Generational trends in executive compensation: Survey results and commentary With the massive exit of retiring during the next twenty years, retaining and rewarding talent correctly has never been more important. 1 This demographic shift from to provides organizations with a predictable timeframe to align compensation strategies and organizational structures with motivators and corporate objectives. Historically, different generations approach their work and workplaces with different attitudes. Baby Boomers think in terms of paying one s dues and earning the opportunity for promotion and leadership. They sometimes postpone personal fulfilment and dedicate time to their career. In contrast, Generation X tends to desire work/life balance with personal fulfilment as a high priority. Their focus is on working smarter, not working longer. Companies should find ways to properly reward this next leadership generation in a manner consistent with these work attitudes and motivations. Appropriate executive compensation is essential to attracting and retaining this talent. Baker Tilly Executive Search survey results Baker Tilly Executive Search conducted a survey of senior executives* representing a variety of industries. Fifty percent of the respondents represented, born between 1963 and 1981, and the other half were, born between 1946 and 1962. Respondents were experienced executives with C-level, presidential, and vice presidential titles. Our analysis also highlights data from other recent studies conducted on behalf of Odgers Berndtson in conjunction with Cass Business School, City University London, and a study by the Hay Group. Job attributes: We asked respondents to rank job attributes in the order most important to them on a five-point scale. The following charts illustrate the responses provided by Baby Boomer and Generation X respondents. Rankings of job attributes (averages) Promotion/Job advancement opportunity 1.2 1.6 Responsbility 2.0 2.5 Sense of accomplishment High pay Meaningful work 1.8 2.7 2.7 3.0 2.4 2.9 0 1 2 3 4 5 Less important More important *Online survey conducted from December 2013 through March 2014 with a sample of 48 executives The ranking scale is inverted from the original survey scale to facilitate easier data interpretation page 1
Of the identified attributes, the Baker Tilly Executive Search survey shows that on average Generation X respondents value high pay the most and the opportunity for advancement/promotion the least. Baby Boomer respondents, on average, value meaningful work and a sense of accomplishment the most. High pay is also significantly less important to the Baby Boomer respondents than it is to respondents. As more mature leaders, are likely more interested in impact and legacy. with this interest may be more inclined to stay with their company on a semi-retired status and coach up-and-coming leaders. Compensation attributes: We asked respondents to rank four compensation attributes in the order most important to them on a five-point scale. Rankings of compensation attributes (averages) Perquisites 1.0 1.7 Long term incentive/equity Annual short term bonus 3.0 2.5 2.8 2.9 Base salary 3.4 3.6 0 1 2 3 4 5 Less important More important The ranking scale is inverted from the original survey scale to facilitate easier data interpretation Regarding compensation attributes, on average both Baby Boomer and respondents find base salary to be the most important of the compensation attributes identified, while perquisites hold significantly less importance. Interestingly, perquisites appear to hold more allure for Generation X respondents than they do for Baby Boomer respondents. respondents, earlier in their careers, appear to be more interested in their take home pay today, but also seem to be thinking about long term compensation., closer to retirement, found base salary, short term bonus, and long term incentive all to be relatively important. page 2
Compensation peak preferences: Historically, compensation peaks at retirement. Based on this premise, we asked respondents to express their agreement with the following statement: People are staying in the workforce longer. Compensation should peak earlier and then decline steadily until retirement, if responsibility and working hours become reduced as one gets closer to retirement. The following charts illustrate the responses received from the and members of respondents. Compensation peak preferences Disagree Somewhat disagree Neutral Somewhat agree 42% Agree 0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 25% 30% 35% 40% 45% To create a smooth transition from one leader to the next, companies may consider having Baby Boomer executives dedicate the final years of their career to educating executives in a mentor/coach/consultant capacity. This can enable the retiring executives to pursue fulfillment in their personal lives as they transition out of the leadership role. Related pay and working hour reductions may help boost the corporate budget and provide options for businesses to retain executives on a part-time or intermittent basis. Respondents from both generations in our survey generally agree that an earlier peak in compensation is preferable to a later one. This is a new and developing idea that companies may be slow to adopt. This concept fits well with the fact that the average age of a CEO is not declining and that as health and life expectancy increases, Baby Boomer executives may want to continue their careers in order to make a bigger impact and remain relevant. 2 page 3
Preparedness for demographic shift: We asked respondents to express their agreement with the following statement: My organization s senior leadership team is ready for the upcoming change in workforce demographics (age, gender, diversity). Perception of preparedness for demographic shift Disagree 0% Somewhat disagree 29% Neutral Somewhat agree Agree 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% Baby Boomer and respondents are in disagreement as to how prepared their organizations are for the demographic changes on the horizon. Half of felt their organizations were prepared, while respondents generally thought their organizations were not prepared. These interesting results, backed by Mercer s 2013 study which showed that 68 percent of those they interviewed thought their organizations were over-dependent on as CEOs, should serve as a catalyst for organizations to be more transparent about how they plan to address workforce demographic changes. 1 The Odger Berndtson study also demonstrated that only 41 percent of their executive respondents believe their organizations are ready. 2 As employee populations shift in terms of age, ethnicity, and gender, organizations may change to incorporate less hierarchy and formality. page 4
Performance based compensation: We asked respondents what they thought their incentives should be tied to. The following graph illustrates the responses from and respondents. Performance based compensation preferences Company performance 0% Company performance first, then my performance 46% 54% My performance first, then company performance 33% My performance 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% In 2017, the Dodd Frank Act Say-On-Pay Vote rule will require publicly-held companies to hold a Sayon-Pay vote for their shareholders at least once every three years regarding the compensation of the most highly compensated executives. 3 This lens of satisfying proxy advisors criteria for earning a yes Say-on-Pay vote by closely following industry trends and best practices 1 is valid and safe. However, we recommend that companies, both publicly-held and privately-held, also recognize the complexities of business and generational trends to support real, long-term shareholder value creation when considering their compensation strategies. How this impacts your organization Over the next twenty years, the leadership transition from Baby Boomer to executives may require organizations to adjust their compensation strategies or risk losing top talent. Baker Tilly Executive Search recommends advanced preparation to ensure a seamless transition from one generation to the next. Stay tuned for our May 2014 article, Generational trends in executive compensation: A roadmap for success, where our consultants will share insights and best practices to help you prepare for this transition. Sources 1. Jennifer Wagner Shenker, Greg Passin. 2013, September/October. Minding the Executive Compensation Gap. NACD Directorship Boardroom Intelligence. Mercer. 2. Cliff Oswick, Fahad Kamal, Alice Hohler. 2012. Cass Business School, City University London. After the : The Next Generation of Leadership. Ogders Berndtson. 3. Investor Bulletin: Say-on-Pay and Golden Parachute Votes. 2011, March. Office of Investor Education and Advocacy. Securities Exchange Commission. www.investor.gov. page 5 2014 Baker Tilly Executive Search, LLC Baker Tilly refers to Baker Tilly Executive Search, LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Baker Tilly Virchow Krause, LLP. Baker Tilly Virchow Krause, LLP, is an independently owned and managed member of Baker Tilly International.