This lecture will introduce: ECON6021 Price Taking, Price Setting, and Competitive Market Profit maximization Price Taking Firm Supply curve Application: multi-plant firm Price Setting Firm Price-cost margin Price discrimination Competitive Market Efficiency of Competitive Market Short Run Cost Curves ATC AVC Marginal Analysis Firm s objective to maximize profit π=tr-tc If MR >, the extra revenue from selling one more unit exceeds the extra cost. If MR <, the extra revenue from selling one more unit is less than the extra cost. AFC Q If MR = economic profit is maximized. 1
Profit Maximization Price Taking Firm π is maximized if MR = and MR cuts from above So long as it is worthwhile producing This holds for whatever market structure such as Perfect competition (price taking firm) Monopoly (price setting firm) Total revenue & total cost (dollars per day) 300 225 183 0 Economic loss TR Economic profit = TR - TC 0 4 9 12 Quantity (sweaters per day) Profit-Maximizing Output for a Price Taking Firm Marginal revenue & marginal cost (dollars per day) 30 25 20 Profitmaximization point D=AR=MR Total Revenue, Total Cost, and Economic Profit for a Price Setting Firm Total revenue & total cost (dollars per day) 300 225 183 0 8 9 Quantity (sweaters per day) 0 4 9 12 Quantity (sweaters per day) 2
Price and cost (dollars per hour) A Price Setting Firm s Profit Maximizing Output 20 14 dp( Q) MR( Q) = P( Q) + Q dq D Price Taking Firm MR 0 1 2 3 4 5 Quantity (haircuts per hour) A Firm s Supply Curve Marginal revenue & marginal cost (dollars per day) 31 25 17 s curve = Supply curve MR 2 MR 1 AVC MR 0 A Firm s Supply Curve Marginal revenue & marginal cost (dollars per day) 31 25 17 s S 7 9 Quantity (sweaters per day) 7 9 Quantity (sweaters per day) 3
Application: Multi-plant firm Suppose a perfectly competitive firm has two plants producing identical goods with marginal cost functions 1 (Q 1 ) and 2 (Q 2 ). It is straightforward to show that it show produce Q 1 and Q 2 in the two plant so that 1 (Q 1 ) = 2 (Q 2 ) = P where P is market price. Price Setting Firm Price Setting Firm and How Monopoly Arises The simplest form of price setting firm is monopoly A monopoly is an industry that produces a good or service for which no close substitute exists and in which there is one supplier that is protected from competition by a barrier preventing the entry of new firms. Natural Monopoly Price (cents per kilowatt-hour) 15 5 ATC D 0 1 2 3 4 Quantity (millions of kilowatt-hours) 4
Monopoly Price- Setting Strategies Price discrimination is the practice of selling different units of a good or service for different prices. A single-price monopoly is a firm that must sell each unit of its output for the same price. Single-Price Monopoly The firm s demand curve is the market demand curve. Marginal revenue is not the same as the market price. There is no supply curve for a monopoly. A Monopoly s Output and Price Price and cost (dollars per hour) 20 14 Economic profit $12 MR 0 1 2 3 4 5 Quantity (haircuts per hour) Profit = $12 ($4 x 3 units) ATC D An example: Linear Demand Q = 0 2P; AC== Inverse demand: P = 50 Q/2 TR = P*Q = (50 Q/2) Q = 50Q Q 2 /2 MR = 50 Q Remark: if P = A BQ, then MR = A 2BQ MR = 50 Q = Q = 40 Substituting Q = 40 into inverse demand, P = 50 40/2 = 30 5
Optimal output, profit margin, and profit 30 P AR = P(Q) =50 Q/2 40 Profit = profit margin X Q* = (P* - AC) Q* MR = 50 Q = AC Q Price-cost Margin and Elasticity dtr MR = dq dp( Q) = P( Q) + Q dq Q dp( Q) = P 1 + P dq dp( Q) / P = P 1 + dq / Q 1 = P 1 + ex, Px 1 = P 1 ex, Px Price-cost market and Equating with MR, we have price - cost margin 1 = MR = P 1 ex, P 1 = = P e Px x, Px Competition and Efficiency Efficiency is achieved when all the gains from trade have been realized (social welfare is maximized). The more elastic the demand, the smaller the price-cost margin Price-cost margin, a.k.a. price-cost markup, or Lerner Index of market power (1934). 6
Monopoly and Competition Compared Inefficiency of Monopoly Price P A Single-price monopoly restricts output, raises price Price P A Consumer surplus Monopoly P M P M P C Equilibrium in competitive industry P C Monopoly s gain Deadweight loss MR D MR D 0 Q M Q C Quantity 0 Q M Q C Quantity Price Discrimination Arcadia Publisher is planning to publish a book. loyalty to the author is fixed at $2M production cost=$0 per copy two groups of buyers 0K group 1 readers--each willing to pay up to $30 400K group 2 readers--each willing to pay up to $5 If p= $30, only group 1 readers will buy the book. Arcadia obtains $30x0K =$3M (gross of loyalty) If p= $5, both groups of readers will buy the book. Arcadia obtains $5x500K=$2.5M (gross of loyalty) Hence, charging $30 is better. Price Discrimination Now suppose Arcadia knows that all group 1 readers are in HK and group 2 readers are in Chile. Then it can charges a fee of $30 for a book sold in HK and $5 for a book sold in Chile. Price discrimination leads to greater profits greater social welfare!! 7
Determination of differentiated prices under constant marginal cost 2 segmented markets, 2 separate price in general. A More generally, the problem is ( P ( Q ) Q + P ( Q ) Q ) TC ( Q Q ) max Q Q 1 1 1 2 2 2 1 + 2 1, 2 Optimal output for the two markets are given by PQ 1( 1) TC P1+ Q1 = 0 Q Q P( Q ) 1 1 TC 2 2 2 + Q2 = Q2 Q2 P PQ ( ) PQ ( ) = P + Q = P + Q = 0 1 1 2 2 1 1 1 2 2 2 Q1 Q2 b b/2 B/2 B q Equalization of marginal cost and marginal revenue in each segment Market Equilibrium Competitive Markets Equilibrium is defined as the price at which the quantity demanded equals the quantity supplied (so markets clear) While all five conditions for perfect competition are (obviously) never fully satisfied, the model is still useful as frame of reference. When a market is out of equilibrium, market forces push the price towards equilibrium Excess supply (a.k.a., surplus) -- This triggers a price decrease Excess demand (a.k.a., shortage) --This triggers a price increase 8
Market Equilibrium (cont.) Long run competitive equilibrium Price ($ per ton-mile) a 22 20 c 0 surplus when market price = 22 b 8 11 supply equilibrium demand Firms enter and exit so achieve long run competitive equilibrium: Each firm produces at its minimum long run average cost Each firm earns a zero profit The number of firms is determined by supply and demand Quantity (Million ton-miles a year) Invisible Hand Minimum Wage: Equilibrium Social welfare (SW) = net gains from production and trade In the absence of tax, SW = buyer surplus + seller surplus In the presence of tax, SW = buyer surplus + seller surplus + tax revenue An outcome is efficient if the SW cannot be further increased. [taxation cannot increase SW, to be shown shortly] Perfect competition is efficient, in which marginal benefit = price marginal cost = price single price in market Wage ($ per hour) a f d Net inc. in seller surplus = fdge -ghb Net inc. in buyer surplus = - (fdge +egb) Net inc. in SW = - (ghb + egb) excess supply e g b h c 0 8 11 supply equilibrium demand Quantity (Billion worker-hours a week) 9
Minimum Wage: Losses Can tax improve SW? deadweight losses -- sellers willing to provide item at price that buyers willing to pay, but provision doesn t occur price elasticities of demand and supply Price ($ per ticket) 804 800 794 f d j e g g h Net inc. in buyer surplus = -(fdge + egb) Net inc. in seller surplus = -(djhg + ghb) Net inc. in tax revenue = fdge + djhg Net inc. in SW = -(egh + ghb) b $ supply demand 0 900 920 Quantity (Thousand tickets a year)