Why is BC Best? The Role of Provincial and Reserve School Systems in Explaining Aboriginal Student Performance
|
|
- Priscilla Nichols
- 8 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 Institut C.D. HOWE Institute commentary NO. 390 Why is BC Best? The Role of Provincial and Reserve School Systems in Explaining Aboriginal Student Performance Education outcomes for young Aboriginal adults living in British Columbia are markedly better than those in other provinces. What is BC doing right? And what can other provinces learn? John Richards
2 The Institute s Commitment to Quality About The Author John Richards School of Public Policy, Simon Fraser University and Fellow-in-Residence, C.D. Howe Institute. C.D. Howe Institute publications undergo rigorous external review by academics and independent experts drawn from the public and private sectors. The Institute s peer review process ensures the quality, integrity and objectivity of its policy research. The Institute will not publish any study that, in its view, fails to meet the standards of the review process. The Institute requires that its authors publicly disclose any actual or potential conflicts of interest of which they are aware. In its mission to educate and foster debate on essential public policy issues, the C.D. Howe Institute provides nonpartisan policy advice to interested parties on a non-exclusive basis. The Institute will not endorse any political party, elected official, candidate for elected office, or interest group. As a registered Canadian charity, the C.D. Howe Institute as a matter of course accepts donations from individuals, private and public organizations, charitable foundations and others, by way of general and project support. The Institute will not accept any donation that stipulates a predetermined result or policy stance or otherwise inhibits its independence, or that of its staff and authors, in pursuing scholarly activities or disseminating research results. Commentary No. 390 October 2013 Social Policy INSTITUT C.D. HOWE INSTITUTE $12.00 isbn issn (print); issn (online) Essential Policy Intelligence les Conseils indispensables sur politiques Finn Poschmann Vice-President, Research
3 The Study In Brief Poor education outcomes for Aboriginals in Canada have long been a source of concern for Aboriginal leaders and the provincial and federal governments. Notably, sixty percent of young Aboriginal adults living on reserves in Canada lack high-school certification. As a result, they face severely limited employment opportunities off-reserve, and limited opportunities on-reserve. Among young Canadians not living on a reserve, those who identify as Indian-First Nation have better education outcomes than those on-reserve, but they are weaker than outcomes for Métis. In general, non-aboriginals achieve the best outcomes. This Commentary undertakes a suggestive, but far-from-definitive, exercise in assessing the role of education policies and institutions in Aboriginal K-12 outcomes. It disaggregates the young adult Aboriginal population (ages at the time of the 2006 census) into subgroups defined by province, location within a province (urban vs. rural and on- vs. off-reserve) and by Aboriginal identity group (non- Aboriginal, Métis, Indian-First Nation). After allowance for the impact of school location and employment rate as a proxy for family characteristics, this examination finds that British Columbia has achieved considerably better K-12 outcomes than the five other provinces, Quebec, Ontario, Manitoba, Saskatchewan and Alberta, with large Aboriginal cohorts. The Commentary discusses three institutional and policy differences between British Columbia and other provinces that may explain its superior outcomes: i) more comprehensive and regular monitoring of Aboriginal student performance in the core competencies of reading, writing and mathematics; ii) incentives for provincial school districts to innovate and consult with local Aboriginal leaders; and iii) the encompassing nature of First Nation institutions providing secondary services to reserve schools. C.D. Howe Institute Commentary is a periodic analysis of, and commentary on, current public policy issues. Michael Benedict and James Fleming edited the manuscript; Yang Zhao prepared it for publication. As with all Institute publications, the views expressed here are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of the Institute s members or Board of Directors. Quotation with appropriate credit is permissible. To order this publication please contact: the C.D. Howe Institute, 67 Yonge St., Suite 300, Toronto, Ontario M5E 1J8. The full text of this publication is also available on the Institute s website at
4 2 In February 2012, a panel jointly sponsored by the Assembly of First Nations and the federal Department of Aboriginal Affairs and Northern Development Canada (AANDC), released its review of on-reserve education. The panel concluded that among the barriers to better outcomes is that, The education system for First Nation students on reserve is a far cry from any system that other Canadians would recognize in terms of degree of input, accountability, and democratic governance most Canadians take for granted (AFN/AANDC 2012,9). Reserve schools operate, the panel added, in a non-system. Each reserve runs its own school much as, a century ago, each rural municipality in the Prairies ran its own one- or two-room school. Dedicated teachers may achieve remarkable success in a non-system, but the overall outcomes will not be satisfactory. In diplomatic language, the panel urged chiefs and councils to professionalize school management by introducing school authorities that assume responsibility for running a number of reserve schools. Such authorities would be democratically accountable to First Nations living within the region, but schools would no longer be primarily accountable to individual band councils. One month after the panel report, the federal budget promised new legislation and sustainable funding for reserve schools: In response to the Panel s report, the Government will work with willing partners to introduce a First Nation Education Act and have it in place for September The purpose of this legislation is to establish the structures and standards to support strong and accountable education systems on reserve. This will set the stage for more positive education outcomes for First Nations children and youth. The Government will also work to explore mechanisms to ensure stable, predictable and sustainable funding for First Nations elementary and secondary education. (Canada 2012.) Most educators and administrators involved with Aboriginal education agree that improvement in reserve school outcomes requires both more money and a more professional organization of schools, one aspect of which is creation of multi-school equivalents of provincial school districts. 1 It is an understatement to observe that events subsequent to the 2012 budget have not demonstrated an analogous consensus among First Nation leaders. In October 2012, a special AFN assembly on education rejected the federal proposals outright. We re not going to let Canada make everybody think that the solution to low graduation levels is resolved by a legislated solution, said Grand Chief Derek Nepinak of the Assembly of Manitoba Chiefs (CBC 2012). In July 2013, the AFN General Assembly repeated its rejection of the AANDC initiative The first draft of this Commentary was presented at a Canadian Economics Association session, jointly sponsored by the C.D. Howe Institute and the Centre for the Study of Living Standards (CSLS). For their extensive discussion, I thank participants at the session, especially Tim Thompson from the Assembly of First Nations, Barry Anderson and Andrew Sharpe, director of the CSLS. I also thank Gordon Martell, Larry Steeves, Don Drummond and an anonymous reviewer who commented on an earlier draft. Colin Busby shepherded this project at the C.D. Howe Institute. 1 An example is Mendelson s (2009) call for creation of reserve school authorities.
5 3 Commentary 390 (AFN 2013). At time of writing (August 2013), AANDC is attempting to secure among First Nation leaders some measure of agreement on legislative reform, based on two Discussion Guides (Canada 2013b, 2013c). Largely absent from the debate over legislation defining reserve school organization has been any reference to whether proposed institutional changes matter in terms of high-school completion. This Commentary undertakes two tasks. It decomposes Aboriginal high-school graduation rates among young adults by province in a manner that provides some evidence that policies and institutional arrangements pursued by both provincial education ministries and on-reserve schools do matter. In general, among the provinces under review, BC has the best Aboriginal high-school completion rates, both on- and off-reserve. Second, the Commentary discusses institutional features of provincial and reserve school organization that almost certainly figure in the explanation for BC s relative success. Compared to other provinces, the BC education ministry generates more detailed information about the K-12 performance of Aboriginal students and has a longer tradition of encouraging provincial school districts to engage local Aboriginal leaders in designing suitable local programs. Furthermore, BC reserve schools benefit from encompassing First Nation organizations that act as proto-school districts, providing some of the secondary services of a school district. Rules of Thumb Education officials school principals, school district superintendents and deputy ministers in provincial education ministries may not cite precise statistics, but they are aware of rules of thumb that characterize student outcomes. One is that K-12 academic performance is superior in big city school districts than elsewhere. A second is that, controlling for the location of the school district, students identifying as Indian-FN have the weakest outcomes and non-aboriginal the best; results for Métis students will fall roughly in the middle. The rules of thumb are illustrated, for all Canada, in Figure 1. The statistics presented are for the cohort of young adults, aged at the time of the 2006 census. (See the Appendix for an explanation of the identity definitions employed by Statistics Canada.) The census data indicate residence, a good but imperfect proxy for the actual location of K-12 instruction. The tabulated census results disaggregate location into four categories: census metropolitan areas (CMAs) with a population of more than 100,000, urban non- CMA, rural and on-reserve. For all three identity groups, the best outcomes are for those living in CMAs. What is of particular concern is the very high share, more than 60 percent, of young adults onreserve without high-school certification. They face severely limited employment opportunities off-reserve, and their employment opportunities on most reserves are also limited. 2 Rule 1: Student performance is better in urban than in rural schools The explanation for the first rule of thumb is straightforward. Rural school districts have more difficulty in retaining teachers, especially specialist teachers. The result is lower average teaching experience in rural than urban schools (CCL 2006). High teacher turnover is one factor, among others, that tends to lower student performance in a school. Indeed, Hanushek and Rivkin s detailed 2 Admittedly, some are completing high school or gaining high-school equivalence after age 24. The Aboriginal incomplete K-12 rates among the cohort are about one-third lower than those illustrated in Figure 1.
6 4 Figure 1: Incomplete K-12 Rate, Ages 20-24, by Identity Group and Location of Residence, Percent North American Indian / First Nation Métis Non-Aboriginal urban, census metropolitan area urban, non-census metropolitan area rural on-reserve Source: Author s calculations from tabulations of the 2006 census (Canada 2008b). econometric study of factors explaining the gap in relative performance of black and white Texas school children attributed much of the difference to the fact that black students attend schools with high teacher turnover. Meanwhile, a recent Alberta longitudinal study (2009) found that high-school completion rates rise with an increase in the average length of teaching experience at the students school. Also, large urban schools enjoy scale economies in their ability to offer specialized services and instruction that rural- and small-town schools, even with compensating higher per-student budgets, often cannot replicate (CCL 2006). But education outcomes depend not only on school quality. Higher family income and parental education levels are also associated with better student outcomes in virtually all studies and average family incomes and parental education levels are higher in large cities. Demand-side effects supplement supplyside effects. For rural families whose children expect to remain in the local community, the financial rewards of high-school completion and subsequent post-secondary training are less evident than in an urban context, the location of most knowledge-based, high-income jobs. In turn, this has led to lower parental expectations about the importance of formal education. 3 3 This is one conclusion from an analysis by Carr (2010) based on a Statistics Canada household survey of participation in post-secondary education by young adults.
7 5 Commentary 390 This demand-side incentive operates among Aboriginals as well as non-aboriginals. The incentive is weakest on-reserve where, in general, jobs requiring formal education are few. Rule 2: Controlling for location of school, students identifying as Indian-FN have the weakest outcomes, and non-aboriginal the strongest; results for Métis students fall roughly in the middle. The explanation for Aboriginal/non-Aboriginal disparities is complex. To begin, relative to non- Aboriginals, those who identify as Aboriginal are more likely to live in small towns or rural communities or, in the case of registered Indians, to live on-reserve. Hence, they suffer the impact of the first rule of thumb: rural and small-town students typically fare less well in terms of highschool completion. Discrimination against Aboriginals has almost certainly declined in Canada over the last three decades. An indicator is that more people now acknowledge an Aboriginal identity in the census (Siggner and Costa 2005). Since 1981, the intercensus increases in the size of Aboriginal identity cohorts are well in excess of projections based on fertility and mortality rates. Although schools no longer disparage Aboriginal culture, discrimination may persist in more subtle ways. Some teachers and administrators still assume that native students are inherently less able than others to master the core competencies and, accordingly, devote less effort to teaching them. Furthermore, a history of past discrimination permeates many Aboriginal families view of formal education. And whether or not their parents are skeptical of schools, Aboriginal children may grow up in an environment where few of the adults they know have benefited in terms of income and employment from a good education. Hence, why should they, the children, struggle to complete high school? Conclusions of the preceding paragraph arise from personal experience and are hard to document. More authoritative is the following summary from a Senate report on urban Aboriginal youth (Canada 2003, s.1.4): There are many complex reasons why [Aboriginal] youth stop attending school. Some of these reasons include racism; lack of parental involvement and guidance; resentment and embarrassment caused by feeling less successful scholastically than other students; instability caused by high rates of residential mobility; feelings of isolation caused by being in environments that are not culturally sensitive; an inability to afford text books, sporting equipment, and excursion fees; an unstable home life; and poverty. Consistently, witnesses emphasized that the lack of parental involvement, guidance and support was partly responsible for the fact that Aboriginal youth continue to fare so poorly academically The damaging effects of residential schools on Aboriginal peoples, cultures and languages are now widely recognized [T]here is a deep mistrust among some Aboriginal people of mainstream educational institutions. The importance of obtaining a good education becomes secondary to what may be perceived as a further assimilative assault on Aboriginal culture, language and traditions. Interprovincial Variation It is important to distinguish between the performance of school systems in teaching students who are expected to complete the K-12 cycle and students from marginal communities such as many Aboriginal students who may well drop out before completing the secondary school cycle. A clear example of this distinction is found in Alberta. In the 2009 round of student performance tests conducted by the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD), Alberta high-school students ranked first among provinces in their combined reading scores but last among the six provinces (see Figure 2) in terms of non- Aboriginal high-school completion and second
8 6 from last among Métis and Indian-FN students (Knighton et al. 2010). High-school incomplete results disaggregated by province are less well known than the above rules of thumb. Figure 2 illustrates incomplete K-12 rates among young adults for Canada and for the six provinces with Aboriginal populations in excess of 100,000. Nine of 10 Aboriginals reside in one of these six provinces. While the rules of thumb apply to all provinces, there exists significant interprovincial variation. For non-aboriginals, the best provincial outcome is in British Columbia (9.2 percent incomplete K-12); the worst is in Alberta (15.6 percent). For Métis, the best is also in British Columbia (18.4 percent); the worst in Manitoba (29.2 percent). 4 For young Indian-FN adults, the best is once again British Columbia (38.5 percent) and, as before, the worst is Manitoba (62.8 percent). Nearly two-thirds of the Aboriginal population identify as Indian-FN, some one-third as Métis; the remainder, under 5 percent, as Inuit. Slightly over half the Canadian population identifying as Indian-FN live on-reserve (Canada 2008a). Based on these ratios, about seven in 10 Aboriginals live off-reserve. The children of registered Indian families living on-reserve have the option to attend an on-reserve school. Nationwide, about 60 percent do. However, about 40 percent mostly highschool students attend a nearby provincial school, often in a small town (Rajekar and Mathilakath 2009). For their part, Métis and Inuit children attend provincial schools. In summary, about one Aboriginal child in five is at any time attending an on-reserve school; the overwhelming majority, four in five, are attending a provincial school. A final introductory observation is that it makes little sense to consider provincial and reserve schools run by band councils as belonging to watertight compartments. Net Aboriginal migration since the Second World War has been toward the city, but a great deal of back and forth has been taking place. Aboriginal families are more mobile than non-aboriginals, which means frequent transfers for many Indian-FN children between a reserve and a provincial school, and among provincial schools. Decomposing Aboriginal K-12 incomplete r ates Figures 3-5 illustrate the variation among provinces in K-12 incomplete rates among Métis and Indian-FN off- and on-reserve. To what extent is variation across provinces due to provincial education systems and, in the case of on-reserve results, the quality of reserve schools? The ideal decomposition procedure would be to generate a national sample of young adults, determine the location of K-12 schooling for each sample member along with a range of socioeconomic and identity characteristics (parental education and income, Aboriginal or non-aboriginal, and subgroups among Aboriginals). In conducting the analysis, we could introduce index variables for each province and school location (urban CMA, rural plus urban non-cma, or on-reserve). Finally, we could regress high-school completion on these variables and estimate the incremental impact of each. The magnitude and statistical significance of the index variable coefficients would provide a good measure of relative success of the various provincial school systems in different locations within the province and of the reserve non-systems. But that is not what this Commentary attempts. 4 The differences in Métis K-12 incomplete rates across the Prairies are trivially small. The results are as follows: Alberta (29.22 percent), Saskatchewan (28.59 percent) and Manitoba (29.24 percent).
9 7 Commentary 390 Figure 2: Incomplete K-12 Rate, Ages 20-24, by Identity Group and Province of Residence, Canada, Percent Canada BC AB SK MB ON QC North American Indian / First Nation Métis Non-Aboriginal Source: Author s calculations from tabulations of the 2006 census (Canada 2008b). Instead, it offers a cruder analysis based on 28 Aboriginal subgroups defined from tabulated 2006 census data: Six on-reserve Indian-FN subgroups: one corresponding to each province from Quebec to British Columbia; 12 Indian-FN off-reserve subgroups: a CMA and a rural/urban, non-cma subgroup for each of the six provinces; 10 Métis subgroups: a CMA and a rural/small town subgroup for each of five provinces from Ontario to British Columbia. (Given its small Métis population, Quebec results are dropped.) In the discussion below, I use the average employment rate for all people aged 15 and over among members of each subgroup as a proxy for average family characteristics that are likely to bear on children s education success. 5 Parental 5 The employment rate is highly dependent on completion of K-12, both among Aboriginals and non-aboriginals and average incomes are in turn highly dependent on presence of employment earnings (Richards and Scott 2009). See also Sharpe et al. (2009) for a decomposition of the relative importance of socioeconomic and family characteristics on Aboriginal incomes.
10 8 Figure 3a: Decomposition of K-12 Incomplete Rate, Métis, Census Metropolitan Areas, Ages 20-24, Canada and Selected Provinces, Percent Canada BC AB SK MB ON Métis / non-aboriginal, provincial (national) gap Non-Aboriginal, provincial (national) K-12 incomplete rate Source: Author s calculations from tabulations of the 2006 census (Canada 2008b). employment is highly correlated with individual family income and parental education levels, which in turn are two key determinants of children s education success. The projections for the Indian-FN subgroups in Table 1 arise from a simple regression that incorporates employment rate and an index variable to identify on-reserve observations. The rationale for inclusion of the index is to accommodate the difficulties of schools graduating their students in the context of largely isolated and very small schools. We would expect a statistically significant negative relationship between a subgroup s overall employment rate and its incomplete K-12 rate among young adults. Such is the implication of the regression. For the Métis subgroups the range in employment rates is much smaller than for Indian-FN groups, and the employment rate variations have negligible effect on incomplete K-12 rates. For Métis subgroups, the projections in Table 1 are simply the respective average incomplete K-12 rates, calculated separately for Métis in CMA and in rural/urban, non-cma locations. (See note to Table 1 for more details.) Several observations are worth noting. The employment rate range is large, particularly among
11 9 Commentary 390 Figure 3b: Decomposition of K-12 Incomplete Rate, Métis, Rural plus non-cma Urban, Ages 20-24, Canada and Selected Provinces, Percent Canada BC AB SK MB ON Métis / non-aboriginal provincial (national) gap Non-Aboriginal provincial (national) incomplete K-12 rate Source: Author s calculations from tabulations of the 2006 census (Canada 2008b). Indian-FN subgroups, indicating considerable interprovincial variation in average prosperity and projected education levels of the disaggregated subgroups. There is little overlap across the three aggregated subgroups in incomplete K-12 or employment rates. The on-reserve incomplete rates are generally the highest and employment rates the lowest; the Métis incomplete rates are lowest and employment rates highest; the off-reserve Indian-FN incomplete and employment rates are intermediary. If we project expected K-12 incomplete rates in terms of the simple regression, or means in the case of Métis subgroups, we can interpret deviations from projection as an approximate indicator of the performance of provincial school systems and reserve schools in the respective provinces. A positive deviation implies the K-12 incomplete rate is higher than projected and the relevant school system is underperforming relative to expectation; a negative deviation implies superior performance. (See Table 1.) British Columbia s most impressive educational achievement is that of its on-reserve subgroup. Its incomplete rate on-reserve is the lowest among the six provinces and 13 percentage points below projection. Among the young Indian-FN adults living off-reserve in a rural/urban, non-cma location, British Columbia s incomplete result is the overall lowest. Its deviation below trend is second largest (in absolute value). Among young Indian-FN adults living off-reserve in a CMA, British Columbia again produces impressive results. Its incomplete rate for this group is second lowest,
12 10 Figure 4a: Decomposition of K-12 Incomplete Rate, North American Indian First Nation, Urban CMAs, Ages 20-24, Canada and Selected Provinces, Percent Canada BC AB SK MB ON QC Indian-FN / non-aboriginal, provincial (national) gap Non-Aboriginal, provincial (national) incomplete K-12 rate Source: Author s calculations from tabulations of the 2006 census (Canada 2008b). as is its rank in terms of deviation below trend. Among Métis, British Columbia s results are the lowest among the five provinces, for both those living in a rural/urban, non-cma and in a CMA location. Summ arizing the Decomposition Analyzing the impact of family characteristics in terms of employment rates is admittedly a back-of-the-envelope exercise. But if we accept that the employment rate is nonetheless a reasonable proxy for variations in average family characteristics among Indian-FN sub-groups, family characteristics explain a good deal of the interprovincial variation in incomplete K-12 rates among the Indian-FN groups but certainly not all. Finally, the deviations from projections offer some evidence that the BC provincial school system and reserve schools are achieving superior education outcomes relative to the other five provinces. That British Columbia has achieved these superior Aboriginal student outcomes is no reason for BC stakeholders to rest on their laurels. The gaps relative to non-aboriginal students remain unacceptably large.
13 11 Commentary 390 Figure 4b: Decomposition of K-12 Incomplete Rate, North American Indian First Nation, Rural Plus Urban non-cmas, Ages 20-24, Canada and Selected Provinces, Percent Canada BC AB SK MB ON QC Indian-FN / non-aboriginal provincial (national) K-12 incomplete gap Non-Aboriginal provincial (national) incomplete K-12 rate Source: Author s calculations from tabulations of the 2006 census (Canada 2008b). BC Institutional Innovations Why are BC outcomes in general superior? This section discusses three institutional and policy dimensions whereby on- and off-reserve Aboriginal education policies and institutions differ, in degree, from elsewhere in the country. Measuring Outcomes For all students, Aboriginal as well as non- Aboriginal, mastering basic skills in reading, writing, science and mathematics is essential for success in post-secondary training and employment prospects in mainstream society. Given the multiple aims of the educational enterprise, as well as the priorities of Aboriginal communities, other aspects of learning also matter for instance, the ability to provide a culturally affirming educational experience for Aboriginal children. While both basic skills and culture matter, affirmation of culture is not a substitute for competence in the former.
14 12 Figure 5: Decomposition of Incomplete K-12 Rate, North American Indian First Nation, On-Reserve, Ages 20-24, Canada and Selected Provinces, Percent Canada BC AB SA MB ON QC Indian-FN on / off-reserve (rural + urban, non-cma) provincial (national) gap Indian-FN off-reserve (rural + urban, non-cma) provincial (national) incomplete K-12 rate Source: Author s calculations from tabulations of the 2006 census (Canada 2008b). There are two main reasons to undertake detailed student-outcome monitoring. First, measuring and reporting school and student performance on a regular basis provides an accountability function. Whether Aboriginal or not, parents are concerned about the quality of the schools that their children attend. Given the historic absence of educational accountability to Aboriginal communities, information about school performance both on- and off-reserve is one means to convince Aboriginal communities that education programs are working for their children. Second, performance measurement is a necessary tool for improving school quality. As the old conundrum has it, if you don t know where you are and you don t know where you want to go, you re unlikely to get there. While far from perfect, both BC provincial and reserve schools have a better tradition of measuring and reporting Aboriginal student outcomes than other provinces. For example, the BC First Nations School Association manages an on-reserve school-reporting project (FNSA 2012). As well, the provincial education ministry (BC 2012) has
15 13 Commentary 390 Table 1: Projected K-12 Incomplete Rates and Deviations from Projections, Young Aboriginals, Ages 20-24, Selected Provinces and Location, 2006 Location Employment Rate K-12 Incomplete Rate Projected K-12 Incomplete Rate Deviation of Actual from Projected K-12 Incomplete Rate percent percentage points Indian-FN, on-reserve BC AB SK MB ON QC Indian-FN, off-reserve, rural and urban, non-cma BC AB SK MB ON QC Indian-FN, off-reserve, CMA BC AB SK MB ON QC Métis, rural and urban, non-cma BC AB SK MB ON Métis, CMA BC AB SK MB ON Source: Author s calculations from Canada (2008b, 2008c). Note: For the 18 Indian-FN subgroups the projection is based on a regression of the incomplete K-12 rate on the employment rate and an index indicating a reserve location. The result is y = x x 2, where y is the projected incomplete K-12 rate, x 1 is the employment rate and x 2 is the index for a reserve location. The adjusted R 2 is The employment rate is significant at 5% one-tail, the on-reserve index at 1% one-tail. The regression could be re-specified to add an index distinguishing CMA from rural/urban, non-cma Indian-FN subgroups. Such an index has the appropriate sign (implying higher rural than CMA incomplete rates) but is insignificant. The number of observations for any regression is, however, too small for the results to be more than suggestive. For Métis, the projections are the respective incomplete K-12 averages, calculated separately for Métis in CMA and in rural/urban, non-cma locations.
16 14 for more than a decade published How are We Doing?, an annual summary of Aboriginal student performance in provincial schools. Canada participates in international random sample testing of students, such as the OECD s triannual PISA tests. These are useful in comparing education results across provinces and between Canada and other countries. However, to assess and manage well a complex school system, such as that of a province, requires data at a far more disaggregated level than PISA or census snapshots every five years. 6 Most provinces undertake core competency tests in reading, writing and arithmetic at several grades in the K-12 cycle. In British Columbia, these tests (so-called Foundations Skills Assessment FSA) have been conducted in Grades 4 and 7 since the 1990s and are disaggregated by identity, allowing analysis of trends among Aboriginal relative to non-aboriginal students. British Columbia also publishes analyses of student cohorts followed from Grade 8, allowing a longitudinal comparison of Aboriginal and non-aboriginal students in higher grades. 7 Admittedly, student performance data can be abused. Average neighbourhood income and parental education are factors relevant to school performance, but largely beyond school control. Aboriginal students face additional handicaps that should be analyzed when reporting results. To rank schools without serious discussion of such factors is not helpful. 8 But the potential to abuse data is not a reason to ignore data. Aboriginal Education Enhancement Agreements and Discretionary Funding to Provincial School Districts School districts are an oft-forgotten but potentially important level of school governance (Anderson 2006). In the 1990s, British Columbia established a precedent, copied in some other provinces, of awarding supplementary funds annually to school districts based on the number of identified Aboriginal students. Provided they are devoted to educational initiatives for Aboriginals, districts exercise wide discretion over how these funds are allocated. There exists reasonably good evidence that Aboriginal student scores on provincial core competency tests are superior in school districts that, by various criteria, take seriously their obligations to monitor and advance their native students relative to native student scores in those districts that do not take these obligations as seriously (Richards et al. 2008). The benefits from encouraging district-level innovation seem to derive from a variety of avenues: The provincial education ministry requires districts to draw up Aboriginal education enhancement agreements with medium-term targets. 9 This obliges district school boards, superintendents and school principals to address Aboriginal student outcomes in their district over time, and relative to other districts. The enhancement agreements oblige school districts to consult local Aboriginal community leaders in school policymaking and setting of targets. School districts enjoy discretion as to how they interpret this obligation to consult. 6 The 2011 census snapshot is likely blurred at best. Elimination of the mandatory long form has probably introduced biases concerning Aboriginal results. See Appendix for more detail. 7 See, for example, the annual detailed report (BC 2012) on Aboriginal student performance in provincial BC schools. 8 An example of analysis that accounts for socioeconomic factors is David Johnson s (2010) assessment of BC school performance. 9 For a description of these agreements, see British Columbia (2013). To read a sample agreement, see Richards and Scott (2009, Appendix 1).
17 15 Commentary 390 School and district-level educators may interact more closely with local on-reserve schools, with the intent of addressing education issues arising from student mobility. A controversial aspect of school-district innovation is the designation of magnet schools whose student body is expected to comprise primarily members of a marginalized minority. Such schools raise the issue of peer effects. Socioeconomic characteristics of individual families may affect not only their own children, they may also impinge positively or negatively on other students in the school and, hence, become determinants of school quality. After adjusting for other factors, a study I undertook with colleagues (Richards et al. 2008, Richards et al. 2010) found that Aboriginal student performance on core competency tests was on average significantly lower in schools with large Aboriginal cohorts. Conversely, the peer effect may be positive. In the same study, the non-aboriginal students (who were a large majority in nearly all shools) had a marked positive impact on Aboriginal student FSA scores. The potential impact of student peers is inseparable from designing school curriculum and hiring faculty in a manner to promote Aboriginal culture. To improve school performance among marginalized ethnic/racial groups, many studies stress the value of hiring teachers who belong to the ethnic/racial group in question, and of introducing a school curriculum oriented to that group s cultural experience. These features are usually more in evidence in schools with large numbers from the relevant group. Such schools have efficient scale to achieve such goals. However, a tradeoff usually exists. 10 The presence of a large culturally homogeneous low-performing student cohort may well encourage a school culture of low academic expectations: some combination of low teacher expectations of their students academic potential and low student expectations of their own and their peers potential (Rivkin, Hanushek and Kain 2005). British Columbia s First Nation Schools Association (FNSA) and First Nations Education Steering Committee (FNESC) Canadian professional educators agree generally that BC reserve schools have achieved more coordination among themselves and with the provincial school system than is the case in any other province. FNESC, in existence since 1992, and FNSA, which dates from the late 1990s, encompass virtually all reserve schools in the province. Which is not to deny the value of protoschool districts serving some (but not all) reserve schools in other provinces. 11 The coordination in British Columbia may be better, but it is far from perfect. FNESC and FNSA have limited discretion relative to chiefs and councils on individual reserves and limited managerial capacity relative to that available to school boards and a provincial education ministry. Meanwhile, across Canada provincially based First Nation organizations, education ministries and AANDC have negotiated a series of tripartite 10 While the study by Richards et al. (2008) and Richards et al. (2010) found a large negative Aboriginal peer effect, there exists some counter-evidence. Friesen and Krauth (2010) found no evidence from their study of Aboriginal performance in BC schools that negative peer effects exist. However, their measure of Aboriginal peer effects was based on small changes in Aboriginal student numbers within classes within particular schools, not on larger inter-school differences in Aboriginal student cohort sizes. 11 A Saskatchewan example is an exercise undertaken by the Yorkton Tribal Council (Steeves et al. 2011). Others include the James Bay Cree school board in Quebec and Mi kmaw Kina matnewey in Nova Scotia.
18 16 education agreements intended to realize various scholastic and cultural education goals. Reflecting the relatively well-established role of FNESC and FNSA, the BC education agreement is the most ambitious. 12 FNESC, a political organization somewhat akin to a school board, is controlled by BC chiefs and band councils operating under provisions of the Indian Act or a modern treaty. Its activities mostly concern liaison with the BC government on school policy and programs for Indian-FN students (FNESC 2011). FNSA, somewhat akin to the professional staff of a school district, provides most on-reserve schools secondary services, such as instruction in local Aboriginal language. Between them, FNESC and FNSA undertake many functions associated with school districts in provincial systems and are, in effect, a proto school district for on-reserve BC schools. Conclusion The above discussion of dimensions whereby British Columbia differs, at least in degree, from other provinces and the decomposition exercise are far from definitive proof that the proposals of the joint AFN/AANDC panel and the 2012 federal budget proposal for reserve school authorities will improve outcomes. An obvious conclusion is a call for better evidence. The more relevant finding, I suggest, is that the available evidence suggests strongly that education policies and institutional arrangements for schools matter. Hence, the 2012 federal budget was right in making a commitment to establish the structures and standards to support strong and accountable education systems on reserve. This is bureaucratic language of budget drafters. It is easy to mock. It is easy also for First Nation leaders to indulge in critiques of past federal policy and inadequacies in AANDC school funding. Such critiques are largely accurate. It is also easy for the federal government to conclude that the chiefs have turned down the offer of reserve school reform and turn to other files. But the goal of decent Aboriginal education outcomes is too important to base decisions on sins of the past. 12 The texts of current tripartite education agreements, including that in British Columbia, are available at
19 17 Commentary 390 Appendix Defining Aboriginal Identity Groups As with all issues of identity in the modern world, the defining criteria are debatable. The Canadian census defines the Aboriginal population in several ways. The most widely used is based on self-identification. Individuals can self-identify as belonging to one of three Aboriginal groups: (i) North American Indian or First Nation (Mohawk, Ojibwa, Cree, and so on); (ii) Métis (descendents of communities formed from the intermarriage of Indians and coureurs de bois engaged in the fur trade); or (iii) Arctic Inuit. Self-identification as an Aboriginal does not necessarily mean an individual has Aboriginal ancestry. Another census definition is based on an individual indicating that he or she is a registered Indian under provisions of the Indian Act, a Canadian statute dating from the late 19 th century. The great majority of those who self-identify as Indian/First Nation are also registered Indians. Only registered Indians have the right to live on designated reserve lands and receive the associated benefits. The census defines the Aboriginal identity population as those who self-identify as Aboriginal or indicate that they are registered Indians. Most of the statistics discussed in this paper derive from the 2006 census. The census is by far the most important source of consistent information about Aboriginal social conditions across Canada. Detailed Aboriginal data from the 2011 census will become available in stages during The 2006 census included a 20 percent random sample required to complete the long-form questionnaire. Since participation was mandatory among those randomly selected, the reported results on many social conditions among Canadians were as accurate as a census could provide. For the 2011 census, the government made the controversial decision to abolish mandatory participation in a long-form 20 percent sample and substituted voluntary participation in a larger 35 percent sample, the basis for the National Household Survey. While the sample was larger, those who rely on census Aboriginal data have expressed serious concerns about bias. The Aboriginal response rate may well have been considerably lower than in 2006, and those Aboriginals who chose not to respond may well have been poorer and/or more alienated from mainstream Canada than one would conclude from a representative sample.
20 18 References Alberta High School Completion Longitudinal Study. Edmonton: Alberta Ministry of Education. Anderson, Steven The School District s Role in Educational Change. International Journal of Education Reform, 15: Assembly of First Nations National Advocacy to Assert First Nations Control of First Nations Education. Resolution approved at AFN General Assembly. July. Whitehorse. Assembly of First Nations and Aboriginal Affairs and Northern Development Canada (AFN/AANDC) Nurturing the Learning Spirit of First Nation Students. Report of the National Panel on First Nation Elementary and Secondary Education for Students on Reserve. Ottawa. British Columbia Aboriginal Report 2006/ /11 How Are We Doing? Victoria: Ministry of Education Aboriginal Education Enhancement Agreements. Available at: Canada Urban Aboriginal Youth: An Action Plan for Change. Final Report of the Senate Standing Committee on Aboriginal Peoples; Senator Thelma Chalifoux, chair. Ottawa a. Aboriginal Identity (8), Area of Residence (6), Age Groups (12) and Sex (3) for the Population of Canada, Provinces and Territories, 2006 Census 20% Sample Data XWE Ottawa: Statistics Canada b. Aboriginal Identity (8), Highest Certificate, Diploma or Degree (14), Major Field of Study Classification of Instructional Programs, 2000 (14), Area of Residence (6), Age Groups (10A) and Sex (3) for the Population 15 Years and Over of Canada, Provinces and Territories, 2006 Census 20% Sample Data XWE Ottawa: Statistics Canada c. Labour Force Activity (8), Aboriginal Identity (8), Highest Certificate, Diploma or Degree (14), Area of Residence (6), Age Groups (12A) and Sex (3) for the Population 15 Years and Over of Canada, Provinces and Territories, 2006 Census 20% Sample Data XWE Ottawa: Statistics Canada Budget Plan. Ottawa: Department of Finance a. Tripartite Education Agreements. Ottawa: Aboriginal Affairs and Northern Development Canada (AANDC) b. Developing a First Nation Education Act: Discussion Guide. Ottawa: AANDC c. Developing a First Nation Education Act: A Blueprint for Legislation. Ottawa: AANDC. Canadian Council on Learning Lessons in Learning: The Rural-urban Gap in Education. Ottawa. Carr, Jeffrey Increasing the Participation of Rural Canadians in Post-Secondary Education. Masters project Simon Fraser University. CBC Harper government s First Nations education plans collapse: Assembly of First Nations National Chief Shawn Atleo rejects proposed bill to overhaul native schools. Available at: cbc.ca/news/politics/story/2012/10/04/pol-cp-firstnations-education-plan-collapse.html. First Nations Education Steering Committee Annual Report 2010/2011. West Vancouver, BC. First Nations School Association School Measures and Data Collection Project 2011/12. West Vancouver, BC. Friesen, Jane, and Brian Krauth Sorting, peers, and achievement of Aboriginal students in British Columbia. Canadian Journal of Economics 43: (4),
21 19 Commentary 390 Hanushek, Eric, and Steven Rivkin School Quality and the Black-White Achievement Gap. Working Paper National Bureau of Economic Research. Cambridge, Mass. Johnson, David British Columbia s Best Schools: Where Teachers Make the Difference. E-Brief. Toronto: C.D. Howe Institute. June. Knighton, Tamara, Pierre Brochu, and Tomasz Gluszynski Measuring Up: Canadian Results of the OECD PISA Study. Ottawa: Statistics Canada. Mendelson, Michael Why We Need a First Nations Education Authority Act. Ottawa: Caledon Institute of Social Policy. Rajekar, Ashutosh, and Ramnarayanan Mathilakath The Funding Requirement for First Nations Schools in Canada. Ottawa: Office of the Parliamentary Budget Officer. Available at: www2.parl.gc.ca/sites/pbo-dpb/documents/inac_ Final_EN.pdf. Richards, John, Jennifer Hove, and Kemi Afolabi Understanding the Aboriginal / non-aboriginal Gap in Student Performance: Lessons from British Columbia. Commentary 276. Toronto: C.D. Howe Institute. December. Richards, John, and Megan Scott Aboriginal Education: Strengthening the Foundations. Ottawa: Canadian Policy Research Network. Richards, John, Aidan Vining, and David Weimer Aboriginal Performance on Standardized Tests: Evidence and Analysis from Provincial Schools in British Columbia. Policy Studies Journal 38 (1), Rivkin, Steven, Eric Hanushek, and John Kain Teachers, Schools, and Academic Achievement. Econometrica, 73, Sharpe, Andrew et al. The Effect of Increasing Aboriginal Educational Attainment on the Labour Force, Output and the Fiscal Balance. Ottawa: Centre for the Study of Living Standards. Siggner, Andrew, and Rosalinda Costa Aboriginal Conditions in Census Metropolitan Areas, Ottawa: Statistics Canada. Steeves, Larry, Sheila Carr-Stewart and James Marshall Enhancing Student Achievement: The Importance of Second Level Educational Services in First Nation Schools in One Tribal Council in Saskatchewan. In-education 17(2). University of Regina.
Students in Jeopardy: An Agenda for Improving Results in Band-Operated Schools
Institut C.D. HOWE Institute commentary NO. 444 Students in Jeopardy: An Agenda for Improving Results in Band-Operated Schools Reserve schools are failing their students. On-reserve, only four of 10 young
More informationImproved data, better outcomes: strengthening Pan-Canadian Aboriginal data
CMEC Technical Workshop on Pan-Canadian Aboriginal Data March 29-30, 2011 Improved data, better outcomes: strengthening Pan-Canadian Aboriginal data Summary Report Council of Ministers of Education, Canada
More informatione-brief School Dropouts: Who Are They and What Can Be Done?
e-brief January 6, 2011 EDUCATION PAPERS School Dropouts: Who Are They and What Can Be Done? I N D E P E N D E N T R E A S O N E D R E L E V A N T By John Richards While Canada has made progress in the
More informationPolicy in Focus SUMMARY. Maytree. Featured Research. Poor Educational Outcomes for Aboriginal Students Threaten Canada s Prosperity
Maytree Policy in Focus issue 5 SEPT 08 Background and Context...2 Education system on reserves failing tomorrow s citizens Featured Research...4 Improving Education on Reserves: A First Nations Education
More informationA Portrait of First Nations and Education
A Portrait of First Nations and Education Population In Canada, 1,172,785 persons identify as Aboriginal, and 698,025 identify as First Nations. Aboriginal youth are the fastest growing demographic. The
More informationA Demographic and Socio-Economic Portrait of. AboriginAl PoPulAtions in CAnAdA
A Demographic and Socio-Economic Portrait of AboriginAl PoPulAtions in CAnAdA table of Contents Aboriginal Population (Total)....1 Registered Indian Population....9 Non-Status Indian Population....17 Métis
More informatione-brief Equipping Ourselves in Tough Times: Canada s Improved Business Investment Performance By Colin Busby and William B.P.
e-brief July 9, 2009 I N D E P E N D E N T R E A S O N E D R E L E V A N T ECONOMIC GROWTH AND INNOVATION Equipping Ourselves in Tough Times: Canada s Improved Business Investment Performance By Colin
More informationKey Policy Issues in Aboriginal Education: An Evidence-Based Approach
Key Policy Issues in Aboriginal Education: An Evidence-Based Approach Founded in 1967, CMEC is the collective voice of Canada s ministers of education. It provides leadership in education at the pan-canadian
More information111 Sparks Street, Suite 500 Ottawa, Ontario K1P 5B5 613-233-8891, Fax 613-233-8250 csls@csls.ca
February 2010 0 111 Sparks Street, Suite 500 Ottawa, Ontario K1P 5B5 613-233-8891, Fax 613-233-8250 csls@csls.ca CENTRE FOR THE STUDY OF LIVING STANDARDS INVESTING IN ABORIGINAL EDUCATION IN CANADA: AN
More informationFirst Nations Fact Sheet: A GENERAL PROFILE ON FIRST NATIONS CHILD WELFARE IN CANADA
First Nations Fact Sheet: A GENERAL PROFILE ON FIRST NATIONS CHILD WELFARE IN CANADA Prepared by Marlyn Bennett Introduction The delivery of child welfare services to First Nations * children, families
More informationFrom Classroom to Career: May 2014 ENGINEERING EMPLOYMENT IN ONTARIO: RESEARCH AND ANALYSIS
ENGINEERING EMPLOYMENT IN ONTARIO: RESEARCH AND ANALYSIS From Classroom to Career: May 2014 To download this report, please visit: http://www.ospe.on.ca/?page=adv_issue_elms Table of Contents Executive
More informationStreet Smart: Demographics and Trends in Motor Vehicle Accident Mortality In British Columbia, 1988 to 2000
Street Smart: Demographics and Trends in Motor Vehicle Accident Mortality In British Columbia, 1988 to 2000 by David Baxter 3-Year Moving Average Age Specific Motor Vehicle Accident Death Rates British
More informationAppendix. Value for Money? Teacher Compensation and Student Outcomes in Canada s Six Largest Provinces
1 Appendix Commentary 434 Appendix Value for Money? Teacher Compensation and Student Outcomes in Canada s Six Largest Provinces Introduction This Appendix contains two additional lines of analysis as robustness
More informationThe Hole in Ontario s Budget: WSIB s Unfunded Liability
Institut C.D. HOWE Institute Conseils indispensables sur les politiques March 22, 2012 FISCAL AND TAX COMPETITIVENESS The Hole in Ontario s Budget: WSIB s Unfunded Liability by Colin Busby and Finn Poschmann
More informationEncouraging Success Ensuring Aboriginal Youth Stay in School
Encouraging Success Ensuring Aboriginal Youth Stay in School Ben Brunnen Policy Analyst Building the New West Project Report #22 December 2003 BUILDING THE NEW WEST As part of the Building the New West
More informationAboriginal People in Canada s Labour Market: Work and Unemployment, Today and Tomorrow
Aboriginal People in Canada s Labour Market: Work and Unemployment, Today and Tomorrow by Michael Mendelson March 2004 Aboriginal People in Canada s Labour Market: Work and Unemployment, Today and Tomorrow
More informationFERENCE WEICKER & COMPANY FERENCE WEICKER & COMPANY FORMATIVE EVALUATION OF THE FINANCIAL LITERACY PROGRAM
FERENCE WEICKER & COMPANY FORMATIVE EVALUATION OF THE FINANCIAL LITERACY PROGRAM Final Report Prepared For the Financial Consumer Agency of Canada May 2, 2013 Ference Weicker & Company Ltd. 550-475 West
More informationAccord on. Indigenous Education ACDE
Accord on Indigenous Education ACDE ACDE Accord on Indigenous Education The Accord was developed under the leadership of Jo-ann Archibald University of British Columbia John Lundy Laurentian University
More informationAP Aboriginal Demographics - The Next Census Day
Catalogue no. 96F0030XIE2001007 2001 Census: analysis series Aboriginal peoples of Canada: A demographic profile This document provides detailed analysis of the 2001 Census of Population data released
More informationFunding formula for First nations schools The instrument of a detrimental policy
1 Funding formula for First nations schools The instrument of a detrimental policy The chronic under-funding of our education is a strategy aiming for the forced integration into the provincial education
More informationEconomic Impacts of MLS Home Sales and Purchases in Canada and the Provinces
Economic Impacts of MLS Home Sales and Purchases in Canada and the Provinces Economic Impacts of MLS Home Sales and Purchases in Canada and the Provinces Prepared for: The Canadian Real Estate Association
More informationMyths and Realities of First Nations Education
Myths and Realities of First Nations Education Centre for Aboriginal Policy Studies August 2014 by Ravina Bains Contents Executive summary / iii Introduction / 1 The structure and funding of education
More informationThe Surveys on Aboriginal People. Focusing on Education and Employment
The Surveys on Aboriginal People Focusing on Education and Employment Surveys on Aboriginal People Two related but distinct surveys that focus on education and employment The Aboriginal Peoples Survey
More informationPublic Accounting Rights for Certified General Accountants in Canada. Issue Brief
Public Accounting Rights for Certified General Accountants in Canada Issue Brief IMPORTANT NOTE: Some information regarding Ontario is out of date pursuant to the adoption of the Public Accounting Act,
More informationFIRST NATION, MÉTIS, INUIT EDUCATION: SELF-IDENTIFICATION
FIRST NATION, MÉTIS, INUIT EDUCATION: 1. PURPOSE ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEDURE Effective: September 1, 2014 Last Revised: Rainbow District School Board believes that fulfilling a commitment to equity and inclusion
More informationAboriginal Post-Secondary Education Strategy and Action Plan
Aboriginal Post-Secondary Education Strategy and Action Plan Strategic Context The Government of British Columbia is forging a new government-to-government relationship with Aboriginal people based on
More informationProjections of the Aboriginal populations, Canada, provinces and territories
Catalogue no. 91-547-XIE Projections of the Aboriginal populations, Canada, provinces and territories 2001 to 2017 How to obtain more information Specific inquiries about this product and related statistics
More informationThe Surveys on Aboriginal People. Focusing on Education and Employment
The Surveys on Aboriginal People Focusing on Education and Employment Surveys on Aboriginal People Two related but distinct surveys that focus on education and employment The Aboriginal Peoples Survey
More informationThe MetLife Survey of
The MetLife Survey of Challenges for School Leadership Challenges for School Leadership A Survey of Teachers and Principals Conducted for: MetLife, Inc. Survey Field Dates: Teachers: October 5 November
More informationGOVERNMENT RESPONSE TO THE CHILD INTERVENTION SYSTEM REVIEW
GOVERNMENT RESPONSE TO THE CHILD INTERVENTION SYSTEM REVIEW October 2010 Closing the Gap Between Vision and Reality: Strengthening Accountability, Adaptability and Continuous Improvement in Alberta s Child
More informationThe Debate on First Nations Education Funding: Mind the Gap
WORKING PAPER 49 DECEMBER 2013 The Debate on First Nations Education Funding: Mind the Gap Don Drummond Ellen Kachuck Rosenbluth School of Policy Studies, Queen s University, 2013 1 Section 1: Introduction
More informationCOMMENTARY. C.D. Howe Institute. Understanding the Aboriginal/ Non-Aboriginal Gap in Student Performance: Lessons From British Columbia
NO. 276, DECEMBER 2008 C.D. Howe Institute COMMENTARY SOCIAL POLICY Understanding the Aboriginal/ Non-Aboriginal Gap in Student Performance: Lessons From British Columbia John Richards Jennifer Hove Kemi
More informationMetro Vancouver Aboriginal Executive Council
phone: (604) 255-2394 website: www.mvaec.ca June 22, 2015 Aboriginal Community Career Employment Service Aboriginal Front Door Aboriginal Mother Centre Canadian Aboriginal AIDS Network Circle of Eagles
More informationArticle. Work absences in 2011. by Maria Dabboussy and Sharanjit Uppal
Component of Statistics Canada Catalogue no. 75-001-X Perspectives on Labour and Income Article Work absences in 2011 by Maria Dabboussy and Sharanjit Uppal April 20, 2012 Statistics Canada Statistique
More informationBackgrounder: Summary of Recommendations
Backgrounder: Summary of Recommendations POLICING 1. Aboriginal Police Services must be improved and strengthened by having their investigative powers and resources, training, and systems of accountability
More informationIndividual Donors to Arts and Culture Organizations in Canada in 2007
Individual Donors to Arts and Culture Organizations in Canada in 2007 www.hillstrategies.com info@hillstrategies.com Statistical insights on the arts, Vol. 8 No. 3 Hill Strategies Research Inc., February
More informationSummative Evaluation of the Elementary/Secondary Education Program on Reserve
Final Report Summative Evaluation of the Elementary/Secondary Education Program on Reserve (Project Number: 1570-7/09057) June 2012 Evaluation, Performance Measurement, and Review Branch Audit and Evaluation
More informationA New Measure of Educational Success in Texas. Tracking the Success of 8th Graders into and through College
A New Measure of Educational Success in Texas Tracking the Success of 8th Graders into and through College National Center for Management Systems (NCHEMS) Contents Introduction 1 The Challenge 2 Purpose
More informationSaskatchewan Small Business Profile 2012
Saskatchewan Small Business Profile 2012 October 2013 Economic and Competitive Analysis Branch www.economy.gov.sk.ca Table of Contents INTRODUCTION... 1 KEY FACTS... 3 1. SMALL BUSINESS SECTOR... 4 2.
More informationCommunity Investing in Canada. Written by: Susannah Cameron, Executive Director Canadian Community Investment Network Cooperative Canada
Community Investing in Canada Written by: Susannah Cameron, Executive Director Canadian Community Investment Network Cooperative Canada TABLE OF CONTENTS Introduction... 1 Describing the community investing
More informationHigh Achievers: number and percentage of grade 12 graduates who achieve high Academic GPA's (of 75% or higher).
STP FAST FACTS 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 B.C. Secondary School Graduation Rate: Percentage of all B.C. grade 12 students who graduated from high school within six years of the time they enrolled in grade
More informationCOLLEGES, INSTITUTES AND COMMUNITIES PARTNERS IN RURAL SUSTAINABILITY
COLLEGES, INSTITUTES AND COMMUNITIES PARTNERS IN RURAL SUSTAINABILITY ACCC SUBMISSION TO THE STANDING SENATE COMMITTEE ON SOCIAL AFFAIRS, SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY Brief prepared by: Association of Canadian
More informationBill C-27: First Nations Financial Transparency Act
Bill C-27: First Nations Financial Transparency Act Overview of Act Bill C-27: First Nations Financial Transparency Act was introduced in the House of Commons on November 23, 2011 and is identified as
More informationFORGOTTEN AND IGNORED: SPECIAL EDUCATION IN FIRST NATIONS SCHOOLS IN CANADA. Ron Phillips, Nipissing University
Canadian Journal of Educational Administration and Policy, Issue #106, June 7, 2010. by CJEAP and the author(s). FORGOTTEN AND IGNORED: SPECIAL EDUCATION IN FIRST NATIONS SCHOOLS IN CANADA Ron Phillips,
More informationSpecializations in Public Administration And Business Administration
Report #98 Specializations in Public Administration And Business Administration Prepared for the Northern Labour Market Information Clearinghouse Prepared by: Beverly A. MacKeen, Ph.D. and Associates (780)
More informationAboriginal Peoples in Canada in 2006: Inuit, Métis and First Nations, 2006 Census
Catalogue no. 97-558-XIE Aboriginal Peoples in Canada in 2006: Inuit, Métis and First Nations, 2006 Census Aboriginal Peoples, 2006 Census Census year 2006 Statistics Canada Statistique Canada How to obtain
More informationMYTHS AND FACTS. 1. What is wrong with the current system? Who is asking for a new system for education on reserve?
MYTHS AND FACTS 1. What is wrong with the current system? Who is asking for a new system for education on reserve? First Nations are not asking for a new system of education on reserve. First Nations are
More informationR E SEARCH HIGHLIGHTS
Canada Research Chair in Urban Change and Adaptation R E SEARCH HIGHLIGHTS Research Highlight No. 2 December 2003 IS WINNIPEG S ABORIGINAL POPULATION GHETTOIZED? Introduction While direct religious and/or
More informationInternet Connectivity Among Aboriginal Communities in Canada
Internet Connectivity Among Aboriginal Communities in Canada Since its inception the Internet has been the fastest growing and most convenient means to access timely information on just about everything.
More informationIssues in Canadian Universities and Impact on Business Schools
Issues in Canadian Universities and Impact on Business Schools November 14, 2012 Carleton University, Ottawa, Ontario By Christine Tausig Ford, Vice-President and Chief Operating Officer, AUCC Summary
More informationFederal Funding for First Nations Schools
Federal Funding for First Nations Schools Funding for First Nations schools is determined by Aboriginal Affairs and Northern Development Canada (AANDC) using an outdated national funding formula that was
More informationReport to UNECE and UNESCO on Indicators of Education for Sustainable Development. Report for Canada. October 2007
Report to UNECE and UNESCO on Indicators of Education for Sustainable Development Report for Canada October 2007 Prepared by the Council of Ministers of Education, Canada in collaboration with Environment
More informationThe Deputy Minister of Community Services Harvey Brooks
Recommendations by the: Chartered Accountants of the Yukon Certified Management Accountants of the Yukon Submitted to: The Minister of Community Services Hon. Elaine Taylor Date: March XX, 2013 The Deputy
More informationPerformance Appraisal: Director of Education. Date of Next Review: September 2015 (every 2 years)
POLICY SECTION: SUB-SECTION: POLICY NAME: POLICY NO: Board of Trustees Director Performance Appraisal: Director of Education H.C.06 Date Approved: September 26, 2013 Date of Next Review: September 2015
More informationArticle. First Nations, Métis and WInuit Women. by Vivian O'Donnell and Susan Wallace. July 2011
Component of Statistics Canada Catalogue no. 89-503-X Women in Canada: A Gender-based Statistical Report Article First Nations, Métis and WInuit Women by Vivian O'Donnell and Susan Wallace July 2011 How
More informationA Note on Business Tax Competitiveness in British Columbia
A Note on Business Tax Competitiveness in British Columbia Volume 21, Issue 2, May 2014 It s slightly more than one year since BC scrapped the Harmonized Sales Tax (HST) and returned to the former Provincial
More informationWhich Pays Better: Public or Private Sector Jobs?
Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives Ontario July 2014 Which Pays Better: Public or Private Sector Jobs? Settling the Debate Richard Shillington www.policyalternatives.ca RESEARCH ANALYSIS SOLUTIONS
More informationDimensions of core housing need in Canada
C O O P E R A T I V E H O U S I N G F E D E R A T I O N O F C A N A D A Dimensions of core housing need in Canada Completed by Will Dunning Inc. for Co-operative Housing Federation of Canada July 2007
More informationProfile of New Brunswick High School Students: Their Reading Skills
Profile of New Brunswick High School Students: Their Reading Skills Research Program on Post-Secondary Education and Training Opportunities in New Brunswick Report #2 February 27, 2007 Undertaken by Tomasz
More informationQUOTAS IN PRACTICE: THE CHALLENGE OF IMPLEMENTATION AND ENFORCEMENT IN RWANDA
QUOTAS IN PRACTICE: THE CHALLENGE OF IMPLEMENTATION AND ENFORCEMENT IN RWANDA Honourable Judith Kanakuze, Member of Parliament, Chamber of Deputies, Kigali, Rwanda A paper presented at the International
More informationCONTRIBUTING PERSPECTIVE DEMOGRAPHIC TRENDS
CONTRIBUTING PERSPECTIVE DEMOGRAPHIC TRENDS June 2013 Canadian Bar Association 865 Carling Avenue, Suite 500 Ottawa, ON K1S 5S8 Tel.: (613) 237-2925 / (800) 267-8860 Fax: (613) 237-0185 E-mail: futures@cba.org
More informationParticipation in Post-Secondary Education: Recent Trends Joseph Berger
The Price of Knowledge Access and Student Finance in Canada 2 Participation in Post-Secondary Education: Recent Trends Joseph Berger 27 Chapter 2 I. Introduction Canada has the highest level of educational
More informationSTP FAST FACTS. Regional Transition Rates from grade 12 graduation to B.C. public post secondary education.
STP FAST FACTS 1 2 3 4 5 6 B.C. Secondary School Six Year Completion Rate: Percentage of all B.C. grade 12 students who graduated from high school within six years of the time they enrolled in grade 8.
More informationPublic Housing and Public Schools: How Do Students Living in NYC Public Housing Fare in School?
Furman Center for real estate & urban policy New York University school of law wagner school of public service november 2008 Policy Brief Public Housing and Public Schools: How Do Students Living in NYC
More informationSmall Business Deduction and the Federal Tax Credit
Institut C.D. HOWE Institute commentary NO. 426 Small Business Preferences as a Barrier to Growth: Not so Tall After All Federal and provincial governments provide tax supports for small businesses. What
More informationAPPENDIX I SOCIAL WORK/SOCIAL SERVICES WORK PROGRAMS SOCIAL WORK/SOCIAL SERVICES WORK PROGRAMS IN BRITISH COLUMBIA
APPENDIX I SOCIAL WORK/SOCIAL SERVICES WORK PROGRAMS SOCIAL WORK/SOCIAL SERVICES WORK PROGRAMS IN BRITISH COLUMBIA INSTITUTION PROGRAM CREDENTIAL NOTES College of the New Caledonia College of the New Caledonia
More informationLondon 3Ts Reference Report
London 3Ts Reference Report Benchmarking Project: Ontario Competes Ontario in the Creative Age April 2009 REF. 2009-BMONT-012 Contents Introduction... 3 Technology Results... 4 Talent Results... 5 Tolerance
More informationPaper on First Nations Education. Funding. First Nations Education Council
Paper on First Nations Education Funding First Nations Education Council February 2009 This paper will be updated regularly to identify costs where estimates are missing and to update costs to reflect
More informationRegulations of the Teacher Qualification Service
Regulations of the Teacher Qualification Service A Joint Project of the BC Teacher's Federation and the BC School Trustees Association Teacher Qualification Service #106-1525 West 8th Avenue VANCOUVER,
More informationAtlantic Provinces 71 COMMUNITIES
NATIONAL STUDY OF AUTOMOBILE INSURANCE RATES Third Release Atlantic Provinces 71 COMMUNITIES vs. British Columbia, Alberta Saskatchewan, Manitoba & Ontario 3,985,162 Auto Insurance Rates Compared October
More informationComprehensive Emergency Management Education 604.528.5800 1.877.528.5591
Bachelor of Emergency & Security Management Studies prepare yourself and your team with the most accessible, customizable emergency management training from Canada s Leading Public Safety Educator Comprehensive
More informationMarch 2014 Second survey report: skills shortages in Canada
Second survey report: skills shortages in Canada About the Initiative This document is one of a series of reports and briefs prepared for Taking Action for Canada: Jobs and Skills for the 21 st Century,
More informationAGREEMENT IN PRINCIPLE Labour Mobility Chapter of the Agreement on Internal Trade/Teaching Profession 1999 09 29
AGREEMENT IN PRINCIPLE Labour Mobility Chapter of the Agreement on Internal Trade/Teaching Profession 1999 09 29 This agreement in principle is developed in conformity with the provisions of Chapter 7
More informationThe Alberta Student Assessment Study Executive Summary
The Alberta Student Assessment Study Executive Summary Charles F. Webber, University of Calgary Nola Aitken, University of Lethbridge Judy Lupart, University of Alberta Shelleyann Scott, University of
More informationFAIRNESS IN INTEREST GRACE PERIOD Eliminating the Interest During a Student s Immediate Post-Loan Grace Period 49% $716
FAIRNESS IN INTEREST GRACE PERIOD Eliminating the Interest During a Student s Immediate Post-Loan Grace Period Currently, at the conclusion of a student loan period, students are given a six month grace
More informationHuman resources development and training
International Labour Conference 92nd Session 2004 Report IV (1) Human resources development and training Fourth item on the agenda International Labour Office Geneva ISBN 92-2-113036-3 ISSN 0074-6681 First
More informationStrengthening the Canada Pension Plan: Take it to the public
Strengthening the Canada Pension Plan: Take it to the public by Ken Battle, Sherri Torjman and Michael Mendelson November 2013 Strengthening the Canada Pension Plan: Take it to the public by Ken Battle,
More informationOccupational Therapists in Canada, 2010 National and Jurisdictional Highlights and Profiles
Occupational Therapists in Canada, 2010 National and Jurisdictional Highlights and Profiles October 2011 Spending and Health Workforce Who We Are Established in 1994, CIHI is an independent, not-for-profit
More informationRed Seal Endorsement and Employer Satisfaction in Private Sector
Survey of Employers in Specific Trades Regarding the Red Seal Program FINAL REPORT Submitted to: John Kealey Trades and Apprenticeship Division Human Resources and Skills Development Canada EKOS RESEARCH
More informationState of Financial Education In Canada
State of Financial Education In Canada Report: November, 2015 Prepared for TD Bank Group by the Canadian Foundation for Economic Education (CFEE) Executive Summary TD Bank Group has an extensive history
More informationIn contrast to other age groups, more Canadians
Youth volunteering on the rise Frank Jones In contrast to other age groups, more Canadians aged 15 to 24 are becoming volunteers. The volunteer participation rate of most of the population changed little
More informationAboriginal Affairs and Northern Development Canada. Internal Audit Report. Audit of Management of Negotiation Loans. Prepared by:
Aboriginal Affairs and Northern Development Canada Internal Audit Report Audit of Management of Negotiation Loans Prepared by: Audit and Assurance Services Branch Project No. 12-11 February 2013 TABLE
More informationPolice-reported crime statistics, 2014 Released at 8:30 a.m. Eastern time in The Daily, Wednesday, July 22, 2015
Police-reported crime statistics, 2014 Released at 8:30 a.m. Eastern time in The Daily, Wednesday, July 22, 2015 The Crime Severity Index (CSI) measures the volume and severity of police-reported crime.
More informationMay 14, 2015 Our Ref: 99816
May 14, 2015 Our Ref: 99816 Mr. Brian Ross Chair, Board of Governors Thompson Rivers University 900 McGill Rd Kamloops BC V2C 0C8 Dear Mr. Ross: Re: 2015/16 Mandate Letter for Public Post-Secondary Institutions
More informationDrug Strategy Community Initiatives Fund
Health Canada Santé Canada Drug Strategy Community Initiatives Fund Funding Guidelines for 2005-2006 Our mission is to help the people of Canada maintain and improve their health. Published by authority
More informationSaskatchewan Small Business Profile 2015
Saskatchewan Small Business Profile 2015 October 2015 Ministry of the Economy Performance and Strategic Initiatives Division economy.gov.sk.ca Table of Contents INTRODUCTION... 1 KEY FACTS... 3 1. SMALL
More informationUNIVERSITY WORKS 2015 EMPLOYMENT REPORT
UNIVERSITY WORKS 2015 EMPLOYMENT REPORT University Works uses empirical data to report on the outcomes of university graduates in terms of employment levels and earnings, as well as average debt upon graduation.
More informationFraser Alert. Canadians Celebrate Tax Freedom Day on June 6. June 2009. Main Conclusions. Market solutions to public policy problems
Fraser Alert Market solutions to public policy problems June 2009 Canadians Celebrate Tax Freedom Day on June 6 Main Conclusions On Tax Freedom Day, the average Canadian family has earned enough money
More informationThe Degree Mobility Spectrum: The Tiering of Canadian Degrees. Dave Marshall, PhD. Mount Royal College. 4825 Mount Royal Gate SW
The Degree Mobility Spectrum: The Tiering of Canadian Degrees Dave Marshall, PhD Mount Royal College 4825 Mount Royal Gate SW Calgary, Alberta T3E 6K6 dmarshall@mtroyal.ca Being submitted for publication
More informationGender and Diversity in Law: List of Resources
Gender and Diversity in Law: List of Resources The Faculty of law would like to thank law student Xue Yan, who compiled the following list of resources. Resources by Subject of Documents... 2 Aboriginal
More informationCONTENTS. Executive Summary... 3 BC Labour Market. Credentials. Employment Outcomes
CONTENTS Executive Summary... 3 BC Labour Market Skills Deficit 2016 to 2020. 5 Labour Market Outlook 2010 to 2020. 6 Employment by Sector..... 7 Job Openings 2010 to 2020..... 8 Regional Job Openings
More informationSpending on Postsecondary. of Education, Fact Sheet. Education Indicators in Canada. June 2011
Catalogue no. 81-599-X Issue no. 007 ISSN: 1709-8653 ISBN: 978-1-100-18860-7 Education Indicators in Canada Spending on Postsecondary Education June 2011 Tourism and the Centre for Education Statistics
More informationProfile of Canadian Environmental Employment
Profile of Canadian Environmental Employment LABOUR MARKET RESEARCH STUDY 2010 ECO CANADA ECO Canada develops programs that help individuals build meaningful environmental careers, provides employers with
More informationReport of the CMEC Quality Assurance Subcommittee
Report of the CMEC Quality Assurance Subcommittee 2007 2007 CMEC Jurisdictional Update on Activities Related to Quality Assurance Introduction In February 2007, ministers responsible for advanced education
More informationSUPPORTING. Immigrants and Immigration to Alberta AN OVERVIEW
SUPPORTING Immigrants and Immigration to Alberta AN OVERVIEW Table of Contents Introduction...1 Alberta s Vision of Immigration...3 Attracting and Retaining Immigrants to Alberta...3 The Need for Immigration...4
More informationOVERVIEW OF CURRENT SCHOOL ADMINISTRATORS
Chapter Three OVERVIEW OF CURRENT SCHOOL ADMINISTRATORS The first step in understanding the careers of school administrators is to describe the numbers and characteristics of those currently filling these
More informationPart 4 of the Corporate and Community Social Responsibility Research Series
Ethical Investing Part 4 of the Corporate and Community Social Responsibility Research Series A survey of 1,000 Canadians Conducted from March 24 to 28, 2011 Conducted for: The Corporate and Community
More information2015 Annual Alberta Labour Market Review. Employment. Unemployment. Economic Regions. Migration. Indigenous People. Industries
2015 Annual Alberta Labour Market Review Employment. Unemployment. Economic Regions Migration. Indigenous People. Industries Occupations. Education. Demographics Employment Despite the economic downturn,
More informationNational Retail Report Canada FALL 2015 EDITION. Accelerating success.
National Retail Report Canada FALL 2015 EDITION Accelerating success. Report prepared by Colliers International Consulting James Smerdon Vice President and Director, Retail Consulting DIRECT +1 604 685
More information