Intro To Timing Synchroniza1on Fundamentals Steve McQuarry / Equinix smcquarry@equinix.com DraB- V3

Similar documents
Packet Synchronization in Cellular Backhaul Networks By Patrick Diamond, PhD, Semtech Corporation

Deploying SyncE and IEEE 1588 in Wireless Backhaul

Precision Time Protocol (PTP/IEEE-1588)

Synchronization and precise timing in packet networks

Securing GNSS with PTP & SyncE Adam Wertheimer Microsemi Adam.Wertheimer@microsemi.com. Power Matters

List of CTS Oscillators for Telecom Timing and Synchronization

Packet Synchronization over Carrier Ethernet Networks for Mobile Backhaul

Evaluating 1588v2 Performance Rev 2

Field Measurement Methodologies for Synchronization in Mobile Networks Neil Hobbs Director EMEA Technical Sales Support

Timing over Packet. Technical Brief

Smart Solutions for Network IP Migration

Synchronization Requirements in Cellular Networks over Ethernet

VoIP Timing and Synchronization Best Practices

THE Evolution of Mobile network and THE role of Network transport. Rodolfo Di Muro, PhD, MBA Programs marketing

A Look at SyncE and IEEE 1588

SYNCHRONIZATION IN PACKET NETWORKS: TIMING METRICS AND MONITORING

Synchronization Deployment Considerations for IP RAN Backhaul Operators

Clocking. Clocking in the Digital Network

Course 12 Synchronous transmission multiplexing systems used in digital telephone networks

Telecommunications Synchronization Overview

TDM services over IP networks

Time Synchronization for Digital Subscriber Lines

GPON in Mobile Backhaul

Best Practices for Testing Ethernet and Network Synchronization at the Cell Site

Challenges and Solutions for Wireless Backhaul

IEEE-1588 Standard for a Precision Clock Synchronization Protocol for Networked Measurement and Control Systems

Synchronous Ethernet explained

Telephone Company Lease Line Elimination. Dewey Day Principal Operational Technology Architect Pacific Gas & Electric

Welcome. People Power Partnership PROFIdag 2013 Peter Van Passen Sales & Business Development Manager HARTING Electric 1/44

SLA Monitoring in Next Generation Networks. Charles Barry CEO, Brilliant Telecommunications ITSF, London, November 2007

MIGRATING TDM SERVICES TO PACKET NETWORKS ENSURING RELIABLE AND EFFICIENT TRANSPORT WITH THE ALCATEL-LUCENT 9500 MICROWAVE PACKET RADIO

DigiPoints Volume 1. Student Workbook. Module 5 Growing Capacity Through Technology

Layer 3 Network + Dedicated Internet Connectivity

Contents. Connection Guide. What is Dante? Connections Network Set Up System Examples Copyright 2015 ROLAND CORPORATION

TDM-over-IP Improving Backhaul efficiency

SDH and WDM A look at the physical layer

White paper. Reliable and Scalable TETRA networks

Mobile Backhaul evolution

3GPP Wireless Standard

Synchronization Essentials of VoIP WHITE PAPER

SDH and WDM: a look at the physical layer

Architecture and transport for mobile broadband backhaul. Kåre Gustafsson Ericsson Research

T200, PTP/IEEE 1588 Grandmaster Clock and

Product Overview. Steve Erickson

Multicast (Group) Addresses for Layer 2 (Ethernet) Transport of IEEE 1588 PTP Messages, with Application to AVB

Deploying Multiservice Applications Using RPR Over the Existing SONET Infrastructure

ALTERNATIVE BACKHAUL AND DATA OFFLOAD SOLUTIONS FOR GSM AND UMTS OPERATORS

Wireless Networks. Reading: Sec5on 2.8. COS 461: Computer Networks Spring Mike Freedman

Enable customers to optimally tune their network performance with real time information and proactive recommendations.

Use of MPLS in Mobile Backhaul Networks

Please purchase PDF Split-Merge on to remove this watermark.

CS263: Wireless Communications and Sensor Networks

WIRELESS IN THE METRO PACKET MICROWAVE EXPLAINED

Mobile Backhaul The Next Telecoms Revolution

Performance Evaluation of VoIP Services using Different CODECs over a UMTS Network

Application Note License-Exempt Gigabit Ethernet Microwave Radio Applications

Understanding Mobile Wireless Backhaul

Failsafe Protection for Utility Critical Infrastructure

Operational Core Network

A review of Plesiochronous Digital Hierarchy (PDH) and Synchronous Digital Hierarchy (SDH)

Precision Clock Synchronization

Technical Bulletin. Enabling Arista Advanced Monitoring. Overview

LTE-Capable Mobile Backhaul

Using & Offering Wholesale Ethernet Network and Operational Considerations

Chapter 5. Data Communication And Internet Technology

TCP and Wireless Networks Classical Approaches Optimizations TCP for 2.5G/3G Systems. Lehrstuhl für Informatik 4 Kommunikation und verteilte Systeme

Leased Line + Remote Dial-in connectivity

FURTHER READING: As a preview for further reading, the following reference has been provided from the pages of the book below:

REMOTE MONITORING MATRIX

MPLS: Key Factors to Consider When Selecting Your MPLS Provider Whitepaper

High Performance VPN Solutions Over Satellite Networks

White Paper Reducing the Cost of Wireless Backhauling Through Circuit Emulation

The Role of Precise Timing in High-Speed, Low-Latency Trading

ETHERNET TIME & SYNC. In Telecoms, Finance, Power, Broadcast,... ITSF Nice, 6 Nov 2012

Computer Network. Interconnected collection of autonomous computers that are able to exchange information

Clock Recovery and Channelized SDH/SONET

EPL 657 Wireless Networks

of Network Access ASC Broadband Services Access Platform The New Edge Advanced Switching Communications

Region 10 Videoconference Network (R10VN)

Wireless Backhaul Solutions

Encapsulating Voice in IP Packets

QoS issues in Voice over IP

Implementing VoIP support in a VSAT network based on SoftSwitch integration

Goal We want to know. Introduction. What is VoIP? Carrier Grade VoIP. What is Meant by Carrier-Grade? What is Meant by VoIP? Why VoIP?

Lecture 12 Transport Networks (SONET) and circuit-switched networks

hp ProLiant network adapter teaming

Application Note Gigabit Ethernet Port Modes

Voice over IP Basics for IT Technicians

Quality of Service in Industrial Ethernet Networks

Agenda. clock tower in old city of Neuchatel ADVA Optical Networking. All rights reserved.

Wireless Networks: Network Protocols/Mobile IP

Voice Over IP. MultiFlow IP Phone # 3071 Subnet # Subnet Mask IP address Telephone.

Local Area Networks (LANs) Blueprint (May 2012 Release)

Wireless Technologies for the 450 MHz band

Synchronizace a stabilita. Měření SyncE a 1588v2 PTP s přístroji VeEX nové vlastnosti

Making Ethernet Over SONET Fit a Transport Network Operations Model

John Ragan Director of Product Management. Billy Wise Communications Specialist

Transcription:

Intro To Timing Synchroniza1on Fundamentals Steve McQuarry / Equinix smcquarry@equinix.com DraB- V3

Network Synchroniza1on TDM TDM TDM TDM Wireless Base Station SSU/TimeHub TDM TimeProvider Access (CES/ PWE)

Telecom Synchroniza1on Synchroniza+on in telecommunica+ons networks is the process of aligning the *me scales of digital transmission and switching equipment so equipment opera*ons occur at the correct *me and in the correct order Synchroniza+on is especially cri+cal for real +me services, such as voice and video The impacts of poor synchroniza+on are: Call setup, takedown, and management problems Degraded speech quality and audible clicks Degraded data traffic throughput Freeze- frames and audio pops on video transmissions Call disconnects during mobile call hand- off Par+al or complete traffic stoppage

Synchroniza1on Requirements Frequency Synchronization A T A =1/f A t B f A =f B T B =1/f B t Phase Synchronization A B f A =f B T A =1/f A T B =1/f B t t Time Synchronization A 01:00:00 T A =1/f A T B =1/f B 01:00:10 t t B f A =f B 01:00:00 01:00:10

Stratum Levels Performance levels, or stratum, are specified by ANSI and Telcordia Telecom networks should always be traceable to Stratum 1 the office s Primary Reference Source Holdover is the ability of a system to maintain frequency accuracy if its Stratum 1 reference timing has been lost A slip, a measure of a synchronization error, it is a frame (193 bits) shift in the time difference between two signals Stratum Clock Type Accuracy 1 st HO Slip Pull-In 1 Cesium/GPS 1 x 10-11 2 Rubidium 1.6 x 10-8 ~ 14 days 1.6 x 10-8 3E Precision Quartz 1 x 10-6 ~ 48 hours 1 x 10-6 3 Transport 1 x 10-6 minutes 1 x 10-6 4 CPE 3.2 x 10-6 N/A 3.2 x 10-6

Clocks Primary Reference Source Warm up ini1aliza1on/1me/no output Acquire valid reference Locked normal state/1me/takes on the quality of input reference Holdover output/drib Free run 1me will return to nominal rate of oscillator

Primary Reference Source Source Equipment that provides a timing signal whose long-term accuracy is maintained at 1 x 10-11 (stratum 1) or better with verification to coordinated universal time (UTC) and whose timing signal may be used as the basis of reference for the control of other clocks. - ANSI T1.101 PRS Cesium GPS PacketPRS Loran-C CDMA TSG

Timing TSG/SSU Signal Architecture Generator 1 x Input Card Clock Card A... TOTA-M Output Card Cards 1 x 1 x Input Card Clock Card B Timing distribution inside the office Holdover Redundancy - No single-point of failure Filtering (FLL vs. PLL) Alarm and comm. Card

Building Integrated Timing Supply, BITS The Heartbeat of the Network Virtually every NE connects to and is dependent on the sync infrastructure

SONET Mapping Synchronization integrity impaired Synchronous T1 tributary mapped in has the clock of the SONET network Frequency offset results in slips if SONET network and T1 network are not plesiochronous. Slip buffers used to compensate for frequency offset Loss or corrup1on of data Asynchronous T1 tributary mapped maintains the source clock of the T1 network frequency offset between T1 network and SONET network generates VT1.5 pointer movements but to slips Frequency offset jus1fied by bit- stuffing VT1.5 pointers = ji_er

SONET PRS&TSG External Timing TSG External Timing PRS TSG Derived DS1/E1 TSG Working Protected OC-N NE OC-N OC-N NE OC-N Line Timing OC-N ADM OC-N ADM Other Specific Modes OC-N NE OC-N OC-N Loop Timing for SONET Terminals Through Timing for Uni-Path Switched Rings/IXC/Regeneration applications Internal Timing for Point-To- Point applications ADM Primary Timing Secondary Timing Input connection point

Timing Degrada1on EXT Timing Mode PRS TSG functions Intra-office timing distribution Holdover Redundancy Filtering Line timing SSU SSU ADM ADM ADM ADM EXT Timing Mode Frequency-lock loop control of direct digital synthesizer in SSU provides mechanism to filter short-term instability on cascaded timing signals. Most effective with long time constant made possible by Rubidium oscillator because of its exceptional stability.

Synchroniza1on Synchronization integrity Integrity impaired Impaired TDM Timing Issues Short- term instability JiHer Wander Phase Transients MTIE & TDEV Long- term accuracy Frequency Offset Phase & Frequency What you see Bit- errors Slips Pointer ac+vity Holdover & Clock Alarms Packet Timing Issues Packet JiHer (PDV) Asymmetry +me/phase for +me transfer Latency or Delay Packet Loss MinTDEV MRTIE Poor synchronization is the most common, non-obvious, cause of service degradation

Network Time Protocol (NTP) Internet protocol for synchronizing system clocks, via +me stamps, over a packet network Uses Universal Coordinated Time (UTC) as reference from GPS constella+on IP Client/Server architecture Time stamps delivered via LAN/WAN Developed in 1985 at U of Delaware Air traffic control was one of first applica+ons Widely employed in informa+on technology domain, e.g. every PC Telecom NEs with NTP clients include so:switches, routers, IP transport, and mobile switching centers

Network Time Protocol (NTP)

Carrier Class NTP Enterprise NTP Telecom NTP Enterprise/Data Center NTP Best Effort Delivery Accuracy - - - 10s of seconds (WAN) Enterprise Implementa+on Traceability is Not Assured Not secure or authen+cated spoofing Not designed for mission cri+cal applica+ons * Set Top Box or Residential Gateway Carrier Class NTP High Performance, High Accuracy UTC Traceable Five Nines Availability and Reliability Security and Authen+ca+on Management and Monitoring Suitable for mission- cri+cal applica+ons

Carrier- Class Timing Architecture Switch Complex IP Transport IP Microwave MSPP PRIMARY EDGE ROUTER BACKUP Data Servers SSU-2000 w/packetime NTP SERVER BLADES Other NTP Client

Changing Landscape of Telecommunica1ons

Networks are Transi1oning to IP TDM TDM TDM TDM Wireless Base Station SSU/TimeHub TDM TimeProvider Access (CES/ PWE)

Network Sync Must Transi1on Too Ethernet Ethernet Ethernet Ethernet Wireless Base Station SSU-2000 Ethernet TimeProvider Access (CES/ PWE)

Frequency Delivery Strategies Synchronization Strategies E1/T1 Packet ACR Packet E1/T1 Circuit(s) Strategy based on use of legacy PDH systems. This method is only applicable to TDM networks. Adaptive Clock Recovery A vendor specific book-end solution used to support TDMoIP services. ACR methods are not industry standard compliant. GPS Radio Good performance, supporting wide range of applications. Cost, vulnerability and maintenance issues limit wide scale use. SyncE Packet 1588-v2 Packet Synchronous Ethernet An end-to-end solution that mirrors, and is a substitute for, the physical layer frequency distribution schemes of SONET/SDH. IEEE 1588-2008 (PTP) Layer 2/3 time transfer technology that can deliver frequency and time. Alternative to SyncE for frequency distribution.

Time/Phase Delivery Strategies Synchronization Strategies 1588-v2 Packet Packet IEEE 1588-2008 (PTP) Layer 2/3 time transfer technology that can deliver frequency and time. Alternative to SyncE for frequency distribution. GPS Radio Good performance, supporting wide range of applications. Cost, vulnerability and maintenance issues limit wide scale use.

IEEE 1588-2008 Profiles IEEE 1588-2008 - 2008 defined for all applica+ons barrier to interoperability profiles define applica+on related features from the full specifica+on, enabling interoperability Power Profile Defined by IEEE PSRC (C37.238) Substation LAN Applications Telecom Profile Defined by ITU-T (G.8265.1) Telecom WAN Applications Default Profile Defined in Annex J. of 1588 specification LAN/Industrial Automation Application (v1)

What is IEEE 1588? IEEE 1588 is a protocol that enables precise distribu+on of +me and frequency over packet- based networks. IEEE 1588 was originally for a building/factory, and version- 2008 contains enhancements for Telecommunica+on networks (Telecomm Profile). The Server clock sends a series of messages to slaves to ini+ate the synchroniza+on process. Clients synchronize themselves to their Server. Network equipment manufacturers are building slaves (clients) into their latest equipment, e.g. IP DSLAM, OLT, and enodeb (LTE base sta*ons). Slave (Client) Slave (Client) Grandmaster (Server) IP Network Slave (Client)

IP Sync & Timing with IEEE- 1588 Any service where synchroniza+on over Ethernet is needed, such as: Wireless Ethernet backhaul (base sta+on synchroniza+on), below Packet PRS - primary reference over IP (IP equivalent of derived OC- N) Enterprise applica+ons requiring synchroniza+on

Extra slides that may be of use

How Is Precision Possible? Message Exchange Technique Frequent Sync messages broadcast between master & slaves, and delay measurement between slaves and master Hardware- Assisted Time Stamping Time stamp leading edge of IEEE 1588 message as it passes between the PHY and the MAC Removes O/S and stack processing delays Best Master Clock (BMC) Algorithm

IEEE 1588-2008 Traffic Impact Message Packet Sizes Signaling (request) 96 bytes (54) Signaling (ACK/NACK) 98 bytes (56) Announce message 106 bytes (64) Sync message 86 bytes (44) Follow_Up message 86 bytes (44) Delay_Resp(onse) 96 bytes (54) Delay_Req(uest) 86 bytes (44) In- band Traffic Rate Using the following typical values: Announce interval 1 per second Sync interval 64 per second Lease dura+on 300 seconds Delay_Req(uest) 64 per second Delay_Resp(onse) 64 per second Peak traffic transmihed in one second: (96x3)+(98*3)+106+64x(86+96+86) = 17840 bytes = 0.017% of Fast Ethernet (100mbps) = 0.00166% of GigE () 1588 only message size in bytes

Introducing IEEE 1588 Elements Ordinary Clocks Grandmaster & Slave (client) Boundary Clock Regenerates PTP message, elimina+ng earlier path delays (Switch with a built- in clock) Transparent Clock Adjusts the correc*on field in the sync and delay_req event messages (Switch with ability to measure packet residence +me) Management Node Human/programma+c interface to PTP management messages

On- Path Support Transparent Clock, Switch not a Clock Measures 1588 packet delay inside the switch (residence +me) Modifies (adds) residence +me to the correc*on field in the 1588 message Limited to non- encrypted networks Correc*on field must be accurate Residence Time = Egress Time Arrival Time Boundary Clock, Switch with built- in clock Internal clock synchronized via 1588 to the upstream master Regenerates 1588 messages Slave on 1 port, master on other ports Interrupts the Sync flow The burden of holdover, reliability and traceability is on the boundary clock PTP Packet PTP Packet Slave Arrival Time Egress Time GMC Transparent Clock Boundary Clock

IEEE 1588-2008 Message Overview The Grandmaster (Server) sends the following messages: Signaling (2 types) Acknowledge TLV (ACK) Nega+ve Acknowledge TLV (NACK) Announce message Sync message Follow_Up message Delay_Resp(onse) The Slave (Client) sends the following messages: Signaling (3 types) Request announce Request sync Request delay_resp(onse) Delay_Req(uest) Message Headers entering the PHY are the on-time marker

IEEE 1588 Rou1ng Op1ons Mul+cast Grandmaster broadcasts PTP packets to a Mul+cast IP address Switches/Routers With IGMP snooping, forwards mul+cast packets to subscribers Else traffic broadcast to all ports Mul+cast Sync Interval; Default Profile: 0.5 Hz, 1Hz & 2 Hz (1 packet/ 2 seconds up to 2 packets/ second) Unicast Grandmaster sends PTP packets directly to PTP slaves Switches/Routers forward PTP packets directly to slaves Unicast Sync Interval; Telecom Profile: User defined Sync interval up to 128Hz Many subscribers supported Mul+cast (1:group) Unicast (1:1)

SLA for PTP Flow Bandwidth Capacity Maximum Loading Intermi_ent Conges1on QoS Hop Count Switch A_ributes Minimum 1GigE (Core) 80% Average 100% load for less than 100s Highest Priority Frequency (10 hops) Hardware Forwarding Time (5 hops) QoS Ji_er (Highest Priority Traffic QoS) 250 us to 10 ms PTP client algorithms use only a frac+on of total packets, the ones with the best quality (low PDV). Packets with high PDV are not used. So high jiher can be tolerated if the distribu+on of the jiher includes sufficient high quality packets.

SyncE Overview What is Synchronous Ethernet? Schema that transports frequency at the Ethernet physical layer Implemented in the IP transport element hardware, i.e. SyncE enabled End to End scheme similar to SONET, synch traceable to office PRS All switches must be SyncE enabled to transport synchroniza+on ITU- T G.8261, G.8262 and G.8264 define Synchronous Ethernet CENTRAL OFFICE Ethernet Frames Frequency Transported by SYNC- E PHY SSU SyncE Switch SyncE Switch SyncE Switch SyncE Switch T1/E1 Service

SyncE Overview How is SyncE different from normal Ethernet? Standard Ethernet PHY (Physical Layer) Rx uses the incoming line +me. Tx uses the built- in 100ppm clock TX RX 100 ppm TX RX No rela*onship between the Rx & Tx SyncE PHY (Physical Layer) TX TX Rx disciplines the internal oscillator (4.6ppm) Tx uses the traceable clock reference, crea+ng end- end scheme RX 4.6 ppm RX As with SONET the PRS provides the reference SyncE and standard Ethernet switches cannot be mixed TX RX Accurate TX TX RX RX Inaccurate 100 ppm TX RX Ext.Sync 4.6 ppm SyncE Switch Ethernet Switch

Extra slides that may be of use.

Commonly Used Terms Meanings of common terms used in IEEE 1588 Boundary clock Clock Clock +mestamp point Direct communica+on External synchroniza+on Epoch A boundary clock is a clock with more than a single PTP port, with each PTP port providing access to a separate PTP communica+on path. Boundary clocks are used to eliminate fluctua+ons produced by routers and similar network elements. A device providing a measurement of the passage of +me since a defined epoch. There are two types of clocks in 1588: boundary clocks and ordinary clocks. 1588 requires the genera+on of a +mestamp on transmission or receipt of all 1588 Sync and Delay_Req messages. The point in the outbound and inbound protocol stacks where this +mestamp is generated is called the clock +mestamp point. The communica+on of PTP informa+on between two PTP clocks with no intervening boundary clock is termed a direct communica+on. It is owen desirable to synchronize a single clock to an external source of +me, for example to a GPS system to establish a UTC +me base. This synchroniza+on is accomplished by means other than those specified by 1588 and is referred to as external synchroniza+on The reference +me defining the origin of a +me scale is termed the epoch. Grandmaster clock Within a collec+on of 1588 clocks one clock, the grandmaster clock, will serve as the primary source of +me to which all others are ul+mately synchronized. hhp://ieee1588.nist.gov/terms.htm

Commonly Used Terms Meanings of common terms used in IEEE 1588 Master clock Message +mestamp point Ordinary clock Preferred master clock set PTP A system of 1588 clocks may be segmented into regions separated by boundary clocks. Within each region there will be a single clock, the master clock, serving as the primary source of +me. These master clocks will in turn synchronize to other master clocks and ul+mately to the grandmaster clock. 1588 Sync and Delay_Req messages contain a dis+nguished feature, the message +mestamp point, serving as a reference point in these messages. When the message +mestamp point passes the clock +mestamp point, a +mestamp is generated that is used by 1588 to compute the necessary correc+ons to the local clock A clock that has a single Precision Time Protocol (PTP) port in a domain and maintains the +mescale used in the domain. It may serve as a source of +me, i.e., be a master clock, or may synchronize to another clock, i.e., be a slave clock. 1588 allows the defini+on a set of clocks that will be favored over those not so designated in the selec+on of the grandmaster clock. PTP is an acronym for Precision Time Protocol, the name used in the standard for the protocol. PTP domain A PTP domain is a collec+on of one or more PTP sub domains. A sub domain is a logical grouping of 1588 clocks that synchronize to each other using the PTP protocol, but that are not necessarily synchronized to PTP clocks in another PTP sub domain. Sub domains provide a way of implemen+ng disjoint sets of clocks, sharing a common network, but maintaining independent synchroniza+on within each set. hhp://ieee1588.nist.gov/terms.htm

Commonly Used Terms Meanings of common terms used in IEEE 1588 PTP message Mul+cast communica+on PTP port There are five designated messages types defined by 1588: Sync, Delay_Req, Follow- up, Delay_Resp, and Management 1588 requires that PTP messages be communicated via a mul+cast. In this style of communica+on any node may post a message and all nodes in the same segment of a sub domain will receive this message. Boundary clocks define the segments within a sub domain. A PTP port is the logical access point for 1588 communica+ons to the clock containing the port. Synchronized clocks Two clocks are synchronized to a specified uncertainty if they have the same epoch and measurements of any +me interval by both clocks differ by no more than the specified uncertainty. The +mestamps generated by two synchronized clocks for the same event will differ by no more than the specified uncertainty. hhp://ieee1588.nist.gov/terms.htm

Synchroniza1on Impact Applica1on Frequency Phase Need for Compliance Impact of Non- compliance LTE (FDD) 16 ppb N/A Hand- off Dropped calls LTE (TDD) 16 ppb ± 1.5 µs Time difference Time slot alignment Interference, Bandwidth efficiency LTE MBSFN 16 ppb ± 32 µs inter- cell Time difference Coherent video signal from mul1ple enodeb Video service degrada1on LTE- A MIMO/CoMP 16 ppb ± 0.5 µs inter- cell Time difference Coordina1on of signals from mul1ple enodeb Slower throughput and Poor signal quality at edge of cells, Accuracy of LBS

LTE Synchroniza1on Applica1on Frequency (Air Interface) Time /Phase Why You Need to Comply Impact of Non- compliance LTE (FDD) 50 ppb N/A Call Ini+a+on Call Interference Dropped calls LTE (TDD) 50 ppb +/- 1.5 µs Time difference Time slot alignment Packet loss/collisions Bandwidth efficiency LTE MBSFN 50 ppb +/- 32 µs inter- cell Time difference Proper +me alignment of video signal decoding from mul+ple BTSs Video broadcast interrup+on LTE- A MIMO/COMP 50 ppb +/- 500 ns (0.5 µs) inter- cell Time difference Coordina+on of signals to/from mul+ple base sta+ons Poor signal quality at edge of cells WiMAX (TDD) includes Femtocell 2 ppm absolute, ~50 ppb between base sta+ons Typically 1-8 µs Time slot alignment Packet loss/collisions Bandwidth efficiency

Frequency and Time Specifica+ons Applica1on Frequency: Transport / Air Interface Phase GSM / UMTS / W-CDMA UMTS/ W- CDMA Femtocells GSM, UMTS, LTE Network Interface 16 ppb / 50 ppb n/a / 200-250 ppb 16 ppb / 50 ppb N/A CDMA2000 16 ppb / 50 ppb +/- 3 10 µs TD- SCDMA 16 ppb / 50 ppb +/- 1.5 µs LTE (FDD) LTE (TDD) LTE MBSFN LTE- A CoMP (Network MIMO) WiMAX (TDD) 16 ppb / 50 ppb 16 ppb / 50 ppb 16 ppb / 50 ppb 16 ppb / 50 ppb 16 ppb / 50 ppb N/A +/- 1.5 µs small cell, +/- 5µs large cell +/- 1-32 µs, implementa1on dependent +/- 500 ns (0.5 µs), pre- standard +/- 1-8 µs, implementa1on dependent