EQUIPMENT REVIEW A new digital camera delivers high-resolution, deep-sky photographs for a fraction of the cost of a CCD camera. /// TEXT BY MARK HANSON AND R. A. GREINER, IMAGES BY MARK HANSON Canon 10D digital camera Until recently, the highest quality astroimaging by amateurs was done universally with highpriced CCD cameras. These cameras, containing cooled, monochrome CCD chips, cost thousands of dollars. To create a color image with one of these CCD cameras, three or more images must be taken through different color filters. The images are then combined to create a composite color image. Using CCD cameras requires considerable patience, practice, and skill. The resulting images from these cameras, however, are excellent, and many have been reproduced in the pages of Astronomy. Single-exposure color images of celestial objects also have been taken for some time with point-and-shoot digital cameras. These cameras have been used in the THE RUNNING MAN NEBULA (NGC 1977) (6-inch Takahashi FCT-150 apochromatic refractor at f/5, fifteen 4-minute exposures with a camera setting of ISO 800, taken January 18, 2004, from the New Mexico Skies astronomy resort) afocal mode, which means they are pointed into the eyepiece of the telescope and an image is recorded. For bright objects such as the Moon and planets, this technique has yielded images of acceptable quality. Most deep-sky objects are dim, however. Thus, the low sensitivity of pointand-shoot cameras combined with the complex optical arrangement of afocal photography have thwarted the attempts of many amateurs to obtain high-quality images of deep-sky objects. Enter the 10D A few professional digital single-lens reflex (SLR) cameras became available in the late 1990s. These allowed deep-sky photography, but their cost has put them out of reach for most amateurs. In the past 2 years, more affordable SLR digital cameras have become available. One of the best is the newest of the Canon line of digital SLR cameras, the 10D, which incorporates a color CCD chip with 6 million pixels (6 megapixels). For astroimaging, the Canon 10D competes with CCD cameras. Still, significant challenges exist. The electronic noise level of current SLR digital cameras is not as low as it is in cooled CCD cameras, but other advantages far outweigh this problem. Digital SLRs can generate a full-color image with each exposure. They have a large chip with megapixels of resolution. And the imaging techniques are similar to those used for 35mm film astrophotography, which are well known to many amateur astronomers. Also, unlike a point-and-shoot digital camera, an SLR digital camera can be used at the THE CANON REMOTE TIMER, used for multiple long-duration exposures, is a must-have accessory. It controls the number of exposures, their length, and the intervals between them. The remote timer makes long sequences of exposures automatic. prime focus of the telescope. This allows the primary telescope optics to be used to full advantage. Pros and cons Author Mark Hanson took all the images in this article with a Canon 10D. A comparison between a CCD camera s technical specifications and the 10D s shows the strengths of each. The 10D has a large chip, 22.7mm by 15.1mm with 6.3 megapixels. A typical CCD camera has a chip 13.8mm by 9.2mm with 1.5 2009 Kalmbach Publishing Co. This material may not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher. www.astronomy.com
THE CANON 10D with a 50mm lens attached is well-suited for wide-field pictures of the Milky Way. THE LCD READOUT on the Canon 10D shows, at a glance, which settings are being used and allows for several adjustments of the camera. MANY TELESCOPE ADAPTERS are available to attach the Canon 10D to virtually any telescope. This Takahashi telescope adapter often is attached to Hanson s 10D. www.astronomy.com 85
THE LAGOON NEBULA (M8) IN SAGITTARIUS (6-inch Takahashi FCT-150 apochromatic refractor at f/5, ten 5-minute exposures with a camera setting of ISO 800, taken July 1, 2003, from the New Mexico Skies astronomy resort). All images were taken in RAW mode and converted using Image Plus into 16-bit TIFF files. They were then calibrated, aligned, and adaptive combined, and the contrast was slightly increased using the digital development function in Image Plus. A mask was applied to the nebula region (to isolate it) and the contrast of the rest of the image was raised again using the background stretch function. This image was then combined with the original image to bring out more of the nebula without stretching the entire background. megapixels. The advantage goes to the digital camera with a factor of 2.7 times the imaging area. The cost of the 10D approximately a quarter that of a typical CCD camera also must be considered an advantage. Ease of use also tips toward THE BACK PANEL of the Canon 10D incorporates a large LCD screen and all the controls necessary to access the camera s wide variety of features. 86 astronomy /// september 04 the 10D. The raw images from both cameras need a significant amount of postprocessing in order to yield excellent final images. In most cases, the same processing software is used, so neither camera has an advantage in this case. Also a draw is the hookup factor how easy it is to attach each camera to the telescope. Most CCD camera heads are slightly lighter than the 10D body, but they also have cords connected to them. The 10D is a self-contained unit. Mounting the 10D on a telescope is easy because standard, commonly available camera adapters are used to couple the camera s body to the telescope s focuser. The major disadvantage of current digital cameras is their noise performance, which is poorer than that of CCD astrocameras. A CCD camera usually is cooled to as low as 30 C because the dark (electronic) noise in the chip declines by a factor of two for each 6 to 8 C drop in temperature. Digital cameras cannot easily be cooled below /// PRODUCT SPECS Canon 10D digital SLR Weight: 27.9 ounces (body only) Dimensions: 5.9 by 4.2 by 3.0 inches Monitor: 1.8-inch color LCD monitor Flash: Built-in Pixels: Approximately 6.3 megapixels (3,088 by 2,056) Price: $1,329 (street price) Contact information Canon U.S.A., Inc. One Canon Plaza Lake Success, NY 11042 [t] 516.328.5000 [w] www.usa.canon.com Mark Hanson is a committed digital astrophotographer who enjoys the challenges the hobby demands. R. A. Greiner is a retired professor of Electrical and Computer Engineering.
THE WHIRLPOOL GALAXY (M51) IN CANES VENATICI (12-inch Meade LX200 Schmidt-Cassegrain telescope at f/10, seven 2-minute exposures at ISO 400 plus seven 2-minute exposures at ISO 800 plus nine 2-minute exposures at ISO 1600, taken April 1, 2003, from the New Mexico Skies astronomy resort). In this image, author Mark Hanson first used Image Plus s color balance function to adjust the color and accentuate the dust lanes between the galaxies. Next, an adaptive smoothing slightly blurred the image. The background then was darkened using the background contrast function. Hanson also used dark line enhancement as well as a multi-resolution sharpening to reveal the dark lanes in the galaxies. 0 C because they are not designed for extreme cold. Auxiliary equipment required for using a digital camera is similar to that required for a CCD camera. For the 10D, Hanson has a right angle finder scope for coarse focusing and the Canon remote control timer accessory (TC80N3) for hands-off operation. The TC80N3 allows Hanson to take any number of exposures in sequence with any exposure time and any interval between exposures. For imaging, Hanson pairs his 10D to one of three telescopes: a 12-inch Meade LX200 Schmidt-Cassegrain telescope; a 4-inch Takahashi FSQ-106 refractor; or a 6-inch Takahashi FCT-150 refractor. The 3000mm focal length of the LX200 telescope is great for smaller deep-sky objects, and the Takahashi telescopes are perfect for wide-field imaging. Whatever telescope you choose, the Canon 10D will connect to it easily. You ll find the 10D easy to use, and the images you ll produce with it will delight you. X GALAXIES M81 AND M82 IN URSA MAJOR (6-inch Takahashi FCT-150 apochromatic refractor at f/7, twenty-one 4-minute exposures with a camera setting of ISO 1600, taken January 19, 2004, from the New Mexico Skies astronomy resort) www.astronomy.com 87
Keep your eyes on the sky and renew your ASTRONOMY subscription Don t break your link to the leading astronomy magazine on the market. Renew your subscription and continue to receive the insightful astronomical information that fills every issue: New-product listings Expert observing tips Field tests: telescopes, cameras, binoculars, eyepieces, accessories Monthly pullout star maps And exclusive online access to Star Atlas, Star Dome Plus, The Sky this Month, Ask Astro archives, videos, image galleries, product information, and more! RENEW TODAY! www.astronomy.com/asyrenew Plus, why not share your enthusiasm? It s easy to send someone a gift subscription today! Give a gift today at www.astronomy.com/asygift CIR-ADH-09X1241RH