STATE OF THE NATION. Challenges for 2015 and beyond. England

Transcription

1 STATE OF THE NATION Challenges for 2015 and beyond England

2 The state of the nation: diabetes in Care for children and young people 28 The challenges for 2015 and beyond: what needs to happen over the next five years Preventing Type 2 diabetes 15 Healthcare Essentials for everyone with diabetes Inpatient care Pregnancy care Specialist care Emotional and psychological support Variations in diabetes care and outcomes 12 References 34 HbA1c 14 Blood pressure Cholesterol Actions to improve care processes and outcomes Eye screening Foot checks Kidney function Weight Smoking Personalised care planning Education and support for self-management About Diabetes UK Diabetes UK is the leading UK charity that cares for, connects with, and campaigns on behalf of people affected by and at risk of diabetes: We help people manage their diabetes effectively by providing information, advice and support. We campaign with people with diabetes and with healthcare professionals to improve the quality of care across the UK s health services. We fund pioneering research into care, cure and prevention for all types of diabetes. We campaign to stem the rising tide of diabetes. Takeda UK Ltd. has financially supported the production of this State of the Nation report. Takeda has had no input into the development or content of this document.

3 Foreword If it was announced that a new condition had emerged that was doubling in prevalence every 17 years, and 13 million people were already directly affected or at serious risk, this would be seen as an epidemic and a national crisis. Last year s State of the Nation report commented on the absence of national plans to improve the quality of diabetes care and reduce complications, and to tackle the rising incidence of this condition. While the former has not yet materialised, we are encouraged by the announcement of a Type 2 diabetes prevention programme in the NHS Five Year Forward View. With nearly 10 million people in England at high risk of developing Type 2 diabetes, such a programme is due urgently, and as highlighted in this year s report it is not too late to reverse the rise of Type 2 diabetes. During 2014, we welcomed four national diabetes audit reports, covering care processes and treatment targets, inpatients, children and young people, and for the first time pregnancy in women with diabetes. We also launched Diabetes Watch our online tool for people with diabetes and professionals to look at and compare CCG-level data. This means we now have comprehensive national and local pictures of the healthcare received by people with diabetes. Unfortunately, while the audit reports indicate some signs of progress, there is clearly a long way to go before everyone with diabetes receives high quality care. What is particularly striking is that some people with diabetes those with Type 1, working age people, and people living in certain parts of the country are receiving considerably worse routine care than other people with diabetes, and are achieving poorer outcomes. This puts them at greater risk of serious complications, which can lead to disability and premature death, and are very expensive for the NHS. People with diabetes are also failing to receive the support they need to self-manage their condition effectively again, elevating the risk of long-term complications. Few people are offered or attend diabetes education, have personalised care plans, or have access to emotional support and specialist psychological care. As well as highlighting this situation, our State of the Nation report sets out a range of actions to address the challenges England faces. There are real opportunities for the incoming government, health services, local authorities, and others, to prevent millions of people from developing Type 2 diabetes, and help make the impact less severe for those who are diagnosed with diabetes of all types. We urge these organisations to act on our proposals and implement them over the coming months. The overarching messages from this State of the Nation report are that good care now for everyone with diabetes, and a greater focus on prevention, can save money in the longer term money that would otherwise be spent on treating avoidable complications, and on caring for people with avoidable cases of Type 2 diabetes. We all have to act before the number of people with diabetes overwhelms our health and social care systems and consumes an even greater proportion of the NHS budget. These are messages that the Government, the NHS, and the country as a whole cannot afford to ignore. Barbara Young Chief Executive 3

4 The state of the nation: diabetes in 2014 Diabetes is an increasingly urgent health issue Diabetes is the fastest growing health threat of our times and an urgent public health issue 1. Since 1996, the number of people living with diabetes has more than doubled. 3.2 million people in England now have diabetes: 2.7 million people or 6 per cent of the adult population have been diagnosed with diabetes 2 a further 500,000 people are estimated to have Type 2 diabetes, but do not know it 3 more than 700 people learn they have diabetes every day that s one person every three minutes 4. Another 9.6 million people in England are at high risk of getting Type 2 diabetes, and that number is rising dramatically every year 5. If nothing changes, by 2025 more than four million people in England will have diabetes 6. Diabetes is expensive to treat and manage Diabetes accounts for around 10 per cent of the annual NHS budget. This is nearly 10 billion a year, or 1 million every hour 7. Eighty per cent of NHS spending on diabetes goes on managing complications, most of which could be prevented 8. One in 20 people with diabetes incurs social services costs. More than three-quarters of these costs are associated with residential and nursing care 9. The total cost (including direct care and indirect costs) associated with diabetes in the UK is currently estimated at 23.7 billion. These costs are predicted to rise to 39.8 billion by Prevalence of diabetes is more than three times higher than prevalence of all cancers combined, and is increasing Percentage of population with this condition Diabetes Cancer Coronary heart disease Stroke and mini stroke Dementia Future diabetes projection Future cancer projection Source: Quality and Outcomes Framework prevalence data,

5 Diabetes can cause serious complications and early death Every year, around 20,000 people with diabetes die early 10. People with diabetes are also at greater risk of developing one or more severe health complications. Diabetes is: responsible for more than 100 amputations a week 11 the leading cause of preventable sight loss in people of working age 12 a major contributor to kidney failure, heart attack, and stroke 13. Poor diabetes care and outcomes now will drive up future costs and complications Too many people with diabetes are still not receiving all of the vital annual checks for the effectiveness of diabetes treatment, cardiovascular risk factors, and the emergence of early complications 15. Some population groups, particularly those with Type 1 diabetes, and working age people, routinely receive poorer care and are less likely to meet treatment targets. Between 2007 and 2012, avoidable complications increased significantly 14 There has been little change in the percentage of people with diabetes receiving recommended care processes and some things are getting worse 67 % 130 % 106 % ANGINA RETINOPATHY CARDIAC FAILURE RENAL REPLACEMENT THERAPY* STROKE 33 % 95 % 60 % 0 AMPUTATIONS *Term used for life-supporting treatments required to treat end stage kidney disease Percentage of people with diabetes receiving care processes* *Excluding eye screening Source: National Diabetes Audit (figures for England and Wales) Blood pressure Serum creatinine HbA1c Cholesterol BMI Smoking Foot surveillance Urine albumin All 5

6 There are significant variations between clinical commissioning group areas. People with diabetes living in some areas receive better care and treatment than people living in other areas. They are also more likely to meet recommended treatment targets. Cholesterol <4mmol/L Cholesterol <5mmol/L BP 140/80 HbA1c <48mmol/ml (6.5%) HbA1c 58mmol/mol (7.5%) HbA1c 86mmol/mol (10%) Across CCGs, there are large variations in achievement rates for HbA1c, cholesterol and blood pressure treatment targets Percentage of people with diabetes in a CCG meeting treatment targets Source: National Diabetes Audit (figures for England) Key Minimum Maximum Median Inter-quartile range It is not too late to reverse these trends Although millions of people are at high risk of Type 2 diabetes, 80 per cent of these cases can be prevented. To halt the rise in Type 2 diabetes requires widespread implementation of: the NHS Health Check programme to identify people at risk of Type 2 diabetes a Type 2 diabetes prevention programme to support those identified as being at high risk measures that help everyone to maintain a healthy weight. Effective diabetes care and self-management now can reduce the long-term cost and impact of complications. Everyone with diabetes no matter their age, where there live, or the type of diabetes they have needs to receive the best care possible. They also need to be supported to self-manage their condition effectively. We need action now to: increase the availability of all of the recommended care processes for everyone with diabetes ensure all people with diabetes are supported to meet recommended treatment targets implement integrated pathways of diabetes care across all local health systems improve access to, and uptake of, a range of appropriate education and learning opportunities fully implement collaborative care planning improve access to a range of specialist diabetes healthcare professionals, in all care settings. 6

7 The challenges for 2015 and beyond: what needs to happen over the next five years If action is not taken now, the longer-term costs and consequences associated with diabetes will be severe for individuals, the NHS, and wider society. We need to focus on preventing Type 2 diabetes, improving diabetes care, reducing avoidable complications, and supporting people with diabetes to manage their condition effectively. Preventing Type 2 diabetes While there is nothing that can be done to prevent Type 1 diabetes, Type 2 diabetes can often be prevented or its onset delayed. This can be done by identifying those at high risk of developing Type 2 diabetes, and implementing effective risk reduction interventions a diabetes prevention programme. However, the main risk identification programme NHS Health Check is still not being implemented fully across England. Referral to risk reduction programmes for those identified as high risk is inconsistent. Obesity the most significant risk factor for Type 2 diabetes is increasing. This situation can be addressed by a range of individual and whole population interventions designed to help people maintain a healthy weight. What needs to happen The new government needs to: continue to commit funding for the NHS Health Check programme support a Type 2 diabetes prevention programme for people identified at high risk coordinate a plan to reduce obesity in the general population. Public Health England and NHS England need to ensure the national evidence-based Type 2 diabetes prevention programme, committed to in the NHS Five Year Forward View, includes appropriate identification, follow up and interventions for people at high risk of Type 2 diabetes. Local authorities need to fully implement the NHS Health Check programme to increase levels of risk identification, and ensure those at high risk are referred to an effective diabetes prevention programme. Health and wellbeing boards need to support programmes to prevent Type 2 diabetes, by having strategies: for whole population prevention, designed to reduce obesity and encourage healthier diets and increased activity to identify and target people at high risk of Type 2 diabetes to ensure there is a Type 2 diabetes prevention pathway. Improving diabetes care NICE recommends everyone with diabetes receives nine care processes every year to check the effectiveness of diabetes treatment, cardiovascular risk factors, and the emergence of complications. Too few people get these checks, though, and achieve the recommended targets. There are significant variations between different population groups and geographical areas. What needs to happen CCGs need to develop and implement performance improvement plans for all of the recommended care processes and treatment targets. Reducing complications through increased access to diabetes specialists Diabetes is a complex condition, often requiring specialist skills and knowledge. People with diabetes need access to a range of specialist healthcare professionals, in hospital and other healthcare settings, so complications can be prevented and treated effectively. 7

8 Without immediate action, the long-term costs and implications of diabetes will be severe. Good care now, and a greater focus on prevention, will save money in the future 8 However, for some people, this kind of specialist care is not available. Diabetes specialist nurses who are integral to providing cost-effective care and preventing complications are having their positions cut or downgraded 16. Moreover, many healthcare professionals lack the competence needed to identify diabetes or the early signs of complications. What needs to happen CCGs need to: ensure all healthcare staff have access to continuing professional development in diabetes care, by incorporating requirements in contracts with service providers recognise the role of diabetes specialist nurses, and other specialist teams, in delivering cost-effective diabetes services. Healthcare service providers need to: increase the availability of specialist diabetes inpatient teams and multidisciplinary foot care teams to ensure all people with diabetes have access to specialist care and support ensure all healthcare professionals are competent in diabetes identification and care, within their scope of practice. Implementing integrated care pathways Integrated pathways of care across primary, community and specialist care are the ideal way of ensuring people with diabetes get the support and treatment they need, at the right time and place. This model of care focuses on the patient s perspective, and can deliver value for both the individual and the health system. However, it is still not widespread. What needs to happen CCGs need to work with service providers to design and implement integrated pathways of care across local health systems. Health and wellbeing boards need to promote integrated approaches to diabetes prevention and care by developing a long-term vision for achieving fully coordinated care, and initiating the changes required to deliver it. Improving education for self-management Diabetes is a serious condition but, if managed well, people can live long and full lives. Supported self-management is the key to successful day-to-day diabetes management. Access to diabetes education and information is an essential part of effective self-management. However, very few people with diabetes are offered structured education, and even fewer attend a programme. What needs to happen Clinical commissioning groups (CCGs) need to increase the availability and uptake of a range of diabetes education and learning opportunities Healthcare professionals need to encourage their patients to attend learning opportunities. Rolling out collaborative care planning Collaborative care planning involves people with diabetes and clinicians working together to agree goals, develop and implement action plans, and monitor progress 17. It has been shown to improve the skills and knowledge of both parties, and enable people with diabetes to make positive changes. Despite this, it is still not widely used. What needs to happen CCGs need to explicitly commission collaborative care planning, and the training and systems needed to support it Healthcare professionals need to engage with patients with diabetes through collaborative care planning.

9 Preventing Type 2 diabetes Type 2 diabetes accounts for 90 per cent of all cases of diabetes 15. The number of people with Type 2 diabetes is increasing from 1.7 million in 2006 to more than 2.5 million in Moreover, 9.6 million people in England are at high risk of getting Type 2 diabetes, and that number is rising every year 5. Unlike Type 1 diabetes, which is not preventable, up to 80 per cent of cases of Type 2 diabetes can be delayed or prevented 19. This can be done by: widespread implementation of a Type 2 diabetes prevention pathway helping people to maintain a healthy weight, through whole population-level interventions. A diabetes prevention pathway to identify and support people at high risk of developing Type 2 diabetes The NHS Health Check programme can help to identify many of the individuals who are at high risk of developing Type 2 diabetes. It is estimated that, if fully implemented, this programme could prevent 4,000 people a year from developing diabetes 20. Since 2013, local authorities have been responsible for implementing the Health Check programme. While many local authorities are making good progress with this, others are not. Overall, the percentage of the eligible population being offered a Health Check is increasing. However, uptake needs to improve. In , less than half of the people offered a Health Check in England actually had one 21. What needs to happen now? The Department of Health should guarantee ongoing financial support for the NHS Health Check programme, and incentivise local authority improvement. NHS England and Public Health England should: develop a national, evidence-based diabetes prevention programme, as proposed in the NHS Five Year Forward View, building on the NHS Health Check programme clarify where responsibility lies for commissioning and evaluating lifestyle interventions. NHS England should mandate appropriate follow up and management of people identified as being at high risk of Type 2 diabetes through the GP contract. Local authorities should: work with NHS England to improve the entire diabetes prevention pathway, ensuring people attend a Health Check, receive a quality check, and are followed up appropriately initiate local awareness-raising campaigns, particularly among those groups that the Health Check programme is failing to reach. Health and wellbeing boards should: make prevention of Type 2 diabetes a priority in the Joint Health and Wellbeing Strategy set out their local strategy for improving the availability and take up of the Health Check programme, and for ensuring those at high risk have access to a diabetes prevention programme. 9

10 2.5 MILLION 1.7 MILLION While identifying people who are at high risk of getting Type 2 diabetes is critical, this is just the first step in a prevention pathway. Those individuals with modifiable risk factors then need to be supported to reduce their weight. NICE guidance specifies that people identified as being at high risk of Type 2 diabetes should be offered intensive lifestyle interventions. However, it is unclear whether this is happening in all cases or, indeed, who is responsible for referrals and follow up and the provision of intervention programmes is patchy. This means the Health Check programme will not deliver the health and economic benefits that it should. Helping everyone to maintain a healthy weight Being overweight or obese is the most significant risk factor for Type 2 diabetes, and accounts for 80 to 85 per cent of the risk of developing this condition 22. Maintaining a healthy weight, eating a balanced diet, and being active, are therefore the most effective ways of preventing Type 2 diabetes. However, there has been a marked increase in obesity over the past 20 years. In England, 61 per cent of adults and 30 per cent of children are now overweight or obese 23. Almost nine out of every 10 people diagnosed with Type 2 diabetes are overweight 24. If we are going to reverse these trends, and stop the sharp rise in Type 2 diabetes, more must be done to support all parts of the population to make healthier choices. Individuals are often working hard to achieve a healthy weight. Government, the NHS, local authorities, employers, and the food and drinks industry need to match that determination What needs to happen now? The new government should: encourage the food and drinks industry and retailers to promote healthier choices to consumers continue to support a consistent front-of-packet labelling system legislate on reformulation of foods to reduce overall calorie intake consider taxation of unhealthy foods THE NUMBER OF PEOPLE WITH TYPE 2 DIABETES IN ENGLAND IS INCREASING RAPIDLY 18 restrict the marketing of foods high in salt, sugar and fat to children invest in national awareness-raising campaigns. Health and wellbeing boards and local authorities should ensure: information about obesity and strategies to target it are included in Joint Strategic Needs Assessments design of the local environment and services promotes active lifestyles and access to healthy food. 10

11 15 Healthcare Essentials for everyone with diabetes Every person with diabetes needs the recommended treatment and services, regardless of their age, ethnicity, where they live, and whether they have Type 1 or Type 2. The Diabetes UK 15 Healthcare Essentials set out the care that all people with diabetes should expect to receive from their healthcare team every year. They include the nine care process checks recommended by NICE 25, and provide a starting point for ensuring everyone gets high quality and effective care. Education and care planning enable people to make the most of the 15 Healthcare Essentials. Education helps them to understand and manage their condition. Care planning involves collaborative working between people with diabetes and their healthcare teams to develop and achieve individual goals Get your blood glucose levels (HbA1c) measured at least once every year. This will measure your overall blood glucose control and help you and your healthcare team set a target. Have your blood pressure measured and recorded at least once a year, and set a personal target that is right for you. Have your blood fats, such as cholesterol, measured every year. You should have a target that is realistic and achievable. Have your eyes screened for signs of retinopathy every year. Have your feet checked. The skin, circulation and nerve supply of your feet should be examined annually. You should then be told if you have any risk of foot problems and how serious they are. Have your kidney function monitored annually. This should involve two tests: a urine test for protein and a blood test to measure kidney function Have your weight checked and your waist measured to see if you need to lose weight. Get support if you are a smoker, including advice and support on how to quit. Engage in care planning discussions with your healthcare team to talk about your individual needs and set targets. Attend an education course in your local area to help you understand and manage your diabetes. Receive care from a specialist paediatric team if you are a child or young person. Receive high-quality care if admitted to hospital from specialist diabetes healthcare professionals, regardless of whether or not you have been admitted due to your diabetes. Get information and specialist care if you are planning to have a baby as your diabetes control has to be a lot tighter and monitored very closely. You should expect care and support from specialists at every stage, from preconception to postnatal care. See specialist diabetes healthcare professionals to help you manage your diabetes, such as podiatrists, ophthalmologists, and dietitians. Get emotional and psychological support. Being diagnosed with diabetes and living with a long-term condition can be difficult, and you should be able to talk about issues and concerns with specialist healthcare professionals. 11

12 Variations in diabetes care and outcomes Having the right care is essential for the wellbeing of everyone with diabetes, and can help reduce the risk, severity, and costs of complications. An integral part of this is the receipt of the NICE-recommended care processes. These are the annual checks for the effectiveness of diabetes treatment (HbA1c), cardiovascular risk factors (blood pressure, serum cholesterol, BMI, smoking), and emergence of early complications (foot checks, eye screening, and two tests for kidney function). Unfortunately, the National Diabetes Audit showed that annual completion rates for eight 26 of these care processes continue to plateau at 60 per cent. Moreover, there are worrying variations in the care and treatment received by some population groups, and in different parts of the country. People with Type 1 diabetes receive poorer care than people with Type 2 People with Type 1 diabetes of all ages and ethnic groups routinely receive worse care and treatment than people with Type 2 diabetes. In , fewer people with Type 1 diabetes received each of the eight recommended care processes. Overall, only 41 per cent of people with Type 1 diabetes received all eight care processes, compared with 62 per cent of people with Type 2. People with Type 1 were also less likely to meet the recommended treatment targets for blood glucose (HbA1c) and cholesterol 15. In , very few people with Type 1 accessed structured education. This was offered to 2.4 per cent of people with Type 1 diabetes, compared with 6 per cent of those with Type 2. Only 1.1 per cent of people with Type 1 diabetes, and 1.6 per cent with Type 2, actually attended structured education 15. The outstanding message from this (audit) report is the need to address the substantially worse routine care and treatment in younger people with Type 1 and Type 2 diabetes and in people with Type 1 diabetes at all ages. Given the potential adverse consequences for these younger people of disability and premature mortality in middle life, designing better systems of care for them would yield considerable health benefits. Foreword, National Diabetes Audit People with Type 1 diabetes receive fewer checks than people with Type % 93.9% HbA1c 89.0% 96.1% Blood pressure 78.2% 92.5% Cholesterol 81.2% 93.7% Serum creatinine Urine albumin Percentage of people with Type 1 receiving care processes 57.0% 74.9% Foot surveillance Care processes 72.7% 86.8% 84.4% 91.6% BMI 80.0% 86.9% Smoking 41.4% 61.6% Eight care processes Percentage of people with Type 2 receiving care processes 12 Source: National Diabetes Audit (figures for England)

13 Working age people receive poorer care People of working age with Type 1 or Type 2 diabetes are less likely than older people to receive the recommended care processes and meet treatment targets. For example, in the under 40s, only 29 per cent of people with Type 1 diabetes and 46 per cent with Type 2 received eight care processes. In comparison, more than 60 per cent of people in the 65 to 79 age group received all these processes 15. Three treatment targets relating to glucose control (HbA1c), blood pressure, and cholesterol should be monitored and met in all people with diabetes. Again, there were variations between age groups, and older people did better. Only 15 per cent of people with Type 1 diabetes in each of the under 65 age groups met all three treatment targets, compared with more than 20 per cent in the older age groups. Similarly, the targets were met by less than one-third of people with Type 2 diabetes in the younger age groups, but more than 40 per cent of those aged 65 and above 15. Too many children and young people also receive poor care Children and young people are even less likely to receive the recommended care processes. In , only 12 per cent of young people aged between 12 and 19 had all their care processes recorded 27. Although this figure had almost doubled from 6.7 per cent in it continues to be well below results for adults with Type 1 diabetes 28. Children and young people also have problems controlling their diabetes. One in four had worryingly high HbA1c levels (over 80mmol/mol). This proportion was even higher among children from ethnic minorities 27. Working age people are less likely to receive eight diabetes care processes than older people 29.1% 46.3% 47.7% 59.2% 59.9% 66.7% Under to to and over Age There are geographical variations in care and outcomes As highlighted throughout this report, there are considerable variations between CCGs in terms of care process completion rates and the achievement of treatment targets in all people with diabetes. This shows that where a person lives has a significant impact on their ability to receive the care they need and achieve good outcomes. Would you want to live in a place where less than 10 per cent of people with Type 1 diabetes meet all their treatment targets? % Source: National Diabetes Audit (figures for England and Wales) 59.8% For CCG-level data, see the Diabetes Watch online tool: diabeteswatch.diabetes.org.uk Percentage of people with Type 1 receiving eight care processes Percentage of people with Type 2 receiving eight care processes 13

14 1 HbA1c A substantial number of people with diabetes have exceptionally high-risk blood glucose levels NICE recommends an annual HbA1c check to measure a person s overall blood glucose control. Blood glucose control is essential to avoid serious complications. This check is carried out frequently. In , more than 90 per cent of all people with diabetes were recorded as having an annual HbA1c check 15. People with Type 1 diabetes were much less likely to receive this check, though only 80 per cent, compared with 94 per cent of people with Type 2. This situation is getting worse in , the figure for people with Type 1 diabetes was 86 per cent 15. There has been a worrying lack of progress with achieving the NICErecommended treatment targets for HbA1c. Of particular concern is that: substantial numbers of people have exceptionally high-risk glucose levels 17 per cent of Type 1 and 7 per cent of Type 2 patients had HbA1c equal to or above 86mmol/mol people with Type 1 diabetes were much less likely to reach recommended targets than people with Type 2 diabetes there were significant regional variations. For the treatment target of equal to or above 58mmol/mol, for example, there was a range of 30 percentage points between the highest- and lowest-performing CCGs 15. People with Type 1 diabetes are less likely to meet recommended HbA1c targets than people with Type 2 7.6% 26.6% HbA1c <48mmol/ mol (6.5%) 27.6% 65.0% HbA1c 58mmol/ mol (7.5%) 83.3% 93.2% HbA1c 86mmol/ mol (10%) Source: National Diabetes Audit (figures for England) Percentage of people with Type 1 meeting HbA1c targets Percentage of people with Type 2 meeting HbA1c targets For CCG-level data, see the Diabetes Watch online tool: diabeteswatch.diabetes.org.uk 14

15 2 Blood pressure A quarter of people with diabetes do not meet recommended blood pressure targets increasing their risk of complications People with diabetes have about twice the risk of developing a range of cardiovascular diseases (including heart disease and stroke), compared with people who do not have diabetes. Cardiovascular disease (CVD) is a major cause of death and disability in people with diabetes, accounting for 44 per cent of fatalities in people with Type 1 diabetes and 52 per cent in people with Type Poor blood pressure control further increases the risk of developing this complication, and of suffering a stroke in particular. It also increases the risk of kidney disease. NICE recommends people with diabetes have their blood pressure measured at least once a year, and recommends treatment targets. In , 95 per cent of people with diabetes had their blood pressure checked a similar figure to previous years. However, only 69 per cent of those people met the recommended treatment target a small improvement from Unlike the targets for HbA1c and cholesterol, people with Type 2 diabetes were less likely to meet the treatment target for blood pressure. People aged under 40 with Type 1 diabetes did better than those in other age groups, and people with Type 2. There was a considerable variation in blood pressure target achievement rates by CCG, for patients with both types of diabetes. The range between the best and worst CCGs was greater than 30 percentage points 15. Most people get their blood pressure checked, but more than a quarter do not meet recommended targets 95.0% 62.0% 95.0% 67.1% 95.3% 69.0% Source: National Diabetes Audit (figures for England and Wales) Percentage of people with diabetes receiving blood pressure care process Percentage of people with diabetes meeting blood pressure target 140/80 People under 65 with Type 2 diabetes are less likely to meet blood pressure targets than those with Type % 65.0% 70.3% 64.9% 71.7% 71.7% 70.7% 72.2% Percentage of people with Type 1 meeting blood pressure targets Percentage of people with Type 2 meeting blood pressure targets For CCG-level data, see the Diabetes Watch online tool: diabeteswatch.diabetes.org.uk Under to to and over Age Source: National Diabetes Audit (figures for England and Wales) 15

16 3 Cholesterol Many people are not getting their cholesterol checked, and are not meeting recommended targets Poor cholesterol control also increases the risk of developing cardiovascular disease. It is important, therefore, that people with diabetes have their cholesterol checked annually, and have realistic and achievable targets. In , 92 per cent of people with Type 2 diabetes received a cholesterol check. Only 78 per cent of people with Type 1 had this essential check, though 15. Younger people with Type 1 or Type 2 diabetes were less likely to have their cholesterol checked than those aged over 40. This check was carried out in only 64 per cent of people with Type 1 in the under 40 age group, and 82 per cent of those with Type 2 in that age group. Around a quarter of all people with diabetes did not meet the cholesterol treatment target of <5mmol/L, and 60 per cent did not meet the tougher target of <4mmol/L. As with treatment targets for HbA1c and blood pressure, there were large variations in achievement rates across CCGs. This indicates there is considerable scope for improvement in many areas. Younger people, particularly those with Type 1 diabetes, are less likely to have their cholesterol checked 64.0% 82.5% 86.1% 91.6% 92.6% 94.6% 89.5% Under to to and over Age Source: National Diabetes Audit (figures for England and Wales) 91.7% Percentage of people with Type 1 receiving cholesterol care process Percentage of people with Type 2 receiving cholesterol care process 16 For CCG-level data, see the Diabetes Watch online tool: diabeteswatch.diabetes.org.uk

17 Actions to improve care processes and outcomes To reduce the risk of serious complications, it is essential that everyone with diabetes receives all of the checks for HbA1c, blood pressure and cholesterol. They should also be supported to achieve the recommended treatment targets. Measurement of these three care processes is relatively high, particularly in older people with Type 2 diabetes (more than 90 per cent for each process). However, improvements are needed in all people with Type 1 diabetes, in the working age population with Type 2 diabetes, and in many CCG areas. Considerable progress is required in relation to the treatment targets. In , only 36 per cent of people with diabetes met all three targets the same as in There were also variations between different population groups, and between CCGs, which need to be addressed. Notably: only 16 per cent of people with Type 1 diabetes met all the treatment targets, compared with 37 per cent of people with Type 2 working age people were less likely to achieve treatment targets than those aged 65 and over the range of CCG target achievement varied by 20 to 30 percentage points. In some CCGs, less than 10 per cent of people with Type 1 diabetes met all the treatment targets 15. While HbA1c, blood pressure and cholesterol are often measured, many people do not achieve recommended treatment targets 80.9% 27.6% 93.9% 65.0% 89.0% HbA1c Blood pressure Cholesterol Percentage of people with Type 1 diabetes receiving care process Percentage of people with Type 2 diabetes receiving care process 73.4% 96.1% 68.7% Care process and treatment target 78.2% 70.2% 92.5% Percentage of people with Type 1 diabetes meeting treatment target* Percentage of people with Type 2 diabetes meeting treatment target* 76.8% *HbA1c 58mmol/mol (7.5%), BP 140/80, Cholesterol <5mmol/L Source: National Diabetes Audit (figures for England) For CCG-level data, see the Diabetes Watch online tool: diabeteswatch.diabetes.org.uk 17

18 What needs to happen now? All CCGs need to set themselves performance improvement targets and implement plans of action In particular, CCGs in the bottom 25 per cent need to take steps to achieve levels of performance similar to the middle 50 per cent, as a matter of urgency. CCGs need to ensure that all people with diabetes have access to the support they need to selfmanage effectively, and that the local health system is designed to deliver this Diabetes is a complex condition, which can be difficult to manage on a daily basis. Effective self-management is essential, and makes up around 95 per cent of care. Psychological and emotional support, education and information, and personalised care planning are key components of self-management, helping people with diabetes to understand and cope with their condition. CCGs need to work with healthcare providers to ensure emotional support and specialist psychological care are available for those with identified needs, as part of an integrated diabetes service. CCGs also need to make sure a range of education and learning opportunities are available, including structured education programmes, peer support, and online information and learning. NHS England needs to ensure CCGs are rolling out care planning and are supporting people with diabetes to engage in the care planning process Care planning is an ongoing, collaborative process, requiring the active engagement of people with diabetes and healthcare professionals. Care planning enables clinicians and people with diabetes to discuss HbA1c, blood pressure and cholesterol levels, agree individual goals and the support needed to reach them, and monitor progress. It also facilitates regular discussions about why particular medication has been prescribed, whether it is working, and whether changes are needed. CCGs and healthcare providers need to work together to make care planning a reality for all people with diabetes, and support clinicians to have the competence to deliver this. NHS England should ensure care planning can be rolled out in all CCGs. This is about more than providing a personal care plan to everyone with a long-term condition which is already an NHS commitment. Collaborative care planning should replace traditional care for people with diabetes, as part of an integrated system that focuses on the patient s perspective. Primary healthcare professionals need to make use of information prescriptions to help people with high blood pressure, HbA1c, or cholesterol Information prescriptions provide people with diabetes with information and support that enables them to live well with their condition. Information prescriptions are being embedded into primary care IT systems. It is up to healthcare professionals to use these new tools to support care planning and behavioural change in their patients. 18

19 4 Eye screening Many people with diabetes are not having their eyes checked regularly Retinopathy is a serious complication that can affect anyone with diabetes. Diabetic retinopathy accounts for around 7 per cent of people who are registered blind 29. People with diabetes also have an increased risk of developing glaucoma and cataracts. Keeping blood glucose, blood pressure and cholesterol levels under control can help to reduce the risk of developing retinopathy. People with diabetes should also have their eyes screened for retinopathy every year, to ensure problems are identified and treated as early as possible. All people aged 12 and over with diabetes should be offered annual screening appointments in their local authority area. In , uptake of appointments was 80 per cent in England 30. However, there were variations across the country in the best-performing eye screening programmes, uptake was more than 90 per cent; in the worst, it was less than 70 per cent. As the early stages of retinopathy are often symptomless, it is vital that people with diabetes understand the risks of developing this complication and the actions they can take. This includes being encouraged and enabled to attend their eye screening appointment. Primary healthcare professionals and screening service providers have important roles to play in ensuring this happens. Less than half of people realise diabetes can cause blindness. Ipsos MORI survey for Diabetes UK, 2014 What needs to happen now? Everyone with diabetes needs to be informed about the risks to their sight and preventative measures, as part of care planning with their healthcare professionals, and through participation in learning opportunities. GPs should check that patients have attended their annual retinal screening appointment, and that they are aware of and understand the results. This should be integrated within overall diabetes care. Eye screening service providers must deliver services that are accessible and convenient for all people with diabetes including the working age population, people with particular needs, and hard-to-reach groups. Providers with relatively low take-up rates need to review how screening services are configured. Diabetes networks should be involved in the review and design of local services. 19

20 5 Foot checks Every week, around 100 leg, foot or toe amputations are carried out on people with diabetes but 80 per cent of these can be prevented 20 If diabetes is poorly controlled, it can lead to nerve damage, poor circulation, and reduced feeling in the feet and legs. This, in turn, can lead to serious foot problems, such as ulcers, and may result in amputation. Around 6,000 people with diabetes have leg, foot or toe amputations each year in England 11. Amputations and foot ulcers have a huge impact on quality of life. They also cost lives up to 80 per cent of people die within five years of having an amputation 31. People with diabetes are more likely to be admitted to hospital with a foot ulcer than with any other complication of diabetes. Foot ulcers and amputations are very costly to the NHS accounting for around 1 in every 150 the NHS spends each year 32. Up to 80 per cent of amputations are potentially preventable, through improved awareness among people with diabetes about their risk status and the actions to take, and access to good-quality structured care 33. Annual foot checks NICE recommends all people with diabetes have their feet checked every year. This enables levels of risk of foot problems to be assessed, and action to be taken accordingly. People with diabetes should be given advice on prevention or, if problems already exist, referred to a specialist foot protection service. Despite this, 28 per cent of people with Type 1 diabetes and 13 per cent of people with Type 2 diabetes are still not receiving an annual foot check 15. These figures have hardly changed over recent years. We are also continuing to see significant variations between CCG areas. In the best-performing areas, more than 90 per cent of people with diabetes had their feet checked in ; in the worst, only 75 per cent did. The gap is even greater in people with Type 1 diabetes 15. People with Type 2 diabetes are more likely to have an annual foot check than people with Type % 86.1% 72.8% 87.0% 72.3% 86.7% Source: National Diabetes Audit (figures for England and Wales) Percentage of people with Type 1 receiving annual foot check Percentage of people with Type 2 receiving annual foot check For CCG-level data, see the Diabetes Watch online tool: diabeteswatch.diabetes.org.uk