Working capital management

Transcription

1 Working capital management What top performing businesses in the Nordics do differently A study of working capital management practices across Nordic organisations

2 Working capital management Due to low economic growth, working capital management (WCM) has never been more important for Nordic businesses. But, until now, there has been little systematic attention paid to tracking relative performance or the underlying reasons why some companies perform so much better than others. Managing working capital should be a clear priority for all organisations. Companies that do it effectively enjoy several benefits including improved cash flow, better return on invested capital, and lower funding costs. Effective WCM can support businesses, regardless of what their challenges and aims are funding, growth, stability, managing risk or streamlining budgets. But, while everyone is aware of the benefits of effective WCM, not all organisations are experiencing them. Challenges to effective WCM Once you get beyond the quick wins, producing sustainable improvements in WCM performance is not a straightforward task. Improving working capital performance means making changes to business processes, technology and organisational structure across multiple departments, as well as to the culture. It often involves balancing competing needs companies may be torn between meeting shareholder expectations for key ratios, optimising cash flow generation and managing customer expectations. Effective WCM can support businesses, regardless of what their challenges and aims are. In seeking improvement, you are likely to face a number of challenges. You will need a complete view of your working capital and the factors that influence it. And you will need strong executive ownership but assigning this responsibility is often difficult because there are many functions and areas involved. In the projects we have engaged in with our customers, we have seen the scale of the challenge first-hand and how high WCM is on their agendas. We have provided advice, ideas and, of course, banking solutions on a case-by-case basis but we know what many organisations want is a clear baseline of data and best practice to follow. 2 Working capital management

3 Exploring diversity, finding common ground To establish that baseline of how Nordic companies are performing, we conducted a study of hundreds of corporates across all industries and most business sizes. We selected 15 top performers and dissected how they improved their working capital to illustrate some key best practices. We have detailed our findings in this report the first of its kind in the Nordics. Who is this report for? The report will, of course, be particularly useful for any Nordic finance professional or executive with influence or responsibility for processes or functions affecting working capital metrics. But we also believe the report s insights will be beneficial for organisations across Europe. Our experiences with customers suggest the same general trends in performance and best practice apply across the wider region. Our approach To create this report we examined key financial metrics from 403 Nordic corporations, over the period , using verified data from annual reports, commercial databases and other trusted public sources. To complement this quantitative study, we performed a further deep dive qualitative analysis of 15 companies and the working capital initiatives they have followed by studying articles, company presentations and analyst reports. For full details of our methodology, see page 11. We are currently running a groupwide working capital management programme. You can do some relatively easy things, such as signing agreements with banks and suppliers to remove some of the working capital you have on your balance sheet. But a working capital reduction programme is something else. You need to involve every part of the organisation. You need to shorten your orderto-cash cycle and extend your purchaseto-pay cycle. Per Norman Head of Treasury and Risk Management, BillerudKorsnäs Working capital management 3

4 Setting the benchmark Every business compares itself against its peers. Benchmarking using performance metrics like days working capital (DWC) enables you to identify areas where you are weak, so you can focus your improvement efforts. Overall performance We looked at the changes in DWC of 403 corporates between 2008 and 2013 to get a view of overall WCM performance in the Nordic region. We also analysed how individual sectors performed to identify any patterns of improvement. Nordics performing better The financial crisis prompted companies to tighten budgets and operations; sales figures were falling, which created a need for organisations to defend their cash flow. Between 2008 and 2013, we found an average improvement in DWC of five days or 6.8% across our sample Process industries Producer manufacturing Consumer durables Consumer non-durables days / -23% Electronic technology Non-energy minerals Distribution services Technology services Transportation Health technology Consumer services Retail trade Industrial services Commercial services Health services Utilities days / -15% -14 days / -28% -30 days / -52% Communications 20-6 days / -30% Energy minerals 0 Figure 1: DWC changes by industry, Most improved industries highlighted. 4 Working capital management

5 120 Commercial services 110 Communications Consumer durables Consumer non-durables 100 Consumer services Distribution services 90 Electronic technology Energy minerals 80 Health services Days working capital Average 2008 Health technology Industrial services Non-energy minerals Process industries Producer manufacturing Retail trade Technology services 40 Transportation Utilities Days working capital change Figure 2: Days change in DWC, , against starting point for each industry. The sector view Of course, the overall average covers a broad spread of performance and level of improvement. In some industries, DWC improved by as much as 52%. But at the other end of the spectrum, some sectors showed deterioration in DWC of up to 86%. The biggest reduction in DWC we saw was in the transportation industry DWC fell by 52% or 30 days, from 57 days in 2008 to 27 days in There was a broad spread of DWC starting figures in 2008, ranging from 100 days to under 10 days. Organisations that improved the most by 2013 in terms of absolute days were generally those with a large initial DWC figure they naturally had more room for improvement. The process industries, for example, went from 113 days in 2008 to 87 days in 2013; an improvement of 26 days or 23%. On the flip side, organisations that began with a lower DWC figure did not have as much opportunity to get better. For instance, the communications sector showed a decrease from 20 days in 2008 to 14 in It is important to note that these improvements are not just a result of DWC figures being particularly poor in Figures in 2013 also show an improvement on those in From the what to the why Looking at macro-level changes in performance at a sector level is interesting, and gives you a benchmark against which to compare your own organisation, set goals and start dialogues with your colleagues. But we believe it is much more useful to look at how and why individual organisations achieved results in their particular circumstances by following their example, you can apply best practices to your own business. Working capital management 5

6 Look to the leaders Some businesses are far ahead of the average. We looked at organisations that showed both strong DWC performance and a positive growth rate. They set an example your business can follow. Picking the winners We selected 15 corporates that demonstrated clear improvement in DWC performance. We chose them because they each had a market capitalisation of more than EUR 1billion, a positive compound annual growth rate (CAGR) to indicate business performance was not sacrificed for working capital optimisation, and a DWC improvement of more than 20%. We chose a group of companies from a range of industries, including retail, transportation, manufacturing and communications we hope you will find one that aligns to your business. We reviewed financial statements and other public documents to gain an insight into the specific measures these companies used to improve their working capital during the time period. Performance by the numbers These organisations demonstrate class-leading DWC, averaging 44 days in 2013, and a 40% improvement during the period. Naturally, depending on whether you look at absolute days improvement or relative percentage improvement, you find different winners. In the annual reviews and public documents we studied, we found a range of improvements. For instance, Volvo improved its DWC by 69%, reducing it from 80 days in 2008 to 24 days in But for an organisation like TeliaSonera starting at just 17 days, its reduction of five days is also a significant achievement. What matters is, regardless of their starting point in terms of DWC, and regardless of their revenue, sector and growth rate, they all showed that it is possible for a large multinational to achieve impressive improvements in DWC in just a five-year period. It is likely your corporation can do this as well. 6 Working capital management

7 Amer Sports Fiskars Swedish Match Novo Nordisk NIBE Industrier days / -26% Volvo days / -31% Huhtamaki Yara International Clas Ohlson Electrolux Royal Unibrew HEXPOL days / -24% -21 days / -37% Hafslund Millicom International Cellular TeliaSonera days / -69% -6 days / -28% 0-40 days / -92% Figure 3: DWC improvements by company, indicating absolute and relative change, Highlighted companies are discussed in the following sections. What makes a top performer? So what can you do to emulate their success? Every business will have unique challenges and will take some unique approaches tailored to their particular situations. Improvements to working capital can and should come from all areas of the business. For example, from what we observed in our study of annual reviews and other public documents from 2008 to 2013, Royal Unibrew began its efforts to improve working capital in 2008 by focusing on managing inventories, trade receivables and trade payables. In 2009, the group kept investment in production facilities limited to replacing individual components related to specific products or optimisation of selected processes or maintenance. This approach was still in place in During the period, the group achieved a dramatic reduction of 92%, lowering its DWC figure from 44 to four days. In our work with customers overall and in our detailed review of the annual reports from these successful companies and other published material, we have identified four focus areas that most of these companies have in common. The most important of these four is that they make WCM part of their DNA, not just in the finance function, but right across the business. Working capital management 7

8 Key success factors The strongest performers have taken all kinds of paths to get where they are today. But they share a focus on four key areas. Make WCM a priority Organisations that have successfully improved their DWC have made WCM a priority and committed to a long-term strategic plan. Most began in the aftermath of the 2008 financial crisis although some started even earlier. For WCM to be successful, it needs strong executive ownership, preferably from the CFO or CEO. Mergers and acquisitions, market fluctuations, and organisational changes, for example, can make it harder to implement effective WCM. Having C-level buy-in can help ensure organisations sustain their WCM focus even in the most volatile environments. It is important to communicate targets clearly and regularly so key staff understand WCM is a business priority. And having realistic targets in place provides a basis for measuring progress. Linking working capital targets to rewards Some corporates have tied their executive remuneration schemes to working capital-related targets, as seen in the publicly available annual filings we studied. For instance, Amer Sports bases its rewards for business area presidents on working capital, as well as EBIT net sales and attainment of group targets. Similarly, Electrolux s remuneration model for managers has clear targets linked to working capital efficiency. In addition, the company has a dedicated programme to improve WCM in areas such as sales, marketing, procurement, manufacturing and administration. Optimise inventory management Effective inventory management means aligning customer demand with production or supply to reduce the value of inventories sitting idle. We found many organisations centralised warehouses as part of the inventory optimisation process and took measures to reduce the complexity of stock keeping. Some organisations that have reduced DWC apply different production models depending on the type, volume and level of product customisation required. This includes practices such as manufacturing customised, low-volume products to order, but using customer forecasts to plan production of standard, higher-volume goods. But, it is important to note there is no one size fits all way to drive optimisation. And you certainly do not want to cut held inventory to the bone if it means running out of stock during a period of high demand, for example. Turning inventory into sales revenue Hardware store chain Clas Ohlson improved inventory turnover by seven days. According to the company s public reports, the majority (90%) of the company s assets comprise non-current assets and inventories. As a result, it focused on detecting and preventing deficiencies in these areas when designing internal controls. During the 2012 financial year, the company s entire inventory of 15,000 items was replaced almost every 60 days. 8 Working capital management

9 We have looked at some supply chain finance programmes to achieve a better working capital. This has included assisting our suppliers to borrow cheaply on our balance sheets. We are also entering into discussions with customers about joining their supply chain finance programmes. Per Norman Head of Treasury and Risk Management, BillerudKorsnäs Streamline supply chain management A number of organisations in the study focused on making their supply chain management more efficient by extending and harmonising payment terms with suppliers, rationalising their range of suppliers, or even moving towards in-house manufacturing. An increased focus on communication is fundamental to tightening the movement of goods and cash throughout the supply chain for example, by using automated messaging to improve supply and demand information sharing across the ecosystem, and increasing collaboration between business functions. A strategic view of the supply chain Amer Sports public filings show it implemented a global supply chain management programme in It incorporated a global operating platform for sales, logistics, local sourcing and information technology, which is used to manage its production centres in several Asian countries. Similarly, Fiskars made supply chain management a focus area in 2008, according to publicly available data. Fiskars created a global procurement strategy by reviewing subcontractor partners and enhancing the efficiency of in-house production to make the overall supply chain demand-driven. By 2009 the company moved more towards outsourcing production, and by 2013 it had restructured its supply chain programme. Prioritise receivables management Some of the best performing companies paid particular attention to harmonising and optimising payment terms, renegotiating contracts, and improving the overall efficiency of invoicing. This could be achieved in a number of ways, such as by implementing processes like electronic or automated invoicing, and moving customers to faster or more reliable payment types such as direct debits. A few of the organisations we evaluated also focused on improving the handling of overdue receivables for instance, by implementing a more proactive and consistent approach to chasing collections. Success in days sales outstanding Our study of Millicom International Cellular s publicly available annual reports and documents shows it renegotiated its contracts with suppliers in In the same year the company introduced a new purchasing process and reduced inventories, which led to a reduction in DWC. The company achieved a reduction of six days of its receivables turnover, with an overall WCM improvement of 28%. Working capital management 9

10 Conclusion While the results of the 15 organisations are inspiring, the scale of the changes they undertook may be daunting, too. The fact is: achieving WCM excellence is a long and difficult road. To get there you will need to take a holistic approach not only moving all the levers that add up to the ultimate DWC metric, but skilfully orchestrating people, process and technology change, right across the business. That is why the most important advice of all is to start by building commitment: inspire the organisation s leaders, including the CEO, and show them what is possible. Only with the business s strategy behind you will you reach your goal. Only with the business s strategy behind you will you reach your goal. NEXT STEPS Would you like to learn more about WCM and the discipline involved in setting targets and making improvements? Visit insights.nordea.com or contact your relationship manager for more information. 10 Working capital management

11 Methodology To create this report we examined key financial metrics from 403 Nordic corporations, over the period Starting with the 570 companies listed on the OMXC, OMXH, OMXS and OSEBX exchanges, we filtered out financial services firms and the smaller organisations listed on the First North exchange, whose volatility could have distorted our trends analysis. We used public information, like company presentations, and supplemented this with figures and statements from each company s annual filings and other published documents. To complement this quantitative study, we performed a further deep dive qualitative analysis of 15 companies and the working capital initiatives they have followed. We chose organisations that displayed: A market value greater than EUR 1billion, ensuring a measure of stability in market performance. A significant and sustained improvement in working capital of more than 20% over the period. Strong business performance, with positive CAGR. This is to ensure improvements in DWC did not compromise business health. 7% Transportation 8% Technology services 10% Electronic technology 16% Producer manufacturing 10% Industrial services CONTRIBUTORS Industry 7% Process industries 9% Health technology ROBIN BERGHOLM Head of Working Capital Management, Wholesale Banking 15% >2,000 64% <500 21% 500-2,000 Robin Bergholm is Head of Working Capital Management, Wholesale Banking for Nordea. Robin is responsible for the WCM solution offering and services for Nordea s largest corporate customers. Prior to joining Nordea in 2008, he worked as a management consultant for 12 years. Turnover (MEUR) 17% 37% Denmark Sweden JOONAS JUNTTILA Global Business Developer at Nordea Trade Finance Sales Development Country 21% Norway 23% Finland Joonas is a transaction banking professional with broad business development and IT project experience in areas such as trade finance, cash management and credit card processing. Joonas is currently working on keeping Nordea s Trade Finance services matched with the latest trends within the corporate market. Working capital management 11

12 About Nordea Nordea s vision is to be a great European bank, acknowledged for its people, creating superior value for customers and shareholders. We are making it possible for our customers to reach their goals by providing a wide range of products, services and solutions within banking, asset management and insurance. Nordea is one of few European banks with an AA-rating and is also among the ten largest full-service banks in Europe, based on market capitalisation. We have the largest customer base of any financial services group in the Nordic region, with approximately 10 million household customers and around 500,000 corporate clients. The Nordea share is listed on the NASDAQ OMX Nordic Exchange in Stockholm, Helsinki and Copenhagen. SWEDEN Nordea Bank AB Smålandsgatan 17 SE Stockholm DENMARK Nordea Bank Danmark A/S Christiansbro, Strandgade 3 PO Box 850 DK-0900 Copenhagen C FINLAND Nordea Bank Finland Plc Aleksanterinkatu 36 B Helsinki FI Nordea NORWAY Nordea Bank Norge ASA Middelthunsgt. 17 NO-0368 Oslo T: T: T: T: nordea.com