1 TRACKING TRENDS IN HEALTH SYSTEM PERFORMANCE SEPTEMBER 2013 IN STATES HANDS How the Decision to Expand Medicaid Will Affect the Most Financially Vulnerable Americans Findings from the Commonwealth Fund Health Insurance Tracking Surveys of U.S. Adults, 2011 and 2012 The mission of The Commonwealth Fund is to promote a high performance health care system. The Fund carries out this mandate by supporting independent research on health care issues and making grants to improve health care practice and policy. Support for this research was provided by The Commonwealth Fund. The views presented here are those of the authors and not necessarily those of The Commonwealth Fund or its directors, officers, or staff. For more information about this study, please contact: Petra W. Rasmussen, M.P.H. Senior Research Associate, Affordable Health Care Insurance and Access for All The Commonwealth Fund To learn more about new publications when they become available, visit the Fund s website and register to receive alerts. Commonwealth Fund pub Vol. 23 Petra W. Rasmussen, Sara R. Collins, Michelle M. Doty, and Tracy Garber Abstract: Between 2010 and 2012, nearly one-third (32%) of U.S. adults ages 19 to 64, or an estimated 55 million people, were either continuously uninsured or spent a period of time uninsured. Data from the 2011 and 2012 Commonwealth Fund Health Insurance Tracking Surveys of U.S. Adults show that people with incomes below 133 percent of the federal poverty level (i.e., the level that will make them eligible for Medicaid in 2014 under the Affordable Care Act) were uninsured at the highest rates. Yet, fewer than half the states are currently planning to expand their Medicaid programs, because the 2012 Supreme Court decision allows states to choose whether to expand eligibility. In those states that have not yet decided to expand, as many as two of five (42%) adults who were uninsured for any time over the two years would not have access to the new coverage provisions in the law. OVERVIEW In January 2014, the central coverage provisions of the Affordable Care Act go into effect, providing new coverage options for millions of Americans who are currently without affordable health insurance. The law will accomplish this by providing subsidies for private health plans sold through the new state insurance marketplaces also called exchanges and by expanding eligibility for Medicaid. In 2012, however, the Supreme Court ruled to allow states to decide whether or not to expand their Medicaid programs. In states that choose not to expand their programs, adults with low incomes will not be able to fully benefit from the law and gain access to coverage. Currently, fewer than half the states have indicated they plan to expand their programs next year (Exhibit 1).
2 2 The Commonwealth Fund Exhibit 1. Status of State Participation in Medicaid Expansion, as of August 2013 WA ME AK HI OR CA NV ID AZ UT MT WY CO NM ND SD NE KS OK MN WI IA IL MO AR MS IN MI TN AL KY OH GA WV SC VA NC NY VT NH MA CT RI PA NJ MD DE DC TX LA Expanding (21 states + DC) Expanding with variation (3) Unclear/undecided (5) Not expanding (21) FL Note: Indiana and Tennessee have considered expanding with variation. Source: Avalere State Reform Insights; Center of Budget and Policy Priorities; Politico.com; Commonwealth Fund analysis. Data from the 2011 and 2012 Commonwealth Fund Health Insurance Tracking Surveys of U.S. Adults reveal why it is critical for all states to fully explore the benefits of participating in the law s Medicaid expansion. Nearly one-third (32%) of U.S. adults ages 19 to 64, or an estimated 55 million people, were either uninsured for the full two years (2011 and 2012) or spent a time without health insurance. Adults who would be eligible for Medicaid next year that is, those with incomes below 133 percent of the federal poverty level ($14,856 for an individual and $30,657 for a family of four) were uninsured at the highest rates. 1 In the 26 states that are leaning toward not expanding their programs or are undecided, nearly three-quarters (72%) of low-income adults had been uninsured at some point during the two-year period. Some of these adults those earning more than the poverty level ($11,170 for an individual and $23,050 for a family of four) will be eligible for subsidized private coverage through the new marketplaces. However, there are no new subsidized insurance options for families with incomes below the poverty level because lawmakers assumed they would be eligible for the Medicaid expansion; they did not anticipate the Supreme Court decision. 2 SURVEY FINDINGS Low-Income Adults Most Likely to Be Uninsured The surveys interviewed adults ages 19 to 64 in June 2011 and again in September 2012 to examine changes in their health insurance coverage. Respondents were asked if they were uninsured at the time of either survey or, if insured, whether they had spent any time without insurance during the prior year. Nearly one-third (32%) of adults, or an estimated 55 million people, were uninsured in either 2011 or 2012, or had spent some time without insurance between June 2010 and September 2012 (Exhibit 2). Over the two-year period, 9 percent of adults were uninsured for the full two years and 23 percent spent some time with health insurance and some time without it. 3 Adults with the lowest incomes were the most likely to have spent a time without insurance. More than two-thirds (68%) of adults in households with
3 In States Hands: How the Decision to Expand Medicaid Will Affect Vulnerable Americans 3 incomes that fell below 133 percent of poverty for all or part of the two-year period were uninsured for a time. This is more than three times the rate of those with higher incomes (21%). 4 Among adults with low incomes, 23 percent were always uninsured over the two years; 45 percent were uninsured for part of the period. States That Are Not Expanding Medicaid Have High Rates of Uninsured Low-Income Adults Most of the estimated 55 million adults in the survey who were uninsured for all or part of the two years will be eligible for new affordable insurance options starting in January These options include a significant expansion in eligibility for Medicaid to people with incomes up to 133 percent of poverty and subsidies for private health plans sold through the new insurance marketplaces for those with incomes up to 400 percent of poverty ($44,680 for an individual and $92,200 for a family of four). Yet the decision by many states not to participate in the law s Medicaid expansion means that many of the lowest-income adults will continue to lack access to affordable coverage. Indeed, the survey found that in the 26 states that have said they are not expanding or are undecided, nearly three-quarters (72%) of adults with incomes below 133 percent of poverty in one or both of the two years spent a time uninsured over the two-year period (Exhibit 3). In states that are planning to expand their Medicaid programs, 61 percent of adults with incomes below 133 percent of poverty spent a time without insurance. 6 In States That Do Not Expand Medicaid, Poorest Residents Will Not Have Access to the Law s Subsidized Insurance Options The Affordable Care Act provides Medicaid coverage to adults with incomes below 133 percent of poverty. Tax credits to offset premium costs are available for people earning between 100 percent and 399 percent Exhibit 2. More Than Two-Thirds of Adults with Incomes Below 133 Percent of Poverty Spent Any Time Uninsured over Two Years Always uninsured Some time uninsured Always insured FPL Uninsured any time over two years* 32% Total <133% FPL in one or both years (single: <$14,856 family of 4: <$30,657) 23 68% % FPL in both years (single: $14,856 family of 4: $30,657) 5 21% Percent of adults ages Notes: Numbers may not sum to indicated total because of rounding. FPL refers to 2012 federal poverty level. * Combines Some time uninsured and Always uninsured. Source: The Commonwealth Fund Health Insurance Tracking Surveys of U.S. Adults (2011 and 2012).
4 4 The Commonwealth Fund Exhibit 3. Nearly Three-Quarters of Low-Income Adults in States That Are Leaning Toward Not Expanding Medicaid Were Uninsured for Any Time over Two Years Medicaid expansion Always uninsured Some time uninsured Always insured Uninsured any time over two years* 68% Total States not expanding Medicaid or undecided 26 61% 72% States expanding Medicaid Percent of adults ages with income <133% FPL in one or both years Note: FPL refers to 2012 federal poverty level. 133% FPL is equal to an income of $14,856 for an individual, or $30,657 for a family of four. Numbers may not sum to indicated total because of rounding. * Combines Some time uninsured and Always uninsured. See Exhibit 1 for state decisions on expanding Medicaid. Source: The Commonwealth Fund Health Insurance Tracking Surveys of U.S. Adults (2011 and 2012). Exhibit 4. In States That Are Leaning Toward Not Expanding Medicaid or Are Undecided, Adults with Incomes Under $11,170 Who Spent Any Time Uninsured over Two Years Will Have No New Coverage Options Percent of adults ages Total adults uninsured for any time over two years* Adults uninsured for any time over two years* in states expanding Medicaid Adults uninsured for any time over two years* in states not expanding Medicaid or undecided <100% FPL in both years (<$11,170 for individual) <100% FPL in one or both years** (<$11,170 for individual) 15% 36% 9% 29% Medicaid coverage 19% 42% No new Medicaid coverage; ineligible for subsidized coverage through state marketplaces Note: FPL refers to 2012 federal poverty level. * Combines Some time uninsured and Always uninsured. ** Combines <100% FPL both years and <100% FPL in 2011 or See Exhibit 1 for state decisions on expanding Medicaid. Source: The Commonwealth Fund Health Insurance Tracking Surveys of U.S. Adults (2011 and 2012).
5 In States Hands: How the Decision to Expand Medicaid Will Affect Vulnerable Americans 5 of poverty, who are not eligible for Medicaid or other public coverage, or affordable employer coverage. In addition, the tax credits are available to legal immigrants with incomes below 100 percent of poverty while they are in the five-year Medicaid waiting period that is required under federal law. But because lawmakers assumed that all states would participate in the Medicaid expansion, no similar allowance was made for citizens with incomes below the poverty level. As a result, in states that do not expand their programs, adults with incomes between 100 percent and 133 percent of poverty will be eligible for subsidies, but adults with incomes below 100 percent of poverty who are not legal immigrants will not have access to Medicaid or subsidies for private plans. In the 26 states that have decided not to expand their programs or are undecided, the survey analysis finds that more than two of five (42%) adults uninsured any time over the two years had incomes that were below poverty in one or both years, potentially leaving them without access to the provisions for part or all of the time they were without coverage (Exhibit 4). In contrast, in states that are planning to expand their Medicaid programs, 29 percent of those who were uninsured for any time over the two-year period had incomes below poverty in one or both years. 7 Annual Income Changes Could Lead to Coverage Losses for Adults The vulnerability of low-income people in states that do not expand their Medicaid programs will be exacerbated by annual changes in income. People might have incomes high enough to gain subsidized health coverage in one year, but then a job loss, or other life change, could mean a reduction in income that would make them ineligible for subsidies in the following year. In the survey, among people in households with incomes between 100 percent and 133 percent of poverty in 2011, 29 percent experienced a change in income that lowered their household earnings to less than 100 percent of poverty in 2012 (Exhibit 5). Twelve percent of those earning between 133 percent and 249 percent of poverty in 2011 also experienced an income change Exhibit 5. Many Adults Experience Year-to-Year Income Fluctuations That Would Change Their Eligibility for Medicaid and Subsidized Private Plans 2012 FPL 2011 FPL <100% FPL 100% <133% FPL 133% 249% FPL 250% 399% FPL 400% FPL+ <100% FPL % <133% FPL % 249% FPL % 399% FPL % FPL Percent of adults ages Notes: Numbers may not sum to 100 percent because of rounding. FPL refers to federal poverty level. Source: The Commonwealth Fund Health Insurance Tracking Surveys of U.S. Adults (2011 and 2012).
6 6 The Commonwealth Fund that lowered their earnings to less than the poverty level in In contrast, 30 percent of adults who earned less than 100 percent of poverty in 2011 experienced an income gain that that would have made them eligible for subsidized coverage in Two-thirds of adults in this income group had incomes below poverty in both years. CONCLUSION AND POLICY IMPLICATIONS The central goal of the Affordable Care Act is to achieve near-universal health insurance coverage over the next decade. It accomplishes this through the largest expansion in eligibility for Medicaid since the program s inception in 1965 and through subsidized private plans available through new state insurance marketplaces. While only 24 states and the District of Columbia have decided to expand eligibility for their Medicaid programs next year, there is a high probability that more states will participate over time. All states currently participate in the existing Medicaid and Children s Health Insurance Programs, which have less federal financial support than the Medicaid expansion. The federal government will finance 100 percent of the Medicaid expansion in most states through 2016, phasing down to 90 percent for all states by This new financing translates to an infusion of $800.2 billion in federal funds over , according to the Kaiser Family Foundation. 8 In addition, with millions of currently uninsured people receiving coverage, states could save an estimated $18.3 billion through 2022 in uncompensated care costs. 9 Several governors and state legislatures are continuing to debate the benefits of participating in the Medicaid expansion. In the meantime, Congress could step in and provide a solution by passing legislation that would amend the law to make all adults with incomes below 100 percent of poverty, who are not eligible for Medicaid, eligible for subsidized private plans offered through the marketplaces. This would ensure that all Americans have access to the law s sweeping new reforms when they take effect in January. Survey Methodology The Commonwealth Fund Health Insurance Tracking Surveys were conducted in two waves by the online research firm Knowledge Networks in 2011 and 2012, among a representative sample of adults ages 19 to 64. The first survey was conducted between June 24, 2011, and July 5, The survey sample was drawn from Knowledge Panel a probability-based online panel that is representative of the U.S. population and includes cell phone only and low-income households that are typically difficult to reach using traditional telephone surveys and random-digit-dialing sampling. Respondents to the 2011 survey were recontacted in 2012 between August 31 and September 28. A total of 1,416 adults completed both waves of the survey. We include in this analysis only those respondents who reported income in both waves, leaving a sample size of 1,317. Data are weighted to correct for the longitudinal panel aspects of the study design and disproportionate nonresponse that might bias results. The data are weighted to the U.S. adult population, ages 19 to 64, by gender, age, race/ethnicity, education, poverty level, census region, metropolitan area, Internet access, and primary language using the U.S. Census Current Population Survey March 2010, the CPS supplemental survey measuring Internet access (from October 2010), and the Pew Hispanic Center Survey (2010) for Spanish language proficiency distributions. The resulting weighted sample is representative of the approximately million U.S. adults ages 19 to 64. The margin of sampling error for the longitudinal sample is +/ 3.4 percent.
7 In States Hands: How the Decision to Expand Medicaid Will Affect Vulnerable Americans 7 Notes 1 Throughout the report, poverty levels are for Under the existing Medicaid program, all states currently offer Medicaid coverage to children through age 5 to at least 133 percent of poverty and to at least 100 percent of poverty for children ages 6 through 18. All states also offer Medicaid coverage to parents of dependent children, though income eligibility levels are very low in many states, particularly in most states that have not yet decided to expand their Medicaid programs under the Affordable Care Act. Only a few states offer Medicaid coverage to adults without children. See Kaiser Family Foundation, State Health Facts, 3 Those who were uninsured for the full two years were uninsured at the time of the survey in both 2011 and 2012 and reported being uninsured for one year or more at each time period. 4 All reported differences are statistically significant at p 0.05 or better, unless otherwise noted. 5 Undocumented immigrants are not eligible for either Medicaid or subsidized private plans. Thus, not all of the adults who were uninsured in the survey would be eligible for the law s coverage expansions. 6 The difference in uninsured rates among people earning less than 133 percent of poverty between those states that plan to expand their Medicaid programs and those that are not currently planning to expand is not statistically significant. 7 This difference is likely driven in part by greater access to health insurance for lower-income adults in the states that are expanding through those states existing Medicaid programs. States that are expanding on balance have higher Medicaid income eligibility limits for parents of dependent children and a few have expanded eligibility in their existing programs for adults without children. See Kaiser Family Foundation, State Health Facts, org/statedata/. 8 J. Holahan, M. Buettgens, and S. Dorn, The Cost of Not Expanding Medicaid (Washington, D.C.: Kaiser Family Foundation, July 2013), the-cost-of-not-expanding-medicaid/. 9 Ibid.
8 8 The Commonwealth Fund About the Authors Petra W. Rasmussen, M.P.H., is senior research associate for the Fund s Health Care Coverage and Access program. In this role, Ms. Rasmussen is responsible for contributing to survey questionnaire development, analyzing survey results through statistical analysis, and writing survey issue briefs and articles. In addition, she is involved in tracking and researching emerging policy issues regarding health reform and the comprehensiveness and affordability of health insurance coverage and access to care in the United States. Ms. Rasmussen holds a B.A. in global health practices and policies from Duke University and an M.P.H. in health policy and management from Columbia University s Mailman School of Public Health. She can be ed at Sara R. Collins, Ph.D., is vice president for the Health Care Coverage and Access program at The Commonwealth Fund. An economist, Dr. Collins joined the Fund in 2002 and has led the Fund s national program on health insurance since Since joining the Fund, she has led several national surveys on health insurance and authored numerous reports, issue briefs, and journal articles on health insurance coverage and policy. She has provided invited testimony before several Congressional committees and subcommittees. Prior to joining the Fund, Dr. Collins was associate director/senior research associate at the New York Academy of Medicine, Division of Health and Science Policy. Earlier in her career, she was an associate editor at U.S. News & World Report, a senior economist at Health Economics Research, and a senior health policy analyst in the New York City Office of the Public Advocate. She holds an A.B. in economics from Washington University and a Ph.D. in economics from George Washington University. Michelle M. Doty, Ph.D., is vice president of survey research and evaluation for The Commonwealth Fund. She has authored numerous publications on cross-national comparisons of health system performance, access to quality health care among vulnerable populations, and the extent to which lack of health insurance contributes to inequities in quality of care. She received her M.P.H. and Ph.D. in public health from the University of California, Los Angeles. Tracy Garber, M.P.H., is senior policy associate for The Commonwealth Fund s Health Care Coverage and Access program, for which she provides grant support, analyzes Fund survey data, and tracks and analyzes health reform implementation. Prior to joining the Fund, she was the development assistant and volunteer coordinator for the Hamilton-Madison House in lower Manhattan, a settlement house. Ms. Garber received her bachelor s degree in women s studies and English from the University of Delaware in 2008, and her M.P.H. from the CUNY School of Public Health at Hunter College in Editorial support was provided by Deborah Lorber.
INSURING the FUTURE Current Trends in Health Coverage and the Effects of Implementing the Affordable Care Act Findings from the Commonwealth Fund Biennial Health Insurance Survey, 2012 Sara R. Collins,
Help on the Horizon How the Recession Has Left Millions of Workers Without Health Insurance, and How Health Reform Will Bring Relief Findings from The Commonwealth Fund Biennial Health Insurance Survey
THE STATE CHILDREN S HEALTH INSURANCE PROGRAM: PAST, PRESENT, AND FUTURE Jeanne M. Lambrew George Washington University January 2007 Prepared for The Commonwealth Fund/Alliance for Health Reform 2007 Bipartisan
GAPS IN HEALTH INSURANCE: AN ALL-AMERICAN PROBLEM FINDINGS FROM THE COMMONWEALTH FUND BIENNIAL HEALTH INSURANCE SURVEY Sara R. Collins, Karen Davis, Michelle M. Doty, Jennifer L. Kriss, and Alyssa L. Holmgren
Making Them Stronger and More Affordable By William Zumeta and Deborah Frankle March 2007 Prepared for The William and Flora Hewlett Foundation By The National Center for Public Policy and Higher Education
Health Insurance Coverage: Early Release of Estimates From the National Health Interview Survey, January March 2014 by Robin A. Cohen, Ph.D., and Michael E. Martinez, M.P.H., M.H.S.A. Division of Health
Affordable Care Act Plans and Premiums in Rural America Policy Brief July 2014 Editorial Note: During its Spring 2014 Committee Meeting in Omaha, Nebraska, the National Advisory Committee on Rural Health
Trends in0 1 Trends Higher Education Series COLLEGE PRICING 2014 See the Trends in Higher Education website at trends.collegeboard.org for the figures and tables in this report and for more information
Issue Report F as in Fat: How Obesity Threatens 2012 America s Future September 2012 Preventing Epidemics. Protecting People. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Trust for America s Health is a non-profit, non-partisan organization
The Effect of Repealing the Florida Motor Vehicle No-fault Law Report Number 2008-102 October 2007 Prepared for The Florida Senate Prepared by Committee on Banking and Insurance Table of Contents Introduction...3
Medical Malpractice: Overview and Legislation in the 112 th Congress Baird Webel Specialist in Financial Economics Vivian S. Chu Legislative Attorney Amanda K. Sarata Specialist in Health Policy June 18,
R E P O R T SNAP Take-up Among Immigrant Families with Children Curtis Skinner March 2011 The National Center for Children in Poverty (NCCP) is the nation s leading public policy center dedicated to promoting
N C S D A E National Council of State Directors of Adult Education Sinking or Swimming: Findings from a Survey of State Adult Education Tuition and Financing Policies June 2012 Marcie Foster with Lennox
ISSUE REPORT F as in Fat: HOW OBESITY POLICIES ARE 2009 FAILING IN AMERICA JULY 2009 PREVENTING EPIDEMICS. PROTECTING PEOPLE. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS TRUST FOR AMERICA S HEALTH IS A NON-PROFIT, NON-PARTISAN ORGANIZATION
The Medical Malpractice Insurance Crisis: Opportunity for State Action Mimi Marchev July 2002 Funded by The Robert Wood Johnson Foundation GNL48 The Medical Malpractice Insurance Crisis: Opportunity for
State Online College Job Market RANKING THE STATES RESUME JOB SEARCH 2015 Anthony Carnevale Tamara Jayasundera Dmitri Repnikov Artem Gulish Center on Education and the Workforce McCourt School of Public
Differences Between Students Who Were and Were Not Retained in Grade GED Testing Service Research Studies, 2007-3 General Educational Development Testing Service of the American Council on Education 2007
JULY 2012 Estimates for the Insurance Coverage Provisions of the Affordable Care Act Updated for the Recent Supreme Court Decision The Congressional Budget Office (CBO) and the staff of the Joint Committee
CHILD POLICY CIVIL JUSTICE EDUCATION ENERGY AND ENVIRONMENT HEALTH AND HEALTH CARE INTERNATIONAL AFFAIRS NATIONAL SECURITY POPULATION AND AGING PUBLIC SAFETY SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY SUBSTANCE ABUSE TERRORISM
Consider Savings as Well as Costs State Governments Would Spend at Least $90 Billion Less With the ACA than Without It from 2014 to 2019 Timely Analysis of Immediate Health Policy Issues July 2011 Matthew
MEASURING UP 2008 THE NATIONAL REPORT CARD ON HIGHER EDUCATION THE NATIONAL CENTER FOR PUBLIC POLICY AND HIGHER EDUCATION BOARD OF DIRECTORS Chairman THE HONORABLE JAMES B. HUNT JR. Womble Carlyle Sandridge
Managing Physical Rehabilitation in a Managed Care Environment Peter R. Kovacek, MSA, PT Kathleen A. Jakubiak Kovacek, PT KovacekManagementServices, Inc Harper Woods, Michigan KovacekManagementServices,
Treatment for Pathological/Problem Gambling and the Role of State Alcohol and Other Drug Agencies Prepared by: The National Association of State Alcohol and Drug Abuse Directors, Inc. (NASADAD) With Support
Using Behavioral Economics to Inform the Integration of Human Services and Health Programs under the Affordable Care Act Prepared by: Fredric Blavin, Stan Dorn, and Jay Dev The Urban Institute Under Task
Spotlight on The Annual Required Contribution Experience of State Retirement s, FY 01 to FY 13 Keith Brainard and Alex Brown National Association of State Retirement Administrators March 2015 Executive