From: Measuring Capital - OECD Manual 2009 Second edition Access the complete publication at: http://dx.doi.org/10.1787/9789264068476-en Scope of Capital Measurement and Classifications Please cite this chapter as: OECD (2009), Scope of Capital Measurement and Classifications, in Measuring Capital - OECD Manual 2009: Second edition, OECD Publishing. http://dx.doi.org/10.1787/9789264068476-12-en
This document and any map included herein are without prejudice to the status of or sovereignty over any territory, to the delimitation of international frontiers and boundaries and to the name of any territory, city or area.
PART II Measuring Capital Stocks and Capital Services Implementation
PART II
ISBN 978-92-64-02563-9 Measuring Capital OECD MANUAL 2009 OECD 2009 Chapter 9 Scope of Capital Measurement and Classifications 81
II.9. SCOPE OF CAPITAL MEASUREMENT AND CLASSIFICATIONS 9.1. Scope Most but not all of the stock and flow measures considered in this Manual relate to produced, non-financial objects (fixed assets and inventories) that are included in gross capital formation as defined in the national accounts. Produced non-financial assets come into being via the production process or as imports. Table 9.1 gives the full listing of non-financial assets recognised in that system. For a treatment of other natural resources such as subsoil assets, the reader is referred to the Handbook on Integrated Environmental and Economic Accounting (United Nations et al. 2003) and to Section 18.3. Note that two items related to non-produced assets are part of the produced assets. These are major improvements to land and costs of ownership transfer on non-produced assets. All assets in the classification are relevant for balance sheets of the economy and should, to the extent possible, be recognised there. When it comes to measuring capital services, the situation is less clear. There is agreement that all fixed assets should be considered sources of capital services. The discussion about inventories is less clear-cut although in the end, their inclusion was decided in the context of the revision of the 1993 SNA. There is also general agreement that land constitutes a source of capital services and should thus be recognised in the measures of capital services. The main difficulty with land as a source of capital services lies in the implementation of capital services measures in the presence of land markets with price bubbles which may produce results that are hard to interpret such as negative user costs of capital (see Section Chapter 17). In addition to land, there are other natural resources and non-produced assets that are used in production and that constitute a source of capital services. However, measurement problems are sometimes severe for these assets and due to practical considerations, they are often excluded from capital services measures. According to national accounts conventions consumer durables are not treated as assets: consumer durables are not treated as fixed assets. The services these durables produce are household services outside the production boundary of the System. If, for example, a washing machine were to be treated as a fixed asset, the production boundary would have to be extended to include all laundry services, whether undertaken by machine or by hand. As it stands, the production boundary restricts laundry services to those services provided to other units but includes services provided by both machine and by hand. However, owner-occupied dwellings are not treated as consumer durables but are included within the asset boundary. The owneroccupiers are treated as owners of unincorporated enterprises producing housing services for their own consumption (2008 SNA, paragraph 10.31). Consumer durables are thus not specifically dealt with in this Manual, although it is well understood that their treatment as capital goods may be analytically useful as long as corresponding adjustments are made to production measures as well. 82
II.9. SCOPE OF CAPITAL MEASUREMENT AND CLASSIFICATIONS Economic analysts and policy makers have also been interested in measuring what is generally called intangible assets (see for example, Corrado, Hulten and Sichel 2005). These include R&D and other assets in relation to innovation, human capital, advertising and organisational assets. While interesting from an analytical viewpoint, they are a long way off from recognition as assets in the national accounts, given the many measurement issues and given some conceptual issues associated with them, one exception being R&D which is now considered as an intellectual property asset. 9.2. Classifications This chapter deals with the classifications used for publishing capital stock statistics. Three classifications contained in the SNA are relevant the Classification of Assets, the Classification of Institutional Sectors, and the International Standard Classification of All Economic Activities. These are used in different combinations for the gross and net capital stocks and the two flow measures covered in this Manual depreciation and the volume index of capital services. The net capital stock, capital services and depreciation appear as entries in the SNA and this determines the classifications to be used. Both are to be classified by the institutional sector that owns the assets. This is the appropriate classification for the net capital stock, which is needed for the Balance Sheets of the system and for depreciation, which appears in the Production Account, in the Distribution and Use of Income Accounts and in the Accumulation Accounts. The classification of non-financial produced assets, as given in the SNA, is designed to distinguish among assets on the basis of their role in production. The single most important difference to the treatment of assets in other classifications such as the Central Product Classification is the treatment of costs of ownership transfer. As spelled out in more detail in Chapter 14, according to the national accounts, costs of ownership transfer are allocated to the asset that is subject to ownership transfer whereas such costs are treated separately under product classifications. Capital stock statistics also serve a number of analytic uses, such as calculating capital-output ratios or rates of return on capital and studying capital and multifactor productivity. For these purposes, it is usually preferable to classify assets according to the kind of activity of the owner and by type of asset. This involves a cross-classification by the ISIC and by the Classification of Assets. 9.2.1. Classification by type of asset The part of the national accounts Classification of Assets covering non-financial assets is given in Table 9.1 Revised classification of non-financial assets above. Most countries that now compile capital stock statistics use an asset breakdown for publication purposes that is less detailed than this and the standard questionnaire that is used by the international organisations to collect annual statistics according to the SNA requires an even less extensive breakdown. In contrast, the United States Bureau of Economic Analysis (BEA) publishes capital stock statistics broken down into over 80 asset types. The accuracy of capital stock statistics is determined to an important extent by the accuracy of the price indices used to revalue assets. In general, the greater the level of investment detail for which separate deflators and depreciation rates are available, the 83
II.9. SCOPE OF CAPITAL MEASUREMENT AND CLASSIFICATIONS Table 9.1. Revised classification of non-financial assets Dwellings Non-residential buildings Produced assets Fixed assets Inventories Valuables Other buildings and structures Machinery and equipment Weapons systems Cultivated assets Costs of ownership transfer on non-produced assets Intellectual property products Materials and supplies Work in progress Finished goods Military inventories Goods for resale Precious metals and stones Antiques and other art objects Other valuables Other structures Land improvements Transport equipment ICT equipment Other machinery and equipment Animal resources yielding repeat products Tree, crop and plant resources yielding repeat products Research and development Mineral exploration and evaluation Computer software and databases Entertainment, literary or artistic originals Other intellectual property products Work in progress on cultivated assets Other work in progress Computer software Databases Non-produced assets Natural resources Contracts, leases and licences Goodwill and marketing assets Natural land Subsoil assets Non-cultivated biological resources Water resources Other natural resources Third party property rights Entitlement to future goods and services on an exclusive basis Natural land under buildings and structures and associated surface water Natural land under cultivation and associated surface water Natural recreational land and associated surface water Other natural land and associated surface water Coal, oil and mineral gas reserves Metallic mineral reserves Non-metallic mineral reserves Natural forests Other crop and plant resources Wild stocks of fish and aquatic mammals Aquifers Other Radio spectra Other Marketable operating leases Permissions to use natural resources Of nominated legal persons Of future production In national waters including Exclusive Economic Zone Outside Exclusive Economic Zone 84
II.9. SCOPE OF CAPITAL MEASUREMENT AND CLASSIFICATIONS more reliable will be the estimates of stocks and consumption of fixed capital; this is one of the reasons For many analytical purposes, investment data that is crossclassified by asset and industry why BEA uses a very detailed asset classification. With the same consideration in mind, Eurostat (2001) or institutional sector constitutes suggests a minimum level of detail appropriate for the key information. Similarly, sectoral balance sheets should deflation of gross fixed capital formation in its provide the necessary asset handbook on price and volume measures in national breakdown for comparison between sectors and over time. accounts; each class of assets in this classification is thought to be relatively homogeneous as regards price movements. Note that communications equipment and computers are separately distinguished because the behaviour of prices for these goods is so different from that of other assets. Note also that this classification still follows the 1993 SNA classification of assets before revision and is therefore not an exact subset of the revised classification shown in the table above. 9.2.2. Classification by institutional sector The SNA identifies five institutional sectors: non-financial corporations, financial corporations, general government, households and non-profit institutions serving households. These five sectors are further broken down to give a total of 36 sub-sectors at the most detailed level. The level of detail to be used for classifying the net capital stock and consumption of fixed capital depends on the degree of sector detail that is used in the balance sheets (for net stock) and in the non-financial accounts (for depreciation). The few countries that compile balance sheets at the present time mostly classify stocks according to the five institutional sectors, but with some breakdown of general government by level central, local, social security funds, for example. A similar breakdown is used by most countries for the nonfinancial accounts; although the financial corporations sector is sometimes broken down to distinguish between depository institutions and other financial institutions. The annual national accounts questionnaire used by the international organisations to collect national accounts statistics calls for the non-financial accounts to be subsectored as follows and this determines the institutional sector detail for classifying consumption of fixed capital: non-financial corporations, financial corporations, central government, state government, local government, social security funds, households and non-profit institutions serving households. In practice many countries cannot distinguish non-profit institutions serving households separately from the household sector. Some countries will also find the breakdown of government too ambitious and will only be able to provide estimates for general government as a whole. 9.2.3. Classification by kind of activity For most kinds of analytic studies, capital stocks and flows will need to be classified by kind of activity. As a general rule, the more detailed the activity breakdown, the more useful will the statistics be for such purposes. However, practical considerations limit the amount of detail that can be shown. For example, if the PIM is used, the kind of activity breakdown cannot be more detailed than the kind of activity classification used for collecting statistics on gross fixed capital formation. If the latter is very detailed, transfers of used assets between producers in different kinds of activities will affect reliability and 85
II.9. SCOPE OF CAPITAL MEASUREMENT AND CLASSIFICATIONS reduce the amount of detail that can reasonably be shown. A classification that may be useful for countries starting capital stock statistics is given in Table 9.2. The annual national accounts questionnaire calls for capital stock statistics to be broken down by 17 kinds of activities. These are the 17 tabulation categories of the ISIC (revision 3). It would be possible to make this list more useful by distinguishing the principal activities within manufacturing (which is a single tabulation category) and by grouping some of the categories covering service activities. Table 9.2. Suggested activity classification for capital stock statistics ISIC Tabulation Categories Description A + B Agriculture, hunting, forestry and fishing C Mining and quarrying D Manufacturing (with 4 or 5 important activities separately identified) E Electricity, gas and water supply F Construction G + H Wholesale and retail trade, repair of vehicles and household goods, hotels and Restaurants I Transport, storage and communications J + K Financial intermediation, real estate, renting and business activities L Public administration, defence and social security M, N + O Education, health and social work, other community, social and personal service activities 86