Tax Deductible Spending, Environmental Policy, and the "Double Dividend" Hypothesis


 Kelly Arnold
 2 years ago
 Views:
Transcription
1 Tax Deducible Spending, Environmenal Policy, and he "Double Dividend" ypohesis Ian W.. Parry Anonio Miguel Beno Discussion Paper February P Sree, W Washingon, DC Telephone Fax Inerne: hp://www.rff.org 999 Resources for he Fuure. All righs reserved. o porion of his paper may be reproduced wihou permission of he auhors. Discussion papers are research maerials circulaed by heir auhors for purposes of informaion and discussion. They have no undergone formal peer review or he ediorial reamen accorded RFF books and oher publicaions.
2 Tax Deducible Spending, Environmenal Policy, and he "Double Dividend" ypohesis Ian W.. Parry and Anonio Miguel Beno Absrac A number of recen sudies have shown ha he general equilibrium welfare effecs of exernaliycorrecing policies depend imporanly on preexising axes in he economy, paricularly hose ha disor he labor marke. This paper exends he prior lieraure by allowing for consumpion goods ha are deducible from labor axes. These "goods" represen medical insurance, oher less angible fringe benefis, morgage ineres, and so on. The iniial ax sysem effecively subsidizes axfavored consumpion relaive o oher consumpion, in addiion o disoring he labor marke. We find ha incorporaing axfavored consumpion may overurn key resuls from earlier sudies. In paricular, a revenueneural polluion ax (or aucioned polluion permis) can produce a subsanial "double dividend" by reducing boh polluion and he coss of he ax sysem. The second dividend arises because he welfare gain from using environmenal ax revenues o cu labor axes is much larger when labor axes also disor he choice among consumpion goods. Indeed (ignoring environmenal benefis) he overall coss of a revenueneural polluion ax are negaive in our benchmark simulaions, a leas for polluion reducions up o 7 percen, and possibly up o 42 percen. In addiion, we show ha he presence of axfavored consumpion may dramaically increase he efficiency gain from using (revenueneural) emissions axes (or aucioned emissions permis) over grandfahered emissions permis. Key Words: environmenal policies, disorionary axes, ax deducions, welfare effecs JE Classificaion umbers: 23, Q28, 5 ii
3 Table of Conens. Inroducion Concepual Framework... 4 A. Assumpions... 4 B. The Welfare Effecs of Environmenal Policies... 5 C. Relaion o Previous Sudies umericallysolved Model... A. Funcional Forms... B. Model Calibraion Resuls...5 A. Marginal Coss...5 B. Toal Coss...7 C. Relaive Polluion Inensiies...20 D. Welfare under he Pigouvian Rule...2 E. Opimal Policies...22 F. Caveas Conclusions...24 Appendix A: Formal Derivaion of Welfare Effecs...26 Appendix B: Deriving a Formula for he MEB...30 Appendix C: The Relaionship beween he Elasiciy of Taxable Income and Key Parameers in our Analysis...3 References...32 is of Figures and Tables Figure... 6 Figure 2 Marginal Coss...6 Figure 3 Toal Coss...8 Figure 4 Varying he Polluion Inensiy of TaxFavored Consumpion...20 Figure 5 Welfare under he Pigouvian Rule...22 Figure 6 Opimal Policies...23 Table Alernaive Scenarios for Key Parameers...4 iii
4 TA DEDUCTIBE SPEDIG, EVIROMETA POICY, AD TE "DOUBE DIVIDED" YPOTESIS Ian W.. Parry and Anonio Miguel Beno *. ITRODUCTIO In recen years here has been a good deal of debae among academics and policy makers abou he ineracions beween environmenal policies and he ax sysem. These debaes arose in response o he socalled "double dividend" hypohesis, ha is he claim ha environmenal axes could simulaneously improve he environmen and reduce he economic coss of he ax sysem. The laer effec seemed plausible, if he revenues from axes on carbon emissions, gasoline, raffic congesion, household garbage, fish caches, chemical ferilizers, and so on, were used o reduce he raes of preexising axes ha disor labor and capial markes. Indeed i was suggesed ha he overall coss of revenueneural environmenal axes migh be negaive. If so, i would no be necessary o know he benefis from environmenal improvemenwhich are ofen highly uncerainin order o jusify an environmenal ax on cos/benefi crierion. owever, a number of recen analyical and numerical analyses have cas doub on he validiy of he double dividend hypohesis. The basic poin is ha he hypohesis ignores an imporan source of ineracion beween environmenal axes and preexising axes. Since environmenal axes raise he coss of producing oupu hey end o discourage (slighly) labor supply and invesmen, and hereby exacerbae he efficiency coss associaed wih ax disorions in labor and capial markes. In fac, aside from cerain special cases, hese sudies find ha he coss from his ineracion effec dominae any efficiency benefis from recycling environmenal ax revenues in oher ax reducions. Tha is, he presence of preexising ax disorions raise he coss of environmenal axes. The models in he recen lieraure ypically assume a uniform ax on labor (and possibly capial) income wih no ax deducions. Thus, in hese models he only he only * Ian W.. Parry, Resources for he Fuure; Anonio Miguel Beno, Universiy of Maryland. We graefully acknowledge he helpful commens and suggesions of Dallas Burraw, Alan Krupnick, Richard ewell, Wally Oaes, Mike Toman, Rob Williams, and seminar paricipans a Resources for he Fuure. We also hank he Environmenal Proecion Agency (Gran R825330) for financial suppor. Correspondence o: Ian Parry, Resources for he Fuure, 66 P Sree, Washingon, D.C Phone: (202) We do no go ino he deails of individual sudies here since he rise and fall of he double dividend hypohesis has been discussed a lengh in oher places. For recen surveys of he lieraure see Bovenberg and Goulder (998), Parry and Oaes (998), Goulder (995a) and Oaes (995). Our discussion is concerned wih models ha assume a compeiive labor marke, which is probably a reasonable approximaion a leas for he U.S. economy. The general equilibrium welfare effecs of environmenal policies are more complex when he labor marke conains significan insiuional disorions which make he real wage "sicky" (see e.g. Bovenberg and van der Ploeg, 998).
5 Parry and Beno RFF source of price disorion creaed by he ax sysem is in facor markes. owever, cerain ypes of spending are (a leas parially) deducible from labor axes. This includes, among oher hings, spending on morgage ineres, employerprovided medical insurance, and oher less angible fringe benefis. 2 In pracice, herefore, he ax sysem creaes an addiional source of price disorion: i effecively subsidizes axfavored spending relaive o all oher, nonaxfavored spending. Indeed some recen evidence poins o he empirical significance of his second source of economic disorion. Tradiionally, esimaes of he welfare cos from raising labor axes o finance governmen ransfers are in he order of 30 cens per dollar of revenue raised alhough here is a fair amoun of uncerainy concerning hese esimaes (see e.g., Browning, 987; Snow and Warren, 996). These sudies focus on he welfare impacs in he labor marke alone. owever, some very recen work suggess ha hese welfare coss may be subsanially higherpossibly wo or hree imes as highwhen he subsiuion beween axfavored consumpion and ordinary (nonaxfavored) consumpion is aken ino accoun (Feldsein, 995a). This paper exends previous lieraure by exploring he implicaions of axfavored consumpion for he general equilibrium coss, and overall welfare effecs (benefis less coss) of environmenal policies. We model a saic economy where households allocae heir ime beween leisure and labor supply. abor, along wih a clean inpu and a polluing inpu (e.g., energy or fossil fuels), is used o produce wo consumpion goods. Expendiure on one of he consumer goods is (parially) deducible from labor axaion. U.S. daa on labor marke parameers is used o calibrae he model. A firs glance, one migh hink ha if he disorionary coss of preexising axes are greaer han assumed in earlier sudies, hen he general equilibrium coss of new environmenal policies would also be greaer. owever we find he opposie resul is ypical for environmenal axes wih revenues used o cu personal income axes. Tha is, he presence of axfavored consumpion can subsanially reduce he coss of environmenal axes (relaive o heir coss in he absence of ax deducions). In fac, resuls on he double dividend hypohesis esablished in he earlier lieraure can easily be overurned, even under very conservaive esimaes for he coss of preexising axes. In our benchmark simulaions, ignoring any environmenal benefis, he ne impac of an environmenal ax swap is o reduce he overall economic coss of he ax sysem for polluion reducions up o a leas 60 percen. In oher words he general equilibrium coss of he policy are less han he parial equilibrium coss, and by a poenially subsanial amoun. Indeed he overall coss of polluion reducion are negaive for axes ha reduce polluion by 7 percen, and possibly up o 42 percen. A relaed poin is ha, in conras o ypical resuls from earlier sudies (e.g., Bovenberg and 2 There are a variey of oher major deducions from federal income axes, such as hose for pension and chariable conribuions, local income axes, acceleraed depreciaion, and so on. owever, for reasons discussed below we do no consider hese oher deducions o be relevan for our paricular analysis. 2
6 Parry and Beno RFF Goulder, 996; Parry, 995) we find he opimal environmenal ax may easily exceed he Pigouvian ax. These resuls arise because he welfare gain from using environmenal ax revenues o reduce labor axes is higher, and perhaps subsanially so, when labor axes disor he relaive prices among consumpion goods in addiion o he price of labor. In conras, (roughly speaking) he ineracion effec menioned above does no change because environmenal axes have approximaely he same impac on raising he price of consumpion goods relaive o leisure. Also, a leas in he case when he polluion inensiy is he same in boh he axfavored and he nonaxfavored consumpion secors, he environmenal ax does no aler he relaive price of he wo consumpion goods, and hence does no exacerbae he coss of he subsidy o axfavored consumpion. Since he gains from recycling environmenal ax revenues are larger, while he cos of he ineracion effec is no, he welfare coss of he environmenal ax are lowerand quie possibly of opposie signhan in earlier models. We also explore he implicaions of axfavored consumpion for he coss of oher policy insrumens. We find ha he coss of nonaucioned polluion emissions permis, or polluion axes whose revenues are reurned lumpsum (raher han used o reduce disorionary axes), could be significanly greaer or significanly less han found in previous sudies, depending on he relaive polluion inensiy of he axfavored consumpion secor. In addiion, regardless of he relaive polluion inensiy, he welfare gain from using revenueneural emissions axes (or aucioned emissions permis) insead of nonaucioned permis can be dramaically higher han suggesed by earlier sudies. This is due o he larger efficiency gain from using revenues from environmenal policies o reduce labor axes in he presence of axfavored consumpion. In many of our simulaions here is much more a sake in wheher environmenal policies raise revenues, and how hese revenues are recycled, han he (parial equilibrium) welfare gain from correcing he environmenal exernaliy. There are a number of imporan caveas o our analysis (hese are discussed in more deail below). Firs he absoluehough no he relaivecoss of emissions axes and emissions permis are sensiive o he relaive polluion inensiy of he axfavored secor. owever, even when he polluing inpu is used significanly less inensively in he axfavored secor here is sill he prospec for a subsanial double dividend, a leas for modes levels of polluion reducion. Second, in pracice he disorion beween marginal social benefi and marginal social cos in he marke for axfavored consumpion is a good deal more complicaed han assumed in our analysis. There are a number of possible eernal benefis, exernal coss, oher regulaions, and subsidies ha affec he overall size of his disorion. owever he empirical imporance of hese facors, and wheher heir ne impac is o increase or decrease he size of he disorion, is unclear. Third, here is also uncerainy abou wo oher imporan parameers in our model, namely he elasiciy of demand for axfavored consumpion and he labor supply elasiciy. Given hese uncerainies, we illusrae he welfare effecs of environmenal policies over a wide range of scenarios for parameer values, raher han emphasizing specific poin esimaes. These simulaion exercises clearly illusrae he seemingly crucial imporance of 3
7 Parry and Beno RFF accouning for axfavored spending. They also highligh he usefulness of fuure empirical sudies ha migh provide more accurae esimaes of cerain key parameers. The res of he paper is organized as follows. Secion 2 discusses he welfare effecs of alernaive environmenal policies in he presence of axfavored consumpion. Secion 3 describes our numerical model and Secion 4 provides he simulaion resuls. Secion 5 offers conclusions. 2. COCEPTUA FRAMEWORK In his secion we explain he general equilibrium welfare effecs of alernaive environmenal policies in he presence of (parially deducible) labor axaion, wih he aid of diagrams and cerain key formulas. This provides a concepual framework for inerpreing he subsequen numerical resuls. We provide a more rigorous mahemaical model, and he derivaion of he formulas, in Appendix A and B. 3 A he end of his secion we relae our resuls o hose in earlier sudies. A. Assumpions Consider a saic economy where wo final goods and Y are produced using labor and inermediae goods. denoes "axfavored" consumpion and represens an aggregae of consumpion goods ha are (a leas parially) deducible from labor axes. These "goods" include (morgage ineres paid on) owneroccupied housing, oher debfinanced spending secured by real esae, child care expendiures, and so on. They also include nonwage compensaion such as employerprovided medical insurance, life insurance, business lunches, healh clubs, and so on. 4 Y denoes an aggregae of consumpion goods ha do no receive preferenial ax reamen. There is a polluing inermediae good Z (e.g. coal), and a clean inermediae good C, boh of which are produced using labor. ousehold uiliy is adversely affeced by polluion. For simpliciy, assume ha polluion damages per uni of Z are consan φ. 5 In addiion we 3 The mahemaical derivaions of he welfare effecs (see Appendix A) are similar o hose in a number of recen models of environmenal policies in he presence of labor axes (e.g. Goulder e al., 997, 998; Parry e al., 998). In paricular, he analyical model in Parry e al. would be almos equivalen o ha in he curren paper, following he inroducion of a subsidy for one of he wo consumpion goods in heir household and governmen budge consrains. Thus, we hink here is more value added from using a diagrammaic approach in he above secion, in which he inuiion is more ransparen, and we relegae he (parially repeiive) mahemaical proofs o he Appendix. 4 A firs glance i migh seem ha axfavored consumpion should also include black marke aciviies where cash ransacions are no repored as axable income (possible examples include he hiring of nannies and gardeners). owever since hese aciviies are no observed hey are implicily couned as leisure aciviies, and hence are capured in sudies ha esimae how axes affec he subsiuion from observed labor supply ino leisure. 5 Some oher models (e.g. Goulder e al., 997) allow for he possibiliy ha polluion per uni of he diry inpu can be reduced, hrough he adopion of endofpipe abaemen echnologies. owever, his exension has very lile impac on he relaive welfare impacs of polluion axes and permis. 4
8 Parry and Beno RFF assume ha producion is compeiive and characerized by consan reurns o scale, herefore supply curves are perfecly elasic. We represen he ax sysem by assuming he governmen levies wo axes on gross labor earnings: a "comprehensive" labor ax C and a "noncomprehensive" ax. Expendiure on is deducible from he noncomprehensive ax bu no expendiure on Y. eiher good is deducible from he comprehensive ax. 6 The governmen reurns all revenues in a lumpsum ransfer (G) o he household secor. The (aggregae) household budge consrain amouns o: ( ) p + p Y = ( ) G (2.) Y C + where p and p Y are he producer prices of and Y which we normalize o uniy in he iniial equilibrium. is labor supply, which is responsive o he (neofax) real wage, since households gain uiliy from leisure. oe ha he ax sysem effecively axes labor income and subsidizes he consumpion of. Figure depics he equilibrium in each of he hree disored markes in he economy. These are he polluing inpu marke (upper panel), he marke for axfavored consumpion (middle panel) and he labor marke (boom panel). Demand and supply curves are denoed by "D" and "S" and iniial quaniies by subscrip 0. MSC Z denoes he marginal social cos of he polluing inpu which equals he supply price plus environmenal damages per uni. In he labor marke he demand curve is perfecly elasic, while he supply curve is upward sloping, reflecing he increasing marginal social cos of labor ime. 7 B. The Welfare Effecs of Environmenal Policies Suppose a ax of τ = φ is imposed on he polluing inpu and, for he momen, ha he revenue consequences of his policy are neuralized by changing he lump sum ransfer. The general equilibrium welfare change from his policy consiss of he welfare impacs in each of he hree disored markes (see Appendix A for a proof): (i) Pigouvian welfare gain. Imposing a ax of τ=φ on he polluing inpu reduces he quaniy o Z in Figure (a). This produces environmenal benefis equal o recangle abcd, or environmenal damages per uni of Z muliplied by he reducion in Z. 8 I also produces economic coss of riangle acd, which we call he primary cos of he policy. This equals he 6 In pracice some componens of, such as nonwage compensaion, are deducible from all labor axaion, ha is boh personal income and payroll axes. Oher componens of, such as morgage ineres, are deducible from income axes bu no payroll axes. 7 Our assumpion of consan reurns o scale, and ha labor is he only primary inpu, imply a fla labor demand curve. On he supply curve, a worker well o he lef of 0 has a relaively low opporuniy cos o being in he labor force and someone well o he righ of 0 would have a relaively high cos o being in he labor force. The laer may represen, for example, he parner of a working spouse who enjoys looking afer he house and children. 8 The change in Z is general equilibrium, ha is, afer he environmenal ax revenues have been reurned in exra ransfers. 5
9 Parry and Beno RFF Figure Price Z D (a) +φ f a b MSC Z e d c S Z Z Z 0 Polluing inpu (b) Price D P P 0 S S 0 ( ) P ( ) P 0 0 Taxfavored consumpion Wage (c) S S 0 D C 0 abor 6
10 Parry and Beno RFF reducion in consumer surplus (rapezoid acz 0 Z ), less he reducion in producion coss (recangle dcz 0 Z ). Environmenal benefis less he primary cos leaves he Pigouvian welfare gain, equal o he shaded riangle. (ii) Subsidyineracion effec. In he marke for axfavored consumpion here is a wedge of beween he supply price (equal o he marginal social cos of ) and he p demand price (equal o he marginal social benefi). The environmenal ax raises he coss of producing and his shifs he supply curve from S 0 o. The demand price increases from ( o p ) 0 ( and oupu falls o. This produces a welfare gain in his p ) marke equal o he shaded parallelogram. Tha is, for each uni reducion in he reducion in social coss exceeds he reducion in consumer benefis by he wedge beween he supply and demand price,.9 We refer o his welfare effec as he subsidyineracion effec. p The size of he subsidyineracion effec relaive o he primary cos depends on he size of he parallelogram relaive o riangle acd. The relaive heigh of hese wo areas reflecs he rae of subsidy relaive o he rae of environmenal ax. The base of he parallelogram relaive o he base of he riangle depends on wo imporan facors. Firs, he easier i is for firms o subsiue oher inpus in producion (labor and he clean inpu) for he diry inpu Z, he smaller will be he change in relaive o he change in Z. Second, noe ha Z is also an inpu in he producion of Y and hence he environmenal ax will drive up he price of Y. The greaer he increase in price of Y (relaive o he increase in price of ) he smaller will be he reducion in. Indeed (as illusraed below) if Z is used more inensively in Y han in he change in could acually be posiive, hereby reversing he sign of he subsidyineracion effec. Our numerical simulaions show ha he subsidyineracion effec is an empirically imporan deerminan of general equilibrium welfare coss when he relaive polluion inensiy differs markedly across he and Y indusries. (iii) Taxineracion effec. The posiion of he labor supply curve in Figure (c) depends on he prices of consumpion goods. In paricular, he increase in price of and Y caused by he environmenal ax reduces he amoun of consumpion ha can be purchased from a given nominal (neofax) wage. Tha is, he environmenal ax indirecly reduces he reurn o work effor relaive o leisure and his ypically causes he labor supply curve o shif upwards (slighly) o S. abor supply falls from 0 o and his produces a welfare loss equal o he shaded recangle. This recangle equals he wedge beween he gross wage (uniy)which equals he value marginal produc of laborand he ne of ax wage (( C ))which equals he opporuniy cos of an incremenal reducion in leisuremuliplied by he reducion in labor S 9 This is a simple applicaion of he familiar formulas for he general equilibrium welfare effec of a new ax in he presence of preexising price disorions (see e.g. arberger, 974, chapers. 2 and 3, and Appendix A below). oe ha a new ax causes a secondorder welfare effec (i.e. riangle) in he marke where i is imposed (in his case he polluing inpu marke). I causes a firsorder welfare effec (a recangle or parallelogram) in any oher marke of he economy where quaniies change and where here is a preexising price disorion (in his case an oupu marke). 7
11 Parry and Beno RFF supply. This is he axineracion effec, which is familiar from oher sudies (e.g. Goulder e al., 997; Parry, 995). For he environmenal ax wih lumpsum replacemen hese hree componens consiue he general equilibrium welfare effec of he policy (Appendix A). ow however, suppose ha one of he wo labor axes adjuss o mainain budge balance insead of he lumpsum ransfer. In his case an addiional welfare effec comes ino play. (iv) Revenuerecycling effecs. The ne revenue received by he governmen is somewha less han he revenue raised in he polluing inpu marke, φz in Figure (a), due o he loss of labor ax revenues in Figure (c). 0 Suppose ne revenues equal recangle fade in Figure (a). If his revenue is used o reduce he noncomprehensive ax insead of increasing he lumpsum ransfer, his produces wo sources of welfare gain. Firs, his (slighly) raises he neofax wage leading o an increase in labor supply. Second, i also (slighly) reduces he relaive subsidy for and herefore induces a subsiuion ou of axfavored consumpion and ino nonaxfavored consumpion. The combined welfare gain from hese wo effecs, per dollar of revenue recycled, is denoed MEB. This is equivalen o he marginal excess burden (MEB) of noncomprehensive labor axaion, ha is he welfare cos from spending an exra dollar of lumpsum ransfers financed by increasing he noncomprehensive labor ax. The oal welfare gain from using he polluion ax revenues o cu he noncomprehensive labor ax is MEB imes recangle fade. We refer o his as he revenuerecycling effec. 2 Suppose insead ha ne revenues are used o reduce he comprehensive labor ax. In his case here is a similar welfare gain in he labor marke, bu no gain from reducing he subsidy wedge in he marke for axfavored consumpion. Therefore (for he same amoun of revenues raised) he welfare gain from he revenuerecycling effec is smaller, MEB C imes recangle fade, where MEB C is he MEB for he comprehensive labor ax and MEB C <MEB. We say here is a "srong" revenuerecycling effec when he noncomprehensive labor ax is reduced and a "normal" revenuerecycling effec when he comprehensive labor ax is reduced. Emissions Permis ow suppose he quaniy of he polluing inpu is reduced o Z in Figure (a) by issuing he appropriae quaniy of polluion permis. This policy induces he same Pigouvian welfare gain as he environmenal ax. I also induces an analogous subsidyineracion effec 0 Alhough his revenue loss is parially offse o he exen ha axfavored consumpion falls. The direc revenues from he environmenal ax are likely o easily dominae he loss of labor ax revenues, excep when environmenal axes approach prohibiive levels (Parry, 995). The welfare gain in he labor marke is (approximaely) equal o he increase in labor supply muliplied by he wedge beween he gross and ne wage. The welfare gain in he marke equals (approximaely) he reducion in muliplied by he rae of noncomprehensive ax. 2 The revenuerecycling and axineracion effecs are familiar from earlier sudies. For ease of exposiion, we use a slighly differen definiion here. Oher sudies (e.g. Parry, 995; Goulder e al., 997) add on he welfare loss from he reducion in labor ax revenues o he cos of he axineracion effec, raher han subracing i from he revenuerecycling effec, as we have above. 8
12 Parry and Beno RFF and axineracion effec because i raises he price of he polluing inpu o he same level (+φ). The permi policy creaes rens of recangle φz. If he permis were aucioned he rens would accrue o he governmen and he general equilibrium welfare effec of he policy would be idenical o ha of he environmenal ax in our model. Insead, in keeping wih pracice so far in U.S. polluion conrol programs, we assume he permis are given ou for free o exising firms. In his case he rens accrue o he privae secor. The governmen does (indirecly) receive a fracion of hese rens because rens are refleced in firm profis (which are subjec o corporae income ax) and ulimaely nonlabor household income (which is subjec o personal income ax). owever, his revenue gain is (slighly) more han offse by he reducion in labor ax revenues in our simulaion resuls. C. Relaion o Previous Sudies In previous sudies (e.g. Goulder e al., 997; Bovenberg and de Mooij, 994; Parry, 995) here is no allowance for axfavored spending and hence no disorion in he marke in Figure (b). 3 The general equilibrium cos of a revenueneural polluion ax in hese models herefore consiss of he primary coss, he axineracion effec, and he normal revenuerecycling effec. These sudies ypically find ha he cos from he axineracion effec dominaes he benefi from he normal revenuerecycling effec. Therefore, he ne impac of environmenal ax swaps is o reduce labor supply and increase he coss of preexising axes. 4 These sudies herefore cas doub on he "double dividend" hypohesis, ha is he claim ha environmenal axes could boh improve he environmen and reduce he coss of he ax sysem a he same ime. 5 3 awrence Goulder has used a sophisicaed dynamic numerical model of he US economy o conduc a number of exercises ha examine he effecs of environmenal axes (see e.g. Goulder, 995b). Alhough i allows for a deailed reamen of he ax sysem, his model does no incorporae ax deducions for medical insurance and morgage ineres. 4 These resuls are consisen wih earlier resuls from he public finance lieraure (see e.g. Sandmo, 976). The environmenal ax swap effecively subsiues revenues from a ax wih a relaively narrow base (for example fossil fuels or energy oupu) for revenues from a ax wih a very broad base (economywide labor income). arrow based axes ypically involve higher coss because he subsiuion possibiliies for avoiding he ax are much greaer han when he ax has a broad base. 5 This hypohesis sems from analyses ha essenially "ack on" he revenuerecycling effec o a parial equilibrium analysis of environmenal axes. Since hey are no general equilibrium, hese analyses fail o capure he crucial axineracion effec. A double dividend could however arise in some special cases. For example, if oupu from he polluing secor is a relaively weak subsiue (or complemen) for leisure compared wih oher marke oupus hen he revenuerecycling effec can dominae he axineracion effec (his may apply, for example, in he case of cigaree axaion or axes on polluing inpus in agriculure). Also, o some exen incorporaing capial can eiher srenghen or weaken he resuls from saic, onefacor models. This depends on he exen o which he MEB of labor and capial axes differ and he exen o which he environmenal ax swap may shif he overall burden of axaion from one facor o anoher. Finally, changes in environmenal qualiy may have feedback effecs ha affec he labor/leisure decision. These feedback effecs are no capured in he empirical models because hey are difficul o quanify. We absrac from all hese complicaions below since hey have been discussed a lengh in he lieraure (see e.g. he survey in Bovenberg and Goulder, 998). 9
13 Parry and Beno RFF Our numerical resuls below differ from hose in hese earlier sudies because of he subsidyineracion effec, and more imporanly o he exen ha he srong and normal revenuerecycling effecs differ. The raio of he srong o he normal revenuerecycling effec equals MEB /MEB C. In Appendix B we derive he following formula for MEB (when τ = 0 and we ignore feedback effecs on he environmen): MEB ε = M ε + s s η + η M (2.2) M where ε and supply elasiciies, ε are he uncompensaed (Marshallian) and compensaed (icksian) labor M η and η are he uncompensaed and compensaed own price elasiciy of demand for axfavored consumpion (expressed as posiive numbers), s is he share of axfavored consumpion in oal consumpion and = C + is he oal labor ax wedge. Seing =0 gives: MEB C ε ε M (2.3) The formula in (2.3) has been discussed a lengh in oher sudies (see e.g. Browning, 987, and Snow and Warren, 996) and we do no go ino deails here. 6 For our purposes he key poin here is ha he increase in he MEB because of axfavored consumpion depends on hree key parameers (which we discuss below): he relaive size of he axfavored consumpion secor, he (compensaed and uncompensaed) demand elasiciy for axfavored consumpion, and he subsidy wedge. 6 These formulas are for an increase in labor axaion o finance an exra dollar of he lumpsum ransfer. If he exra revenue were no reurned o households (for example i wen ou of he economy in foreign aid) all he elasiciies would be uncompensaed, while if he exra public spending was sufficien o keep household uiliy consan all he elasiciies would be compensaed. In our case he formulas depend on boh uncompensaed and compensaed elasiciies because he exra revenue o be recycled from an incremenal increase in (+d/d in he case of (2.3)) does no fully compensae households for he loss in surplus from he ax increase (). The formula in (2.3) is exac when =0, as in previous sudies. The MEB for he comprehensive ax in our model is a lile more complicaed due o a crossprice effec in he marke, however in quaniaive erms he difference is very small. 0
14 Parry and Beno RFF UMERICAYSOVED MODE We now perform numerical simulaions o compare, empirically, he welfare impacs of alernaive environmenal policies. Subsecions A and B describe he assumed funcional forms and model calibraion underlying he simulaions. Due o uncerainy over he values of key parameers, we consider "low", "medium" and "high" scenarios for he disorionary coss of he ax sysem. A. Funcional Forms The household has he following consan elasiciy of subsiuion (CES) form for uiliy: U = α U C σu σu + ( α U )( ) σu σu σu σu φ( Z) (3.) σ C σ C σ C σ C σ C σ C C = α C + ( α C ) Y (3.2) where C denoes composie consumpion or subuiliy from he consumpion of goods and he σ's and α's are parameers. σ U and σ C denoe he elasiciies of subsiuion beween composie consumpion and leisure, and beween individual consumpion goods, respecively. The α's are share parameers. φ(.) is disuiliy from he polluion caused by he diry inpu Z, where φ >0, φ 0. There are wo noable resricions embedded in his uiliy funcion. Firs, he separabiliy assumpion in (3.) simplifies our analysis by ruling ou possible feedback effecs of changes in environmenal qualiy on he labor/leisure decision and he choice among consumpion goods. 7 Second, he weak separabiliy beween leisure and consumpion goods, and he homoheic propery of (3.2) ogeher imply ha and Y are equal subsiues for leisure. 8 This seems a reasonable benchmark assumpion, given ha we know of no evidence o sugges ha he degree of subsiuion beween axdeducible consumpion and leisure is significanly sronger or weaker han he degree of subsiuion beween oher consumpion goods and leisure. and Y are produced using he polluing inermediae good (Z), a clean inermediae good (), and labor using he following CES producion funcions: 7 One possible feedback effec migh occur in he case of raffic congesion. Under cerain condiions, a congesion ax on workrelaed raffic can increase he household wage ne of commuing coss, and hence raise he labor force paricipaion rae a he margin. Anoher example is he possibiliy ha reduced polluion will raise worker produciviy by improving human healh (see e.g. Williams, 998). 8 See Deaon (98) for a proof. For a discussion of how he relaive degree of subsiuion beween goods and leisure alers he welfare impac of environmenal policies, see e.g. Boveneberg and Goulder (998) and Parry (995).
15 Parry and Beno RFF σ σ σ σ σ σ σ σ + α + α C C = αdz (3.3) Y Y = Y α D Z σy σy σy σy σy σy Y σ σ + α Y Y + α Y Y C C Y Y where σ and σ Y are he elasiciy of subsiuion beween inpus in he wo indusries and he α's are inpu share parameers, and Y Z = Z + Z ; Y = + (3.4) abor is he only inpu used o produce Z and and he marginal produc of labor in each of hese inermediae goods indusries is aken o be consan and normalized o uniy. Thus: Z Z = ; abor marke equilibrium requires: Y Z = (3.5) = (3.6) Tha is, labor demanded by final and inermediae good indusries equals labor supplied by households. As discussed above, he governmen provides a lumpsum ransfer (G), levies a comprehensive ax ( C ) and noncomprehensive ax ( ) on labor income, and reduces Z eiher by a polluion ax (τ) or polluion permis. We assume he governmen budge mus balance. In he case of he polluion ax his consrain is: G = ( + ) p + τz (3.7) C Tha is, governmen spending equals labor ax revenues less deducions plus polluion ax revenue. ouseholds choose, Y and o maximize uiliy subjec o he budge consrain given by (2.). This generaes he demand funcions for goods and he labor supply funcion. Firms choose inpus o minimize producion coss and his deermines coss per uni of oupu, or producer prices. In equilibrium demand and supply are equaed in he final goods, inermediae goods, and labor markes, and he household and governmen budge consrains are saisfied. 9 B. Model Calibraion The consumpion/leisure subsiuion elasiciy (σ U ) is calibraed o be consisen wih esimaes of labor supply elasiciies. The economeric evidence on labor supply elasiciies has been reviewed many imes and we do no go ino he deails here (see e.g. Killingsworh, 9 We used GAMS wih MPSGE o solve he model. 2
16 Parry and Beno RFF ). For our purposes here are several imporan poins. Firs, for our highly aggregaed model he labor supply response o changes in ne wages represens he impac on average hours worked per employee and he impac on he paricipaion rae, averaged across all members (male and female) of he labor force. Second, despie numerous sudies, here is sill a fair amoun of uncerainy over he economywide labor supply elasiciy, and herefore i pruden o consider a range of values. Third, our model should be consisen wih esimaes for boh he compensaed and uncompensaed labor supply elasiciy. In our medium scenario for he MEB of preexising axes, we choose he consumpion/leisure elasiciy and he iniial raio of labor supply o he ime endowmen o imply an uncompensaed and a compensaed labor supply elasiciy of 0.5 and 0.4 respecively. These are ypical values used in previous sudies of environmenal policies (e.g. Goulder e al., 997). In our low and high MEB scenarios we use values of 0. and 0.3, and 0.25 and 0.5 respecively. 20 Following oher sudies (ucas, 990; Goulder e al., 997), we assume a marginal ax wedge in he labor marke of 40 percen, which reflecs he combined effecs of personal, payroll and sales axes. The wo larges componens of axfavored spending are employer provided medical insurance and homeowner morgage ineres. These iems amouned o abou 5 percen and 4 percen respecively, of oal consumpion expendiures in There are a variey of oher quanifiable iems ha add abou anoher 4 percen. 22 In addiion, here are oher caegories ha are difficul o measure, such as business lunches and rips, employerprovided healh clubs, debfinanced spending secured by real esae, and so on. 23 In shor, i is ricky o pin down really accuraely he relaive size of he axfavored consumpion secor. We assume s = 0., 0.5 and 0.2 in our low, medium, and high MEB scenarios, respecively. If all axfavored consumpion were fully deducible from labor axes, he subsidy wedge in he marke for axfavored consumpion would be 40 percen in our model. This is no quie 20 These values are roughly consisen wih a recen survey of opinion among labor economiss by Fuchs e al. (998), assuming a weigh of 0.6 and 0.4 for he male and female elasiciies repored in heir Table 2. 2 Direc esimaes of hese iems oversae axfavored spending, for example morgage paymens include repaymen of principal, which is no axdeducible. To obain he above values we used esimaes of losses in personal income ax revenues from hese deducions from Table 523 in he Saisical Absrac of he Unied Saes (995), divided by he marginal rae of personal income ax (assumed o be 0.25 percen for he average axpayer). 22 In his lis of caegories in Table 523 we include employee parking, life insurance, child care, medical claims (raher han premiums), workman's compensaion benefis and deducions for axes paid on home sales. 23 In fac we include less han 40 percen of deducions from federal income axes in our definiion of. We exclude pension conribuions, since his ax deducion is offse a leas o some exen by fuure axes on he income from savings. For more discussion of his issue see Feldsein (995a), pp Alhough chariable conribuions are axdeducible, hey may also confer imporan exernal benefis. We exclude chariable conribuions o avoid geing ino he messy business of esimaing exernaliy benefis. There are a variey of oher deducions lised in Table 523 of he Saisical Absrac, bu which are no really relevan for our analysis. For example deducions for capial expendiures and savings are no relevan because our analysis is saic and does no capure preexising axes on capial. In addiion, deducions for local income axes reduce he overall rae of labor ax bu do no disor he allocaion of consumpion expendiures. 3
17 Parry and Beno RFF he case however, and we assume a subsidy of 30 percen. 24 As discussed in Secion 4, we absrac from a number of oher complicaions ha affec he overall size of he subsidy wedge. I is difficul o assess he overall demand elasiciies for axfavored consumpion. These are deermined by he elasiciy of subsiuion beween axdeducible consumpion and M oher consumpion goods, and s, as follows: η = ( s ) σ C + s and η = ( s ) σ C. Various sudies have esimaed demand elasiciies for individual componens of. For example, Rosen (979) esimaed he (uncompensaed) demand elasiciy for home morgages o be uniy. A recen esimae of he demand elasiciy for healh insurance is.8 (Gruber and Poerba, 994). 25 We choose σ C o imply values of,.25 and.6 for he uncompensaed demand elasiciy for in our low, medium and high MEB scenarios. Table summarizes our key parameer values. They imply an MEB from he noncomprehensive ax equal o 0.3, 0.50 and 0.9 in he low, medium and high scenarios. In earlier sudies ha neglec axfavored consumpion (e.g. Goulder e al., 997) he MEB is around 0.3, which equals our MEB for he comprehensive ax in he medium scenario. A firs glance i may seem surprising ha he presence of axfavored consumpion increases he MEB so much, when axfavored consumpion is only around 020 percen of he size of he labor marke. owever, his is roughly offse because axfavored consumpion is much more sensiive o changes in ax raes han labor supply. Table. Alernaive Scenarios for Key Parameers Parameer ow MEB Medium MEB igh MEB s M η η M ε ε MEB MEB C oe: See Secion 2 for noaional definiions. 24 In paricular morgage ineres is only deducible from he personal income ax, and no he payroll ax. I is subsidized a he marginal rae of income ax (averaged across individuals) which is around 25 percen. Our assumpions abou ax raes and s imply governmen revenue is percen of oal spending in our benchmark, which is approximaely consisen wih he raio of oal ax receips o ne naional produc. oe ha our srong revenuerecycling effec implicily assumes ha environmenal ax revenues are used o cu he rae of personal income ax. The revenuerecycling effec would be somewha smaller if revenues were used o cu he payroll ax, since his ax has less deducions. 25 Earlier sudies ypically find significanly lower esimaes, however Gruber and Poerba sugges ha hese sudies conain a number of mehodological problems. 4
18 Parry and Beno RFF In fac, our parameer assumpions appear o be conservaive in ligh of a recen sudy by Feldsein (995a). e found ha he MEB for he personal income ax could easily exceed a dollar, when all subsiuion possibiliies for avoiding he ax increase are aken ino accoun. To obain his value, Feldsein used esimaes from several recen sudies of he elasiciy of he personal income ax base wih respec o changes in ax raes. This elasiciy reflecs a combinaion of labor supply effecs and subsiuion ino axdeducible spending. Feldsein's resuls sugges haeven in our high MEB scenariowe could be significanly undersaing s and he elasiciies for axfavored consumpion and labor supply. The relaionship beween our parameer values and Feldsein's esimaes are discussed in more deail in Appendix C. 26 We ake he elasiciies of subsiuion in he and Y indusries (σ and σ Y ) o be uniy. This is a sandard assumpion and our resuls are no sensiive o oher values. In our iniial simulaions he facor inpu raios are iniially he same in boh consumpion goods indusries, bu his is relaxed laer on. Finally, we assume he iniial value of oupu in each inermediae good indusry amouns o 0 percen of he value of oal final oupu. The relaive coss of environmenal policies are no especially sensiive o alernaive assumpions abou he size of he polluing secor in GDP (his finding is consisen wih earlier sudies). 4. RESUTS This secion presens our simulaion resuls illusraing how he ax sysem affecs he coss, overall welfare impacs, and opimal levels of environmenal policies. We also discuss some imporan caveas o he resuls. A. Marginal Coss In Figure 2 we compare he marginal cos of reducing polluion under alernaive policy insrumens up o 50 percen below preregulaion levels. Marginal coss are expressed as a percen of he iniial value produc of he polluing inpu. For his figure we mainly focus on qualiaive resuls, and since hese are essenially he same under all hree MEB scenarios, we jus illusrae he medium MEB case. MC PRIM indicaes marginal coss in a firsbes case when we se preexising axes and he subsidy o zero. This curve reflecs primary coss only and is he same under boh he polluion ax and polluion permis. 27 MC PRIM has a zero inercep, and is upward sloping, reflecing he increasing marginal cos of subsiuing oher inpus for he polluing inpu in producion and he increasing marginal cos of reducing he amoun of consumpion. 26 We prefer no o commi ourselves o "bes guesses" for hese parameers unil more evidence becomes available. Insead we illusrae a range of oucomes under plausible values. The labels low, medium, and high MEB scenarios are used for conveniencehey do no reflec any views abou "mos likely" parameer values. 27 To calculae he primary coss we recalibrae he disribuion parameers such ha he iniial quaniy of goods and leisure are he same as in he model wih nonzero axes. owever he subsiuion elasiciy parameers, which crucially deermine he relaive coss of policies, are he same across he models wih and wihou he labor axes. 5
19 Parry and Beno RFF Figure 2. Marginal Coss MC S 5 Marginal Cos MC COM MC SI MC PRIM 0 MC C Percenage reducion in polluion MC SI shows marginal coss when we allow for he 30 percen subsidy for, bu sill se labor axes a zero. 28 The difference beween his curve and MC PRIM reflecs he (marginal) subsidyineracion effec. This effec is a welfare gain (he parallelogram in Figure (b)) because he polluion ax reduces he oupu of, hus offseing o some exen he disorionary effec of he subsidy. owever, he subsidyineracion effec is no very large. This is because he price of and Y increase in he same proporion, and hence he reducion in reflecs subsiuion ino leisure only and no ino oher consumpion. Subsequen simulaions show, however, ha he subsidyineracion effec can be imporan when he relaive polluion inensiy differs significanly beween he axfavored and nonaxfavored producion secors. MC S indicaes marginal cos under he polluion ax wih boh labor axes bu wih no revenuerecycling effec; ha is, environmenal ax revenues are neuralized by adjusing he lumpsum ransfer. The difference beween his curve and MC SI reflecs he (marginal) axineracion effec. Thus he axineracion effec causes a subsanial upward shif of he marginal cos curve (see Goulder e al. (997) for more discussion). 28 For his case he subsidy is financed by a (negaive) lumpsum ransfer, and he lumpsum ransfer is adjused o neuralize he revenue effecs of environmenal policies. 6
20 Parry and Beno RFF MC COM shows marginal coss under he polluion ax wih revenues used o reduce he comprehensive ax (holding governmen ransfers consan in real erms). I equals MC S less he (marginal) benefi from he normal revenuerecycling effec. Comparing MC COM wih MC SI we can infer ha he axineracion effec dominaes he normal revenuerecycling effec a he margin (excep a zero polluion reducion). Again, his resul is familiar from oher sudies (e.g. Goulder e al., 997). The gap beween MC S and MC COM decreases wih he amoun of polluion reducion, since he erosion of he polluion ax base reduces he marginal revenuerecycling effec. Indeed he marginal revenuerecycling effec evenually becomes negaive if polluion is reduced by more han a cerain amoun. Beyond his poin he polluion ax affer curve is downward sloping and MC COM rises above MC S. Finally, MC C is he marginal cos curve for he polluion ax wih revenues used o reduce he noncomprehensive labor ax. 29 This curve equals MC S less he (marginal) benefi from he srong revenuerecycling effec. I has a negaive inercep and marginal coss are negaive up o a polluion reducion of 5 percen in our medium cos scenario. Thus, even if here were no environmenal benefis i would sill be opimal o reduce polluion by 5 percen in his case. Up o a poin herefore, he environmenal ax swap reduces he overall coss of he ax sysem, no couning environmenal benefis. I makes he ax sysem more efficien by effecively reducing he ne subsidy for axfavored consumpion. 30 On he oher hand, he environmenal ax is more disorionary han he labor ax in he sense ha i excludes nonpolluing inpus from he ax base. A leas for more modes levels of polluion ax, he advanage from he former effec ouweighs he disadvanage from he laer effec. B. Toal Coss Figure 3 shows he oal (as opposed o marginal) coss of reducing polluion under various policies, expressed relaive o he oal primary coss. When a cos curve lies above (below) uniy, he ne impac of he ax sysem is o raise (lower) he overall cos of a policy above (below) is primary coss. The mos novel feaure of Figure 3 is he oal cos curves for he polluion ax wih revenues used o reduce he noncomprehensive labor ax, denoed TC C, which are shown for he low, medium and high MEB scenarios. These curves lie below he horizonal axis for polluion reducions up o beween 7 and 42 percen. When oal coss are negaive he welfare gain from reducing he coss of he ax sysem more han offse he primary cos of he policy. Goulder (995a) refers o his as a "srong" double dividend from environmenal axes. When oal coss are posiive bu less han uniy, here is sill a ne welfare gain from ineracions wih he ax sysem. This is referred o as an "inermediae" form of he double 29 To avoid cluering Figure 2, we omi marginal coss for emissions permis in he presence of preexising axes. The effecs of his policy are explained below. 30 If he were no ax deducions in our model (and no environmenal effecs), he labor ax would always be more efficien han he polluion ax for raising revenues. 7
Duration and Convexity ( ) 20 = Bond B has a maturity of 5 years and also has a required rate of return of 10%. Its price is $613.
Graduae School of Business Adminisraion Universiy of Virginia UVAF38 Duraion and Convexiy he price of a bond is a funcion of he promised paymens and he marke required rae of reurn. Since he promised
More informationBALANCE OF PAYMENTS. First quarter 2008. Balance of payments
BALANCE OF PAYMENTS DATE: 20080530 PUBLISHER: Balance of Paymens and Financial Markes (BFM) Lena Finn + 46 8 506 944 09, lena.finn@scb.se Camilla Bergeling +46 8 506 942 06, camilla.bergeling@scb.se
More informationINVESTMENT. Contents:  Introduction.  A model of investment with adjustment costs (discrete and continuous time case)
INVESTMENT Conens:  Inroducion  A model of invesmen wih adjusmen coss (discree and coninuous ime case) The imporance of invesmen Why sudy invesmen? Capial accumulaion is he main deerminan of growh invesmen
More information4. International Parity Conditions
4. Inernaional ariy ondiions 4.1 urchasing ower ariy he urchasing ower ariy ( heory is one of he early heories of exchange rae deerminaion. his heory is based on he concep ha he demand for a counry's currency
More informationPROFIT TEST MODELLING IN LIFE ASSURANCE USING SPREADSHEETS PART TWO
Profi Tes Modelling in Life Assurance Using Spreadshees, par wo PROFIT TEST MODELLING IN LIFE ASSURANCE USING SPREADSHEETS PART TWO Erik Alm Peer Millingon Profi Tes Modelling in Life Assurance Using Spreadshees,
More information11/6/2013. Chapter 14: Dynamic ADAS. Introduction. Introduction. Keeping track of time. The model s elements
Inroducion Chaper 14: Dynamic DS dynamic model of aggregae and aggregae supply gives us more insigh ino how he economy works in he shor run. I is a simplified version of a DSGE model, used in cuingedge
More informationEconomics Honors Exam 2008 Solutions Question 5
Economics Honors Exam 2008 Soluions Quesion 5 (a) (2 poins) Oupu can be decomposed as Y = C + I + G. And we can solve for i by subsiuing in equaions given in he quesion, Y = C + I + G = c 0 + c Y D + I
More informationNotes on Price Indexes and Inflation
Noes on Price Indexes and Inflaion Professor John Yinger The Maxwell School Syracuse Universiy Inroducion The prices of goods and services are no consan over ime. A general increase in prices, also known
More informationPROFIT TEST MODELLING IN LIFE ASSURANCE USING SPREADSHEETS PART ONE
Profi Tes Modelling in Life Assurance Using Spreadshees PROFIT TEST MODELLING IN LIFE ASSURANCE USING SPREADSHEETS PART ONE Erik Alm Peer Millingon 2004 Profi Tes Modelling in Life Assurance Using Spreadshees
More informationδ (real interest rate) is roughly constant.
Calibraing he Growh Model Kaldor's sylized facs 1. / L (oupu per worker) exhibis coninual growh. 2. K / L (capial per worker) exhibis coninual growh. 3. r δ (real ineres rae) is roughly consan. 4. K /
More informationWhy Did the Demand for Cash Decrease Recently in Korea?
Why Did he Demand for Cash Decrease Recenly in Korea? Byoung Hark Yoo Bank of Korea 26. 5 Absrac We explores why cash demand have decreased recenly in Korea. The raio of cash o consumpion fell o 4.7% in
More informationIndividual Health Insurance April 30, 2008 Pages 167170
Individual Healh Insurance April 30, 2008 Pages 167170 We have received feedback ha his secion of he e is confusing because some of he defined noaion is inconsisen wih comparable life insurance reserve
More informationMorningstar Investor Return
Morningsar Invesor Reurn Morningsar Mehodology Paper Augus 31, 2010 2010 Morningsar, Inc. All righs reserved. The informaion in his documen is he propery of Morningsar, Inc. Reproducion or ranscripion
More informationChapter 6: Business Valuation (Income Approach)
Chaper 6: Business Valuaion (Income Approach) Cash flow deerminaion is one of he mos criical elemens o a business valuaion. Everyhing may be secondary. If cash flow is high, hen he value is high; if he
More informationLecture Notes for DeLongOlney (2e): Inflation, Unemployment, and Stabilization Policy
Lecure Noes for DeLongOlney (2e): Inflaion, Unemploymen, and abilizaion Policy In he Phillips CurveMoneary Policy Reacion Funcion framework, we collapse all behavior on he side of aggregae supply ino
More informationII.1. Debt reduction and fiscal multipliers. dbt da dpbal da dg. bal
Quarerly Repor on he Euro Area 3/202 II.. Deb reducion and fiscal mulipliers The deerioraion of public finances in he firs years of he crisis has led mos Member Saes o adop sizeable consolidaion packages.
More informationMacroeconomics I, UPF Professor Antonio Ciccone SOLUTIONS PROBLEM SET 2
Macroeconomics I, UPF Professor Anonio Ciccone SOLUTIONS PROBLEM SET 1. (from Romer Advanced Macroeconomics Chaper 1) Describe how, if a all, each of he following developmens affecs he breakeven and acual
More information(Relevant to AAT Examination Paper 4: Business Economics and Financial Mathematics)
Index Numbers (Relevan o AAT Examinaion Paper 4: Business Economics and Financial Mahemaics) Y.O. Lam, SCOPE, Ciy Universiy of Hong Kong In business world, we need o reduce a large number of facs or informaion
More informationMarkit Excess Return Credit Indices Guide for price based indices
Marki Excess Reurn Credi Indices Guide for price based indices Sepember 2011 Marki Excess Reurn Credi Indices Guide for price based indices Conens Inroducion...3 Index Calculaion Mehodology...4 Semiannual
More informationPrice elasticity of demand for crude oil: estimates for 23 countries
Price elasiciy of demand for crude oil: esimaes for 23 counries John C.B. Cooper Absrac This paper uses a muliple regression model derived from an adapaion of Nerlove s parial adjusmen model o esimae boh
More informationWhy Do Real and Nominal. InventorySales Ratios Have Different Trends?
Why Do Real and Nominal InvenorySales Raios Have Differen Trends? By Valerie A. Ramey Professor of Economics Deparmen of Economics Universiy of California, San Diego and Research Associae Naional Bureau
More informationNewton's second law in action
Newon's second law in acion In many cases, he naure of he force acing on a body is known I migh depend on ime, posiion, velociy, or some combinaion of hese, bu is dependence is known from experimen In
More informationThe Real Business Cycle paradigm. The RBC model emphasizes supply (technology) disturbances as the main source of
Prof. Harris Dellas Advanced Macroeconomics Winer 2001/01 The Real Business Cycle paradigm The RBC model emphasizes supply (echnology) disurbances as he main source of macroeconomic flucuaions in a world
More informationThe Impact of Interest Rate Liberalization Announcement in China on the Market Value of Hong Kong Listed Chinese Commercial Banks
Journal of Finance and Invesmen Analysis, vol. 2, no.3, 203, 3539 ISSN: 2240998 (prin version), 2240996(online) Scienpress Ld, 203 The Impac of Ineres Rae Liberalizaion Announcemen in China on he Marke
More informationMarket Liquidity and the Impacts of the Computerized Trading System: Evidence from the Stock Exchange of Thailand
36 Invesmen Managemen and Financial Innovaions, 4/4 Marke Liquidiy and he Impacs of he Compuerized Trading Sysem: Evidence from he Sock Exchange of Thailand Sorasar Sukcharoensin 1, Pariyada Srisopisawa,
More informationA Brief Introduction to the Consumption Based Asset Pricing Model (CCAPM)
A Brief Inroducion o he Consumpion Based Asse Pricing Model (CCAPM We have seen ha CAPM idenifies he risk of any securiy as he covariance beween he securiy's rae of reurn and he rae of reurn on he marke
More informationChapter 1.6 Financial Management
Chaper 1.6 Financial Managemen Par I: Objecive ype quesions and answers 1. Simple pay back period is equal o: a) Raio of Firs cos/ne yearly savings b) Raio of Annual gross cash flow/capial cos n c) = (1
More informationYTM is positively related to default risk. YTM is positively related to liquidity risk. YTM is negatively related to special tax treatment.
. Two quesions for oday. A. Why do bonds wih he same ime o mauriy have differen YTM s? B. Why do bonds wih differen imes o mauriy have differen YTM s? 2. To answer he firs quesion les look a he risk srucure
More informationunemployment for 40 years has fallen flat. If inflation had responded to the Great Recession and
The Phillips curve. Back o he 60s? Olivier Blanchard The behavior of inflaion since he crisis appears puzzling o many. To cie Paul Krugman (2015): The acceleraionis docrine ha has dominaed economic discussion
More informationA OneSector Neoclassical Growth Model with Endogenous Retirement. By Kiminori Matsuyama. Final Manuscript. Abstract
A OneSecor Neoclassical Growh Model wih Endogenous Reiremen By Kiminori Masuyama Final Manuscrip Absrac This paper exends Diamond s OG model by allowing he agens o make he reiremen decision. Earning a
More informationEcon 352 Spring 2012 The Solow Model (Ch. 6)
Econ 352 Spring 2012 The Solow Model (Ch. 6) Insrucor: Kanda Naknoi February 7, 2012 1 Growh Accouning Consider he CobbDouglas producion funcion: Y = F (K, ) = A K 0.3 L 0.7, (1) Noe ha all variables
More informationWorking Paper No. 482. Net Intergenerational Transfers from an Increase in Social Security Benefits
Working Paper No. 482 Ne Inergeneraional Transfers from an Increase in Social Securiy Benefis By Li Gan Texas A&M and NBER Guan Gong Shanghai Universiy of Finance and Economics Michael Hurd RAND Corporaion
More informationGENERATIONAL ACCOUNTING
GENERATIONAL ACCOUNTING G000203 Many governmen programmes ransfer resources beween differen populaion groups. Programmes o provide reiremen and healh securiy levy axes on workers o finance ransfers o reirees.
More informationLEASING VERSUSBUYING
LEASNG VERSUSBUYNG Conribued by James D. Blum and LeRoy D. Brooks Assisan Professors of Business Adminisraion Deparmen of Business Adminisraion Universiy of Delaware Newark, Delaware The auhors discuss
More informationThe Perverse Response of Interest Rates
The Perverse Response of Ineres Raes Virginie Boine and Chrisopher Marin Brunel Business School Brunel Universiy Uxbridge Middlesex UB8 3PH June 2006 Absrac We argue ha an increase in aggregae demand can
More informationPrice Controls and Banking in Emissions Trading: An Experimental Evaluation
This version: March 2014 Price Conrols and Banking in Emissions Trading: An Experimenal Evaluaion John K. Sranlund Deparmen of Resource Economics Universiy of MassachusesAmhers James J. Murphy Deparmen
More information/30/2009. Perhaps the most important of all the applications of calculus is to differential equations. Modeling with Differential Equations
10 DIFFERENTIAL EQUATIONS DIFFERENTIAL EQUATIONS Perhaps he mos imporan of all he applicaions of calculus is o differenial equaions. DIFFERENTIAL EQUATIONS When physical or social scieniss use calculus,
More informationMACROECONOMIC FORECASTS AT THE MOF A LOOK INTO THE REAR VIEW MIRROR
MACROECONOMIC FORECASTS AT THE MOF A LOOK INTO THE REAR VIEW MIRROR The firs experimenal publicaion, which summarised pas and expeced fuure developmen of basic economic indicaors, was published by he Minisry
More informationAppendix D Flexibility Factor/Margin of Choice Desktop Research
Appendix D Flexibiliy Facor/Margin of Choice Deskop Research Cheshire Eas Council Cheshire Eas Employmen Land Review Conens D1 Flexibiliy Facor/Margin of Choice Deskop Research 2 Final Ocober 2012 \\GLOBAL.ARUP.COM\EUROPE\MANCHESTER\JOBS\200000\22348900\4
More informationChapter 8: Regression with Lagged Explanatory Variables
Chaper 8: Regression wih Lagged Explanaory Variables Time series daa: Y for =1,..,T End goal: Regression model relaing a dependen variable o explanaory variables. Wih ime series new issues arise: 1. One
More informationImpact of Debt on Primary Deficit and GSDP Gap in Odisha: Empirical Evidences
S.R. No. 002 10/2015/CEFT Impac of Deb on Primary Defici and GSDP Gap in Odisha: Empirical Evidences 1. Inroducion The excessive pressure of public expendiure over is revenue receip is financed hrough
More informationTHE FIRM'S INVESTMENT DECISION UNDER CERTAINTY: CAPITAL BUDGETING AND RANKING OF NEW INVESTMENT PROJECTS
VII. THE FIRM'S INVESTMENT DECISION UNDER CERTAINTY: CAPITAL BUDGETING AND RANKING OF NEW INVESTMENT PROJECTS The mos imporan decisions for a firm's managemen are is invesmen decisions. While i is surely
More informationBenefitCost Analysis
Slide 1 BenefiCos Analysis Sco Pearson Sanford Universiy Sco Pearson is Professor Emerius of Agriculural Economics a he Food Research Insiue, Sanford Universiy. He has paricipaed in projecs ha combined
More informationBALANCE OF PAYMENTS AND FINANCIAL MA REPORT 2015. All officiell statistik finns på: www.scb.se Statistikservice: tfn 08506 948 01
RKET BALANCE OF PAYMENTS AND FINANCIAL MA REPORT 2015 All officiell saisik finns på: www.scb.se Saisikservice: fn 08506 948 01 All official saisics can be found a: www.scb.se Saisics service, phone +46
More informationUnivariate time series models
Univariae ime series models Naive model: i The naïve model is useful and will perform mos saisfacorily when he acual hisorical daa is very shor and conains no sysemaic paern, or a paern ha is changed very
More informationThe Economic Value of Medical Research
The Economic Value of Medical Research Kevin M. Murphy Rober Topel Universiy of Chicago Universiy of Chicago March 1998 Revised Sepember, 1999 Absrac Basic research is a public good, for which social reurns
More informationDecomposition Forecasting
NCSS Saisical Sofware Chaper 469 Decomposiion Forecasing Inroducion Classical ime series decomposiion separaes a ime series ino five componens: mean, longrange rend, seasonaliy, cycle, and randomness.
More informationIntroducing Advanced Macroeconomics: Growth and business cycles
Inroducing Advanced Macroeconomics: Growh and business cycles Chaper 3 firs lecure CAPITAL ACCUMULATION AND GROWTH: THE BASIC SOLOW MODEL The basic Solow model How can a naion become rich, i.e., iniiae
More informationDynamic Problem Set 2 Solutions
Dynamic Problem Se 2 Soluions Jonahan Kreamer July 22, 20 Consumpion wih Labor Supply Consider he problem of a household ha hao choose boh consumpion and labor supply. The household s problem is: V 0 =
More informationTaxation and Economic Efficiency
Taxaion and Economic Efficiency Alan J. Auerbach Universiy of California, Berkeley and NBER James R. Hines Jr. Universiy of Michigan and NBER February 2001 This paper has been prepared for a forhcoming
More informationAn Optimal Inventory Model With Partial Backorders
An Opimal Invenory Model Wih Parial Backorders Chenhsiung Lee Dep. of Business Adminisraion, Soochow Universiy Taipei, Taiwan 00 +8867878 brucelee@cgpc.com.w Jinshyang Roan Dep. of Business Adminisraion,
More informationTotal factor productivity growth in the Canadian life insurance industry: 19791989
Toal facor produciviy growh in he Canadian life insurance indusry: 19791989 J E F F R E Y I. B E R N S T E I N Carleon Universiy and Naional Bureau of Economic Research 1. Inroducion Produciviy growh
More informationUIUC Physics 406 Acoustical Physics of Music. Beats Phenomenon
UIUC Physics 406 Acousical Physics of Music Beas Phenomenon Linearly superpose (i.e. add) wo signals wih ampliudes A() and A(), and which have similar/comparable frequencies, () ~ (), wih insananeous phase
More informationFinance 400 A. Penati  G. Pennacchi. Recursive Utility
Finance 400 A. Penai  G. Pennacchi Recursive Uiliy A class of nonimeseparable uiliy known as recursive uiliy has been sudied by a number of auhors. D. Kreps and E. Poreus (1978) Temporal Resoluion of
More informationMeasuring the Effects of Exchange Rate Changes on Investment. in Australian Manufacturing Industry
Measuring he Effecs of Exchange Rae Changes on Invesmen in Ausralian Manufacuring Indusry Robyn Swif Economics and Business Saisics Deparmen of Accouning, Finance and Economics Griffih Universiy Nahan
More informationJournal Of Business & Economics Research September 2005 Volume 3, Number 9
Opion Pricing And Mone Carlo Simulaions George M. Jabbour, (Email: jabbour@gwu.edu), George Washingon Universiy YiKang Liu, (yikang@gwu.edu), George Washingon Universiy ABSTRACT The advanage of Mone Carlo
More informationWorking paper No.3 Cyclically adjusting the public finances
Working paper No.3 Cyclically adjusing he public finances Thora Helgadoir, Graeme Chamberlin, Pavandeep Dhami, Sephen Farringon and Joe Robins June 2012 Crown copyrigh 2012 You may reuse his informaion
More informationRisk Modelling of Collateralised Lending
Risk Modelling of Collaeralised Lending Dae: 4112008 Number: 8/18 Inroducion This noe explains how i is possible o handle collaeralised lending wihin Risk Conroller. The approach draws on he faciliies
More informationThe Grantor Retained Annuity Trust (GRAT)
WEALTH ADVISORY Esae Planning Sraegies for closelyheld, family businesses The Granor Reained Annuiy Trus (GRAT) An efficien wealh ransfer sraegy, paricularly in a low ineres rae environmen Family business
More informationPerformance Measurement of Portfolios With Option Strategies
Performance Measuremen of Porfolios Wih Opion Sraegies By Nadima ElHassan Tony Hall School of Finance and Economics Universiy of Technology, Sydney. Telephone: 9514 7725 Augus 2006 1 Performance Measuremen
More information4.8 Exponential Growth and Decay; Newton s Law; Logistic Growth and Decay
324 CHAPTER 4 Exponenial and Logarihmic Funcions 4.8 Exponenial Growh and Decay; Newon s Law; Logisic Growh and Decay OBJECTIVES 1 Find Equaions of Populaions Tha Obey he Law of Uninhibied Growh 2 Find
More informationResearch. Michigan. Center. Retirement. Behavioral Effects of Social Security Policies on Benefit Claiming, Retirement and Saving.
Michigan Universiy of Reiremen Research Cener Working Paper WP 2012263 Behavioral Effecs of Social Securiy Policies on Benefi Claiming, Reiremen and Saving Alan L. Gusman and Thomas L. Seinmeier M R R
More informationDYNAMIC MODELS FOR VALUATION OF WRONGFUL DEATH PAYMENTS
DYNAMIC MODELS FOR VALUATION OF WRONGFUL DEATH PAYMENTS Hong Mao, Shanghai Second Polyechnic Universiy Krzyszof M. Osaszewski, Illinois Sae Universiy Youyu Zhang, Fudan Universiy ABSTRACT Liigaion, exper
More informationDOES TRADING VOLUME INFLUENCE GARCH EFFECTS? SOME EVIDENCE FROM THE GREEK MARKET WITH SPECIAL REFERENCE TO BANKING SECTOR
Invesmen Managemen and Financial Innovaions, Volume 4, Issue 3, 7 33 DOES TRADING VOLUME INFLUENCE GARCH EFFECTS? SOME EVIDENCE FROM THE GREEK MARKET WITH SPECIAL REFERENCE TO BANKING SECTOR Ahanasios
More informationEconomics 140A Hypothesis Testing in Regression Models
Economics 140A Hypohesis Tesing in Regression Models While i is algebraically simple o work wih a populaion model wih a single varying regressor, mos populaion models have muliple varying regressors 1
More informationCapital Budgeting and Initial Cash Outlay (ICO) Uncertainty
Financial Decisions, Summer 006, Aricle Capial Budgeing and Iniial Cash Oulay (ICO) Uncerainy Michael C. Ehrhard and John M. Wachowicz, Jr. * * The Paul and Beverly Casagna Professor of Finance and Professor
More informationInformation technology and economic growth in Canada and the U.S.
Canada U.S. Economic Growh Informaion echnology and economic growh in Canada and he U.S. Informaion and communicaion echnology was he larges conribuor o growh wihin capial services for boh Canada and he
More informationValue Relevance of Other Comprehensive Income
Absrac: Value Relevance of Oher Comprehensive Income Yousef Jahmani Professor of Accouning College of Business Adminisraion Savannah Sae Universiy Diaeldin Osman Assisan Professor of Accouning College
More informationDISCUSSION PAPER. Emissions Targets and the Real Business Cycle. Intensity Targets versus Caps or Taxes. Carolyn Fischer and Michael R.
DISCUSSION PAPER November 2009 RFF DP 0947 Emissions Targes and he Real Business Cycle Inensiy Targes versus Caps or Taxes Carolyn Fischer and Michael R. Springborn 66 P S. NW Washingon, DC 20036 2023285000
More informationRESIDUAL INCOME VALUATION:
RESIDUAL INCOME ALUATION: ALUING COMMON EQUITY RESIDUAL INCOME Economic Profi Presener enue Dae Abnormal Earnings Residual Income Economic alue Added RESIDUAL INCOME EXAMPLE: RESIDUAL INCOME Ne Equiy Residual
More informationEvaluation methods Costbenefit analysis and multicriteria analysis issues and implementation
FFEM Componen 2 Mehods and ools for socioeconomic assessmen of goods and services provided by Medierranean fores ecosysems Evaluaion mehods Cosbenefi analysis and mulicrieria analysis issues and implemenaion
More informationStimulus Spending and Economic Growth
Simulus Spending and Economic Growh Annual Growh in RGDP 1976 1993 8% 1955 1984 1959 1962 6% 4% 2% 1956 1966 1968 1985 1990 2008 1970 1975 0% 2% 1% 19910% 1% 2% 3% 4% 5% 2% 1982 20094% Change in Governmen
More informationHomework 1: Warmup Exercise Solutions Eco 603 Fall 2016
Homework : Warmup Exercise Soluions Eco 603 Fall 206 Quesion : Normalizaion a. The producion funcion is consan reurns o scale in K and L. Therefore, we can use he procedure given in he class noes o remove.
More informationFinance and Economics Discussion Series Divisions of Research & Statistics and Monetary Affairs Federal Reserve Board, Washington, D.C.
Finance and Economics Discussion Series Divisions of Research & Saisics and Moneary Affairs Federal Reserve Board, Washingon, D.C. The Effecs of Unemploymen Benefis on Unemploymen and Labor Force Paricipaion:
More informationMath 308 Week 2 Solutions
Mah 308 Week Soluions Here are soluions o he evennumbered suggesed problems. The answers o he oddnumbered problems are in he back of your exbook, and he soluions are in he Soluion Manual, which you can
More informationAggregate Output. Aggregate Output. Topics. Aggregate Output. Aggregate Output. Aggregate Output
Topics (Sandard Measure) GDP vs GPI discussion Macroeconomic Variables (Unemploymen and Inflaion Rae) (naional income and produc accouns, or NIPA) Gross Domesic Produc (GDP) The value of he final goods
More informationLECTURE: SOCIAL SECURITY HILARY HOYNES UC DAVIS EC230 OUTLINE OF LECTURE:
LECTURE: SOCIAL SECURITY HILARY HOYNES UC DAVIS EC230 OUTLINE OF LECTURE: 1. Inroducion and definiions 2. Insiuional Deails in Social Securiy 3. Social Securiy and Redisribuion 4. Jusificaion for Governmen
More informationMeasuring macroeconomic volatility Applications to export revenue data, 19702005
FONDATION POUR LES ETUDES ET RERS LE DEVELOPPEMENT INTERNATIONAL Measuring macroeconomic volailiy Applicaions o expor revenue daa, 1970005 by Joël Cariolle Policy brief no. 47 March 01 The FERDI is a
More informationLab 1: One Dimensional Kinematics
Lab 1: One Dimensional Kinemaics Lab Secion (circle): Day: Monday Tuesday Time: 8:00 9:30 1:10 2:40 Name: Parners: PreLab You are required o finish his secion before coming o he lab, which will be checked
More informationI. Basic Concepts (Ch. 14)
(Ch. 14) A. Real vs. Financial Asses (Ch 1.2) Real asses (buildings, machinery, ec.) appear on he asse side of he balance shee. Financial asses (bonds, socks) appear on boh sides of he balance shee. Creaing
More informationOutput, Inflation, and the Quantity Theory of Money. Ref: Chap 20 p45457, & Chap 21 p48189
Oupu, Inflaion, and he Quaniy Theory of Money Ref: Chap 20 p45457, 46673 & Chap 21 p48189 Aggregae Oupu (Income) Aggregae Oupu is measured by GDP, Gross Domesic Produc: The marke value of final goods
More informationARCH 2013.1 Proceedings
Aricle from: ARCH 213.1 Proceedings Augus 14, 212 Ghislain Leveille, Emmanuel Hamel A renewal model for medical malpracice Ghislain Léveillé École d acuaria Universié Laval, Québec, Canada 47h ARC Conference
More informationGraduate Macro Theory II: Notes on Neoclassical Growth Model
Graduae Macro Theory II: Noes on Neoclassical Growh Model Eric Sims Universiy of Nore Dame Spring 2011 1 Basic Neoclassical Growh Model The economy is populaed by a large number of infiniely lived agens.
More informationA Note on Using the Svensson procedure to estimate the risk free rate in corporate valuation
A Noe on Using he Svensson procedure o esimae he risk free rae in corporae valuaion By Sven Arnold, Alexander Lahmann and Bernhard Schwezler Ocober 2011 1. The risk free ineres rae in corporae valuaion
More informationRevisions to Nonfarm Payroll Employment: 1964 to 2011
Revisions o Nonfarm Payroll Employmen: 1964 o 2011 Tom Sark December 2011 Summary Over recen monhs, he Bureau of Labor Saisics (BLS) has revised upward is iniial esimaes of he monhly change in nonfarm
More informationMarket Analysis and Models of Investment. Product Development and Whole Life Cycle Costing
The Universiy of Liverpool School of Archiecure and Building Engineering WINDS PROJECT COURSE SYNTHESIS SECTION 3 UNIT 11 Marke Analysis and Models of Invesmen. Produc Developmen and Whole Life Cycle Cosing
More informationSPECIAL REPORT May 4, Shifting Drivers of Inflation Canada versus the U.S.
Paul Ferley Assisan Chief Economis 4169747231 paul.ferley@rbc.com Nahan Janzen Economis 4169740579 nahan.janzen@rbc.com SPECIAL REPORT May 4, 2010 Shifing Drivers of Inflaion Canada versus he U.S.
More informationPremium Income of Indian Life Insurance Industry
Premium Income of Indian Life Insurance Indusry A Toal Facor Produciviy Approach Ram Praap Sinha* Subsequen o he passage of he Insurance Regulaory and Developmen Auhoriy (IRDA) Ac, 1999, he life insurance
More informationOne Dimensional Kinematics
Chaper B One Dimensional Kinemaics Blinn College  Physics 2425  Terry Honan Kinemaics is he sudy of moion. This chaper will inroduce he basic definiions of kinemaics. The definiions of he velociy and
More informationUSE OF EDUCATION TECHNOLOGY IN ENGLISH CLASSES
USE OF EDUCATION TECHNOLOGY IN ENGLISH CLASSES Mehme Nuri GÖMLEKSİZ Absrac Using educaion echnology in classes helps eachers realize a beer and more effecive learning. In his sudy 150 English eachers were
More informationRelationships between Stock Prices and Accounting Information: A Review of the Residual Income and Ohlson Models. Scott Pirie* and Malcolm Smith**
Relaionships beween Sock Prices and Accouning Informaion: A Review of he Residual Income and Ohlson Models Sco Pirie* and Malcolm Smih** * Inernaional Graduae School of Managemen, Universiy of Souh Ausralia
More informationHedging with Forwards and Futures
Hedging wih orwards and uures Hedging in mos cases is sraighforward. You plan o buy 10,000 barrels of oil in six monhs and you wish o eliminae he price risk. If you ake he buyside of a forward/fuures
More informationAccounting Based Valuation Formulae
Accouning Based Valuaion Formulae James A. Ohlson *. Inroducion Equiy valuaion is a opic of grea ineres in pracice and academia. The broad issue concerns he forecasing of fuure expeced payoffs which are
More informationSKF Documented Solutions
SKF Documened Soluions Real world savings and we can prove i! How much can SKF save you? Le s do he numbers. The SKF Documened Soluions Program SKF is probably no he firs of your supplier parners o alk
More informationForeign Trade and China s Economic Development: A TimeSeries Analysis
Volume 25, Number 1, June 2000 Foreign Trade and China s Economic Developmen: A TimeSeries Analysis Shuanglin Lin This paper examines he relaionship beween rade and economic growh based on China s naional
More informationINFLATION DIFFERENTIAL AND REAL CONVERGENCE IN PORTUGAL*
Aricles INFLAION DIFFERENIAL AND REAL CONVERGENCE IN PORUGAL* Paulo Brio** Isabel Hora Correia*** his work is inended o measure how real convergence observed in Porugal in he 990s may have conribued o
More informationA Conceptual Framework for Commercial Property Price Indexes
GraninAid for Scienific Research(S) Real Esae Markes, Financial Crisis, and Economic Growh : An Inegraed Economic Approach Working Paper Series No.4 A Concepual Framework for Commercial Propery Price
More informationINVESTIGATION OF THE INFLUENCE OF UNEMPLOYMENT ON ECONOMIC INDICATORS
INVESTIGATION OF THE INFLUENCE OF UNEMPLOYMENT ON ECONOMIC INDICATORS Ilona Tregub, Olga Filina, Irina Kondakova Financial Universiy under he Governmen of he Russian Federaion 1. Phillips curve In economics,
More information1. An introduction to dynamic optimization  Optimal Control and Dynamic Programming AGEC
This documen was generaed a 8:54 AM, 1/3/017 Copyrigh 017 Richard T. Woodward 1. An inroducion o dynamic opimiaion  Opimal Conrol and Dynamic Programming AGEC 64017 I. Overview of opimiaion Opimiaion
More informationChapter 10 Social Security 1
Chaper 0 Social Securiy 0. Inroducion A ypical social securiy sysem provides income during periods of unemploymen, illhealh or disabiliy, and financial suppor, in he form of pensions, o he reired. Alhough
More information