Lohnt sich Computing? Überreicht durch die WiB Solutions AG Identity Management Business Process Management Qualitäts Management WiB BRINGT THEMEN AUF DEN PUNKT. W W W. W I B. CH WiB Solutions AG, Aarburgerstrasse 7, CH-4600 Olten +41 62 297 12 10
A closer look at the cloud computing business case A SCIENTIFIC METHODOLOGY FOR EVALUATION Daniel Kappeler Danillo Sprovieri Sandro Vogler
Agenda Computing Business Case 2 Introduction to Services Risks assessment, Value analysis & : Calculating the Business Case Conclusion
3 Welcome to the cloud salesroom AN INTRODUCTION
What Providers are promising 4 Reduce capital costs / pay-as-you-go Minimize software licensing Reduce IT risks Reduce spending on technology infrastructure Globalize your workforce on the cheap Streamline processes Monitor projects more effectively Less staff training is needed Achieve economy of scale
and what they are not telling you 5 Adoption of cloud computing often requires a transformation process Exception: Startups Advantages of could are not straightforward Companies have large investments in infrastructure, software and maintenance systems processes are costly Cost advantage of could solutions is not always given Due to the fact that it is not clear if a cloud service is financially beneficial, a method is needed to evaluate the opportunity.
6 Methods? Cost-benefit equation is different in each case Business Case Pilot study Pilot study Expensive to set up Only one solution is evaluated Return on Investment Total Cost of Ownership Time consuming For startups cloud solutions can be a business opportunity The calculation is simpler and mainly focusing on running costs
7 METHODOLOGY FOR CLOUD SERVICES
8 Business Case - Definition A scenario for the evaluation of an investment To convince the management of an investment, clear Return of Value need to been shown Analyses costs and benefits of certain investment options Also, risks and strategy of the company do have an influence on the investment Financial values are defined and compared over a certain period of time Risks Investment Options Cost Benefit
Problem Awareness Uncertainty if current solution is most competitive 9 Business Case Possible Solution transformation Analysis and Alignment Risk assessment Value analysis Business Case ROI and KPI Assessment Criteria Cost Key Criteria ROI and KPI
10 WHAT THE CHANGE MEANS
11 Solutions do not immediately reduce costs Cost advantages of cloud transformation by Increased HW and SW utilization Reduced facility costs Reduced labor costs Inherent effects of outsourcing Scaling and elasticity Reduced time-to-value Reduced risks
12 (2) Existing resources (hardware, infrastructure, employees) need to be adapted to new situation Shift of resources Bound resources prevent shifting Consequence: Repurpose or pull out Transition costs are dependent on transition time Depends on contracts for software, workforce, buildings E.g. need to sell building
13 Risks assessment, Value analysis &
14 Computing Risks Loss of governance Individual support usually too expensive Data security Loss of operational expertise Lock-in Dependency on external provider Interoperability Availability issues Compliance with regulatory and security standards Data recovery No exit strategy defined Technical issues (e.g. Firewall needed) SLAs (ensures Quality of service)
Generated Business Values 15 Cost that can be permanently reduced E.g. repurposed facilities, re-trained workforce Savings due to increased utilization Costs that can be avoided E.g. live meetings due to ubiquitous information access
Generated Business Values (2) 16 But often, impacts are difficult to quantify Increased efficiency due to knowledge sharing E.g. Employee happiness Easier global collaboration Widespread framework is missing Quantification heavily based on assumptions Possible approach: Integrate a productivity model in the cost model Further value: mini-meetings get protocolled can be reused, referenced, etc. gathered data might reveal problems when analyzed Scalability (on demand allocation of resources) Enabler for business agility can add value for business and customer Gaining competitive advantage (e.g. offering new business model) Often added value creates further values Transparency (performance, cost, quality)
17 Strategic Alignment Transition to cloud must fit the corporate strategy The cloud may not be the solution to all business models Depending on identified risks and values, different impact on strategy Service Level Alignment (weakness in IT infrastructure) Competitive Potential Alignment (weakness in Business ) Or fusion strategy
18 CALCULATING THE BUSINESS CASE
ROI Return on Investment 19 Compares cost and benefits of the current infrastructure in contrast to a cloud solution Common definition of ROI: Value vs savings (!)
20 Cost considered in ROI Increased scalability (short term agility) Less bound capital Optimizing ownership use Optimizing cost of capacity Savings in hardware and software costs Risk and labor
Hidden costs you might overlook 21 Energy costs (servers and A/C) Bandwidth can be your best friend or your worst foe Outbound bandwidth from cloud server might be expensive Replacement cost for on-premise systems (new hardware, software fees, labor) Costs for downtime of systems
22 Further Criteria for ROI Not all factors can be expressed in economical indicators Key criteria regarding non-monetary assets Time Knowledge Quality Those criteria allow to systematically analyze non-monetary factors
23 Key Criteria Time Accelerated time to market for new products (long term agility) Service delivery time Provisioning time Increased reaction time of workforce
24 Key Criteria (2) Knowledge Retain and transfer knowledge Causes external effects on other business units Knowledge does support core competences Degree of innovation Maintaining an IT Architecture Excessive use of different cloud solution might cause misalignment
25 Key Criteria (3) Quality Optimizing cost to execute or deliver Utilization Improved Quality of Service Improves business continuity Green costs of Increased End-User satisfaction Loyalty
KPIs Key Performance Indicators 26 Performance measurement on the basis of indicators, which are related to cloud computing characteristics The following indicators could support service providers to measure the performance: Default rates (measurement of failures or downtime) Automation (ratio of automated processes) Degree of use Average rate of successful delivery Profit generated associated to revenue Cost of goods compared to generated profit Satisfaction rate (Usability etc.)
27
28 Conclusion computing often sold as silver bullet But it is not always the best solution Often no appropriate calculation is done A cloud service solution is often more expensive in the long run To correctly assess the factors, an evaluation method is needed A business case is a suitable approach for this Our methodology gives a guideline to assess all relevant factors
and Take-home message 29 Risk management Actively decide which risks to take or to evade Business Values Consider unique values delivered by cloud solutions A Business Case must be calculated and must Show a positive impact (ROI & KPI) Consider all other Key criteria (Time, Knowledge, Cost) KPI are identified to measure the performance solutions often interesting for Startups Diverse expectations from the view of the provider and customer
30 Thank you for your attention! QUESTIONS?
Bibliography 31
[1] H. Bidgoli, Successful Introduction of Computing into your Organization : A Six-Step Conceptual Model, pp. 21 38, 2011. [2] V. Chang, G. Wills, and D. De Roure, A Review of Business Models and Sustainability, Comput. (CLOUD), 2010 IEEE 3rd Int. Conf., 2010. [3] Esri, The Business Case for, no. April, 2013. [4] P. Hofmann and S. A. P. Labs, Computing : The Limits of Public s for Business Applications, 2010. [5] S. Marston, Z. Li, S. Bandyopadhyay, J. Zhang, and A. Ghalsasi, computing The business perspective, Decis. Support Syst., vol. 51, no. 1, pp. 176 189, Apr. 2011. [6] The Business Case for Computing - Eide Bailly LLP. [Online]. Available: http://www.eidebailly.com/services/technology-consulting/technology-services/the-business-case-for-cloud-computing/. [Accessed: 02-Apr-2014]. [7] Strengthening your Business Case for Using : Business Use-Case Analysis. [Online]. Available: http://www.opengroup.org/cloud/whitepapers/wp_cbuc/cbuc-analysis.htm. [Accessed: 02-Apr-2014]. [8] Comparing cloud vs on-premise? Six hidden costs people always forget about. [Online]. Available: http://betanews.com/2013/11/04/comparing-cloud-vs-on-premise-six-hidden-costs-people-always-forget-about/. [Accessed: 02- Apr-2014]. [9] HP Blogs - The Business Value of : Improve productivity - The HP Blog Hub. [Online]. Available: http://h30507.www3.hp.com/t5/-source-blog/the-business-value-of--improve-productivity/ba-p/122047. [Accessed: 08-Apr-2014]. [10] How cloud-based products improve business productivity Media Network - Microsoft partner zone Guardian Professional. [Online]. Available: http://www.theguardian.com/media-network/partner-zone-microsoft/cloud-technologybusiness-productivity. [Accessed: 08-Apr-2014]. 32
[11] How Computing Improves Productivity ERP News. [Online]. Available: http://erpcloudnews.com/2013/01/how-cloud-computing-improves-productivity/. [Accessed: 08-Apr-2014]. [12] 7 Ways To Increase Productivity Using The. [Online]. Available: http://www.computerescape.com/blog- 0/bid/311565/7-Ways-To-Increase-Productivity-Using-The-. [Accessed: 08-Apr-2014]. [13] K. A. Beaty, V. K. Naik, and C.-S. Perng, Economics of cloud computing for enterprise IT, 2011. [14] V. Chang, D. Bacigalupo, G. Wills, and D. De Roure, A Categorisation of Computing Business Models, 2010 10th IEEE/ACM Int. Conf. Clust. Grid Comput., pp. 509 512, 2010. [15] V. Chang, G. Wills, and D. De Roure, A Review of Business Models and Sustainability, 2010 IEEE 3rd Int. Conf. Comput., pp. 43 50, Jul. 2010. [16] claranet, The business case for cloud computing, 2000. [17] Compuware, computing: TRENDS & BUSINESS OPPORTUNITIES. [18] P. Ingholt, J. Bell, and O. Cynthia, Developing a Business Case for, McLean. [19] A. M. Kuo, N. Bhatia, and J. Chang, Computing Return on Investment ( ROI ) and Recommendations, 2010. [20] S. Leimeister, C. Riedl, M. Böhm, and H. Krcmar, The Business Perspective of Computing: Actors, Roles, and Value Networks, in Proceedings of 18th European Conference on Information Systems ECIS 2010, 2010, pp. 1 12. [21] S. Marston, Z. Li, S. Bandyopadhyay, J. Zhang, and A. Ghalsasi, computing The business perspective, Decis. Support Syst., vol. 51, no. 1, pp. 176 189, Apr. 2011. [22] B. Martens, M. Walterbusch, and F. Teuteberg, Costing of Computing Services : A Total Cost of Ownership Approach, in International Conference on System Sciences, 2012. [23] A. Mcdonald, Business Case for the. [24] C. Metzger, T. Reitz, and J. Villar, Entscheidungskriterien für Computing, in Computing, 2011, pp. 75 88. 33
[25] J. Myllykoski and P. Ahokangas, TRANSFORMATION TOWARD A CLOUD, pp. 1 10. [26] N. Phaphoom, N. Oza, X. Wang, and P. Abrahamsson, Does Computing Deliver the Promised Benefits for IT Industry?, pp. 45 52, 2012. [27] L. Pizette and J. Manring, Cost and Business Case Considerations, 2010. [28] J. Staten, Is Computing Ready For The Enterprise?, 2008. [29] C. Weinhardt, A. Anandasivam, B. Blau, N. Borissov, T. Meinl, W. Michalk, and J. Stößer, Computing A Classification, Business Models, and Research Directions, Bus. Inf. Syst. Eng., vol. 1, no. 5, pp. 391 399, Sep. 2009. [30] William M. Sinnett, Building the Business Case for Computing, New Jersey. 34