1 The Parliament of the Commonwealth of Australia Same country: different world The future of Norfolk Island Joint Standing Committee on the National Capital and External Territories October 2014 Canberra
2 Commonwealth of Australia 2014 ISBN (Printed version) ISBN (HTML version) This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial- NoDerivs 3.0 Australia License. The details of this licence are available on the Creative Commons website:
3 Contents Chair s foreword... vii Membership of the Committee... ix Terms of reference... xi Abbreviations... xiii Recommendations... xv REPORT 1 Introduction... 1 Norfolk Island - a history of reports and reviews... 1 Three years on from the Road Map little progress made... 2 Minister s visit... 3 Community views sought on reform... 3 Australian National Audit Office report... 4 Referral of inquiry and terms of reference... 5 Conduct of the inquiry... 5 Visit to Norfolk Island in April Bipartisan support for future direction and best outcome for all Norfolk Islanders... 7 Scope of inquiry... 7 Report outline Economy and governance: time to end the stalemate... 9 Economy... 9 Unemployment and underemployment - people doing it tough... 10
4 iv Decreasing population and family dispersal Decline in tourism Barriers to growth in tourism Committee comment Committee comment The deficit revenue and expenditure Insolvency Transparency, accountability and tax practices Lack of on-island expertise for the scale of the fix Committee comment Self-government just not working Community in limbo Support from the community for change Committee comment - change the status quo Governance: a new model Repeal the Norfolk Island Act 1979 (Cth) and appoint a transitional administration Options Traditional local government Local government type authority no template State-level services under New South Wales or Queensland jurisdiction Transitional issues Impact of taxation and introduction of Australian standards Mitigate worst of the impacts of taxation through the introduction of social benefits first and other supports Welfare dependency Australian government to take the lead Timing of introduction of new arrangements Committee comment Infrastructure: investment required Condition of current landing facilities: Kingston and Cascade Piers Committee comment... 47
5 v Complementary or alternative sea access Safe deep water harbour/port facilities prohibitive cost Alternative landing sites on western and southern sides of the island Cascade Pier project the most developed Cascade Pier upgrade Works stalled Multi-purpose barges Increase off-load rate Ideal cruise ship stop Economic benefits of growing visitor numbers Modern freight handling Australian accreditation and standards Are the barges the best solution for increasing tourist numbers and containerisation? Redesigning the project scope to include barges Barges instead of upgrade? Committee comment barges as part of a reform package that includes pier upgrades Air services Air New Zealand contract Additional airline Committee comment Roads Committee comment Telecommunications Committee comment Framework for new economic opportunities Benefits of being in the Australian system Taxation, social security, and access to grants Committee comment Retirement amenity, accessing retirement benefits and superannuation portability Committee comment Immigration Committee comment Investment... 77
6 vi Partnerships with Tourism Australia and state tourism organisations marketing Improving the quality and diversity of the tourist product Kingston and Arthur s Vale Historic Area Ecotourism the Great Norfolk Walk Improving the supply chain Committee comment Complementary and emerging export and niche industries Committee comment Pest and quarantine control Committee comment Domestic rather than international destination Committee comment Economic modelling of the impact of reforms Concluding comments APPENDI CES Appendix A - Submissions and other documentary evidence Appendix B - Public hearings and witnesses Appendix C - Committee s visit program Appendix D - Norfolk Island Government s preferred model for territory selfgovernance
7 Chair s foreword The Committee s terms of reference were to focus on the prospects for economic development in the wake of a marked decline in tourist visitors, a serious budget deficit, and ongoing financial management concerns. There is an ever increasing reliance on the Commonwealth Government for financial and other assistance, just to keep basic services going for Norfolk Islanders. A consistent theme throughout the inquiry, from witnesses and experts, was that economic development is simply not possible without the establishment of new governance arrangements. The Norfolk Island Act 1979 (Cth) established self-government. Over the years, a number of reviews and reports have assessed the effectiveness of self-government and questioned whether it has best served the interests of Norfolk Island residents. Some 35 years on, it is clear that this model has failed and on many levels. The Joint Standing Committee on the National Capital and External Territories has a long standing history and interest in the welfare of Norfolk Island and Norfolk Islanders, as Australian residents. Norfolk Islanders should have the same rights and responsibilities as all Australian residents. The priority therefore must be what is in the best interests of the people, and not a defence at all costs of governance arrangements that have not been able to provide a social or economic existence that equates to the rest of the nation. Bringing Norfolk Island into the Australian system will require legislative reform, a period of transition and resolve. Seizing the new opportunities and concomitant prospects for growth and prosperity will be dependent on the will of the Commonwealth Government to proceed with bold reforms. It will also depend on
8 viii the fortitude and willingness of the Norfolk Island community to work with the Commonwealth to ensure their future sustainability. Vested interests must now be put aside for action that is in the best interests of every man, woman and child resident on Norfolk Island. Mr Luke Simpkins MP Chair
9 Membership of the Committee Chair Deputy Chair Mr Luke Simpkins MP Senator Carol Brown Members Senator Chris Back Ms Gai Brodtmann MP Mrs Natasha Griggs MP Senator Sarah Hanson-Young Senator the Hon Kate Lundy Senator Stephen Parry (to 7/7/14) The Hon Bruce Scott MP The Hon Warren Snowdon MP Senator Zed Seselja Mr Ross Vasta MP Senator Gavin Marshall (from 7/7/14)
10 x Committee secretariat Secretary Inquiry Secretary Dr Alison Clegg Ms Sara Edson Administrative Officers Mrs Fiona McCann Ms Kathy Blunden
11 Terms of reference The Norfolk Island Roadmap has as one of its aspirational goals under Economic Development: Positive action to encourage diversification and broaden the Island s economic base. The Committee will inquire into and report on: redressing barriers to tourism, with particular regard to air services, facilities for cruise ships, roads and other infrastructure; complements to tourism, such as agriculture, other industry or smallmedium enterprises; and proposals and opportunities for niche industries.
13 Abbreviations ANAO ASCOT ATDW CITA Cth DIRD GBE IOTs JSCNCET KAVHA MLA NIA NICESC NIG NSW OH & S RTOs Australian National Audit Office Australian Standing Committee on Tourism Australian Tourism Data Warehouse Christmas Island Tourism Association Commonwealth Department of Infrastructure and Regional Development Government Business Enterprise Indian Ocean Territories Joint Standing Committee on the National Capital and External Territories Kingston and Arthur s Vale Historic Area Member of the Norfolk Island Legislative Assembly Norfolk Island Administration Norfolk Island Convention, Entertainment and Sports Centre Norfolk Island Government New South Wales Occupational health and safety Regional Tourism Organisations
14 xiv STOs TA TAG TMM TTF WA State Tourism Organisations Tourism Australia Tourism Action Group Tourism Ministers Meeting Tourism Transport Forum Western Australia
15 Recommendations 3 Governance: a new model Recommendation 1 The Committee recommends that, as soon as practicable, the Commonwealth Government repeal the Norfolk Island Act 1979 (Cth) and establish an interim administration, to assist the transition to a local government type body, determined in line with the community s needs and aspirations. This will require the development of a new legislative framework. Recommendation 2 The Committee recommends that formal mechanisms for community consultation be established which allow for regular and ongoing communication between any transitional administration and the community about the reform process and new governance arrangements. 4 Infrastructure: investment required Recommendation 3 The Committee recommends that the Commonwealth Government assume responsibility for the Cascade and Kingston Pier upgrades and that the Commonwealth Government expedite the works in line with Australian standards and occupational health and safety requirements, as soon as practicable.
16 xvi Recommendation 4 The Committee recommends that the Commonwealth Government purchase multi-purpose barges for use on Norfolk Island in conjunction with upgrades made to Cascade and Kingston Piers. Barge use must be integrated into the design and functionality of the upgrades. Recommendation 5 The Committee recommends that the Commonwealth Government ensure that, as part of the new governance arrangements, the public road infrastructure on Norfolk Island is assessed against current Australiawide design, building and engineering standards and, where needed, work is undertaken to remedy deficiencies. 5 Framework for new economic opportunities Recommendation 6 The Committee recommends that the Commonwealth Government appoint officers in the transitional administration to strengthen Norfolk Island s economic and human resource capacity. Officers from Commonwealth agencies like Tourism Australia and Austrade should be tasked to provide advice and support to define the tourist market, develop the tourist product and promote and market tourist and other products and services, including new ones. Recommendation 7 The Committee recommends that the Commonwealth Government provide a dedicated officer to assist Norfolk Island cottage industry owners and operators to brand their products, set up a cooperative shopfront, and look at ways to market and export their products. Recommendation 8 The Committee recommends that the Commonwealth Government take charge of the psyllid eradication effort on Norfolk Island, and that responsibility for quarantine control matters be transferred to the Commonwealth Department of Agriculture, Fisheries and Forestry.
17 1 Introduction Norfolk Island - a history of reports and reviews 1.1 The need to reform Norfolk Island, a self-governing external territory of Australia since 1979, 1 has long been a subject of discussion. Over the decades, there have been numerous reports and reviews on governance arrangements and economic development on Norfolk Island, completed by this Committee, and others, including the Commonwealth Department of Infrastructure and Regional Development (which has portfolio responsibility for Australia s external territories, hereafter referred to as DIRD) and experts In March 2014, the Assistant Minister for Infrastructure and Regional Development, the Hon Jamie Briggs MP (hereafter referred to as the Minister) referred to the abundance of reports and reviews produced todate: Over the last four decades there has been a plethora of reviews and reports looking at these arrangements, including a royal commission conducted in 1976, 12 separate parliamentary inquiries and the commissioning of more than 20 reports from experts in various fields including outgoing reports from former 1 Norfolk Island was established as a self-governing territory by the Norfolk Island Act (Cth). See the Department s website for details, including the island s history and administrative arrangements: 2 See for example: Joint Standing Committee on National Capital and External Territories reports such as Report of the visit to Norfolk Island April 2013 (June 2013) and Inquiry into Norfolk Island Governance Part 2: Sustainability of Government (December 2005); the consulting firm ACIL Tasman s Norfolk Island Economic Development Report (March 2012); and the Deloitte work (still in draft form) Norfolk Island Government Business Analysis (2014).
18 2 SAME COUNTRY: DIFFERENT WORLD - THE FUTURE OF NORFOLK ISLAND administrators. All of these reviews, reports and audits have been unanimous in recommending significant changes and reforms. 3 Three years on from the Road Map little progress made 1.3 This inquiry into economic development on Norfolk Island comes three years after the Norfolk Island Road Map was introduced in March The Road Map was a partnership agreed to by both the Commonwealth and Norfolk Island Governments (the latter hereafter referred to as NIG). Its reform objectives included: Governance through providing a stronger, more open and transparent form of government, building on the reforms in the Territories Law Reform Act 2010; and Economic development through quick action to address barriers to tourism, particularly reform of air services, access to the Island, and facilities for cruise ships; Enabling the Norfolk Island Public Service to provide good financial and policy advice and effective services to the Norfolk Island Government and community; Social services including immigration removing barriers to business investment...; Access to the benefits provided by the Australian tax system and a fair contribution to the tax system in return for the benefits; and Extend[ing] Commonwealth laws to the Island to promote improved economic growth and diversification In March 2014, the Minister said that while the Australian Government had been working with the NIG to introduce public sector and immigration reforms, as well as land valuations ahead of the introduction of municipal rates on island, progress has been disappointingly slow. He acknowledged the steps that previous Australian Governments had taken to help the Norfolk Island community, including the provision of emergency financial assistance on an annual basis and ensuring certainty for the tourism industry by agreeing to underwrite the airline services to the island. 5 Yet, despite all these measures, he observed: 3 The Hon Jamie Briggs MP, House of Representatives Official Hansard, Canberra, 27 March 2014, p The Norfolk Island Road Map (2 March 20111), p The Hon Jamie Briggs MP, Assistant Minister for Infrastructure and Regional Development, House of Representatives Official Hansard, Canberra, 27 March 2014, p. 25.
19 INTRODUCTION 3 the Norfolk Island Government seems to lack the capability to address many of the key sustainability issues facing the island. 6 Minister s visit 1.5 The Minister visited Norfolk Island in February During the visit he made a speech where he restated the Commonwealth Government s intention to integrate the Norfolk Island community into the broader taxation and welfare system of Australia. He spoke about the challenges facing the island and emphasised the positive opportunities ahead: Lots of chances for a better future, a stronger economy, more jobs, higher wages, better outcomes. I think if we work together on some of the unique challenges you have, we can achieve that. It seems to me quite absurd that we have got a different system in one part of Australia than we do in the rest of it, and I think we have to address that quickly. We are going to work away at addressing that, and in doing so now is also the time, to have a good look at how else we can make Norfolk work better for the community and work better for the country. 7 Community views sought on reform 1.6 On his return to Australia the Minister wrote to Norfolk Island residents noting that almost everyone he met during that visit believed that things need to change. The Minister sought the community s views on the best ways to deliver real changes that will make a difference, including the identification and promotion of economic opportunities, best delivery of essential services and best governance model for the future. The Minister said the input would inform government policy going forward. 8 Australian National Audit Office report 1.7 In March 2014, the Minister tabled an Australian National Audit Office (ANAO) report on Norfolk Island s financial statements. The independent report outlines the pervasive extent of Norfolk Island s growing debt and 6 The Hon Jamie Briggs MP, Assistant Minister for Infrastructure and Regional Development, House of Representatives Official Hansard, Canberra, 27 March 2014, p The Hon Jamie Briggs MP, Assistant Minister for Infrastructure and Regional Development, Speech-Official Reception, Norfolk Island, media release, 14 February Copy of Minister s letter to residents provided to Committee as private correspondence.
20 4 SAME COUNTRY: DIFFERENT WORLD - THE FUTURE OF NORFOLK ISLAND associated problems. The Delegate of the Auditor-General paints a picture of the Norfolk Island Administration failing to keep economically afloat:... the Administration is currently experiencing financial difficulty, associated with a continuing economic downturn and a decline in tourism, and continues to incur losses. The Administration has prepared cash flow forecasts that estimate that the Administration will not hold sufficient cash and cash equivalents as at 30 June 2014 to cover net cash outflows from operations in the , and financial years of approximately $7.4 million, $7.4 million and $7.8 million respectively. In addition these forecasts do not make any provision for any repayments of the outstanding balance of $11.4 million of a loan from the Commonwealth the forecast significant negative net cash flows and the end of the Commonwealth s current funding commitment to June 2014 give rise to a material uncertainty that may cast significant doubt upon the Administration s ability to continue as a going concern. in the event that the Administration does not obtain additional funding from the Commonwealth and/or reduce expenditure in line with available revenue, the Administration may not be able to continue its operations as a going concern However, I have not been provided with sufficient appropriate audit evidence by the Administration of how the Administration and the Consolidated Group s 9 funding requirements will be met to enable the Administration and Consolidated Group to operate in and later years. Consequently, I am unable to remove significant doubt of the Norfolk Island Administration s and Consolidated Group s ability to continue as going concerns The Minister spoke about the lack of proper financial controls and poor financial management practices within the Norfolk Island Administration. He emphasised the gravity of the financial situation and the worsening state of the island s infrastructure: 9 The Consolidated statements include the Norfolk Island Administration (including the Kingston Arthur Vale Historic Area, workers compensation and healthcare) as well as the Norfolk Island Government Tourist Bureau and Hospital. Source: Department of Infrastructure and Regional Development, private communication, 13 August Covering letter in Australian Government Department of Infrastructure and Regional Development, The Australian National Audit Office Independent Report of Norfolk Island s Financial Statements 2012/3, (10 December 2013).
21 INTRODUCTION 5 These issues identified by the ANAO are longstanding but these problems are becoming more critical as deficits increase and essential infrastructure on the island further deteriorates. There has been no significant infrastructure investment since the 1970s The roads are deteriorating. Broadband services are poor. And the island s electricity network is extremely fragile and at risk of collapse. 11 Referral of inquiry and terms of reference 1.9 Soon after his visit, the Minister referred the inquiry into economic development on Norfolk Island on 25 March 2014, asking the Committee to focus on positive action to encourage diversification and broaden the island s economic base The Committee was asked to inquire into and report on: redressing barriers to tourism, with particular regard to air services, facilities for cruise ships, roads and other infrastructure; complements to tourism, such as agriculture, other industry or smallmedium enterprises; and proposals and opportunities for niche tourism. Conduct of the inquiry 1.11 The inquiry received 34 written submissions from a range of stakeholders including the Commonwealth and NIG, business owners, community groups, former public servants and Norfolk Island residents. The submissions are listed at Appendix A The inquiry was advertised in The Australian on 9 April 2014, 14 May 2014 and 11 June 2014 and The Norfolk Islander on 29 March The Committee held five public hearings: four in Canberra and one on Norfolk Island. As part of the proceedings on Norfolk Island, the Committee held two hour-long sessions of community statements during which individuals and organisations were given the opportunity to address any of the terms of reference in a dedicated time slot. The fiveminute community statements were an effective way for the Committee to hear from a large number of residents in the time available to it. Members 11 The Hon. Jamie Briggs MP, Assistant Minister for Infrastructure and Regional Development, House of Representatives Official Hansard, Canberra, 27 March 2014, p. 25.
22 6 SAME COUNTRY: DIFFERENT WORLD - THE FUTURE OF NORFOLK ISLAND listened to different views within the community, key priorities and recurrent themes Details of the hearings and witnesses are listed at Appendix B. The transcripts of the hearings are available from the Committee s website. 12 Visit to Norfolk Island in April The Committee visited Norfolk Island from April Apart from the public hearing and community statement sessions on 29 April 2014, the Committee undertook a diverse range of inspections, visiting staff at tourist sites, and meeting business owners including farmers, tourist and retail operators, accommodation providers and boutique producers. The visit program is included at Appendix C The Committee acknowledges the valuable contribution of all those it met with and the effort put into facilitating an excellent visit program, including by the former Norfolk Island Administrator, The Hon Neil Pope, and staff The Committee was impressed with the passion and enthusiasm that local resident, Ms Rachel Nebauer, together with Ms Ginny Maidment, put into organising a comprehensive site visit program that focused on the island s small commodity-based industries which complement tourism and/or have export potential. This was a highlight of the visit and instrumental to members gaining insights into the limitations faced by and possibilities for small business owners on the Island. Bipartisan support for future direction and best outcome for all Norfolk Islanders 1.18 During his visit to Norfolk Island, the Minister indicated that there is a bipartisan commitment to: making sure [that] Norfolk [Island] is as good as can be This sentiment was endorsed a month later by the Shadow Parliamentary Secretary for External Territories, The Hon Warren Snowdon MP, when the Minister tabled the ANAO report in the House of Representatives. Mr Snowdon said: 12 The Joint Standing Committee on the National Capital and External Territories website, Public hearings, External_Territories/Norfolk_Island/Public_Hearings 13 The Hon Jamie Briggs MP, Assistant Minister for Infrastructure and Regional Development, Speech-Official Reception, Norfolk Island, media release, 14 February 2014.
23 INTRODUCTION 7 I commend the Assistant Minister for Infrastructure and Regional Development for his statement on the governance and finances of Norfolk Island and say that we agree with the direction in which the government is heading. We support the development of a discussion paper but I think those of us on this side of the chamber, with experience of Norfolk Island, which we have had over many years, would say to you: let s expedite the process I am sure the Member for Canberra and I can attest to the strong feeling of support for change It is very important that we actually address the needs of the community on Norfolk Island. Your observations and the examples that you provided about those people that are missing out is a salutary reminder of what we need to do in this place as parliamentarians to make sure all Australians are treated fairly and equally. 14 Scope of inquiry 1.20 The Committee sees little point in this report simply repeating the findings of the numerous previous reports undertaken on economic development and governance Whilst the Committee s original intention was to focus on economic development and leave governance matters aside not least because they were not spelled out in the terms of reference it soon became apparent that sound governance underpins any discussion of economic development This is especially the case given the increasingly dire fiscal situation that the Norfolk Island Administration finds itself in The Minister asked the Committee to focus on positive action to encourage diversification and broaden the island s economic base. Certainty and confidence is contingent on the introduction of a form of mainstream government. This is a prerequisite for investor confidence and growth. 14 The Hon Warren Snowdon MP, House of Representatives Official Hansard, Canberra, 27 March 2014, p. 28.
24 8 SAME COUNTRY: DIFFERENT WORLD - THE FUTURE OF NORFOLK ISLAND Report outline 1.24 The report consists of five chapters Chapter two provides an overview of the economy and governance on Norfolk Island. The purpose of this chapter is not to explore all the failings in full, because few are new ones, but rather to paint a clear and frank picture of the reality today and why change is required Chapter three addresses governance reform and what form that might take. Without it, economic development will not be possible Chapter four focuses on infrastructure because it is so vital to the economy and a recurrent theme of the inquiry. The focus is on the stalled Cascade Pier upgrade which is expected to deliver two key economic benefits: a greater successful offload rate of cruise ship passengers; and containerised freight Chapter five looks ahead to what Norfolk Island s economic prospects might look like once the reforms in chapter two get underway, and Norfolk Island is brought into the Australian system. Reform of the nature described in chapter three should deliver better essential services and provide a framework for new economic opportunities.
25 2 Economy and governance: time to end the stalemate 2.1 The tourist sector has traditionally been the main economic driver on Norfolk Island. A marked decline in tourist revenue has contributed significantly to the current financial crisis. However, it is but one of many fiscal and other challenges facing the Norfolk Island Government (NIG) and Norfolk Island Administration (NIA). 1 Most residents want to see the downward trajectory reversed. Economy 2.2 The previous Committee visited Norfolk Island in April 2013 and reported that the economic situation there has continued to deteriorate. Specifically: Economic activity was down 24% on the previous year; Approximately 40% of shops had closed; Approximately 25% of the male population aged had left the island since August 2011; Overall population had dropped by 9.4% since August 2011; and Tourism trends were variable One year on, the current Committee visited again, and it is clear that economic conditions have not improved. 1 The Norfolk Island Government refers to the Norfolk Island ministry. The Norfolk Island Administration refers to the Norfolk Island public service. The two appear to be used interchangeably, and sometimes confused with, the Norfolk Island Legislative Assembly. This reflects a blurred delineation of powers and responsibilities that is a feature of the territory s self-governing model. 2 The Joint Standing Committee on National Capital and External Territories, Report of the visit to Norfolk Island April 2013, June 2013, p. 9.
26 10 SAME COUNTRY: DIFFERENT WORLD THE FUTURE OF NORFOLK ISLAND 2.4 Mr Bruce Walker, Norfolk Island resident and businessman, painted a grim picture: Economic activity has dropped off, businesses have closed, real estate sales stalled, and consequently a good number of residents have had to move to other jurisdictions to gain employment that will sustain their families and mortgages. The domino effect on island is very evident without drilling too deep. A good deal of remaining private sector businesses are only marginally viable and on the brink of closing down. You might describe the community outside the public sector as depressed Ms Elva Leaming, a visitor, observed a noticeable decline during a trip she made this year, comparing it with an earlier one in 2011: Many properties and good land for sale. Many empty shops and the brewery closed. Decline in the number of shops selling quality goods. Decline in the bulk of goods in quality ware shops e.g. lack of range in shoe sizes. 4 Unemployment and underemployment - people doing it tough 2.6 It is common practice for Norfolk Islanders to hold down several different jobs in order to make ends meet. Norfolk Island resident, Mr Peter Wilson described a modest lifestyle and increasing cost of living pressures: Norfolk Island is about sidelines most Norfolk Islanders have at least three jobs. I myself have five Many families here still live quite a self-sufficient lifestyle. They grow their own vegies, meat and eggs, and of course catch their own fish. These other incomes then provide us with a sustainable lifestyle. However it is becoming increasingly difficult to survive on our island home as the cost of living rapidly rises, and these sidelines are not producing enough for a reasonable standard of living Mr Neil Pope, Administrator of Norfolk Island from 1 April 2012 to 30 June 2014, pointed to the high cost of living too. He said that residents pay 43 per cent more for their food and groceries. There is also a growing number of people doing it tough : that is witnessed in a number of different ways, not just issues of food parcels but departures from the island the emigration. 6 3 Mr Bruce Walker, Submission 29, p Ms Elva Leaming, Submission 7, p Mr Peter Wilson, Committee Hansard, Norfolk Island, 29 April 2014, p Mr Neil Pope, Committee Hansard, Canberra, 18 July 2014, p. 6.
INTRODUCTION 1 1 Introduction Referral and terms of reference 1.1 On 4 March 2015, then Minister for Infrastructure and Regional Development, the Hon. Jamie Briggs MP, referred an inquiry into governance
The Senate Community Affairs Legislation Committee Private Health Insurance Amendment Bill (No. 2) 2014 [Provisions] May 2015 Commonwealth of Australia 2015 ISBN 978-1-76010-200-5 Secretariat Ms Jeanette
2 Reopening the Christmas Island Casino The former casino s operations and closure in the nineties 2.1 Mr Michael Asims, Owner s Representative, Soft Star Pty Ltd (Soft Star), described the former Christmas
CRUISING TO PROSPERITY SUBMISSION TO THE Australia REVIEW JUNE 2014 OF THE COASTAL TRADING ACT Submission to the review of coastal shipping regulation in Membership of the Tourism & Transport Forum The
THE HON JOSH FRYDENBERG MP Assistant Treasurer SPEECH FINANCIAL SERVICES COUNCIL BT FINANCIAL GROUP BREAKFAST SYDNEY 15 APRIL 2015 **CHECK AGAINST DELIVERY** Introductory remarks Good morning. Thank you
AUSTRALIAN GOVERNMENT RESPONSE TO THE REPORT ON CURRENT AND FUTURE GOVERNANCE ARRANGEMENTS IN THE INDIAN OCEAN TERRITORIES BY THE JOINT STANDING COMMITTEE ON THE NATIONAL CAPITAL AND EXTERNAL TERRITORIES
ISSUE 6: NOVEMBER 2015 2012015 2015 Message from Administrator There has been much achieved over the past five months and I ll be pleased to welcome Paul Fletcher MP, Minister for Territories, Local Government
Review of PIRSA s Cost Recovery Policy and practices, including their application to the Fisheries and Aquaculture Industries Primary Industries and Regions SA 29 July 2015 Contents Executive Summary...
Chapter 2 Key issues and committee view 2.1 The submissions received by the inquiry overwhelmingly supported the establishment of the ASBFE Ombudsman position, and its proposed role of supporting small
Long Term Financial Planning Framework and Guidelines Long Term Financial Planning Framework and Guidelines for Western Australian Local Governments p1. Contents Foreword 4 1. Introduction 7 2. Purpose
SUBMISSION TO INQUIRY INTO AFFORDABLE HOUSING Prepared by National Policy Office March 2014 COTA Australia Authorised by: Ian Yates AM Chief Executive email@example.com 0418 835 439 Prepared by: Jo Root
FINAL REPORT 2014 Residential Electricity Price Trends To COAG Energy Council 5 December 2014 Reference: EPR0040 2014 Residential Price Trends Inquiries Australian Energy Market Commission PO Box A2449
Introduction Chapter 5 Private health insurance 5.1 The private health insurance industry in Australia comprises 34 private health insurers. At the end of 2012 13, 47 per cent of the Australian population
3 Audit Report No. 14, 1999-2000 &RPPRQZHDOWK'HEW0DQDJHPHQW Introduction 3.1 Since Federation, the Commonwealth has issued a wide range of debt instruments to finance its expenditure programs. To ensure
Corporate Plan 2015 2016 Corporate Plan 2015 2016 i DEPARTMENT OF INFRASTRUCTURE AND REGIONAL DEVELOPMENT Commonwealth of Australia 2015 ISBN 978-1-925216-54-7 June 2015 / INFRA2410 Ownership of intellectual
ASPG Conference, Perth Jonathan O'Dea - October 2013 "Financial Overseers and their Oversight A NSW Public Accounts Committee Perspective" OVERVIEW Statutory Officers play central roles as financial overseers
Master Builders Australia Foreign Investment in Australian Real Estate: Response to the Australian Government s Options Paper Master Builders Australia Limited 2015. Master Builders Australia Limited ABN
Standing Committee on Procedure Inquiry into The adequacy of procedures for examining the estimates of expenditure. Terms of Reference: To inquire into the adequacy of procedures for the House s examination
2013 Regional Aviation Association of Australia Conference Keynote Address By The Hon. Warren Truss MP, Minister for Infrastructure and Regional Development Speech WTS002/2013 10 October 2013 Source: http://www.minister.infrastructure.gov.au/wt/speeches/2013/wts002_2013.aspx
NATIONAL PARTNERSHIP AGREEMENT ON ENERGY EFFICIENCY Council of Australian Governments An agreement between the Commonwealth of Australia and the States and Territories, being: The State of New South Wales
19 September 2014 Senate Select Committee on Health PO Box 6100 Parliament House Canberra ACT 2600 firstname.lastname@example.org Thank you for the opportunity to provide a submission to the Senate Select Committee
National Disability Insurance Scheme. May 2012 Chamber of Commerce and Industry of Western Australia (Inc) Contents Executive summary 3 Background 4 Western Australia current disability services 6 Funding
Commonwealth of Australia 2014 This work is copyright. In addition to any use permitted under the Copyright Act 1968, all material contained within this work is provided under a Creative Commons Attribution
Financial literacy Australians understanding money Financial literacy Australians understanding money Commonwealth of Australia 2007 ISBN: 0 642 74410 6 This work is copyright. Apart from any use as permitted
A Guide to Aged Care and Retirement Villages in Australia FOR INVESTORS AND PROSPECTIVE OPERATORS PREPARED BY ARTHUR KOUMOUKELIS, PARTNER, GADENS 2014 Gadens providing straightforward, clear advice you
Project Agreements Information for employers requesting a project labour agreement May 2015 Table of Contents What is a project agreement?... 4 What is a labour agreement... 5 Duration of a labour agreement...
About the Author is the owner of Argos Consulting, a private business which provides advice, recommendations and support for organisations and individuals requiring assistance in working with government
APRIL 2014 ELECTRICITY PRICES AND NETWORK COSTS 1 WHAT MAKES UP THE RETAIL ELECTRICITY BILL? Retail electricity bills are made up of a number of components: Wholesale costs reflecting electricity generation
Future COAG Regulatory Reform Agenda Submission of the Accommodation Association of Australia CONTENTS Executive Summary...3 Introduction...4 About the Accommodation Association...4 The Accommodation Sector
EXAMINING PUBLIC SPENDING Estimates Review: A Guide for Parliamentarians Some information for this booklet was taken from the Treasury Board of Canada Secretariat s website. A description of the Expenditure
New Arrangements for Training Product Development for Australian Industry ED15-0079 1 Key messages The Government aims to enhance Australia s economic prosperity by ensuring the future and emerging skills
1. Executive Summary For many Australians, their main form of savings over their lifetime is their home. Directing savings towards a home provides two benefits:- Ø A place to live, with security of tenure.
Business Planning for Major Capital Works Business Planning for Major Capital Works September 2011 Victorian Auditor-General s Report Telephone 61 3 8601 7000 Facsimile 61 3 8601 7010 www.audit.vic.gov.au
Optus Submission to Productivity Commission Inquiry into National Frameworks for Workers Compensation and Occupational Health and Safety June 2003 Overview Optus welcomes the opportunity to provide this
WATER AND SEWERAGE FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT PLANNING ABSTRACT Chris Adam, Cardno MBK (Qld) Pty Ltd In recent years, the utilities industries have been subject to far greater commercial scrutiny than ever before.
Grant Programme Guidelines Community Development Grants Programme Community Development Grants Programme Guidelines Contents Process Flowchart... 3 1. Introduction... 4 1.1. Programme Background... 4 1.2.
Version 4.0 Preparation Date: 2 November 2009 This document provides some additional information to help you understand the financial planning concepts discussed in the SOA in relation to business insurance.
Address by the Hon Chris Pearce MP Shadow Minister for Financial Services, Superannuation and Corporate Law Lifewise Campaign Launch Shangri-La Hotel, Sydney 1 May 2009 Good afternoon ladies and gentlemen.
Steps to success To be successful in today s highly competitive tourism industry, you must attend to each of the following areas. Getting assistance In establishing and developing your tourism business,
Inland Revenue Department: Managing tax debt This is an independent assurance report about a performance audit carried out under section 16 of the Public Audit Act 2001. June 2009 ISBN 978-0-478-32627-7
The National Health Plan for Young Australians An action plan to protect and promote the health of children and young people Copyright 1997 ISBN 0 642 27200 X This work is copyright. It may be reproduced
Western Australian Auditor General s Report Regulation of Training Organisations Report 11: June 2015 Office of the Auditor General Western Australia 7 th Floor Albert Facey House 469 Wellington Street,
ITEM 2. FILE NO: DRAFT ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT STRATEGY, RETAIL AND TOURISM ACTION PLANS PUBLIC EXHIBITION S038970 SUMMARY Sydney is Australia s largest and only global city. It is the leading knowledge-based
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY The Government published the Healthcare Reform Consultation Document Your Health, Your Life (the Consultation Document ) on 13 March 2008 to initiate the public consultation on healthcare
Implementation Plan: Development of an asset and financial planning management framework for TAMS Australian Capital Territory NATIONAL PARTNERSHIP AGREEMENT TO SUPPORT LOCAL GOVERNMENT AND REGIONAL DEVELOPMENT
Department of the Parliamentary Library I NFORMATION AND R ESEARCH S ERVICES Bills Digest No. 56 2001 02 Health and Other Services (Compensation) Legislation Amendment Bill 2001 ISSN 1328-8091 Copyright
Submission to the Senate Standing Committee on Community Affairs - References Committee Inquiry into the out-of-pocket costs in Australian healthcare May 2014 Out-of-pocket costs in Australian healthcare
Australia & New Zealand Return to Work Monitor 2011/12 Prepared for Heads of Workers Compensation Authorities July 2012 SUITE 3, 101-103 QUEENS PDE PO BOX 441, CLIFTON HILL, VICTORIA 3068 PHONE +613 9482
Department of Education, Training and Employment 130107 Photography: Tony Phillips Great skills. Real opportunities. The Queensland Government reform action plan for further education and training Foreword
Opportunities for Growth in the UK Events Industry Roles & responsibilities A report to the All Party Parliamentary Group For Events Presented jointly by the October 2011 1 Contents 1.0 The UK events industry
Public Sector Program (RRP RMI 43321-1) A. Summary ECONOMIC ANALYSIS (Republic of the Marshall Islands: Public Sector Program) 1. The Republic of the Marshall Islands (RMI) gross domestic product (GDP)
Vote Revenue APPROPRIATION MINISTER(S): Minister of Revenue (M57) APPROPRIATION ADMINISTRATOR: Inland Revenue Department RESPONSIBLE MINISTER FOR INLAND REVENUE DEPARTMENT: Minister of Revenue THE ESTIMATES
The Parliament of the Commonwealth of Australia Rebuilding Australia s Coastal Shipping Industry Inquiry into coastal shipping policy and regulation House of Representatives Standing Committee on Infrastructure,
Regulatory Audit Results by Transport Sector As part of the Government s Red Tape Reduction Programme the Infrastructure and Regional Development portfolio (the portfolio) has undertaken an Audit of its
Council of Australian Governments Business Advisory Forum Canberra, 6 December 2012 Communiqué The second meeting of the Business Advisory Forum to the Council of Australian Governments (COAG), convened
Working holiday maker visa review Submission of Accommodation Association of Australia Accommodation Association of Australia Principal Contact Mr Richard Munro Chief Executive Officer Phone: +61 2 8666
TASMANIAN STATE GOVERNMENT and LOCAL GOVERNMENT ASSOCIATION OF TASMANIA Framework for Long Term Financial and Asset Management Planning for all Tasmanian Councils FINAL REPORT September 2009 Document Control
PART 1 OVERVIEWS Clerk s review Departmental overview Financial performance The Clerk (foreground) and Deputy Clerk on duty at the Table in the House of Representatives Chamber. Photo: David Foote AUSPIC/DPS.
Australian Work Health and Safety Strategy 2012 2022 Healthy, safe and productive working lives Creative Commons ISBN 978-0-642-78566-4 [PDF online] ISBN 978-0-642-78565-7 [Print] With the exception of
STEVEN MARSHALL, STATE LIBERAL LEADER MARTIN HAMILTON-SMITH, SHADOW MINISTER FOR ECONOMIC AND REGIONAL DEVELOPMENT The State Liberals want South Australia to grow and prosper. We need more people active
Chapter 1 Introduction Referral 1.1 On 12 November 2015, the Senate referred the provisions of the Health Insurance Amendment (Safety Net) Bill 2015 (Bill) to the Senate Community Affairs Legislation Committee
Transcript of Participants Jim Byers Investor Relations, MKR David Dunlap Chief Financial Officer Analysts Brian Swift Security Research Associates Al Troy Private Investor Presentation Greetings and welcome
WSAA SUBMISSION Industry Engagement in Training Package Development-Discussion Paper 'Towards a Contestable Model' DECEMBER 2014 23 December 2014 Australian Government Department of Industry Level 2, Nishi
The Auditor-General Audit Report No.27 2001 2002 Assurance and Control Assessment Audit Agency Management of Software Licensing Australian National Audit Office Commonwealth of Australia 2001 ISSN 1036-7632
REVIEW OF AUDITOR-GENERAL S REPORT NO. 10 OF 2015: 2014 15 FINANCIAL AUDITS S TANDING C OMMITTEE ON P UBLIC A CCOUNTS APRIL 2016 REPORT 26 REVIEW OF AUDITOR- GENERAL S REPORT NO. 10 OF 2015: 2014 15 FINANCIAL
Attracting Business Events to Australia A GUIDE FOR THE AUSTRALIAN BUSINESS EVENTS INDUSTRY 2 Cover Image: Melbourne, Victoria This page: Brisbane, Queensland Message from the Minister for Trade and Investment
Version 4.2 This document provides some additional information to help you understand the financial planning concepts discussed in the SOA in relation to. Important information This document has been published
Australian National Audit Office IT Audit Capability and Resourcing Report by the Independent Auditor June 2012 Commonwealth of Australia 2012 ISSN 1036 7632 ISBN 0 642 81248 9 COPYRIGHT INFORMATION This
Integrated Planning & Reporting Framework Frequently Asked Questions and their answers August 2009 Question Why are the planning and reporting requirements for local councils being changed? Page 3 What
Evolving Oversight The Australian Joint Committee of Public Accounts and Audit By Shane Armstrong, Department of the House of Representatives The Australian Joint Committee of Public Accounts and Audit,
The Parliament of the Commonwealth of Australia Report 452 Natural Disaster Recovery; Centrelink Telephone Services; and Safer Streets Program Review of Auditor-General Reports Nos 24-50 (2014-15) Joint
WORK HEALTH AND SAFETY CONSULTATION, CO-OPERATION AND CO-ORDINATION Code of Practice DECEMBER 2011 Safe Work Australia is an Australian Government statutory agency established in 2009. Safe Work Australia
Chapter 4 Evidence in support of the current legislative and regulatory framework 4.1 This chapter considers the evidence to the committee in support of the current legislative and regulatory framework.
PUBLIC ACCOUNTS AND ESTIMATES COMMITTEE FIFTY EIGHTH REPORT TO THE PARLIAMENT Report on the Review of the Auditor-General s special report no. 51 - Victorian Rural Ambulance Services: fulfilling a vital
Households ('s) Proportion of the population A consortium of peak community sector organisations has been formed to research housing and homelessness issues in the ACT. The consortium is comprised of ACT
Health expenditure Australia 2011 12: analysis by sector HEALTH AND WELFARE EXPENDITURE SERIES No. 51 HEALTH AND WELFARE EXPENDITURE SERIES Number 51 Health expenditure Australia 2011 12: analysis by sector
Department of Economic Development Strategic Plan 2010 2013 We envision an economy driven by a healthy private sector and expanding at a pace that maximizes opportunities for Yukon businesses and workers.
Supporting Australia s Live Music Industry: Suggested principles for best practice 2010 2010 Commonwealth of Australia, in conjunction with the governments of the Australian Capital Territory, New South
ACSA response to Exposure Draft Legislation Tax and Superannuation Laws Amendment (2015 Measures No. #) Bill 2015: Limiting fringe benefit tax concessions on salary packaged entertainment benefits 21 August
Tourism Investment Opportunities of Significance in National Parks Guidelines Published by the Victorian Government Department of Sustainability and Environment Melbourne April 2013. The State of Victoria
Your consent to our cookies if you continue to use this website.