This presentation is approved for one hour of CE credit for all CFPs. Send your CFP # to : Tabitha.Morris@S1L.com

Similar documents
Background On Reverse Mortgages

Increasing the Sustainable Withdrawal Rate using the Standby Reverse Mortgage

2. Line of Credit: Borrowers have the option of setting up a line of credit (a cash account ) and drawing funds whenever they wish.

Standby Reverse Mortgages: A Risk Management Tool for Retirement Distributions

Is there a role for Reverse Mortgages in financial planning?

Reverse Mortgages in Retirement Income Planning

SPRINGWATER C APITAL

Reverse Mortgage Opportunities

Evaluating the HECM product

Standby Reverse Mortgages: A Risk Management Tool for Retirement Distributions

Welcome. YourHomeYourEquity.com. Integrity Mortgage Group I 2220 Highway 17 I Little River, SC I Phone: (843)

A Smart Choice Learn How The New Reverse Mortgage May Fit Into Your Retirement Plan.

History, Facts and Uses of Reverse Mortgages For: Columbus FPA

PERFECT STORM STATISTICS

The New Tool For Retirement Income Planning. Presented by: Becky Bell, Regional VP, Mortgage Banking

Delay Social Security: Funding the Income Gap with a Reverse Mortgage

How HECMs Work. Prepared by Genworth. Reverse Mortgages: A Financial Planning Tool

Managing Home Equity to Build Wealth By Ray Meadows CPA, CFA, MBA

Converting Home Equity into Income: AReverseMortgageReview

Guide to Reverse Mortgages

Professor Jamie Hopkins Co-Director of The American College New York Life Center for Retirement Income

PERFECT STORM STATISTICS

Incorporating Home Equity into a Retirement Income Strategy

Reverse Mortgage Information Guide

Enhance Your Financial Security

Nationwide Mortgage Licensing System #222955

THE GOVERNMENT S REDESIGNED REVERSE MORTGAGE PROGRAM

The 6% Rule. by Gerald C. Wagner, Ph.D.

New Research: Reverse Mortgages, SPIAs and Retirement Income

RETIREMENT FALL 2015 Volume 3 Number 2

The Effective Use of Reverse Mortgages in Retirement

Converting Home Equity into Income: A Reverse Mortgage Review

New Smart. Learn how it can help you take advantage of the existing equity in your home, and live the life you ve earned.

10/22/2014. Securing Retirement with Home Equity Conversion Mortgages. Retirement Planning Using Home Equity. What is a HECM?

The 6.0 Percent Rule. Executive Summary

Reverse Mortgage Guide

Enhance Your Financial Security. With a Home Equity Conversion Mortgage

for INCOME IN USING YOUR HOUSE RETIREMENT A retirement PLANNING GUIDE

Reverse Mortgage Presented by Ian MacGillivray, NMLS # American Capital Corporation, NMLS # Phone: Website:

Reverse Mortgages (HECM) Helping Seniors

Reversing the Conventional Wisdom: Using Home Equity to Supplement Retirement Income

Frequently asked questions for advisors

Just the FAQs: Answers to Common Questions About Reverse Mortgages. From the National Reverse Mortgage Lenders Association

Section D. Reverse Mortgage Loan Features and Costs Overview

WILL REVERSE MORTGAGES RESCUE THE BABY BOOMERS?

Reverse Mortgage Is it right for you?

The Facts. About Reverse Mortgages. without the hype

Reverse Mortgage Counseling 101

What You Need to Know Before Considering a. Reverse Mortgage. Fair Housing Legal Support Center & Clinic

The Facts About Reverse Mortgages. without the hype

There are no asset or income limitations on borrowers receiving HUD's reverse mortgages.

Maggie O'Connell Reverse Mortgage Store

Concierge Financial Planning, LLC Prepared for: December 01, 2014

LHFS Wholesale. Understanding the HECM LIBOR Product Training. Great Rates. Great Programs. Great Service.


New Research: Reverse Mortgages, SPIAs and Retirement Income

When Even Wealthy Homeowners Are Using Reverse Mortgages, The Question Is: Why Aren't You?

Increasing the Sustainable Withdrawal Rate Using the Standby Reverse Morgage

CLE Alabama. 33 rd Annual Bankruptcy Law Update. Hyatt Regency Wynfrey Hotel Birmingham, Alabama Friday, November 14, 2014

The 5 Facts You Need to Know about FHA-insured Reverse Mortgages aka HECMs

How To Get A Home Equity Conversion Mortgage

Senior Concerns. Will you outlive your money?

How To Get A Reverse Mortgage

Reverse Mortgage. Work With a Local Expert

The Cost and Benefit of Reverse Mortgages

Reverse Mortgages, Refinancing, and Home Equity Lines of Credit

Understanding Home Equity Conversion Mortgages

Forward vs Reverse Mortgages

Reverse Mortgage Basics. Norma P. Garcia Senior Attorney Consumers Union May 28, 2012

Is A Reverse Mortgage Right for You?

Just the FAQs: Answers to Common Questions About Reverse Mortgages. From the National Reverse Mortgage Lenders Association

What You Should Know About Reverse Mortgages

THE FHA REVERSE MORTGAGE PROGRAM:

Understanding Home Equity Conversion Mortgages

The Boomer Effect. What Advisors Need to Know about the $18 Trillion Wealth Transfer

L.K. Benson & Company Lyle Benson, CPA/PFS, CFP 1107 Kenilworth Dr, Suite 302 Baltimore, MD lyle@lkbenson.com

Seniors Reverse Mortgage Fact File and Answers to Frequently Asked Questions

SOA 2010 Annual Meeting & Exhibit Oct , Session 119 PD, Impact of Housing on Economic Security in Retirement

NET PRINCIPAL LIMIT (NPL) FROM REVERSE MORTGAGES IN THE STATE OF NEW YORK: A COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS

Just the FAQs: Answers to Common Questions About Reverse Mortgages. From the National Reverse Mortgage Lenders Association

REVERSE MORTGAGES EXPLAINED

Just the FAQs: Answers to Common Questions About Reverse Mortgages. From the National Reverse Mortgage Lenders Association

Is a Reverse Mortgage Right for You?

Table of Contents Reverse Mortgage O verview... Reverse Mortgage K ey Questions... 5 Reverse Mortgage Pros and Cons... 7 Reverse Mortgage Borr

A Guide to Reverse Mortgages

Just the FAQs: Answers to Common Questions About Reverse Mortgages. From the National Reverse Mortgage Lenders Association

Reverse Mortgage Education

How To Get A Home Equity Conversion Mortgage For Purchase

Reverse Mortgage Counseling Checklist

Enhance Your Financial Security. With a Home Equity Conversion Mortgage

Higgins Capital Management, Inc.

Reverse Mortgages in Relocation Assistance

Operations & Technology

Alain Valles, President CRMP, MBA, CSA. Direct Finance Corp.

U.S. Department of the Treasury Information Guide Regarding Reverse Mortgage

The following information is provided to you by U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development.

Secure your financial future with a Reverse Mortgage today!

January 28, 2015 Kauffman Conference Center

House Rich and Cash Poor: Ways to Unlock Your Home s Value

THE NATIONAL REVERSE MORTGAGE LENDERS ASSOCIATION

Transcription:

This presentation is approved for one hour of CE credit for all CFPs. CFPs are required to log in to the webinar using the unique link received at the time of registration. CFPs must remain on the webinar for a minimum of 50 minutes to be eligible for credit. Send your CFP # to : Tabitha.Morris@S1L.com 1

Welcome to the RIIA Virtual Learning Center Sponsored by: Bank of America Merrill Lynch September 3, 2014 RIIA 101 Federal Street, Suite 190, Boston, MA 02110 Ph: 617.342.7390 Fax: 617.342.7080 www.riia-usa.org

Bank of America Merrill Lynch Exclusive Sponsor of RIIA s 2014/2015 Virtual Learning Center

RIIA Virtual Learning Center Webinars earn RMA CE credit Adviser Track First Wednesday of every month, 12:00 p.m. (eastern) October 1 st David Freitag, CLU, ChFC, CRPC, MML Investor Services Understand Social Security WEP and GPO for Advisers Home Office Track Third Wednesday of every month, 12:00 p.m. (eastern) September 17 th Howard Schneider, Practical Perspectives, and Dennis Gallant, GDC Research Social Security Support to Financial Advisors Insights and Opportunities 2014 Interested in presenting? Contact Kim McSheridan kim@riia-usa.org

Archived Webinars Easy as 1, 2, 3 for RIIA members: 1. Login 2. Click vlc webinars tab 3. Scroll down to select a webinar

Retirement Management Journal Retirement Management Analyst Essential Readings Page Retirement Management Journal - Now on Amazon.com Retirement Management Analyst Essential Readings Page Boost your knowledge with our list of leading authors Click on Education at www.riia-usa.org

RIIA FALL CONFERENCE Register Now

Questions Have a question? Type it into the box in the lower right hand side of your screen at any time. Q&A at the end of the presentation.

About Today s Presenter Shelley Giordano Chair, Funding Longevity Task Force Academic Research: Housing Wealth in Retirement Distribution

Jeanne Louise Calment, ( February 1875 August 1997) had the longest confirmed human lifespan on record, living to the age 122 years,164 days. 10

How to protect both the homeowner and the lender? 1. 1988 HUD reconfigures FHA Mortgage Insurance Premium and applies it to the new Home Equity Conversion Mortgage (HECM)* ****** Homeownership remains with borrower/no title transfer just like any other mortgage 2. The MIP protects both the homeowner and the lender a. The loan s maturity date is at the youngest borrower s 150 th birthday b. No deficiency judgment may be taken against the homeowner or his estate c. At maturity, defined as the last homeowner dying, moving or selling, the lender is reimbursed from the FHA fund if the loan balance exceeds the home value 11

Incorporating Housing Wealth in Retirement Distribution Income Streams American C.E. Institute RIIA Incorporating Housing Wealth in the distribution phase Shelley Giordano James Warns One Hour Credit CFP These materials are designed to provide the reader with a general overview and understanding of the topic(s) presented and are not intended as a substitute for consultation with qualified legal counsel regarding the manner in which the laws, regulations, and guidelines covered may apply to a particular fact pattern or business model. No part of this presentation may be reproduced, forwarded, copied, or redistributed in any form or by any means without the prior written consent of Reverse Mortgage Solutions, Inc. ( RMS ). This presentation could include technical inaccuracies or typographical errors. RMS does not guarantee the accuracy of the information provided and disclaims any and all express or implied warranties, including, but not limited to, any warranties of merchantability or fitness for a particular purpose or use. This presentation should not be construed as legal advice or relied on as a sole resource for any part of the Home Equity Conversion Mortgage program. Unauthorized reproduction, forwarding, distribution or display of this copyrighted work is subject to criminal and civil penalties under federal law. 12

First, the Rules of the Road These strategies are not designed for the purchase of investments but rather to maximize and protect existing investments. The revised FHA HECM program has been restructured with the aim that the homeowner will use his home equity prudently to last throughout the retirement lifespan. This is exactly how you would treat all other assets. FINRA has withdrawn its recommendation that a HECM be used only as a last resort. 13

Where is Wealth Concentrated? 14

An Old Tool is New Again Home Equity Conversion Mortgage HECM Wealth Advisors Have Embraced the Managed Payment Revolving LOC 15

Change from Defined-Benefit to Defined-Contribution Plans to Fund Retirement 16

What They Fear the Most 17

Baby Boomers: Unprecedented Longevity 18

For the Average Couple in Your Practice For a 65-year-old married couple 19

Why take a new look at HECM Program? Consumer Safeguards Published Studies Examining HECM as a Portfolio Survival Tool Longevity Crisis in a Defined Contribution World Reduced Upfront Fees Purchase Money HECM Copyright ( ) 2013. NOT FOR CONSUMER USE 20

Consumer safeguards are up The FHA insured Home Equity Conversion Mortgage (HECM) which was developed by Congress in 1988 to provide a mechanism for retirees to use their housing wealth in conservative and prudent manner. The inherent consumer safeguards are summarized by the 4 Nevers * 1. Never Give Up Title to the Home 2. Never Owe More than Home is Worth 3. Never Have to Move 4. Never Make a Monthly Payment on Principal or Interest * Caveat is never say never 21

Dramatically Reduced Set up Fees Closing Cost Fee Chart Pre-2013 Now Servicing Fee Loan Origination Fee Closing Costs Upfront Mortgage Insurance Premium * *reduced from 2.5% to 0.5% for borrowers not taking full disbursement to pay existing obligations 22

HECM Primer Mortgage secured by real estate only 62 minimum age Primary home/ HUD sees the first $625,500 of home value for lending purposes Positive equity RULE OF THUMB : 50% and we are in business No monthly payments required but voluntary payments accepted No defined term Client must maintain insurance, taxes, home repairs Federally insured Voluntary payments result in increasing credit line I-O Payments P and I Payments Skip Payments Balloon Payments No Payments 23

Tax Free Money accessed via the HECM is considered proceeds from a loan. 24

Continuous Evolution Over a Quarter of a Century 1. Discourage equity-stripping through MIP pricing a. Prohibitions against accessing full credit in first year b. In circumstances where full draws are allowed, the homeowner is assessed a 2.5% upfront Mortgage Insurance Premium on home value 2. Change emphasis on MIP structure to a use fee rather than an upfront cost a. Initially, upfront MIP was 2% of home value regardless of use rate b. Today, for clients using roughly 60% or less of available credit, the Upfront MIP is.5% 3. Expected Soon : More underwriting rigor to prevent using the HECM to kick the can down the road Is a HECM suitable for this client? 25

Flexible Access to Cash Four Access Methods Line of Credit Monthly Payments Lump Sum Current Home Purchasing a New Home Combination 26

The Mass Affluent Traditional Needs-Based Client MASS AFFLUENT House Rich, Cash Poor Estate Maximization Renters w/ Few Assets Strategic Use of Home Equity 27

The Individual Retirement Plan and Cash Flow Survival: Can a HECM Help to Defend the Client Against These Risks? Spending Beyond Safemax Sequence of Returns Risk Reverse Dollar Cost Averaging 28

Sequence of Returns Risk Negative Returns in Early Years Positive Returns in Early Years 29

Reverse Dollar Cost Averaging 30

Could a HECM Strategy Mitigate Portfolio Volatility? Product Changes Spur Academic Research 31

Barry Sacks, J.D., Ph.D. Stephen Sacks, Ph.D. 32

Cash Flow Survival, Spending Beyond Safemax 33

34

Conclusions particularly in the range of initial withdrawal rates between 5 percent and 6.5 percent, we have found substantially greater cash flow survival probabilities when the reverse mortgage credit line is used in either of two active strategies rather than in the conventional, passive, strategy as a last resort. We have also found that use of these active strategies is likely to result in a higher residual net worth after 30 years than the use of the conventional strategy. 35

Great Minds Think Alike: John Salter, Ph.D., CFP and Harold Evensky, CFP, AIF Texas Tech University 36

HECM versus HELOC HELOC HECM Line of Credit Line Can Be Frozen or Cancelled Yes No Loan Subject to Recast Yes, I-O Resets No Automatic Growth in Borrowing Power No Yes Line Guaranteed to Grow Despite Home Value Payments Required Yes No No Yes Age-Based Lending No Yes ( 62+) 37

Glidepath Concept 38

Risk Management Tool : Comparing Cash Flow Reserve Bucket Strategies At the 30-year mark of retirement, or when our client is 92, we see the probability of their portfolio having a positive value is approximately 52 percent. When we implement the SRM ( Standby Reverse Mortgage) strategy we find the probability dramatically increases to 78 percent. When the line of credit is used to fund living after the portfolio is exhausted, the probability increases to 82 percent. 39

Conclusions The Standby Reverse Mortgage strategy is appealing for four primary reasons: 1. It diminishes the size of the cash bucket and thus the opportunity cost of holding cash; 2. It provides flexibility in that the investment bucket is not sold during bear markets; 3. It allows the retiree to decide how much home equity is used to meet needs; 4. and most importantly, it increases the life expectancy of an investor s nest egg. 40

Simply Put : Don t Feed the Bear Draw from IP only when portfolio returns are positive. Use HECM instead. 41

Replacing a Mortgage with a HECM? Michael Kitces @ kitces.com There's a danger than equities won't perform as expected, and fail to generate a return in excess of the borrowing cost over a relevant time period. And even if the returns do ultimately add up, the ongoing payment obligations for a traditional mortgage create a "sequence of returns" risk for the retiree, where withdrawals to handle the mortgage payments could so deplete the portfolio during an extended period of bad returns that there may not be enough money left over for when the good returns finally arrive. From this perspective, retirees should perhaps consider the reverse mortgage instead. While such loans have been relatively unpopular - due in part to their high costs, and because they're often viewed as a borrowing option of last resort - the reality is that the lack of any cash flow obligations for a reverse mortgage actually allows it to eliminate the sequence risk from the mortgage-in-retirement strategy. In fact, over a long period of time, using a reverse mortgage in retirement can result in materially greater wealth when equities do perform as desired, as the reverse mortgage maintains a greater amount of household leverage, even while reducing the exposure to the impact of an unfavorable sequence of returns. 42

Compared to a Traditional Mortgage Make a down payment and then monthly mortgage payments until paid off Mortgage There is a cost for all of the mortgage payments 10 20 30 Probably 2 to 3 times the loan amount toolsforretirementplanning.com 43

How would portfolio perform without P and I payments? www.fundinglongevity.com 44

Voluntary Payments on HECM? www.fundinglongevity.com Housing Wealth Optimizer Calculator Every payment against the HECM adjustable rate HECM results in a corresponding increase in the available Line of Credit. If needed down the road, the Line of Credit can be converted to monthly tenure payments: 45

HELOC v. HECM Rates Tom Davison, Ph.D., CFP toolsforretirementplanning.com The green line is the RMLOC is represented as the 1-month LIBOR, adding in the current 1.25% MIP and a margin of 2.25%. The black is HELOC, estimated by adding 0.5% to the history of prime. 46

Scheduled Monthly Payments Provide Resilience 47

New Study Confirms Protective Power of Housing Wealth: The 6% Rule Gerald Wagner, Ph.D. Scheduled Payment from HECM? Portfolio Alone Portfolio Alone Retirement Horizon Initial Withdrawal Rate Probability of Success Outcome 30 years 4% 90% Spending Limited 30 years 6.0% 36% Not Viable Tenure Plan 30 years 6.0% 90% + Greater Spending Portfolio Alone 37 years 3.25% 90% Spending Limited Tenure Plan 37 years 5.5% 90.6% Longevity Protection Assumptions: 63-yr-old Client; $800,000 IP, minimum 60% Equities; $450,000 Home 48

Wagner: 60+% Increased Portfolio-based Spending With Reverse Mortgage Monthly Income Portfolio alone: 3.75% Sustainable Withdrawal Portfolio + Monthly Income: 6% Sustainable Withdrawal Wagner, 2013. Journal of Financial Planning 49

Monthly Draw : Add $1200 a month from Housing Wealth Retires at Age 66 First Year Income Need $ 72,000 401K $ 750,000 Cash $ 325,000 Initial Social Security $ 25,571 Housing Wealth $ 500,000 Add Home Equity Draws $ 14, 400 a year 50

Outcome without Home Equity Draws 51

Outcome with $1,200 Monthly HECM Draws 52

Comparison Without a HECM With HECM Draws of $1,200/mo. 53

HECM Scheduled Monthly Payments www.fundinglongevity.com HECM RETIREMENT CALCULATOR 54

Retained Housing Wealth @$1200/month/30 years Estimated Values 55

Jack Guttentag, Professor Emeritus University of Pennsylvania Using a HECM Reverse Mortgage to Insure Against Running Out of Money December 17, 2012 Is there a way for seniors living off of retirement assets to insure themselves against running out of money? Today, an alternative that keeps your assets in your own hands is available to any senior with significant equity in the home they occupy as their principal residence. The alternative is the HECM reverse mortgage administered by FHA. 56

HECM LOC as Liquidity Insurance Estimated Values 57

Effective Interest Rate Available Credit by Interest Rate Youngest Borrower s Age 62 67 72 77 82 87 92 5% 52.6% 55.1% 57.5% 59.7% 62.1% 64.6% 66.0% 6% 42.0% 45.0% 48.3% 51.1% 54.5% 58.1% 60.2% 7% 34.3% 37.9% 41.7% 45.1% 48.9% 53.2% 55.8% 8% 28.1% 31.9% 36.1% 40.0% 44.2% 49.0% 52.1% 9% 22.9% 26.9% 31.3% 35.2% 40.0% 45.3% 48.4% 10% 18.5% 22.5% 26.9% 31.2% 36.1% 41.8% 45.1% Tom Davison, toolsforretirementplanning.com 58

Rising Interest Rates Will Reduce INITIAL Loan Proceeds HECM LINE OF CREDIT BORROWER AGE 66 HOME VALUE $500,000 EXPECTED RATE OF PROVIDES INITIAL PROCEEDS OF 3% $274,500 4% $274,500 5% $274,500 6% $210,500 7% $169,000 8% $132,000 59

Journal of Financial Planning, December, 2013 Salter,Pfeiffer,Evensky Together, these findings suggest that the adage of using a reverse mortgage as a last resort could be a huge mistake in a rising interest rate environment where a retiree waits to set up a line of credit in the future. In addition, the current retirement landscape, due to low interest rates, should incentivize the consideration of reverse mortgages in retirement for many financial planners and their clients. 60

Another Radical Change: Purchase Money HECM Also known as HECM for Purchase Finance the purchase of a new primary residence by getting a HECM on the new home as part of the purchase transaction, instead of getting a traditional mortgage or paying all cash. No Debt Service Requirement. Easier to Qualify. 61

Use Your Equity to Fund a Purchase Appraised Value-Lump Sum = Down Payment $600,000 - $300,000 = $300,000 62

Upsizing with Purchase Money HECM. 66 Year Old Without HECM Financing Sales Price for Departure Home $ 500,000 Less Selling Costs ( Commission, Fees) $ 40,000 Net Proceeds from Departure Home $ 460,000 New Home Price, Paid in Cash $ 700,000 Withdrawal from Assets to Accomplish Cash Sale $ (240,000) With HECM Financing Sales Price for Departure Home $ 500,000 Less Selling Costs (Commission, Fees) $ 40,000 Net Proceeds from Departure Home $ 460,000 New Home Price $ 700,000 Financing Available from HECM $ 300,000 Cash Required from Net Proceeds $ 400,000 Liberated Funds Remaining for Retirement Needs ($240K Assets protected + $60K residual from departure home) $ 300,000 63

Upsizing with Purchase Money HECM How Cash Retention Affects Retirement Outcome Balanced II Only Average Risk Tolerance Low Probability Retain $300,000 Higher Probability 64

HECM Purchase Money Calculator www.fundinglongevity.com 65

Defer Social Security Without Losing Income Delay Social Security :Funding the Income Gap with a Reverse Mortgage Thomas C. B. Davison, MA, Ph.D, CFP NAPFA Registered Financial Advisor toolsforretirementplanning.com Using HECM Line of Credit to fund the gap in income created by delaying Social Security can dramatically improve a retirement income plan.. 66

Funding the Income Gap 67

Social Security at 62 68

Delay Social Security, HECM to Fund Income Gap 69

5% v. 90% Success Rate TIME IN THE MARKET 70

A Common Theme The bottom line to all of these strategies, though, is fairly straightforward: reverse mortgages may work far better when they're done not as a last resort, but as a part of an ongoing retirement plan. --Michael Kitces, Partner & Director of Research Pinnacle Advisory Group 71

Conclusion : Research Proves Positive Role of Housing Wealth Consumer Safeguards Protect Housing Asset Draws from Housing Wealth Protect Investment Portfolio HECM LOC Provides Benefits that HELOCs Do Not HECM LOC Insures Access to Housing Wealth for Future Terminal Wealth Enhanced Greater Withdrawal Rates Possible Substitutes Income During Social Security Deferral Years Inclusion of Housing Wealth in Retirement Matrix Allows more time in the market 72

An Adviser Website www.fundinglongevity.com 73

Bibliography Prepared by ToolsforRetirementPlanning.com Research from Gerald Wagner and Barry and Stephen Sacks A variety of strategies can be used to fund spending when combining reverse mortgage and portfolio draws. Wagner s paper examines 5 strategies, such as a using the reverse mortgage line of credit first before any portfolio withdrawals, fixed monthly draws for 30 years, or monthly tenure advance guaranteed to continue as long as the homeowner stays in the house. All the strategies improved retirement withdrawals. Benefits of each strategy are examined. Wagner, Gerald C. 2013. The 6.0 Percent Rule. Journal of Financial Planning, 26(12): 46 54. With only the portfolio to fund spending, sustainable withdrawals were 3.75%. In contrast, With a 30-year spending horizon and first-year withdrawal of 6.0 percent, reverse mortgage scheduled advances as a portfolio supplement give spending success levels of 88 to 92 percent. Even with a first-year withdrawal of 6.5 percent, success levels are still 83 to 86 percent. This paper provides financial planners with a review of the relative merits of using a reverse mortgage as a retirement spending supplement. After 15 years, the client s estate value is 10 to 30% higher using the reverse mortgage plus portfolio than relying on the portfolio alone, combining current portfolio, home value and deducting the reverse mortgage loan balance. http://www.onefpa.org/journal/pages/december-2013-the-6-0-percent-rule.aspx Sacks, Barry H., and Stephen R. Sacks. 2012. Reversing the Conventional Wisdom: Using Home Equity to Supplement Retirement Income. Journal of Financial Planning 25(2): 43-52. This paper examines three strategies for using home equity, in the form of a reverse mortgage credit line, to increase the safe maximum initial rate of retirement income withdrawals. http://www.onefpa.org/journal/pages/reversing%20the%20conventional%20wisdom%20using%20home%20equity%20to%20supplement%20retirement%20income.aspx Standby Reverse Mortgage: Borrow from then repay Line of Credit to augment Portfolio withdrawals A Standby Reverse Mortgage is a strategy of borrowing from the HECM Line of Credit when the portfolio has suffered a significant downturn and repaying it after the portfolio recovers so it is available to help future spending in the future. The team of Salter, Pfeiffer and Evensky introduced this concept. Pfeiffer, Shaun, C. Angus Schaal, and John Salter. 2014. HECM Reverse Mortgages: Now or Last Resort? Journal of Financial Planning 27(5) 44-51. This study outlines recent changes in the reverse mortgage market and investigates plan survival rates for distribution strategies that establish a Home Equity Conversion Mortgage (HECM) reverse mortgage line of credit at the beginning of retirement and as a last resort. Early establishment of an HECM line of credit in the current low interest rate environment is shown to consistently provide higher 30-year survival rates than those shown for the last resort strategies. The early establishment survival advantage for real withdrawal rates at or above 5 percent is estimated to begin between 15 and 20 years after loan origination and is shown to be as high as 31 percentage points, or 85 percent, greater than the last resort survival rates. Pfeiffer, Shaun, John Salter, and Harold Evensky. 2013 Increasing the Sustainable Withdrawal Rate Using the Standby Reverse Mortgage. Journal of Financial Planning 26(12): 55-62. Sustainable withdrawal rates jumped from 3.15% to 5 and 6% with a standby HECM Line of Credit. The real key, not directly addressed in the article, is the size of the line of credit in realation to the portfolio. Clients had an important boost in sustainable spending with a line of credit as small as 8% 10% of the portfolio. The authors note The findings from this research suggest that the adage of using a reverse mortgage as a last resort could be a huge mistake in a rising interest rate environment where a retiree waits to set up a line of credit in the future. http://www.onefpa.org/journal/pages/december-2013-increasing-the-sustainable-withdrawal-rate-using-the-standby-reverse-mortgage.aspx 74

ToolsforRetirementPlanning.com Michael Kitces notes: this latest version looks specifically at the maximum safe withdrawal rate that can be sustained by the strategy, and is updated for the latest reverse mortgage rules that took effect this fall. Using reduced market expectations (relative to historical standards), the results show a significant improvement in safe withdrawal rates (in the neighborhood of 5% even with lower return assumptions) under the standby reverse mortgage scenario, driven in part by the favorable liquidation effects and in part simply because the strategy taps home equity and introduces additional assets to the retirement balance sheet. clients who wish to implement the strategy should look at establishing the line of credit sooner rather than later (while interest rates are still low), even if there is no intention to borrow until an extended period into the future (to reduce the risk that rates will be higher and borrowing limits will be lower if the client waits until funds actually need to be used). http://www.kitces.com/blog/weekend-reading-for-financial-planners-dec-7-8/ Salter, John, Shaun Pfeiffer, and Harold Evensky. 2012. Standby Reverse Mortgages: A Risk Management Tool for Retirement Distributions. Journal of Financial Planning 25 (8): 40 48. The authors propose using an HECM Saver reverse mortgage as a risk management tool in conjunction with a two-bucket investment strategy to increase the probability a client will be able to meet predetermined retirement goals. http://www.onefpa.org/journal/pages/standby%20reverse%20mortgages%20a%20risk%20management%20tool%20for%20retirement%20distributions.aspx Salter, John, Shaun Pfeiffer, and Harold Evensky. 2012. Standby Reverse Mortgages: A Risk Management Tool for Retirement Distributions. Presentation sponsored by Genworth. Document created August 17, 2012. Talk based on Journal of Financial Planning 2012 article. Additional charts of interest, including details of HECM balance usage. For example: Less than 25% of plans had a HECM loan balance in any year, and about 5% of months had a plan with 100% of line of credit used http://bit.ly/1hgk0i2 Evensky, Harold. June 2013 10 Questions. Harold Evensky on ETFs, Reverse Mortgages, and the Most Important Investment in the Coming Decade. Journal of Financial Planning 26(6): 16-20. Short discussion described in detail in other papers. our conclusion was, anyone who qualified for it should consider doing it. And there s a high probability, based on our simulations, that most investors would never have occasion to draw on it, but as I said, we see it as an insurance policy. http://www.fpanet.org/docs/assets/cd39a280-e3a4-36a0-74a2636662d9880e/10q.pdf Reverse Mortgages in Financial Planning General Kitces, Michael. 2014. Taking a Fresh Look at Reverse Mortgages in Retirement. AICPA Advanced Personal Financial Planning Conference. January 21. An updated version of earlier talks. Kitces, Michael. 2013. HECM Reverse Mortgages Current Borrowing Limits May Not Last Much Longer. Nerd s Eye View. December 4. http://www.kitces.com/blog/hecm-reverse-mortgages-current-borrowing-limits-may-not-last-much-longer/ Kitces, Michael. 2013. Is a Reverse Mortgage Better Than Keeping a Traditional Amortizing Mortgage in Retirement? Nerd s Eye View. September 18. the fact remains that all else being equal, traditional amortizing mortgages introduce additional sequence risks to the household leverage scenario (above and beyond just the risk that the portfolio fails to outperform the loan) that reverse mortgages alleviate, which should make reverse mortgages especially appealing for retirees who believe it s worth the risk of maintaining a mortgage and a portfolio side by side in retirement. http://www.kitces.com/blog/is-a-reverse-mortgage-better-than-keeping-a-traditional-amortizing-mortgage-in-retirement/ Kitces, Michael. 2013. Will New Reverse Mortgage Changes Make Them a Better Financial Planning Tool? Nerd s Eye View. September 11. http://www.kitces.com/blog/will-new-reverse-mortgage-changes-make-them-a-better-financial-planning-tool/ Kitces, Michael. 2013. HUD Eliminating Fixed-Rate HECM Standard Reverse Mortgages, But HECM Saver Option Remains. Nerd s Eye View. February 27. http://www.kitces.com/blog/hud-eliminating-fixed-rate-hecm-standard-reverse-mortgages-but-hecm-saver-option-remains/ Kitces, Michael. 2011. Evaluating Reverse Mortgage Strategies. The Kitces Report. November. Broad review of how reverse mortgages can fit in client s retirement plans. Kitces, Michael. 2011. A Fresh Look at the Reverse Mortgage. The Kitces Report. October. Summarizes the internal workings of reverse mortgages. Lynch, Nicholas C. and Charles R Pryor. 2012. Know the costs, benefits and alternatives for this retirement funding tool. Journal of Accountancy. July. Includes section on family-funded alternatives to reverse mortgages 75

ToolsforRetirementPlanning.com Munnell, Alicia H. and Steven A. Sass. 2014. The Government s Redesigned Reverse Mortgage Program. Center for Retirement Research at Boston College. January, Number 14-1. Reverse mortgages, which allow retirees to tap their home equity, are insured by the government. The financial crisis hurt both the government s insurance fund and the borrowers: Declining home prices led to losses when homes were sold; More borrowers defaulted. In response, the government has redesigned the program by: creating a single loan option with a lower limit and fees; limiting initial withdrawals; and requiring financial assessments of borrowers. These changes should help reduce pressure on the insurance fund and make defaults less likely Conclusion: All these changes should be viewed as positive. A better customer experience combined with lower fees will also make reverse mortgages a more attractive option for retirees. http://crr.bc.edu/briefs/the-government%e2%80%99s-redesigned-reverse-mortgage-program Quinn, Jane Bryant. 2013. A great reverse mortgage idea: Take a credit line now. August 15. But there s a valuable new opportunity at hand, for borrowers who don t need extra money now. You borrow as early as age 62 and take the mortgage in the form of a credit line instead of all-cash. You can borrow against the credit line at any time, but you don t have to take the money now. More important, this credit line grows every year greatly increasing your borrowing power in the future. http://janebryantquinn.com/2013/08/a-great-reverse-mortgage-idea-take-a-credit-line-now Jack Guttentag posts as The Mortgage Professor Guttentag discusses reverse mortgages and other types of mortgages on his website. Wide variety of posts available. http://www.mtgprofessor.com/articlecategories/reverse_mortgages.htm Technical Details for Reverse Mortgage Nerds HUD handbook for Home Equity Conversion Mortgages (4235.1) http://portal.hud.gov/hudportal/hud?src=/program_offices/administration/hudclips/handbooks/hsgh/4235.1 HUD Mortgagee Letters Official HUD communication on Reverse Mortgages http://portal.hud.gov/hudportal/hud?src=/program_offices/administration/hudclips/letters/mortgagee HUD s site for lenders: Home Equity Conversion Mortgages for Lenders (HECMs) The purpose of this page is to help FHA approved lenders by providing links to policy, guidance and tools that help in the origination and servicing of HECM loans. http://portal.hud.gov/hudportal/hud?src=/program_offices/housing/sfh/hecm/hecmhomelenders 76

Questions? shelley.giordano@s1l.com jwarns@s1l.com 77

This presentation is approved for one hour of CE credit for all CFPs. CFPs are required to log in to the webinar using the unique link received at the time of registration. CFPs must remain on the webinar for a minimum of 50 minutes to be eligible for credit. Send your CFP # to : Tabitha.Morris@S1L.com 78