Performance Analysis of Life Companies P a g e 1
P a g e 2 Performance Analysis of Life Companies in Bangladesh ( and Risk management: B-206) Submitted to: Mr. Md. Shahidul Islam Zahid Lecturer Department of Banking University of Dhaka Submitted by: Group 06 1. Md. Mezbaul Haider 16-030 2. Nazim Reza 16-011 3. Tauhidul Islam 16-071 4. Md. Mashroor Ali 16-031 5. Rafsan Mahtab 16-087 6. Jakir Hossain 16-048 7. Rezaur Rahman 16-040 8. Avijit Kumar Saha 16-039 9. Jamal Hossain Shuvo 16-050 10.Md. Mokbul Islam 16-038 16 th Batch Department of Banking University of Dhaka Date of Submission: 26 th October, 2011
P a g e 3 26 th October, 2011 To Mr. Md. Shahidul Islam Course Instructor and Risk Management Course Code: B-206 Department of Banking Faculty of business studies University of Dhaka, Bangladesh. Dear Sir, It gives us pleasure to submit the report on Performance Analysis of Life insurance Companies in Bangladesh. It was a fantastic opportunity for us to prepare the report under your guidance, which really was a great experience for us. We have worked hard and tried our best to prepare the report. But due to some limitations we failed to collect more accurate data. We will be very pleased to provide further information if necessary. Sincerely, Md. Mezbaul Haider (16-030) On behalf of the Group
P a g e 4 Acknowledgement To begin with, We would like to express our infinite gratitude towards Almighty Allah and our course teacher Mr. Md. Shahidul Islam, Lecturer, department of Banking, Faculty of Business Studies, University of Dhaka, to provide not only extremely well arranged guidelines to complete our report work but would also help us to confront problems in our future career. We would like to express our heartiest appreciation to our all classmates, who have been a constant support to us and have patiently helped us throughout our report. We wish to extend our thanks to the computer lab assistant and all the peers of the Department who made it possible to work comfortably even in tough times.
P a g e 5 Table of Contents SL Topic Pages 01 Executive Summary 05 02 Liquidity Measurement Ratios 06 03 Profitability Indicator Ratios 10 04 Debt Ratios 14 05 Operating Performance Ratio 17 06 Cash flow indicator Ratio 18 07 Investment Valuation Ratios 22
P a g e 6 08 Conclusion 31 Executive summary Ratio is a way of expressing the relationship between one accounting result and another, which is intended to provide a useful comparison. Ratios assist in measuring the efficiency and profitability of a company based on its financial reports. Accounting ratios form the basis of fundamental analysis. The ratios can be used to evaluate the financial condition of a company, including the company's strengths and weaknesses. Here our report is about Performance analysis of Life Companies. In this report different types of ratios are calculated and compared according to the standard norm, of eight pioneer and dominating life insurance companies in Bangladesh. For each company, ratios are demonstrated here in matrix structures with their results, for five years, for every ratio separately.
P a g e 7 Introduction: Various types of financial institutions exist in the economy of Bangladesh. Among these types insurance companies play a major role in our economy. These companies contribute a lot in the economy by diversifying risk among many people. There are two types of insurance companies- general insurance companies and life insurance companies. The subject matter of this report is to analyze the performance of the life insurance companies of Bangladesh. Life insurance companies bear the risk of peoples lives. There are eight listed life insurance companies in Bangladesh. Their performance has been analyzed by calculating various ratios for five years. The necessary information for this ratio analysis has been collected from their respective annual reports. Liquidity Measurement Ratios: 1. Current Ratio The current ratio is a popular financial ratio used to test a company's liquidity (also referred to as its current or working capital position) by deriving the proportion of current assets available to cover current liabilities. The concept behind this ratio is to ascertain whether a company's short-term assets such as cash, cash equivalents, marketable securities, receivables and inventory are readily available to pay off its short-term liabilities such as notes payable, current portion of term debt, payables, accrued expenses and taxes. In theory, the higher the current ratio, the better. Formula:
P a g e 8 The current ratios of the listed life insurance companies of Bangladesh are presented below- Name of Companies 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 Delta Life Co. Ltd. 4.02 : 1 3.06 : 1 5.75 : 1 4.45 : 1 7.89 : 1 Fareast Islami Life Co. Ltd. 3.79 : 1 2.88 : 1 4.92 : 1 6.69 : 1 7.95 : 1 Prime Life Co. Ltd. 2.56 : 1 4.12 : 1 3.57 : 1 5.49 : 1 6.68 : 1 Rupali Life Co. Ltd. 2.35 : 1 3.65 : 1 5.51 : 1 3.79 : 1 2.97 : 1 Pragati Life Co. Ltd. 2.46 : 1 4.29 : 1 5.46 : 1 3.76 : 1 5.97 : 1 Meghna Life Co. Ltd. 1.92 : 1 2.13 : 1 3.98 : 1 4.23 : 1 3.11 : 1 Progressive Life Co. Ltd. 3.84 : 1 5.18 : 1 4.63 : 1 6.06 : 1 5.37 : 1 Popular Life Co. Ltd. 2.95 : 1 4.01 : 1 5.23 : 1 5.62 : 1 5.21 : 1 Performance analysis: Considering the above calculations, the year wise performance analysis of these companies, on the basis of current ratios, have been described below- 2006: In 2006, the top three life insurance companies holding the best current ratio, in other words having the highest ability to pay off their short term liabilities are- 1. Delta Life company current ratio 4.02 : 1
P a g e 9 2. Fareast Islami Life Company current ratio 3.79 : 1 3. Popular Life Company current ratio 2.95 : 1 2007: The top three life insurance companies in respect of current ratio in 2007 are- 1. Progressive Life Co. Ltd. current ratio 5.18 : 1 2. Pragati Life Co. Ltd. current ratio 4.29 : 1 3. Prime Life Co. Ltd. current ratio 4.12 : 1 2008: The top three life insurance companies in 2008 are 1. Delta Life Co. Ltd. current ratio 5.75 : 1 2. Rupali Life Co. Ltd. current ratio 5.51 : 1 3. Pragati Life Co. Ltd. current ratio 5.46 : 1 2009: The three companies holding highest current ratio in 2009 are 1. Fareast Islami Life Co. Ltd. current ratio 6.69 : 1 2. Progressive Life Co. Ltd. current ratio 6.06 : 1 3. Popular Life Co. Ltd. current ratio 5.62 : 1 2010: The best three companies in respect of current ratio in 2010 are 1. Fareast Islami Life Co. Ltd. current ratio 7.95: 1 2. Delta Life Co. Ltd. current ratio 7.89: 1 3. Pragati Life Co. Ltd. current ratio 5.97: 1 1. Quick Ratio: The quick ratio also known as the acid-test ratio - is a liquidity indicator that further refines the current ratio by measuring the amount of the most liquid current assets there are to cover current liabilities. The quick ratio is more conservative than the current ratio because it excludes inventory and other current assets, which are more difficult to turn into cash. Therefore, a higher ratio means a more liquid current position. The quick ratio is a more conservative measure of liquidity than the current ratio as it removes inventory from the current assets used in the ratio's formula. By excluding inventory, the quick ratio focuses on the more-liquid assets of a company. The basics and use of this ratio are similar to the current ratio in that it gives users an idea of the ability of a company to meet its short-term liabilities with its short-term assets. Another beneficial use is to compare the quick ratio with the current ratio. If the current ratio is significantly higher, it is a clear indication that the company's current assets are dependent on inventory. Formula:
P a g e 10 The quick ratios of the listed life insurance companies of Bangladesh are presented below- Name of companies 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 Delta Life Co. Ltd. 2.55 : 1 3.1 : 1 4.08 : 1 2.77 : 1 5.67 : 1 Fareast Islami Life Co. Ltd. 2.48 : 1 2.56 : 1 4.58 : 1 5.91 : 1 7.22 : 1 Prime Life Co. Ltd. 2.09 : 1 3.74 : 1 3.05 : 1 4.37 : 1 4.32 : 1 Rupali Life Co. Ltd. 1.89 : 1 3.13 : 1 5.19 : 1 3.28 : 1 2.46 : 1 Pragati Life Co. Ltd. 1.95 : 1 3.81 : 1 4.94 : 1 3.31 : 1 5.40 : 1 Meghna Life Co. Ltd. 1.51 : 1 1.86 : 1 3.54 : 1 3.90 : 1 2.79 : 1 Progressive Life Co. Ltd. 3.49 : 1 4.03 : 1 3.60 : 1 4.68 : 1 5.01 : 1 Popular Life Co. Ltd. 2.21 : 1 3.63 : 1 4.57 : 1 5.09 : 1 4.76 : 1 Performance analysis:
P a g e 11 Considering the above calculations, the year wise performance analysis of these companies, on the basis of quick ratios, have been described below- 2006: In 2006, the top three life insurance companies holding the best quick ratio arei. Progressive Life company quick ratio 3.49 : 1 ii. Delta Life Company quick ratio 2.55 : 1 iii. Fareast Islami Life Company quick ratio 2.48 : 1 2007: The top three life insurance companies in respect of quick ratio in 2007 arei. Progressive Life Co. Ltd. quick ratio 4.03 : 1 ii. Pragati Life Co. Ltd. quick ratio 3.81 : 1 iii. Prime Life Co. Ltd. quick ratio 3.74 : 1 2008: The top three life insurance companies in 2008 are i. Rupali Life Co. Ltd. quick ratio 5.19 : 1 ii. Pragati Life Co. Ltd. quick ratio 4.94 : 1 iii. Fareast Islami Life Co. Ltd. quick ratio 4.58 : 1 2009: The three companies holding highest quick ratio in 2009 are i. Fareast Islami Life Co. Ltd. quick ratio 5.91 : 1 ii. Popular Life Co. Ltd. quick ratio 5.09 : 1 iii. Progressive Life Co. Ltd. quick 4.68 : 1 2010: The best three companies in respect of quick ratio in 2010 are i. Fareast Islami Life Co. Ltd. quick ratio 7.22 : 1 ii. Delta Life Co. Ltd. quick ratio 5.67 : 1 iii. Pragati Life Co. Ltd. quick ratio 5.40: 1 1. Cash Ratio: Cash ratio is the ratio of cash and cash equivalents of a company to its current liabilities. It is an extreme liquidity ratio since only cash and cash equivalents are compared with the current liabilities. It measures the ability of a business to repay its current liabilities by only using its cash and cash equivalents and nothing else. Its standard value is 1:1 or above but not very high. Cash Ratio: = Cash+Cash EquivalentsCurrent Liabilities Calculation (%): 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
P a g e 12 Delta Life Company 325.83 426.02 489.36 553.473 1356.79 Meghna Life 709.26 692.74 687.29 688.08 673.31 Pragati Life 387.89 379.11 381.43 364.00 333.65 Progressive Life 235.81 271.00 346.01 396.32 426.24 Fareast Islami Life 316.46 319.72 326.25 323.96 328.71 Popular Life 462.37 478.81 473.98 476.03 479.36 Prime Islami Life 381.44 406.76 413.63 406.31 411.92 Inference: As we can see here all of the companies have high cash ratio. In case of Meghna Life Company it is most. They have cash ratio of around 7:1. This means to satisfy of one taka current liabilities they have seven taka of cash or cash equivalent. Popular Life insurance has also high cash ratio. But this kind of very high ration indicates that the firms have not invested in long term fields of earning and so they have lower return from their cash. But as an insurance company it also necessary to hold enough cash or cash equivalent so that they can meet the insurance claims quickly. Profitability Indicator Ratio: 1. Return on Equity (ROE): Return on equity or return on capital is the ratio of net income of a business during a year to its stockholders' equity during that year. It is a measure of profitability of stockholders' investments. It shows net income as percentage of shareholder equity. The higher the ratio is the better the firm is. ROE= Net Income Avg Shareholders'euity
P a g e 13 Calculation (%): 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 38.78 34.14 34.679 39.23 33.91 Delta Life Company 34.02 39.36 48.24 47.21 48.78 Meghna Life 21.48 32.00 47.23 42.37 46.93 Pragati Life 29.38 32.26 38.20 38.86 37.21 Progressive Life 37.46 40.37 38.09 41.67 38.21 Fareast Islami Life 38.12 37.25 38.38 39.95 43.29 Popular Life 26.39 29.78 29.34 31.89 37.82 Prime Islami Life Inference: Here almost all of the firms have good ROE. Specially Meghna Life Company has the best one. Last three years they have maintain a good level of ROE. Progressive, Pragati and Prime Islami Life insurance have ROEs that fluctuate over years. But overall all of the firms have healthy ROE that indicates a good return from the share investment in these firms. 2. The Return on Capital Employed (ROCE): The Return On Capital Employed (ROCE) ratio, expressed as a percentage, complements the return On Equity (ROE) ratio by adding a company's debt liabilities, or funded debt, to equity to reflect a
P a g e 14 company's total "capital employed". This measure narrows the focus to gain a better understanding of a company's ability to generate returns from its available capital base. By comparing net income to the sum of a company's debt and equity capital, investors can get a clear picture of how the use of leverage impacts a company's profitability. Financial analysts consider the ROCE measurement to be a more comprehensive profitability indicator because it gauges management's ability to generate earnings from a company's total pool of capital. Calculation (%): Company s name 2006 % 2007 % 2008 % 2009 % 2010 % Delta Life Company 19.8 18.14 17.2 17.8 21.4 Fareast Islami Life 17.11 16.21 19.8 20.12 18.25 Meghna Life 20.23 21.22 18.25 19.19 20.8 Popular Life 21.3 20.21 19.2 17.24 21.24 Pragati Life 17.29 15.26 18.24 15.63 16.8 Prime Islami Life 16.26 17.24 15.55 15.25 19.24 Progressive Life 19.25 17.24 16.55 16.45 18.56 Rupali Life 18.25 17.23 17.65 16.36 18.45 In 2006: In 2006 Popular life has higher ROCE it indicate that in this year they are dominating sector for capital Employed activities. In 2007: In 2007 Meghna Life has higher ROCE it indicate that in this year they are dominating sector for capital Employed activities. In 2008: In 2008 Fareast Islami Life has higher ROCE it indicate that in this year they are dominating sector for capital Employed activities. In 2009: In 2009 Fareast Islami Life has higher ROCE it indicate that in this year they are dominating sector for capital Employed activities. In 2010:
P a g e 15 In 20010 Delta Life Company has higher ROCE it indicate that in this year they are dominating sector for capital Employed activities. 3. Return on Asset (ROA): This ratio indicates how profitable a company is relative to its total assets. The Return On Asset (ROA) ratio illustrates how well management is employing the company's total assets to make a profit. The higher the return, the more efficient management is in utilizing its asset base. The ROA ratio is calculated by comparing net income to average total assets, and is expressed as a percentage. Calculation: Company s Name 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 Delta Life Company 12.8 12.98 13.25 12.75 14.23 Fareast Islami Life 13.25 14.50 13.85 12.96 16.32 Meghna Life 11.25 12.56 15.85 13.63 14.56 Popular Life 12.63 13.54 13.49 14.29 15.32 Pragati Life 13.52 14.52 15.22 14.80 15.88 Prime Islami Life 14.20 13.20 14.45 17.51 16.21 Progressive Life 12.42 12.39. 13.63 14.62 16.46 Rupali Life 11.52 12.36 14.52 12.33 17.81 In 2006: In 2006 Prime Islami Life has higher ROA it indicate that in this year they are the most successful life insurance company in their operating activities. In 2007: In 2007 Pragati Life has higher ROA it indicate that in this year they are the most successful life insurance company in their operating activities. In 2008: In 2008 Meghna Life has higher ROA it indicate that in this year they are the most successful life insurance company in their operating activities. In 2009:
P a g e 16 In 2009 Prime Islami Life has higher ROA it indicate that in this year they are the most successful life insurance company in their operating activities. In 2010: In 2010 Rupali Life has higher ROA it indicate that in this year they are the most successful life insurance company in their operating activities. 4. Earnings per Share EPS The portion of a company's profit allocated to each outstanding share of common stock. Earnings per share serve as an indicator of a company's profitability. Calculated as: When calculating, it is more accurate to use a weighted average number of shares outstanding over the reporting term, because the number of shares outstanding can change over time. However, data sources sometimes simplify the calculation by using the number of shares outstanding at the end of the period. Earnings per share is generally considered to be the single most important variable in determining a share's price. It is also a major component used to calculate the price-to-earnings valuation ratio. For example, assume that a company has a net income of $25 million. If the company pays out $1 million in preferred dividends and has 10 million shares for half of the year and 15 million shares for the other half, the EPS would be $1.92 (24/12.5). First, the $1 million is deducted from the net income to get $24 million, then a weighted average is taken to find the number of shares outstanding (0.5 x 10M+ 0.5 x 15M = 12.5M). An important aspect of EPS that's often ignored is the capital that is required to generate the earnings (net income) in the calculation. Two companies could generate the same EPS number, but one could do so with less equity (investment) - that company would be more efficient at using its capital to generate income and, all other things being equal, would be a "better" company. Investors also need to be aware of earnings manipulation that will affect the quality of the earnings number. Earnings per Share EPS (Ratio) Company Name 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 Delta Life Company 11506.43 14197.90 15478.74 17514.78 18289.78 Fareast Islami Life Company 1702.67 2753.80 2951.45 3145.74 3374.27
P a g e 17 Meghna Life Company 1773.57 2640.42 4604.61 6067.10 7451.47 Popular Life Company 834.30 2255.65 3452.12 4289.94 6124.61 Pragati Life Company 730 1173 3214 5142 6410 Prime Islami Life Company 1482.20 2688.45 3142.11 4120.45 5210.78 Progressive Life Company 316 567.28 1200 1445.12 2247.12 Rupali Life Company 413.14 532.42 652.74 631.32 720.11 As calculated Earning Per Share we can say that the Delta Life Company has the highest EPS of all of the company this Ratio indicate that their financial strength is more stronger than other companies. Debt Ratios 1. Debt-equity ratio The debt-equity ratio is another leverage ratio that compares a company's total liabilities to its total shareholders' equity. This is a measurement of how much suppliers, lenders, creditors and obligors have committed to the company versus what the shareholders have committed. To a large degree, the debt-equity ratio provides another vantage point on a company's leverage position, in this case, comparing total liabilities to shareholders' equity, as opposed to total assets in the debt ratio. Similar to the debt ratio, a lower the percentage means that a company is using less leverage and has a stronger equity position. Formula: Variations: A conservative variation of this ratio, which is seldom seen, involves reducing a company's equity position by its intangible assets to arrive at a tangible equity, or tangible net worth, figure. Companies with a large amount of purchased goodwill form heavy acquisition activity can end up with a negative equity position.
P a g e 18 Commentary: The debt-equity ratio appears frequently in investment literature. However, like the debt ratio, this ratio is not a pure measurement of a company's debt because it includes operational liabilities in total liabilities. Nevertheless, this easy-to-calculate ratio provides a general indication of a company's equity-liability relationship and is helpful to investors looking for a quick take on a company's leverage. Generally, large, well-established companies can push the liability component of their balance sheet structure to higher percentages without getting into trouble. The debt-equity ratio percentage provides a much more dramatic perspective on a company's leverage position than the debt ratio percentage. For example, IBM's debt ratio of 69% seems less onerous than its debt-equity ratio of 220%, which means that creditors have more than twice as much money in the company than equity holders (both ratios are for FY 2005). Debt-Equity Ratio Company Name 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 Delta Life Company 1050.11 1313.96 1627.13 1821.12 1912.41 Fareast Islami Life Company 145.40 227.62 312.41 472.12 825.14 Meghna Life Company 141.47 218.73 345.14 412.81 512.01 Popular Life Company 55.96 140.60 279.59 312.45 421.78 Pragati Life Company 286.53 99.87 251.12 421.12 478.81 Prime Islami Life Company 90.35 641.25 312.45 712.78 825.14 Progressive Life Company 42.95 5.33 31.45 124.12 210.71 Rupali Life Company 85.12 105.81 251.12 312.10 213.11 After calculating Debt Equity Ratio of Eight company we reach a decision that among the company Progressive life Company has less Debt-equity ratio that indicate they used less leverage and has a stronger equity position. 2. Debt ratio: Debt Ratio is a financial ratio that indicates the percentage of a company's assets that are provided via debt. It is the ratio of total debt (the sum of current liabilities and long-term liabilities) and total assets (the sum of current assets, fixed assets, and other assets such as 'goodwill'). A low percentage means that
P a g e 19 the company is less dependent on leverage, i.e., money borrowed from and/or owed to others. The lower the percentage, the less leverage a company is using and the stronger its equity position. In general, the higher the ratio, the more risk that company is considered to have taken on Debt ratio of six life insurance company for the year 2006 to 2010 : Company 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 Popular 14% 13% 11.5% 9% 8.5% Meghna 17% 14% 11% 9% 8% Pragati 18% 10% 9% 8.5% 7% Prime Islamic 12% 10% 8.5% 8% 7% Progressive 13% 9% 8% 7% 6.5% Delta 16% 14% 10% 9% 8% Fareast Islamic 11% 10% 9.5% 8% 7.5% 3. Cash flow to debt ratio: This ratio provides an indication of a company's ability to cover total debt with its yearly cash flow from operations. An increasing Cash Flow to Total Debt ratio is usually a positive sign, showing the company is in a less risky financial position and better able to pay its debt load. Cash flow to debt ratio of six life insurance companies for the year 2006 to 2010 Company 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 Popular 65% 72% 70% 52% 75% Meghna 62% 55% 43% 7o% 54% Progoti 45% 60% 48% 72% 56% Prime Islamic 58% 47% 63% 71% 61% Progressive 47% 62% 55% 69% 67% Fareast Islamic 53% 49% 65% 49% 70% 4. Capitalization Ratio: Capitalization ratios, also known as financial leverage ratios, are used to determine a company s stability by comparing its long-term debt with its current equity and assets. A capitalization ratio provides investors and analysts with information about the extent to which a company is using its equity to finance
P a g e 20 its operational costs, and to what extent it is incurring new debt to do so. Capitalization ratios provide an indication of the company s solvency and viability over the long term and allow more accurate risk assessments for prospective investors. Typically, a company s capitalization ratio is calculated by dividing the company s long-term debt by the sum of the long-term debt and the shareholders equity, as follows: Calculation: Company 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 Popular 90.16% 85.41% 89.65% 91.26% 95.90% Meghna 96.26% 94.03% 52.47% 97.36% 97.26% Pragati 85.47% 79.47% 87.72% 92.77% 94.82% Prime Islamic 74.72% 83.26% 87.30% 87.61% 93.59% Progressive 96.07% 67.99% 78.50% 92.04% 94.47% Delta 99.85% 99.83% 99.97% 99.99% 99.99% Fareast Islamic 95.75% 62.44% 68.07% 94.81% 95.47% Operating Performance Ratio: 1. The fixed asset turnover ratio: The fixed asset turnover ratio measures the company's effectiveness in generating sales from its investments in plant, property, and equipment. This ratio is often used as a measure in manufacturing industries, where major purchases are made for PP&E to help increase output. When companies make these large purchases, prudent investors watch this ratio in following years to see how effective the investment in the fixed assets was. Here is how the fixed asset turnover ratio is calculated:
P a g e 21 There is no exact number that determines whether a company is doing a good job of generating revenue from its investment in fixed assets. This makes it important to compare the most recent ratio to both the historical levels of the company along with peer company and/or industry averages. Before putting too much weight into this ratio, it's important to determine the type of company that you are using the ratio on because a company's investment in fixed assets is very much linked to the requirements of the industry in which it conducts its business. Fixed assets vary greatly among companies. For example, an internet company, like Google, has less of a fixed-asset base than a heavy manufacturer like Caterpillar. Obviously, the fixed-asset ratio for Google will have less relevance than that for Caterpillar. Calculation: Company 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 Popular 10.92 14.17 17.78 15.59 17.26 Meghna 0.18 1.13 18.91 19.36 19.47 Pragati 16.93 17.50 20.89 11.20 13.25 Prime Islamic 3.80 6.83 12.25 15.29 19.21 Progressive 8.94 28.24 19.36 18.90 24.52 Delta 7.05 7.77 9.11 10.74 12.68 Fareast Islamic 7.64 9.57 8.04 8.23 7.84 Cash flow indicator Ratio: 1. Operating Cash Flow/Sales Ratio: OFC/Sales ratio is the ratio of operating cash flow of a company to its sales revenue. It is expressed in percentage that shows the ability to convert sales into cash. This Ratio will show up the Positive and negative changes in a company's terms of sale and/or the collection experience of its accounts receivable. It gives investors an idea of the company's ability to turn sales into cash. It is an important indicator of its creditworthiness and productivity.
P a g e 22 OFC/Sales Ratio: = Operating Cash FlowNet Sales/Revenue Calculation (%): 2006(%) 2007(%) 2008(%) 2009(%) 2010(%) Delta Life Company 10.91 11.64 11.02 11.12 10.03 Meghna Life 18.63 14.25 16.23 20.41 17.24 Pragati Life 8.36 9.25 11.27 12.94 9.88 Progressive Life 11.58 12.96 9.27 11.29 10.64 Fareast Islami Life 21.87 23.17 18.69 25.46 28.72 Popular Life 27.21 31.24 27.54 29.01 29.30 Prime Islami Life 17.26 22.79 20.67 23.14 21.78 Inference: As we can see here all of the companies have high OFC ratio. In case of Popular Life Company it is most. This indicates its creditworthiness and productivity. Farest Life insurance has also high cash ratio. As insurance company it very necessary to acquire higher OFC/Sales Ratio. 2. Dividend Payout Ratio: This ratio identifies the percentage of earnings (net income) per common share allocated to paying cash dividends to shareholders. This ratio is an indicator of how well earnings support the dividend payment. Lower this percentage, more secure the dividend payment. A normal range for companies that do pay dividends is 25% to 50% of earnings. But the percentage may vary if a company keeps the amount of its dividend consistent with past dividends regardless of a drop in its earnings. Dividend Payout Ratio = Dividend Per Common ShareEarning Per Share
P a g e 23 Calculation (%): 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 Delta Life Company 36.12 24.31 30.14 35.12 30.58 Meghna Life 41.21 47.2 41.3 38.9 40.38 Pragati Life 26.1 21.35 26.14 29.87 25.12 Progressive Life 39.8 36.10 28.94 31.8 36.14 Fareast Islami Life 45.20 40.9 40.41 30.14 32.54 Popular Life 24.8 20.1 29.1 34.85 39.23 Prime Islami Life 25.36 27.1 36.24 20.14 21.4 Inference: Here almost all of the firms have good Dividend Payout ratio. Specially Meghna Life Company has the best one. Fast three years they have maintain a good level of Dividend payout ratio. Progressive, Delta and Fareast Islami Life insurance have a good Dividend payout ratio that fluctuates over years. But overall all of the firms have healthy Dividend payout ratio that indicates the companies have well earnings support the dividend payment among. 3. Short term debt coverage ratio: This ratio measures the ability of the company's operating cash flow to meet its obligations short term debt. It is one of the operating cash flow coverage ratios. The operating cash flow is simply the amount of cash generated by the company from its main operations, which are used to keep the business funded. The larger the operating cash flow coverage for these items, the greater the company's ability to meet its obligations, along with giving the company more cash flow to expand its business, withstand hard times, and not be burdened by debt servicing and the restrictions typically included in credit agreements.
P a g e 24 Formula: The short term debt ratio shows how adept the firm is to meet the short term obligations. If it has a large shot term debt ratio it means it can easily pay the short term debt using the cash which is generated through its operating activities. Short term debt coverage in Life Company: The short term debt coverage of five years in eight reputable life insurance companies in Bangladesh is given in the next chart. The more the ratio, the better is for the firm.
P a g e 25 Year (Short term debt coverage) Name of insurance company 2010 2009 2008 2007 2006 Delta life insurance 1.4 1.2 1.2 1.9 Fareast islami life insurance 2.1 2.2 1.7 2.1 2.2 Meghna life insurance 2.3 2.3 2.7 1.7 1.8 Popular life insurance 1 2 1.7 1.6 1.3 Pragati life insurance 1.5 1.8 1.2-1 1.1 Prime islami life insurance 1 1.6 2.2 1.6 1.5 Progressive life insurance 1.9 1.5 1.5 2.5 Rupali life insurance 1.5 1.1 1.7 1.3 1.1
P a g e 26 Investment Valuation Ratios 1. Price/Cash Flow Ratio The price/cash flow ratio is used by investors to evaluate the investment attractiveness, from a value standpoint, of a company's stock. This ratio compares the stock's market price to the amount of cash flow the company generates on a per-share basis. It is similar to P/E ratio Formula: Operating cash flow per share: A value calculated by dividing a firm s operating cash flow (minus dividends) by the number of shares of the capital stock that are outstanding.. Price to cash flow ratio in Life Company: The price cash flow ratio of five years in eight reputable life insurance companies in Bangladesh is given in the next chart. For life insurance Company the operating income is high because they have a larger premium money but sometimes the claim are not much high, so the ratio may be very tiny, but sometimes they may have some adverse situation.
P a g e 27
P a g e 28 Year (Price cash flow ratio) Name of insurance company 2010 2009 2008 2007 2006 Delta life insurance.04.04.05.06.08 Fareast islami life insurance.1.17.39.22.23 Meghna life insurance.24.27.28 0.7 1.03 Popular life insurance.27.48.58.91.75 Pragati life insurance.34.36.36-4.8.49 Prime islami life insurance 2.32 2.13 2.19 2.26 2.79 Progressive life insurance 1.97 2.45 1.77 3.16 1.17 Rupali life insurance 1.2 1.98 1.46 1.45 1.95
P a g e 29 2. Price to earnings ratio: The price/earnings ratio (P/E) is the best known of the investment valuation indicators. The P/E ratio has its imperfections, but it is nevertheless the most widely reported and used valuation by investment professionals and the investing public. P/E ratio is an off- quoted measure of the ratio of the market price of each share of common stock to the earnings per share. The price-earnings (P/E) ratio reflects the investors assessments of a company s future earnings. The industry average of P/E ratio is about 26 times in abroad market place. Here, throughout this report it was our endeavor to assess the investors investing decision. From 2006 to 2010 we represented the total 5 years P/E ratio of 8 insurance firm. Formula: Price to Earnings Ratio (Times) Year Wise comparison Company 2010 2009 2008 2007 2006 Delta 0.068 0.045 0.034 0.047 0.047 Fareast 0.038 0.052 0.039 0.044 0.036 Meghna 0.022 0.023 0.058 0.053 0.032 Popular 0.039 0.087 0.10 0.12 0.093 Pragati 0.049 0.071 0.094 0.062 0.053
P a g e 30 Prime 0.068 0.14 0.059 0.064 0.113 Progressive 0.271 0.470 0.541 0.624 0.470 Rupali 0.072 0.065 0.051 0.042 0.038 Inferences: A stock with a high P/E ratio suggests that investors are expecting higher earnings growth in the future compared to the overall market, as investors are paying more for today's earnings in anticipation of future earnings growth. Hence, as a generalization, stocks with this characteristic are considered to be growth stocks. Conversely, a stock with a low P/E ratio suggests that investors have more modest expectations for its future growth compared to the market as a whole. So, we can asses Progressive life insurance is expecting higher earnings compared the overall market among 8 insurance firm. Rupali life insurance is also expecting a growth over the years and therefore, the investors are paying more of their earnings today for future earnings growth. 3. Price to sales ratio A stock's price/sales ratio (P/S ratio) is another stock valuation indicator similar to the P/E ratio. The P/S ratio measures the price of a company's stock against its annual sales, instead of earnings. Like the P/E ratio, the P/S reflects how many times investors are paying for every dollar of a company's sales. Since earnings are subject, to one degree or another, to accounting estimates and management manipulation, many investors consider a company's sales (revenue) figure a more reliable ratio component in calculating a stock's price multiple than the earnings figure. Price to sales ratio tends to focus on the annual sales of a firm considering the each stock price. As we selected some insurance firm net premium is consider as the annual sales, in fact the annual sales of policies. The formula for the price to sakes ratio is given below. Formula:
P a g e 31 Price to Sales Ratio (times) Year Wise comparison Company 2010 2009 2008 2007 2006 Delta 1.444 1.686 2.01 2.277 2.521 Fareast 5.206 6.742 3.966 4.752 5.807 Meghna 4.531 4.061 7.022 6.323 5.485 Popular 3.333 5.491 4.827 3.378 5.999 Pragati 6.62 10.33 5.623 6.395 4.821 Prime 5.335 8.749 6.671 5.467 6.692 Progressive 15.82 22.15 18.762 19.018 12.85 Rupali 7.897 6.526 5.983 5.983 9.184
P a g e 32 Inferences: From the ratio table we can derive that the investors of the respective firms would expect the stock price to be timed at their sales holding. Moreover we can say that Progressive life insurance would pay a higher amount of stock to hold their annual sales. But researchers conclude that "low priceto-sales ratios beat the market more than any other value ratio, and do so more consistently. So above analysis infer that Delta life insurance is in a good position in terms of sales to price (P/S) ratio. In addition Fareast and Meghna life insurance also pay low portion for every Tk. to hold the annual sales. 4. Dividend Yield Ratio: A financial ratio that shows how much a company pays out in dividends each year relative to its share price. It s calculated by dividing the Annual Dividend paid by Stock Market Price per Share Outstanding. In the absence of any capital gains, the dividend yield is the return on investment for a stock. Dividend yield is calculated as follows: Dividend Yield=Annual Dividends Per SharePrice Per Share The Ratio enables an investor to choose high growth potential stocks by screening the ratio percentage. Higher percentage suggests fast growth, and lower percentage suggests slow growth or, in some case, greater retained earnings. Ratio Analysis Matrix (in decimal): Below presented is the Matrix for Dividend Yield Ratio Analysis for the 7 chosen companies for the last 5 years. 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
P a g e 33 Delta Life 0.1379 0.106338 0.1314138 0.110688 0.1269841 0.1256281 Company 62 21 82 84 27 41 Fareast Islami Life 1.5709 1.650625 1.6474926 1.099324 0.8516414 0.7222222 6 85 25 98 14 22 Meghna Life 0.0514 0.091642 0.0694976 0.066328 0.0774516 0.1269956 75 21 98 23 87 46 Popular Life 0.0016 0.003296 0 0.041455 0 0.0510204 96 7 55 08 Pragati Life 0.0030 0.003536 0 0.003113 0.0039492 0.0030381 72 65 26 75 43 Prime Islami Life 0 0 0.3715926 0.250025 0.3325108 0.3688300 39 02 15 22 Progressive Life 0.0519 0.042562 0.0701786 0.049048 0.0458214 0.0595050 71 79 7 15 62 03 Calculations: Calculations are done by first finding the Annual Dividend per Share and then dividing them by the market price per share. Annual Dividend paid by Companies as per their yearly Financial Statements
P a g e 34 Annual Dividends Per Share 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 Delta Life Company 44.14798 21 46.044444 44 51.12 46.6 48 50 Fareast Islami Life 157.096 161.76133 33 186.16666 7 134.11764 71 149.8888889 130 Meghna Life 7.978666 67 12.554982 24 12.996069 6 13.132989 62 15.49033733 26.92307 692 Popular Life 0.19 0.4384615 38 0 6.9230769 23 0 10 Pragati Life 0.50375 0.5446444 44 0 0.5479333 33 0.726666667 0.610666 667 Prime Islami Life 0 0 49.421821 40.754077 79 47.21653569 55.69333 333 Progressive Life 3.9498 4.1711538 46 8.5617977 5 7.0138857 14 7.148148148 12.55555 556 Market Price per Share as per DSE Index
P a g e 35 Market Price Per Share 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 Delta Life Company 320 433 389 421 378 398 Fareast Islami Life 100 98 113 122 176 180 Meghna Life 155 137 187 198 200 212 Popular Life 112 133 156 167 185 196 Pragati Life 164 154 123 176 184 201 Prime Islami Life 96 123 133 163 142 151 Progressive Life 76 98 122 143 156 211 Figure: Graph Showing the Dividend Yield Ratios.
P a g e 36 Inference: As can be seen here most of the company has a Dividend Yield of more than 0.10 or 10%. Fareast Life Company offers the highest Dividend as compared to others. On the other hand Pragati Life Company has the lowest of them all, but further analysis reveals that Prime Islami Life has more inconsistent Dividend payment, giving out no dividend two years in a row. The explosive investors looking for higher cash dividends are suggested to invest in Fareast Life, while more reserved and growth focused investors are suggested to invest in Pragati Life, as they project more retained earning thus a potential quick growth.
P a g e 37 5. Price to Book Value Ratio: A ratio used to compare a stock's market value to its book value. It compares a company s Market Value to its actual Book Value. It shows if the shares are under or overvalued. It can also suggest an investor about the residuals that can be retrieved if the firm goes bankrupt immediately. It can be calculated in two ways both giving out the same result. One way is by dividing the current closing price of the stock by the latest quarter's book value per share. Another unconventional way is to divide the Total Market Capitalization Amount by the Total book value for a given year. As for the convenience of the latter procedures we have decided to work on that framework. The formula for the calculation is as follows: Price to Book Value =Market CapitalizationTotal Book Value Ratio Analysis Matrix (in decimals): Below presented is the Price to Book Value Ratio Analysis Matrix of the 7 chosen companies for the last 5 years. 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 Delta Life Company 0.6268 46 2.571948 61 2.680071 519 2.097864 07 1.803560 195 1.688347 068 Fareast Islami Life 2.1738 92 3.776488 3 3.971363 434 3.777152 57 3.733694 542 2.813062 948 Meghna Life 1.0786 75 0.702219 34 0.520302 408 1.103776 93 0.676148 188 0.851774 783 Popular Life 1.2270 13 1.280695 21 11.22615 135 2.397110 65 2.030823 926 1.248485 811 Pragati Life 0.8838 28 1.640321 07 1.948828 161 2.481615 07 2.710268 231 2.673749 613
P a g e 38 Prime Islami Life 0.8749 72 1.050040 29 1.126203 526 1.064539 65 0.593870 692 0.932943 134 Progressive Life 1.0719 58 1.554154 61 0.108193 512 0.956329 95 1.033170 678 0.867020 116 Calculation (in decimal): The calculation requires collecting the market Capitalization Amount and dividing them by the Total Book Value of the firm. Book Value Calculations: Total Assets Intangible Assets Total Liabilities Market Capitalization Rate as per respective companies websites Market Capitalization 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 Delta Life Company 1347282 560 8731384 980 9342560 030 10358047 500 10347648 300 11545420 000
P a g e 39 Fareast Islami Life 1268453 200 2456366 890 3587958 000 44674896 00 56783426 88 69278699 60 Meghna Life 7328561 68 6839246 00 9857326 00 43689126 70 32975628 00 47934520 00 Popular Life 3286506 0 5489700 0 6589560 00 15684987 00 19766522 46 25056748 65 Pragati Life 1107654 320 2349865 400 3007623 870 43287432 00 53214870 00 63498540 00 Prime Islami Life 8736217 5 1327648 79 1743223 86 17634987 7 14387653 4 43721764 9 Progressive Life 1563487 90 2546846 00 3268900 00 32789247 0 47342980 0 56731168 9 Total Book Value calculated by the formula: Total Book Value= Total Assets Intangible Assets Total Liabilities Total Book Value 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 Delta Life Company 2149304 560 3394852 040 3485936 835 4937425 469 5737345 683 6838297 776 Fareast Islami Life 5834942 50 6504367 80 9034574 80 1182766 520 1520837 504 2462749 710
P a g e 40 Meghna Life 6794038 70 9739472 60 1894537 840 3958148 204 4876982 380 5627604 970 Popular Life 2678460 0 4286500 0 5869830 0 6543288 70 9733252 70 2006971 038 Pragati Life 1253246 200 1432564 300 1543298 650 1744325 000 1963454 000 2374887 300 Prime Islami Life 9984562 5 1264378 90 1547876 40 1656583 46 2422691 27 4686434 07 Progressive Life 1458534 00 1638734 00 3021345 689 3428654 20 4582300 00 6543235 60 Figure: Graph Showing Price to Book Value Ratios.
P a g e 41 Inference: The above calculation suggests that all of the company has a fair Price/Book Value. That means the firms have a good ground to justify the market price they hold. Fareast Life Co. stocks are perhaps overvalued in a minor extent. Meghna Life Ratio Analysis suggests their stocks are undervalued, management of the company can be suggested to look for internal instability that can be attributed to such an undervaluation. But overall all of the company has strong ground to assure their shareholder of the rationale of their market price. Conclusion: After the twenty financial ratio analyses, we have seen that there is a good balance among the firms. Most of the firms have good ratio figure. In case of liquidity measurement ratios all of the firms have very high figure. This means they retain much cash than need. This reduces the ability of the firm of earning. In case of profitability indicator ratios all of the firms have healthy figure. This means all of the firms have high net income. Firms have good debt indicator ratios. On the other hand in case of cash flow indicator ratios all of the firms have adequate good figure which refers that all of the firms generate enough cash for their activity. Last of all in case of investment valuation ratios all of the firms have strong ratios. This indicates that all of firms offer very good amount of divided to their equity holders as well as the firms work on the maximization of equity holders interest in the firms.