1 2009s-47 Fair Value Accounting Michel Magnan, Dan Thornton Série Scientifique Scientific Series Montréal Décembre Michel Magnan, Dan Thornton. Tous droits réservés. All rights reserved. Reproduction partielle permise avec citation du document source, incluant la notice. Short sections may be quoted without explicit permission, if full credit, including notice, is given to the source.
2 CIRANO Le CIRANO est un organisme sans but lucratif constitué en vertu de la Loi des compagnies du Québec. Le financement de son infrastructure et de ses activités de recherche provient des cotisations de ses organisations-membres, d une subvention d infrastructure du Ministère du Développement économique et régional et de la Recherche, de même que des subventions et mandats obtenus par ses équipes de recherche. CIRANO is a private non-profit organization incorporated under the Québec Companies Act. Its infrastructure and research activities are funded through fees paid by member organizations, an infrastructure grant from the Ministère du Développement économique et régional et de la Recherche, and grants and research mandates obtained by its research teams. Les partenaires du CIRANO Partenaire majeur Ministère du Développement économique, de l Innovation et de l Exportation Partenaires corporatifs Banque de développement du Canada Banque du Canada Banque Laurentienne du Canada Banque Nationale du Canada Banque Royale du Canada Banque Scotia Bell Canada BMO Groupe financier Caisse de dépôt et placement du Québec DMR Fédération des caisses Desjardins du Québec Gaz Métro Hydro-Québec Industrie Canada Investissements PSP Ministère des Finances du Québec Power Corporation du Canada Raymond Chabot Grant Thornton Rio Tinto State Street Global Advisors Transat A.T. Ville de Montréal Partenaires universitaires École Polytechnique de Montréal HEC Montréal McGill University Université Concordia Université de Montréal Université de Sherbrooke Université du Québec Université du Québec à Montréal Université Laval Le CIRANO collabore avec de nombreux centres et chaires de recherche universitaires dont on peut consulter la liste sur son site web. Les cahiers de la série scientifique (CS) visent à rendre accessibles des résultats de recherche effectuée au CIRANO afin de susciter échanges et commentaires. Ces cahiers sont écrits dans le style des publications scientifiques. Les idées et les opinions émises sont sous l unique responsabilité des auteurs et ne représentent pas nécessairement les positions du CIRANO ou de ses partenaires. This paper presents research carried out at CIRANO and aims at encouraging discussion and comment. The observations and viewpoints expressed are the sole responsibility of the authors. They do not necessarily represent positions of CIRANO or its partners. ISSN Partenaire financier
3 Fair Value Accounting * Michel Magnan, Dan Thornton Résumé Le document présente une genèse de la comptabilisation à la juste valeur et revoit certains travaux de recherche et certaines preuves empiriques qui sont pertinents dans le cadre du débat entourant le recours à cette méthode. Nous commentons aussi le rôle de la comptabilisation à la juste valeur dans le contexte de la crise financière : a-t-elle simplement été un indicateur de mauvaises nouvelles ou a-t-elle été «procyclique», c est-à-dire a-t-elle contribué à la triste situation économique en plus d informer sur celle-ci? Nous décrivons brièvement la comptabilisation à la juste valeur comme étant constituée de trois niveaux d évaluation : le niveau 1 pour les actifs/passifs dont la valeur de marché est directement observable ; le niveau 2 pour les actifs/passifs dont les données issues du marché, mais non les prix, sont observables ; et le niveau 3 pour les actifs/passifs dont la valeur est obtenue à partir de modèles. Nous concluons que le recours à la méthode de comptabilisation à la juste valeur par les organismes de réglementation a probablement été procyclique dans le cas des éléments d actif du niveau 1 évalués selon cette méthode, c est-à-dire les actifs dont les valeurs comptables était fondées sur les prix du marché directement observables. En comparaison, les valeurs comptables établies selon la comptabilisation à la juste valeur dans le cas des éléments d actif qui n étaient pas fortement négociés (niveaux 2 et 3) ont probablement pris du recul par rapport à l évolution du marché et ont vraisemblablement fait l objet d opinions biaisées quant à leur estimation. Notre analyse permet aussi de penser que la pertinence de l évaluation selon la comptabilisation à la juste valeur est tributaire des conditions du marché (efficience et fluidité) et que les facteurs d évaluation fondamentaux, dont les flux de trésorerie sous-jacents aux actifs/passifs, sont toujours pertinents malgré l existence de prix du marché parallèles. En terminant, le document offre des observations au sujet du rôle des vérificateurs, des organismes de réglementation et de normalisation, ainsi que des investisseurs en ce qui a trait à l information qui se dégage de la comptabilisation à la juste valeur. Mots clés : comptabilisation à la juste valeur, procyclicalité, crise de liquidité, juste valeur marchande, efficience du marché, bulle * Acknowledgments: The authors are grateful for support from SSHRCC Standard Research Grant No , the Chartered Accountants Professorship at Queen s University and the Lawrence Bloomberg Chair at Concordia University. Ph.D., FCA, ASC, Lawrence Bloomberg Chair in Accountancy, John Molson School of Business, Concordia University, Associate Fellow, CIRANO. Ph.D., FCA, Chartered Accountants of Ontario, Professor of Accounting, Queen s University School of Business, Associate Fellow, CIRANO.
4 Abstract The paper provides a genesis of fair value accounting (FVA) and reviews some research and empirical evidence that are relevant to the debate surrounding its use. We also comment on FVA s role in the financial crisis: was it just the messenger of bad news or was it procyclical, contributing to the sad state of the economy in addition to reporting on it? We briefly characterize FVA as comprising three levels of valuation: level 1 for assets/liabilities for which market values are directly observable, level 2 for assets/liabilities for which market-derived inputs, but not prices, are observable and level 3 for assets/liabilities which value is derived from models. We conclude that the use of FVA by regulators was probably procyclical for level 1 FVA assets, i.e., those assets which accounting values were based upon directly observable market prices. In contrast, accounting values for FVA assets that were not actively traded (levels 2 and 3) probably lagged market developments and were likely biased in their valuation. Our analysis also suggests that the appropriateness of FVA-derived valuation is conditional upon market conditions (efficiency and liquidity), and that fundamental valuation drivers such as an asset/ liability underlying cash flows are still relevant valuation inputs despite the existence of concurrent market prices. The paper concludes with some observations regarding the role of auditors, regulators, standard-setters and investors regarding FVA-derived information. Keywords: Fair value accounting, procyclicality, liquidity crisis, fair market value, market efficiency, bubble.
5 1 Introduction When we started writing this article, the InTrade.com web site was offering to the public a security paying a hundred dollars if a North American city were later chosen to host the 2016 Summer Olympics, and zero dollars if it weren t. The bid and ask prices of this security were $50.10 and $54.30, suggesting a probability range for the Olympics taking place in North America of between 50% and 54%. The prices rose a week later when President Obama visited Scandinavia to promote Chicago as the venue, then crashed to zero when Rio de Janeiro was awarded the games. On any given day, up to 100,000 InTrade clients trade securities promising to pay $ if similar political, economic, and social events transpire. The website says its security prices provide unbiased estimates of the probabilities the events will happen. If the probability of Chicago getting the Olympics had been higher than 54%, there would have been excess demand for the Olympics security by the cognoscenti. They would have bid up the price and pushed the market toward equilibrium, where the marginal informed trader would have been indifferent between buying and shorting the security. Economists have long agreed that prices in perfect markets transmit less biased estimates of the values of commodities and securities than any single expert trader could provide. In the past decade or so, accounting standards acceded to this efficient-markets view at an increasing rate, under the rubric of Fair Value Accounting ( FVA ). At first, the shift from Historical Cost Accounting (HCA) toward FVA spawned orderly debates among accountants, businesspeople, regulators and investors about the definition of fair value and when its use was appropriate. But during the financial crisis, when even economic theorists doubted that financial
6 2 markets were working anywhere close to perfection, the debates intensified, shining a harsh light on FVA and the accounting profession in general. We review some research and empirical evidence that are relevant to the FVA debate. We also comment on FVA s role in the financial crisis: was it just the messenger of bad news or was it procyclical, contributing to the sad state of the economy in addition to reporting on it? Time to Take Stock FVA has had its ups and downs. In the late 19 th and early 20 th centuries, firms often valued their capital assets using appraised, net realizable values. By the 1930s, moral hazard manifest in abusive and self-serving over-valuation practices by some managers led to the dominance of HCA as an antidote. However, accounting theorists continued to tout FVA and a one-sided version of FVA ( lower-of-cost-or-market ) continued to be applied to inventories. FVA did not emerge in full bloom again until 1993, in SFAS 115 Accounting for Certain Investments in Debt and Equity Securities. Ironically, SFAS 115 was predicated on the assumption that HCA allows managers to smooth companies earnings by timing the recognition of unrealized portfolio gains and losses; and FVA is the antidote for this earnings management hanky panky. Another, implicit assumption was that quoted market prices for securities possess at least some of the magical properties alluded to in the introduction to this article, conveying less biased information than would be provided by any single market participant, including the management of the reporting company. But what if quoted market prices are unavailable? FVA Hierarchy US standard setters took a step toward answering that question in 2006 when they issued SFAS 157 Fair Value Measurements, defining fair value as...the price that would be received to sell an asset or paid to transfer a liability in an orderly transaction between market participants at
7 3 the measurement date... So, whenever FVA is called for, one uses quoted prices of assets, if they are available, in actual, well-functioning markets. If they aren t available, one must simulate what those prices would be, if such markets existed. This requirement raised two additional questions that inflamed FVA debates during the financial crisis: How do we know if markets are working well enough to use quoted market prices without further investigation? And if quoted market prices are unavailable or if markets are not working well enough to rely on those prices, how can we ensure that the simulated prices faithfully simulate the hypothetical prices that would eventuate in a real market? After all, managers propounding the prices are subject to moral hazard. At least some of them would be expected to exaggerate fair values and to self-select whether to use quoted or simulated prices. SFAS 157 identifies three categories of fair values depending on the level of judgment or subjectivity associated with their measurement. At level 1, financial instruments are measured at quoted prices for identical instruments in active markets. If an asset does not trade in an active market but valuation inputs are observable, level 2 fair values reflect a) quoted prices for similar financial instruments in active markets, b) quoted prices for identical or similar financial instruments in markets that are not active, c) inputs other than quoted prices but which are observable (e.g., rates on a yield curve in-between quoted rates) or d) correlated prices. Finally, at level 3, one finds assets that have no market or are so unique as to have no comparable assets whose prices could be used as bench marks. They would be marked-to-model using discounted cash flow models or hypothetical hedge portfolios, based on knowledgeable market participants views and assessments. In a recent article, Alex Milburn observed that active, well-regulated capital markets exhibit reasonable efficiency. However, it is easy to see that the potential for moral hazard and
8 4 adverse selection escalates as we move down the valuation hierarchy, especially in going from level 2 to level 3. For example, the New York Times recently reported that Wall Street was flirting with a new financial instrument called securitized insurance. The idea would be to approach individuals with $1 million life insurance policies and offer them, say, $400 thousand to assign the $1 million payoff to the buyer. Tranches of these assigned policies would then be bundled and sold to investors. The investors would profit if policy holders died shortly after assigning the payoffs. A securitized insurance specialist said that the chief risk was that drug companies would discover a cure for cancer, prolonging the time before the payoff and reducing its present value. On reflection, one can see the potential for moral hazard (sellers understating their health) and adverse selection (healthy people accepting the payouts). We doubt that any analyst could provide reliable level 3 simulated prices for these derivatives. Distressed Markets A related issue is what to do when markets would normally provide reliable, level 1 quotes but are temporarily distressed. Economists Franklin Allen and Elena Carletti recently provided very substantial insights on this issue. They argue that markets work properly only if market prices reflect the present value of future cash flows. However, in times of financial crisis, such as the Russian crisis of 1998 that led to the demise of Long Term Capital Management and the credit crisis of 2008, prices diverge from the asset s underlying value and instead reflect the amount of cash-in-the-market, the liquidity that is available to buyers who are currently active. In such times, money becomes a valuable good in itself rather than being a mere numeraire that we use to keep track of the prices of other goods. If money is in short supply, the only sustainable equilibrium entails all security prices falling. Liquidity injected by governments is then a tide that lifts all boats.
9 5 An example of liquidity pricing relates to the 2008 price collapse of AAA-rated tranches of mortgage backed securities. Some banks had to write down AAA-rated super senior tranches of mortgage-linked collateralized debt obligations by as much as 30% because of a drop in market prices. If this price drop had stemmed from deterioration in the fundamental value of the mortgages, it would have implied a loss rate of 38%, consistent with 76% of the households defaulting and only repaying 50% of the face value of the mortgages. The Bank of England noted that this was not realistic because none of the AAA-rated tranches had yet defaulted and the Bank estimated that there should not be any future defaults at all, even with a continued decline in US house prices. Another indication of liquidity pricing is the unusually high co-movement among different types of securities with different fundamentals. This can only be explained by their joint dependence on a third variable, the amount of cash in the market. In such situations, slavishly marking down asset values to quoted prices on banks balance sheets can exacerbate a liquidity crunch by forcing banks to sell good assets at depressed prices to obtain enough liquidity to maintain regulatory solvency or capital ratios. Unfortunately, this means there will be more good assets chasing the same amount (or less) of cash-in-the-market. This can drive down asset prices even farther in a vicious circle and even lead to contagion in the market where all banks suffer and liquidity is unavailable to finance business activities in the real economy. At the time of writing, the IASB s solution is to account for banking books groups of assets managed on the basis of income and expenses incurred to maturity of the instruments at amortized historic cost, reflecting only expected credit losses in earnings. Expected credit losses would be estimated using management s estimates of expected cash flows, irrespective of the quoted fair values of similar assets in distressed markets. The FASB, in contrast, seems to be
10 6 moving toward always marking banks financial instruments to market but sending non-credit loss markdowns, during times of market distress, to Other Comprehensive Income ( OCI ). Financial statement readers would then decide how much weight to put on the OCI amounts. In our view, the key issue to resolve is whether distressed asset prices reflect what would be obtained from the distressed sale of good assets that banks might be forced to sell to satisfy liquidity needs or the desire to offload lemons whose expected cash inflows are lower than they were when the assets were purchased. Consumers of used cars can appreciate the distinction. When a seller advertises a car as must sell, presumably the seller is trying to convince readers that he or she doesn t really want to sell the car but needs to sell it to obtain liquidity. Is this a credible claim or is it a ruse to sell a lemon to a sucker? If the claim is true, the seller has every incentive to convince us it is true, by disclosing the car s service records. Financial statement users have information needs that are similar to the readers of used car ads and banks have incentives that are very similar to those of used car sellers. Accounting can supply valuable information to users, including bank regulators and policy makers, by distinguishing good assets from lemons. The good assets do not deserve to be marked down to quoted prices provided banks have the ability and intention to hold them long enough to recover their investments. The lemons, however, do deserve to be marked down as they are not going to pay off no matter how long a bank holds them. This has nothing to do with how long the market for financial assets might be depressed because of liquidity pricing. It also has nothing to do with whether the market is efficient or not. It has to do with the fundamental valuation of the asset. Like used car sellers, bankers have every incentive to convince auditors that their assets are not lemons by presenting detailed data relating to borrowers financial strength and plausible assumptions about the amount and timing of future collections, co-movements of asset prices
11 7 with similar assets in the market, and so on. In our view, the real issue is not whether we footnote non-credit losses or relegate them to OCI, it is whether the numbers are backed up by rigorous auditing to ensure the plausibility of expected cash flows. Early empirical evidence is consistent with this preference. Procyclicality Early Empirical Evidence Three recent empirical studies shed some early light on investors assessments of the carrying values of US banks assets and liabilities during the financial crisis. The studies used cross-sectional regressions to estimate the multiples that shareholders assigned to level 1, 2, and 3 carrying values in pricing bank shares during Results are summarized in the table below. Two Studies of Quarterly Ranges of Valuation Multiples during 2008 One Study Combining all Quarters Hierarchy Levels (Dollars of Share Price per Dollar of Assets at Three Levels of the Valuation Hierarchy) Q1 Q2 Q3 Combined Quarters Level 1 $0.81 $0.84 $0.64 $1.03 $1.01 $1.00 for both assets and liabilities Level 2 $0.77 $0.58 $0.63 $0.50 $1.00 for both assets and liabilities Level 3 $0.65 $0.71 $0.37 $0.42 $0.28 +$0.68 for assets; $2.19 for liabilities One study looked at all four quarters of 2008, combined. It reported that level 1 and 2 assets and liabilities were valued by investors at close to their reported book on average. Level 3 assets, however, were heavily discounted: share prices reflected only $0.68 per dollar of carrying value on the balance sheet. Moreover, level 3 liabilities were priced at more than double their carrying values, so that share prices were $2.19 lower for every extra dollar of level 3 liabilities. This implies that investors took level 3 carrying values with a strong grain of salt. Importantly,
12 8 however, the study reported that stronger governance was associated with higher asset multiples and lower liability multiples, especially at levels 2 and 3. Governance measures included board independence, audit committee activity, ownership structure, internal controls, and auditor size. Two other studies estimated similar valuation multiples quarterly for At the end of Q1 2008, a one dollar cross-sectional increase in level 1 net assets was valued at $0.81 $0.84, while similar increases in the carrying values of level 2 and 3 assets were valued at $0.65 to $0.77. As the crisis intensified, however, the table above shows that some of the multiples declined dramatically, especially for level 3 assets most spectacularly in Q3 when the level 3 multiple declined to $0.28. Indeed, in Q3 the level 3 multiple was not significantly greater than zero except for banks with high capital adequacy ratios and Big-Four auditors. One of the studies, which focused on smaller banks listed on the NASDAQ, showed that the level 1 multiple actually increased in Q2 and Q3, consistent with the suggestion that investors thought that the assets had been written down too much: i.e., the accounting was mildly procyclical, leading rather than lagging the deterioration in the economy. We draw three tentative conclusions from these early studies. First, if FVA is procyclical, the procyclical impact of the accounting was evident only in level 1 assets, which were marked down as much as, or even a bit more than, investors valuation of the assets especially on the balance sheets of smaller, NASDAQ-listed banks. These are precisely the assets that banks would have been likely to sell if they needed liquidity. Level 3 asset values, in contrast, were resistant to mark-downs: the accounting for these assets lagged, rather than leading, the economic downcycle. It is unlikely that the banks would have sold them during the crisis. Second, investors generally perceived that level 3 asset carrying values were biased upward, especially as the crisis intensified. This probably reflected time lags in marking the
13 9 instruments to model, the uncertainty about their actual fair values, and, perhaps, the discretion available to management in biasing the carrying values upward to suit their own purposes. Third, more favorable capital ratios, higher quality auditors, and stronger governance translate into higher valuation coefficients for level 2 and 3 assets. Hence, marking to model including the IASB s incurred credit loss model is a defensible accounting method provided auditors can attest to the credibility of management s estimates. The case of Lehman Brothers is consistent with the empirical findings and our tentative conclusions. On November 30, 2007, three-quarters of Lehman s fair-valued assets were valued using level 2 or 3 inputs, not on the basis of quoted prices. By May 31, 2008, that proportion had increased to nearly 82%. Further empirical work as well as the liquidation of Lehman Brothers will eventually provide evidence regarding the extent to which its assets had been overstated or purposely shifted into levels 2 or 3, to hide developing losses and give management more breathing room before marking down the assets. This unflattering interpretation is consistent with Lehman Brothers being an early-adopter of both SFAS 157 (Fair Value Measurements) and SFAS 159 (Option for Fair Value Measurement) and implementing the provisions of the new FVA standards in Q without having auditors attest specifically to the credibility of the estimates. Accounting and the Market: Mirrors Facing Each Other? Reporting market prices on corporate balance sheets is inconsistent with using financial statement data to see if a firm s stock price reflects its fundamental or intrinsic value. Finance studies in the late 1990s show that value and price are statistically co-integrated; however, they can diverge from each other for considerable periods of time when information acquisition is costly or markets are distressed. The studies also suggest that value relevance has two
14 10 dimensions. When price is a noisy measure of value, value-relevance may be assessed according to the ability of an information signal to contribute to future returns rather than current values. Other studies conducted during the late 1990s and early 2000s raise a fundamental question, at the macro-economic level, as to the grounding of financial statements in real economic phenomena. A study by Norman Macintosh and his colleagues at Queen s University in 2000 argues companies earnings determine security prices, which determine derivative prices, which determine companies earnings. In short, neither the accounting sign nor the financial market sign appear to be grounded in any external reality. Instead, each model appeals to the other model for the only reality check available. In other words, at the macro-economic level, accounting and the market are like two mirrors reflecting each other, each depending on the other for its information, in an endless endogeneity-loop where it is not clear what determines what. This has the potential to create market bubbles, where asset prices are decoupled from underlying cash flows; and to create systemic risk, where companies (especially financial institutions) mutually depend on each others assessment of fair values of derivatives without reference to underlying property values. The Lehman case illustrates that possibility. During the last complete fiscal year before its bankruptcy (2007), Lehman reported earnings of $4.3 billion. Investors presumably relied on Lehman s reported earnings to assess its prospects and determine share price. A significant proportion of Lehman s assets and expenses were shares and share-based derivatives. Close to 50% of its assets were measured according to FVA. Arguably, then, Lehman s earnings and stock price were mutual reflections of each other. Similar arguments may apply to many financial institutions deeply involved in the current crisis or engulfed by it.
15 11 Implications for Standard-Setters and the Profession The use of FVA is spreading beyond financial instruments and banks. It is manifest in such areas as the measurement of minority interests, capital asset revaluations under IFRS, and goodwill impairments. This emphasis on FVA evinces a focus by standard-setters on the information needs of investors, especially shareholders, to the potential detriment of other financial statement users. Support for FVA in the academic literature comes largely from empirical findings that FVA-based numbers are associated with companies share prices they are value-relevant. However, mere associations between accounting numbers and stock market prices do not justify adopting FVA holus bolus, because accounting serves many constituents besides shareholders, often serving as a basis for contracts relating to compensation, debt covenants, and partnership interests. Lenders, for example, would be loath to endorse a firm s policy of paying dividends based on unrealized, expected cash flows. We think that the excessive bonuses paid by many financial firms in the years leading to the crisis, often based partly on FVA-derived earnings, suggest that enthusiasm for FVA should be tempered with caution in compensation contracts as well. In short, FVA pulls accounting away from its traditional stewardship role, for which verifiability and conservatism ensure that payouts are based on delivered, not expected, performance. The emergence of FVA also poses challenges for auditors. The market crisis has made clear that auditors cannot blindly rely on quoted prices. We think that the evidence strongly suggests that auditors need to go beyond reported prices to gain a comprehensive understanding of underlying market conditions in the context of companies business models: banking books would generally not be affected by quoted values, provided audits add credibility to level 2 and 3 carrying values.
16 12 Conclusion There can be little doubt that regulators use of FVA, as it is currently practiced, can result in FVA being more than just a messenger delivering bad news. Perhaps paradoxically, however, we view this and other criticisms of FVA during the financial crisis as being good for the accounting profession, in the sense that they have caused standard setters to ponder when FVA is appropriate and when quoted market prices can be relied on as reliable indicators of fair values. Without the crisis, accountants would have merely speculated how FVA should be modified in distressed markets; during the crisis, they had to confront the issue head-on. The FVA debate goes beyond accounting and financial reporting. It strikes at the essence of what accountants are expected to contribute to society and what competencies and skills they must possess in order to deliver useful information to financial statement readers. We believe that accounting standards overstretch accountants current capabilities and prior learning, and they tend to ignore the informational needs of stakeholders other than investors. In our view, standard setters and auditors need to start with a clean sheet of paper in determining how FVA is implemented. When level 1 inputs are unavailable or unreliable due to market distress, manifest in such phenomena as liquidity pricing or cash-in-the-market pricing, management must drill down into the opaque assets on banks balance sheets to assess their underlying value, and auditors must opine on the plausibility of managers expected cash flow projections. If management claims that quoted prices diverge from intrinsic values due to a lack of liquidity, then a rigorous audit could validate management s claim. Otherwise, the securities are probably lemons and should be summarily marked to market. We call on accountants to exercise leadership over the financial reporting process instead of passively relaying market-induced values. The evidence shows that investors valuation of fair-
17 13 valued assets is enhanced by higher quality auditing and stronger governance, suggesting that accountants can add credibility to fair values by taking an active role in auditing level 2 and 3 inputs and expressing opinions about the plausibility of level 2 and 3 fair values. To the extent that they are reluctant to do this because of legal liability concerns, it would be appropriate to consider safe-harbor reforms of the legal liability regime for auditors. The intervention of external parties, such as auditors, also has the potential to break the facing-mirrors endogeneity-loop by focusing on the fundamental cash flows underlying asset values. Thus, the market crisis has provided the accounting and auditing profession with a rare opportunity to actively manage the transition of financial statements toward a more thoughtful, better grounded way of implementing FVA. The future of the profession rests on its success in managing this transition.
2015s-13 Effective Age of Retirement: Innovative Methodology and Recent Experience Maxime Comeau, Denis Latulippe Série Scientifique/Scientific Series 2015s-13 Effective Age of Retirement: Innovative Methodology
2014s-31 Global Value Chains and Trade Elasticities Byron S. Gangnes, Alyson C. Ma, Ari Van Assche Série Scientifique Scientific Series Montréal Juin 2014 2014 Byron S. Gangnes, Alyson C. Ma, Ari Van Assche..
014s-16 General Equilibrium Effects of Green Technological Progress Ngo Van Long, Frank Staehler Série Scientifique Scientific Series Montréal Février 014/February 014 014 Ngo Van Long, Frank Staehler.
2011s-56 Fair Value Accounting: Information or Confusion for Financial Markets? Antonio Parbonetti, Andrea Menini, Michel Magnan Série Scientifique Scientific Series Montréal Août 2011 2011 Antonio Parbonetti,
INTERIM FINANCIAL STATEMENTS FOR THE THIRD QUARTER ENDED SEPTEMBER 30, (UNAUDITED AND EXPRESSED IN CANADIAN DOLLARS) NOTICE TO READER Under National Instrument 51-102, Part 4, subsection 4.3(3) (a), if
2007s-30 The Competitive Value of Music to Commercial Radio Stations Paul Audley, Marcel Boyer Série Scientifique Scientific Series Décembre 2007 2007 Paul Audley, Marcel Boyer. Tous droits réservés. All
High Yield Bonds A Primer With our extensive history in the Canadian credit market dating back to the Income Trust period, our portfolio managers believe that there is considerable merit in including select
2013RP-21 A Socio-Economic Cost Assessment Regarding Damages to Underground Infrastructures Executive Summary Nathalie de Marcellis-Warin, Ph. D. CIRANO and École Polytechnique de Montréal Ingrid Peignier,
An Introduction to the Impact of Mark to Market Accounting on MBIA and Financial Guarantors MBIA provides credit protection on municipal, essential asset and securitized financings, and the terms and conditions
Unrealized Gains in Stocks from the Viewpoint of Investment Risk Management Naoki Matsuyama Investment Administration Department, The Neiji Mutual Life Insurance Company, 1-1 Marunouchi, 2-chome, Chiyoda-ku,
Ipx!up!hfu!uif Dsfeju!zpv!Eftfswf Credit is the lifeblood of South Louisiana business, especially for the smaller firm. It helps the small business owner get started, obtain equipment, build inventory,
CHAPTER 3 The Measurement Fundamentals of Financial Accounting SYNOPSIS In this chapter, the author discusses the measurement fundamentals of financial accounting which consist of the basic assumptions,
The cost of capital A reading prepared by Pamela Peterson Drake O U T L I N E 1. Introduction... 1 2. Determining the proportions of each source of capital that will be raised... 3 3. Estimating the marginal
Banking accounts volatility induced by IAS 39: A simulation model applied to the French case Nessrine Ben Hamida, email: Nessrine.Ben-Hamida@fsa.ulaval.ca, adr : Bureau 5244, Pavillon Palasis Prince Université
Controls and accounting policies Controls and procedures Management s responsibility for financial information contained in this Annual Report is described on page 92. In addition, the Bank s Audit and
CHAPTER 8 Investments in Equity Securities SYNOPSIS In this chapter, the author discusses investments in equity securities. The discussion is divided into equity securities classified as current and long-term
How Do I Qualify for a loan? Borrowing money is one of the most common sources of funding for a small business, but obtaining a loan isn't always easy. Before you approach your banker for a loan, it is
2015s-32 What Drives Productivity Volatility of Chinese Industrial Firms? Xubei Luo, Nong Zhu Série Scientifique/Scientific Series 2015s-32 What Drives Productivity Volatility of Chinese Industrial Firms?
2001s-51 Capital Structure and Risk Management Karine Gobert Série Scientifique Scientific Series Montréal Septembre 2001 CIRANO Le CIRANO est un organisme sans but lucratif constitué en vertu de la Loi
Financial ratio analysis A reading prepared by Pamela Peterson Drake O U T L I N E 1. Introduction 2. Liquidity ratios 3. Profitability ratios and activity ratios 4. Financial leverage ratios 5. Shareholder
Article from: Reinsurance News February 2010 Issue 67 Life Settlements A Window Of Opportunity For The Life Insurance Industry? By Michael Shumrak Michael Shumrak, FSA, MAAA, FCA, is president of Shumrak
MEASUREMENTS OF FAIR VALUE IN ILLIQUID (OR LESS LIQUID) MARKETS Objective The objective of this paper is to discuss issues associated with the measurement of fair value under existing generally accepted
University of California, Merced EC 121-Money and Banking Chapter 2 Lecture otes Professor Jason Lee I. Introduction In economics, investment is defined as an increase in the capital stock. This is important
Liquidity Risk: What is it? How to Measure it? René Garcia Professor of finance EDHEC Business School, CIRANO Cirano, Montreal, January 7, 2009 The financial and economic environment We are living through
9. Short-Term Liquidity Analysis. Operating Cash Conversion Cycle 9.1 Current Assets and 9.1.1 Cash A firm should maintain as little cash as possible, because cash is a nonproductive asset. It earns no
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE CONTACTS: PRESS RELATIONS BETSY CASTENIR (212) 339-3424 INVESTOR RELATIONS ROBERT TUCKER (212) 339-0861 FSA HOLDINGS FIRST QUARTER 2004 RESULTS NET INCOME $84 Million in Q1 04 (+28%
2008s-14 Risk Retention Groups in Medical Malpractice Insurance: A Test of the Federal Chartering Option Patricia Born, M. Martin Boyer Série Scientifique Scientific Series Montréal Mai 2008 2008 Patricia
SMALL BUSINESS DEVELOPMENT CENTER RM. 032 FINANCING THROUGH COMMERCIAL BANKS Revised January, 2013 Adapted from: National Federation of Independent Business report Steps to Small Business Financing Jeffrey
Financial Statement Analysis: An Introduction 2014 Level I Financial Reporting and Analysis IFT Notes for the CFA exam Contents 1. Introduction... 3 2. Scope of Financial Statement Analysis... 3 3. Major
RISK ASSESSMENT FOR SMALL BUSINESS Terry S. Campbell, Community Development Officer Department of Development & Technology Date: March 25, 2004 1 Counseling Tool Outline - Cover Page - Outline - Introduction
Key Points to Borrowing Money Borrowing money is one of the most common sources of funding for a small business, but obtaining a loan isn't always easy. Before you approach your banker for a loan, it is
OPTIONS THEORY Introduction The Financial Manager must be knowledgeable about derivatives in order to manage the price risk inherent in financial transactions. Price risk refers to the possibility of loss
SPDR S&P 400 Mid Cap Value ETF Summary Prospectus-October 31, 2015 Before you invest in the SPDR S&P 400 Mid Cap Value ETF (the Fund ), you may want to review the Fund's prospectus and statement of additional
NOTES TO CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS to Consolidated Financial Statements Note 1: Basis of Presentation Bank of Montreal ( the bank ) is a public company incorporated in Canada having its registered
9 Questions Every ETF Investor Should Ask Before Investing 1. What is an ETF? 2. What kinds of ETFs are available? 3. How do ETFs differ from other investment products like mutual funds, closed-end funds,
Answers to Concepts in Review 1. Puts and calls are negotiable options issued in bearer form that allow the holder to sell (put) or buy (call) a stipulated amount of a specific security/financial asset,
COMMENTARY ON THE RESTRICTIONS ON PROPRIETARY TRADING BY INSURED DEPOSITARY INSTITUTIONS By Paul A. Volcker Full discussion by the public, and particularly by directly affected institutions, on the proposed
NOTES POUR L ALLOCUTION DE M. RÉJEAN ROBITAILLE, PRÉSIDENT ET CHEF DE LA DIRECTION, À LA CONFÉRENCE DES SERVICES FINANCIERS CANADIENS LE 31 MARS 2009, À 11H AU CENTRE MONT-ROYAL, À MONTRÉAL Mise en garde
International Diversification and Exchange Rates Risk Y. K. Ip School of Accounting and Finance, University College of Southern Queensland, Toowoomba, Queensland 4350, Australia Summary The benefits arisen
Discussion of Gertler and Kiyotaki: Financial intermediation and credit policy in business cycle analysis Harris Dellas Department of Economics University of Bern June 10, 2010 Figure: Ramon s reaction
11 Option Payoffs and Option Strategies Answers to Questions and Problems 1. Consider a call option with an exercise price of $80 and a cost of $5. Graph the profits and losses at expiration for various
BUS303 Study guide 2 Chapter 14 1. An efficient capital market is one in which: A. all securities that investors want are offered. B. all transactions are closed within 2 days. C. current prices reflect
Condensed Interim Consolidated Financial Statements of Canada Pension Plan Investment Board December 31, 2015 Condensed Interim Consolidated Balance Sheet As at December 31, 2015 (CAD millions) As at December
Mini Case (p.45) Assume that you recently graduated and have just reported to work as an investment advisor at the brokerage firm of Balik and Kiefer Inc. One of the firm's clients is Michelle Della Torre,
(Formerly CVTech Group Inc.) Condensed Interim Consolidated Financial Statements For the three months ended, 2014 Consolidated Statement of Financial Position (in thousands of Canadian dollars) December
Market Linked Certificates of Deposit This material was prepared by Wells Fargo Securities, LLC, a registered brokerdealer and separate non-bank affiliate of Wells Fargo & Company. This material is not
Practice Bulletin No. 2 INTERNATIONAL GLOSSARY OF BUSINESS VALUATION TERMS To enhance and sustain the quality of business valuations for the benefit of the profession and its clientele, the below identified
2009s-05 The Impact of Distance on Offshore Business Relationships Benoit A. Aubert, Suzanne Rivard, Mathieu Templier Série Scientifique Scientific Series Montréal Mars 2009 2009 Benoit A. Aubert, Suzanne
An Overview of Short Stock Selling An effective short stock selling strategy provides an important hedge to a long portfolio and allows hedge fund managers to reduce sector and portfolio beta. Short selling
Short Selling Tutorial http://www.investopedia.com/university/shortselling/ Thanks very much for downloading the printable version of this tutorial. As always, we welcome any feedback or suggestions. http://www.investopedia.com/investopedia/contact.asp
Trading Costs and Taxes! Aswath Damodaran Aswath Damodaran! 1! The Components of Trading Costs! Brokerage Cost: This is the most explicit of the costs that any investor pays but it is usually the smallest
ECON 4110: Sample Exam Name MULTIPLE CHOICE. Choose the one alternative that best completes the statement or answers the question. 1) Economists define risk as A) the difference between the return on common
Remarks by Gordon Thiessen Governor of the Bank of Canada to the Chambre de commerce du Montréal métropolitain Montreal, Quebec 4 December 2000 Why a Floating Exchange Rate Regime Makes Sense for Canada
Oil Speculation by Jussi Keppo July 8, 2008 The increase in the oil spot price seems to be mainly driven by the global demand. According to the U.S. Energy Information Administration, in 1999 the global
April 2006 Comment Letter Discussion Paper: Measurement Bases for Financial Accounting Measurement on Initial Recognition The Austrian Financial Reporting and Auditing Committee (AFRAC) is the privately
Conceptual Framework for Financial Reporting Chapter 1: The Objective of Financial Reporting INTRODUCTION OB1. The first chapter of the conceptual framework establishes the objective of general purpose
2012s-21 The topsy-turvy sharing of the gaming tax field in Canada, 1970-2010: provincial payments, federal withdrawal Étienne Desjardins, Mélina Longpré, François Vaillancourt Série Scientifique Scientific
Embedded Value 2014 Report Manulife Financial Corporation Page 1 of 13 Background: Consistent with our objective of providing useful information to investors about our Company, and as noted in our 2014
2011s-67 Loan Aversion among Canadian High School Students Cathleen Johnson, Claude Montmarquette Série Scientifique Scientific Series Montréal Novembre 2011 2011 Cathleen Johnson, Claude Montmarquette.
SSAP 24 STATEMENT OF STANDARD ACCOUNTING PRACTICE 24 ACCOUNTING FOR INVESTMENTS IN SECURITIES (Issued April 1999) The standards, which have been set in bold italic type, should be read in the context of
40 Statement on Standards for Valuation Services No. 1 APPENDIX B International Glossary of Business Valuation Terms* To enhance and sustain the quality of business valuations for the benefit of the profession
The Depository Trust Company Unaudited Condensed Consolidated Financial Statements as of March 31, 2016 and December 31, 2015 and for the three months ended March 31, 2016 and 2015 THE DEPOSITORY TRUST
Statement for the Record On Behalf of the AMERICAN BANKERS ASSOCIATION Before the Subcommittee on Capital Markets, Insurance, and Government Sponsored Enterprises Committee on Financial Services United
2010 annual report additional information Annual Report 2010 Additional Information I. Tables of returns 1. Auditors Report... 1 2. General Notes... 4 3. Short Term Investments... 6 4. Real Return Bonds...
2007s-32 The Economics of Copyright and Fair Dealing Marcel Boyer Série Scientifique Scientific Series Décembre 2007 2007 Marcel Boyer. Tous droits réservés. All rights reserved. Reproduction partielle
VIEWPOINTS: Applying IFRSs in the Mining Industry BACKGROUND A common feature of certain transactions entered into by mining entities, in particular exploration stage companies, is the issuance of units
2005s-36 VoIP Regulation in Canada Marcel Boyer, Catherine Mercier Série Scientifique Scientific Series Montréal Novembre 2005 2005 Marcel Boyer, Catherine Mercier. Tous droits réservés. All rights reserved.
2002s-66 Hypergame Analysis in E Commerce: A Preliminary Report Maxime Leclerc, Brahim Chaib-draa Série Scientifique Scientific Series Montréal Juillet 2002 2002 Maxime Leclerc, Brahim Chaib-draa. Tous
Valuation of Illiquid Securities Held by Business Development Companies A White Paper By Joan Sweeney Chief Operating Officer Allied Capital Corporation And Penni Roll Chief Financial Officer Allied Capital
2009s-23 A Note on Monitoring Daily Economic Activity Via Electronic Transaction Data John W. Galbraith, Greg Tkacz Série Scientifique Scientific Series Montréal Mai 2009 2009 John W. Galtraith, Greg Tkacz.
CENTURY ENERGY LTD. FORM 51-102F1 MANAGEMENT DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS FOR THE YEAR ENDED AUGUST 31, 2014 The following management s discussion and analysis ( MD&A ), prepared as of December 11, 2014, should
Canadian Social Science Vol.5 No.2 April 2009 Study on Exit Mechanism for Private Equity Investment ETUDES SUR LE MECANISME DE SORTIE POUR L INVESTISSEMENT PRIVE YU Suli 1 Abstract: As a new type of investment
THE FINANCIAL CRISIS: Is This a REPEAT OF THE 80 S FOR AGRICULTURE? Mike Boehlje and Chris Hurt, Department of Agricultural Economics The current financial crisis in the capital markets combined with recession
MANITOBA TRADE AND INVESTMENT CORPORATION ANNUAL REPORT 2012/13 SOCIÉTÉ DU COMMERCE ET DE L'INVESTISSEMENT DU MANITOBA RAPPORT ANNUEL 2012/13 Board of Directors Conseil d administration Hugh Eliasson Chair
How to Detect and Prevent Financial Statement Fraud GLOBAL HEADQUARTERS the gregor building 716 West Ave Austin, TX 78701-2727 USA VI. GENERAL TECHNIQUES FOR FINANCIAL STATEMENT ANALYSIS Financial Statement
What Do Short-Term Liquidity Ratios Measure? What Is Working Capital? HOCK international - 2004 1 HOCK international - 2004 2 How Is the Current Ratio Calculated? How Is the Quick Ratio Calculated? HOCK
Pacific Life Insurance Company Indexed Universal Life Insurance: Frequently Asked Questions THE GROWTH CAP, PARTICIPATION RATE, AND FLOOR RATEE 1. What accounts for the gap in indexed cap rates from one
Overview of Financial 1-1 Statement Analysis 1-2 Financial Statement Analysis Financial Statement Analysis is an integral and important part of the business analysis. Business analysis? Process of evaluating
2004s-12 Reinforcing Economic Incentives for Carbon Credits for Forests Robert D. Cairns, Pierre Lasserre Série Scientifique Scientific Series Montréal Mars 2004 2004 Robert D. Cairns, Pierre Lasserre.
Condensed Consolidated Financial Statements September 30, 2015 and 2014 (Unaudited) Condensed Consolidated Balance Sheets (Unaudited) (thousands of Canadian dollars) Note September 30, 2015 December 31,
Should Banks Trade Equity Derivatives to Manage Credit Risk? Kevin Davis 9/4/1991 Banks incur a variety of risks and utilise different techniques to manage the exposures so created. Some of those techniques