PennsylvaniaPublicUtilityCommission RateComparisonReport April30,2012

Transcription

1 PennsylvaniaPublicUtilityCommission RateComparisonReport April30,2012 PreparedBy: TheBureauofTechnicalUtilityServices

2 Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission Rate Comparison Report April 30, 2012 Prepared by: The Bureau of Technical Utility Services

3 The Honorable Thomas W. Corbett Governor of Pennsylvania The Honorable James F. Cawley Lieutenant Governor of Pennsylvania Members of the General Assembly, I am pleased to submit for your review the Commission s Rate Comparison Report. Act 201, signed into law on Nov. 30, 2004, added Section 308.1(b) to the Public Utility Code, 66 Pa. C.S Section 308.1(b) requires the Public Utility Commission to file an annual Rate Comparison Report (Report) with the Governor and the General Assembly on April 15, every year. The Report compares all categories of ratepayers for all electric and gas public utilities so that a reasonably accurate comparison of rates can be made between similar ratepayers receiving services in different service areas of the Commonwealth. The first section of the Report provides information on electric service. The second section provides information on natural gas service. Each section contains a comparison table of all companies followed by individual company information. Sincerely, Robert F. Powelson Chairman 1

4 Table of Contents Table of Contents 2 Introduction 4 Section 1: Electric Utilities 6 Electric Utilities Comparison 7 Electric Utilities Monthly Bill Comparison 8 Citizens Electric Company 10 Duquesne Light Company 11 Metropolitan Edison Company 12 PECO Energy Company 13 Pennsylvania Electric Company 14 Pennsylvania Power Company 15 Pike County Light & Power Company 16 PPL Electric Utilities Corporation 17 UGI Utilities Inc. - Electric 18 Wellsboro Electric Company 19 West Penn Power Company 20 Section 2: Gas Utilities 21 Gas Utilities Comparison 22 Large Gas Utilities Monthly Bill Comparison 25 Able Company Ltd. 27 Andreassi Gas Company 28 Chartiers Natural Gas Company Inc. 29 Columbia Gas of Pennsylvania Inc. 30 Corsica Gas Company 31 CRG Inc. (Clarion River Gas) 32 C.E. Dunmire Gas Company 33 Equitable Gas Company 34 Herman Oil & Gas Company Inc. 35 Herman Riemer Gas Company 36 Kaib & Kaib Gas Company 37 2

5 Larkin Oil & Gas Company 38 Mountain Energy Ltd. 39 National Fuel Gas Distribution Corporation 40 North East Heat & Light Company 41 PECO Energy Company 42 Peoples Natural Gas Company 43 Peoples TWP LLC 44 Philadelphia Gas Works 45 Pike County Light & Power Company 46 Pine-Roe Natural Gas Company Inc. 47 SAR Gas Company 48 Sigel Gas Company 49 UGI Utilities Inc. - Gas Division 50 UGI Central Penn Gas Inc. 51 UGI Penn Natural Gas Inc. 52 Valley Energy Inc. 53 Walker Gas and Oil Company 54 Wally Gas Company 55 3

6 Introduction To achieve an accurate comparison, the Commission established ratepayer categories and monthly usage parameters. These usage parameters include a demand component where applicable. The Commission also established that the rates used would be as of Jan. 31, 2012, and would be based on the Provider of Last Resort (POLR) default service for electric customers, or Supplier of Last Resort (SOLR) default service for gas customers. All rates are for ratepayers not currently purchasing their gas or electric generation from competitive suppliers (non-shoppers) and reflect a monthly bill at the given usage parameters. The ratepayer classifications and usage assumptions are detailed below. Ratepayer Classification Electric Usage Gas Usage KWH 2 MCF/month 2. Heating 2,000 KWH 15 MCF/month 3. 5 KW demand 1,000 KWH KW demand 10,000 KWH KW demand 9,000 MCF/year 200,000 KWH 6. 1,000 KW demand >9,000 MCF/year 400,000 KWH 7. Public Street Lighting (sodium vapor) 250 watts N/A KWH = Kilowatt hour, a standard measure of electricity usage calculated by multiplying total wattage by hours of use divided by 1,000, e.g. one 100-watt bulb will use 24 KWH in one month (30 days) if used eight hours a day [(100*240)/1,000 = 24 KWH]. KW = Kilowatt (1000 watts), used as a demand measure for larger users of electricity. Essentially, it is a measure of the electrical capacity required by the customer at any instantaneous moment. MCF = 1,000 cubic feet of gas, a standard measure of gas usage. It is the measure of the flow of cubic feet of gas through the meter. Street lighting is determined as the cost of running one 250-watt sodium vapor light for a month. 4

7 The Commission issued a Secretarial Letter by certified mail to the appropriate contact for every electric and gas utility. Utilities with Internet access were asked to download and fill out a rate table based on the ratepayer categories and usage parameters above. Utilities then submitted the forms via with subsequent printed copies mailed to the Commission. Utilities without Internet access were asked to fill out enclosed hard copies of the rate tables and to submit those hard copies to the Commission. The Commission is grateful for the timely response of the utility companies. The following sections present the rate tables for each utility, so an accurate comparison between utilities can be made. Section 1 begins with a comparison table that includes all of the electric utilities. After the comparison table, Section 1 presents each of the electric utilities, in alphabetical order, with their individual rate tables and a brief description of the utility, the applicable tariff number, and any unique companyspecific information that is relevant to the rate information provided. Section 2 contains the same information, also in the same format, for the gas utilities. The only exception is the beginning comparison tables, which are divided between the 1307(f) 1 and GCR 2 gas utilities. The comparison tables in the beginning of each section show the total charges for each rate classification between all of the electric and gas utilities. The individual company rate tables detail the separate pieces that make up the total charges for each rate classification. While the beginning tables of each section present the easiest measure of comparison for rates, the Commission encourages readers of this report to examine the full contents of Sections 1 and 2, to understand the components that make up the rate for any company and any unique situations that may affect the company s rates. 1 Gas utilities with more than $40 million in revenues and subject to rate filings under Section 1307(f) of the Public Utility Code, 66 Pa. C.S. 1307(f). 2 Gas utilities with revenues less than $40 million that file annual Gas Cost Rate (GCR) adjustments. 5

8 Section 1: Electric Utilities Abbreviations Used in the Tables KWH Kilowatt Hours KW Kilowatt CTC Competitive Transition Charge, for companies still recovering stranded costs ITC Intangible Transition Charge, for companies still recovering stranded costs STAS State Tax Adjustment Surcharge 6

9 Utilities Electric Utilities Comparison Citizens' Duquesne Metropolitan- PECO Pennsylvania Pennsylvania Pike County PPL Electric UGI Wellsboro West Penn Electric Light Edison Co. Energy Elec. Co. Power Co. Light & Utilities Utilities Inc. Electric Power Co. Rate Classification Company Company (FirstEnergy) Company (FirstEnergy) (FirstEnergy) Power Co. Corporation Company (FirstEnergy) using 500 KWH $56.30 $78.57 $72.42 $86.78 $73.68 $64.18 $72.77 $64.33 $64.08 $67.72 $51.66 Heating using 2000 KWH $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ (5KW Demand) using 1000 KWH $ $ $ $ $ $96.66 $ $ $ $ $90.25 (25KW Demand) using 10,000 KWH $ $ $1, $1, $ $ $1, $ $1, $1, $ (500KW Demand) using 200,000 KWH $18, $16, $23, $21, $21, $15, $22, $19, $21, $22, $15, (1000KW Demand) using 400,000 KWH $36, $33, $44, $39, $41, $24, $45, $39, $36, $39, $30, Public Street (Sodium Vapor Service) at 250 Watts $21.16 $22.69 $14.12 $19.00 $17.81 $29.48 $25.72 $26.15 $12.94 $

10 Electric Utilities Monthly Bill Comparison $89.50 $79.50 $69.50 $59.50 $49.50 $39.50 $29.50 $19.50 $9.50 ($0.50) Electric Utilities: 500 KWH Total Monthly Bill Calculation as of Jan. 31, 2012 Customer & Distribution Charges Generation & Transmission Charges CTC & ITC STAS & Other* *Other charges may include any of the following: Universal Service Charges, Education Charges, CAP charges, Systems Benefits Charges, Default Service Support Rider, or Energy Efficiency Charges related to Act 129 legislation. Please see a utility s individual chart for a breakdown of what charges can be found on its bill. 8

11 Electric Utilities Monthly Bill Comparison $ $ $ $ $ $ $89.50 $59.50 $29.50 ($0.50) Electric Utilities: Heating 2,000 KWH Total Monthly Bill Calculation as of Jan. 31, 2012 Customer & Distribution Charges Generation & Transmission Charges CTC & ITC STAS & Other* * Other charges may include any of the following: Universal Service Charges, Education Charges, CAP charges, Systems Benefits Charges, Default Service Support Rider, or Energy Efficiency Charges related to Act 129 legislation. Please see a utility s individual chart for a breakdown of what charges can be found on its bill.. 9

12 Citizens Electric Company Citizens Electric Company (Citizens ), a subsidiary of C&T Enterprises Inc., serves roughly 5,700 residential, 1,070 commercial and 40 industrial customers. Its service territory consists of Lewisburg Borough and the townships of East Buffalo, Buffalo and Kelly in Union County, as well as West Chillisquaque in Northumberland County. Citizens operates under the terms of Electric Tariff Pa. P.U.C. No. 14. With a service area of only 55 square miles, Citizens is one of the smallest electric companies both in area and in number of customers included in this rate comparison. C&T Enterprises Inc. is a holding company owned by the Claverack and Tri-County Rural Electric Cooperatives for their for-profit enterprises. C&T also owns Valley Energy Inc. (gas) and Wellsboro Electric Company. Citizens' Electric Company Default Rate Schedule for Electric Service in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Customer Distribution Generation (Energy) Transmission CTC ITC Universal Rate Classification Charge Charges Charges** Charges (if applicable) (if applicable) Service GRT*** STAS TOTAL using 500 KWH $8.00 $10.61 $35.59 $2.10 $0.00 $56.30 Heating using 2000 KWH (5KW Demand) using 1000 KWH (25KW Demand) using 10,000 KWH (500KW Demand) using 200,000 KWH (1000KW Demand) using 400,000 KWH $8.00 $42.44 $ $8.41 ($0.01) $ $13.25 $25.50 $71.18 $4.20 ($0.01) $ $13.25 $ $ $42.03 ($0.05) $ $50.22 $2, $14, $ ($1.02) $18, $50.22 $5, $28, $1, ($2.03) $36, Public Street* (Sodium Vapor Service) at 250 Watts Notes: *Citizens does not tarriff 250 watt lights, only 100 flat rate of $10.93 per month and per month. **Transmission is bundled in generation rates ***GRT - Gross Receipt Tax Shopping Update: As of January 31, 2012, there were no electric generation suppliers making offers within Citizen s service territory. Competition has yet to penetrate the markets of small EDCs. As soon as suppliers begin making offers within Citizen s territory, shopping information, as well as the current price to compare, will be available at 10

13 Duquesne Light Company Duquesne Light Company (Duquesne), a subsidiary of Duquesne Light Holdings, serves approximately 525,000 residential, 54,200 commercial and 1,160 industrial customers. Duquesne s service territory consists of parts of Allegheny, Beaver, and Westmoreland counties, in Western Pennsylvania. Duquesne operates under the terms of Electric Tariff Pa. P.U.C. No. 24. On February 24, 2011, the Commission approved a settlement allowing for a $45.7 million (3.5%) base rate increase for Duquesne. Duquesne Light Company Default Rate Schedule for Electric Service in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Customer Distribution Generation (Energy) Transmission Universal Smart Meter EECDR*** Education Rate Classification Charge Charges Charges Charges Service Charge Surcharge Charges STAS* TOTAL using 500 KWH $7.00 $21.83 $39.30 Heating $7.29 $1.86 $0.72 $0.55 $0.20 ($0.18) $78.57 using 2000 KWH $7.00 $64.35 $ $21.68 $7.42 $0.72 $2.20 $0.20 ($0.46) $ (5KW Demand) using 1000 KWH $30.00 $11.16 $56.95 $14.92 $0.72 $0.30 $0.09 ($0.24) $ (25KW Demand) using 10,000 KWH $43.00 $ $ $ $0.72 $3.00 $0.08 ($1.34) $ ** (500KW Demand) using 200,000 KWH $3, $10, $1, $0.72 $ $0.37 ($23.75) $16, ** (1000KW Demand) using 400,000 KWH $7, $20, $3, $0.72 Public Street (Sodium Vapor Service) at 250 Watts $14.29 $6.42 $0.53 $1, $0.37 ($49.78) $33, ($0.08) $21.16 Notes: *Effective 1/21/12, Rider 10, STAS (Part 1) is set at % and applied to all distribution charges of customer bills; STAS (Part 2) is set at 0.% and applied to all portions of customer bills. **All Duquesne customers with a peak demand greater than 300 KW are enrolled in an hourly price plan for the generation component of their bill. The generation rate used for this report was a calculated average based on historic hourly price service data throughout the past year. ***Act 129, Energy Efficiency and Conservation and Demand Response Surcharge. Shopping Update: As of January 31, 2012, there were 22 electric generation suppliers (EGSs) making offers within Duquesne s service territory. Furthermore, there were 202,061 total customers shopping, which represents 34.3% of customers and 69.3% of total load. Additional information, including Duquesne s current price to compare and actual residential customer price offerings by EGSs in Duquesne s service territory, is available at 11

14 Metropolitan Edison Company Metropolitan Edison Company (Met-Ed), a subsidiary of FirstEnergy Corporation, serves approximately 487,000 residential, 63,500 commercial and 1,720 industrial customers. Met-Ed s service territory consists of parts of the Easton, Lebanon and Reading areas in Eastern Pennsylvania and the York Area in South Central Pennsylvania. The total service area is roughly 3,300 square miles. Met-Ed operates under the terms of Electric Tariff Pa. P.U.C. No. 50. FirstEnergy Corporation, headquartered in Akron, Ohio, is one of the country s largest investor-owned electric systems, serving approximately 6 million customers through its ten electric utility operating companies in Pennsylvania, Ohio, Maryland, West Virginia and New Jersey. Other FirstEnergy electric utility operating companies in Pennsylvania are the Pennsylvania Electric Company, Pennsylvania Power Company, and West Penn Power Company. Metropolitan Edison Company Default Rate Schedule for Electric Service in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Customer Distribution Generation (Energy) CTC Energy Smart Universal Education Rate Classification Charge Charges Charges (if applicable) DSSR* Efficiency Meter Service Charges STAS TOTAL using 500 KWH $8.11 $11.64 $45.46 $2.35 ($1.50) $1.81 $1.11 $3.39 $0.14 ($0.09) $72.42 Heating using 2000 KWH $11.00 $34.22 $ $9.38 ($4.78) $7.22 $1.11 $13.54 $0.56 ($0.30) $ (5KW Demand) using 1000 KWH $10.88 $12.64 $86.56 $10.22 ($3.69) $1.69 $1.11 $0.05 ($0.14) $ (25KW Demand) using 10,000 KWH $21.52 $ $ $ ($36.90) $16.90 $1.11 (500KW Demand) using 200,000 KWH $60.98 $1, $20, $2, ($710.00) $ $1.25 $0.50 ($1.29) $10.00 ($28.19) $1, $23, (1000KW Demand) using 400,000 KWH $ $1, $40, $2, ($1,336.00) $ $1.25 ($53.18) $44, Public Street (Sodium Vapor Service) at 250 Watts $9.86 $8.48 $1.00 ($0.22) $3.60 ($0.03) $22.69 Notes: The and rates are billed generation based on hourly pricing. The generation cost per kwh used to calculate the generation portion was based on the calendar year 2011 average hourly rate. *Default Service Support Rider Shopping Update: As of January 31, 2012, there were 16 electric generation suppliers (EGSs) making offers within Met-Ed s service territory. Furthermore, there were 77,560 total customers shopping, which represents 14% of customers and 50.4% of total load. Additional information, including Met-Ed s current price to compare and actual residential customer price offerings by EGSs in Met-Ed s service territory, is available at 12

15 PECO Energy Company PECO Energy Company (PECO), a subsidiary of the Exelon Corporation (Exelon), serves approximately 1.4 million residential, 157,000 small commercial and industrial, and 3,100 large commercial and industrial customers. PECO s service territory consists of parts of the following counties in Southeastern Pennsylvania: Philadelphia; Bucks; Delaware; Montgomery; Chester; and York. PECO operates under the terms of Electric Tariff Pa. P.U.C. No. 3. PECO also provides gas service to approximately 490,000 customers in the Philadelphia area. Exelon, through its utility operating companies, is one of the nation s largest electric utilities. Exelon is headquartered in Chicago and provides service to approximately 6.6 million customers in Illinois, Maryland, and Pennsylvania. PECO Energy Company Default Rate Schedule for Electric Service in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Customer Distribution Generation (Energy Transmission Smart Universal Education Energy Rate Classification Charge Charges Charges Charges Metering AEPS** TARC*** Service Charges STAS Efficiency TOTAL using 500 KWH $7.11 $27.60 $45.90 $3.70 $1.40 ($0.45) ($0.25) $0.09 ($0.02) $1.70 $86.78 Heating using 2000 KWH $7.11 $71.60 $ $14.80 $5.60 ($1.80) ($1.00) $0.09 ($0.04) $6.80 $ (5KW Demand) using 1000 KWH $10.86 $29.70 $93.06 $12.85 $2.16 ($0.60) $0.09 ($0.02) $2.70 $ (25KW Demand) using 10,000 KWH $10.86 $ $ $64.25 $2.16 ($6.00) $0.09 ($0.10) $27.00 $1, (500KW Demand) using 200,000 KWH $ $2, $18, $1, $2.15 ($40.00) $0.01 ($1.44) $ $21, * (1000KW Demand) using 400,000 KWH $ $4, $31, $2, $2.15 $40.00 ($80.00) $0.01 ($2.73) $ $39, Public Street (Sodium Vapor Service) at 250 Watts $7.11 $0.43 $6.25 $0.11 ($0.24) $0.46 $14.12 Notes: *For the class, GSA 4 Hourly Pricing Option for Rate HT was used for calculation. **Alternative Energy Portfolio Standards ***Tax Accounting Repair Credit Shopping Update: As of January 31, 2012, there were 41 electric generation suppliers (EGSs) making offers within PECO s service territory. Furthermore, there were 409,002 total customers shopping, which represents 26% of customers and 57% of total load. Additional information, including PECO s current price to compare and actual residential customer price offerings by EGSs in PECO s service territory, is available at 13

16 Pennsylvania Electric Company Pennsylvania Electric Company (Penelec), a subsidiary of the FirstEnergy Corporation, serves approximately 506,000 residential, 81,600 commercial and 2,250 industrial customers. Penelec s service territory consists of 17,600 square miles spanning more than 30 counties throughout mostly rural areas of Northern and Central Pennsylvania. Penelec operates under the terms of Electric Tariff Pa. P.U.C. No. 79. FirstEnergy Corporation, headquartered in Akron, Ohio, is one of the country s largest investor-owned electric systems, serving approximately 6 million customers through its ten electric utility operating companies in Pennsylvania, Ohio, Maryland, West Virginia and New Jersey. Other FirstEnergy electric utility operating companies in Pennsylvania are the Metropolitan Edison Company, Pennsylvania Power Company, and West Penn Power Company. Pennsylvania Electric Company Default Rate Schedule for Electric Service in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Customer Distribution Generation (Energy) CTC Energy Smart Universal Education Rate Classification Charge Charges Charges (if applicable) DSSR* Efficiency Meter Service Charges STAS TOTAL using 500 KWH $7.98 $14.90 $41.04 $2.41 $0.25 $1.89 $1.30 $3.95 $0.17 ($0.21) $73.68 Heating using 2000 KWH $11.24 $57.45 $ $9.62 $1.50 $7.54 $1.30 $15.78 $0.66 ($0.75) $ (5KW Demand) using 1000 KWH $7.73 $16.29 $75.80 ($0.19) ($0.77) $1.45 $1.33 $0.04 ($0.28) $ (25KW Demand) using 10,000 KWH $14.95 $ $ ($1.90) ($7.70) $14.50 $1.33 $0.40 ($2.57) $ (500KW Demand) using 200,000 KWH $41.29 $2, $18, ($38.00) ($148.00) $ $1.35 $8.00 ($59.24) $21, (1000KW Demand) using 400,000 KWH $ $2, $36, $1, ($272.00) $ $1.35 Public Street (Sodium Vapor Service) at 250 Watts $8.21 $8.34 ($0.02) ($0.02) $2.54 ($115.42) $41, ($0.05) $19.00 Notes: The and rates are billed generation based on hourly pricing. The generation cost per kwh used to calulate the generation portion was based on the calendar year 2011 average hourly rate. *Default Service Support Rider Shopping Update: As of January 31, 2012, there were 10 electric generation suppliers (EGSs) making offers within Penelec s service territory. Furthermore, there were 107,237 total customers shopping, which represents 18.2% of customers and 56.9% of total load. Additional information, including Penelec s current price to compare and actual residential customer price offerings by EGSs in Penelec s service territory, is available at 14

17 Pennsylvania Power Company Pennsylvania Power Company (Penn Power), a subsidiary of FirstEnergy Corporation, serves approximately 140,000 residential, 19,600 commercial and 210 industrial customers. Penn Power s service territory consists of 1,100 square miles in parts of the following Western Pennsylvania counties: Allegheny; Beaver; Butler; Crawford; Lawrence; Mercer; and Venango. Penn Power operates under the terms of Electric Tariff Pa. P.U.C. No. 33. FirstEnergy Corporation, headquartered in Akron, Ohio, is one of the country s largest investor-owned electric systems, serving approximately 6 million customers through its ten electric utility operating companies in Pennsylvania, Ohio, Maryland, West Virginia and New Jersey. Other FirstEnergy electric utility operating companies in Pennsylvania are the Metropolitan Edison Company, Pennsylvania Electric Company, and West Penn Power Company. Pennsylvania Power Company Default Rate Schedule for Electric Service in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Customer Distribution Generation (Energy) Transmission Energy Smart Universal Rate Classification Charge Charges Charges Charges Efficiency Meter Service DSSR* STAS TOTAL using 500 KWH $8.89 $11.07 $37.19 $1.30 $1.36 $3.20 $0.74 $0.43 $64.18 Heating using 2000 KWH $8.86 $30.60 $ $5.18 $1.36 $12.80 $2.94 $1.41 $ (5KW Demand) using 1000 KWH $14.44 $8.71 $69.87 $1.29 $1.43 $0.28 $0.64 $96.66 (25KW Demand) using 10,000 KWH $14.44 $95.85 $ $12.90 $1.43 $2.80 $5.54 $ (500KW Demand) using 200,000 KWH $1, $13, $ $1.43 (1000KW Demand) using 400,000 KWH $1, $21, $ $1.43 $46.00 $ $15, $12.28 $ $24, Public Street (Sodium Vapor Service) at 250 Watts $9.15 $6.85 $1.67 $0.02 $0.12 $17.81 Notes: The Indusrtial rates are billed generation based on hourly pricing. The generation cost per kwh used to calculate the generation portion was calendar year 2011 average hourly rate. *Default Service Support Rider Shopping Update: As of January 31, 2012, there were 3 electric generation suppliers (EGSs) making offers within Penn Power s service territory. Furthermore, there were 39,993 total customers shopping, which represents 24.9% of customers and 57.6% of total load. Additional information, including Penn Power s current price to compare and actual residential customer price offerings by EGSs in Penn Power s service territory, is available at 15

18 Pike County Light & Power Company Pike County Light & Power Company (Pike), a subsidiary of Orange & Rockland Utilities Inc., serves approximately 3,660 residential and 1,000 commercial customers. Pike s service territory consists of Westfall, Milford and Dingman (northern section) townships, and Matamoras and Milford boroughs in Pike County, Northeastern Pennsylvania. Pike operates under the terms of Electric Tariff Pa. P.U.C. No. 8. Pike also provides natural gas service in Pennsylvania in Westfall Township and Matamoras Borough, Pike County. Orange & Rockland Utilities Inc. (O&R), through subsidiaries Pike County Light & Power and Rockland Electric Company, provides service to roughly 300,000 electric and 130,000 natural gas customers. Based in Pearl River, New York, O&R s service area covers 1,350 square miles in Southeastern New York, Northern New Jersey and Northeastern Pennsylvania. Default Rate Schedule for Electric Service in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Customer Distribution Generation (Energy) Transmission CTC ITC Universal Rate Classification Charge Charges* Charges*** Charges (if applicable) (if applicable) Service SBC** STAS TOTAL using 500 KWH $6.25 $27.53 $38.50 $0.47 $0.02 $72.77 Heating Pike County Light & Power Company using 2000 KWH $6.25 $ $ $1.87 $0.06 $ (5KW Demand) using 1000 KWH $10.00 $46.35 $69.88 $0.04 $ (25KW Demand) using 10,000 KWH $10.00 $ $ $0.23 $1, (500KW Demand) using 200,000 KWH $ $6, $16, $1.98 $22, (1000KW Demand) using 400,000 KWH $ $12, $32, $3.89 $45, Public Street (Sodium Vapor Service) at 250 Watts $20.98 $8.48 $0.02 $29.48 Notes: *Distribution Charges includes transmission charges. The demand components are included where applicable. **System Benefits Charges ***Pike's default generation rate is a spot rate that is set monthly, based on a forecast of market prices and a reconciliation of prior-period costs. The rate used for this report was the one in effect on Jan. 31, Pike customers also have the option of participating in a fixed price retail aggregation plan provided by Direct Energy. Shopping Update: As of January 31, 2012, there were 3 electric generation suppliers (EGSs) making offers within Pike s service territory. Furthermore, there were 3,148 total customers shopping, which represents 68% of customers and 53% of total load. Additional information, including Pike s current price to compare and actual residential customer price offerings by EGSs in Pike s service territory, is available at 16

19 PPL Electric Utilities Corporation PPL Electric Utilities Corporation (PPL), a subsidiary of the PPL Corporation, serves approximately 1.22 million residential, 172,000 commercial and 4,400 industrial customers. PPL s service territory consists of parts of the following counties in Eastern Pennsylvania: Berks; Bucks; Carbon; Chester; Clinton; Columbia; Cumberland; Dauphin; Juniata; Lackawanna; Lancaster; Lebanon; Lehigh; Luzerne; Lycoming; Monroe; Montgomery; Montour; Northampton; Northumberland; Perry, Pike; Schuylkill; Snyder; Susquehanna; Union; Wyoming; Wayne; and York. PPL operates under the terms of Electric Tariff Pa. P.U.C. No PPL Corporation, headquartered in Allentown, Lehigh County, delivers energy to more than 10 million customers in Kentucky, Pennsylvania, and the United Kingdom. PPL Electric Utilities Corporation Default Rate Schedule for Electric Service in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Customer Distribution Generation (Energy) Transmission CTC ITC Smart Act 129 Rate Classification Charge Charges* Charges Charges (if applicable) (if applicable) Meter Charges STAS TOTAL using 500 KWH $8.75 $16.82 $35.20 $3.76 ($0.20) $64.33 Heating using 2000 KWH $18.06 $28.50 $ $15.04 ($0.60) $ (5KW Demand) using 1000 KWH $14.00 $22.65 $59.00 $8.94 $0.05 $3.33 ($0.34) $ (25KW Demand) using 10,000 KWH $30.00 $ $ $89.40 $0.50 $33.30 ($2.54) $ ** (500KW Demand) using 200,000 KWH $ $1, $17, $ $0.22 $ ($56.72) $19, ** (1000KW Demand) using 400,000 KWH $ $2, $35, $1, $0.22 $ ($112.90) $39, Public Street (Sodium Vapor Service) at 250 Watts $17.71 $6.69 $1.01 $0.01 $0.38 ($0.08) $25.72 Notes: *USR, EE&C, and Smart Meter charges are included in the distribution prices for rates. **Default service for 500KW and 1000KW customers is Real Time Pricing (RTP). Generation charges are average of lmp for 2011 including adders, line-loss, and GRT. Shopping Update: As of January 31, 2012, there were 34 electric generation suppliers (EGSs) making offers within PPL s service territory. Furthermore, there were 587,903 total customers shopping, which represents 41.9% of customers and 75.5% of total load. Additional information, including PPL s current price to compare and actual residential customer price offerings by EGSs in PPL s service territory, is available at 17

20 UGI Utilities Inc. - Electric UGI Utilities Inc. (UGI), a subsidiary of UGI Corporation, serves approximately 54,600 residential, 7,400 commercial and 160 industrial customers. UGI s service territory consists of parts of Luzerne and Wyoming counties in Northeastern Pennsylvania. UGI operates under the terms of Electric Tariff Pa. P.U.C. No. 5. UGI also provides natural gas service in Pennsylvania. UGI Corporation, with principal offices in King of Prussia, Montgomery County, provides electric, gas, propane gas, and energy supply through its subsidiaries UGI Utilities Inc., AmeriGas Inc. and UGI Enterprises Inc. UGI Utilities Inc. - Electric Division Default Rate Schedule for Electric Service in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Customer Distribution Generation (Energy) Transmission CTC ITC Universal Education Rate Classification Charge Charges Charges Charges (if applicable) (if applicable) Service Charges STAS TOTAL using 500 KWH $5.50 $15.83 $39.49 $1.85 $0.56 $0.07 $0.78 $64.08 Heating using 2000 KWH $5.50 $48.96 $ $7.40 $2.20 $0.28 $2.73 $ (5KW Demand) using 1000 KWH $6.75 $40.35 $84.77 $3.11 $0.14 $1.66 $ (25KW Demand) using 10,000 KWH $ $ $20.95 $14.93 $1, (500KW Demand) using 200,000 KWH $3, $16, $ $ $21, * (1000KW Demand) using 400,000 KWH $6, $28, $ Public Street (Sodium Vapor Service) at 250 Watts $8.45 $5.61 $11.78 $ $36, $0.31 $26.15 Notes: *Customers with demand > 500 kw are billed on an hourly basis for actual costs incurred. The generation charges shown above were calculated using the average rate billed for these customers during calendar year The distribution and transmission charges use tariff rates. Shopping Update: As of January 31, 2012, there were no electric generation suppliers making offers to residential customers within UGI s service territory. However, as of January 25, 2012, 1% of customers in UGI s service territory chose an electric generation supplier, accounting for 18% of load. When suppliers resume making offers to residential customers within UGI s territory, shopping information will be available at 18

21 Wellsboro Electric Company Wellsboro Electric Company (Wellsboro), a subsidiary of C&T Enterprises Inc., serves approximately 5,000 residential, 1,130 commercial and 14 industrial customers. Wellsboro s service territory consists of about 178 square miles in the Borough of Wellsboro, and the townships of Charleston, Delmar and Middlebury in Tioga County in North Central Pennsylvania. Wellsboro operates under the terms of Electric Tariff Pa. P.U.C. No. 8. C&T Enterprises Inc. is a holding company owned by the Claverack and Tri-County rural electric cooperatives for for-profit enterprises. C&T also owns Valley Energy Inc. (gas), and Citizens Electric Company. Default Rate Schedule for Electric Service in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Customer Distribution Generation (Energy) Demand CTC ITC Universal Education Rate Classification Charge Charges Charges Charges (if applicable) (if applicable) Service Charges STAS TOTAL Heating Wellsboro Electric Company using 500 KWH $9.75 $18.68 $39.29 $67.72 using 2000 KWH $9.75 $61.65 $ $0.02 $ (5KW Demand) using 1000 KWH $10.00 $58.94 $78.57 $0.01 $ (25KW Demand) using 10,000 KWH $28.00 $ $ $ $0.07 $1, (500KW Demand) using 200,000 KWH $28.00 $3, $15, $2, $1.46 $22, (1000KW Demand) using 400,000 KWH $42.90 $1, $31, $6, Public Street (Sodium Vapor Service) at 250 Watts $7.60 $5.34 $2.64 $39, $12.94 Notes: Public Street (Sodium Vapor) is at 150 watts. Shopping Update: As of January 31, 2012, there were no electric generation suppliers making offers within Wellsboro s service territory. Competition has yet to penetrate the markets of small EDCs. As soon as suppliers begin making offers within Wellsboro s territory, shopping information, as well as the current price to compare, will be available at 19

22 West Penn Power Company West Penn Power Company (West Penn), a subsidiary of FirstEnergy Corporation, serves approximately 620,000 residential, 82,800 commercial and 13,470 industrial customers. West Penn s service territory consists of portions of 24 counties throughout Southwestern and Central Pennsylvania. West Penn operates under the terms of Electric Tariff Pa. P.U.C. No. 39. FirstEnergy Corporation, headquartered in Akron, Ohio, is one of the country s largest investor-owned electric systems, serving approximately 6 million customers through its ten electric utility operating companies in Pennsylvania, Ohio, Maryland, West Virginia and New Jersey. Other FirstEnergy electric utility operating companies in Pennsylvania are the Metropolitan Edison Company, Pennsylvania Electric Company, and Pennsylvania Power Company. West Penn Power Company Default Rate Schedule for Electric Service in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Customer Distribution Generation (Energy) Transmission Energy First Energy Smart Energy Rate Classification Charge Charges Charges Charges Cost Adj. Merger Credit Meter Efficiency STAS TOTAL using 500 KWH $5.00 $9.37 $32.55 $2.26 $1.19 ($0.48) $0.98 $0.88 ($0.09) $51.66 Heating using 2000 KWH $5.00 $37.48 $ $9.04 $4.74 ($0.48) $3.90 $3.50 ($0.35) $ (5KW Demand) using 1000 KWH $19.63 $62.81 $3.90 $0.71 $2.13 $1.23 ($0.16) $90.25 (25KW Demand) using 10,000 KWH $ $ $39.00 $7.10 $2.13 $12.30 ($1.53) $ (500KW Demand) using 200,000 KWH $1, $12, $ ($4.00) $2.66 $ ($27.73) $15, (1000KW Demand) using 400,000 KWH $3, $25, $1, ($8.00) Public Street (Sodium Vapor Service) at 250 Watts $12.36 $5.33 $0.34 $0.06 $2.66 $ ($55.36) $30, ($0.03) $18.06 Notes: and power factor assumed to be 85%. and use Rate 30 (small) Generation and ECA rates as a proxy since such customers are billed via spot market. PLC Demand assumed equal to kw Demand. Sodium Vapor Overhead Service (cobra head) is per Rate Schedule 57 at 200W. Shopping Update: As of January 31, 2012, there were 8 electric generation suppliers (EGSs) making offers within West Penn s service territory. Furthermore, there were 121,592 total customers shopping, which represents 17.1% of customers and 45.2% of total load. Additional information, including West Penn s current price to compare and actual residential customer price offerings by EGSs in West Penn s service territory, is available at 20

23 Section 2: Gas Utilities Abbreviations Used in the Tables MCF One Thousand Cubic Feet, a standard gas measure TCC Transition Cost Charge, for companies still recovering stranded costs CCC Customer Choice Costs, for companies still recovering stranded costs GCR Gas Cost Rate STAS State Tax Adjustment Surcharge USC Universal Service Charge 21

24 Gas Utilities Comparison (f) Companies* Utilities Columbia Equitable National PECO Peoples Peoples Philadelphia UGI UGI Central UGI Penn Gas of Gas Fuel Gas Energy Natural Gas TWP LLC Gas Works Utilities Penn Gas Natural Gas Rate Classification PA Inc. Company Dist. Co. Company Company (PGW) Inc. - Gas Inc. Co. Inc. 2 MCF $30.29 $33.47 $31.46 $31.82 $31.56 $34.40 $42.11 $29.24 $38.66 $32.58 Heating 15 MCF $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $5, $6, $5, $6, $5, $7, $9, $6, $5, > $6, $6, $5, $7, $5, $16, $10, * 1307(f) companies are those companies whose annual revenues are greater than $40 million. 22

25 Gas Utilities Comparison - GCR Companies* Utilities Able Co. Andreassi Chartiers Corsica CRG C.E. Dunmire Herman Oil & Herman Kaib & Kaib Larkin Oil Ltd. Gas Co. Natural Gas Gas Co. Inc. Gas Co. Gas Co. Inc. Riemer Gas Co. & Gas Co. Rate Classification Co. Inc. Gas Co. 2 MCF $45.00 $33.86 $35.10 $28.00 $30.15 $25.00 $15.87 $17.62 $16.50 $13.02 Heating 15 MCF $45.00 $ $ $ $ $ $ $78.82 $88.00 $69.44 $ $ $ $ $ $67.06 $74.25 $ $ $ $ $ $ $6, $9, $7, $7, $3, > $7, *Gas companies with annual revenues less than $40 million that file annual Gas Cost Rate (GCR) adjustments. 23

26 Gas Utilities Comparison - GCR Companies Utilities Mountain North East Pike County Pine-Roe SAR Sigel Gas Valley Walker Gas & Wally Energy Ltd. Heat & Light Light & Power Natural Gas Gas Co. Co. Energy Oil Co. Gas Co. Rate Classification Co. Co. Co. Inc. Inc. 2 MCF $19.00 $25.37 $25.37 $16.09 $24.00 $24.01 $28.43 $28.35 $29.16 Heating 15 MCF $97.00 $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $6, $6, $6, $6, $6, > $6, $6, $6, $5, $6,

27 Large Gas Utilities Monthly Bill Comparison $44.50 $39.50 $34.50 $29.50 $24.50 $19.50 $14.50 $9.50 $4.50 ($0.50) Large Gas Utilities (over 1,000 customers): 2 MCF Total Monthly Bill Calculation as of Jan. 31, 2012 Customer & Distribution Charges Gas Commodity & GCR Adjustment Other* *Other charges may include any of the following: STAS, Universal Service Charge, Capacity Charge, Education Charge, or Merchant Function Charge. Please see a utility s individual chart for a breakdown of what charges can be found on its bill. 25

28 Large Gas Utilities Monthly Bill Comparison $ Large Gas Utilities (over 1,000 customers): Heating 15 MCF Total Monthly Bill Calculation as of Jan. 31, 2012 $ $ $ $ $89.50 $59.50 $29.50 ($0.50) Customer & Distribution Charges Gas Commodity & GCR Adjustment Other* * Other charges may include any of the following: STAS, Universal Service Charge, Capacity Charge, Education Charge, or Merchant Function Charge. Please see a utility s individual chart for a breakdown of what charges can be found on its bill. 26

29 Able Company Ltd. Able Company Ltd. (Able) provides natural gas service in Kittanning Township and Wayne Township in Armstrong County, Upper Burrell and Hempfield townships in Westmoreland County, and Armstrong Township in Indiana County. Able operates under Gas Tariff Pa. P.U.C. No. 1. Able provides a flat rate for all thousand cubic feet (MCF) of gas consumed for both residential and commercial customers. rates are gauged according to the square footage of a building and consist of the following categories: mobile home; detached garage with gas heater; and house and swimming pool with heater. For the purpose of this report, the residential rate was calculated using a house consisting of between 1,300 and 1,500 square feet, and a commercial building consisting of between 2,000 to 3,000 feet. Able Company Ltd. Default Rate Schedule for Gas Service in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Customer Commodity Distribution GCR Customer Universal Education Rate Classification Charge Charge Charge Adjustment Choice Costs Service Charge Charge STAS TOTAL 2 MCF $45.00 $45.00 Heating 15 MCF $45.00 $45.00 $ $ > Notes: Able charges flat monthly rates based on the square footage of the customers' buildings. 27

30 Andreassi Gas Company Andreassi Gas Company provides natural gas service to the public in portions of Armstrong and Butler counties. The company currently provides service to approximately 350 residential customers and 20 commercial customers. Andreassi operates under Gas Tariff Pa. P.U.C. No. 2. Andreassi Gas Company Default Rate Schedule for Gas Service in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Customer Commodity Distribution GCR Customer Universal Education Rate Classification Charge Charge Charge Adjustment Choice Costs Service Charge Charge STAS TOTAL 2 MCF $15.00 $18.66 $0.20 $33.86 Heating 15 MCF $15.00 $ $1.49 $ $15.00 $ $1.24 $ $15.00 $ $4.13 $ $15.00 $6, $74.42 $6, > 28

31 Chartiers Natural Gas Company Inc. Chartiers Natural Gas Company Inc. (Chartiers) provides natural gas service to the public in the Munntown, Nottingham and North Strabane townships, and in various isolated lease areas in Washington and Allegheny counties. Chartiers provides natural gas to approximately 260 residential customers and 10 commercial customers throughout the designated service territory. Chartiers operates under Gas Tariff Pa. P.U.C. No. 1. Chartiers Natural Gas Co. Inc. Default Rate Schedule for Gas Service in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Customer Commodity Distribution GCR Customer Universal Education Rate Classification Charge Charge Charge Adjustment Choice Costs Service Charge Charge 2 MCF $12.00 $21.33 $1.77 Heating 15 MCF $12.00 $ $13.27 STAS TOTAL $35.10 $ > $15.00 $ $11.06 $15.00 $ $36.87 $15.00 $8, $ $ $ $9,

32 Columbia Gas of Pennsylvania Inc. Columbia Gas of Pennsylvania Inc. (Columbia), a subsidiary of NiSource Inc., is a provider of gas service to the public in the following counties: Adams; Allegheny; Armstrong; Beaver; Bedford; Butler; Centre; Clarion; Crawford; Elk; Fayette; Franklin; Fulton; Green; Indiana; Jefferson; Lawrence; McKean; Mercer; Somerset; Venango; Warren; Washington; Westmoreland; and York. Columbia currently provides service to approximately 377,000 residential customers, 37,300 commercial customers, and 290 industrial customers. Columbia operates under Gas Tariff Pa. P.U.C. No. 9. NiSource Inc., based in Merrillville, Indiana, delivers energy to nearly 4 million customers throughout the United States. NiSource is the second-largest natural gas distributor in the U.S. On October 14, 2011, the Commission approved a settlement allowing for a $17 million base rate increase for Columbia. Columbia Gas of Pennsylvania Inc. Default Rate Schedule for Gas Service in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Customer Commodity Distribution GCR Customer Universal Education Rate Classification Charge Charge Charge Adjustment Choice Costs Service Charge Charge STAS TOTAL 2 MCF $18.73 $10.28 $1.64 ($1.29) $0.95 ($0.02) $30.29 Heating 15 MCF $18.73 $75.96 $49.57 ($9.65) $7.11 ($0.06) $ > $20.18 $64.27 $37.80 ($8.05) $20.18 $ $ ($26.82) $ $3, $1, ($482.70) $ $3, $2, ($536.33) ($0.06) $ ($38.32) $ ($1.47) $5, ($2.02) $6, Notes: Commodity Charge for small and medium commercial reflects refund of Tennessee Gas Pipeline Settlement per PUC Order of 4/19/10 at Docket No. P > 9,000 MCF/year was calculated using 10,000 MCF/year. 30

33 Corsica Gas Company Corsica Gas Company (Corsica) serves about 26 residential customers in portions of Union and Elder townships in Jefferson County, Western Pennsylvania. Corsica operates under Gas Tariff Pa. P.U.C. No. 1. Corsica Gas Co. Default Rate Schedule for Gas Service in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Customer Commodity Distribution GCR Customer Universal Education Rate Classification Charge Charge Charge Adjustment Choice Costs Service Charge Charge STAS TOTAL 2 MCF $10.00 $18.00 $28.00 Heating 15 MCF $10.00 $ $ > 31

34 CRG Inc. (Clarion River Gas) CRG Inc. (CRG), owned by Orwell Natural Gas Co., provides natural gas service to the public in the townships of Farmington, Highland and Millcreek in Clarion County; Millstone, Elk County; Barnett and Jenks, Forest County; and Barnett, Eldred and Heath in Jefferson County. CRG provides service to roughly 300 residential customers and 25 commercial customers. CRG operates under Gas Tariff Pa. P.U.C. No. 1. Orwell Natural Gas Company, based in Mentor, Ohio, owns the Pennsylvania gas utilities of CRG and Walker. CRG Inc. (Clarion River Gas) Default Rate Schedule for Gas Service in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Customer Commodity Distribution GCR Customer Universal Education Rate Classification Charge Charge Charge Adjustment Choice Costs Service Charge Charge STAS TOTAL 2 MCF $11.48 $17.81 $0.86 $30.15 Heating 15 MCF $11.48 $ $6.45 $ $11.48 $ $5.37 $ $11.48 $ $17.91 $ $11.48 $7, $ $7, > $11.48 $7, $ $7,

35 C.E. Dunmire Gas Company C.E. Dunmire Gas Company (Dunmire) furnishes gas service to roughly 50 residential customers and five commercial customers in portions of North Buffalo, East Franklin and Washington townships in Armstrong County. Dunmire operates under Gas Tariff Pa. P.U.C. No. 1. C.E. Dunmire Gas Co. Inc. Default Rate Schedule for Gas Service in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Customer Commodity Distribution GCR Customer Universal Education Rate Classification Charge Charge Charge Adjustment Choice Costs Service Charge Charge STAS TOTAL 2 MCF $9.00 $16.00 $25.00 Heating 15 MCF $9.00 $ $ $18.00 $ $ $18.00 $ $ $18.00 $7, $7, > 33

36 Equitable Gas Company Equitable Gas Company (Equitable) is a division of Equitable Resources Inc., a gas supplier to customers in Pennsylvania, Kentucky and West Virginia. In Pennsylvania, Equitable provides gas service to the City of Pittsburgh, and various boroughs and townships in Allegheny, Armstrong, Butler, Clarion, Fayette, Greene, Indiana, Jefferson, Washington and Westmoreland counties. Equitable operates under Gas Tariff Pa. P.U.C. No. 22. Equitable s tariff lists two divisions -- Equitable and Apollo -- although the same rates are applied to both divisions. Equitable has approximately 227,000 residential customers, 14,200 commercial customers and 40 industrial customers. Equitable Gas Company Default Rate Schedule for Gas Service in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Customer Commodity Distribution GCR Transition Universal Education Rate Classification Charge Charge Charge Adjustment Surcharge Service Charge Charge STAS TOTAL 2 MCF $13.25 $11.90 $6.72 $0.64 $0.96 $33.47 Heating 15 MCF $13.25 $89.25 $50.43 $4.80 $7.20 $ $17.00 $74.38 $33.89 $4.00 $ $28.00 $ $ $13.31 $ $ $4, $1, $ $6, * > $ $4, $1, $ $6, Notes: * customers with annual throughput in excess of 25,000 MCF pay a monthly customer charge of $1,

37 Herman Oil & Gas Company Inc. Herman Oil and Gas Company Inc. (Herman) provides for the distribution of gas to customers in a portion of Summit, Clearfield and Winfield townships in Butler County. Herman serves roughly 380 residential customers and operates under Gas Tariff Pa. P.U.C. No. 4. Herman Oil & Gas Company Inc. Default Rate Schedule for Gas Service in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Customer Commodity Distribution GCR Customer Universal Education Rate Classification Charge Charge Charge Adjustment Choice Costs Service Charge Charge 2 MCF $14.45 $1.42 Heating 15 MCF $ $10.64 > STAS TOTAL $15.87 $

38 Herman Riemer Gas Company Herman Riemer Gas Company (Riemer Gas) provides natural gas service in Buffalo, Clinton and Jefferson townships, Butler County. Riemer Gas provides service to approximately 580 residential customers and 55 commercial customers. Riemer Gas operates under Gas Tariff Pa. P.U.C. No. 2. Herman Riemer Gas Company Default Rate Schedule for Gas Service in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Customer Commodity Distribution GCR Customer Universal Education Rate Classification Charge Charge Charge Adjustment Choice Costs Service Charge Charge STAS TOTAL 2 MCF $8.20 $9.39 $0.03 $17.62 Heating 15 MCF $8.20 $70.42 $0.20 $78.82 $8.20 $58.69 $0.17 $67.06 $8.20 $ $0.56 $ $23.75 $3, $10.13 $3, > Notes: An additional 6% for sales tax is added to the total for commercial customers. 36

39 Kaib & Kaib Gas Company Kaib & Kaib Gas Company (Kaib & Kaib) provides natural gas service to the public in the Borough of Hazen and the Township of Warsaw in Jefferson County. Kaib & Kaib provides gas service to 44 residential customers and two commercial customers. Kaib & Kaib operates under Gas Tariff Pa. P.U.C. No. 1. Kaib & Kaib Gas Company Default Rate Schedule for Gas Service in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Customer Commodity Distribution GCR Customer Universal Education Rate Classification Charge Charge Charge Adjustment Choice Costs Service Charge Charge STAS TOTAL 2 MCF $5.50 $11.00 $16.50 Heating 15 MCF $5.50 $82.50 $88.00 $5.50 $68.75 $74.25 $5.50 $ $ > Notes: All customers pay $5.50 per MCF plus a $5.50 monthly service charge. 37

40 Larkin Oil & Gas Company Larkin Oil and Gas Company (Larkin) provides natural gas service in Perry Township, Clarion County, and Madison Township, Armstrong County. Larkin s customer base consists of 25 residential customers. Larkin operates under Gas Tariff Pa. P.U.C. No. 2. Larkin Oil & Gas Co. Default Rate Schedule for Gas Service in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Customer Commodity Distribution GCR Customer Universal Education Rate Classification Charge Charge Charge Adjustment Choice Costs Service Charge Charge STAS TOTAL 2 MCF $4.34 $8.68 $13.02 Heating 15 MCF $4.34 $65.10 $69.44 > 38

41 Mountain Energy Ltd. Mountain Energy Ltd. (Mountain) provides gas service to roughly 80 residential customers in the townships of Richhill, Aleppo, Springhill, Jackson, Freeport and Center in Greene County. Mountain Energy operates under Gas Tariff Pa. P.U.C. No. 1. Mountain is currently in the process of abandoning service because it can no longer provide adequate service to its natural gas customers. As part of the abandonment process Mountain is helping to fund the conversion of its customers to alternative sources of energy. Mountain Energy Ltd. Default Rate Schedule for Gas Service in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Customer Commodity Distribution GCR Customer Universal Education Rate Classification Charge Charge Charge Adjustment Choice Costs Service Charge Charge 2 MCF $7.00 $12.00 STAS TOTAL $19.00 Heating 15 MCF $7.00 $90.00 $97.00 > 39

42 National Fuel Gas Distribution Corporation National Fuel Gas Distribution Corporation (NFG) furnishes natural gas service to the public in portions of the following counties: Armstrong; Butler; Cameron; Clarion; Clearfield; Crawford; Elk; Erie; Forest; Jefferson; McKean; Mercer; Potter; Venango; and Warren. NFG currently serves approximately 197,000 residential customers, 15,500 commercial customers and 600 industrial customers. NFG operates under Gas Tariff Pa. P.U.C. No.9. National Fuel Gas Distribution Corp. Default Rate Schedule for Gas Service in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Customer Commodity Distribution GCR Customer Universal Education Rate Classification Charge Charge Charge Adjustment Choice Costs Service Charge Charge STAS TOTAL 2 MCF $12.00 $12.48 $7.26 ($0.56) $0.32 ($0.04) $31.46 Heating 15 MCF $12.00 $93.57 $44.13 ($4.21) $2.39 ($0.18) $ > $19.89 $76.45 $35.36 ($3.44) $27.53 $ $91.87 ($11.47) $ $4, $1, ($206.48) $ $4, $1, ($206.48) ($0.15) $ $0.01 ($0.44) $ $0.15 ($6.99) $5, $0.15 ($6.81) $5, Notes: Commodity Charge and GCR Adjustment includes the Merchant Function Charge (MFC) Rider. 40

43 North East Heat & Light Company North East Heat & Light Company (North East) provides natural gas service in North East, Erie County. North East provides natural gas to approximately 2,660 residential customers, 280 commercial customers and 13 industrial customers. North East operates under Gas Tariff Pa. P.U.C. No. 12. North East Heat & Light Co. Default Rate Schedule for Gas Service in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Customer Commodity Distribution GCR Customer Universal Education Rate Classification Charge Charge Charge Adjustment Choice Costs Service Charge Charge STAS TOTAL 2 MCF $8.50 $13.23 $2.96 $0.68 $25.37 Heating 15 MCF $8.50 $92.55 $22.17 $5.13 $ $22.00 $77.13 $17.94 $4.28 $ $44.00 $ $59.79 $14.25 $ $44.00 $5, $1, $ $6, > $ $5, $1, $ $6,

44 PECO Energy Company PECO Energy Company (PECO), a subsidiary of the Exelon Corporation (Exelon), serves approximately 448,000 residential, 41,600 small commercial and industrial, and 440 large commercial and industrial customers. PECO s service territory consists of parts of Bucks, Chester, Delaware and Montgomery counties in Southeastern Pennsylvania. PECO operates under the terms of Gas Tariff Pa. P.U.C. No. 2. PECO also provides electric service to more than 1.5 million customers in the Philadelphia area. Exelon is headquartered in Chicago and provides energy service to approximately 6.6 million customers in Illinois, Maryland, and Pennsylvania. PECO Energy Company Default Rate Schedule for Gas Service in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Customer Commodity Distribution GCR Customer Universal Education Rate Classification Charge Charge Charge Adjustment Choice Costs Service Charge Charge STAS TOTAL 2 MCF $11.75 $12.58 $7.74 ($0.22) ($0.03) $31.82 Heating 15 MCF $11.75 $94.37 $58.05 ($1.64) ($0.16) $ $28.55 $78.64 $47.23 $28.55 $ $ $28.55 $4, $2, ($0.15) $ ($0.45) $ ($6.95) $6, > $ $4, $2, ($7.63) $7,

45 Peoples Natural Gas Company Peoples Natural Gas Company (Peoples), formerly Dominion Peoples, serves approximately 330,000 residential, 28,300 commercial and 200 industrial customers. Peoples service territory consists of parts of the following counties in Southwestern Pennsylvania: Allegheny; Armstrong; Beaver; Bedford; Blair; Butler; Cambria; Clarion; Fayette; Greene; Indiana; Lawrence; Mercer; Somerset; Venango; Washington; and Westmoreland. Peoples operates under Gas Tariff Pa. P.U.C. No. 43. On June 9, 2011, the Commission approved a settlement allowing for a $53 million base rate increase for Peoples. Peoples Natural Gas Company Default Rate Schedule for Gas Service in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Customer Commodity Distribution GCR** Capacity Universal Merchant Rate Classification Charge Charge Charge Adjustment Charge Service Charge Function Charge STAS TOTAL 2 MCF $13.75 $8.19 $6.57 $1.19 $0.94 $0.57 $0.37 ($0.02) $31.56 Heating 15 MCF $13.75 $61.40 $49.26 $8.96 $7.04 $4.26 $2.77 ($0.12) $ $13.75 $51.16 $30.30 $7.46 $5.53 $0.48 ($0.07) $ $24.00 $ $ $24.89 $18.45 $1.58 ($0.24) $ $69.00 $3, $1, $ $ $28.65 ($4.56) $5, > $69.00 $3, $1, $ $ $28.65 ($3.33) $5,

46 Peoples TWP LLC Peoples TWP LLC (Peoples TWP), formerly T.W. Phillips Gas & Oil Company, is based in Butler and serves approximately 56,000 residential, 4,400 commercial and 10 industrial customers. Peoples TWP s service territory consists of parts of Allegheny, Armstrong, Butler, Clarion, Clearfield, Indiana, Jefferson and Westmoreland counties in Western Pennsylvania. Peoples TWP operates under Gas Tariff Pa. P.U.C. No. 6. On May 19, 2011, the Commission approved a change of control of T.W. Phillips Gas and Oil Company from TWP INC. to LDC Holdings II LLC, an indirect subsidiary of Steel River Infrastructure Fund North America LP. Subsequently, Steel River renamed the utility to Peoples TWP LLC. Peoples TWP LLC Default Rate Schedule for Gas Service in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Customer Commodity Distribution GCR Merchant Universal Education Rate Classification Charge Charge Charge Adjustment Function Charge Service Charge Charge STAS TOTAL 2 MCF $12.75 $12.22 $9.54 ($0.86) $0.22 $0.55 ($0.01) $34.40 Heating 15 MCF $12.75 $91.62 $71.55 ($6.46) $1.62 $4.10 ($0.06) $ $28.00 $77.48 $54.15 ($3.73) $0.32 ($0.05) $ $60.00 $ $ ($12.44) $1.06 ($0.18) $ $ $4, $2, $46.88 ($3.23) $7, * > $ $9, $5, $ ($7.17) $16, Notes: *Peoples TWP used consumption of 20,001 MCF for the Customer class, as this is minimum usage needed to be considered an industrial customer. 44

47 Philadelphia Gas Works Philadelphia Gas Works (PGW) serves approximately 481,000 residential, 26,200 commercial and 2,350 industrial customers within the City of Philadelphia. PGW is the largest municipally owned gas utility in the nation, maintaining a distribution system consisting of 6,000 miles of gas mains. PGW operates under Gas Tariff Pa. P.U.C. No. 2. Philadelphia Gas Works Default Rate Schedule for Gas Service in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Customer Commodity Distribution GCR Customer Universal Education Rate Classification Charge Charge Charge Adjustment Choice Costs Service Charge Charge STAS TOTAL 2 MCF $12.00 $12.56 $13.49 ($0.44) $4.50 $42.11 Heating 15 MCF $12.00 $94.16 $ ($3.27) $33.78 $0.01 $ $18.00 $78.47 $62.42 ($2.73) $28.15 $0.01 $ $18.00 $ $ ($9.09) $93.82 $0.03 $ $18.00 $4, $3, ($163.65) $1, $0.53 $9, > $50.00 $4, $3, ($163.65) $1, $0.53 $10, Notes: The bill assumes (9,000/12) MCF. The Default Service is assumed to be firm, sales service. 45

48 Pike County Light & Power Company Pike County Light & Power Company (Pike), a subsidiary of Orange & Rockland Utilities Inc., serves approximately 1,100 residential customers and 90 commercial customers. Pike s service territory consists of Westfall Township and Matamoras Borough, in Pike County, Northeastern Pennsylvania. Pike operates under the terms of Gas Tariff Pa. P.U.C. No. 6. Orange & Rockland Utilities Inc. (O&R), through subsidiaries Pike County Light & Power and Rockland Electric Company, provides service to roughly 300,000 electric and 130,000 natural gas customers. Based in Pearl River, New York, O&R s service area covers 1,350 square miles in Southeastern New York, Northern New Jersey and Northeastern Pennsylvania. Pike County Light & Power Company Default Rate Schedule for Gas Service in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Customer Commodity Distribution GCR Customer Universal Education Rate Classification Charge Charge Charge Adjustment Choice Costs Service Charge Charge 2 MCF $6.00 $25.73 ($6.37) STAS TOTAL $0.01 $25.37 Heating 15 MCF $6.00 $ ($47.79) $0.06 $ > $9.00 $ ($39.83) $9.00 $ ($132.75) $9.00 $8, ($2,389.58) $9.00 $8, ($2,389.58) $0.05 $ $0.16 $ $2.69 $6, $2.69 $6,

49 Pine-Roe Natural Gas Company Inc. Pine-Roe Natural Gas Company Inc. (Pine-Roe) serves customers in the townships of Beaver, Clarion, Monroe and Piney in Clarion County, Western Pennsylvania. Pine-Roe serves approximately 163 residential customers and operates under Gas Tariff Pa. P.U.C. No. 1. Pine Roe Natural Gas Company Inc. Default Rate Schedule for Gas Service in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Customer Commodity Distribution GCR Customer Universal Education Rate Classification Charge Charge Charge Adjustment Choice Costs Service Charge Charge STAS TOTAL 2 MCF $16.01 $0.08 $16.09 Heating 15 MCF $ $0.59 $ > Notes: Pine-Roe charges a base rate of $ for the first 2 mcf. Anything beyond 2 mcf costs $ per mcf. 47

50 SAR Gas Company SAR Gas Company furnishes natural gas service to the public in Rockland Township, Venango County. SAR Gas currently has 192 residential customers and operates under Gas Tariff Pa. P.U.C. No. 1. SAR Gas Company Default Rate Schedule for Gas Service in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Customer Commodity Distribution GCR Customer Universal Education Rate Classification Charge Charge Charge Adjustment Choice Costs Service Charge Charge 2 MCF $24.00 STAS TOTAL $24.00 Heating 15 MCF $ $ $ $ > Notes: SAR Gas charges $12.50 for the first mcf and $11.50 for each subsequent mcf. 48

51 Sigel Gas Company Sigel Gas Company (Sigel) based in New Bethlehem, Clarion County, serves approximately 137 residential and 17 commercial customers. Sigel s service territory is comprised of Barnett, Clover, Rose and Union townships in Jefferson County, Western Pennsylvania. Sigel operates under Gas Tariff Pa. P.U.C. No. 3. Sigel Gas Company Default Rate Schedule for Gas Service in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Customer Commodity Distribution GCR Customer Universal Education Rate Classification Charge Charge Charge Adjustment Choice Costs Service Charge Charge STAS TOTAL 2 MCF $7.50 $9.77 $5.43 $1.31 $24.01 Heating 15 MCF $7.50 $73.25 $40.71 $9.84 $ $7.50 $61.04 $33.92 $8.20 $ $7.50 $ $ $27.34 $ $7.50 $3, $2, $ $6, > $7.50 $3, $2, $ $6,

52 UGI Utilities Inc. - Gas Division UGI Utilities Inc. (UGI), a subsidiary of UGI Corporation, serves approximately 306,000 residential, 33,500 commercial and 1,410 industrial customers. UGI s service territory consists of parts of Berks, Bucks, Carbon, Chester, Cumberland, Dauphin, Lancaster, Lebanon, Lehigh, Luzerne, Monroe, Montgomery, Northampton, Schuylkill and York counties in Eastern Pennsylvania. UGI operates under the terms of Gas Tariff Pa. P.U.C. No. 5. UGI also provides electric service to more than 60,000 customers in Pennsylvania. UGI Corporation, with principal offices in King of Prussia, Montgomery County, provides electric, gas, propane gas and energy supply through its subsidiaries UGI Utilities Inc., AmeriGas Inc. and UGI Enterprises Inc. UGI Utilities Inc. - Gas Default Rate Schedule for Gas Service in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Customer Commodity Distribution GCR Merchant Universal Education Rate Classification Charge Charge Charge Adjustment Function Charge Service Charge Charge STAS TOTAL 2 MCF $8.55 $6.67 $13.70 $0.30 $0.13 ($0.11) $29.24 Heating 15 MCF $8.55 $43.61 $ $2.25 $0.96 $8.55 $50.70 $85.51 $0.31 ($0.58) $ ($0.54) $ $8.55 $ $ $1.03 ($1.68) $ * * > Notes: *Consistent with UGI s Restructuring Filing at R in accord with the Natural Gas Choice and Competition Act, UGI does not maintain an obligation to provide default service for customers having annual use of 4,000 Mcf or greater. Service to new customers under, or transfers of existing customers or customer loads to, default (Rate N) retail service provided by UGI where annual use is projected to be 4,000 Mcf or greater, is permitted only as determined by the Company, subject to reasonable limitations. Accordingly, as availability is determined on a case-by-case basis, UGI has not provided bill information for default service where usage exceeds 4,000 Mcf annually. 50

53 UGI Central Penn Gas Inc. UGI Central Penn Gas Inc. (UGI Central), formerly PPL Gas, distributes gas in Pennsylvania and operates under Gas Tariff Pa. P.U.C. No. 3. UGI Central serves approximately 66,000 residential, 10,100 commercial and 210 industrial customers in North Central and Eastern Pennsylvania. On August 11, 2011, the Commission approved a settlement allowing for an $8.9 million (8.2%) base rate increase for UGI Central. UGI Central Penn Gas Inc. Default Rate Schedule for Gas Service in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Customer Commodity Distribution GCR Merchant Universal Education Rate Classification Charge Charge Charge Adjustment Function Charge Service Charge Charge STAS TOTAL 2 MCF $14.85 $11.77 $10.94 $0.25 $0.87 ($0.02) $38.66 Heating 15 MCF $14.85 $88.30 $82.07 $1.85 $6.53 ($0.10) $ $31.00 $41.21 $67.68 $0.10 ($0.07) $ $31.00 $ $ $0.32 ($0.20) $ $31.00 $2, $4, $5.78 ($3.29) $6, > 51

54 UGI Penn Natural Gas Inc. UGI Penn Natural Gas Inc. (UGI Penn) was formerly PG Energy. PG Energy was a division of the Southern Union Company. UGI Corporation purchased UGI Penn on August 24, 2006, and subsequently made UGI Penn a wholly owned direct subsidiary of UGI Utilities Inc. UGI Penn serves approximately 145,000 residential, 15,800 commercial and 230 industrial customers. UGI Penn s service territory consists of parts of Clinton, Columbia, Lackawanna, Luzerne, Lycoming, Monroe, Northumberland, Pike, Snyder, Susquehanna, Union, Wayne and Wyoming counties in Northeastern Pennsylvania. UGI Penn operates under Gas Tariff Pa. P.U.C. No. 8. UGI Penn, headquartered in Wilkes-Barre, Luzerne County, is Northeastern and Central Pennsylvania's largest natural gas distribution company. UGI Penn Natural Gas Co. Inc. Default Rate Schedule for Gas Service in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Customer Commodity Distribution GCR Merchant Universal Education Rate Classification Charge Charge Charge Adjustment Function Charge Service Charge Charge STAS TOTAL 2 MCF $13.17 $7.08 $11.33 $0.36 $0.63 $32.58 Heating 15 MCF $13.17 $51.69 $84.98 $2.72 $4.76 $ $32.41 $27.00 $69.75 $0.28 $ $32.41 $90.00 $ $0.93 $ $32.41 $1, $4, $16.74 $5, > 52

55 Valley Energy Inc. Valley Energy Inc. (Valley), based in Sayre, Bradford County, serves approximately 5,200 residential, 750 commercial and 50 industrial customers. Valley s service territory is comprised of parts of Bradford County in Northern Pennsylvania. Valley operates under Gas Tariff Pa. P.U.C. No. 1. Valley is owned by C&T Enterprises Inc., which also owns the Pennsylvania electric utilities of Citizens and Wellsboro. Valley Energy Inc. Default Rate Schedule for Gas Service in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Customer Commodity Distribution GCR Customer Universal Education Rate Classification Charge Charge Charge Adjustment Choice Costs Service Charge Charge 2 MCF $10.50 $5.13 $12.79 STAS TOTAL $0.01 $28.43 Heating 15 MCF $10.50 $38.44 $95.96 $0.04 $ > $18.00 $25.14 $79.96 $18.00 $83.82 $ $18.00 $1, $4, $67.00 $1, $4, $0.04 $ $0.08 $ $1.22 $6, $0.88 $5,

56 Walker Gas and Oil Company Walker Gas and Oil Company (Walker), owned by Orwell Natural Gas Co., is based in Bruin and serves approximately 260 residential customers and 15 commercial customers in Butler County, Western Pennsylvania. Walker operates under Gas Tariff Pa. P.U.C. No. 1. Orwell Natural Gas Co. is based in Mentor, Ohio, and owns the Pennsylvania gas utilities of CRG and Walker. Walker Gas and Oil Company Default Rate Schedule for Gas Service in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Customer Commodity Distribution GCR Customer Universal Education Rate Classification Charge Charge Charge Adjustment Choice Costs Service Charge Charge 2 MCF $10.00 $17.62 $0.72 Heating 15 MCF $10.00 $ $5.43 STAS TOTAL $28.35 $ > $11.00 $ $4.52 $11.00 $ $15.08 $11.00 $6, $ $11.00 $6, $ $ $ $6, $6, Notes: Please note that an additional 6% is added for sales tax to the total for small commercial customers. 54

57 Wally Gas Company Wally Gas Company serves roughly 200 residential and six commercial customers in the townships of East Franklin and North Buffalo in Armstrong County, Western Pennsylvania. Wally Gas Company operates under Gas Tariff Pa. P.U.C. No. 1. Wally Gas Company Default Rate Schedule for Gas Service in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Customer Commodity Distribution GCR Customer Universal Education Rate Classification Charge Charge Charge Adjustment Choice Costs Service Charge Charge STAS TOTAL 2 MCF $10.00 $17.44 $1.72 $29.16 Heating 15 MCF $10.00 $ $12.89 $ $10.00 $ $10.74 $ $10.00 $ $35.79 $ > 55

58 PennsylvaniaPublicUtilityCommision 400NorthStreet Harisburg,PA