A Data Based Assessment of Research Doctorate Programs in the United States

A Data Based Assessment of Resear rch Doctorate Programs in the United States National Research Council Initial Analysis for University of California, Davis Graduat te Program in Cell & Developmental Biology

Table of Contents About the NRC Study... 1 UC Davis Coordination... 1 Rankings by Lead Dean... 2 S Rankings by Lead Dean... 2 R Rankings by Lead Dean... 3 Dimensional Measures... 4 Research Activity by Lead Dean... 4 Student Support & Outcomes by Lead Dean... 5 Diversity by Lead Dean... 6 Cell & Developmental Biology (GCDB)... 7 Distribution of Range of Rankings by Percentile within the NRC Field... Key to Distribution of Range of Rankings Tables... Distribution of Range of Rankings... Graphs of Program Rankings... All NRC Rankings, by Program... S Rankings by Field... 11 R Rankings by Field... 14 Dimensional Measures... 17 Research Activity by Field... 17 Student Support & Outcomes by Field... 20 Diversity by Field... NRC Tables... Dimensional Measures... 31 Page ii

About the NRC Study The National Research Council (NRC) has reported the results of its latest project to assess U.S. research doctorate programs. This is the most comprehensive survey of research doctorate programs in the United States. The NRC has reported data for 5000 programs at 2 different institutions across 62 fields of study. Each participating university provided data at an institutional level, at the program level and at the faculty level. Additionally, students in five selected fields were invited to complete questionnaires regarding their programs. The assessment offers data for each program on 20 characteristic variables: Publications per allocated faculty member Citations per publication Percent faculty with grants Percent faculty Interdisciplinary Percent non Asian minority faculty Percent female faculty Awards per allocated faculty Average GRE Q Percent 1st yr. students with full support Percent 1st yr. students with external funding Percent non Asian minority students Percent female students Percent international students Average PhDs 2002 to 2006 Percent completing within 6 years Time to degree Percent students in academic positions Student work space Health insurance Number of student activities offered The assessment also illustrates how the data can be used to rank the quality of programs based on the importance of particular characteristics to various users. It does not include an authoritative declaration of the 'best programs' in given fields, as the study committee concluded that no single such ranking can be produced in an unambiguous and rigorous way. Rather, to illustrate how the data can be used to assess and compare the quality of programs, the report offers five sets of rankings of programs in each field. These illustrative rankings should not be interpreted as definitive conclusions about the relative quality of doctoral programs, nor are they endorsed as such by the National Research Council. Rather, they demonstrate how the data can be used to rank programs based on the importance of particular characteristics to various users in this case, to faculty at participating institutions. The approach used to generate the illustrative rankings incorporates both data on program characteristics and faculty values. For each program, the study analyzed data on 20 characteristics, "weighing" the data according to the characteristics valued most by faculty in that field. The rankings are given in broad ranges rather than as single numbers, to reflect some of the uncertainties inherent in any effort to rank programs by quality. The full set of illustrative rankings includes overall rankings based on weights of characteristic variables determined from a direct survey that asked faculty to rate the importance of the 20 different program characteristics in determining the quality of a program (S weights). In addition, a second set of rankings is based on an indirect way of determining the importance faculty attach to various characteristics. First, groups of randomly selected faculty were asked to rate the quality of a sample of representative programs in their field. Based on the sample program ratings, weights were assigned to each of the 20 characteristics using statistical techniques (R weights). Additional rankings are based on research activity, student support and outcomes and diversity of the academic environment. UC Davis Coordination Jeffery Gibeling, Dean of Graduate Studies, was designated to serve as the UC Davis Institutional Coordinator (IC) for this project. In that capacity, he is the campus liaison to the NRC. Helen Frasier, Director of Analysis and Policy, Office of Graduate Studies, is the principal technical coordinator and contact person for the NRC Assessment Survey on the Davis campus. In July 2006, each eligible program was asked to name a Program Responder (faculty or staff) who will serve as the principal contact person for that program. Page 1

Rankings by Lead Dean S Rankings by Lead Dean SOM & SOVM L&S: SS L&S: MPS L&S: HARCS Engineering CA&ES Biological Sciences Population Biology (n=4) 4 Plant Biology (1) 5 2 Molecular, Cellular & Integrative Physiology (63) 1 48 Neuroscience (4) Genetics (65) Biophysics () Biochemistry & Molecular Biology () 33 Cell & Developmental Biology (1) Animal Behavior (4) 51 Entomology () 1 7 Agricultural & Resource Economics () 2 4 Nutritional Biology () 3 Food Science (31) 4 17 Ecology (4) 5 Plant Pathology (1) 7 Geography (4) 30 Ecology (w/ SDSU) (4) Pharmacology & Toxicology (1) 1 Agricultural & Environmental Chemistry (178) 31 Soils & Biogeochemistry () Civil & Environmental Engineering (130) 6 37 Materials Science and Engineering () 7 31 Chemical Engineering () 13 41 Computer Science (1) 51 Biomedical Engineering (74) 54 Transportation Technology & Policy (130) 32 Electrical & Computer Engineering (136) 53 Mechanical & Aeronautical Engineering (127) 55 Applied Science Engineering (1) Spanish (60) 1 6 Performance Studies (27) 4 Music (63) 12 Comparative Literature (46) 14 French (43) 34 English (11) Applied Mathematics (33) 4 Mathematics (127) 33 Statistics (61) 12 Chemistry (178) 30 Physics (1) 31 Geology (140) 46 Anthropology (82) 7 Political Science (5) 7 Psychology (6) 57 Economics (117) 2 History (137) 40 Sociology (118) 48 Philosophy (0) 53 Microbiology (74) Immunology (78) 17 Comparative Pathology (78) Epidemiology (1) 2 6 71 72 68 63 70 78 77 75 77 76 85 88 0 5 5 5 136 1 0 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 0 1 120 130 140 0 0 170 180 200 0 0 0 0 Page 2

R Rankings by Lead Dean SOM & SOVM L&S: SS L&S: MPS L&S: HARCS Engineering CA&ES Biological Sciences Plant Biology (n=1) 1 5 Molecular, Cellular & Integrative Physiology (63) 3 27 Population Biology (4) 4 20 Animal Behavior (4) 41 Genetics (65) 40 Neuroscience (4) 53 Biochemistry & Molecular Biology () 33 73 Biophysics () Cell & Developmental Biology (1) 62 Ecology (4) 1 4 Nutritional Biology () 1 5 Agricultural & Resource Economics () 2 5 Entomology () 2 Food Science (31) 4 Plant Pathology (1) 11 36 Geography (4) 14 3 Pharmacology & Toxicology (1) 72 Ecology (w/ SDSU) (4) 25 71 Agricultural & Environmental Chemistry (178) 35 Soils & Biogeochemistry () Civil & Environmental Engineering (130) 11 Materials Science and Engineering () 14 30 Biomedical Engineering (74) 41 Mechanical & Aeronautical Engineering (127) 65 Chemical Engineering () Computer Science (1) 31 54 Applied Science Engineering (1) 36 Electrical & Computer Engineering (136) 58 Transportation Technology & Policy (130) 73 Performance Studies (27) 6 18 Music (63) 30 Comparative Literature (46) Spanish (60) 13 French (43) 35 English (11) 38 Applied Mathematics (33) 5 Statistics (61) 43 Mathematics (127) 47 Chemistry (178) 5 Physics (1) 33 61 Geology (140) 52 Anthropology (82) 14 41 Philosophy (0) 1 35 Political Science (5) 20 35 Psychology (6) 67 History (137) 2 50 Sociology (118) 2 60 Economics (117) 30 Microbiology (74) 14 33 Epidemiology (1) 13 52 Comparative Pathology (78) 50 Immunology (78) 25 58 7 7 86 85 1 5 5 114 1 1 0 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 0 1 120 130 140 0 0 170 180 200 0 0 0 0 Page 3

Dimensional Measures Research Activity by Lead Dean SOM & SOVM L&S: SS L&S: MPS L&S: HARCS Engineering CA&ES Biological Sciences Population Biology (n=4) Plant Biology (1) Biophysics () Molecular, Cellular & Integrative Physiology (63) Genetics (65) Neuroscience (4) Biochemistry & Molecular Biology () Cell & Developmental Biology (1) Animal Behavior (4) Agricultural & Resource Economics () Entomology () Food Science (31) Nutritional Biology () Plant Pathology (1) Ecology (4) Geography (4) Pharmacology & Toxicology (1) Ecology (w/ SDSU) (4) Agricultural & Environmental Chemistry (178) Soils & Biogeochemistry () Materials Science and Engineering () Civil & Environmental Engineering (130) Chemical Engineering () Computer Science (1) Biomedical Engineering (74) Transportation Technology & Policy (130) Mechanical & Aeronautical Engineering (127) Electrical & Computer Engineering (136) Applied Science Engineering (1) Spanish (60) Music (63) Performance Studies (27) Comparative Literature (46) French (43) English (11) Applied Mathematics (33) Mathematics (127) Chemistry (178) Statistics (61) Physics (1) Geology (140) Political Science (5) Anthropology (82) Psychology (6) Economics (117) History (137) Sociology (118) Philosophy (0) Microbiology (74) Epidemiology (1) Immunology (78) Comparative Pathology (78) 3 25 6 1 1 2 2 5 2 13 3 17 4 5 7 32 18 4 32 14 2 37 41 2 6 12 20 35 37 4 5 25 31 38 6 13 27 31 14 1 32 43 7 4 81 46 5 43 75 71 51 60 50 72 57 64 41 74 63 54 55 81 63 7 48 6 68 72 86 113 1 2 8 5 3 7 7 1 4 135 136 0 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 0 1 120 130 140 0 0 170 180 200 0 0 0 0 Page 4

Student Support & Outcomes by Lead Dean SOM & SOVM L&S: SS L&S: MPS L&S: HARCS Engineering CA&ES Biological Sciences Biophysics (n=) 2 Neuroscience (4) 8 51 Population Biology (4) 8 58 Molecular, Cellular & Integrative Physiology (63) 18 46 Genetics (65) 48 Animal Behavior (4) 52 Cell & Developmental Biology (1) 68 Plant Biology (1) Biochemistry & Molecular Biology () Ecology (w/ SDSU) (4) 2 2 Entomology () 3 Agricultural & Resource Economics () 5 Food Science (31) 5 17 Nutritional Biology () 8 25 Ecology (4) 8 51 Geography (4) 33 Agricultural & Environmental Chemistry (178) 11 Pharmacology & Toxicology (1) 35 Plant Pathology (1) 46 Soils & Biogeochemistry () 55 Materials Science and Engineering () 5 31 Biomedical Engineering (74) 7 2 Transportation Technology & Policy (130) 8 52 Chemical Engineering () 18 Computer Science (1) 20 Civil & Environmental Engineering (130) 4 Mechanical & Aeronautical Engineering (127) 57 Electrical & Computer Engineering (136) 68 Applied Science Engineering (1) 68 Comparative Literature (46) 1 14 Performance Studies (27) 25 Spanish (60) 11 3 French (43) 12 Music (63) 1 41 English (11) 30 Statistics (61) 6 Applied Mathematics (33) Physics (1) 18 Mathematics (127) Geology (140) Chemistry (178) Political Science (5) 5 31 Anthropology (82) 13 41 Philosophy (0) History (137) Sociology (118) 34 Economics (117) 51 Psychology (6) Microbiology (74) Immunology (78) 47 Comparative Pathology (78) 55 Epidemiology (1) 17 78 76 70 68 8 77 7 75 3 2 82 87 8 4 75 75 8 84 2 113 112 1 131 141 1 6 174 0 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 0 1 120 130 140 0 0 170 180 200 0 0 0 0 Page 5

Diversity by Lead Dean SOM & SOVM L&S: SS L&S: MPS L&S: HARCS Engineering CA&ES Biological Sciences Animal Behavior (n=4) Genetics (65) Neuroscience (4) Molecular, Cellular & Integrative Physiology (63) Cell & Developmental Biology (1) Biochemistry & Molecular Biology () Plant Biology (1) Population Biology (4) Biophysics () Entomology () Geography (4) Food Science (31) Nutritional Biology () Ecology (4) Agricultural & Resource Economics () Ecology (w/ SDSU) (4) Agricultural & Environmental Chemistry (178) Plant Pathology (1) Soils & Biogeochemistry () Pharmacology & Toxicology (1) Chemical Engineering () Materials Science and Engineering () Biomedical Engineering (74) Computer Science (1) Transportation Technology & Policy (130) Civil & Environmental Engineering (130) Applied Science Engineering (1) Electrical & Computer Engineering (136) Mechanical & Aeronautical Engineering (127) Performance Studies (27) Spanish (60) Comparative Literature (46) Music (63) French (43) English (11) Statistics (61) Geology (140) Applied Mathematics (33) Chemistry (178) Mathematics (127) Physics (1) History (137) Economics (117) Anthropology (82) Sociology (118) Philosophy (0) Political Science (5) Psychology (6) Microbiology (74) Immunology (78) Comparative Pathology (78) Epidemiology (1) 2 3 3 12 1 12 13 11 13 18 1 20 4 12 8 4 8 5 2 11 17 11 17 3 1 17 46 48 38 53 31 47 34 48 4 3 54 55 37 37 43 52 40 54 3 45 57 57 62 72 75 78 71 70 80 80 82 80 88 8 1 8 8 8 2 120 3 7 120 114 120 87 88 1 1 13 145 188 0 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 0 1 120 130 140 0 0 170 180 200 0 0 0 0 Page 6

Cell & Developmental Biology (GCDB) Program ID: 2006704 Broad Field: Biological and Health Sciences Field: Cell and Developmental Biology Website: http://biosci3.ucdavis.edu/gradgroups/bmcdb/default.aspx # Programs: 1 Size Quartile: 3 5 th Percentile: 5 th Percentile: Width of Rankings Band: R Rankings: 62 5 43 S Rankings: 58 DIMENSIONAL RANKINGS: Research Activity: 46 60 Student Support & Outcomes: 68 113 45 Diversity: 62 3 DATA: RESEARCH ACTIVITY: Average Number of Publications (2000 2006) per Allocated Faculty, 2006: 1.53 Average Citations per Publication: 2.3 Percent of Faculty with Grants, 2006: 82.3% Awards per Allocated Faculty Member, 2006: 0.32 DATA: STUDENT SUPPORT & OUTCOMES: Percent of First Year Students with Full Financial Support, Fall 2005: 0.0% Average Completion Ratio, 6 Years or Less: 55.7% Median Time to Degree (Full and Part Time Graduates), 2006: 5.84 Percent with Academic Plans: 25.% Collects Data About Post Graduation Employment: No DATA: DIVERSITY: Non Asian Minority Faculty as a Percent of Total Core and New Faculty, 2006: 6.1% Female Faculty as a Percent of Total Core and New Faculty, 2006: 3.4% Non Asian Minority Students as a Percent of Total Students, Fall 2005: 13.8% Female Students as a Percent of Total Students, Fall 2005:.7% International Students as a Percent of Total Students, Fall 2005: 1.1% DATA: OTHER OVERALL RANKING MEASURES: Average Number of Ph.D.s Graduated, 2002 2006: 4.00 Percent of Interdisciplinary Faculty, 2006: 25.0% Average GRE Scores, 2004 2006: 7 Percent of Students with External Fellowships, 2005: 0.0% Is Student Work Space Provided? Yes Is Health Insurance Provided? Yes Number of Student Activities (Max=18): 18 Page 7

DATA: NOT USED IN RANKING: Total Faculty, 2006 Number of Allocated Faculty, 2006 18.17 Assistant Professors as a Percent of Total Faculty, 2006.0% Tenured Faculty as a Percent of Total Faculty, 2006 84.0% Number of Core and New Faculty, 2006 33 Number of Students Enrolled, Fall 2005 47 Average Annual First Year Enrollment, 2002 2006.20 Percent of Students with Research Assistantships, Fall 2005 55.3% Percent of Students with Teaching Assistantships, Fall 2005 4.3% DATA: STUDENT ACTIVITIES: KEY: 1=provided for by institution; 2=program support only; 3=both institutional and program support; 4=neither institutional nor program support. Orientation for New Graduate Students 3 International Student Orientation 1 Language Screening / Support Prior to Teaching 1 Instruction in Writing 1 Instruction in Statistics 1 Prizes / Awards for Teaching or Research 1 Assistance / Training in Proposal Writing 1 On campus Graduate Research Conferences 1 Formal Training in Academic Integrity 1 Active Graduate Student Association 1 Staff Assigned to the Graduate Student Association 1 Financial Support for the Graduate Student Association 1 Posted Academic Grievance Procedure 1 Dispute Resolution Procedure 1 Regular Graduate Programs Directors / Coordinators Meetings 1 Annual Review of All Enrolled Doctoral Students 3 Organized Training to Help Students Improve Teaching Skills 1 Travel Support to Attend Professional Meetings Count of Student Activities 3 Page 8

Distribution of Range of Rankings by Percentile within the NRC Field Key to Distribution of Range of Rankings Tables KEY: NRC Broad Field Example NRC Broad Field NRC Field UCD Program [program range of rankings] NRC Field. VALUES = Cut off of percentile rankings YELLOW = Range of rankings in top 5% of field overall BLUE = Range of rankings in top % of field overall PINK = Range of rankings in top 25% (or 1 st Quartile) of field overall GREEN, program name not highlighted Range of rankings as high as 2nd Quartile overall PURPLE, program name not highlighted Range of rankings as high as 3rd Quartile overall GREY, program name not highlighted Range of rankings as high as 4th Quartile overall MIXED SCORES: The range of rankings for a program does not always fall within the same set of percentiles within the distribution. In such instances, the program's range can only be reported in terms of the highest range in which both rankings fall. For example: Mixed 5% and % scores = range in top % of field overall Mixed Q2 and Q1 scores = range in 2nd Quartile of field overall NRC s 5th Percentile Ranking Percentile Distribution of Rankings in Field Top Top 1st 2nd 3rd 4th 5% % Q Q Q Q NRC s 5th Percentile Ranking Percentile Distribution of Rankings in Field Top Top 1st 2nd 3rd 4th 5% % Q Q Q Q 1 3 7 12 20 30 3 7 50 60 x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x Distribution of Range of Rankings Biological and Health Sciences: Cell and Developmental Biology 5th Percentile Ranking 5th Percentile Ranking NRC Field UCD Program [program range of rankings] 5% % 1st Q 2nd Q 3rd Q 4th Q 5% % 1st Q 2nd Q 3rd Q 4th Q S Rankings 4 6 14 32 53 117 27 34 67 3 5 1 UCD: Cell & Developmental Biology [ ] x x R Rankings 4 7 18 32 58 120 31 68 0 8 1 UCD: Cell & Developmental Biology [62 5] x x Research Activity 4 6 25 53 1 32 73 8 1 UCD: Cell & Developmental Biology [46 ] x x Student Support & Outcomes 3 5 8 54 120 54 74 5 113 1 UCD: Cell & Developmental Biology [68 113] x x Diversity 4 7 71 1 2 55 1 UCD: Cell & Developmental Biology [ 62] x x Page

Graphs of Program Rankings All NRC Rankings, by Program Cell & Developmental Biology S Ranking R Ranking 62 5 DM: Research Activity 46 DM: Student Support & Outcomes 68 113 DM: Diversity 62 0 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 0 1 120 130 Programs Ranked = 1 Page

S Rankings by Field NRC S Rankings by Field: Cell and Developmental Biology (page 1) MASS. INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY 1 1 HARVARD UNIV. 2 7 UNIV. OF TEXAS HLTH SCI CNTR. AT HO 2 STANFORD UNIV. 2 JOHNS HOPKINS UNIV. 2 UNIV. OF CALIFORNIA SAN FRANCISCO 3 NEW YORK UNIV. 4 DUKE UNIV. 4 BAYLOR COLLEGE OF MEDICINE 5 STANFORD UNIV. 5 UNIV. OF PENNSYLVANIA 5 UNIV. OF CALIFORNIA BERKELEY 6 UNIV. OF MICHIGAN ANN ARBOR 6 YALE UNIV. 6 NEW YORK UNIV. 7 BAYLOR COLLEGE OF MEDICINE 7 WASHINGTON UNIV. IN ST. LOUIS 7 WASHINGTON UNIV. IN ST. LOUIS 7 UNIV. OF TEXAS HLTH SCI CNTR. AT HO 8 UNIV. OF IOWA BAYLOR COLLEGE OF MEDICINE JOHNS HOPKINS UNIV. NEW YORK UNIV. VANDERBILT UNIV. UNIV. OF MICHIGAN ANN ARBOR 11 12 UNIV. OF CALIFORNIA LOS ANGELES 13 COLUMBIA UNIV. IN THE CITY OF NEW Y 13 STATE UNIV. OF NEW YORK AT STONY BR 14 CORNELL UNIV. 14 EMORY UNIV. 14 UNIV. OF ALABAMA AT BIRMINGHAM UNIV. OF WISCONSIN MADISON UNIV. OF TEXAS AT AUSTIN 17 UNIV. OF TEXAS HLTH SCI CNTR. AT HO 17 UNIV. OF CINCINNATI MAIN CAMPUS 17 UNIV. OF CALIFORNIA IRVINE 18 GEORGETOWN UNIV. 18 UNIV. OF WISCONSIN MADISON 1 UNIV. OF GEORGIA 1 18 27 27 27 32 38 34 34 36 33 43 48 48 47 48 51 54 57 58 60 58 65 63 67 67 74 76 76 78 80 75 78 74 8 0 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 0 1 120 130 Programs Ranked = 1 Page 11

NRC S Rankings by Field: Cell and Developmental Biology (page 2) UNIV. OF PITTSBURGH PITTSBURGH CAMP WAKE FOREST UNIV. DUKE UNIV. UNIV. OF ILLINOIS AT URBANA CHAMPAI UNIV. OF COLORADO AT BOULDER UNIV. OF ARIZONA UNIV. OF MASSACHUSETTS AT WORCESTER UNIV. OF IOWA THOMAS JEFFERSON UNIV. UNIV. OF VIRGINIA UNIV. OF ILLINOIS AT CHICAGO UNIV. OF SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA UNIV. OF CONNECTICUT MICHIGAN STATE UNIV. UNIV. OF MINNESOTA TWIN CITIES NEW YORK UNIV. UNIV. OF CALIFORNIA SANTA CRUZ BOSTON UNIV. WAYNE STATE UNIV. UNIV. OF CINCINNATI MAIN CAMPUS UNIV. OF NORTH CAROLINA AT CHAPEL H VANDERBILT UNIV. TUFTS UNIV. UNIV. OF PITTSBURGH PITTSBURGH CAMP UNIV. OF SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA UNIV. OF FLORIDA STATE UNIV. OF NEW YORK UPSTATE MED UNIV. OF MISSOURI KANSAS CITY PURDUE UNIV. MAIN CAMPUS UNIV. OF KANSAS OHIO STATE UNIV. MAIN CAMPUS UNIV. OF MARYLAND COLLEGE PARK UNIV. OF NEVADA RENO UCD: Cell & Developmental Biology CARNEGIE MELLON UNIV. PENN STATE UNIV. UNIV. OF CONNECTICUT INDIANA UNIV. AT BLOOMINGTON RUTGERS NEW BRUNSWICK AND UNIV. OF UNIV. OF UTAH 20 25 25 2 30 31 31 32 32 33 33 33 35 35 36 36 38 40 41 41 41 43 43 77 78 80 87 84 87 86 86 85 86 3 0 4 1 4 4 1 3 3 1 2 6 0 6 8 5 1 7 3 5 2 2 4 0 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 0 1 120 130 Programs Ranked = 1 Page 12

NRC S Rankings by Field: Cell and Developmental Biology (page 3) PURDUE UNIV. MAIN CAMPUS VANDERBILT UNIV. UNIV. OF MARYLAND COLLEGE PARK SAN DIEGO STATE UNIV. UNIV. OF CALI UNIV. OF MIAMI UNIV. OF CALIFORNIA SANTA BARBARA UNIV. OF ARIZONA UNIV. OF MASSACHUSETTS AMHERST UNIV. OF MICHIGAN ANN ARBOR VIRGINIA COMMONWEALTH UNIV. UNIV. OF VERMONT IOWA STATE UNIV. UNIV. OF HAWAII AT MANOA BROWN UNIV. UNIV. OF SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA UNIV. OF NEVADA RENO ARIZONA STATE UNIV. UNIV. OF COLORADO DENVER (UNIV. OF GEORGETOWN UNIV. NEW MEXICO STATE UNIV. MAIN CAMPUS UNIV. OF IOWA WAYNE STATE UNIV. OREGON STATE UNIV. UNIV. OF HOUSTON OREGON HEALTH AND SCIENCE UNIV. STATE UNIV. OF NEW YORK AT STONY BR TEXAS A & M UNIV. UNIV. OF KANSAS UNIV. OF ARKANSAS MAIN CAMPUS LOYOLA UNIV. CHICAGO TULANE UNIV. UNIV. OF CONNECTICUT COLORADO STATE UNIV. LEHIGH UNIV. MIAMI UNIV. TEMPLE UNIV. UNIV. OF NORTH DAKOTA MAIN CAMPUS UNIV. OF RHODE ISLAND UNIV. OF MISSOURI KANSAS CITY 45 45 47 48 48 4 4 52 52 53 53 55 60 63 64 64 66 67 6 6 71 78 80 81 87 2 1 3 5 2 4 2 5 4 3 7 8 111 112 111 112 1 111 114 113 1 11 117 7 117 7 11 118 1 118 3 118 3 120 1 1 1 111 1 112 1 113 1 1 1 117 1 0 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 0 1 120 130 Programs Ranked = 1 Page 13

R Rankings by Field NRC R Rankings by Field: Cell and Developmental Biology (page 1) HARVARD UNIV. 1 MASS. INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY 1 STANFORD UNIV. JOHNS HOPKINS UNIV. UNIV. OF CALIFORNIA SAN FRANCISCO STANFORD UNIV. WASHINGTON UNIV. IN ST. LOUIS UNIV. OF PENNSYLVANIA NEW YORK UNIV. UNIV. OF CALIFORNIA BERKELEY DUKE UNIV. BAYLOR COLLEGE OF MEDICINE YALE UNIV. WASHINGTON UNIV. IN ST. LOUIS UNIV. OF CALIFORNIA LOS ANGELES CORNELL UNIV. UNIV. OF IOWA NEW YORK UNIV. UNIV. OF MICHIGAN ANN ARBOR UNIV. OF WISCONSIN MADISON BAYLOR COLLEGE OF MEDICINE UNIV. OF TEXAS HLTH SCI CNTR. AT HO STATE UNIV. OF NEW YORK AT STONY BR DUKE UNIV. COLUMBIA UNIV. IN THE CITY OF NEW Y NEW YORK UNIV. UNIV. OF ALABAMA AT BIRMINGHAM UNIV. OF UTAH OREGON HEALTH AND SCIENCE UNIV. JOHNS HOPKINS UNIV. WAKE FOREST UNIV. UNIV. OF TEXAS AT AUSTIN UNIV. OF WISCONSIN MADISON UNIV. OF MICHIGAN ANN ARBOR PURDUE UNIV. MAIN CAMPUS VANDERBILT UNIV. CARNEGIE MELLON UNIV. UNIV. OF MASSACHUSETTS AT WORCESTER UNIV. OF ILLINOIS AT URBANA CHAMPAI 2 2 3 7 3 11 4 13 4 4 4 1 4 5 20 6 6 7 7 8 8 8 11 12 13 13 17 17 18 1 20 20 25 2 31 34 3 43 47 4 54 53 64 65 68 68 68 6 73 72 74 74 77 80 81 82 4 0 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 0 1 120 130 Programs Ranked = 1 Page 14

NRC R Rankings by Field: Cell and Developmental Biology (page 2) VIRGINIA COMMONWEALTH UNIV. UNIV. OF CALIFORNIA SANTA CRUZ STATE UNIV. OF NEW YORK UPSTATE MED UNIV. OF GEORGIA UNIV. OF TEXAS HLTH SCI CNTR. AT HO UNIV. OF VIRGINIA UNIV. OF IOWA PURDUE UNIV. MAIN CAMPUS UNIV. OF CONNECTICUT UNIV. OF KANSAS INDIANA UNIV. AT BLOOMINGTON VANDERBILT UNIV. GEORGETOWN UNIV. UNIV. OF COLORADO AT BOULDER BAYLOR COLLEGE OF MEDICINE UNIV. OF SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA UNIV. OF MARYLAND COLLEGE PARK OHIO STATE UNIV. MAIN CAMPUS UNIV. OF CINCINNATI MAIN CAMPUS UNIV. OF TEXAS HLTH SCI CNTR. AT HO UNIV. OF MICHIGAN ANN ARBOR UNIV. OF IOWA THOMAS JEFFERSON UNIV. UNIV. OF CALIFORNIA IRVINE EMORY UNIV. UNIV. OF MINNESOTA TWIN CITIES UNIV. OF MASSACHUSETTS AMHERST IOWA STATE UNIV. BOSTON UNIV. BROWN UNIV. MICHIGAN STATE UNIV. TUFTS UNIV. UNIV. OF SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA SAN DIEGO STATE UNIV. UNIV. OF CALI UNIV. OF ARIZONA GEORGETOWN UNIV. UNIV. OF MARYLAND COLLEGE PARK UNIV. OF ILLINOIS AT CHICAGO UNIV. OF CONNECTICUT VANDERBILT UNIV. 2 30 31 32 32 33 33 34 35 35 36 37 3 40 41 41 43 45 46 47 47 67 70 71 74 7 86 2 76 75 7 3 81 82 5 7 75 87 5 78 0 0 84 1 7 88 88 0 5 3 4 1 0 5 8 111 111 0 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 0 1 120 130 Programs Ranked = 1 Page

NRC R Rankings by Field: Cell and Developmental Biology (page 3) UNIV. OF NEVADA RENO NEW YORK UNIV. UNIV. OF HOUSTON PENN STATE UNIV. UNIV. OF FLORIDA WAYNE STATE UNIV. UNIV. OF CALIFORNIA SANTA BARBARA UNIV. OF PITTSBURGH PITTSBURGH CAMP UNIV. OF MISSOURI KANSAS CITY UNIV. OF SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA UNIV. OF ARIZONA UNIV. OF NORTH CAROLINA AT CHAPEL H UCD: Cell & Developmental Biology UNIV. OF PITTSBURGH PITTSBURGH CAMP UNIV. OF COLORADO DENVER (UNIV. OF UNIV. OF CINCINNATI MAIN CAMPUS STATE UNIV. OF NEW YORK AT STONY BR UNIV. OF KANSAS UNIV. OF HAWAII AT MANOA UNIV. OF VERMONT UNIV. OF MIAMI RUTGERS NEW BRUNSWICK AND UNIV. OF WAYNE STATE UNIV. ARIZONA STATE UNIV. OREGON STATE UNIV. LOYOLA UNIV. CHICAGO LEHIGH UNIV. UNIV. OF MISSOURI KANSAS CITY NEW MEXICO STATE UNIV. MAIN CAMPUS UNIV. OF NEVADA RENO TULANE UNIV. UNIV. OF CONNECTICUT UNIV. OF NORTH DAKOTA MAIN CAMPUS MIAMI UNIV. COLORADO STATE UNIV. TEXAS A & M UNIV. TEMPLE UNIV. UNIV. OF ARKANSAS MAIN CAMPUS UNIV. OF RHODE ISLAND 4 50 51 52 54 54 58 58 5 62 62 63 64 68 70 71 72 77 7 80 84 87 87 8 0 0 1 6 6 7 1 3 7 1 3 118 8 112 5 7 120 1 113 112 114 1 1 1 114 118 1 114 11 11 120 120 11 2 118 7 120 1 1 111 1 114 1 120 1 0 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 0 1 120 130 Programs Ranked = 1 Page

Dimensional Measures Research Activity by Field NRC Research Activity Rankings by Field: Cell and Developmental Biology (page 1) MASS. INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY 1 1 STANFORD UNIV. 2 7 UNIV. OF CALIFORNIA SAN FRANCISCO 2 8 UNIV. OF TEXAS HLTH SCI CNTR. AT HO 2 HARVARD UNIV. 2 JOHNS HOPKINS UNIV. 3 CORNELL UNIV. 4 DUKE UNIV. 4 BAYLOR COLLEGE OF MEDICINE 5 STANFORD UNIV. 6 JOHNS HOPKINS UNIV. 6 UNIV. OF TEXAS HLTH SCI CNTR. AT HO 6 UNIV. OF PENNSYLVANIA 6 UNIV. OF MICHIGAN ANN ARBOR 6 UNIV. OF CINCINNATI MAIN CAMPUS 6 THOMAS JEFFERSON UNIV. 6 NEW YORK UNIV. 7 UNIV. OF CALIFORNIA BERKELEY 7 BAYLOR COLLEGE OF MEDICINE 7 YALE UNIV. 7 NEW YORK UNIV. 8 COLUMBIA UNIV. IN THE CITY OF NEW Y 8 UNIV. OF COLORADO AT BOULDER 8 WASHINGTON UNIV. IN ST. LOUIS 8 EMORY UNIV. WASHINGTON UNIV. IN ST. LOUIS UNIV. OF MASSACHUSETTS AT WORCESTER UNIV. OF MICHIGAN ANN ARBOR GEORGETOWN UNIV. UNIV. OF TEXAS AT AUSTIN NEW YORK UNIV. UNIV. OF PITTSBURGH PITTSBURGH CAMP UNIV. OF CONNECTICUT 11 BAYLOR COLLEGE OF MEDICINE 12 VANDERBILT UNIV. 12 UNIV. OF WISCONSIN MADISON 13 UNIV. OF CALIFORNIA LOS ANGELES 14 14 UNIV. OF CALIFORNIA IRVINE UNIV. OF CINCINNATI MAIN CAMPUS 18 27 32 41 46 55 57 5 61 62 53 57 62 61 62 66 65 6 71 6 67 70 70 73 66 76 78 82 81 81 82 77 80 80 82 0 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 0 1 120 130 Programs Ranked = 1 Page 17

NRC Research Activity Rankings by Field: Cell and Developmental Biology (page 2) UNIV. OF IOWA STATE UNIV. OF NEW YORK AT STONY BR UNIV. OF IOWA UNIV. OF CALIFORNIA SANTA CRUZ UNIV. OF NORTH CAROLINA AT CHAPEL H UNIV. OF NEVADA RENO UNIV. OF TEXAS HLTH SCI CNTR. AT HO UNIV. OF WISCONSIN MADISON TUFTS UNIV. WAYNE STATE UNIV. DUKE UNIV. UNIV. OF VERMONT UNIV. OF PITTSBURGH PITTSBURGH CAMP UNIV. OF ILLINOIS AT URBANA CHAMPAI NEW YORK UNIV. UNIV. OF ALABAMA AT BIRMINGHAM UNIV. OF ARIZONA VANDERBILT UNIV. UNIV. OF FLORIDA UNIV. OF MICHIGAN ANN ARBOR UNIV. OF ARIZONA UNIV. OF VIRGINIA OREGON HEALTH AND SCIENCE UNIV. UNIV. OF CONNECTICUT UNIV. OF IOWA OREGON STATE UNIV. SAN DIEGO STATE UNIV. UNIV. OF CALI UNIV. OF MINNESOTA TWIN CITIES UNIV. OF MIAMI UNIV. OF MISSOURI KANSAS CITY UNIV. OF CALIFORNIA SANTA BARBARA UNIV. OF SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA OHIO STATE UNIV. MAIN CAMPUS UNIV. OF SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA RUTGERS NEW BRUNSWICK AND UNIV. OF UNIV. OF SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA UNIV. OF NEVADA RENO STATE UNIV. OF NEW YORK UPSTATE MED UNIV. OF MARYLAND COLLEGE PARK UNIV. OF MARYLAND COLLEGE PARK 17 18 18 1 1 20 25 25 25 25 27 2 2 30 30 32 32 33 35 35 36 36 37 37 38 41 75 77 87 0 1 3 2 2 2 3 86 8 6 3 2 5 88 4 5 7 6 8 2 4 3 5 7 2 3 1 5 1 3 1 0 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 0 1 120 130 Programs Ranked = 1 Page 18

NRC Research Activity Rankings by Field: Cell and Developmental Biology (page 3) UNIV. OF GEORGIA MICHIGAN STATE UNIV. VANDERBILT UNIV. ARIZONA STATE UNIV. UNIV. OF ILLINOIS AT CHICAGO UNIV. OF KANSAS UCD: Cell & Developmental Biology UNIV. OF CONNECTICUT CARNEGIE MELLON UNIV. UNIV. OF MASSACHUSETTS AMHERST BROWN UNIV. UNIV. OF HAWAII AT MANOA PENN STATE UNIV. BOSTON UNIV. UNIV. OF ARKANSAS MAIN CAMPUS WAKE FOREST UNIV. UNIV. OF UTAH UNIV. OF HOUSTON UNIV. OF COLORADO DENVER (UNIV. OF GEORGETOWN UNIV. WAYNE STATE UNIV. NEW MEXICO STATE UNIV. MAIN CAMPUS LOYOLA UNIV. CHICAGO PURDUE UNIV. MAIN CAMPUS INDIANA UNIV. AT BLOOMINGTON TEXAS A & M UNIV. UNIV. OF KANSAS STATE UNIV. OF NEW YORK AT STONY BR IOWA STATE UNIV. COLORADO STATE UNIV. UNIV. OF RHODE ISLAND TULANE UNIV. VIRGINIA COMMONWEALTH UNIV. LEHIGH UNIV. PURDUE UNIV. MAIN CAMPUS TEMPLE UNIV. MIAMI UNIV. UNIV. OF MISSOURI KANSAS CITY UNIV. OF NORTH DAKOTA MAIN CAMPUS 43 43 45 46 48 4 53 53 53 54 54 54 55 55 57 58 61 72 72 73 74 77 78 7 82 88 8 1 3 3 4 5 4 8 8 111 1 8 111 1 112 1 112 112 112 112 1 1 1 114 1 1 117 1 1 11 117 120 120 120 120 1 120 113 1 114 1 120 1 1 1 0 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 0 1 120 130 Programs Ranked = 1 Page 1

Student Support & Outcomes by Field NRC Student Support & Outcomes by Field: Cell and Developmental Biology (page 1) UNIV. OF NORTH DAKOTA MAIN CAMPUS 1 6 VIRGINIA COMMONWEALTH UNIV. 1 11 WAKE FOREST UNIV. 1 UNIV. OF KANSAS 2 WAYNE STATE UNIV. 3 UNIV. OF TEXAS HLTH SCI CNTR. AT HO 3 NEW YORK UNIV. 3 LOYOLA UNIV. CHICAGO 3 UNIV. OF GEORGIA 3 UNIV. OF FLORIDA 4 INDIANA UNIV. AT BLOOMINGTON 4 MICHIGAN STATE UNIV. 4 UNIV. OF PITTSBURGH PITTSBURGH CAMP 5 UNIV. OF HAWAII AT MANOA 5 UNIV. OF TEXAS HLTH SCI CNTR. AT HO 5 UNIV. OF UTAH 5 PENN STATE UNIV. 5 VANDERBILT UNIV. 5 NEW YORK UNIV. 5 DUKE UNIV. 5 UNIV. OF PITTSBURGH PITTSBURGH CAMP 6 EMORY UNIV. 6 BOSTON UNIV. 6 PURDUE UNIV. MAIN CAMPUS 6 UNIV. OF SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA 6 UNIV. OF ILLINOIS AT CHICAGO 6 NEW YORK UNIV. 7 TEMPLE UNIV. 7 UNIV. OF MICHIGAN ANN ARBOR 8 VANDERBILT UNIV. 8 8 UNIV. OF PENNSYLVANIA CARNEGIE MELLON UNIV. BAYLOR COLLEGE OF MEDICINE UNIV. OF MINNESOTA TWIN CITIES TUFTS UNIV. UNIV. OF MISSOURI KANSAS CITY TEXAS A & M UNIV. IOWA STATE UNIV. 12 UNIV. OF MISSOURI KANSAS CITY 12 13 17 2 38 43 48 51 50 50 54 54 55 5 61 5 5 61 64 64 66 66 70 71 72 70 77 78 7 76 82 82 82 86 8 4 0 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 0 1 120 130 Programs Ranked = 1 Page 20

NRC Student Support & Outcomes by Field: Cell and Developmental Biology (page 2) UNIV. OF WISCONSIN MADISON DUKE UNIV. UNIV. OF MASSACHUSETTS AT WORCESTER JOHNS HOPKINS UNIV. UNIV. OF CALIFORNIA IRVINE UNIV. OF IOWA STATE UNIV. OF NEW YORK AT STONY BR UNIV. OF CALIFORNIA BERKELEY OHIO STATE UNIV. MAIN CAMPUS UNIV. OF CALIFORNIA SANTA CRUZ UNIV. OF COLORADO DENVER (UNIV. OF UNIV. OF SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA UNIV. OF CALIFORNIA SANTA BARBARA UNIV. OF CINCINNATI MAIN CAMPUS STANFORD UNIV. UNIV. OF CINCINNATI MAIN CAMPUS HARVARD UNIV. THOMAS JEFFERSON UNIV. UNIV. OF VIRGINIA SAN DIEGO STATE UNIV. UNIV. OF CALI WASHINGTON UNIV. IN ST. LOUIS UNIV. OF ARIZONA BAYLOR COLLEGE OF MEDICINE RUTGERS NEW BRUNSWICK AND UNIV. OF UNIV. OF ALABAMA AT BIRMINGHAM WASHINGTON UNIV. IN ST. LOUIS NEW YORK UNIV. VANDERBILT UNIV. UNIV. OF MARYLAND COLLEGE PARK MASS. INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY UNIV. OF MICHIGAN ANN ARBOR JOHNS HOPKINS UNIV. UNIV. OF IOWA UNIV. OF CONNECTICUT UNIV. OF TEXAS HLTH SCI CNTR. AT HO MIAMI UNIV. WAYNE STATE UNIV. TULANE UNIV. UNIV. OF CALIFORNIA LOS ANGELES 13 13 13 14 14 17 18 18 18 18 1 1 20 20 25 30 30 31 32 32 34 34 35 37 37 41 76 78 74 72 78 82 86 7 86 85 86 7 80 87 5 2 4 3 8 0 4 1 5 4 5 2 1 5 7 5 4 7 8 7 0 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 0 1 120 130 Programs Ranked = 1 Page

NRC Student Support & Outcomes by Field: Cell and Developmental Biology (page 3) BAYLOR COLLEGE OF MEDICINE GEORGETOWN UNIV. UNIV. OF COLORADO AT BOULDER STATE UNIV. OF NEW YORK AT STONY BR LEHIGH UNIV. UNIV. OF NEVADA RENO GEORGETOWN UNIV. CORNELL UNIV. UNIV. OF WISCONSIN MADISON UNIV. OF VERMONT UNIV. OF MARYLAND COLLEGE PARK UNIV. OF NEVADA RENO ARIZONA STATE UNIV. COLUMBIA UNIV. IN THE CITY OF NEW Y STANFORD UNIV. OREGON STATE UNIV. STATE UNIV. OF NEW YORK UPSTATE MED UNIV. OF MASSACHUSETTS AMHERST PURDUE UNIV. MAIN CAMPUS UNIV. OF KANSAS UCD: Cell & Developmental Biology UNIV. OF CONNECTICUT BROWN UNIV. UNIV. OF RHODE ISLAND UNIV. OF NORTH CAROLINA AT CHAPEL H UNIV. OF ILLINOIS AT URBANA CHAMPAI NEW MEXICO STATE UNIV. MAIN CAMPUS UNIV. OF ARKANSAS MAIN CAMPUS YALE UNIV. UNIV. OF ARIZONA UNIV. OF CALIFORNIA SAN FRANCISCO UNIV. OF HOUSTON COLORADO STATE UNIV. UNIV. OF MIAMI UNIV. OF TEXAS AT AUSTIN UNIV. OF CONNECTICUT UNIV. OF SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA UNIV. OF MICHIGAN ANN ARBOR UNIV. OF IOWA OREGON HEALTH AND SCIENCE UNIV. 43 45 46 46 46 4 51 53 54 55 57 58 58 60 62 62 64 66 66 68 6 70 70 75 82 84 84 84 87 87 8 8 1 5 114 1 117 3 8 3 117 114 117 117 113 1 1 1 113 117 113 1 114 117 11 1 1 1 118 118 118 118 11 120 112 1 114 1 1 1 120 1 0 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 0 1 120 130 Programs Ranked = 1 Page

Diversity by Field NRC Diversity Rankings by Field: Cell and Developmental Biology (page 1) UNIV. OF GEORGIA 1 NEW MEXICO STATE UNIV. MAIN CAMPUS 1 UNIV. OF TEXAS HLTH SCI CNTR. AT HO 1 PURDUE UNIV. MAIN CAMPUS 2 TULANE UNIV. 2 UNIV. OF MICHIGAN ANN ARBOR NEW YORK UNIV. NEW YORK UNIV. VANDERBILT UNIV. UNIV. OF ARIZONA UNIV. OF TEXAS HLTH SCI CNTR. AT HO VANDERBILT UNIV. UNIV. OF ARIZONA WAKE FOREST UNIV. UNIV. OF TEXAS HLTH SCI CNTR. AT HO UNIV. OF MIAMI JOHNS HOPKINS UNIV. WAYNE STATE UNIV. TEMPLE UNIV. UNIV. OF MASSACHUSETTS AMHERST BAYLOR COLLEGE OF MEDICINE INDIANA UNIV. AT BLOOMINGTON UNIV. OF MICHIGAN ANN ARBOR UNIV. OF ILLINOIS AT CHICAGO MIAMI UNIV. GEORGETOWN UNIV. RUTGERS NEW BRUNSWICK AND UNIV. OF TEXAS A & M UNIV. PURDUE UNIV. MAIN CAMPUS UNIV. OF CALIFORNIA LOS ANGELES UNIV. OF CONNECTICUT UNIV. OF CALIFORNIA IRVINE UNIV. OF KANSAS EMORY UNIV. UNIV. OF ILLINOIS AT URBANA CHAMPAI UNIV. OF MARYLAND COLLEGE PARK MICHIGAN STATE UNIV. NEW YORK UNIV. LEHIGH UNIV. UNIV. OF CALIFORNIA SANTA CRUZ 3 4 4 5 6 6 6 7 7 6 6 8 8 13 11 11 12 12 12 12 13 14 14 1 1 1 20 20 20 20 20 25 27 25 33 37 3 35 40 43 45 4 52 54 51 4 50 51 51 55 61 61 5 5 62 62 60 65 65 68 0 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 0 1 120 130 Programs Ranked = 1 Page

NRC Diversity Rankings by Field: Cell and Developmental Biology (page 2) UNIV. OF VIRGINIA UNIV. OF MASSACHUSETTS AT WORCESTER NEW YORK UNIV. CARNEGIE MELLON UNIV. UCD: Cell & Developmental Biology STATE UNIV. OF NEW YORK AT STONY BR TUFTS UNIV. OHIO STATE UNIV. MAIN CAMPUS UNIV. OF MARYLAND COLLEGE PARK UNIV. OF HOUSTON JOHNS HOPKINS UNIV. STANFORD UNIV. UNIV. OF CONNECTICUT UNIV. OF SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA UNIV. OF ALABAMA AT BIRMINGHAM UNIV. OF IOWA WAYNE STATE UNIV. UNIV. OF CALIFORNIA BERKELEY UNIV. OF COLORADO DENVER (UNIV. OF UNIV. OF KANSAS BAYLOR COLLEGE OF MEDICINE BROWN UNIV. UNIV. OF MINNESOTA TWIN CITIES UNIV. OF CINCINNATI MAIN CAMPUS BAYLOR COLLEGE OF MEDICINE GEORGETOWN UNIV. IOWA STATE UNIV. BOSTON UNIV. UNIV. OF SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA UNIV. OF ARKANSAS MAIN CAMPUS UNIV. OF CONNECTICUT CORNELL UNIV. MASS. INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY UNIV. OF WISCONSIN MADISON VANDERBILT UNIV. HARVARD UNIV. LOYOLA UNIV. CHICAGO UNIV. OF PITTSBURGH PITTSBURGH CAMP UNIV. OF FLORIDA UNIV. OF WISCONSIN MADISON 25 27 2 2 2 32 33 33 37 38 41 43 43 46 46 46 48 51 52 52 53 55 64 70 55 61 62 64 68 64 66 68 70 72 73 73 72 58 5 60 61 62 63 63 63 77 77 81 86 8 81 84 85 82 8 8 85 88 85 88 0 4 5 8 8 8 0 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 0 1 120 130 Programs Ranked = 1 Page

NRC Diversity Rankings by Field: Cell and Developmental Biology (page 3) ARIZONA STATE UNIV. UNIV. OF NORTH CAROLINA AT CHAPEL H COLUMBIA UNIV. IN THE CITY OF NEW Y UNIV. OF MISSOURI KANSAS CITY UNIV. OF MICHIGAN ANN ARBOR UNIV. OF PENNSYLVANIA STANFORD UNIV. UNIV. OF NEVADA RENO COLORADO STATE UNIV. WASHINGTON UNIV. IN ST. LOUIS STATE UNIV. OF NEW YORK UPSTATE MED UNIV. OF UTAH DUKE UNIV. UNIV. OF PITTSBURGH PITTSBURGH CAMP UNIV. OF MISSOURI KANSAS CITY PENN STATE UNIV. WASHINGTON UNIV. IN ST. LOUIS DUKE UNIV. YALE UNIV. UNIV. OF RHODE ISLAND UNIV. OF NEVADA RENO UNIV. OF IOWA UNIV. OF CINCINNATI MAIN CAMPUS UNIV. OF COLORADO AT BOULDER UNIV. OF CALIFORNIA SAN FRANCISCO UNIV. OF SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA THOMAS JEFFERSON UNIV. UNIV. OF VERMONT VIRGINIA COMMONWEALTH UNIV. UNIV. OF CALIFORNIA SANTA BARBARA UNIV. OF NORTH DAKOTA MAIN CAMPUS UNIV. OF HAWAII AT MANOA OREGON STATE UNIV. UNIV. OF TEXAS AT AUSTIN SAN DIEGO STATE UNIV. UNIV. OF CALI STATE UNIV. OF NEW YORK AT STONY BR OREGON HEALTH AND SCIENCE UNIV. UNIV. OF IOWA 65 65 66 66 68 68 6 71 71 71 72 72 73 73 76 78 80 82 84 87 88 0 3 6 7 1 4 8 3 4 4 8 8 5 7 5 114 112 112 112 113 1 111 111 111 1 117 117 1 117 1 117 1 118 2 118 5 11 8 118 8 11 1 11 1 1 118 1 11 1 1 1 0 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 0 1 120 130 Programs Ranked = 1 Page 25

NRC Tables TABLE 1: Standardized Program Values and Range of Regression-Based (R) and Survey-Based (S) Coefficients Institution Name: UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA-DAVIS Program: Cell & Developmental Biology Program ID: 2006704 (Col 1) (Col 2) (Col 3) (Col 4) (Col 5) (Col 6) (Col 7) (Col 8) Program Program Value Regression Coefficients Survey-Based Coefficients Description Variable Value* Standardized** Minus 1 SD*** Plus 1 SD*** Minus 1 SD*** Plus 1 SD*** Publications per Allocated Faculty V1 1.534-0.7 0.00 to 0.071 0.1 to 0.132 Cites per Publication V2 2.30-0.714 0.072 to 0.11 0.08 to 0.3 Percent Faculty with Grants V3 82.25% -0.7 0.051 to 0.088 0.6 to 0. Percent Faculty Interdisciplinary V4 25.00% -0.030 0.035 to 0.080 0.040 to 0.043 Percent Non-Asian Minority Faculty V5 6.06% 0.18-0.0 to 0.025 0.0 to 0.012 Percent Female Faculty V6 3.3% 1.418-0.050 to -0.014 0.018 to 0.01 Awards per Allocated Faculty V7 0.3-0.30 0.037 to 0.0 0.057 to 0.060 Average GRE V8 7 0.308 0.047 to 0.3 0.078 to 0.081 Percent 1st yr. Students with Full Support V 0.00% -0.37-0.007 to 0.0 0.057 to 0.060 Percent 1st yr. Students with External Funding V 0% -0.6 0.0 to 0.078 0.040 to 0.043 Percent Non-Asian Minority Students V11 13.7% 0.4-0.0 to 0.011 0.0 to 0.025 Percent Female Students V12.68% -0.782-0.008 to 0.035 0.01 to 0.0 Percent International Students V13 1.% -0.654-0.001 to 0.050 0.007 to 0.00 Average PhDs 2002 to 2006 V14 4.0-0.2 0.0 to 0.1 0.0 to 0.0 Percent Completing within 6 Years V 55.71% 0. 0.041 to 0.04 0.05 to 0.062 Time to Degree Full and Part Time V 5.84 0.258 0.002 to 0.048-0.034 to -0.032 Percent Students in Academic Positions V17 25.3% 0.140 0.04 to 0.081 0.078 to 0.080 Student Work Space V18 1 1.000 0.011 to 0.0 0.004 to 0.005 Health Insurance V1 1 1.000-0.0 to -0.037 0.004 to 0.005 Number of Student Activities Offered V20 18 0.8-0.0 to 0.00 0.036 to 0.038 * Col 3 shows data submitted by the program or calculated from these data. ** Col 4 shows the standardized program value across all program values in the field, with mean of 0 and variance of 1. *** Col 5 shows Minus 1 Standard Deviation from the Mean for the regression-based coefficients for the field as a whole *** Col 6 shows Plus 1 Standard Deviation from the Mean for the regression-based coefficients for the field as a whole *** Col 7 shows Minus 1 Standard Deviation from the Mean for the survey-based coefficients for the field as a whole *** Col 8 shows Plus 1 Standard Deviation from the Mean for the survey-based coefficients for the field as a whole Page

TABLE 2a: 5th Percentile for the Regression-Based (R) Ranking Calculation Institution Name: UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA-DAVIS Program: Cell & Developmental Biology Program ID: 2006704 (Col 1) (Col 2) (Col 3) (Col 4) (Col 5) (Col 6) Standardized Program Program Value Regression Product of Description Variable Value* with Variation Coefficient Col 4 X Col 5 Publications per Allocated Faculty V1 1.534-0.136 0.062-0.008 Cites per Publication V2 2.30-0.631 0.084-0.053 Percent Faculty with Grants V3 82.25% -0.257 0.035-0.00 Percent Faculty Interdisciplinary V4 25.00% 0.087 0.050 0.004 Percent Non-Asian Minority Faculty V5 6.06% 0. 0.0 0.0 Percent Female Faculty V6 3.3% 1.855-0.011-0.0 Awards per Allocated Faculty V7 0.3-0.336 0.05-0.020 Average GRE V8 7 0.255 0.1 0.032 Percent 1st yr. Students with Full Support V 0.00% -0.1 0.040-0.008 Percent 1st yr. Students with External Funding V 0% -0.147 0.073-0.011 Percent Non-Asian Minority Students V11 13.7% 0.138-0.050-0.007 Percent Female Students V12.68% -1.254 0.007-0.00 Percent International Students V13 1.% -0.750-0.012 0.00 Average PhDs 2002 to 2006 V14 4.0-0. 0.0-0.01 Percent Completing within 6 Years V 55.71% 0.8 0.0 0.005 Time to Degree Full and Part Time V 5.84 0.2-0.002-0.001 Percent Students in Academic Positions V17 25.3% 0.327 0.02 0.030 Student Work Space V18 1 1.000 0.060 0.060 Health Insurance V1 1 1.000-0.065-0.065 Number of Student Activities Offered V20 18-0.3-0.007 0.001 Program Ranking: 62 of 1 programs * Col 3 is based on data submitted by the program or calculated from these data. Col 4 is standardized value for the set of perturbed program values that produced the 5th percentile ranking. Standardized values have a mean of 0 and variance of 1. Col 5 is the regression-based weight for each variable Page 27

TABLE 2b: 5th Percentile for the Regression-Based (R) Ranking Calculation Institution Name: UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA-DAVIS Program: Cell & Developmental Biology Program ID: 2006704 (Col 1) (Col 2) (Col 3) (Col 4) (Col 5) (Col 6) Standardized Program Program Value Regression Product of Description Variable Value* with Variation Coefficient Col 4 X Col 5 Publications per Allocated Faculty V1 1.534-0.1 0.065-0.0 Cites per Publication V2 2.30-0.752 0. -0.082 Percent Faculty with Grants V3 82.25% -0.45 0.063-0.05 Percent Faculty Interdisciplinary V4 25.00% -0.180 0.057-0.0 Percent Non-Asian Minority Faculty V5 6.06% 0.785-0.0-0.008 Percent Female Faculty V6 3.3% 1.707-0.04-0.084 Awards per Allocated Faculty V7 0.3-0.0 0.040-0.011 Average GRE V8 7 0.33 0.03 0.037 Percent 1st yr. Students with Full Support V 0.00% -0.4-0.014 0.006 Percent 1st yr. Students with External Funding V 0% -0.60 0.078-0.075 Percent Non-Asian Minority Students V11 13.7% 0.04-0.011-0.001 Percent Female Students V12.68% 0.0 0.00 0.000 Percent International Students V13 1.% -0.632 0.0-0.014 Average PhDs 2002 to 2006 V14 4.0-0.111 0.112-0.012 Percent Completing within 6 Years V 55.71% 0.474 0.046 0.0 Time to Degree Full and Part Time V 5.84 1.36 0.005 0.007 Percent Students in Academic Positions V17 25.3% 0.011 0.068 0.001 Student Work Space V18 1 1.000 0.052 0.052 Health Insurance V1 1 1.000-0.080-0.080 Number of Student Activities Offered V20 18 1.620-0.017-0.0 Program Ranking: 5 of 1 programs * Col 3 is based on data submitted by the program or calculated from these data. Col 4 is standardized value for the set of perturbed program values that produced the 5th percentile ranking. Standardized values have a mean of 0 and variance of 1. Col 5 is the regression-based weights for each variable (See Appendix A). Page

TABLE 3a: 5th Percentile for the Survey-Based (S) Ranking Calculation Institution Name: UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA-DAVIS Program: Cell & Developmental Biology Program ID: 2006704 (Col 1) (Col 2) (Col 3) (Col 4) (Col 5) (Col 6) Standardized Program Program Value Survey-Based Product of Description Variable Value* with Variation Coefficient Col 4 X Col 5 Publications per Allocated Faculty V1 1.534-0.047 0.133-0.006 Cites per Publication V2 2.30-0.601 0.1-0.061 Percent Faculty with Grants V3 82.25% 0.37 0.8 0.7 Percent Faculty Interdisciplinary V4 25.00% -0.076 0.040-0.003 Percent Non-Asian Minority Faculty V5 6.06% 0.74 0.0 0.0 Percent Female Faculty V6 3.3% 1.32 0.018 0.0 Awards per Allocated Faculty V7 0.3-0.325 0.060-0.020 Average GRE V8 7 0.1 0.07 0.0 Percent 1st yr. Students with Full Support V 0.00% -0.3 0.057-0.018 Percent 1st yr. Students with External Funding V 0% -0.620 0.041-0.025 Percent Non-Asian Minority Students V11 13.7% 0.30 0.025 0.008 Percent Female Students V12.68% -0.253 0.01-0.005 Percent International Students V13 1.% -0.6 0.007-0.005 Average PhDs 2002 to 2006 V14 4.0-0.176 0.0-0.004 Percent Completing within 6 Years V 55.71% 1.002 0.060 0.061 Time to Degree Full and Part Time V 5.84 0.461-0.032-0.0 Percent Students in Academic Positions V17 25.3% 0.072 0.07 0.006 Student Work Space V18 1 1.000 0.004 0.004 Health Insurance V1 1 1.000 0.005 0.005 Number of Student Activities Offered V20 18 0.578 0.037 0.0 Program Ranking: of 1 programs * Col 3 is based on data submitted by the program or calculated from these data. Col 4 is standardized value for the set of perturbed program values that produced the 5th percentile ranking. Standardized values have a mean of 0 and variance of 1. Col 5 is the survey-based weights for each variable Page 2

TABLE 3b: 5th Percentile for the Survey-Based (S) Ranking Calculation Institution Name: UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA-DAVIS Program: Cell & Developmental Biology Program ID: 2006704 (Col 1) (Col 2) (Col 3) (Col 4) (Col 5) (Col 6) Standardized Program Program Value Survey-Based Product of Description Variable Value* with Variation Coefficient Col 4 X Col 5 Publications per Allocated Faculty V1 1.534-0.177 0.1-0.0 Cites per Publication V2 2.30-0.757 0.1-0.077 Percent Faculty with Grants V3 82.25% -1.6 0.8-0.3 Percent Faculty Interdisciplinary V4 25.00% -0.070 0.040-0.003 Percent Non-Asian Minority Faculty V5 6.06% 1.045 0.012 0.012 Percent Female Faculty V6 3.3% 1.1 0.01 0.0 Awards per Allocated Faculty V7 0.3-0.0 0.060-0.017 Average GRE V8 7 0.5 0.078 0.0 Percent 1st yr. Students with Full Support V 0.00% -1.6 0.057-0.071 Percent 1st yr. Students with External Funding V 0% -0.5 0.041-0.0 Percent Non-Asian Minority Students V11 13.7% 0.117 0.025 0.003 Percent Female Students V12.68% -0.6 0.0-0.004 Percent International Students V13 1.% -0.585 0.008-0.005 Average PhDs 2002 to 2006 V14 4.0-0.30 0.0-0.007 Percent Completing within 6 Years V 55.71% 0.572 0.060 0.034 Time to Degree Full and Part Time V 5.84 1.368-0.033-0.045 Percent Students in Academic Positions V17 25.3% 0.278 0.078 0.0 Student Work Space V18 1 1.000 0.005 0.005 Health Insurance V1 1 1.000 0.005 0.005 Number of Student Activities Offered V20 18 1.125 0.037 0.041 Program Ranking: of 1 programs * Col 3 is based on data submitted by the program or calculated from these data. Col 4 is standardized value for the set of perturbed program values that produced the 5th percentile ranking. Standardized values have a mean of 0 and variance of 1. Col 5 is the survey-based weights for each variable Page 30

Dimensional Measures TABLE 4a: 5th Percentile Dimensional Ranking Calculation: Research Activity Institution Name: UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA-DAVIS Program: Cell & Developmental Biology Program ID: 2006704 (Col 1) (Col 2) (Col 3) (Col 4) (Col 5) (Col 6) Standardized Program Program Value Survey-Based Product of Description Variable Value* with Variation Coefficient Col 4 X Col 5 Publications per Allocated Faculty V1 1.534-0.4 0.276-0.02 Cites per Publication V2 2.30-0.7 0.20-0.1 Percent Faculty with Grants V3 82.25% 1.146 0.386 0.2 Awards per Allocated Faculty V7 0.3-0.31 0.12-0.041 Program Ranking: 46 of 1 programs * Col 3 is based on data submitted by the program or calculated from these data. Col 4 is standardized value for the set of perturbed program values that produced the 5th percentile ranking. Standardized values have a mean of 0 and variance of 1. Col 5 is the survey-based weights for each variable. TABLE 4b: 5th Percentile Dimensional Ranking Calculation: Research Activity Institution Name: UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA-DAVIS Program: Cell & Developmental Biology Program ID: 2006704 (Col 1) (Col 2) (Col 3) (Col 4) (Col 5) (Col 6) Standardized Program Program Value Survey-Based Product of Description Variable Value* with Variation Coefficient Col 4 X Col 5 Publications per Allocated Faculty V1 1.534-0.4 0.2-0.066 Cites per Publication V2 2.30-0.725 0.0-0.3 Percent Faculty with Grants V3 82.25% -1.363 0.385-0.525 Awards per Allocated Faculty V7 0.3-0.335 0.1-0.041 Program Ranking: of 1 programs * Col 3 is based on data submitted by the program or calculated from these data. Col 4 is standardized value for the set of perturbed program values that produced the 5th percentile ranking. Standardized values have a mean of 0 and variance of 1. Col 5 is the survey-based weights for each variable. Page 31

TABLE 5a: 5th Percentile Dimensional Ranking Calculation: Student Support and Outcomes Institution Name: UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA-DAVIS Program: Cell & Developmental Biology Program ID: 2006704 (Col 1) (Col 2) (Col 3) (Col 4) (Col 5) (Col 6) Standardized Program Program Value Survey-Based Product of Description Variable Value* with Variation Coefficient Col 4 X Col 5 Percent 1st yr. Students w/ Full Support V 0.00% 0.02 0.1 0.007 Percent Completing within 6 Years V 55.71% 0.875 0.251 0.0 Time to Degree Full and Part Time V 5.8-0.358-0.127 0.045 Percent Students in Academic Positions V17 25.3% 0. 0. 0.037 Program Collects Outcomes Data V -1-1.000 0. -0. Program Ranking: 68 of 1 programs * Col 3 is based on data submitted by the program or calculated from these data. Col 4 is standardized value for the set of perturbed program values that produced the 5th percentile ranking. Standardized values have a mean of 0 and variance of 1. Col 5 is the survey-based weights for each variable. TABLE 5b: 5th Percentile Dimensional Ranking Calculation: Student Support and Outcomes Institution Name: UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA-DAVIS Program: Cell & Developmental Biology Program ID: 2006704 (Col 1) (Col 2) (Col 3) (Col 4) (Col 5) (Col 6) Standardized Program Program Value Survey-Based Product of Description Variable Value* with Variation Coefficient Col 4 X Col 5 Percent 1st yr. Students with Full Support V 0.00% -1.504 0.7-0.357 Percent Completing within 6 Years V 55.71% -0.388 0.25-0.1 Time to Degree Full and Part Time V 5.8-0.64-0.133 0.086 Percent Students in Academic Positions V17 25.3% 0.7 0.185 0.0 Program Collects Outcomes Data V -1-1.000 0.185-0.185 Program Ranking: 113 of 1 programs * Col 3 is based on data submitted by the program or calculated from these data. Col 4 is standardized value for the set of perturbed program values that produced the 5th percentile ranking. Standardized values have a mean of 0 and variance of 1. Col 5 is the survey-based weights for each variable. Page 32