Tracker Plus BREEAM / Comparison Report Low Energy Building Design Created by Group E, 01 May
1.0 Introduction to the Tracker Plus BREEAM / Comparator The Tracker Plus BREEAM / comparator tool has been produced to assist assessors and design teams in evaluating the impact of assessing their project under the new BREEAM scheme rather than the current BREEAM scheme. Questions this tool aims to answer are: 1) What should my BREEAM design / specification under BREEAM? 2) What additional BREEAM credits will we need to achieve to attain our target rating under BREEAM? In order to generate the likely s under BREEAM the user must undertake the following: 1) Select the appropriate building type (eg ice) and other relevant features (eg location type (Other Buildings only), presence of lifts, irrigation systems etc). This sets the appropriate credit list. 2) Select the credits targeted / assumed achievable under BREEAM. This information is used to calculate the equivalent BREEAM. 3) Select any additional credits that may be targeted / assumed achievable under BREEAM in order to attain the desired BREEAM. Comparator Results Project name Building details User defined BREEAM 97.93 Calculated equivalent BREEAM 88.11 Final BREEAM 96.38 Report downloaded by Company name Low Energy Building Design ice Type Lifts / escalators present: Yes Non-regulated water use present: No Group E Group E Download date 01 May BREEAM Rating Score Pass < 25% Good 40-55% Very Good 55-70% Excellent 70-85% Outstanding > 85% The assumptions made in this calculator are generally conservative and are stated in the comments in Section 5.0 for information. As such the 'equivalent BREEAM ' should be considered the lowest that the building is likely to achieve under the new version of BREEAM. It should also be noted that that the comparator does not include a minimum standards check and so the user should ensure that they check the minimum required s have been achieved in order to achieve the target rating regardless of overall. Produced by Tracker Plus: www.tracker-plus.co.uk 1
2.0 BREEAM New Construction Draft guidance for BREEAM New Construction scheme was released on 10th February. The draft technical manual can be downloaded from the BREEAM website at: http://www.breeam.org/page.jsp?id=676 A summary of the key changes between the and version of BREEAM is available on the Tracker Plus blog at: http://blog.tracker-plus.co.uk/?p=133 The new () scheme is scheduled to go live on 27th May and registrations for the current () version of BREEAM will close on 30th June. 3.0 About Tracker Plus This report has been produced by Tracker Plus, a comprehensive, end-to-end management system for BREEAM assessments. Tracker Plus BREEAM provides a complete assessment project management and submission environment for use by project teams working together to achieve BREEAM certification. The first software product to receive a 'BREEAM Badge of Recognition', Tracker Plus brings major time savings by effectively administering assessments while ensuring that team members have access to all of the information on credit requirements and evidence that should be submitted. Once all the required information has been collected and checked by the assessor, submissions can be made directly to the BRE for certification. For more information on Tracker Plus go to: http://tracker-plus.co.uk 4.0 Disclaimer & copyright The scoring contained within this comparison tool is based on a preliminary appraisal of the draft BREEAM manual released by BRE on 10th February and without access to the BREEAM Scoring & Reporting tool. As such neither Tracker Plus nor Southfacing Services Ltd (the owners of Tracker Plus) accept any liability for the accuracy of the scoring comparison or this output report and the comparator tool should be used for indicative pupose only. Users should be aware that copyright exists on the BREEAM logo and this may not be used or reproduced for any purpose without the prior written consent of the BRE. The BREEAM name and logo are registered trademarks of the Building Research Establishment Ltd. The Tracker Plus name and logo are registered trademarks of Southfacing Services Ltd. Produced by Tracker Plus: www.tracker-plus.co.uk 2
5.0 BREEAM / credit scoring The table below summarises the predicted BREEAM scoring based on BREEAM input data and additional targeted BREEAM credits targeted by the user. BREEAM issues with minimum standard requirements are shown in blue and it is the user's responsibility to check that the minimum standards required for the specified BREEAM rating are achievable. BREEAM BREEAM Management 1 - Project brief/decision making (roles, responsibility & training) 1 1 Man 01 - Project brief and design 1 - Stakeholder consultation (project delivery) 1 1 1 The requirement of this credit now goes slightly beyond BREEAM Man 01 (1st in that there is a requirement to demonstrate how the consultation process influenced the project brief. However, for the purposes of the comparator, it is felt likely that this would be achieved if the appropriate consultation has been undertaken. 2 - BREEAM AP (RIBA Stage B appointment) 1 1 Man 01 - Project brief and design 2 - Stakeholder consultation (third party) 1 1 1 Slightly simplified version of BREEAM Man 04 (1st 3 - BREEAM AP (to RIBA Stage E) 1 1 Man 01 - Project brief and design 3 - Sustainability Champion (design) 1 1 1 As BREEAM Man 01 (2nd 4 - BREEAM AP (to RIBA Stage L) 1 1 Man 01 - Project brief and design 4 - Sustainability Champion (monitoring progress) 1 1 1 As BREEAM Man 01 (3rd 5 - Thermographic survey 1 1 Man 02 - Life cycle cost and service life planning 1 - Elemental life cycle cost (LCC) 1 1 2 Broadly as BREEAM Man 05 (1st - RIBA stages updated to new Plan of Work Stage 2 6 - Design/construction commissioning 1 1 Man 02 - Life cycle cost and service life planning 7 - Seasonal commissioning 1 1 Man 02 - Life cycle cost and service life planning 2 - Component level LCC plan 1 1 1 Broadly as BREEAM Man 05 (2nd - RIBA stages updated to new Plan of Work Stage 4 3 - Capital cost reporting 0 0 1 New credit for provision of capital cost information on project. 8 - Data collection & aftercare support 1 1 Man 03 - Responsible construction practices 1 - Environmental management 0 1 1 Requirements of BREEAM Man 03 (4th & 5th credits) merged Man 02 - Responsible Construction Practices 1 - Considerate Constructors Scheme (or equivalent) 2 2 Man 03 - Responsible construction practices 2 - Sustainability Champion (construction) 1 1 1 As BREEAM Man 01 (4th Man 03 - Construction Site Impacts 1 - Energy consumption 1 1 Man 03 - Responsible construction practices 3 - Considerate construction 2 2 2 As BREEAM Man 02 Produced by Tracker Plus: www.tracker-plus.co.uk 3
Man 03 - Construction Site Impacts 2 - Water consumption 1 1 Man 03 - Responsible construction practices 4 - Monitoring of construction site impacts - Utility consumption 0 1 1 As BREEAM Man 03 (1st credit & 2nd credits) Man 03 - Construction Site Impacts 3 - Transport of construction materials and waste 1 1 Man 03 - Responsible construction practices 5 - Monitoring of construction site impacts - Transport of construction materials and waste 1 1 1 As BREEAM Man 03 (3rd Man 03 - Construction Site Impacts 4 - Timber procurement 1 1 Man 04 - Commissioning and handover 1 - Commissioning schedule and responsibilities 0 1 1 Part of BREEAM Man 01 (6th Man 03 - Construction Site Impacts 5 - Construction site management 1 1 Man 04 - Commissioning and handover 2 - Commissioning building services 0 1 1 Part of BREEAM Man 01 (6th Man 04 - Stakeholder Participation 1 - Consultation 1 1 Man 04 - Commissioning and handover 3 - Commissioning building fabric 1 1 1 As BREEAM Man 01 (5th Man 04 - Stakeholder Participation 2 - Inclusive & accessible design 1 1 Man 04 - Commissioning and handover 4 - Handover 0 1 1 Requirements of BREEAM Man 04 (3rd and requirement 3 from Man 01 (1st merged. Man 04 - Stakeholder Participation 3 - Building user information 1 1 Man 05 - Aftercare 1 - Aftercare support 1 1 1 As BREEAM Man 01 (8th Man 04 - Stakeholder Participation Man 05 - Life Cycle Cost and Service Life Planning Man 05 - Life Cycle Cost and Service Life Planning Man 05 - Life Cycle Cost and Service Life Planning 4 - Post Occupancy Evaluation (POE) and information dissemination 1 - Life Cycle Cost analysis (RIBA Stage C/D) 2 - Life Cycle Cost analysis (component options) 3 - Life Cycle Cost analysis (RIBA Stage D/E) 1 1 Man 05 - Aftercare 2 - Seasonal commissioning 1 1 1 As BREEAM Man 01 (7th 1 1 Man 05 - Aftercare 3 - Post occupancy evaluation 1 1 1 As BREEAM Man 04 (4th 1 1 As BREEAM Man 04 (4th 1 1 As BREEAM Man 04 (4th Total 22 22 Total 19 19 21 Score 12 12 Score 10.86 10.86 12 Health & Wellbeing Hea 01 - Visual Comfort 1 - Daylighting 1 1 Hea 01 - Visual Comfort 1 - Glare control 0 1 1 New credit just for glare control Hea 01 - Visual Comfort 2 - Glare control & view out 1 1 Hea 01 - Visual Comfort 2 - Daylighting 1 1 1 Broadly as BREEAM Hea 01 (1st Hea 01 - Visual Comfort 3 - Internal & external lighting 1 1 Hea 01 - Visual Comfort 3 - View out 0 1 1 New credit just for view out (95% of floor area needs to comply) Produced by Tracker Plus: www.tracker-plus.co.uk 4
Hea 02 - Indoor Air Quality 1 - Indoor air quality 1 1 Hea 01 - Visual Comfort 4 - Internal and external lighting levels, zoning and control 1 1 1 Broadly as BREEAM Hea 01 (3rd Hea 02 - Indoor Air Quality Hea 02 - Indoor Air Quality 2 - Volatile Organic Compounds (Finishes) 3 - Formaldehyde & Volatile Organic Compound testing 1 1 Hea 02 - Indoor Air Quality 1 - Indoor air quality (IAQ) plan 0 1 1 As requirement 1 from BREEAM Hea 02 (1st 1 1 Hea 02 - Indoor Air Quality 2 - Ventilation 0 1 1 Broadly as requirements 2-5 from BREEAM Hea 02 (1st Hea 02 - Indoor Air Quality 4 - Potential for natural ventilation 0 1 Hea 02 - Indoor Air Quality 3 - Volatile organic compound (VOC) emission levels (products) Hea 03 - Thermal Comfort 1 - Thermal modelling 1 1 Hea 02 - Indoor Air Quality 4 - Volatile organic compound (VOC) emission levels (post construction) Hea 03 - Thermal Comfort 2 - Thermal zoning & control 1 1 Hea 02 - Indoor Air Quality 5 - Potential for natural ventilation 1 1 1 As BREEAM Hea 02 (2nd 1 1 1 As BREEAM Hea 02 (3rd 0 0 1 As BREEAM Hea 02 (4th Hea 04 - Water Quality 1 - Prevention of legionella & provision of fresh drinking water 1 1 Hea 04 - Thermal comfort 1 - Thermal modelling 1 1 1 Broadly as BREEAM Hea 03 (1st Hea 05 - Acoustic Performance Hea 06 - Safety and Security 1 - Internal acoustic performance 1 2 Hea 04 - Thermal comfort 2 - Adaptability - for a projected climate change scenario 1 - Safe access 1 1 Hea 04 - Thermal comfort 3 - Thermal zoning and controls 0 1 1 New credit for carrying out thermal comfort analysis for a projected climate change scenario 1 1 1 As BREEAM Hea 03 (2nd Hea 06 - Safety and Security 2 - Security of site & building 1 1 Hea 05 - Acoustic Performance 1 - Acoustic performance 1 2 3 Broadly as BREEAM Hea 05 Hea 06 - Safety and Security 1 - Safe access 1 1 1 As BREEAM Hea 06 (1st Hea 06 - Safety and Security 2 - Security of site and building 1 1 1 Broadly as BREEAM Hea 06 (2nd Total 12 14 Total 13 15 17 Score 12.86 15 Score 11.47 13.24 15 Energy Ene 01 - Reduction of CO2 Emissions 1 - Reduction of CO2 emissions 12 15 Ene 01 - Reduction of energy use and carbon emissions 1 - Energy performance 9 9 12 Number of credits for this issue reduced from 15 to 12 and minimum standards for Excellent & Outstanding changed (although EPRnc levels for these thresholds are broadly the same). Produced by Tracker Plus: www.tracker-plus.co.uk 5
Ene 02 - Energy Monitoring 1 - Sub-metering of major energy consuming systems 1 1 Ene 02 - Energy Monitoring 1 - Sub-metering of major energy consuming systems 1 1 1 List of previous equipment to be metered in BREEAM Ene 02 (1st replaced by requirement to meter 90% of energy demand Ene 02 - Energy Monitoring 2 - Sub-metering of tenancy/function areas 1 1 Ene 02 - Energy Monitoring 2 - Sub-metering of high energy load and tenancy areas 1 1 1 As BREEAM Ene 02 (2nd Ene 03 - External Lighting 1 - External lighting & controls 1 1 Ene 03 - External Lighting 1 - External lighting 1 1 1 Slightly simplified version of BREEAM Ene 03 Ene 04 - Low and Zero Carbon Technologies 1 - LZC feasibility study (or renewable energy supply contract) 1 1 Ene 04 - Low carbon design 1 - Passive design - Passive design analysis 0 1 1 New credit for passive design analysis and use of passive design measures to reduce energy demand Ene 04 - Low and Zero Carbon Technologies 2 - Enhanced feasibility study (including LCA) AND LZC technology specification & installation 3 3 Ene 04 - Low carbon design 2 - Passive design - Free cooling 0 0 1 Broadly as Ene 04 (free cooling but must achieve new passive deign credit first. Ene 04 - Low and Zero Carbon Technologies 3 - Free cooling 0 1 Ene 04 - Low carbon design 3 - Low and zero carbon technologies - LZC feasibility study 1 1 1 As BREEAM Ene 04 (1st Ene 06 - Energy Efficient Transportation Systems 1 - Transportation demand/usage & energy consumption analysis 1 1 Ene 05 - Energy Efficient Cold Storage 1 - Refrigeration energy consumption 0 0 1 Ene 06 - Energy Efficient Transportation Systems 2 - Energy efficient features 1 1 Ene 05 - Energy Efficient Cold Storage 2 - Indirect greenhouse gas emissions 0 0 1 Ene 08 - Energy Efficient Equipment 1 - Energy efficient equipment 2 2 Ene 06 - Energy Efficient Transportation Systems Ene 06 - Energy Efficient Transportation Systems Ene 06 - Energy Efficient Transportation Systems Ene 08 - Energy Efficient Equipment 1 - Energy consumption 1 1 1 As BREEAM Ene 06 (1st 2 - Energy efficient features 0 1 1 As BREEAM Ene 06 (2nd but excluding requirement 3d 3 - Regenerative drives 0 1 1 As requirement 3d of BREEAM Ene 06 (2nd 1 - Energy efficient equipment 2 2 2 As BREEAM Ene 08 Total 23 27 Total 18 19 25 Score 16.19 19 Score 10.8 11.4 15 Transport Tra 01 - Public Transport Accessibility 1 - Accessibility index 3 3 Tra 01 - Public Transport Accessibility 1 - Public transport accessibility 3 3 3 As BREEAM Tra 01 Tra 02 - Proximity to Amenities 1 - Proximity to amenities 1 1 Tra 02 - Proximity to amenities 1 - Proximity to local amenities 1 1 1 Building Type definitions have been slightly revised Produced by Tracker Plus: www.tracker-plus.co.uk 6
Tra 03 - Cyclist Facilities 1 - Cyclist facilities 2 2 Tra 03 - Cyclist facilities 1 - Cycle storage 0 1 1 Broadly as BREEAM Tra 03 (1st Tra 04 - Maximum Car Parking Capacity 1 - Maximum car parking capacity 2 2 Tra 03 - Cyclist facilities 2 - Cyclist facilities 0 1 1 Broadly as BREEAM Tra 03 (2nd Tra 05 - Travel Plan 1 - Travel plan 1 1 Tra 04 - Maximum Car Parking Capacity 1 - Maximum car parking capacity 2 2 2 As BREEAM Tra 04 Tra 05 - Travel Plan 1 - Travel plan 1 1 1 Broadly as BREEAM Tra 05 Total 9 9 Total 9 9 9 Score 8 8 Score 9 9 9 Water Wat 01 - Water Consumption 1 - Water consumption 5 5 Wat 01 - Water Consumption 1 - Water consumption 5 5 5 As BREEAM Wat 01 Wat 02 - Water Monitoring 1 - Water metering & sub-metering 1 1 Wat 02 - Water Monitoring 1 - Water monitoring 1 1 1 As BREEAM Wat 02 Wat 03 - Leak Detection 1 - Major leak detection 1 1 Wat 03 - Leak Detection 1 - Leak detection system 1 1 1 As BREEAM Wat 03 (1st Wat 03 - Leak Detection 2 - Sanitary supply shut off 1 1 Wat 03 - Leak Detection 2 - Flow control devices 1 1 1 Broadly as BREEAM Wat 03 (2nd Materials Total 8 8 Total 8 8 8 Score 6 6 Score 7 7 7 Mat 01 - Life Cycle Impacts 1 - Life cycle impact of main building elements 4 5 Mat 01 - Life Cycle Impacts 1 - Life cycle impacts 4 4 5 As BREEAM Mat 01 Mat 02 - Hard Landscaping and Boundary Protection 1 - Life cycle impact of hard landscaping & boundary protection 1 1 Mat 02 - Hard Landscaping and Boundary Protection 1 - Hard landscaping and boundary protection 1 1 1 As BREEAM Mat 02 Mat 03 - Responsible Sourcing of Materials 1 - Responsible sourcing of materials 1 3 Mat 03 - Responsible Sourcing of Materials 1 - Sustainable Plan 0 1 1 New credit for contractor use of a sustainable procurement plan to purchse construction materials Produced by Tracker Plus: www.tracker-plus.co.uk 7
Mat 04 - Insulation 1 - Green Guide rating & insulation index 1 1 Mat 03 - Responsible Sourcing of Materials 2 - Responsible sourcing of materials (RSM) 1 1 3 This credit now covers the responsible sourcing of insulation products removed from Mat 04. As the tier levels for the certification schemes within this credit are still out to consultation the potentail under BREEAM is taken to be as d under. Mat 04 - Insulation 2 - Responsible sourcing 1 1 Mat 04 - Insulation 1 - Embodied impact 1 1 1 For purposes of comparator from BREEAM Mat 04 (1st is copied across but be aware that requirements are now slightly more onerous. Insulation index must now be greater than 2.5 rather than 2 Mat 05 - Designing for Robustness 1 - Designing for robustness 1 1 Mat 05 - Designing for durability and resilience 1 - Protecting vulnerable parts of the building from damage & protecting exposed parts of the building from material degradation 1 1 1 For purposes of comparator from BREEAM Mat 05 is copied across but be aware that requirements are now slightly more onerous. Consideration must now also be given to limiting degradation of the building exterior from environmental factors. Mat 06 - Material efficiency 1 - Material efficiency 0 1 1 New credit for optimisation of materials use/efficiency Total 9 12 Total 8 10 13 Score 9.38 12.5 Score 8.31 10.38 13.5 Waste Wst 01 - Construction Waste Management 1 - SWMP & non-hazardous waste benchmarks 3 3 Wst 01 - Construction Waste Management 1 - Construction resource efficiency 3 3 3 As BREEAM Wst 01 (1st Wst 01 - Construction Waste Management 2 - Diversion of waste from landfill 1 1 Wst 01 - Construction Waste Management 3 - Diversion of resources from landfill 0 1 1 Wst 02 - Recycled Aggregates 1 - Recycled aggregates 1 1 Wst 02 - Recycled Aggregates 1 - Recycled aggregates 1 1 1 requirements now less onerous than BREEAM Wst 02. There is a reduction in % recycled volumes required for most element and 30km sourcing requirement now only applies to exemplary credit. Wst 03 - Operational Waste 1 - Recyclable/compostable waste storage and facilities 1 1 Wst 03 - Operational Waste 1 - Operational waste 1 1 1 Broadly as BREEAM Wst 03 Wst 04 - Speculative Floor and Ceiling Finishes 1 - Floor and ceiling finishes 1 1 Wst 04 - Speculative Floor and Ceiling Finishes 1 - Speculative floor and ceiling finishes 1 1 1 As BREEAM Wst 04 Produced by Tracker Plus: www.tracker-plus.co.uk 8
Wst 05 - Adaptation to climate change 1 - Adaptation to climate change structural and fabric resilience 0 1 1 New credit for including measures within the project that will mitigate impact of extreme weather arising from climate change. Wst 06 - Functional adaptability 1 - Functional adaptability 0 1 1 New credit to recognise measures taken to ensure the building Total 7 7 Total 6 9 9 Score 7.5 7.5 Score 5.67 8.5 8.5 Land Use & Ecology LE 01 - Site Selection 1 - Previously developed land 1 1 LE 01 - Site Selection 1 - Previously occupied land 1 1 1 Broadly as BREEAM LE 01 (1st LE 01 - Site Selection 2 - Contaminated land 0 1 LE 01 - Site Selection 2 - Contaminated land 0 0 1 As BREEAM LE 01 (2nd LE 02 - Ecological Value of Site and Protection of Ecological Features 1 - Ecological value of site & protection of features 1 1 LE 02 - Ecological Value of Site and Protection of Ecological Features 1 - Ecological value of site 0 1 1 New credit for LE 03 - Mitigating Ecological Impact 1 - Mitigating ecological impact 1 2 LE 02 - Ecological Value of Site and Protection of Ecological Features 2 - Protection of ecological features 0 1 1 New credit for LE 04 - Enhancing Site Ecology 1 - Ecological report & general enhancements 1 1 LE 03 - Minimising impact on existing site ecology 1 - Change in ecological value 1 1 2 As BREEAM LE 03 LE 04 - Enhancing Site Ecology LE 05 - Long Term Impact on Biodiversity 2 - Increase in site ecological value 1 2 LE 04 - Enhancing site ecology 1 - Long term impact on biodiversity 1 2 LE 04 - Enhancing site ecology 1 - Ecologist 1 1 1 As BREEAM LE 04 (1st 2 - Increase in ecological value 0 0 1 Now only 1 credit available for species enhancement of 6 or more (was worth 2 credits under BREEAM ) LE 05 - Long Term Impact on Biodiversity 1 - Long term impact on biodiversity 1 1 2 As BREEAM LE 05 Total 6 10 Total 6 6 10 Score 6 10 Score 6 6 10 Pollution Pol 01 - Impact of Refrigerants 1 - Refrigerant selection, leak detection & pump down 3 3 Pol 01 - Impact of Refrigerants 1 - Impact of refrigerants 3 3 3 Broadly as BREEAM Pol 01 Produced by Tracker Plus: www.tracker-plus.co.uk 9
Pol 02 - NOx Emissions 1 - NOx emissions (heating) 3 3 Pol 02 - NOx emissions 1 - NOx emission levels for heating and hot water 3 3 3 For purposes of comparator from BREEAM Pol 02 is copied across but be aware that requirements are now slightly more onerous. All thresholds now cover space heating and hot water. Pol 03 - Surface Water Run Pol 03 - Surface Water Run 1 - Flood risk 2 2 Pol 03 - Surface Water Run 2 - Surface water run-off 1 1 Pol 03 - Surface Water Run 1 - Flood risk 2 2 2 As BREEAM Pol 03 (1st 2 - Surface water run-off 0 2 2 As BREEAM Pol 03 (2nd & 3rd credits). Be aware that requirements are now slightly more onerous for drainage failure credit as there is now a requirement for the ongoing maintenance of SUDS Pol 03 - Surface Water Run 3 - Prevention of flooding 1 1 Pol 03 - Surface Water Run 3 - Minimising water course pollution 1 1 1 For purposes of comparator from BREEAM Pol 03 (4th is copied across but be aware that requirements are now slightly more onerous. There is now a requirement for the ongoing maintenance of SUDS Pol 03 - Surface Water Run 4 - Minimising watercourse pollution 1 1 Pol 04 - Reduction of Night Time Light Pollution 1 - Reduction of night time light pollution 1 1 1 As BREEAM Pol 04 Pol 04 - Reduction of Night Time Light Pollution 1 - Reduction of night time light pollution 1 1 Pol 05 - Noise Attenuation 1 - Reduction of noise pollution 1 1 1 As BREEAM Pol 05 Pol 05 - Noise Attenuation 1 - Noise attenuation 1 1 As BREEAM Pol 05 Total 13 13 Total 13 13 13 Score 10 10 Score 10 10 10 Innovation 1 - Consumption monitoring, targeting & feedback (3 years post occupation) 1 1 Man 03 - Responsible construction practices 1 - Considerate Construction: Exemplary performance 1 1 1 As BREEAM Inn (Man 02) Man 02 - Responsible Construction Practices 1 - Exemplary practice levels 1 1 Man 05 - Aftercare 1 - Aftercare / monitoring: 3 years 1 1 1 As BREEAM Inn (Man 01) Hea 01 - Visual Comfort 1 - Exemplary daylighting levels 1 1 Hea 01 - Visual Comfort 1 - Daylighting: Exemplary levels 1 1 1 Broadly as BREEAM Inn (Hea 01) but now two means of compliance Ene 01 - Reduction of CO2 Emissions 1 - Carbon neutral/negative operational energy consumption 3 5 Hea 02 - Indoor Air Quality 1 - VOC emissions (post construction): Exemplary levels 0 0 2 New credit for improvement in VOC emission levels (post construction) over and above standard credit Ene 04 - Low or Zero Carbon Technologies 1-30% reduction in CO2 emissions 1 1 Ene 01 - Reduction of energy use and carbon emissions 1 - Zero regulated carbon / carbon negative 3 3 5 As BREEAM Inn (Ene 01) Produced by Tracker Plus: www.tracker-plus.co.uk 10
Ene 05 - Cold Storage 1 - Specify Carbon Trust 0 1 Wat 01 - Water Consumption 1 - Water consumption: Exemplary levels 1 1 1 As BREEAM Inn (Wat 01) Wat 01 - Water Consumption 1-65% reduction in water consumption 1 1 Mat 01 - Life Cycle Impacts 1 - Green Guide to Specification (elemental approach) 0 0 1 As BREEAM Inn (Mat 01) first credit Mat 01 - Life Cycle Impacts 1 - Exemplary material life cycle impact 0 3 Mat 01 - Life Cycle Impacts 2 - Compliant Life Cycle Assessment software tools (Whole Building approach) 0 0 2 As BREEAM Inn (Mat 01) second two credits Mat 03 - Responsible Sourcing of Materials 1-70% of available responsible sourcing points achieved 0 1 Mat 03 - Responsible Sourcing of Materials 1 - Exemplary performance: Responsible sourcing 0 0 1 As the tier levels for the certification schemes within this credit are still out to consultation the potentail under BREEAM is taken to be as d under. Wst 01 - Construction Waste Management 1 - Exemplary performance for diversion of waste from landfill 1 1 Wst 01 - Construction Waste Management 1 - Resource efficiency / Diversion of waste from landfill: Exemplary performance 1 1 1 For purposes of comparator from BREEAM Inn (Wst 01) is copied across but be aware that requirements are now slightly more onerous. There is now a benchmark for diversion of excavation waste from landfill. Wst 02 - Recycled Aggregates 1 - Exemplary performance for specification of recycled aggregates 1 1 Wst 02 - Recycled Aggregates 1 - Recycled aggregates: Exemplary performance 1 1 1 requirements now less onerous than BREEAM Inn (Wst 02). Wst 02 - Recycled Aggregates 1 - Exemplary performance for specification of recycled aggregates 1 1 Wst 05 - Adaptation to climate change 1 - Responding to adaptation to climate change 0 1 1 New credit for achieving specified credits under credits Hea 03, Ene 01, Ene 04, Wat 01, Mat 05 & Pol 03 Pol 03 - Surface Water Run 1 - Surface water run off 1 1 AI - Approved Innovation 1 - Innovation application approved by BRE Global 0 0 1 AI - Approved Innovation 1 - BRE Global 0 1 Total 12 20 Total 9 10 19 Score 10 10 Score 9 10 10 Overall Scores: Score under : 97.93 : 88.11 Score under : 96.38 Produced by Tracker Plus: www.tracker-plus.co.uk 11