NCQA's Health Insurance Plan Rankings Medicare Plans October 18, 2010

Transcription

1 1 Capital Health Plan HMO 89 Yes FL 2 Kaiser Foundation Health Plan of Colorado HMO 88.9 Yes CO 3 Fallon Community Health Plan HMO 88.9 Yes MA 4 Kaiser Foundation Health Plan of the Northwest HMO 88.7 Yes OR, WA 5 Kaiser Foundation Health Plan of Southern California (H0524) HMO 88.4 Yes CA 6 Security Health Plan of Wisconsin HMO 88.4 Yes WI 7 Tufts Associated Health Maintenance Organization HMO 88.3 Yes MA 8 Kaiser Foundation Health Plan of Northern California (H0524) HMO 88.2 Yes CA 9 MVP Health Care (Rochester Area) HMO 87.7 Yes NY 10 Geisinger Health Plan HMO 87.6 Yes PA 11 Group Health Cooperative HMO 87.3 Yes WA 12 Kaiser Foundation Health Plan of Hawaii HMO 87.3 Yes HI 13 Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Massachusetts HMO 87 Yes MA 14 Kaiser Foundation Health Plan of the Northwest HMO 86.9 Yes OR, WA (Demonstration Project) 15 Capital District Physicians' Health Plan HMO 86.9 Yes NY 16 Medical Associates Health Plan HMO 86.7 Yes IA, IL 16 Medical Associates Health Plans HMO 86.7 Yes WI 18 Independent Health Association HMO 86.6 Yes NY 19 Kaiser Foundation Health Plan of the Mid-Atlantic States HMO 86.4 Yes DC, MD, VA 20 Health First Health Plans HMO 86.2 Yes FL 21 Health Alliance Medical Plans HMO 86.2 Yes IL 22 Keystone Health Plan Central HMO 86.1 Yes PA 23 MVP Health Care HMO 86.1 Yes NY 24 Univera Healthcare HMO 86.1 Yes NY 25 Blue Care Network of Michigan HMO 86 Yes MI 26 Excellus BlueCross BlueShield HMO 86 Yes NY 27 HealthPlus of Michigan HMO 85.9 Yes MI 28 HealthAmerica Pennsylvania HMO 85.9 Yes PA 29 Keystone Health Plan West HMO 85.9 Yes PA 30 Kaiser Foundation Health Plan of Georgia HMO 85.3 Yes GA 31 SummaCare HMO/POS 85.3 Yes OH 32 HealthNow New York HMO 84.9 Yes NY 33 Aetna Health - Pennsylvania HMO 84.9 Yes PA 34 Empire BlueCross BlueShield HMO 84.9 Yes NY 35 Health Alliance Plan of Michigan HMO 84.9 Yes MI 36 UnitedHealthcare of New England HMO/POS 84.5 Yes RI 37 Scott and White Health Plan HMO 84.5 Yes TX 38 Kaiser Foundation Health Plan of Ohio HMO 84.4 Yes OH 39 AmeriHealth HMO (New Jersey) HMO/POS 84.3 Yes NJ 40 PrimeTime Health Plan HMO 84.3 Yes OH Specific plan demographic data supplied by AIS s Directory of Health Plans ( Page: 1 of 7

2 41 Cariten Health Plan HMO 84 Yes TN 42 Humana Health Plan of Kansas City HMO 84 Yes KS, MO 43 UPMC Health Plan HMO 83.8 Yes OH, PA, WV 44 Humana Health Benefit Plan of Louisiana HMO 83.6 Yes LA 45 Aetna Health - New York HMO 83.6 Yes NY 46 HIP Health Plan of New York (H3330) HMO 83.6 Yes NY 47 Oxford Health Plans (CT) HMO 83.5 Yes CT 48 Aetna Health (New Jersey) - Northern New Jersey HMO 83.5 Yes NJ 49 AvMed Health Plans HMO 83.5 Yes FL 50 Aetna Health (New Jersey) - Southern New Jersey HMO 83.5 Yes NJ 51 UnitedHealthcare Plan of the River Valley HMO 83.5 Yes IA, IL, TN, VA 52 Paramount Health Care HMO 83.4 Yes OH 53 Presbyterian Health Plan HMO 83.4 Yes NM 54 PacifiCare of Oregon HMO 83.3 Yes OR 55 Medical Mutual of Ohio HMO/POS 83.2 Yes OH 56 Keystone Health Plan East HMO 83.1 Yes PA 57 PacifiCare of Colorado HMO 83 Yes CO 58 Aetna Health (Pennsylvania) - Ohio HMO 83 Yes OH 59 PacifiCare of Washington HMO 82.6 Yes WA 60 PacifiCare of Arizona HMO 82.6 Yes AZ 61 Health Net of California HMO 82.4 Yes CA 62 Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield in Ohio HMO 82.4 Yes OH 63 Health Plan of the Upper Ohio Valley, The (H5151) HMO 82.4 Yes OH, WV 64 Aetna Health (Pennsylvania) - Maryland HMO 82.3 Yes MD 65 UnitedHealthcare of Florida (H1080) HMO/POS 82.2 Yes FL 66 PacifiCare of California HMO Yes CA com 67 Aetna Health - Florida HMO 82.2 Yes FL 68 Health Plan of the Upper Ohio Valley, The (H3672) HMO 82 Yes OH, WV 69 Humana Health Plan of Texas HMO 82 Yes TX 70 Lovelace Health Plan HMO 81.9 Yes NM 71 UnitedHealthcare of North Carolina HMO/POS 81.8 Yes NC 72 Health Options HMO 81.5 Yes FL 73 Oxford Health Plans (NY) HMO 81.4 Yes NY 74 Humana Medical Plan of Florida HMO 81.4 Yes FL 75 UnitedHealthcare of Florida (H9011) HMO/POS 81.4 Yes FL 76 PacifiCare of Texas HMO 81.3 Yes TX 77 Aetna Health - Georgia HMO 81.3 Yes GA 78 Aetna Health of California HMO 81.3 Yes CA 79 Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield in Kentucky HMO 80.9 Yes KY 80 Aetna Health - Texas HMO 80.8 Yes TX 81 Blue Shield of California HMO 80.6 Yes CA 82 Humana Health Plan of Arizona HMO 80.4 Yes AZ Specific plan demographic data supplied by AIS s Directory of Health Plans ( Page: 2 of 7

3 83 Freedom Health HMO 80.4 Yes FL 84 PacifiCare of Oklahoma HMO 80.3 Yes OK 85 Health Plan of Nevada (H2961) HMO 80 Yes NV 86 UnitedHealthcare of New York HMO 79.9 Yes NY 87 UnitedHealthcare Insurance (Mid-Atlantic) HMO/POS 79.8 Yes DC, VA 88 Universal Health Care HMO/POS 79.7 Yes FL 89 UnitedHealthcare of Georgia (H1111) HMO/POS 79.5 Yes GA 90 Oxford Health Plans (NJ) HMO 79.5 Yes NJ 91 UnitedHealthcare Insurance of Alabama HMO 79.4 Yes AL 92 Bravo Health Pennsylvania HMO 79.1 Yes PA 93 Bravo Health Pennsylvania (Senior Partners) HMO 79.1 Yes PA 94 UnitedHealthcare of Tennessee HMO/POS 78.9 Yes TN 95 Humana Medical Plan of Florida (AdvantageCare) HMO 78.8 Yes FL 96 Optimum Healthcare HMO 78.6 Yes FL 97 Aetna Health (Pennsylvania) - Illinois HMO 78.5 Yes IL 98 Bravo Health Texas HMO 78.2 Yes TX 99 Care1st Health Plan HMO 77.1 Yes CA Health Plan of Nevada (H2931) HMO 77 Yes NV Gundersen Lutheran Health Plan HMO 74.1 No WI Group Health (Cost) HMO 74 No MN, WI Priority Health HMO 74 No MI UCare (H2459) HMO/POS 72 No MN, WI Martin's Point Health Care HMO 71.5 No ME Providence Health Plans - Oregon HMO/POS 71.5 No OR, WA BlueCross BlueShield of North Carolina HMO 70.6 No NC medicare-supplement 108 Florida Health Care Plans HMO 70.6 No FL Dean Health Plan HMO 70.5 No WI Health Net of Connecticut HMO 70.3 No CT Welborn Health Plans HMO 70.3 No IN ConnectiCare HMO 70.2 No CT KelseyCare Advantage HMO 70.1 No TX Humana Benefit Plan of Illinois HMO 69.6 No IL Essence Healthcare (H2610) HMO 69.6 No IL, MO CIGNA HealthCare of Arizona (CIGNA Medicare Select Plus RX) HMO 69.4 No AZ HealthPartners (MSHO) HMO 69.3 No MN Essence Healthcare (H1837) HMO 69.3 No WA UnitedHealthcare Insurance (Midlands) HMO/POS 69.2 No IA, NE UnitedHealthcare of the Midlands HMO/POS 69.2 No IA, NE Partnership Health Plan HMO 69.1 No WI Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield - Connecticut HMO 69 No CT Specific plan demographic data supplied by AIS s Directory of Health Plans ( Page: 3 of 7

4 123 UnitedHealthcare of Rhode Island HMO 69 No RI Fidelis Care New York POS 68.9 No NY Clarian Health Plans (H1553) HMO 68.8 No IN Samaritan Advantage Health Plans HMO 68.7 No OR UnitedHealthcare of Wisconsin HMO/POS 68.7 No WI Western Health Advantage HMO 68.7 No CA Coventry Health Care of Kansas HMO 68.5 No KS, MO HealthSpring of Tennessee (H4454) HMO 68.4 No MS, TN Mt. Carmel Health Plan HMO 68.3 No OH Banner MediSun HMO 68.1 No AZ Rocky Mountain Health Plans HMO 68.1 No CO, WY Health Net of Arizona HMO 67.7 No AZ UnitedHealthcare of Massachusetts (Evercare) HMO 67.5 No MA Essence Healthcare (H8778) HMO 67.4 No IN, KY Denver Health Medical Plan HMO 67.4 No CO Horizon HMO HMO/POS 67.4 No NJ UnitedHealthcare of Ohio HMO/POS 66.7 No OH SelectCare of Texas HMO 66.6 No TX SCAN Health Plan Legacy/Connections HMO 66.4 No AZ, CA CommunityCare Managed Healthcare Plans of Oklahoma HMO 66.4 No OK Partnership HealthPlan of California HMO 66.4 No CA SCAN Health Plan Classic/Connections/Options/Signature HMO 66.4 No AZ, CA UnitedHealthcare Insurance (OR/WA) HMO/POS 66.2 No OR, WA Gateway Health Plan HMO 66.1 No PA UnitedHealthcare of Washington HMO 66.1 No WA Humana Health Plan - Chicago Market HMO 66.1 No IL GEMCare Health Plan HMO 66.1 No CA Elderplan HMO 66 No NY UnitedHealthcare of the Midwest HMO/POS 66 No IL, MO UnitedHealthcare of Utah HMO/POS 65.9 No UT Managed Health HMO 65.9 No NY CarePlus Health Plans HMO 65.8 No FL Inter Valley Health Plan HMO 65.8 No CA HealthSpring HMO 65.7 No TX SCAN Health Plan Gold/Gold Select/Silver HMO 65.6 No AZ, CA UnitedHealthcare of Arizona HMO/POS 65.4 No AZ Vista Healthplan HMO 65.4 No FL Blue Cross Blue Shield of Georgia HMO 65.4 No GA Vista Healthplan of South Florida HMO 65.4 No FL Medica Healthcare Plans HMO 65.3 No FL ATRIO Health Plans HMO 65.3 No OR Vantage Health Plan HMO/POS 65.2 No LA Specific plan demographic data supplied by AIS s Directory of Health Plans ( Page: 4 of 7

5 165 Marion Polk Community Health Plan Advantage HMO 64.8 No OR HealthSpring of Tennessee (H4407) HMO 64.8 No MS, TN UnitedHealthcare of Colorado HMO/POS 64.6 No CO Community Health Plan of Washington HMO 64.3 No WA Humana Health Plan of Nevada HMO 64.2 No NV Healthfirst Health Plan of New Jersey HMO 64.2 No NJ Colorado Access Health Plan HMO 64.2 No CO Health Plan of San Mateo HMO 63.9 No CA Abri Health Plan HMO 63.9 No WI UnitedHealthcare Insurance (Illinois) HMO/POS 63.8 No IL Summit Health Plans HMO 63.6 No FL Health Choice Generations HMO 63.6 No AZ Passport Health Plan HMO 63.1 No KY Molina Healthcare of Michigan HMO 63 No MI SelectCare of Texas (Dallas/Fort Worth) HMO 62.6 No TX HealthSpring of Illinois HMO 62.4 No IL GlobalHealth HMO 62.2 No OK Evercare of Texas HMO 61.8 No TX Anthem Blue Cross HMO 61.7 No CA Insufficient Data Aetna Health - Connecticut HMO Yes CT Insufficient Data Aetna Health - Maine HMO Yes ME Insufficient Data Aetna Health (Pennsylvania) - Arizona HMO Yes AZ Insufficient Data Aetna Health (Pennsylvania) - Delaware HMO No DE Insufficient Data Aetna Health (Pennsylvania) - Oklahoma HMO Yes OK Insufficient Data Aetna Health (Pennsylvania) - Tennessee HMO Yes TN Insufficient Data Alameda Alliance for Health HMO No CA Insufficient Data AlohaCare HMO No HI Insufficient Data AMERIGROUP Florida HMO No FL Insufficient Data AMERIGROUP Maryland HMO No MD Insufficient Data AMERIGROUP New Jersey HMO No NJ Insufficient Data Arcadian Health Plan HMO No LA Insufficient Data Arcadian Health Plan HMO No WA Insufficient Data Arcadian Health Plan (Desert Canyon Community Care) HMO No AZ Insufficient Data Arcadian Health Plan (Northeast Community Care) HMO No ME Insufficient Data Arcadian Health Plan (Southeast Community Care) HMO No NC Insufficient Data Arcadian Health Plan (Southeast Community Care) HMO No GA Insufficient Data Arcadian Health Plan (Southeast Community Care) HMO No SC Insufficient Data Arcadian Health Plan (Texas Community Care) HMO No TX Insufficient Data Arkansas Community Care HMO No AR Insufficient Data Bravo Health Mid-Atlantic HMO Yes DC, MD Insufficient Data CareMore HealthPlan HMO No CA Insufficient Data Central Health Plan of California HMO No CA Specific plan demographic data supplied by AIS s Directory of Health Plans ( Page: 5 of 7

6 Insufficient Data Chinese Community Health Plan HMO No CA Insufficient Data Citizens Choice Healthplan HMO No CA Insufficient Data Citrus Health Care HMO No FL Insufficient Data Clarian Health Plans (H7220) HMO/POS No IN Insufficient Data Clear One Health Plans HMO/POS No OR Insufficient Data Commonwealth Care Alliance HMO No MA Insufficient Data Easy Choice Health Plan HMO No CA Insufficient Data Group Health Plan HMO No IL, MO Insufficient Data Harmony Health Plan of Illinois HMO No IL Insufficient Data Harmony Health Plan of Indiana HMO No IN Insufficient Data Harmony Health Plan of Missouri HMO No MO Insufficient Data HealthSpring HMO No AL Insufficient Data HealthSun Health Plans HMO No FL Insufficient Data HIP Health Plan of New York (H3314) HMO No NY Insufficient Data HMO California/Brand New Day HMO No CA Insufficient Data Humana Health Plan (Colorado) HMO No CO Insufficient Data Inland Empire Health Plan HMO No CA Insufficient Data Kaiser Foundation Health Plan of Northern California (H6052) HMO No CA Insufficient Data Kaiser Foundation Health Plan of Southern California (H6050) HMO No CA Insufficient Data Leon Medical Centers Health Plans HMO No FL Insufficient Data MD Care Health Plan HMO No CA Insufficient Data Mercy Care Plan HMO No AZ Insufficient Data Mercy Health Plan of Missouri HMO No MO Insufficient Data MetroPlus Health Plan HMO No NY Insufficient Data Mid Rogue Independent Physician Association HMO No OR Insufficient Data Molina Healthcare of California Partner Plan HMO No CA Insufficient Data ONECare by Care1st HealthPlan Arizona HMO No AZ Insufficient Data PacifiCare of Nevada HMO No NV Insufficient Data Physicians Health Choice HMO No NM, TX Insufficient Data Physicians Health Choice HMO No NM, TX Insufficient Data Preferred Care Partners Health Plan HMO No FL Insufficient Data PrimeWest Health HMO No MN Insufficient Data SCAN Health Plan Arizona Classic/Connections HMO No AZ, CA Insufficient Data Trillium Community Health Plan HMO No OR Insufficient Data UCare (H4270) HMO/POS No MN, WI Insufficient Data UnitedHealthcare Insurance (Florida) HMO No FL Insufficient Data UnitedHealthcare Insurance (KS/MO) HMO/POS No KS, MO Insufficient Data UnitedHealthcare Insurance (Maryland) HMO/POS No MD Insufficient Data UnitedHealthcare Insurance (Pennsylvania) HMO/POS No PA Insufficient Data UnitedHealthcare Insurance of Massachusetts (Secure Horizons) HMO/POS Yes MA Specific plan demographic data supplied by AIS s Directory of Health Plans ( Page: 6 of 7

7 Insufficient Data UnitedHealthcare of Arkansas HMO/POS No AR Insufficient Data UnitedHealthcare of Georgia (H2182) HMO/POS No GA Insufficient Data UnitedHealthcare Plan of the River Valley HMO No TN Insufficient Data VNS CHOICE HMO No NY Insufficient Data WellCare of Connecticut HMO No CT Insufficient Data WellCare of Florida HMO No FL Insufficient Data WellCare of Georgia HMO No GA Insufficient Data WellCare of Louisiana HMO No LA Insufficient Data WellCare of New Jersey HMO No NJ Insufficient Data WellCare of New York HMO No NY Insufficient Data WellCare of Ohio HMO No OH Insufficient Data WellCare of Texas HMO No TX Insufficient Data Windsor Health Plan HMO No AL, AR, MS, SC, TN No Data Reported Arizona Physicians IPA HMO No AZ No Data Reported Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Rhode Island POS No RI No Data Reported Blue Cross of Idaho Health Services HMO No ID No Data Reported CalOPTIMA HMO No CA No Data Reported Medica HMO No MN, ND, SD, WI No Data Reported Medica (Cost) HMO No MN, ND, SD, WI No Data Reported Peoples Health Network HMO/POS No LA No Data Reported Physicians United Plan HMO No FL No Data Reported Quality Health Plans HMO No FL No Data Reported Touchstone Health (H3327) HMO No NY No Data Reported UCare (H2456) HMO No MN, WI No Data Reported Unison Health Plan of Pennsylvania HMO No PA No Data Reported VIVA Health HMO No AL Specific plan demographic data supplied by AIS s Directory of Health Plans ( Page: 7 of 7