1 ENTREPRENEURSHIP AND MANAGEMENT PRZEDSIĘBIORCZOŚĆ I ZARZĄDZANIE Tom XIV, Zeszyt 7 Logistics Management Editor: Katarzyna Kolasińska-Morawska Łódź 2013
2 This magazine is financed by Społeczna Akademia Nauk All the articles published in the magazine are subject to reviews. Editor: Katarzyna Kolasińska-Morawska Adjustment:Dominika Świech Typesetting i cover design: Marcin Szadkowski Copyright by Społeczna Akademia Nauk ISSN: Wydawnictwo Społecznej Akademii Nauk ul. Kilińskiego 109, Łódź , w. 339, Printed version is the original version of the magazine. Printing and binding: Mazowieckie Centrum Poligrafii, ul. Duża 1, Marki,
3 Spis treści Katarzyna Kolasińska-Morawska Preface Michał Chmielecki Multi-Cultural Customer Service in 3PL Danuta Janczewska The Position of Innovative Strategy in Marketing-Logistic Management in SMEs Sector Mirosław Włodarczyk, Jerzy Janczewski Problems of Material Flows in Recovery Logistics Joanna Krygier The Role of SCM Systems in the Management of Global Supply Chains Bartłomiej Stopczyński Logistic centers as the integration of international supply chains Marta Brzozowska Relationship management in supply chains on the example of chain retailers Robert Seliga Ecologistics - contemporary trend in building the image of medical units Sławomir Bartosiewicz, Katarzyna Świerszcz IT and telematic systems in Polish logistics centres Katarzyna Świerszcz, Sławomir Bartosiewicz Partnership as a determining factor of competitive strategy in supply chain management Paweł Nowicki, Piotr Kafel, Tadeusz Sikora Food safety management fulfillment of selected hygienic and sanitary requirements in polish grocery stores networks Ludmiła Łopacińska, Adam Mazurkiewicz The use of multi-level evaluation approach in research projects undertaken within strategic research programmes Łukasz Sułkowski The identity and demarcation of management in family of social sciences Katarzyna Kolasińska-Morawska Logistic customer service in online sales of FMCG using the example of retail chains Paweł Morawski E-Logistics tools in distribution channels
5 Preface It is my pleasure to announce that new Logistics Management volume published at the University of Social Sciences in a series of scientific Entrepreneurship and Management is ready to be released. This is a special edition because all articles are published in English and therefore it can be distributed and promoted abroad as well. Articles presented in the following volume concern area of logistics management and are result of observation, analysis, research and professional experience of scientists from the University of Social Sciences and invited representatives of scientific and business. The following volume is focused on distribution channels however spectrum of subjects presented is wider as logistics is comprehensive scientific discipline. Logistics, as a scientific discipline, achieved on the one hand a strong and stable position in the field of management and engineering sciences on the other hand is one of the main areas of business practice that effectively integrates business processes. Logistics processes that cover the area of procurement, production (internal) and distribution are very important, even crucial impact on the effectiveness and efficiency of the entire enterprises. In this light the tasks of distribution channels are extremely important. Optimization of logistics activities in the sphere of distribution plays crucial role in the success of the whole business venture because distribution channel ends at client-consumer who is treated as a business sponsor. Such sponsor can determine success of particular company by choosing one or another product or service through one or another distribution channel. Logistics within scientific disciplines refers to detailed disciplines such as management science, commodity, computer science, finance, production engineering, the science of defense and security. On the practical field logistics plays key role in the support for businesses in the areas of marketing and customer service and technical organization of the flow of physical goods. In this regard a special place and importance is undertaken to research and development (R&D) which should be responsible transfer of knowledge from science to business. The subject of articles presented in the current volume of Logistics Management covers a broad spectrum of issues in the field of logistics in theoretical and practical frame as well. Presented articles are result of scientific research and cover five main areas as follow: logistic customer service within distribution channels, ecologistics, e-logistics and ICT usage in logistics, relationship and partnership management in supply chains, logistic centers and their role within distribution channels, research methods, sustainable development and innovative strategies in logistics.
6 Two authors have presented their articles in the area of logistic customer service. Dr Katarzyna Kolasińska-Morawska has described logistics customer service issues in online sales of fast-moving consumer goods on the example of network retail companies. Dr Michal Chmielecki turned his thoughts towards multi-cultural customer service in third party logistics. Area of e-logistics and ICT usage in logistics has been elaborated by four authors in current volume of Logistics Management. Dr Joanna Krygier has described the role of Supply Chain Management (SCM) systems in the management of global supply chains. Two authors dr Katarzyna Świerszcz and dr Sławomir Bartosiewicz have presented article concerning IT and telematic systems in polish logistics centres. In that area dr inż. Pawel Morawski has described e-logistics tools in distribution channels. Topic of relationship and partnership management within supply chain has been described by three authors. Dr Katarzyna Świerszcz and dr Sławomir Bartosiewicz presented their thoughts about partnership as a determining factor of competitive strategy in supply chain management. In turn mgr inż. Marta Brzozowska has described relationship management issues in supply chains on the example of chain retailers. Dr Bartłomiej Stopczyński has presented topic of logistic centers as the integration of international supply chains, while dr Robert Seliga has turned his thoughts into ecologistics as contemporary trend in building the image of medical units. Three authors prof. dr hab. Tadeusz Sikora, dr inż. Paweł Nowicki and dr inż. Piotr Kafel have presented topic of food safety management and fulfilmment of selected hygienic and sanitary requirements in polish grocery stores networks. Problems of material flows in recovery logistics were described by two authors prof. dr hab. Mirosław Włodarczyk and dr inż. Jerzy Janczewski in their article. In turn dr inż. Danuta Janczewska in her article has analysed the position of innovative strategy in marketing-logistic management in SMEs Sector. Current volume of Logistics Management contains extremely valuable article in the area of strategic research programme. Prof. dr hab. inż. Adam Mazurkiewicz and mgr Ludmiła Łopacińska have presented evaluation of new technology solutions developed in strategic research programmes as one of the most important aspects ensuring competitiveness of modern knowledge based economies. Prof. dr hab. Łukasz Sułkowski has described the identity and demarcation of management in family of social sciences. Giving that volume of Logistics Management to the reader s hands editors hope that it will be a source of valuable knowledge and inspiration for further research in the area of logistics and distribution. dr Katarzyna Kolasińska-Morawska
7 Michał Chmielecki Społeczna Akademia Nauk Przedsiębiorczość i Zarządzanie Wydawnictwo SAN ISSN Tom XIV, Zeszyt 7, ss Multi-Cultural Customer Service in 3PL Abstract: Successful companies understand what their customers want. Less successful companies often find it hard to obtain a good understanding of what their customers value and how they should be treated, and spend considerable time hustling to do things that are not fully appreciated by their customers. This applies to third-party Logistics sector as well. This paper explores the influence of cultural differences in customer service in 3PL. It outlines the important aspects of culture for international customer service, shows the potential cultural traps and why companies fail to gain maximum value from the customer service. This article offers advice on how to organize international customer service optimally while considering cultural issues. Key-words: Cultural Values, Customer service, Service Quality, Customer Satisfaction. Introduction The idea of adopting third party logistics services has grown in different industries around the world during the past several years and it involves outsourcing logistics activities that were traditionally performed in-house. Opportunities arising from globalization, advances in technology, and outsourcing mean that companies in logistics sector must turn their attention to customer service across national borders. The key is to manage customer service to satisfy customers better than the competition does and that can be done among others by using cultural differences as a competitive advantage. This article explores the influence of cultural differences in customer service in 3PL. It outlines the important aspects of culture for international customer service, shows the potential cultural traps and why companies fail to gain maximum value from the customer service. This article offers advice on how to organize international customer service optimally while considering cultural issues.
8 8 Michał Chmielecki Third-party Logistics According to Sink and Langley , there seems to be no common definition of third party logistics that will satisfy all industry observers and views third party logistics as using the services of an external supplier to perform some or all of a firm s logistics. Bhatnagar et al  also refer to third party logistics as the use of external companies to perform logistics activities either in part or in full. Laarhoven et al  defines third party logistics as activities performed by a logistics service provider on behalf of a shipper and consisting of at least management and execution of transportation and warehousing. Other elements such as inventory management, information related activities, value added activities are also included. According to Knemeyer and Murphy , third-party logistics can be referred to as logistics outsourcing or contract logistics. Coyle, Bardi, and Langley [2003, p. 425] for example define third-party logistics to involve an external supplier that performs all or part of a company s logistics functions and to encompass suppliers of services such as transportation, warehousing, distribution, financial services, and so on. The majority of shippers worldwide are increasing their use of 3PL services, with 64 percent of respondents reporting a rise. At the same time, the 16 th Annual Third-Party Logistics Study report indicates an average of 42 percent of total logistics expenditures being spent on outsourcing, the same as last year s study. However, 24 percent of shipper respondents reported a return to insourcing 3PL services and 58 percent report they are reducing or consolidating the number of 3PLs they use, indicating uncertainty about the global economy continues to impact 3PLs (16th Annual Third-Party Logistics Study, 3PL companies challenges There are not many papers which look at the challenges faced by 3PL companies and address how they can overcome such challenges. However, not many of them have been devoted to cross-cultural communication and management issues [more on this topic Sułkowski 2012]. Logistics planning attempts to make decision at three different levels: strategic, tactical, operational.
9 Multi-Cultural Customer Service in 3PL 9 All these three levels are differentiated by their planning horizon. In figure 1 the 3PL challenges are differentiated by their level of tangibility. At the top level is the Logistics Network Configuration layer (most tangible), to Material Flow layer, to Information Flow layer, and finally to Relationship Management layer (least tangible). Figure 1. Layers of challenges faced by 3PL companies Source: M.L.F. Cheong, Logistics Outsourcing and 3PL Challenges, bitstream/handle/1721.1/3908/imst011.pdf. 3PL companies most of the times seek long-term relationship with their clients and thus are very concerned with maintaining good relationship through good performance and customer service level (Fig. 2). Figure 2. Relative importance of 3PL service features Source: T. Coltman, Price and demand: what do 3PL customers really want?, University of Wollongong Research Online, retrieved
10 10 Michał Chmielecki Today s 3PL marketplace is experiencing significant change and established 3PLs are adjusting their business models to provide greater value to shippers. The 16th Annual Third-Party Logistics Study report shows relationships between shippers and 3PLs continue to be successful with 94 percent of 3PLs and 88 percent of shippers stating communication, flexibility and openness are key to contributing to their success. However just 68 percent of shippers judge their 3PLs as sufficiently agile and flexible, down from 72 percent last year suggesting this is an area where 3PLs can make significant further contributions to supply chain success. (16th Annual Third-Party Logistics Study, It must be stressed that cross-cultural understanding is a key to successful communication and thus successful customer service. Customer service Most of the companies operating in logistics sector perceive customer service centers as cost centers. Relatively few companies see customer service centers as providers of competitive advantage [Feinberg, Ruyter, Bennington 2005]. Creating a winning customer strategy is to deliver a customer value proposition based on a thorough understanding of the customer s culture, values and needs. All of the aforementioned elements of culture influence an effective life relationship. Customer relationships are nowadays viewed as strategic assets and the customer service center must be made into a strategic part of the organization and central part of the Customer Relationship Management (CRM) system. Economic and competitive challenges of the XXI century require that functions of customer service change from an order taking to creating a long term strategic relationship with a client [as described in: Sułkowski, Morawski 2012]. According to McKinsey, The key is to develop a customer service strategy that successfully balances costs, revenues generated, and quality. Only then can companies transform their call centers into strategic assets that provide a competitive advantage and promote growth [McKinsey Quarterly, April 2005]. Cross-cultural differences in customer service in logistics sector Evidence has shown cross-cultural differences do exist and can be observed, measured and statistically tested [Pizam 1999; Reisinger, Turner 1999]. The role of culture in the world of business has been the subject of various research for at
11 Multi-Cultural Customer Service in 3PL 11 least twenty-five years. It plays more and more important role in management sciences [Sułkowski 2002, Sułkowski 2008]. The complexity of culture makes impossible to create one, proper definition. One of the most commonly used definitions of culture, being not a complex one at the same time, in the literature on culture is the definition by Hofstede. Hofstede and Hofstede  suggest that culture is the collective programming of the mind that distinguishes the members of one group or category of people from others [p. 4]. Bjerke  expresses the opinion that culture is a mechanism which fuses social structures [p. 13]. Thus culture is an output formed by a given community consisted of some bases, ideas and classes. Schwartz [qtd. in Lewicki et al. 2007] describes culture as the values, distinguishing ten essential values, namely: power, security, traditions, conformity, benevolence, universalism, self-directions, simulation, hedonism achievement and power [p. 237]. The values might cooperate with each other or there might be a conflict between them. In practice, the values which are on the opposite side of the circle tend to be in a conflict. Service quality and satisfaction One can define service quality as the consumer s comparison between service expectation and service performance [Parasuraman, Zeithaml, Berry 1988]. Although service quality is known to have multiple dimensions [Grönroos 1990], there was no general agreement as to the nature or content of the dimensions [Brady, Cronin 2001]. Although, Parasuraman et al.  identified five dimensions of service quality included: tangibility, reliability, responsiveness, assurance, and empathy, collectively referred to as the SERVQUAL, Carman  found the items of SERVQUAL required further testing to ascertain their broad applicability. An alternative approach to using SERVQUAL was a simplified performance measures only model, namely, the SERVPERF approach [Teas 1994]. This approach was especially useful when service expectations were ambiguous or unknown. One can define satisfaction as contentment determined by comparing customer expectations to the actual perceptions regarding service [Hoffman & Bateson 1997]. Satisfaction can also be referred to a customer s emotional evaluation and subjective judgment about the received service, and has been conceptualized as the fulfillment of drives, motives, needs, or expectations [Oliver 1980]. Satisfaction has been an important measure in marketing since it stems from the belief that users who were highly satisfied with their service experience would likely become loyal users, and there is a chance that they will share their satisfaction with others [Manning 1999]. Rust and Oliver  viewed service quality as an antecedent of satisfaction.
12 12 Michał Chmielecki Intercultural management is an essential part in practicing global CRM. When polled in 2007 by the Conference Board, 80% of companies worldwide believe customer satisfaction to be directly related to their turnover [Feinberg, Ruyter, Bennington 2005]. In support of this, research shows that a 5% increase in customer retention results in a net present value increase in profits of between 25% and 95% [Liu, Furrer, Suharsham 2001]. Customer service across cultures Table 1 is a compilation of issues that must be addressed while the 3PL company is planning to incorporate, improve or simply change their cross-cultural customer service. Table 1. Customer service across cultures Assessing importance of customer service Assess target markets. Language preferences Assess the scope of customer queries Reflecting values and norms Assess the importance of customer service. Before getting started, you need to figure out how important customer service is to your business strategy. For example, if you focus on low prices, customer service excellence may not make too much sense. One must understand what countries and customer segments constitute the company s target market. This will help assess the need for multi-cultural customer service, and identify what languages to support in customer service strategy. In most of the cases, this is obvious but in many other cases, one may need demographic information that tells what languages are primarily and secondarily spoken in specific target markets. Customer service representatives accents, dialects, and understanding of the customer make or break the transactions. Customers in general do not tolerate poor language skills and they will not call a customer service center twice if the language skills are not up to par. For a customer service center, a number of native language speakers is of course preferable because they know all the nuances that help convey meaning and establish understanding with the customer. One should also find language preferences through primary customer research, where one may find that customers have different language preferences depending on the communication channel. For example, English may be possible for and chat but not for phone conversations in many countries. Customer queries fall into four broad categories of varying complexity and interaction depth: informational, transactional, advice-related and diagnostic. On average, transactional, diagnostic and advice-related queries present more service differentiation opportunities through customer service than informational ones. Customer service should respect and reflect the values and norms of particular cultures. Customer service representatives should be able to understand and match the cultural background of the customer. Customer service representatives need to be able to understand and answer the customer correctly according to the customer s expectations, which are imbedded in the norms and values of the customer s culture. Intercultural awareness plays a very important part in this process. For example let us take Hofstede s Power Distance Index into consideration. It is very likely that in some cultures customer will want to speak to someone of at least the same rank and someone with authority. In such case, the customer service representative, who may be a young low rank employee, should transfer the customer and not take it personally. Situations like these which are handled incorrectly can easily lead to frustration for both the customer and the employee, resulting in customer defection and lost sales. On the other hand for customers from Low Power Distance Index cultures e.g. Anglo-Saxon customers, where the emphasis is on pragmatism; matters how the issue is resolved, not who resolves it.
13 Multi-Cultural Customer Service in 3PL 13 Cross-cultural training Adopt culturally nuanced policies and practices Leverage technology. The perception of excellent customer service Customers involvement and expectations Conflict management The cultural context of teamwork in customer service centers Due to globalization, cross-cultural communication has become a vital part of every training more than ever before. According to Datamonitor, all over the world there are roughly interactions per day between customers and businesses and 95% of communication in call centers occurs over the phone. Not surprisingly, successful operations of a customer service department are contingent upon one of the organization s core competencies which is efficient communication. It is worth stressing that This is more important in phone interactions than in other channels such as due to its real-time, high-touch nature.. Customer service policies and practices are often implemented with little or sometimes even without any consideration to cultural aspects. but they should be. Good example can be cross-selling or upselling. In some countries, it may not be polite to cross-sell even at the end of a successful customer service interaction. Another example can be a 48-hour response time for queries may be acceptable in some cultures but tantamount to ignoring the customer in others. Enabling highly culturally differentiated customer service adds to the cost of service. It is therefore important to leverage technology-enabled automation, where possible, to curb the costs. Language-aware customer query routing, multilingual user interfaces, knowledge-guided customer interactions and culture-aware interaction tools (e.g. chatbot technology) can help in this area. The perception of excellent customer service is different in different cultures. For companies it is important to acknowledge that excellent customer service lies in the eyes of the customer. Research has shown that culture has an important influence on customer service; quality expectations and customer satisfaction because perceived service quality varies among different cultures. Customer service representatives are engaged in different degrees of interactive customer service work. A high degree of person-to-person interaction requires considerable adaptation during the service interaction. According to InformationWeek, European customers expect Customer service representatives to answer about 80% of their questions without reference, which is different from the US where customers do not have such high expectations. This is also culturally contingent. Strong Uncertainty Avoidance Cultures (like many European countries) place a particular value on expertise. Taken together with the fact that one of the most important success criteria for customer service is to be able to resolve an issue the first time around, it is not difficult to predict that the technical competence of a CSR becomes an important variable in high uncertainty avoiding cultures. Customer service centers often have to handle conflicts. In many of such situations, customers can be very emotional. Therefore, customer service representatives have to understand the emotional triggers of their customers. And this is also influenced by culture. The outcome of teamwork in customer service departments is highly influenced by culture. It has been documented that, provided that certain conditions are met, multicultural teams are more successful than teams consisting of team members from only one culture in terms of better and more creative ideas etc. One important condition to make it work is: successfully managed diversity. This requires highly skilled and excellent leadership. Source: Own study based on: Turek 2000, Bianchi 2001, Herbig and Genestre 1996; Furrer, Liu, and Sudharsan 2000; Liu, Furrer and Sudharshan 2001; Bianchi 2001; Reimann, Lünemann, and Chase 2008, Datamonitor, Hofstede and Hofstede Summary Logistics is an important part of every economy and every business entity. The worldwide trend in globalization, customer orientation, lead time reduction, cost reduction, reengineering has led to many companies outsourcing their logistics function to Third-Party Logistics companies, in order to focus on their
14 14 Michał Chmielecki core competencies [see Hertz & Alfredsson 2002, Lieb & Randall 1996]. It has never been more important for companies to be able to provide customer service that meets the needs of a multicultural customer base. That means not only providing customer service in different languages depends on what you sell and who your customer is, but also understanding the varied cultural backgrounds of customers.
15 Multi-Cultural Customer Service in 3PL 15 Bibliography 16 th Annual Third-Party Logistics Study Bhatnager R., Sohal A.S., Millen R. (1999), Third party logistics services: A Singapore perspective, International Journal of Physical Distribution and Logistics Management, Vol. 29, No.9. Bjerke B. (2004), Kultura a style przywództwa zarządzanie w warunkach globalizacji, Oficyna Ekonomiczna, Kraków. Bianchi C. (2001), The Effect of Cultural Differences on Service Encounter Satisfaction, Proceedings 2001 AMA Winter Educator s Conference 12. Brady M.K., Cronin, J.J. Jr. (2001), Some new thoughts on conceptualizing perceived service quality: A hierarchical approach, Journal of Marketing, 65. Carman J. (1990), Consumer perception of service quality: An assessment of the SERVQUAL dimensions, Journal of Retailing, 66(1). Cheong M.L.F., Logistics Outsourcing and 3PL Challenges, bitstream/handle/1721.1/3908/imst011.pdf, retrieved Coltman T., Price and demand: what do 3PL customers really want?, University of Wollongong Research Online, retrieved Coyle J.J., Bardi E.J., Langley C.J. (2003), The Management of Business Logistics A Supply Chain Perspective (7th ed.), Mason, OH: South-Western. Feinberg R., Ruyter de. K., Bennington L. (2005), Cases in Call Center Management Great Ideas (Th)at Work, USA: Purdue University. Furrer O., Liu B. S-C., Sudharshan D. (2000), The relationships Between Culture and Service Quality. Gronroos C. (1990), Service management and marketing, Lexington Books, Lexington, MA. Herbig P., Genstre A. (1996), An examination of the cross-cultural differences in service quality: the example of Mexico and the USA, Journal of Consumer Marketing, Vol. 13, No. 3. Hertz S., Alfredsson M. (2002), Strategic development of third party logistics providers, Industrial marketing management, 32. Hofstede G., Hofstede G.J. (2005), Cultures and Organizations Software of the Mind, McGraw Hill, New York. Knemeyer A.M., Murphy P.R. (2004), Evaluating the Performance of Third-Party Logistics Arrangements: A Relationship Marketing Perspective. Journal of Supply Chain Management: A Global Review of Purchasing & Supply, 40(1). Lewicki J.R., Saunders D.M., Barry B., Minton J.W., Zasady negocjacji kompendium wiedzy dla trenerów i menadżerów, Rebis, Poznań Lieb R.C., Randall H.L. (1996), A comparison of the use of third-party logistics services by large American manufacturers, 1991, 1994 and 1995, Journal of Business Logistics, 17, 1. Liu B. S-C., Furrer O., Sudharshan D. (2001), The Relationship between Culture and Behavioral Intentions toward Services, Journal of Service Research, Volume 4, No. 2.
16 16 Michał Chmielecki Manning R.E. (1999), Studies in Outdoor Recreation: Search and Research for Satisfaction (2nd Ed.), Oregon State University Press. McKinsey Quarterly (2005), Getting more from call centers Used properly, they can be strategic assets. Oliver R.L. (1980), A cognitive model of the antecedents and consequences of satisfaction decisions, Journal of Marketing Research, 19 (November). Parasuraman A., Zeithaml V.A., Berry L.L. (1988), SERVQUAL: A multiple-item scale for measuring consumer perceptions of service quality, Journal of Marketing, 64(1). Pizam A. (1999), Cross-cultural tourist behavior [in:] A. Pizam, Y. Mansfeld (eds.), Consumer behavior in travel and tourism, New York: The Haworth Hospitality Press. Reimann M., Lünemann U.F., Chase R.B. (August 2008), Uncertainty Avoidance as Moderator of the Relationship between Perceived Service Quality and Customer Satisfaction, Journal of Service Research, Volume 11, No. 1. Reisinger Y., Turner L. (1999), A cultural analysis of Japanese tourists: challenges for tourism marketers, European Journal of Marketing, 33(11/12). Rust R.T., Oliver R. (1994), Service quality insights and managerial implications from the frontier [in:] R.T. Rust, R. Oliver (eds.), Service quality: new directions in theory and practice, Sage, London. Sink H.L., Langley C.J. (1997), A managerial framework for the acquisition of thirdparty logistics services, Journal of Business Logistics, 19, 1. Solomon et. al (1985), cited in Bianchi C. (2001), The Effect of Cultural Differences on Service Encounter Satisfaction, Proceedings 2001 AMA Winter Educator s Conference 12. Sułkowski Ł. (2002), Procesy kulturowe w organizacjach. Koncepcja, badania i typologia kultur organizacyjnych, Toruń-Łódź, Towarzystwo Nauk Organizacji i Kierowania Dom Organizatora. Sułkowski Ł. (2008), Czy warto zajmować się kulturą organizacyjną?, Zarządzanie Zasobami Ludzkimi, nr 6. Sułkowski Ł., Morawski P. (2012), Wirtualizacja procesów logistycznych z wykorzystaniem nowoczesnych rozwiązań teleinformatycznych (e-logistyka), [w:] Kolasińska-Morawska K., Zarządzanie logistyczne, Wyd. PiZ SAN, tom XIII, zeszyt 16, Łódź. Sułkowski Ł. (2012), Interdyscyplinarność logistyki [w:] Kolasińska-Morawska K., Zarządzanie logistyczne, Wyd. PiZ SAN, tom XIII, zeszyt 16, Łódź. Teas R.K. (1994), Expectations as a comparison standard in measuring service quality: An assessment of a reassessment, Journal of Marketing, 58(January). Turek N. (2000), Call Centers: Here, There, And Everywhere, InformationWeek. Van Laarhoven P., Berlund M., Peters, M. (2000), Third-party logistics in Europe: Five years later, International Journal of Physical Distribution and Logistics Management, Vol. 30, No. 5. Press articles: Orange repatriates its call centres to improve service, The Independent, 9 November Dell moves outsourced jobs back to U.S. shores, 28 April 2004; Forbes.com.
17 Danuta Janczewska University of Social Sciences Przedsiębiorczość i Zarządzanie Wydawnictwo SAN ISSN Tom XIV, Zeszyt 7, ss The Position of Innovative Strategy in Marketing-Logistic Management in SMEs Sector Abstract: The marketing-logistic management is now the very interesting method for entrepreneurs and consolidate the conviction, that perfecting the marketing and logistic skills of enterprise contributes to growth of competitiveness of enterprise. Activity of SMEs found on the modest resources than in biggest enterprises, therefore building the logistic and marketing advantage by innovative strategy is often the right direction of growing of competitiveness of SMEs. The aim of article is presentation of space and possibilities of application of innovative strategy in SMEs in confectionery sector. Formulating of innovative strategy is connected with marketing methods and perfecting the logistic process. Necessary is growing the level of logistic and marketing education of managers by learning and study of logistic and marketing- especially of marketing-logistic management specialization. Key-words: SMEs, strategy, innovations, marketing, logistic. Introduction The marketing logistic management becomes now the interesting concept for entrepreneurs, and thus consolidates opinion, that improvement skills of marketing and logistic contributed to increasing of competitive position of the enterprise in the market. The activity of enterprises from SMEs sector based on the smaller material resources than in big ones, thus building of logistic and marketing skills is often the right direction of development of SMEs. Orientate and integration of marketing and logistic activities for common goal, who is the customer makes more effective, dynamic and flexible the system of marketing and logistic in enterprise. The consequence of this orienta-
18 18 Danuta Janczewska tion is going into improvement of wide broadly innovation in all areas of activity of enterprise, according the idea of meet demand of customers the best way. The aim of article is presentation of meaning and position of innovative strategy in marketing and logistic managing of SMEs. On the example of research in SMEs in confectionery branch there are presented the model of marketing and logistic management and consideration of building of innovative strategy. The marketing and logistic managing in SMEs sector The competition and strong attempts of reach the competitive advantage make that using the traditional methods of managing is often insufficient. Also the used the individual and separately conceptions of improvement the managing of enterprise not ensure the expecting advantages. For this reason the modern enterprises building the methods of management by integration of many aspects of activity. Commonly used model of marketing- mix in present conditions should be extend of marketing and logistic conception, up to instruments of logistic- mix, and connecting with new ideas of lean- management and reenginiering. Each of those conceptions needs the individual approach and adapt the methods of management to the individual characteristics. Sułkowski said that the main marketing ideas are the tools for managers, and help receive the planned goals of organizations [Sułkowski 2009, p.16]. The one from more promising conception of management is integration of logistic management with marketing oriented conception of enterprise. The main function characterized the modern enterprise is delivery the values to the customers. Demands of clients are more different and the spiral of demands inevitable constantly growing, additional the conscious of meaning of quality is growing, too. The explicitly tendency of enhancement of quality is especially significant in area of delivery service and structure of demands for integrated logistic performances. Particularly it means that there are necessary oriented for time, quality, flexibility and shaping numerous interrelationships. The rules of marketing and logistic management can be formulate according theory Direct Beam of Value [Dytwald 1997, pp ]. This theory defines three options of delivery of value for customers: Option of Operating Excellence expressing in offer the products and services with the best price for customers. This price is shaping by optimization of process from point of view of customer and costs, time, flexibility, effectiveness, convenience of customers and shaping of effectiveness of process. Option of Product Leadership consisting for innovations, project of new products and their introducing into market, creating the new structure of organization based by processes.
19 The Position of Innovative Strategy in Marketing-Logistic Management in SMEs Sector 19 Option of Customer Intimacy expressed recognized of customer s demand and his chain of value and building the stable relationship with him. Direct Beam of Value formulated by M. Treacy i F. Wiersema [Treacy, Wiersema 1995], showing the integration of logistic and marketing process in enterprises. Developing of new products, building the long-term relationship with customers and adapt the logistic processes of material and information flow confirms the necessity using of marketing and logistic instruments simultaneously. Innovations are defined in the same time as the main direction of marketing- logistic activity. Szymura-Tyc [Szymura-Tyc 2001] supplements this theory by building the marketing assets, carry on to competitive advantages of enterprise. In marketing assets there are: distinguishing products, advantageous price, identity of mark, connections in distribution channels, reputation and image of company. The supplement of discussion can be the additional logistic assets integrated with Direct Beam of Value. Logistic assets which influence of attractiveness of logistic offer for customer are: unique skills of creation of logistic process, their dynamic and flexibility of components of logistic process, effectiveness and efficiency of logistic processes. The Innovative Process in SMEs According the Shumpeter s theory the innovations born as science research effect, and lead to trans forming knowledge into a material form. Shumpeter identified innovations with introduction to production the new products or improvement still existing product or method of production [Schumpeter 1960, p. 322]. He defined the term of innovation wide, as open a new market, application a new method of selling or buying, using a new raw materials or half- products, application a new organization of production. It should be accented, that Schumpeter s theories assumed, that the main creators of innovations are the big enterprises, and he named them as innovators, whereas SMEs as imitators. Shumpeter s views are not grounded in economical practice [Stawasz 1999, p. 50], and in opinion of contemporary researches SMEs are faster react for signal from environment and changing needs of customers. SMEs can acting more flexible, faster create the innovations and make the shorter the time of their implementation and commercialization [Nowacki, Staniewski 2010, p. 16]. Introduction the wide definition of innovation according Oslo [Oslo Manual, 2005] give the possibility changing the statistic data by the new position, as imitation characteristic: innovation by improvement,
20 20 Danuta Janczewska innovation by changing the products and process, as regards by SMEs. The contemporary of types of innovations distinguish a new categories [OECD 2010, p. 5], as technical innovations: product innovations, process innovations, and non-technical innovations: organizational innovations, marketing innovations. The non- technological innovations recently were not recognized as main as product or process innovations. In Poland from 2008 The Main Statistic Office (GUS) introduced near the technological innovations data the new non-technical ones. The organizational innovations mean the implementation of new method of organization in rules of activity in enterprise, in way of work place organization or in relation with environment. Those new methods are implemented for reach the better results by cost reduction in administration or transaction costs and increasing of job satisfaction, gaining access to activities, which are not subject of commercial exchange, as for example non-codification external knowledge. The marketing innovations apply the implementation of a new marketing methods, including the significant changes in project or construction of product, or in distribution, promotion or price strategy [Oslo Manual 2005, p. 49]. The goal of implementation of marketing innovations are the better satisfy of needs of customers, open the new markets or a new positioning of product in the market for the growth of selling. There are observed the connection between non-technological, innovations and strategic decisions concerning technological investments, as buying technology or new machines or apparatus. The researches of innovativeness of SMEs Researches of innovativeness are conducted by GUS in Poland, and the results are published in papers The Innovative Activity of Enterprises and Science and Technique. Results of GUS are not separate the micro enterprises and presented data for enterprises employer over 10 persons [Juchniewicz, Grzybowska 2010, p. 34]. Results of GUS show the low innovativeness of enterprises in Poland. The similar results appear from European Commission Report, and the level of Summary Innovation Index in Poland is lower than average factor in EU countries. For this reason Poland is included into group of catching up countries [European Innovation Scoreboard 2006]. In opinion of EU researchers this situation follows of low expenses for R&D in Poland. This view can be discussed, and in author s opinion the important reason is not identical definitions of innovative activity of SMEs in different countries.
330.44:338.2:330.47 OUTSOURCING IN THE OPERATION OF FMCG COMPANIES Dr S AWOMIR JARKA, PhD Warsaw University of Life Sciences (WULS),..,.,,,. In the age of the information technology revolution there is
MARKETING LOGISTICS Ryszard Barcik 1, Marcin Jakubiec 2 1 University of Bielsko-Biała, Faculty of Management and Computer Sciences,Ul. Willowa 2, 43-309 Bielsko- Biała, Poland Email:email@example.com
TOTAL LOGISTIC MANAGEMENT No. 1 2008 PP. 145 151 Grażyna RADZIEJOWSKA QUALITY OF THE LOGISTIC CUSTOMER SERVICE IN SERVICE AREA Abstract: The paper presents the issue of customer logistics. Particular attention
Status of Customer Relationship Management in India by Dr. G. Shainesh & Ramneesh Mohan Management Development Institute Gurgaon, India Introduction Relationship marketing is emerging as the core marketing
E-LOGISTICS ASPECTS OF FUNCTIONING Ryszard Barcik, Marcin Jakubiec Key words: e-business, e-logistics, B2B, B2C, C2C, data base, EDI, RFID, escm Abstract In the background of changing situation on local
THIRD PARTY LOGISTICS FUNCTION FOR CONSTRUCTING VIRTUALCOMPANY STUDY OF ASSIGNMENTS IN JAPANESE COMPANIES Kajita, H. Deloitte Tohmatsu Consulting 1-2-8 Toranomon, Minato-ku Tokyo Japan firstname.lastname@example.org and
Globalization Drives Market Need for Supply Chain Segmentation: Research & Key Strategies Sponsored by: Conducted by: On behalf of: Introduction Businesses continue look to their supply chain operations
POLITECNICO DI MILANO GRADUATE SCHOOL OF BUSINESS INTERNATIONAL MASTER IN INDUSTRIAL Management Courses Description A joint program with POLITECNICO DI MILANO SCHOOL OF MANAGEMENT First semester (Universidad
Executive Leadership MBA Course Descriptions MBA 608: Interpersonal Leadership and Managing Organizational Behavior (3 credits) This course provides rising stars learning opportunities to take the next
Measurement of E-service Quality in University Website 1 Sayyed Aliakbar Ahmadi 2 Naser Barkhordar 3 Amirhossein Moradi Firoozabadi 4 Asadollah Dolatkhah 1 Associate Professor, Department of Management
Executive Leadership MBA Course Descriptions MBA 608: Interpersonal Leadership and Managing Organizational Behavior (3 credits) This course provides rising stars learning opportunities to take the next
Krzysztof Wilk Katedra Systemów Sztucznej Inteligencji Akademia Ekonomiczna im. Oskara Langego we Wrocławiu e-mail: email@example.com Knowledge management in logistics Summary The organizations
OUTSOURCING LOGISTICS CRITERIA AND IT S IMPACT TO SUPPLY CHANNEL STRUCTURE Andrius Jaržemskis Vilnius Gediminas Technical University, Transport Research Institute Plytinės Str. 27, LT-10105, Vilnius-16,
Barometr Regionalny Tom 12 nr 2 R&D Expenditures in Poland. Voivodship Perspective Aleksandra Zygmunt Opole University of Technology, Poland Abstract The main purpose of the paper is R&D expenditures analysis
STRENGTHS AND WEAKNESSES OF CURRENT SUPPLY CHAIN MANAGEMENT AND INITIATIVES FOR THE FUTURE Diana-Maria DIACONU (NIDELEA) 1 Cristina ALPOPI 2 ABSTRACT Supply Chain Management is the potential way of securing
c o u r s e o u t l i n e MBAProgramme The College of The Bahamas Year 1 Fall Financial/Managerial Accounting (3 credits) Introduces students to the financial and managerial accounting disciplines; develops
LOGISTICS OUTSOURCING RESULTS OF THE RESEARCH Magdalena K. Gasowska* * University of Warsaw, Faculty of Management, Warsaw, 02-678, Poland, Email: firstname.lastname@example.org Abstract The purpose of this
INFORMATION FLOW IN SUPPLY CHAIN MANAGEMENT WITH AN EXAMPLE OF WASTE MANAGEMENT COMPANY Joanna Nowakowska-Grunt, Janusz K. Grabara Czestochowa University of Technology, Management Faculty Abstract: The
CORPORATE SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY AND ITS APPLICATION IN THE ENTERPRISE Bartłomiej Zinczuk Maria Curie-Skłodowska University, Poland email@example.com Abstract: Extensive changes in today's business environment,
A CULTURAL APPROACH TO STUDY CUSTOMER RELATIONSHIP MANAGEMENT (CRM) SYSTEMS Maged A. A. Ali Information Systems and Computing Department Brunel University, UK Maged.Abdelsalam@brunel.ac.uk Sarmad Alshawi
Invest in People! Project co-financed by European Social Fund through the Sectoral Operational Programme Human Resource Development 2007 2013 Priority Axis: 1. Education and training in support for growth
Supply Chain development - a cornerstone for business success Agenda 1. Supply chain considerations 2. Benefits of a developed SCM strategy 3. Competitive advantage by using a LSP 4. CRM/SCM key to business
Chapter 2 INFO1400 Review Questions 1. What are business processes? How are they related to information systems? Define business processes and describe the role they play in organizations. A business process
DEVELOPMENT OF CROSS-CULTURAL COMMUNICATION SKILLS OF ENGINEERING STUDENTS Anete Mezote Latvia University of Agriculture firstname.lastname@example.org Abstract. Besides specific profession-related skills, it is
Knowledge is the food of the soul ~Plato Knowledge Transferred Transferencia del Saber Unlocking your organization s workforce potential with customized key solutions Saber Academy Capacity Building Program
REVERSE LOGISTICS AS THE ELEMENT OF ENTERPRISE MANAGEMENT Iwona Grabara, Msc, email@example.com Czestochowa University of Technology Aleksandra Nowakowska, Msc, firstname.lastname@example.org Czestochowa University
OUTSOURCING IN REVERSE LOGISTICS Janusz Grabara, PhD, email@example.com Czestochowa University of Technology, Management Faculty Abstract: Nowadays cost reduction is a fundamental strategy used in companies
Fiorenzo Franceschini Politechnico di Torino, Torino, Italy Politechnico di Torino, Torino, Italy Keywords Quality, Logistics, Service quality, Measurement, Supply chain Abstract The paper highlights some
3PL Selection Strategies Presented by: Sponsored by: Matt Kulp Principal 2014 MHI Copyright claimed as to audiovisual works of seminar sessions and sound recordings of seminar sessions. All rights reserved.
EXECUTIVE MASTER IN CORPORATE COMMUNICATION Increasing corporate value in today s complex digital world through reputation management and communication with stakeholders. COURSE DESCRIPTION At a Glance
PERCEIVED QUALITY IN THE DELIVERY OF BUSINESS SUPPORT SERVICES: A CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK (WITH PRACTICAL IMPLICATIONS) Nicola Bellini LINK Research Center Scuola Superiore Sant'Anna Pisa - Italy firstname.lastname@example.org
All available Global Online MBA routes have a set of core modules required to be completed in order to achieve an MBA. Those modules are: Building High Performance Organisations Management and Organisational
Customer Experience Management (CEM) Technology: What, Why, and How Does It Work February 2005 Executive Summary A new class of technology has arrived. Customer Experience Management (CEM) Technology delivers
ADVANTAGES OF COLLABORATIVE APPROACH IN CUSTOMER SERVICE MANAGEMENT Bogdan Wierzbiński* and Tomasz Surmacz* * Department of Marketing and Entrepreneurship, University of Rzeszow, Rzeszow, Poland, Email:
USE OF ICT IN SMES MANAGEMENT WITHIN THE SECTOR OF SERVICES Plumb Ion Academy of Economic Studies Bucharest, Faculty of Management, 6 th Piata Romana RO 030173 Bucharest Romania, email@example.com, +4021.319.19.00/287
MEDZINÁRODNÁ VEDECKÁ KONFERENCIA GLOBALIZÁCIA A JEJ SOCIÁLNO EKONOMICKÉ DÔSLEDKY 08 THE PROBLEM OF ACHIEVING COMPETITIVE ADVANTAGE IN THE TRANSPORT SERVICES SECTOR Pawel Romanow 1 Maciej Stajniak 2 Key
All available Global Online MBA routes have a set of core modules required to be completed in order to achieve an MBA. Those modules are: Management and Organizational Change (P.4) Leading Strategic Decision
ELEMENTS OF THE INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY SERVICES MANAGEMENT SYSTEM Dr. Sławomir Czarniewski University of Finance and Management in Bialystok Ul. Ciepła 40 15-472 Białystok, POLAND ABSTRACT Digital media
Supply Chain Management and Value Creation YAN Xi 1, KANG Canhua 2 School of Economics, Wuhan University of Technology, Wuhan 430070, China 1. firstname.lastname@example.org, email@example.com Abstract: In recent
Chapter 4: Implementing the CRM Strategy Overview Topics discussed: Elements of a CRM System Customer Interphase / Touch Points CRM Applications Return on Investment (ROI) of CRM CRM Costs Why is ROI of
INNOVATIONS AS A FACTOR OF BUSINESS MODELS DYNAMICS IN METALLURGICAL COMPANIES Jan BRZÓSKA Politechnika Śląska Wydział Organizacji i Zarządzania ul.roosevelta 26-28 41-800 Zabrze, Poland, EU, Jan.Brzoska@polsl.pl
Service Quality In Accounting Firms: The Relationship Of Service Quality To Client Satisfaction And Firm/Client Conflict Carl L. Saxby, (E-mail: firstname.lastname@example.org), University of Southern Indiana Craig R.
Professional Diploma in Marketing Syllabus 05/06 www.cim.co.uk/learningzone 1: Marketing Research & Information Aim The Marketing Research and Information subject covers the management of customer information
DOI: 10.17626/dBEM.ICoM.P00.2015.p017 PROCESS MANAGEMENT ORIENTATION IN THE FINANCE AREA OF SMALL AND MEDIUM-SIZED ENTERPRISES Małgorzata OKRĘGLICKA, Anna LEMAŃSKA-MAJDZIK Czestochowa University of Technology,
Cotrugli MBA & Executive MBA outline COTRUGLI MBA programs are not only an investment in knowledge, information and networks, nor are they just an investment in career advancement. Our MBA programs inspire
ADDENDUM D: NEW COURSES: THEIR DESCRIPTIONS AND LEARNING GOALS Applicable to All New Courses: 1. All courses will be offered primarily for business majors. 2. All courses will have a one-unit value. 3.
3PL Selection Strategies Sponsored by: Presented by: Bryan Jensen Principal 2015 MHI Copyright claimed for audiovisual works and sound recordings of seminar sessions. All rights reserved. 1 Agenda Current
TQM TOOLS IN CRISIS MANAGEMENT Anna Starosta 1 Grzegorz Zieliński 2 Abstract The current article is concerned with basic aspects connected with improvement of crisis management activities employed by economic
Journal of Intercultural Management Vol. 2, No. 1, March 2010, pp. 49 56 Monika Chutnik Uniwersytet Ekonomiczny we Wrocławiu Katarzyna Grzesik Uniwersytet Ekonomiczny we Wrocławiu Performance Through Relationships.
ACCOUNTING MODERNIZATION PREMISE OF AN EFFECTIVE GOVERNANCE SYSTEM OF ENTERPRISE MIHAELA UNGUREANU ALEXANDRU IOAN CUZA UNIVERSITY OF IASI email@example.com Abstract: Value of company is maximizing insofar
Yeditepe University offers Executive Master of Business Administration Program (EMBA) for those who would like to positively differentiate themselves in their career development. Yeditepe Executive MBA
BUNDESMINISTERIUM FÜR WIRTSCHAFT UND ARBEIT BUNDESMINISTER IUM FÜR WIRTSCHAFT UND ARBEIT BUNDESMINISTERIUM FÜR WIRTSCH AFT UND ARBEIT BUNDESMINISTERIUM FÜR WIRTS CHAFT UNDARB EIT NDESMI NISTERIUM FÜR WIRTSCHAFT
Presentation of a Framework for Implementing Knowledge Management in Supply Chain HamedMellatdoust 1, OmidZolfaghari 2, MojtabaMansouri 3, Ali Bahramnezhad 4 1234-MA Students of MBA, Islamic Azad University,
JaroslavNenadál * Risks related to quality management systems implementation some lessons learned from Czech Republic Introduction Efficient and effective implementation of quality management principles
The Masters of Science in Information Systems & Technology College of Engineering and Computer Science University of Michigan-Dearborn A Rackham School of Graduate Studies Program PH: 313-593-5361; FAX:
The Investigation in Service Quality Management of 3G Business for Telecom Operators Jian Shen 1 School of Economics and Management Beijing University of Posts and Telecommunications Key Account Center
The 2013 Supply Chain Agenda Time to go beyond the traditional supply chain optimization projects 5 th Edition Prepared and edited by: Erik Koperdraat Kris Dieteren Capgemini Consulting The Netherlands
Small Business Supply Management Michael E. Smith, Ph.D. Western Carolina University 828/227-3697; firstname.lastname@example.org Lee Buddress, Ph.D., C.P.M. Portland State University 503-725-4769; email@example.com 93
The Umbrella Concept Results of the SME and Start-up Survey 2012 Prof. Dr. R.-Dieter Reineke Andrew Mpeqa, MSc, MA Michael Sitte, MSc, MA Institut für Unternehmensführung Olten, November 2012 Agenda THE
E-Banking and Payment System Technology-Driven Demand and e- Customer Relationship Management e-crm Sittikorn Direksoonthorn Assumption University 1/2004 E-Banking and Payment System Quick Win Agenda Data
Maciej Urbaniak University of Łódź, Poland BUILDING A RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN PARTNERS IN THE SUPPLY CHAIN USING ONLINE COMMUNICATION Introduction The modern logistics emphasis the planning and movement of
Marek Matejun, Agnieszka Zakrzewska Bielawska CHARACTER AND APPLICATION OF OUTSOURCING BASED ON THE LODZ ENTERPRISES 1. Introduction [ For more publications visit www.matejun.com ] In traditional, post-industrial
Manufacturing Flow Management Distribution D Distribution Authorized to Department of Defense and U.S. DoD Contractors Only Aim High Fly - Fight - Win Supply Chain Management Processes Information Flow
УДК 330.322:631 Gutkevych S., Doctor of Economics, Professor, Head of Department of International Economy, National University of Food Technologies, Kyiv Zavadskyh A., Candidate of Economics, Associate
Journal of Economic Development, Management, IT, Finance and Marketing, 4(1), 12-26, March 2012 12 Brand Loyalty in Insurance Companies Sancharan Roy, (B.E., MBA) Assistant Professor, St. Joseph's College
The Decision Making Systems Model for Logistics Ing. Miroslav Peťo, Faculty of Management Science and Informatics, Department of Management Theories, Univerzitná 1, 01026 Žilina, Miroslav.Peto@fri.uniza.sk
Industrial Strategy: government and industry in partnership UK Government Information Economy Strategy A Call for Views and Evidence February 2013 Contents Overview of Industrial Strategy... 3 How to respond...
Churchill/Ford/Walker's Sales Force Management Tenth Edition Mark W. Johnston Crummer Graduate School of Business Rollins College Greg W. Marshall Crummer Graduate School of Business Rollins College draw
Debbie Schmidt FIS Consulting Services 1 800 822 6758 Table of Contents More Than an IT Project...2 One Size Does Not Fit All...2 Moving Toward an Effective CRM Strategy...3 The Process...4 The Technology...4
TRANSPORT PROBLEMS 2015 PROBLEMY TRANSPORTU Volume 10 Issue 2 Maria CIEŚLA Faculty of Transport, Silesian University of Technology Krasiński 8, 40-019 Katowice, Poland Corresponding author. E-mail: firstname.lastname@example.org
Agile Master Data Management A Better Approach than Trial and Error A whitepaper by First San Francisco Partners First San Francisco Partners Whitepaper Executive Summary Market leading corporations are
DELIGHTFUL OR DEPENDABLE? VARIABILITY OF CUSTOMER EXPERIENCES AS A PREDICTOR OF CUSTOMER VALUE Yanliu Huang George Knox Daniel Korschun * WCAI Proposal December 2012 Abstract Is it preferable for a company
ALLGEMEINE FORST UND JAGDZEITUNG (ISSN: 0002-5852) Available online www.sauerlander-verlag.com/ Miracle Integrating Knowledge Management and Business Intelligence Nursel van der Haas Technical University
ING COMMERCIAL FINANCE POLAND ANNUAL REPORT 2011 The ING Foundation for Polish Arts All images presented in Annual Report belong to The ING Foundation for Polish Arts. The ING Foundation for Polish Arts
Chapter 1 An Introduction to Information Systems in Organizations 1 Principles and Learning Objectives The value of information is directly linked to how it helps decision makers achieve the organization
Thunderbird School of Global Management is using TMC s Cultural Orientations Indicator to help more than 1,200 students each year become global leaders. Founded in 1946, Thunderbird School of Global Management