Risk Margin for a NonLife Insurance RunOff


 Neal Berry
 2 years ago
 Views:
Transcription
1 Risk Margin for a NonLife Insurance RunOff Mario V. Wüthrich, Pau Embrechts, Andreas Tsanakas August 15, 2011 Abstract For sovency purposes insurance companies need to cacuate socaed bestestimate reserves for outstanding oss iabiity cash fows and a corresponding risk margin for nonhedgeabe insurancetechnica risks in these cash fows. In actuaria practice, the cacuation of the risk margin is often not based on a sound mode but various simpified methods are used. In the present paper we propery define these notions and we introduce insurancetechnica probabiity distortions. We describe how the atter can be used to cacuate a risk margin for nonife insurance runoff iabiities in a mathematicay consistent way. Key words. Caims reserving, bestestimate reserves, runoff risks, risk margin, market vaue margin, oneyear uncertainty, caims deveopment resut, marketconsistent vauation. 1 Marketconsistent vauation The main task of an actuary is to predict and vaue insurance cash fows. These predictions and vauations form the basis for premium cacuation as we as for sovency considerations of an insurance company. As a consequence, and in order to be abe to successfuy run the insurance business, actuaries need to have a good understanding of such insurance cash fows. In most situations, insurance cash fows are not traded on deep and iquid financia markets. Therefore vauation of insurance cash fows basicay means pricing in an incompete financia market setting. Artice 75 of the Sovency II Framework Directive Directive 2009/138/EC states iabiities sha be vaued at the amount for which they coud be transferred, or setted, between two knowedgeabe wiing parties in an arm s ength transaction. The genera understanding ETH Zurich, RiskLab, Department of Mathematics, 8092 Zurich, Switzerand Senior Swiss Finance Institute Professor Cass Business Schoo, City University, 106 Bunhi Row, London EC1Y 8TZ, UK 1
2 is that this amount shoud consist of two components, namey the socaed bestestimate reserves for the cash fows and a risk margin for nonhedgeabe risks in these cash fows. We wi discuss these two eements in detai by giving an economicay based approach how they can be cacuated. The cacuation of the bestestimate reserves is fairy straightforward. Artice 77 of the Sovency II Framework Directive says the best estimate sha correspond to the probabiityweighted average of future cashfows, taking account of time vaue of money... the cacuation of the best estimate sha be based upon uptodate and credibe information.... This simpy means that the bestestimate reserves are a time vaue adusted conditiona expectation of future cash fows, conditioned on the information that we have coected up to today. The cacuation of the risk margin has ed to more discussion as there is no genera understanding on how it shoud be cacuated. The most commony used approach is the socaed costofcapita approach. The costofcapita approach is based on the reasoning that a financia agent provides for every future accounting year the risk bearing capita that protects against adverse deveopments in the runoff of the insurance cash fows. Since that financia agent provides this yeary protection, a reward in the form of a yeary price is expected. The tota of these yeary prices constitutes the socaed costofcapita margin which is then set equa to the risk margin. The difficuty with this costofcapita approach is that in amost a situations it is not tractabe. It invoves pathdependent mutiperiod risk measures; see SazmannWüthrich [10. In most interesting cases these pathdependent mutiperiod risk measure oadings can not be cacuated anayticay, nor can they be cacuated numericay in an efficient way because they usuay invove arge amounts of nested simuations. Therefore, various proxies are used in practice. Probaby the two most commony used proxies are the proportiona scaing proxy and the spit of tota uncertainty proxy; see SazmannWüthrich [10, Wüthrich [13 and Artices TP.5.32 and TP.5.41 of QIS5 [9. Reated papers are ArtznerEisee [1 and Möhr [8. In this paper we present a competey different, more economicay based approach. We argue that the risk margin shoud be reated to the risk aversion of the financia agent that provides the protection against adverse deveopments. This risk aversion can be modeed using probabiity distortion techniques and this wi ead to a mathematicay fuy consistent risk margin. Under the proposed method, riskadusted vaues of insurance cash fows are cacuated as expected vaues after modifying distorting the probabiities used. This kind of idea has been used in actuaria practice for a very ong time, however typicay in the fied of ife insurance mathematics, corresponding to the construction of first order ife tabes out of second order ife tabes. Second 2
3 order ife tabes are expected death/surviva probabiities whereas for first order ife tabes a safety oading is added to insure that the ife insurance premium is sufficienty high. We appy these ideas to the context of nonife insurance iabiities. We study the runoff of outstanding oss iabiities in a chain adder framework. Using probabiity distortions, we deveop socaed riskadusted chain adder factors from the cassica chain adder factors. These riskadusted factors have a surprisingy simpe form and aow for a natura incusion of the risk margin into our considerations. Reated iterature to these probabiity distortion considerations and the reated changeofmeasure techniques in financia mathematics are, among others, Bühmann et a. [2, Denuit et a. [4, FömerSchied [5, TsanakasChristofides [11, Wang [12 and Wüthrich et a. [14. The paper is organized as foows. In the next section we define the Bayesian ognorma chain adder mode for caims reserving. Within this mode we then cacuate the bestestimate reserves as required by the sovency directive; see Section 3 beow. In Section 4 we introduce genera insurancetechnica probabiity distortions. An expicit choice for the atter then provides the positive risk margin. Finay, in Section 5 we provide a rea data exampe that is based on private iabiity insurance data. We compare our numerica resuts to other concepts used in practice. A the proofs of the statements are provided in the Appendix. 2 Mode assumptions We assume that a fina time horizon n N is given and consider the insurance cash fow vauation probem in discrete time t 0,..., n}. For simpicity we assume that the time unit corresponds to years. We denote the underying probabiity space by Ω, G, P and assume that, on this probabiity space, we have two fows of information given by the fitrations F = F t t=0,...,n and T = T t t=0,...,n. We assume F 0 and T 0 are the trivia σfieds. The fitration F corresponds to the financia market fitration and T corresponds to the insurancetechnica fitration. In order to keep the mode simpe, we assume that these two fitrations are stochasticay independent under the probabiity aw P; see aso Section 2.6 in Wüthrich et a. [14. Of course, this ast assumption can be rather restrictive in appications, however, we emphasize that it can be reaxed by expressing insurance iabiities in the right financia units; see the vauation portfoio construction in Wüthrich et a. [14. This independent decouping into financia variabes adapted to F and insurancetechnica vari 3
4 abes adapted to T impies that we can repicate expected insurance cash fows in terms of defautfree zero coupon bonds; see Assumption 5.1 and Remark 5.2 in Wüthrich et a. [14. This is inine with Artice 77 of the Sovency II Framework Directive, but needs to be questioned if we have no independent decouping into financia and insurancetechnica variabes. Insurance cash fows are denoted by X i,, where i 1,..., I} are the accident years of the insurance caims origin years and 0,..., J} are the deveopment years of these insurance caims payment deays. We assume that a caims are setted after deveopment year J and that I J + 1. With this terminoogy, cash fow X i, is paid in accounting year k = i +. This provides the accounting year cash fows over a accident years i 1,..., I} X k = i+=k X i, = I k i=1 k J X i,k i = J k 1 =0 k I X k,. We denote the tota cash fow by X = X 1,..., X n and the outstanding oss iabiities at time t < n are given by X t+1 = 0,..., 0, X t+1,..., X n. Thus, our aim is to mode, predict and vaue this outstanding oss iabiity cash fow X t+1 for every t < n. For the modeing of the cash fow X we use the foowing Bayesian chain adder mode. Mode 2.1 Bayesian ognorma chain adder mode We assume n = I + J and T t = σ X i, ; i + t, i = 1,..., I, = 0,..., J} for a t = 1,..., I + J; conditionay, given Φ = Φ 0,..., Φ J 1 and σ = σ 0,..., σ J 1, we have X i, are independent for different accident years i; cumuative payments C i, = =0 X i, satisfy def. Ci,+1 ξ i,+1 = og 1 C i, Ti+,Φ,σ N Φ, σ 2 for = 0,..., J 1 and i = 1,..., I; σ > 0 is deterministic and Φ, = 0,..., J 1, are independent with Φ N φ, s 2, with prior parameters φ and s > 0, and 4
5 X 1,0,..., X I,0 and Φ are independent. We assume that the insurancetechnica fitration T is generated by the insurance cash fows X i,. This suggests that this is the ony insurancetechnica information avaiabe to sove the cash fow prediction probem. Moreover, since we have assumed independence between F and T we know that the time vaue adustments of cash fows need to be done with defautfree zero coupon bonds. This immediatey impies that the bestestimate reserves for the outstanding oss iabiities at time t < n are given by R t Xt+1 = k t+1 E [X k T t P t, k = E [X i, T t P t, k, 2.1 k t+1 i+=k where P t, k is the price at time t of the defautfree zero coupon bond that matures at time k. This definition of bestestimate reserves provides the necessary martingae framework for the oint fitration of F and T under the measure P which in these terms provides an arbitragefree pricing framework; for more detais see Chapter 2 in Wüthrich et a. [14. We have chosen a Bayesian Ansatz in the assumptions of Mode 2.1. The advantage of a Bayesian mode is that the parameter uncertainty is, in a natura way, incuded in the mode, and parameter estimation is canonica using posterior distributions. Moreover, we have chosen an exact credibiity mode see BühmannGiser [3, Chapter 2 which has the advantage that we obtain cosed form soutions for posterior distributions. However, our anaysis is by no means restricted to the Bayesian ognorma chain adder mode. Other modes can be soved competey anaogousy, but in some cases one has to rey on simuation methods such as the Markov Chain Monte Caro MCMC simuation methodoogy. 3 Bestestimate reserves cacuation In formua 2.1 we have defined the bestestimate reserves. In this section we cacuate these bestestimate reserves expicity for Mode 2.1. We assume that t I, which impies that at time t a initia payments X i,0 have been observed for accident years i 1,..., I}. For i + > t we then obtain, using the tower property for conditiona expectations note that we aso condition on the mode parameters Φ, 2 E [X i, T t, Φ = C i,t i =t i exp Φ + σ 2 /2} + 1 exp Φ 1 + σ 2 1/2 }
6 For a proof, we refer to Lemma 5.2 in WüthrichMerz [15. Formua 3.1 impies that we woud ike to do Bayesian inference on Φ, given the observations T t. That is, we woud ike to determine the posterior distribution of Φ at time t. This then provides the Bayesian predictor [ 2 E [X i, T t = C i,t i E exp Φ + σ 2 /2} + 1 exp Φ 1 + σ 1/2 2 } T t. =t i In Mode 2.1 we can expicity provide the posterior density of Φ, given the observations T t : } J 1 I } h Φ T t exp 1 t i J 2s 2 Φ φ 2 exp 1 =0 2σ 2 ξ i, Φ 1 2. i=1 1 The first term on the righthand side is the prior information about the parameters Φ, the second =1 term is the ikeihood function of the observations, given the parameters Φ. density immediatey provides the foowing theorem. This posterior Theorem 3.1 In Mode 2.1, the posteriors of Φ, given T t with t I, are independent normay distributed random variabes with Φ Tt N φ t, st 2, and posterior parameters φ t = s t 2 φ s σ 2 t 1 I i=1 ξ i,+1 and s t 2 = 1 s t 1 I σ 2. Theorem 3.1 impies that φ t = E [Φ T t = β t ξ t + 1 β t φ, 3.2 with sampe mean and credibiity weight given by ξ t = t 1 I 1 t 1 I i=1 ξ i,+1 and β t = [t 1 I s2 σ 2 + [t 1 I. s2 Hence, the posterior mean of Φ is a credibiity weighted average between the sampe mean ξ t and the prior mean φ with credibiity weight β t. For noninformative prior information we et s and find that β t 1 which means that we give fu credibiity to the observation based parameter estimate ξ t. For perfect prior information we et s 0 and concude that β t 0, i.e. we give fu credibiity to the prior estimate φ. Using the posterior independence and Gaussian properties of Φ we obtain the foowing coroary for the Bayesian predictor. 6
7 Coroary 3.2 In Mode 2.1 we obtain, for i + > t I, with posterior chain adder factors 2 E [X i, T t = C i,t i =t i f t f t 1 1, f t = E [ exp Φ + σ 2 /2} + 1 } T t = exp φ t + s t 2 /2 + σ 2 / Moreover, f t t=0,...,n are P, Tmartingaes for a = 0,..., J 1. This emma has the consequence that, in Mode 2.1, the bestestimate reserves at time t I are given by I R t Xt+1 = i=t+1 J C i,t i J =t i+1 2 =t i f t f t 1 1 P t, i This soves the question about the cacuation of bestestimate reserves for outstanding oss iabiities: it is a probabiityweighted, time vaue adusted amount that considers the most recent avaiabe information. We now turn to the more chaenging cacuation of the risk margin which covers deviations from these bestestimate reserves. 4 Riskadusted reserves and risk margin In this section we define the risk margin using the economic argument that a risk averse financia agent wi ask for a premium that is higher than the conditionay expected discounted caim. This wi be achieved by introducing a probabiity distortion on the payments X i, which wi ead to the socaed riskadusted reserves R + t Xt+1 at time t. The risk margin at time t can then by defined as the difference RM t Xt+1 = R + t Xt+1 Rt Xt+1, 4.1 which wi be stricty positive under an appropriate probabiity distortion. Before doing this expicity for the Bayesian chain adder mode, we describe the probabiity distortions that we are going to use in more generaity. The crucia idea is that we introduce a density process ϕ = ϕ 0,..., ϕ n that modifies the probabiities in an appropriate way. The probabiity distortion functions introduced by Wang [12 reate to our framework in sufficienty smooth cases and the changeofmeasure techniques from financia mathematics are obtained by the transformations presented in Sections 2.5 and 2.6 of Wüthrich et a. [14. 7
8 4.1 Insurancetechnica probabiity distortions An insurancetechnica probabiity distortion ϕ = ϕ 0,..., ϕ n is a Tadapted and stricty positive stochastic process that is a P, Tmartingae with normaization ϕ 0 = 1. This is exacty the definition given in of Wüthrich et a. [14 and means that ϕ is a density process w.r.t. P, T which can be used for a changeofmeasure. For a cash fow X we can then define the riskadusted units by Λ t,k = 1 ϕ t E [ϕ k X k T t. In view of 2.1, the riskadusted reserves are then defined by R + t Xt+1 = k t+1 Λ t,k P t, k = k t+1 i+=k 1 ϕ t E [ϕ k X i, T t P t, k. 4.2 For the choice ϕ 1 the bestestimate reserves and the riskadusted reserves coincide, but for an appropriate risk averse choice of ϕ we wi obtain a stricty positive risk margin RM t Xt+1. For the atter, it is required that ϕ k T t and X k T t are positivey correated, where in this case using the martingae property of ϕ Λ t,k = 1 ϕ t E [ϕ k X k T t 1 ϕ t E [ϕ k T t E [X k T t = E [X k T t. This correation inequaity is often achieved by using the FortuinKasteeynGinibre FKG inequaity from [6, which sometimes is aso caed the supermoduar property. The positive correatedness impies that more probabiity weight is given to adverse scenarios. In order to have timeconsistency w.r.t. to risk aversion, we require that Λ t,k t=0,...,n is a P, T supermartingae. This impies that E [Λ t+1,k E [X k T t+1 T t Λ t,k E [X k T t, 4.3 which says that, in expectation, the risk margin is constanty reeased over time. 4.2 Riskadusted reserves for the Bayesian chain adder mode In the previous section, using insurancetechnica probabiity distortions, we have given the genera concept for the cacuation of a positive risk margin. In the present section we give an expicit exampe for the insurancetechnica probabiity distortion ϕ that wi fit to our Bayesian chain adder mode. We make the foowing particuar choice: J I ϕ n = exp α 1 ξ i, + α 2 Φ 1 Iα 1 + α 2 φ 1 Iα 1 + α 2 2 s2 1 2 =1 i=1 Iα 2 1 σ }, 4.4 8
9 where α 1, α 2 0 are fixed constants. As wi become apparent beow, the parameters α 1 and α 2 characterize risk aversion: α 1 reates to the process risk in ξ i, and α 2 to the parameter uncertainty in Φ. We then define the insurancetechnica probabiity distortion ϕ by ϕ t = E [ϕ n T t. Lemma 4.1 ϕ is a stricty positive and normaized P, Tmartingae. The proof of the emma is provided in the appendix. theorem. We are now ready to state our main Theorem 4.2 In Mode 2.1 we have, for k > t I and i k J,..., I}, 1 ϕ t E [ϕ k X i,k i T t = C i,t i k i 2 =t i f +t f +t k i 1 1, with riskadusted chain adder factors } f +t = exp φ t + st 2 + σ2 2 2 exp α 2 + [I t 1α 1 s t 2 + α 1 σ 2 } + 1. The theorem is proved in the appendix. In view of Coroary 3.2 and Theorem 4.2 we obtain, for t I, the inequaity f +t f t. The posterior chain adder factors f t the bestestimate reserves at time t, the riskadusted chain adder factors f +t provide provide riskadusted reserves that consider both process risk in ξ i, and parameter uncertainty in Φ. The riskadusted reserves are then given by R + t Xt+1 = I i=t+1 J C i,t i J =t i+1 2 =t i f +t f +t 1 1 P t, i +, 4.5 and we obtain a positive risk margin RM t Xt+1. Remarks. We observe that it is fairy easy to cacuate the riskadusted reserves in the Bayesian ognorma chain adder Mode 2.1 with probabiity distortion 4.4, a that we need to do is to modify the chain adder factors appropriatey: f +t = f t 1 The foowing function for t I 0, exp α 2 + [I t 1α 1 s t 2 + α 1 σ 2 } τ,t α 1, α 2 = exp α 2 + [I t 1α 1 s t 2 + α 1 σ }
10 exacty refects this modification according to the risk aversion parameters α 1 0 and α 2 0. Note that τ,t α 1, α 2 is deterministic and, as stated before, represents the eve of prudence simiar to the construction of the first and second order ife tabes in ife insurance. The parameter α 2 refects risk aversion in the parameter uncertainty and the parameter α 1 refects risk aversion in the process risk. However, α 1 aso infuences parameter uncertainty because in the Bayesian anaysis we do inference on the parameters from the observed information T t. This concept of constructing riskadusted chain adder factors is by no means excusive to the Bayesian ognorma chain adder mode. It can be appied to other chain adder modes, or even more broady, to every caims reserving and pricing mode simiar as the risk neutra measure constructions in financia mathematics. It hence yieds a very genera concept for constructing a risk margin. We have chosen the Bayesian ognorma chain adder mode because of its practica reevance and because it aows for cosed form soutions, heping interpretation. Note that 4.4 gives a specia type of probabiity distortion, other choices coud have been made. The remaining, more economic and reguatory, question then is: which are aternative constructions of insurancetechnica probabiity distortions used in practice, and how shoud these be caibrated? 4.3 Expected runoff of the risk margin In this subsection we study the expected runoff of the bestestimate and of the riskadusted reserves. For this, we need to foowing emma. Lemma 4.3 For t I s I 0 we have f +t,s [ = E f +t T s = f s 1 τ,t α 1, α The proof of this emma immediatey foows from 4.6 and the martingae property of the chain adder factors f t t=0,...,n. Observe that τ,t α 1, α 2 is decreasing in t which gives the supermartingae property 4.3. Moreover, we have the foowing theorem. Theorem 4.4 For t > s I we have for the expected bestestimate reserves E [ R t Xt+1 T s, F s = I J C i,s i i=t+1 J =t i+1 2 =s i f s f s 1 1 E [P t, i + F s, 10
11 and for the expected riskadusted reserves E [ [ R + I t Xt+1 Ts, F s = i=t+1 J J =t i+1 C i,s i t i 1 2 =t i =s i f +t,s f s f +t,s 1 1 E [P t, i + F s Note that, in order to proect the expected runoff of the bestestimate reserves and the risk margin for t s I, we aso need to mode the expected future zero coupon bond prices E [P t, i + F s. In the next section we give a numerica exampe for this runoff.. 5 Rea data exampe We present a rea data exampe. The data set is a private iabiity insurance cash fow triange. In Tabe 4 we provide the cumuative payments C i, = =0 X i, for i We choose the fina accident year under consideration I = 17 and we assume that a caims are setted after deveopment year J = 16. We then consider the runoff situation at time I for t = I,..., n = 33. Using the parameter choices from Tabe 4 we are abe to cacuate the credibiity weights β t and the posterior means φ t at time t = 17. In Figure 1 we present the prior means φ, sampe prior mean sampe mean posterior mean Figure 1: Prior mean φ, sampe mean ξ t and posterior mean φ t for = 0,..., 15 and t = 17. means ξ t and posterior means φ t based on the data T t with t = 17. We see that the posterior mean smooths the sampe mean using the prior mean with credibiity weights 1 β t ; see aso the credibiity formua
12 Next, we need to provide the term structure for the zero coupon bond prices at time t = 17 in order to cacuate the bestestimate and the riskadusted reserves. We choose the actua CHF bond yied curve avaiabe from the Swiss Nationa Bank. Finay, we choose the risk aversion parameters: α 1 = 0.02 and α 2 = 1. Now, we are ready to cacuate the bestestimate and the riskadusted reserves, they are given in Tabe 1. These reserves are cacuated under the actua R 17 X 18 R + 17 X 18 RM 17 X 18 reserves under actua ZCB prices nomina reserves, i.e. P 17, k discounting effect discounting effect in % 2.82% 2.90% 4.64% Tabe 1: Bestestimate reserves R 17 X 18, riskadusted reserves R + 17 X 18 and risk margin RM 17 X 18 for the data set given in Tabe 4. CHF bond yied curve and for nomina prices, i.e. P 17, k 1. We observe that the discounting effect is quite sma which comes from the fact that we are currenty in a ow interest rate period. On the other hand we obtain a risk margin RM 17 X 18 of which is 4.54% in terms of the bestestimate reserves R 17 X 18. Of course, the size of this risk margin heaviy depends on the choice of the risk aversion parameters. In our case we have chosen these such that we obtain a simiar risk margin as in the costofcapita approach under the parameter choices used for Sovency II. If we choose the spit of tota uncertainty approach from SazmannWüthrich [10 with security oading φ = 2 and costofcapita rate c = 6% see formua 4.2 in [10 and TP.5.25 in [9 we obtain for nomina reserves a risk margin of see aso Tabe 3 which is comparabe to the of the probabiity distortion approach. Finay, the baancing between α 1 and α 2 was done such that if we turn off one of these two parameters then the risk margin has simiar size; see Tabe 2. The question of the choice of the risk aversion parameters aso needs input from the reguator. The atter gives the ega framework within which a oss portfoio transfer needs to take pace. This question concerns whether or not the insurance portfoio is sent into runoff. Moreover, the reguator needs to decide at which state of the economy this transfer shoud take pace between socaed wiing financia agents because this aso determines their risk aversion. In Tabe 3 we compare the probabiity distortion approach 4.5 to the spit of tota uncertainty Swiss Nationa Bank s website: 12
13 R 17 X 18 R + 17 X 18 RM 17 X 18 α 1 = 0.02 and α 2 = α 1 = 0 and α 2 = α 1 = 0.02 and α 2 = Tabe 2: Bestestimate reserves R 17 X 18, riskadusted reserves R + 17 X 18 and risk margin RM 17 X 18 for different risk aversion parameter choices. nomina reserves R 17 X 18 R + 17 X 18 RM 17 X 18 probabiity distortion approach spit of tota uncertainty approach [ proportiona scaing proxy TP.5.41 in [ Tabe 3: Comparison of probabiity distortion approach 4.5, spit of tota uncertainty approach [10 and proportiona scaing proxy TP.5.41 in [9 in the risk measure framework of [10. approach proposed in SazmannWüthrich [10 and to the proportiona scaing proxy which is the method used in QIS5 [9, Artice TP.5.41, see aso SazmannWüthrich [10 and Keer [7. We see that in this exampe the proportiona scaing proxy is ceary beow the other two approaches. This is further investigated in Figure 3 beow we aso refer to Wüthrich [13. Next, we cacuate the expected runoff of the bestestimate reserves and the risk margin. Therefore, we need a stochastic mode for the deveopment of the term structure which determines future zero coupon bond prices; see Theorem 4.4. For simpicity we ony consider nomina cash fows for the runoff anaysis which avoids modeing future zero coupon bond prices, i.e. we set P t, k 1 for t, k 17. Figure 3 provides for this case the expected runoff of the bestestimate reserves and the risk margin. Finay, we cacuate the expected reative runoff of the risk margins defined by w k = E [ RM k Xk+1 T 17, F 17 RM 17 X18 for k 17. We observe that the spit of tota uncertainty approach v k 1, as defined in SazmannWüthrich [10, gives a simiar picture to the risk margin runoff pattern w k, see Figure 3. On the other hand, the proportiona scaing proxy v k 2 from Artice TP.5.41 in QIS5 [9, see aso Sazmann Wüthrich [10 and Keer [7 ceary underestimates runoff risks. This agrees with the findings 13
14 30'000 25'000 20'000 15'000 10'000 5' bestestimate reserves risk margin Figure 2: Expected runoff of the bestestimate reserves E [ R k Xk+1 T 17, F 17 and the risk margin E [ RM k Xk+1 T17, F 17 for k = 17,..., n 1. in Wüthrich [13 and refects that the expected caims reserves as voume measure for the runoff risk scaing is not appropriate. The main reason for this underestimation of the proportiona scaing proxy is that the payout of the caims reserves takes paces much faster than the reease of insurance technica risk because we first sette sma nonrisky caims and risky caims stay in the runoff portfoio for much onger accounting for the fact that their settement is more difficut. 6 Concusion We have considered the concept of insurancetechnica probabiity distortions for the cacuation of the risk margin in nonife insurance. This concept is based on the assumption that financia agents are risk averse which is refected by a positive correation between the insurancetechnica probabiity distortions and the insurance cash fows. This then provides, in a natura and mathematicay consistent way, a positive risk margin. For our specific choice within the Bayesian ognorma chain adder mode we have found that this concept resuts in choosing prudent chain adder factors. The prudence margin refects the risk aversion in process risk and parameter uncertainty. We have compared our choice of the risk margin to the methods used in practice and we have found that the quaitative resuts are simiar to the more advanced methods presented 14
15 100% 80% 60% 40% 20% 0% runoff w_k runoff v_k 1 runoff v_k 2 Figure 3: Expected reative runoff of the risk margins w k, k 17, compared to the spit of tota uncertainty approach v k 1 of SazmannWüthrich [10 and the proportiona scaing proxy v k 2 see Artice TP.5.41 in QIS5 [9 and SazmannWüthrich [10. in SazmannWüthrich [10. In the present paper we have chosen one specific insurancetechnica probabiity distortion because this choice has ed to cosed form soutions. Future research shoud investigate aternative constructions of probabiity distortions according to market behavior of financia agents and it shoud aso investigate the question how these choices can be caibrated. In our exampe, we have assumed that the insurance cash fow is independent from financia market deveopments. This has resuted in the choice of the defautfree zero coupon bond as repicating financia instrument. Future research shoud aso anayze situations where this independence assumption is not appropriate. A Proofs Proof of Lemma 4.1. The strict positivity and the martingae property immediatey foow from the definition of ϕ. So there remains the proof of the normaization ϕ 0 = 1. Using the assumptions of Mode 2.1 and the tower property we obtain note that T 0 =, Ω} [ J 1 ϕ 0 = E [ϕ n = E [E [ ϕ n Φ = E exp Iα 1 + α 2Φ Iα 1 + α 2φ Iα 1 + α 2 2 s 2 /2 } = 1. This proves the caim. =0 15
16 Proof of Theorem 4.2. Note that we have C i,k i = X i,k i X i,k i 1, therefore it is sufficient to prove the caim for cumuative caims C i,k i. We first condition on the knowedge of the chain adder parameters Φ, 1 ϕ t E [ϕ k C i,k i T t = 1 ϕ t E [ϕ n C i,k i T t = 1 ϕ t E [E [ϕ n C i,k i T t, Φ T t. Further, ϕ n = [ J =1 =1 I exp α 1ξ, } J 1 =0 exp α 2Φ Iα 1 + α 2φ Iα 1 + α 2 2 s 2 2 σ 2 } Iα This means, that conditionay on Φ, the first term in the brackets is the ony random term in ϕ n. Define ϕ Φ t = E [ϕ n T t, Φ = J =1 t I J 1 =0 =1 exp exp α 1ξ, α 1Φ 1 α 2 1σ 2 1/2 } Iα 1 + α 2Φ Iα 1 + α 2φ Iα 1 + α 2 2 s 2 }. 2 Hence, for k > t, E [ϕ n C i,k i T t, Φ = E [ ϕ Φ k C i,k i Tt, Φ. For the ast term, note that ϕ Φ t t=0,...,n is a martingae for the fitration T t, Φ t=0,...,n and that the cumuative caim C i,k i = C i,t i k i =t i+1 exp ξ i,} + 1 ony contains terms for accident year i which are conditionay independent given Φ. This impies that, for k > t, E [ ϕ Φ k We therefore concude that 1 ϕ t C i,k i Tt, Φ E [ϕ k C i,k i T t = Ci,t i ϕ t k i 1 = ϕ Φ t C i,t i E [ ϕ Φ t k i 1 =t i =t i exp Φ + α 1σ 2 + σ 2 /2 } + 1. exp Φ + α 1σ 2 + σ 2 /2 } + 1 T t. A.1 There are three important observations that aow to cacuate this ast expression. The first is that E [ ϕ Φ t Tt = ϕ t which is the tower property for conditiona expectations. The second comes from Theorem 3.1, namey we have posterior independence of the Φ s, conditionay given T t. This impies that expected vaues over the products of Φ can be rewritten as products over expected vaues. The third observation is that in the expected vaue of A.1 we have exacty the same product terms as in ϕ t except for the deveopment periods t i,..., k i 1}. This impies that a terms cance except the ones that beong to these deveopment parameters. If, in addition, we cance a constants and T tmeasurabe terms we arrive at 1 ϕ t E [ϕ k C i,k i T t k i 1 = C i,t i =t i E [ exp [I t 1α 1 + α 2Φ } exp Φ + α 1σ 2 + σ 2 /2 } + 1 Tt E [ exp [I t 1α 1 + α 2Φ } T t. 16
17 So there remains the cacuation of the terms in the product of the righthand side of the equaity above. Using Theorem 3.1 we obtain, for t i,..., k i 1}, E [ exp [I t 1α 1 + α 2Φ } exp Φ + α 1σ 2 + σ 2 /2 } + 1 T t This proves Theorem 4.2. E [ exp [I t 1α 1 + α 2Φ } T t E [ exp 1 + α2 + [I t 1α1Φ} Tt = exp α 1σ 2 + σ 2 /2 } + 1 E [ exp α 2 + [I t 1α 1Φ } T t } } = exp φ t + s t 2 /2 + σ 2 /2 exp α 2 + [I t 1α 1s t 2 + α 1σ Proof of Theorem 4.4. We ony prove the caim for the bestestimate reserves because the proof for the riskadusted reserves is competey anaogous. From Coroary 3.2 we see that φ t Therefore we can concentrate on this term. First we study the decouping of φ t use the credibiity formua for this term we obtain φ t = β t with credibiity weight given by ξ t + 1 β t φ = γ t 1 ξ t 1, γ t 1 φ t 1, s 2 is the ony random term in f t. conditionay given T t 1. If we γ t 1 = σ 2 + t. 1s2 This is the weknown iterative update mechanism of credibiity estimators; see for exampe BühmannGiser [3, Theorem 9.6. Therefore, conditiona on T t 1, ξ t 1,+1 is the ony random term in f t. Since a these terms beong to different accident years and deveopment periods for t i,..., J 1} we have posterior independence, conditiona on T t 1, which impies, for k > t I, that [ [ [ 2 2 E C i,t i f t f t 1 1 = E E C i,t i f t f t 1 1 = E [ =t i E [C i,t i T t 1 2 =t i [ E Ts f t T t 1 E [ f t Iteration of this argument competes the proof. =t i 1 1 Tt 1 Ts = E [ Tt 1 C i,t i 1 Ts 1 =t i 1 f t 1 f t T s. Acknowedgment. The authors woud ike to thank the referees for their constructive comments on an earier version of the paper. References [1 Artzner, P., Eisee, K Supervisory insurance accounting mathematics for provision  and sovency capita  requirement. Astin Buetin 40/2, [2 Bühmann, H., Debaen, F., Embrechts, P., Shiryaev, A.N On Esscher transforms in discrete finance modes. Astin Buetin 28/2, [3 Bühmann, H., Giser, A A Course in Credibiity Theory and its Appications. Springer. 17
18 [4 Denuit, M., Dhaene, J., Goovaerts, M., Kaas, R., Laeven, R Risk measurement with equivaent utiity principes. Statistics & Decisions 24/1, [5 Fömer, H, Schied, A Stochastic Finance. 2nd edition. de Gruyter, Studies in Mathematics 27. [6 Fortuin, C.M., Kasteeyn, P.W., Ginibre, J Correation inequaities on some partiay ordered sets. Comm. Math. Phys. 22, [7 Keer, P A primer for cacuating the Swiss Sovency Test cost of capita for a market vaue margin. Federa Office of Private Insurance. Avaiabe under: dam/fies/consutations/qis/qis2/ PrimerCoCM wo Scenarios pdf [8 Möhr, C Marketconsistent vauation of insurance iabiity by cost of capita. Submitted preprint. [9 Quantitative Impact Study QIS QIS5 Technica Specifications. Annex to Ca for Advice from CEIOPS on QIS5, Brusses, 5 Juy [10 Sazmann, R., Wüthrich, M.V Costofcapita margin for a genera insurance iabiity runoff. Astin Buetin 40/2, [11 Tsanakas, A., Christofides, N Risk exchange with distorted probabiities. Astin Buetin 36/1, [12 Wang, S.S A cass of distortion operators for pricing financia and insurance risks. J. Risk Insurance 67/1, [13 Wüthrich, M.V Runoff of the caims reserving uncertainty in nonife insurance: a case study. Zavarovaniski horizonti 6/3, [14 Wüthrich, M.V., Bühmann, H., Furrer, H MarketConsistent Actuaria Vauation. 2nd edition. Springer. [15 Wüthrich, M.V., Merz, M Stochastic Caims Reserving Methods in Insurance. Wiey. 18
19 a.y. deveopment year i φ σ s Tabe 4: Cumuative payments Ci, = =0 X i,, i + 17, parameters φ, σ and s. 19
Risk Margin for a NonLife Insurance RunOff
Risk Margin for a NonLife Insurance RunOff Mario V. Wüthrich, Pau Embrechts, Andreas Tsanakas February 2, 2011 Abstract For sovency purposes insurance companies need to cacuate socaed bestestimate
More informationEstimation of Tail Development Factors in the PaidIncurred Chain Reserving Method
Estimation of Tai Deveopment Factors in the aidincurred Chain Reserving Method by Michae Merz and Mario V Wüthrich AbSTRACT In many appied caims reserving probems in &C insurance the caims settement process
More informationDiscounted Cash Flow Analysis (aka Engineering Economy)
Discounted Cash Fow Anaysis (aka Engineering Economy) Objective: To provide economic comparison of benefits and costs that occur over time Assumptions: Future benefits and costs can be predicted A Benefits,
More informationRunoff of the Claims Reserving Uncertainty in NonLife Insurance: A Case Study
1 Runoff of the Claims Reserving Uncertainty in NonLife Insurance: A Case Study Mario V. Wüthrich Abstract: The marketconsistent value of insurance liabilities consists of the bestestimate prediction
More informationMeasuring operational risk in financial institutions
Measuring operationa risk in financia institutions Operationa risk is now seen as a major risk for financia institutions. This paper considers the various methods avaiabe to measure operationa risk, and
More informationTERM INSURANCE CALCULATION ILLUSTRATED. This is the U.S. Social Security Life Table, based on year 2007.
This is the U.S. Socia Security Life Tabe, based on year 2007. This is avaiabe at http://www.ssa.gov/oact/stats/tabe4c6.htm. The ife eperiences of maes and femaes are different, and we usuay do separate
More informationPricing and hedging of variable annuities
Cutting Edge Pricing and hedging of variabe annuities Variabe annuity products are unitinked investments with some form of guarantee, traditionay sod by insurers or banks into the retirement and investment
More informationBetting Strategies, Market Selection, and the Wisdom of Crowds
Betting Strategies, Market Seection, and the Wisdom of Crowds Wiemien Kets Northwestern University wkets@keogg.northwestern.edu David M. Pennock Microsoft Research New York City dpennock@microsoft.com
More informationOligopoly in Insurance Markets
Oigopoy in Insurance Markets June 3, 2008 Abstract We consider an oigopoistic insurance market with individuas who differ in their degrees of accident probabiities. Insurers compete in coverage and premium.
More informationAA Fixed Rate ISA Savings
AA Fixed Rate ISA Savings For the road ahead The Financia Services Authority is the independent financia services reguator. It requires us to give you this important information to hep you to decide whether
More informationCONTRIBUTION OF INTERNAL AUDITING IN THE VALUE OF A NURSING UNIT WITHIN THREE YEARS
Dehi Business Review X Vo. 4, No. 2, Juy  December 2003 CONTRIBUTION OF INTERNAL AUDITING IN THE VALUE OF A NURSING UNIT WITHIN THREE YEARS John N.. Var arvatsouakis atsouakis DURING the present time,
More informationKey Features of Life Insurance
Key Features of Life Insurance Life Insurance Key Features The Financia Conduct Authority is a financia services reguator. It requires us, Aviva, to give you this important information to hep you to decide
More informationEarly access to FAS payments for members in poor health
Financia Assistance Scheme Eary access to FAS payments for members in poor heath Pension Protection Fund Protecting Peope s Futures The Financia Assistance Scheme is administered by the Pension Protection
More informationStructural Developments and Innovations in the Asset Backed Commercial Paper Market
Structura Deveopments and Innovations in the Asset Backed Commercia Paper arket ark H. Adeson anaging Director, AssetBacked Commercia Paper oody s Investors Service Strategic Research Institute 1997
More informationSecure Network Coding with a Cost Criterion
Secure Network Coding with a Cost Criterion Jianong Tan, Murie Médard Laboratory for Information and Decision Systems Massachusetts Institute of Technoogy Cambridge, MA 0239, USA Emai: {jianong, medard}@mit.edu
More informationASYMPTOTIC DIRECTION FOR RANDOM WALKS IN RANDOM ENVIRONMENTS arxiv:math/0512388v2 [math.pr] 11 Dec 2007
ASYMPTOTIC DIRECTION FOR RANDOM WALKS IN RANDOM ENVIRONMENTS arxiv:math/0512388v2 [math.pr] 11 Dec 2007 FRANÇOIS SIMENHAUS Université Paris 7, Mathématiques, case 7012, 2, pace Jussieu, 75251 Paris, France
More informationTeamwork. Abstract. 2.1 Overview
2 Teamwork Abstract This chapter presents one of the basic eements of software projects teamwork. It addresses how to buid teams in a way that promotes team members accountabiity and responsibiity, and
More informationVirtual trunk simulation
Virtua trunk simuation Samui Aato * Laboratory of Teecommunications Technoogy Hesinki University of Technoogy Sivia Giordano Laboratoire de Reseaux de Communication Ecoe Poytechnique Federae de Lausanne
More informationThe Whys of the LOIS: Credit Risk and Refinancing Rate Volatility
The Whys of the LOIS: Credit Risk and Refinancing Rate Voatiity Stéphane Crépey 1, and Raphaë Douady 2 1 Laboratoire Anayse et Probabiités Université d Évry Va d Essonne 9137 Évry, France 2 Centre d économie
More informationLife Contingencies Study Note for CAS Exam S. Tom Struppeck
Life Contingencies Study Note for CAS Eam S Tom Struppeck (Revised 9/19/2015) Introduction Life contingencies is a term used to describe surviva modes for human ives and resuting cash fows that start or
More informationAdvanced ColdFusion 4.0 Application Development  3  Server Clustering Using Bright Tiger
Advanced CodFusion 4.0 Appication Deveopment  CH 3  Server Custering Using Bri.. Page 1 of 7 [Figures are not incuded in this sampe chapter] Advanced CodFusion 4.0 Appication Deveopment  3  Server
More informationPricing and Revenue Sharing Strategies for Internet Service Providers
Pricing and Revenue Sharing Strategies for Internet Service Providers Linhai He and Jean Warand Department of Eectrica Engineering and Computer Sciences University of Caifornia at Berkeey {inhai,wr}@eecs.berkeey.edu
More informationBusiness schools are the academic setting where. The current crisis has highlighted the need to redefine the role of senior managers in organizations.
c r o s os r oi a d s REDISCOVERING THE ROLE OF BUSINESS SCHOOLS The current crisis has highighted the need to redefine the roe of senior managers in organizations. JORDI CANALS Professor and Dean, IESE
More informationOlder people s assets: using housing equity to pay for health and aged care
Key words: aged care; retirement savings; reverse mortgage; financia innovation; financia panning Oder peope s assets: using housing equity to pay for heath and aged care The research agenda on the ageing
More informationNetwork/Communicational Vulnerability
Automated teer machines (ATMs) are a part of most of our ives. The major appea of these machines is convenience The ATM environment is changing and that change has serious ramifications for the security
More informationSorting, Merge Sort and the DivideandConquer Technique
Inf2B gorithms and Data Structures Note 7 Sorting, Merge Sort and the DivideandConquer Technique This and a subsequent next ecture wi mainy be concerned with sorting agorithms. Sorting is an extremey
More informationPricing Internet Services With Multiple Providers
Pricing Internet Services With Mutipe Providers Linhai He and Jean Warand Dept. of Eectrica Engineering and Computer Science University of Caifornia at Berkeey Berkeey, CA 94709 inhai, wr@eecs.berkeey.edu
More informationIncome Protection Options
Income Protection Options Poicy Conditions Introduction These poicy conditions are written confirmation of your contract with Aviva Life & Pensions UK Limited. It is important that you read them carefuy
More informationLeakage detection in water pipe networks using a Bayesian probabilistic framework
Probabiistic Engineering Mechanics 18 (2003) 315 327 www.esevier.com/ocate/probengmech Leakage detection in water pipe networks using a Bayesian probabiistic framework Z. Pouakis, D. Vaougeorgis, C. Papadimitriou*
More informationThis paper considers an inventory system with an assembly structure. In addition to uncertain customer
MANAGEMENT SCIENCE Vo. 51, No. 8, August 2005, pp. 1250 1265 issn 00251909 eissn 15265501 05 5108 1250 informs doi 10.1287/mnsc.1050.0394 2005 INFORMS Inventory Management for an Assemby System wh Product
More informationPayondelivery investing
Payondeivery investing EVOLVE INVESTment range 1 EVOLVE INVESTMENT RANGE EVOLVE INVESTMENT RANGE 2 Picture a word where you ony pay a company once they have deivered Imagine striking oi first, before
More informationA quantum model for the stock market
A quantum mode for the stock market Authors: Chao Zhang a,, Lu Huang b Affiiations: a Schoo of Physics and Engineering, Sun Yatsen University, Guangzhou 5175, China b Schoo of Economics and Business Administration,
More informationHedge Fund Capital Accounts and Revaluations: Are They Section 704(b) Compliant?
o EDITED BY ROGER F. PILLOW, LL.M. PARTNERSHIPS, S CORPORATIONS & LLCs Hedge Fund Capita Accounts and Revauations: Are They Section 704(b) Compiant? THOMAS GRAY Hedge funds treated as partnerships for
More informationJournal of Economic Behavior & Organization
Journa of Economic Behavior & Organization 85 (23 79 96 Contents ists avaiabe at SciVerse ScienceDirect Journa of Economic Behavior & Organization j ourna ho me pag e: www.esevier.com/ocate/j ebo Heath
More informationDistribution of Income Sources of Recent Retirees: Findings From the New Beneficiary Survey
Distribution of Income Sources of Recent Retirees: Findings From the New Beneficiary Survey by Linda Drazga Maxfied and Virginia P. Rena* Using data from the New Beneficiary Survey, this artice examines
More informationFast Robust Hashing. ) [7] will be remapped (and therefore discarded), due to the loadbalancing property of hashing.
Fast Robust Hashing Manue Urueña, David Larrabeiti and Pabo Serrano Universidad Caros III de Madrid E89 Leganés (Madrid), Spain Emai: {muruenya,darra,pabo}@it.uc3m.es Abstract As statefu fowaware services
More informationArt of Java Web Development By Neal Ford 624 pages US$44.95 Manning Publications, 2004 ISBN: 1932394060
IEEE DISTRIBUTED SYSTEMS ONLINE 15414922 2005 Pubished by the IEEE Computer Society Vo. 6, No. 5; May 2005 Editor: Marcin Paprzycki, http://www.cs.okstate.edu/%7emarcin/ Book Reviews: Java Toos and Frameworks
More informationSimultaneous Routing and Power Allocation in CDMA Wireless Data Networks
Simutaneous Routing and Power Aocation in CDMA Wireess Data Networks Mikae Johansson *,LinXiao and Stephen Boyd * Department of Signas, Sensors and Systems Roya Institute of Technoogy, SE 00 Stockhom,
More informationFixed income managers: evolution or revolution
Fixed income managers: evoution or revoution Traditiona approaches to managing fixed interest funds rey on benchmarks that may not represent optima risk and return outcomes. New techniques based on separate
More informationKey Features and Terms & Conditions of the Stocks & Shares Junior ISA
June 2013 Key Features and Terms & Conditions of the This document shoud be read in conjunction with an uptodate Key Investor Information Document (KIID) for the fund in which you want to invest. You
More informationCERTIFICATE COURSE ON CLIMATE CHANGE AND SUSTAINABILITY. Course Offered By: Indian Environmental Society
CERTIFICATE COURSE ON CLIMATE CHANGE AND SUSTAINABILITY Course Offered By: Indian Environmenta Society INTRODUCTION The Indian Environmenta Society (IES) a dynamic and fexibe organization with a goba vision
More informationCapacity of Multiservice Cellular Networks with TransmissionRate Control: A Queueing Analysis
Capacity of Mutiservice Ceuar Networs with TransmissionRate Contro: A Queueing Anaysis Eitan Atman INRIA, BP93, 2004 Route des Lucioes, 06902 SophiaAntipois, France aso CESIMO, Facutad de Ingeniería,
More informationBusiness Banking. A guide for franchises
Business Banking A guide for franchises Hep with your franchise business, right on your doorstep A true understanding of the needs of your business: that s what makes RBS the right choice for financia
More informationPREFACE. Comptroller General of the United States. Page i
 I PREFACE T he (+nera Accounting Office (GAO) has ong beieved that the federa government urgenty needs to improve the financia information on which it bases many important decisions. To run our compex
More informationHybrid Process Algebra
Hybrid Process Agebra P.J.L. Cuijpers M.A. Reniers Eindhoven University of Technoogy (TU/e) Den Doech 2 5600 MB Eindhoven, The Netherands Abstract We deveop an agebraic theory, caed hybrid process agebra
More informationFUNDING FOR RETAINED WORKERS COMPENSATION EXPOSURES. Brian Z. Brown Michael D. Price
FUNDING FOR RETAINED WORKERS COMPENSATION EXPOSURES Brian Z. Brown Michae D. Price Funding for Retained Workers Compensation Exposures ABSTRACT by Brian Z. Brown and Michae D, Price The sefinsured workers
More informationA Supplier Evaluation System for Automotive Industry According To Iso/Ts 16949 Requirements
A Suppier Evauation System for Automotive Industry According To Iso/Ts 16949 Requirements DILEK PINAR ÖZTOP 1, ASLI AKSOY 2,*, NURSEL ÖZTÜRK 2 1 HONDA TR Purchasing Department, 41480, Çayırova  Gebze,
More informationA short guide to making a medical negligence claim
A short guide to making a medica negigence caim Introduction Suffering from an incident of medica negigence is traumatic and can have a serious ongterm impact on both the physica and menta heath of affected
More informationThe Radix4 and the Class of Radix2 s FFTs
Chapter 11 The Radix and the Cass of Radix s FFTs The divideandconuer paradigm introduced in Chapter 3 is not restricted to dividing a probem into two subprobems. In fact, as expained in Section. and
More informationVALUE TRANSFER OF PENSION RIGHTS IN THE NETHERLANDS. June 2004  publication no. 8A/04
STICHTING VAN DE ARBEID REVISION VALUE TRANSFER OF PENSION RIGHTS IN THE NETHERLANDS June 2004  pubication no. 8A/04 Vaue transfer of pension rights in the Netherands 1. Introduction The opportunity to
More informationLADDER SAFETY Table of Contents
Tabe of Contents SECTION 1. TRAINING PROGRAM INTRODUCTION..................3 Training Objectives...........................................3 Rationae for Training.........................................3
More informationA New Statistical Approach to Network Anomaly Detection
A New Statistica Approach to Network Anomay Detection Christian Caegari, Sandrine Vaton 2, and Michee Pagano Dept of Information Engineering, University of Pisa, ITALY Emai: {christiancaegari,mpagano}@ietunipiit
More informationOracle Project Financial Planning. User's Guide Release 11.1.2.2
Orace Project Financia Panning User's Guide Reease 11.1.2.2 Project Financia Panning User's Guide, 11.1.2.2 Copyright 2012, Orace and/or its affiiates. A rights reserved. Authors: EPM Information Deveopment
More informationDesign of FollowUp Experiments for Improving Model Discrimination and Parameter Estimation
Design of FoowUp Experiments for Improving Mode Discrimination and Parameter Estimation Szu Hui Ng 1 Stephen E. Chick 2 Nationa University of Singapore, 10 Kent Ridge Crescent, Singapore 119260. Technoogy
More informationmedical injury a claimant s guide
medica injury a caimant s guide The ega caims process is not a simpe one and cinica negigence caims are amongst the most compex. We have over three decades of experience representing patients and recovering
More informationA Latent Variable Pairwise Classification Model of a Clustering Ensemble
A atent Variabe Pairwise Cassification Mode of a Custering Ensembe Vadimir Berikov Soboev Institute of mathematics, Novosibirsk State University, Russia berikov@math.nsc.ru http://www.math.nsc.ru Abstract.
More informationAustralian Bureau of Statistics Management of Business Providers
Purpose Austraian Bureau of Statistics Management of Business Providers 1 The principa objective of the Austraian Bureau of Statistics (ABS) in respect of business providers is to impose the owest oad
More informationHYBRID FUZZY LOGIC PID CONTROLLER. Abstract
HYBRID FUZZY LOGIC PID CONTROLLER Thomas Brehm and Kudip S. Rattan Department of Eectrica Engineering Wright State University Dayton, OH 45435 Abstract This paper investigates two fuzzy ogic PID controers
More informationComparison of Traditional and OpenAccess Appointment Scheduling for Exponentially Distributed Service Time
Journa of Heathcare Engineering Vo. 6 No. 3 Page 34 376 34 Comparison of Traditiona and OpenAccess Appointment Scheduing for Exponentiay Distributed Service Chongjun Yan, PhD; Jiafu Tang *, PhD; Bowen
More informationLESSON 13 TIME VALUE OF MONEY 13.0 AIMS AND OBJECTIVES 13.1 INTRODUCTION CONTENTS
Accounting and Finance for Managers LESSON 13 TIME VALUE OF MONEY CONTENTS 13.0 Aims and Objectives 13.1 Introduction 13.2 Foundations of The Time Vaue of Money 13.3 Cassifications of The Time Vaue of
More informationTort Reforms and Performance of the Litigation System; Case of Medical Malpractice [Preliminary]
Tort Reforms and Performance of the Litigation System; Case of Medica Mapractice [Preiminary] Hassan Faghani Dermi Department of Economics, Washington University in St.Louis June, 2011 Abstract This paper
More informationEstimation of Liabilities Due to Inactive Hazardous Waste Sites. by Raja Bhagavatula, Brian Brown, and Kevin Murphy
Estimation of Liabiities Due to Inactive Hazardous Waste Sites by Raja Bhagavatua, Brian Brown, and Kevin Murphy ESTIMATION OF LIABILITIES DUE TO INACTIVE HAZARDOUS WASTE SITJZS Abstract: The potentia
More informationCOMPARISON OF DIFFUSION MODELS IN ASTRONOMICAL OBJECT LOCALIZATION
COMPARISON OF DIFFUSION MODELS IN ASTRONOMICAL OBJECT LOCALIZATION Františe Mojžíš Department of Computing and Contro Engineering, ICT Prague, Technicá, 8 Prague frantise.mojzis@vscht.cz Abstract This
More informationLESSON LEVERAGE ANALYSIS 21.0 AIMS AND OBJECTIVES 21.1 INTRODUCTION 21.2 OPERATING LEVERAGE CONTENTS
LESSON 21 LEVERAGE ANALYSIS CONTENTS 21.0 Aims and Objectives 21.1 Introduction 21.2 Operating Leverage 21.3 Financia Leverage 21.4 EBITEPS Anaysis 21.5 Combined Leverage 21.6 Let us Sum up 21.7 Lessonend
More informationHow to deal with personal financial problems
How to dea with persona financia probems D I S P U T E R E S O L U T I O N Introduction Heping you face the future with confidence In 2014, the eve of consumer debt in the UK grew to reach a sevenyear
More informationInternal Control. Guidance for Directors on the Combined Code
Interna Contro Guidance for Directors on the Combined Code ISBN 1 84152 010 1 Pubished by The Institute of Chartered Accountants in Engand & Waes Chartered Accountants Ha PO Box 433 Moorgate Pace London
More informationOracle Hyperion Tax Provision. User's Guide Release 11.1.2.2
Orace Hyperion Tax Provision User's Guide Reease 11.1.2.2 Tax Provision User's Guide, 11.1.2.2 Copyright 2013, Orace and/or its affiiates. A rights reserved. Authors: EPM Information Deveopment Team Orace
More informationBetting on the Real Line
Betting on the Rea Line Xi Gao 1, Yiing Chen 1,, and David M. Pennock 2 1 Harvard University, {xagao,yiing}@eecs.harvard.edu 2 Yahoo! Research, pennockd@yahooinc.com Abstract. We study the probem of designing
More informationArtificial neural networks and deep learning
February 20, 2015 1 Introduction Artificia Neura Networks (ANNs) are a set of statistica modeing toos originay inspired by studies of bioogica neura networks in animas, for exampe the brain and the centra
More informationComputing the depth of an arrangement of axisaligned rectangles in parallel
Computing the depth of an arrangement of axisaigned rectanges in parae Hemut At Ludmia Scharf Abstract We consider the probem of computing the depth of the arrangement of n axisaigned rectanges in the
More informationManaging money and making a profit
Managing money and making a profit For your information How to get the most from today s workshop Ask questions Participate Worksheets Action Pan Today s objectives To hep you gain a greater understanding
More informationMarket Design & Analysis for a P2P Backup System
Market Design & Anaysis for a P2P Backup System Sven Seuken Schoo of Engineering & Appied Sciences Harvard University, Cambridge, MA seuken@eecs.harvard.edu Denis Chares, Max Chickering, Sidd Puri Microsoft
More information3.5 Pendulum period. 20090210 19:40:05 UTC / rev 4d4a39156f1e. g = 4π2 l T 2. g = 4π2 x1 m 4 s 2 = π 2 m s 2. 3.5 Pendulum period 68
68 68 3.5 Penduum period 68 3.5 Penduum period Is it coincidence that g, in units of meters per second squared, is 9.8, very cose to 2 9.87? Their proximity suggests a connection. Indeed, they are connected
More informationWHITE PAPER UndERsTAndIng THE VAlUE of VIsUAl data discovery A guide To VIsUAlIzATIons
Understanding the Vaue of Visua Data Discovery A Guide to Visuaizations WHITE Tabe of Contents Executive Summary... 3 Chapter 1  Datawatch Visuaizations... 4 Chapter 2  Snapshot Visuaizations... 5 Bar
More informationFinance 360 Problem Set #6 Solutions
Finance 360 Probem Set #6 Soutions 1) Suppose that you are the manager of an opera house. You have a constant margina cost of production equa to $50 (i.e. each additiona person in the theatre raises your
More informationWorkspace Group Plc. (incorporated and registered in England and Wales under number 2041612)
PROSPECTUS Workspace Group Pc (incorporated and registered in Engand and Waes under number 2041612) 6.00 per cent Stering Bonds due 2019 Issue price: 100 per cent 6.00 per cent Stering Bonds due 2019 (the
More informationeffect on major accidents
An Investigation into a weekend (or bank hoiday) effect on major accidents Nicoa C. Heaey 1 and Andrew G. Rushton 2 1 Heath and Safety Laboratory, Harpur Hi, Buxton, Derbyshire, SK17 9JN 2 Hazardous Instaations
More informationIntroduction the pressure for efficiency the Estates opportunity
Heathy Savings? A study of the proportion of NHS Trusts with an inhouse Buidings Repair and Maintenance workforce, and a discussion of eary experiences of Suppies efficiency initiatives Management Summary
More informationImperial Money Market Pool. Annual Management Report of Fund Performance
Imperia Money Market Poo Annua Management Report of Fund Performance for the financia year ended December 31, 2014 A figures are reported in Canadian doars uness otherwise noted This annua management report
More informationLet s get usable! Usability studies for indexes. Susan C. Olason. Study plan
Let s get usabe! Usabiity studies for indexes Susan C. Oason The artice discusses a series of usabiity studies on indexes from a systems engineering and human factors perspective. The purpose of these
More informationMeanfield Dynamics of LoadBalancing Networks with General Service Distributions
Meanfied Dynamics of LoadBaancing Networks with Genera Service Distributions Reza Aghajani 1, Xingjie Li 2, and Kavita Ramanan 1 1 Division of Appied Mathematics, Brown University, Providence, RI, USA.
More informationSELECTING THE SUITABLE ERP SYSTEM: A FUZZY AHP APPROACH. Ufuk Cebeci
SELECTING THE SUITABLE ERP SYSTEM: A FUZZY AHP APPROACH Ufuk Cebeci Department of Industria Engineering, Istanbu Technica University, Macka, Istanbu, Turkey  ufuk_cebeci@yahoo.com Abstract An Enterprise
More informationNCH Software MoneyLine
NCH Software MoneyLine This user guide has been created for use with MoneyLine Version 2.xx NCH Software Technica Support If you have difficuties using MoneyLine pease read the appicabe topic before requesting
More informationELECTRONIC FUND TRANSFERS YOUR RIGHTS AND RESPONSIBILITIES
About ELECTRONIC FUND TRANSFERS YOUR RIGHTS AND RESPONSIBILITIES The Eectronic Fund Transfers we are capabe of handing for consumers are indicated beow, some of which may not appy your account. Some of
More informationSeries B, US Dollar Hedged Series F
SIMPLIFIED PROSPECTUS Russe Funds June 30, 2015 No securities reguatory authority has expressed an opinion about these securities and it is an offence to caim otherwise. The funds and their securities
More informationVendor Performance Measurement Using Fuzzy Logic Controller
The Journa of Mathematics and Computer Science Avaiabe onine at http://www.tjmcs.com The Journa of Mathematics and Computer Science Vo.2 No.2 (2011) 311318 Performance Measurement Using Fuzzy Logic Controer
More informationGerman Working Papers in Law and Economics
German Working Papers in Law and Economics Voume 2003 Paper 21 Efficient Third Party Liabiity of Auditors in Tort Law and in Contract Law HansBernd Schäfer University of Hamburg, Germany Copyright c 2003
More informationUncertain Bequest Needs and LongTerm Insurance Contracts 1
Uncertain Bequest Needs and LongTerm Insurance Contracts 1 Wenan Fei (Hartford Life Insurance) Caude Fuet (Université du Québec à Montréa and CIRPEE) Harris Schesinger (University of Aabama) Apri 22,
More informationFinancial Accounting
Financia Accounting Course Text Professiona, Practica, Proven www.accountingtechniciansireand.ie Tabe of Contents FOREWORD...xi SYLLABUS: FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING...xiii CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION TO ACCOUNTING...1
More informationManagement Accounting
Management Accounting Course Text Professiona, Practica, Proven www.accountingtechniciansireand.ie Tabe of Contents FOREWORD...v SYLLABUS: MANAGEMENT ACCOUNTING...vii PART 1 INTRODUCTION Chapter 1: Introduction
More informationThe Web Insider... The Best Tool for Building a Web Site *
The Web Insider... The Best Too for Buiding a Web Site * Anna Bee Leiserson ** Ms. Leiserson describes the types of Webauthoring systems that are avaiabe for buiding a site and then discusses the various
More informationFederal Financial Management Certificate Program
MANAGEMENT CONCEPTS Federa Financia Management Certificate Program Training to hep you achieve the highest eve performance in: Accounting // Auditing // Budgeting // Financia Management ENROLL TODAY! Contract
More informationThe definition of insanity is doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results
insurance services Sma Business Insurance a market opportunity being missed Einstein may not have known much about insurance, but if you appy his definition to the way existing brands are deveoping their
More informationUndergraduate Studies in. Education and International Development
Undergraduate Studies in Education and Internationa Deveopment Wecome Wecome to the Schoo of Education and Lifeong Learning at Aberystwyth University. Over 100 years ago, Aberystwyth was the first university
More informationTeaching fractions in elementary school: A manual for teachers
Teaching fractions in eementary schoo: A manua for teachers H. Wu Apri 0, 998 [Added December, 200] I have decided to resurrect this fie of 998 because, as a reativey short summary of the basic eements
More informationA Description of the California Partnership for LongTerm Care Prepared by the California Department of Health Care Services
2012 Before You Buy A Description of the Caifornia Partnership for LongTerm Care Prepared by the Caifornia Department of Heath Care Services Page 1 of 13 Ony ongterm care insurance poicies bearing any
More informationGREEN: An Active Queue Management Algorithm for a Self Managed Internet
: An Active Queue Management Agorithm for a Sef Managed Internet Bartek Wydrowski and Moshe Zukerman ARC Specia Research Centre for UtraBroadband Information Networks, EEE Department, The University of
More informationThe guaranteed selection. For certainty in uncertain times
The guaranteed seection For certainty in uncertain times Making the right investment choice If you can t afford to take a ot of risk with your money it can be hard to find the right investment, especiay
More informationHistory of Stars and Rain Education Institute for Autism (Stars and Rain)
History of Education Institute for Autism () Estabished:: March 15. 1993 in Beijing Founder:: Ms. Tian Huiping (mother of a boy with autism) STARS AND RAIN was founded in 1993 by a parent and is China
More informationGWPD 4 Measuring water levels by use of an electric tape
GWPD 4 Measuring water eves by use of an eectric tape VERSION: 2010.1 PURPOSE: To measure the depth to the water surface beow andsurface datum using the eectric tape method. Materias and Instruments 1.
More information