2013 First release - Legal Aid Reform and transition to Legal Aid Agency Contents 1. Overview 2. Scope 3. Investigative Help (Stage 1) 4. Issue of Proceedings Mutual Exchange (Stage 2) 5. Settlement (Stage 3) 6. Trial Full Trial or Liability only (Stage 4) 7. Quantum Investigations (Stage 5) 8. Quantum Trial (Stage 6) 1 April 2013 VHCC - Legal Aid Agency Clinical Negligence Funding Checklist April 2013 v1 Page 2
1. Overview From 1 April 2013 this is the Legal Aid Agency s Clinical Negligence Funding checklist. For Experts rates please refer to www.justice.gov.uk/legal-aid/newslatest-updates/legal-aid-reform 2. Scope Below are the proposed costs limitations/contract prices to cover all work in a publicly funded clinical negligence case. If the likely final costs exceed 25,000 a Very High Cost Case contract will be entered into when the certificate is first amended. The VHCC contract terms are unaffected by the Funding Checklist. These staged sums represent the maximum likely to be authorised and payable by the Legal Aid Agency if the case is unsuccessful. These sums can be revised downwards if necessary to keep cases within The Civil Legal Aid (Merits Criteria) Regulations 2012 cost/benefit ratios: (1:4 for cases with 50-60% prospects, 1:2 for cases with 60-80% prospects, 1:1 for cases with 80%+ prospects) The stages are: 1 - The Investigative Stage, 2 - Issue of Proceedings to Mutual Exchange, 3 - Settlement, 4 Trial, 5 - Quantum Investigations, 6 - Quantum Trial Hourly rates (1 st 25,000) Solicitor - 108 ph (this includes enhancement), QC (in High Court) - 180 ph, Senior Junior acting alone - 135 ph, Led Junior Counsel - 112.50 ph, Medical experts - the rates that will be authorised for the most commonly sought experts are in The Civil Legal Aid (Remuneration) Regulations 2013. (Form CIVAPP8A must be completed if you are seeking a higher rate for an expert) Hourly rates (post 25,000) Solicitor - 70 ph, Senior Counsel 90 ph, Junior Counsel 50 ph Simplified claims for payment Where you have agreed costs limits with the Legal Aid Agency using the Funding Checklist please submit the following: Claim 1 This Funding Checklist Time recording sheets for each stage Counsel s fee notes Disbursement vouchers 1 April 2013 VHCC - Legal Aid Agency Clinical Negligence Funding Checklist April 2013 v1 Page 3
If the Checklist is answered in full and the costs limitations agreed there is no need to provide a separate case plan or detailed costs schedule. 3. Investigative Help (Stage 1) Includes attendance on client, medical records, client statement(s), instructing experts, considering reports, supplementary questions to experts, instructing counsel, conference(s) with counsel and experts, protocol letter and response. 1 expert - 4,500 2 experts - 6,750 3 experts - 9,000-13,500 4 experts - 13,500-18,000 5/6 experts (+ MRI) - 20,250-22,500 For authorisation of the above sums please answer the following: a) Please provide a brief statement (in addition to any client statement) including date of injury, date of knowledge, nature of injury, prognosis (if known), likely particulars of negligence. Please ensure you have addressed the funding requirement that the NHS complaints procedure is followed unless clearly inappropriate. b) Are there any additional risk factors e.g. limitation, multiple defendants, client credibility (client evidence conflicts with medical records)? c) List all medical experts likely to be instructed before proceedings are issued and in relation to each: Discipline of expert (and name if known) Medical issue the expert will address Proposed order of instruction Approximate timetable for instruction and receipt of report d) Have there been any informal or informal admissions (e.g. through the Complaints procedure)? e) An estimate of costs: (if any) To conclude investigative stage (Stage 1) To conclude settlement To conclude trial f) Is a split trial likely to be appropriate? Please give brief reason. (In a case where numerous quantum experts are required the assumption will be that funding is provided on the basis of a split trial unless liability/causation is conceded or a realistic offer of settlement has been made) g) An estimated date for pre-issue conference with counsel and expert 1 April 2013 VHCC - Legal Aid Agency Clinical Negligence Funding Checklist April 2013 v1 Page 4
h) An estimated date for final hearing i) An estimate of general and special damages, specifying likely heads of damage. A broad estimate is acceptable if quantum is complex or the prognosis unclear. j) The assumption at this stage is that prospects are unclear. Please confirm. 4. Issue of Proceedings Mutual Exchange (Stage 2) Includes issue/service, allocation questionnaire, CMC, considering Defence, experts consideration of defence/revision of reports, exchanging statements and reports, Part 35, conference with counsel and experts. There is an assumption that Leading Counsel may be involved in a 4/5 expert case. I expert - 6,750 2 experts - 9,000 3 experts - 10,750-13,500 4 experts - 14,25000-16,750 5 experts - 16,750-19,000 For authorisation of the above sums please answer the following: a) Please provide a brief updated report on case including particulars of negligence, causation, injury and prognosis, defendant s response to letter of claim, any formal or informal admissions. Are there any additional risk factors e.g. limitation, multiple Defendants, client credibility? b) List all medical reports obtained and in relation to each: Discipline of expert and name Medical issue addressed Specific conclusion of each expert c) Is a split trial likely to be appropriate? Please give brief reason. (In a case where numerous quantum experts are required the assumption will be that funding is provided on the basis of a split trial unless liability/causation is conceded or a realistic offer of settlement has been made) d) An estimate of costs: To conclude mutual exchange (Stage 2) To settlement. To trial e) An estimate of general and special damages specifying heads of damage. A broad estimate is acceptable if quantum is very complex or the prognosis unclear. 1 April 2013 VHCC - Legal Aid Agency Clinical Negligence Funding Checklist April 2013 v1 Page 5
f) Prospects of success in percentage terms g) Likelihood of settlement h) Estimated date of final hearing i) Please submit copies of all reports, Notes of Conference or Counsel s Advice and Defendant s letter of response. 5. Settlement (Stage 3) Includes considering quantum reports (preliminary quantum reports if the case is proceeding by way of split trial), instructing experts for meetings and revision of reports, making Part 36 offer, considering response, settlement meeting/negotiations. I expert - 6,750 2 experts - 6,750-9,500 3 experts - 12,000-14,250 4 experts - 19,000 5 experts - 21,750 For authorisation of the above sums please answer the following: a) Please provide a brief updated report on case including a brief summary of the defence theory, any formal or informal admissions and any other risk factors. b) Is the case proceeding by way of a split trial? c) Prospects of success (if case does not settle) in percentage terms. d) An estimate of costs: To settlement (stage 3) To trial e) An estimate of general and special damages f) Please submit copy of Notes of Conference or Counsel s written Advice 1 April 2013 VHCC - Legal Aid Agency Clinical Negligence Funding Checklist April 2013 v1 Page 6
6. Trial Full Trial or Liability only (Stage 4) Includes PTR, finalising statements, conference, trial bundle, trial preparation, and attendance at trial. There is an assumption that in a 4/5 expert case, Leading Counsel may be involved and that a 5-day trial is likely. 1 expert - 6,750-9,500 2 experts 12,000-14,250 3 experts - 19,000-28,500 4 experts - 35,750 5 experts - 40,000 For authorisation of the above sums please answer the following: a) Please provide a brief updated report on case including a summary of key issues in dispute, any admissions, outcome of any settlement negotiations including details of offers made/rejected and any other risk factors. b) List all medical experts to attend trial and in relation to each: Discipline and name Issue they will address Specific conclusion of each expert Summary of defendant s expert s view. i. Prospects of success in percentage terms. ii. iii. iv. An estimate of costs: To conclude trial (stage 4) To conclude quantum trial if appropriate An estimate of general and special damages. Defendant s valuation of claim v. Prospects of beating any Part 36 offer and advice to client vi. Please submit copies of joint expert reports and Notes of Conference or written Advice. 7. Quantum Investigations (Stage 5) Includes instructing experts, considering reports and defendant s reports, revision of reports, schedule of loss, indexation issues, conference, and settlement negotiations. 1 April 2013 VHCC - Legal Aid Agency Clinical Negligence Funding Checklist April 2013 v1 Page 7
8-10 quantum expert case - 34,000 For authorisation of the above sum please answer the following: a) Please specify number and disciplines of experts b) Please detail any offers to settle and response c) An estimate of costs To conclude quantum investigations (stage 5) To conclude the quantum trial 8. Quantum Trial (Stage 6) Includes PTR, finalising witness statements, conference, trial bundle, trial preparation, attend trial. 8-10 quantum expert case and 5 day trial - 41,000 For authorisation of the above sum please answer the following: a) Please specify number and disciplines of experts attending trial b) Please detail any offers to settle and response and likelihood of beating any Part 36 offer c) An estimate of costs: To conclude quantum trial (stage 6) d) Please submit claimant and defendant schedules of loss Please note that the Legal Aid Agency is likely to authorise a maximum of 178,250 in total for a fully contested cerebral palsy case (split trial) with 5 liability and 10 quantum experts where all 6 stages are completed. End of Document 1 April 2013 VHCC - Legal Aid Agency Clinical Negligence Funding Checklist April 2013 v1 Page 8