Leading and Managing Innovation

Transcription

1 Leading and Managing Innovation Russell D. Archibald PhD (Hon), MSc, PMI Fellow, APM Honorary Fellow, PMP

2 Executives and Project Management Although Projects are the primary vehicles for: Many Executives: Achieving significant innovations Implementing corporate strategies In all industries and countries Fail to recognize the power and importance of project management. 2

3 Project Management is: Disregarded by Business Management Gurus Ignored by most top MBA Programs Discounted as a Key Topic by the Finest Business Publications. Only when project management is recognized as being vital to strategy execution [and innovation] will companies begin to more effectively achieve their goals. Source: Antonio Nieto-Rodriguez, Evidence of the Neglect of Project Management by Senior Executives. PM World Journal Vol. II, Issue II February

4 This Presentation Is intended to provide you with information ready for sharing with your executives. Why? To assist you in overcoming this neglect by those senior executives. 4

5 What all Executive Teams must know about Project, Program, and Portfolio Management Innovations and Project Management Innovations relate to process & products Operations versus Projects All Innovations are Projects Kinds of Organizations and Projects What Executive Teams Must Know The Essence of PPPM What Executives can demand Conclusions PPPM is a neglected core competence We must overcome this Executive neglect 5

6 What Innovations Are Innovation = Change: Business or creative processes, and/or Output or products of a process. Innovate or die! Innovate and succeed! 6

7 Every Innovation is a Project! Idea, vision Project: > Objectives > Schedule > Definition > Sponsor > Manager > Team > Execution > Controls Satisfying a need for key project stakeholders. 7

8 Creation Myth Xerox PARC, Apple, and the truth about innovation (by Malcolm Gladwell) New Yorker magazine May 16, 2011 The mouse was conceived by Engelbart, developed by Xerox PARC, and made marketable by Apple Reality: It takes a project to innovate! See this article and a slideshow on the mouse at

9 Steve Jobs: Master Project Manager Steve Jobs had the vision and Set the objectives Put together the Project Team members with the needed skills Executed and controlled the project. His innovations revolutionized the use of personal computers 9

10 Ideas and Innovation there are too many ideas, not too few. Dozens of solutions appear and disappear in chaotic piles of data, crowds of expert opinion, and a jumble of contradictory statistics and reports on every aspect of every issue. Michael Ray and Rochelle Myers, Creativity in Business

11 Idea to Innovation Real or perceived need Idea and vision Creation of the Project Execution of the Project Satisfaction of the Need 11

12 Project Management versus Operations Management All enterprises consist of these two classes of activity: Operations that are ongoing and repetitive, and Projects and programs that are temporary endeavors undertaken to create unique products, services or results, or otherwise significantly change the enterprise. 12

13 Three Underlying Concepts of Project Management What is different compared to on-going functional operations management? Assignment of integrative responsibilities for projects at several levels, Application of integrated project planning and control information systems ( project controls ), and Execution of the work required for each project by integrated teams of people using available, assigned resources. 13

14 Six levels of Project Management Integrative Responsibilities CEO Portfolio Steering Group Executive Project Sponsor PMO: Project Management Office Project Managers Functional Managers 14

15 Project Stakeholders In addition to these direct responsibilities the stakeholders in any project also include all persons or agencies that are affected by or exert influence over the conduct of or the results from the project. Project success often depends as much on inside and outside stakeholders as it does on those directly responsible for the effort. 15

16 Success with Stakeholders High Degree of Authority Over Project Low Keep Satisfied Monitor Minimum Effort Manage Closely Keep Informed Low Interest in Project High 16

17 Project Controls Systems Second PM Concept Computer-based project planning and control information systems today are complex and powerful, and require welltrained staff support to be effective. Historically these are based on once-through, deterministic methods, although iterative, heuristic, and agile processes are now often used -- but these iterative processes still have a predictive and control objective for the entire project. 17

18 The Project Team Third PM Concept A primary responsibility of each Project Manager is to build and lead a cohesive multi-disciplinary team. The nature of the project determines the resources and skills required Selection of the team members is usually a negotiation process The Project/Program Manager leads the team either directly or through the Functional Managers 18

19 The Project Team Third PM Concept A project only really exists comes to life when the Project Team is assigned to do the work 19

20 All innovations are achieved by projects. But Not all projects are innovative! 20

21 Strategic Transformative versus Commercial or Routine Projects Transformative Projects are intended to change or transform the enterprise significantly Routine, commercial Projects provide a product or service to generate income, or comply with laws or stakeholder requirements and expectations; they do not significantly change the organization 21

22 Project-Driven and Project-Dependent Organizations It is important to recognize the differences between these two types of enterprises They usually exhibit widely different levels of maturity in their project management capabilities 22

23 How they Differ Project-Driven Organizations: Rely on projects for normal revenue. Are usually mature in the management of their "delivery" projects. May be less mature in management of transformative programs and projects. Project- Dependent Organizations: Derive most of their revenues from selling products or services. Rely on innovative projects for expansion: new/improved products or processes. Often employ Project-Driven organizations for specific needs. 23

24 Projects & Programs Related to Operations In Project- Dependent Enterprises: Innovative Projects and Programs feed and support the on-going operations and its strategic growth plans Operations (sales of products and services) generate the desired return on the investments made in innovative Projects and Programs In Project- Driven Enterprises: Operations support the delivery of its projects to customers, which generate the income 24

25 Two Kinds of Programs Traditional Programs consist of a group of related projects, while Strategic or Transformation Programs usually include both projects and on-going operations. 25

26 Projects Must Be Categorized To: Strategically select, authorize, and prioritize the projects within an enterprise. Plan and execute projects: individually, within programs, and within project portfolios. Educate and train PM managers and specialists. Provide career paths for PM managers and specialists. 26

27 A Practical Set of 12 Project Categories: 1. Administrative and Organizational Change 2. Aerospace/Defense 3. Communication Systems 4. Events 5. Facilities 5.1 Facility decommissioning 5.2 Facility demolition 5.3 Facility maintenance and modification 5.4 Facility Design-procurementconstruction Some separate facilities design and construction into two separate categories, but these must be closely integrated on one facility. 6. Information Systems/IT 7. International Development 8. Media & Entertainment 9. Product and Service Development 9.1 Industrial product 9.2 Consumer product 9.3 Pharmaceutical product 9.4 Service (financial, other) 10. Research and Development 10.1 Environmental 10.2 Industrial 10.3 Economic development 10.4 Medical 10.5 Scientific 11. Healthcare 12. Other Projects Disaster Recovery, others. 27

28 Classifying Projects within Categories & Sub-Categories Major or Minor Projects Project Complexity & Risk Strategic Transformational Size (money, scope, duration, etc.) Relative to organizational size and experience Number of different skills or technologies needed, Geography/cultures/languages; Risks can be financial, technological, political, time pressure, or others Multiple projects (and programs) that also directly involve on-going operations Mega Projects and Programs Major projects on steroids, usually major programs over a number of years, involve consortia of agencies and companies 28

29 Project Types within the Project Diamond Model Shenhar, Aaron J., What s the Next Generation of Project Management, PMI Global Congress 2012 North America, Session # RES01, Vancouver BC, Canada, October 20-23,

30 The Impact of the Diamond Dimensions on Project Management Shenhar, Aaron J., What s the Next Generation of Project Management, PMI Global Congress 2012 North America, Session # RES01, Vancouver BC, Canada, October 20-23,

31 Project Portfolio Management Projects & Programs must be managed within portfolios for the most effective use of resources. Governance of these portfolios is a strategic job. Integrated information and prioritization are the major challenges in portfolio management. Major benefits and strategic gains are reported from good project-program portfolio management practices. 31

32 Types of Project Portfolios Value-creating: New or improved product, service, or market Operational process improvement: Projects that make the organization more efficient and satisfy some fundamental functional work. Compliance: Must-do projects required to maintain regulatory compliance. Combe, Margaret W., and Gregory D. Githens, Managing Pop-corn Priorities: How Portfolios and Programs Align Projects With Strategies. Proceedings of the PMI 1999 Seminars and Symposium. 32

33 Three Types of Innovation Investments Empowering innovations that create jobs, use capital to expand capacity and to finance receivables and inventory. Sustaining innovations that replace old products with new models. in dollars, they account for the most innovation. Efficiency innovations that reduce the cost of making and distributing existing products and services. Harvard Professor Clayton M. Christensen, A Capitalist s Dilemma, Whoever Wins on Tuesday, The New York Times, Nov. 3,

34 Two Vital Needs A coherent, documented Project Portfolio Management Process and A Portfolio Steering Group are vital requirements in today s globally competitive environment. 34

35 The Power of Portfolio Management Project portfolio management can be a potent weapon to ensure an organization s investments work together and deliver true business results. Organizations with little variation in their project portfolio management practices see 64% of their projects meet expected ROI 17 percentage points more than those companies with high variability. The 443 global portfolio managers surveyed said the number of projects completed on time and on budget would increase by roughly one-third with more effective portfolio management. They also thought achieving objectives and ROI goals would see similar gains. PMI 2012 Pulse of the Profession Portfolio Management Report, PM Network, June 2012, pp

36 Guides and Standards for Project Portfolio Management PMI: Standards/Standards-Library-of-PMI-Global- Standards.aspx UK Government: / 36

37 Project Portfolio Control Systems Advanced Management Solutions: Realtime Enterprise CA Technologies Compuware Changepoint Dekker, Ltd: Dekker Trakker Deltek Integrated Program Management HP Project and Portfolio Management Center IBM Rational Software Microsoft: MS Project and Project Server Oracle Primavera P6 Enterprise Project Portfolio Management Planview Enterprise Portfolio Management Safran North America: Project Management Toolkit SAP Portfolio and Project Management Spider Project 37

38 Greatest Challenge Today To adopt and implement a truly integrated and fully capable information system for project portfolio management. 38

39 Project Management Offices Establishing a home base PMO for the project management function is required. A wide variety of roles & responsibilities exists for PMOs and their placement in the organization. Major problems have been encountered with improperly defined PMOs. Impressive benefits are obtained from establishing PMOs: Survey results of 554 organizations in North America and the European Union 39

40 2012 PMO Research Results PM Solutions, The State of the PMO respondents, 79% N. America, 12% EU, 9% rest of the world, all sizes, 10% governmental agencies 87% of companies surveyed have a PMO. Definition of PMO Role is the greatest challenge. PMO staff members are highly experienced. More than half of those surveyed have standard training programs in place. 40

41 Managing Individual Projects Project success depends on the Project Manager s knowledge, authority and capability plus the Project Controls capability. The Project Controls function requires the proper knowledge and use of advanced integrated PM information systems to define, plan, estimate, and control the project objectives, scope, cost, schedule, risks, labor and other resources. 41

42 Project Controls Two aspects: Product planning and control: What will be the end results of the project, and Project planning and control: How and when the end results of the project will be achieved and at what cost 42

43 Executive Demands for Success Placing these demands on the executive s staff and managers communicates to the entire enterprise that: Top management understands what it takes to achieve the best performance possible in selecting and managing their projects and programs, and Top management fully supports the continuous improvement needed to assure the continued success of their enterprise. 43

44 31 Executive Demands for Success Strategic (4) Project Management Processes (4) Roles and Responsibilities (5) Management Training and Authority (3) Project Controls (8) Project Teams (6) Post-Project Completion (1) 44

45 Strategic Demands 1. Every authorized program and project clearly supports an approved strategic objective of the organization. 2. All significant innovations are achieved through application of the principles of project, program and portfolio management. 3. Each project s risks are identified, evaluated and managed using currently available methods and systems. 4. All projects are evaluated, prioritized and approved on the basis of the same corporate criteria. 45

46 Project Management Process Demands 5. The program, project and portfolio management processes of the organization are documented in a coherent, easily understood manner. 6. All projects are managed within their appropriate, defined portfolios. 7. The project management discipline and supporting systems are fully integrated with affected parts of the organization. 8. A network enabled project management system is selected and implemented at the most effective (project portfolio or total enterprise) level. 46

47 Roles and Responsibilities Demands 9. All of the project integrative roles are clearly defined, understood and assigned to qualified people. 10. A portfolio steering group is appointed for each project portfolio. 11. An executive sponsor is appointed for every major project and portfolio. 12. An experienced manager of project management is appointed for each PMO. 13. Appropriate homes (PMOs) are established within the organization for the project management discipline. 47

48 Manager Training and Authority Demands 14. All major project and program managers are given the training needed to ensure their effective performance. 15. Each project manager respects the functional lines of authority when giving project direction to their team members. 16. Functional (line) managers and project leaders respect the project lines of authority as exercised by the project managers. 48

49 Project Controls Demands 17. Every project is planned and controlled within the guidelines specified in the corporate project management processes documentation. 18. All project planning and control systems and procedures are integrated so that all project information is current and consistent throughout the organization. 19. Only one summarizing project planning and control system is used throughout the organization. 20. Earned value progress evaluation and forecasting methods are applied on all major projects. 49

50 Project Controls Demands (Cont d) 21. The corporate project management process includes a detailed description of the corporate project management information and control system. 22. All required technical, risk, and project information modules are included in the corporate project management process and the overall corporate information and control system. 23. All (with specifically approved exceptions) reporting documents are produced by the supporting computer software systems. 24. The concepts of the project/work breakdown structure (P/WBS) and project interface management are applied to achieve an effective, sustainable level of detail in project documentation. 50

51 Project Team Demands 25. A complete project team list is produced and distributed to all key team members. 26. Each project team develops a statement of project objectives that all team members understand and support consistent with the official project objectives within two weeks of the team formation. 27. Project teams set both hard and soft criteria for project success in the eyes of the key project stake-holders. 28. Each team establishes an achievable project plan to which all team members are committed. 29. The corporate project management process documentation includes the procedures needed to in-sure effective teamwork. 30. Project managers are given appropriate leadership training prior to their being put in charge of any major project. 51

52 Project Post-Completion Demand 31. A post-completion appraisal is performed on every project to: 1) determine whether the business plan benefits of the project have been achieved, 2) document the lessons learned, and 3) improve the corporate project management process, practices and procedures. 52

53 Maturity in Project Management The PM maturity of an organization for specific types of projects can be measured effectively. This measurement is useful to determine where improvements are needed and to benchmark against competitors capabilities. The existence of a PMO for more than one year is directly related to higher PM Maturity 53

54 PM Maturity Research Check your own PM maturity at no cost And see reports on 7 years of project management maturity research in Brazil and 3 other countries at 54

55 Project Management Recognition Development of the Project Management as a Profession Professional associations, standards, registration, and certifications PMI: 400,000 members in 120 countries, 266 formal chapters in over 80 countries; 4 million copies of PMI PMBOK in 11 languages IPMA: 120,000 members in its federation of 55 national organizations around the world Plus many others: IAPM, AACEi, CMAA, ISO, CPM, GAPPS, PDMA. University degrees in Project Management: 55

56 Conclusions 56

57 Project Management Is Now a Vital Core Capability for All Enterprises Strategies are achieved through projects All significant innovation is achieved through projects Therefore knowledge of and capability in project and program management has now become vital to all executives and managers in every sector of human endeavor 57

58 Your Mission! Adapt and present this information to your executives at all levels. Convince them that PPPM is an essential core capability for all enterprises that desire to innovate, survive, and prosper. 58

59

60 60