1 KPMG INTERNATIONAL. Issues Monitor. Increasing Importance of Social Media in Healthcare. October 2011, Volume Eight. kpmg.com
2 Mark Britnell Chairman, KPMG's Global Healthcare Practice Keeping up to date with the very latest and most pressing issues in healthcare can be a challenge, and while there is no shortage of information in the public domain, filtering and prioritizing the knowledge you need can be time consuming and unrewarding. I hope that you find this edition of Issues Monitor useful and I welcome the opportunity to further discuss the issues presented and their impact on our sector. Welcome to the October edition of Issues Monitor Healthcare. Each edition pulls together and shares industry knowledge to help you quickly and easily get briefed on the issues that affect your sector. In our continuing series of Issues Monitors for Healthcare, this issue examines growing usage of social media in healthcare business, types of models being followed by providers and information portals, and insights into what the future could hold for this trend.
3 Social media dials up patient power in healthcare. The large-scale use of technology has had a significant impact on the global healthcare sector. From new testing techniques to improved surgical equipment, technological advances have revolutionized the healthcare industry. Social media is one such tool that is rapidly transforming this segment. Social media platforms are fast becoming a cost-effective and easily accessible solution for both healthcare providers and online patients. While healthcare providers across Europe and the US are fast adopting social media technologies, many providers across the Asia Pacific region remain cautious and have been relatively slow to get on the social media bandwagon. A patient s voice, via social networking, sits at the heart of assessing patient outcomes, experience and quality of care. Few providers are ready for the role instant feedback from patients will play, and regulators will need to think about how to incorporate patient power in their regulatory regimes.
4 2 Issues Monitor: October 2011, Volume Eight Social media in healthcare. Newer technologies such as the internet and social media websites have enabled healthcare providers to reach their patients in a virtual environment, thus revolutionizing the way patient care is being provided. During its early years, the web served as a platform for read-only information that users retrieved passively. However, it has now transcended its role as an information provider, and is facilitating interactive two-way information sharing. Further, the rate of online networking among global users has been constantly increasing, which in turn has expanded the reach of businesses across all industries. 1 In the healthcare industry, face-toface interaction has traditionally been the primary medium for information exchange. The entire communication process has always revolved around a real-time physical setting in which patients met with physicians. However, newer technologies such as the internet and social media websites have enabled healthcare providers to reach their patients in a virtual environment, revolutionizing the way patient care is being provided. An increasing number of people now use the web to communicate and are more likely to use social media websites and portals to procure healthcare-related information. A May 2011 Pew Research Center s Internet study showed that, of 3,001 US adults surveyed, approximately 80 percent of the internet users use online media for healthcare information. The same study also revealed that 15 percent of US adults use their cell phone to access healthcare information. 2 Across developing economies as well, using the internet to access healthcare information is fairly popular. An online survey conducted by Max Bupa Health Insurance in 2010 revealed that of 1,004 Indians surveyed, 39 percent use the internet for general healthcare information. 3 Today, users are not only using the internet to search for information, but are increasingly using social media to interact with their physicians. Such interactions are helping patients shift from the regular in-person patient doctor interaction to a virtual environment where e-doctors provide solutions at lower costs. Technology has also facilitated the transformation of one-to-one communication into a one-to-many setup, in which a doctor reaches out to thousands of online users in seconds through tweets or blog posts. Interactive websites such as Hello Health and PatientsLikeMe enable users to easily connect with online doctors and patients to get instant information regarding various ailments. 4
5 Issues Monitor: October 2011, Volume Eight 3 Table 1: Examples of online healthcare portals with different business models Portal Year of introduction Business model Revenue model Key differentiating factor 5, 6, 7 Hello Health (US) Healthcare Magic 8, 9 (India) Organizedwisdom 10, 11 (US) 12, 13 Sermo (US) 2008 Facilitates online communication between patients and physicians Provides the following practice solutions to healthcare providers: New direct-pay practice: Hello Health optimizes the workflow of its clients by managing their documentation and patient profiles online Addition of new cash-pay services to the existing insurance-based practice: Through this, Hello Health allows its clients to add cash-pay services such as secure and video visits to their existing insurance-based practice 2008 Helps patients find doctors by specialty in India, the UK and the US Facilitates online communication between patients and doctors Provides information on diseases and conditions 2007 Provides healthcare information Collects and provides information shared by healthcare experts to users 2006 Facilitates physician physician collaboration Provides healthcare information through dedicated blogs Earns revenue by providing different membership plans to patients and practice solutions to healthcare providers Funded by sponsorships and advertisements Sells different membership plans to patients for interaction with doctors Funded by advertisements and sponsorships Generates revenue from healthcare institutions, government agencies and financial services firms that purchase its products to access the elite group of practitioners Easy-to-use online communication portal Provides personalized diet and fitness plan services Free alerts are provided to users Inter-doctor collaboration. Practicing physicians can join the portal for free
6 4 Issues Monitor: October 2011, Volume Eight Portal Year of introduction Business model Revenue model Key differentiating factor 14, 15, 16 PatientLikeMe (US) 17, 18, 19 NHS Direct (UK) Facilitates patient patient interaction Provides healthcare information through research reports Provides healthcare advice and information through telephone and online portal service to patients across the UK Helps patients find different healthcare providers operating in their region Allows users to rate their doctors, based upon their experiences Sells patient experiences to companies that develop or sell medical products such as devices, equipment, drugs, medical services and insurance Earns revenues by providing patient care activities. Dedicated focus on patients looking for other patients with similar ailments Provides service application for iphones and Android mobiles RateMyMD 20 (Canada) NA Funded by advertisements and sponsorships Provides ratings and feedback from user experience in terms of punctuality, knowledge, helpfulness and overall quality *Note: For further examples of healthcare portals with similar business models, please refer to Table 3 in the Appendix section. Why social media in healthcare? Social media provides an ideal platform for healthcare professionals for sharing ideas, experiences and medical journal articles with each other. With the increased accessibility of social media globally, it is now being used as a tool to foster serious discussion on healthcare issues. Apart from being an always-on support platform for patients in need of advice and treatment, social media also offers significant advantages to healthcare service providers. Benefits for provider organizations Reduced costs Social networking platforms offer huge cost benefits to healthcare providers, as the two-way online communication helps minimize the costs associated with paper, telephone calls and other overhead components. The Department of Veterans Affairs (VA), a US-based military veteran benefit system, implemented VistA, an online healthcare system that enables doctors to interact with each other on a regular basis. According to a 2010 report by Healthcare Performance Management (HPM) Institute, a US-based research and education organization, the online communication system helped VA reduce its per-patient healthcare costs by 30 percent. 21 Improved physician physician collaboration Social media provides an ideal platform for healthcare professionals to share ideas, experiences and medical journal articles with each other. Websites such as Sermo and Ozmosis enable doctors to
7 Issues Monitor: October 2011, Volume Eight 5 collaborate and share their favorite articles and research using social bookmarking functions, postings and voting tools. This helps ensure better patient outcomes, as doctors can conveniently build their knowledge in real time and facilitate faster adoption of best clinical practices. 22 Wider reach with no geographic boundaries Social media has the capability to reach a large audience within a few seconds. In case of critical emergencies such as natural disasters and disease outbreaks, social media has proved to be an effective tool. During the devastating earthquake and tsunami that hit Japan in March 2011, Twitter acted as a lifesaver, as doctors could update chronically ill patients about various treatment locations. Also, during the 2009 H1N1 flu outbreak, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) used social media platforms to update users about the disease and its possible preventions. Its Facebook page was followed by over 50,000 users, and H1N1 videos on YouTube were viewed over 2.6 million times. 23 Launch of new services Certain healthcare providers prefer using social media tools such as blogs to introduce new services. This helps the provider achieve better publicity than it can through a regular press release or other media channels. Users can easily comment and share their feedback on the new service. The Holy Cross Hospital in Florida has been regularly using social media to pass information on new therapeutic methods on its different therapeutic-specific blogs. 24 Talent search As the healthcare industry requires specialized skills and expert knowledge, healthcare providers are moving beyond the traditional methods to search for workers with the required skill sets. Healthcare providers such as the Mayo Clinic and HCA Group both use Twitter to advertise During the devastating earthquake and tsunami that hit Japan in March 2011, Twitter acted as a lifesaver, as doctors could update chronically ill patients about various treatment locations.
8 6 Issues Monitor: October 2011, Volume Eight A regular online visit to a doctor in the US is estimated to cost around US$30 per visit, much less than the US$ fee for an in-office visit. new openings in their hospitals. Healthcare professionals are visiting social media platforms and professional portals such as LinkedIn to look for new opportunities. In 2010, AMN Healthcare conducted a study of more than 1,200 healthcare professionals, including doctors, pharmacists, nurses and allied professionals across multiple disciplines. The study revealed that around 20 percent of the respondents have used at least one social media website for their job search. As information can be disseminated rapidly through social media, healthcare providers are likely to leverage this further in their talent 25, 26 search programs. Benefits for online patients Reduced costs Social media initiatives help patients get timely solutions to their problems at lower costs. Instead of paying huge amounts of money to visit a doctor, a patient can easily register with a healthcare portal and get on-demand healthcare services at a fraction of the cost of a physical visit. A regular online visit to a doctor in the US is estimated to cost around US$30 per visit, much less than the US$ fee for an in-office visit. 27 According to a US-based online healthcare service provider Teladoc, it provides 62 percent cost savings on visits to a regular primary care physician (PCP), 68 percent on visits to a specialist, 75 percent on visits to an urgent care unit and 95 percent on visits to an emergency room. 28 Improved self monitoring Social media websites and healthcare portals such as WebMD provide a range of healthcare tools and applications that help the users to better understand their healthcare needs. WebMD tools like Fit-O-Meter, Food and Fitness Planner and Personal Diet Evaluator help the users conveniently monitor their daily healthcare and exercise requirements. 29 Interaction with other patients to make informed choices Healthcare portals such as PatientsLikeMe and imedix help patients with similar medical conditions to connect with each other, discuss their conditions and make informed choices regarding doctors and medical treatments. According to a June 2010 survey of 1,323 PatientsLikeMe members, 12 percent of patients changed their physicians as a result of interaction with other patients. The survey also highlighted that 22 percent of mood disorder patients required less in-patient care, subsequent to the regular interactions they had on the website. 30 Readily available healthcare provider information Several social media websites and healthcare portals help patients looking for a hospital or a healthcare facility in a particular locality. Websites such as ZocDoc and WebMD allow users to select doctors as per their specifications, and also help in booking appointments. 31, 32 At the same time, there are several other portals such as RateMyMD and DoctorScorecard that allow users to rate their doctors, based upon their 33, 34 experiences.
9 Issues Monitor: October 2011, Volume Eight 7 Adoption of social media across geographies. Due to its wider reach and easy accessibility, social media is also influencing the choice of healthcare providers for a large number of patients. In a recent survey by hospital market research firm YouGov Healthcare, 57 percent of users revealed that their social media connections with a hospital strongly affect their decision to use a particular facility for treatment. 35 Further, for those patients who are not comfortable sharing their illnessrelated experiences during face-to-face meetings with doctors, social media is a convenient alternative platform. 36 Social media provides a viable opportunity to build brand awareness and create long-term relations with patients for healthcare providers. There has been a steep rise in the number of US hospitals adopting social media, according to Ed Bennet social media statistics, the number of US hospitals using social media increased from 365 in September 2009 to 965 in May Figure 1 provides an overview of the growth in social media accounts by US 37, 38, 39 hospitals. The number of US hospitals using social media increased from 365 in September 2009 to 965 in May Figure 1: Number of social media accounts by US hospitals, Number of social media accounts by US hospitals , YouTube Twitter Facebook LinkedIn Blogs 137 September 2009 October 2010 June 2011 Source: Hospital Social Network Data & Charts, ebennett.org, accessed on
10 8 Issues Monitor: October 2011, Volume Eight Hospitals in the UK and the US have been using social media technologies in a variety of innovative ways. As early as March 2009, physicians at the Henry Ford Healthcare System in Detroit used social media to educate medical students by answering the queries of more than 1,900 people on Twitter, during the brain surgery of a 47-year-old man. 40 Rather than using social media for only specific instances, hospitals have now gradually started to use it more frequently and are including it in their day-to-day activities. Texas Health Resources, a 24-hospital health system in northern Texas, uses social media to frequently update its patients about healthcare and promotes use of electronic health records (EHRs) and other new technologies. 41 Children s Hospital Boston, a leading pediatric medical center, has a Facebook fan following of over 500,000 fans, uses social media websites to promote open discussions on healthcare topics and obtain regular donations. 42 The Sarasota Memorial Health Care System in Florida also uses social media platforms such as Twitter to answer patient queries and provide customer service post diagnosis. 43 In addition to hospitals, public healthcare systems and regulatory bodies are leveraging social media technologies to effectively inform the general public about diseases, health tips, treatment options and healthcare services. The UK s public healthcare system the National Health Service (NHS) uses Twitter and Facebook to promote healthy lifestyles and inform patients about prevailing diseases. On Twitter, the NHS operates several accounts with different focus areas. For its primary account, focuses on healthy living issues and content. account supports forums and blogs on the site, and account highlights responses from NHS organizations and positive patient feedback. On Facebook, its healthy living page focuses on four primary objectives losing weight, drinking less alcohol, quitting smoking and exercising more. 44 As of October 2011, the American Diabetes Association had over 117,000 people following its updates on Facebook, and the American Cancer Society page had more than 264,000 followers. 45 In Europe, an increasing number of hospitals in Belgium, Germany, the Netherlands, Sweden, the UK and other countries are beginning to integrate social media into their marketing functions. Figures 2 and 3 provide an overview of the increase in the use of social media by hospitals in the UK and Germany. 46 Figure 2: Percentage use of social media by hospitals in UK, (n=197) % use You TubeTwitterFacebook Blog LinkedIn RSS June 2009 January 2010 September Figure 3: Percentage use of social media by hospitals in Germany, (n=741) % use YouTube Twitter Facebook LinkedIn RSS June 2009 December Source: European Hospitals, ebennett.org, accessed on
11 Issues Monitor: October 2011, Volume Eight 9 In emerging markets, healthcare organizations are not using social media as widely as those in the developed markets. However, there has been an increased interest in social media in these countries and its use is gradually increasing. In India, online healthcare portals that connect users with doctors are slowly gaining popularity. In May 2011, it was reported that Healthcaremagic.com, an Indian healthcare portal that provides online doctor services, was adding an average of 1,900 new users each day. 47 In Indonesia, healthcare organizations such as AIMI-ASI (Indonesian Breastfeeding Mothers Association) have successfully integrated social media in their marketing strategy. They use different social media platforms for different purposes Twitter for campaign and recruitment, Facebook for promotion and mailing lists for consultations. 48 As more users start sharing their healthcare experiences online, social media websites and the internet are expected to emerge as an important resource for making critical healthcare decisions. Healthcare providers undertaking significant initiatives Ever-increasing competition, demand for high-quality care and the need for faster responses to patient queries are leading to an increasing number of healthcare providers and facilitators adopting social media platforms to build stronger relationships with their patients. As the lack of resources and the shortage of time often restrict doctors and hospitals from staying connected with their patients, social media helps them to quickly respond to patient requirements. While a large number of healthcare providers are now considering the use of social media in their business strategy, leading providers have already joined the social media trend. Table 2 outlines some recent social media initiatives undertaken by various healthcare organizations.
12 10 Issues Monitor: October 2011, Volume Eight While a number of hospitals and healthcare providers have been taking significant initiatives with regard to social media, there is still ample potential for the healthcare community to utilize this opportunity comprehensively. According to a May 2011 study published in Annals of Internal Medicine, only 21 percent of the 1,800 randomly selected hospitals from the American Hospital Association 2008 Annual Survey use social media. 49 In addition, rapid advancement in technologies and the emergence of new tools within the social media space will also encourage the healthcare industry to leverage this platform to ensure best quality of care and strong industry growth. Table 2: Social media initiatives recently taken by companies / online portals Organization Social media initiative Targeted outcome Kaiser Permanente Mayo Clinic The Ontario Health Coalition Raritan Bay Medical Center Inova Health System In September 2011, Kaiser Permanente Center for Total Health introduced an official blog to explore and discuss new topics and issues facing the healthcare sector. 50 In March 2010, Kaiser Permanente implemented the Kaiser Permanente HealthConnect, an innovative health information system, in its 431 medical offices and 36 hospitals. 51 In July 2011, Mayo Clinic launched the Mayo Clinic online community, which shares content from various Mayo Clinic videos and blogs, and provides links to news articles about its research and treatment developments. The community has no registration charges and features a discussion forum where members can easily interact with each other. 52 A social media center was established in June 2010 to provide training to other hospitals on the use of social media tools such as Facebook, Twitter and YouTube. 53 The Ontario Health Coalition, a Canadian healthcare community, recently announced plans to identify the top healthcare issues in Ontario by using a democratic social media campaign. The social media campaign will take place in three phases between June and September In December 2010, Raritan Bay Medical Center, New Jersey, performed a knee surgery. The details related to the surgery were posted in real time on Twitter and were used to tutor medical lab students of the New Jersey-based St. Joseph High School. 55 In September 2010, Inova Health System, a Virginia-based nonprofit healthcare system, sponsored Fitfor50 a 50-day interactive fitness program in association with former Washington Redskins star Darrell Green. The program incorporated user stories from Facebook and Twitter. It also 56, 57 featured video messages and blog entries from Green. The blog looks to position itself as an innovative learning destination, where users and various experts, bloggers, thought leaders, and the media can discuss different healthcare-related issues. The system facilitates easy and instant interaction between Kaiser Permanente professionals and members. The community is aimed at helping patients share their Mayo Clinic experiences and interact with other patients with similar medical ailments. The center aims to hold conferences, deliver workshops and provide training and consulting services on how hospitals can leverage social media to create better relationships with patients, achieve business goals and provide vital information regarding their products. The campaign is aimed at reaching people across all classes through social media, to understand their healthcare issues and experiences. The activity was aimed at educating the medical students about the minute details related to the surgery. The innovative program was aimed at helping participants receive helpful healthcare and fitness tips from Inova physicians.
13 Issues Monitor: October 2011, Volume Eight 11 Challenges and risks associated with social media in healthcare. While social media can prove to be a boon for healthcare providers, it can also become a major threat to their reputation and credibility. A number of challenges are associated with the use of social media in healthcare, which can present significant roadblocks to its rapid adoption. Legal and liability concerns Interaction between healthcare providers and social media users may lead to various legal issues. Patient privacy violations While communicating with a patient, healthcare providers risk violating the US Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA), which limits healthcare providers from disclosing any health-related information of patients without their consent. 58 Hospital employees can easily use social media websites to leak important hospital information or violate patient privacy rights. In April 2011, a physician at Westerly Hospital in Rhode Island was reprimanded and fined by the state medical board for posting patient information on Facebook. 59 In a similar incident in June 2010, five nurses from Tri-City Medical Center in California, who were found to be discussing patient cases on Facebook, were discharged from their duties. 60 Fraud and abuse Healthcare providers paying money to third parties to promote their services on social media platforms may violate laws aimed at preventing fraud and abuse. In the US, laws such as the federal Medicare and the Medicaid Patient Protection Act of 1987 impose penalties on those healthcare providers that pay third parties to generate referrals, or exclude them from the Medicare 61, 62 and Medicaid programs. Licensing violations Physicians and other healthcare providers risk violating regional licensing laws. A doctor providing online medical advice to a patient residing in another region might not be licensed to provide consultation in that region. 63 Lack of accuracy Misinformation about diseases and treatments is a major concern for patients using social media websites. In January 2011, the American Medical Informatics Association published a study on 10 different diabetes-related social networking sites. The study, conducted by researchers at the Children's Hospital Boston Informatics Program, revealed that several of these websites had posted inaccurate information, and that they lacked user privacy. 64 Due to the abundance of healthcare information on social media websites and portals, there is a high likelihood that the information will be inaccurate. According to a January 2011 study by Health Dialog, a London-based healthcare management company, only 25 percent of users of online health By being aware of the potential issues that social media can cause, and putting a few simple safeguards in place, doctors and medical students can enjoy social media without it coming back to haunt them in the future. Dr Michael Bonning, Chairman of Australian Medical Association Council for Doctors in Training (AMACDT) information verify the reliability of the source. Inaccurate information and nonverification of sources can be harmful to users, as they may consequently waste money, take risks with unnecessary tests and treatments, or dismiss serious symptoms that require immediate attention. 65 Budget constraints Despite the fact that several healthcare organizations and hospitals are adopting social media, budgeting for the use of such media, including hiring dedicated employees for the purpose, is relatively low. According to a study released by Greystone.net in January 2010, 70 percent of around 100 healthcare providers included in the study have only three or fewer employees monitoring their social media operations. As all the content on such sites must be strictly regulated and all the information frequently updated, healthcare providers need to dedicate sufficient budgets and manpower even though they generally do not have such resources available. 66
14 12 Issues Monitor: October 2011, Volume Eight Low availability of online doctors Users who wish to interact with online doctors have to settle for limited options. Doctors lack of both time and knowledge of social media hinders any form of comprehensive collaboration of social media and healthcare. A 2009 social media survey conducted by Medimix International of 510 physicians across Europe, Mexico, Brazil and the US revealed that 66 percent of the physicians either do not use, or do not have information about social media networking websites. 67 Although the various risks and challenges associated with social media may restrict healthcare providers in actively using these platforms, implementation of stringent policies and proper guidance can help healthcare providers in using social media more effectively. In November 2010, the Australian Medical Association Council of Doctors-in- Training (AMACDT) released guidance to help doctors and medical students maintain a high level of professionalism while using social media. Such guidance helps doctors not only better understand the potential threats of social media, but also overcome these threats, while maintaining their ethical standards. According to Dr Michael Bonning, Chairman of AMACDT, By being aware of the potential issues that social media can cause, and putting a few simple safeguards in place, doctors and medical students can enjoy social media without it coming back to haunt 68, 69 them in the future. Healthcare will continue to embrace social media, with caution. The healthcare landscape has evolved to Health 2.0, wherein patients have assumed the role of active participants and seek control of their own health. In summary, over the past few years, the healthcare landscape has evolved to Health 2.0, wherein patients have assumed the role of active participants and seek control of their own health. Individuals are now interacting on social media websites and healthcare portals, seeking to reduce the communication gap between patients and healthcare providers. This rapid transformation is making healthcare delivery more patient-centric, and empowering users to make informed decisions about their health. Further, as doctors begin dealing with more informed patients, the time spent on patient care and the related costs will likely decrease, leading to improved overall standards of care. Better self-management of one s health could also help governments to control the growing healthcare costs and deal with the problem of staff shortages in the healthcare sector. It is impossible to ignore the effect that social media is having on the Internet in general, and on hospitals and health systems specifically. Organizations that have a formal plan to manage their social media interactions are more likely to be successful, and we expect more and more hospital Web departments to embrace this strategy moving forward. 70 Mike Schneider, Executive VP, Greystone.net Although some caution is necessary to deal with concomitant challenges posed by the use of social media in healthcare, a rational strategy adopted by healthcare organizations and regulatory agencies can help the industry to adequately respond to this important change in the healthcare landscape and fully leverage the 71, 72 opportunities offered by it.
15 Issues Monitor: October 2011, Volume Eight 13 Appendix. Table 3: Further examples of online healthcare portals and their business models Portal 73, 74 Medeguide (Thailand / Hong Kong) 75, 76 Ozmosis (US) 77, 78 imedix (US / Israel) ZocDoc 79 (US) American Well 80 (US) Teladoc 81 (US) Year of introduction Business model Revenue model Key differentiating factor 2009 Facilitates online communication between patients and doctors Helps patients find and contact doctors by specialty and region, free of charge Provides healthcare information on diseases and conditions 2008 Facilitates real-time interaction with US-licensed physicians Provides healthcare blog service 2007 Facilitates patient patient interaction Provides support group facility that allows users with similar medical ailments to easily interact with each other 2007 Helps users find doctors by specialty, region, hospital affiliation and insurance coverage 2006 Facilitates instant interaction between patients and doctors 2002 Facilitates interaction between patients and doctors through online and telephonic consultations Sells membership plans to doctors and hospitals that join Medeguide Earns revenue by providing product solutions such as OzmosisESP Connects healthcare, insurance and medical companies with consumers Funded by sponsorships and advertisements Earns revenue by brokering interactions between patients and healthcare providers Earns revenue by connecting patients with doctors Promotes medical tourism and helps patients find doctors abroad Inter-doctor collaboration. US physicians can join the portal for free Users can share their views offline and are provided with an inbox facility. Registration for members is free of charge Provides service application for iphones and Android mobiles Provides interactive online platform Teladoc claims an average physician callback time of 22 minutes after an appointment request
16 14 Issues Monitor: October 2011, Volume Eight Portal 82, 83 WebMD (US) MedHelp 84 (US) mydr 85 (Australia) 86, 87 Doctors.net.uk (UK) 88, 89 Doctor Fox (UK) BootsWebMD 90 (UK) Year of introduction Business model Revenue model Key differentiating factor 1995 Provides comprehensive healthcare information through portals, blogs, newsletters and magazines Helps users to find doctors by specialty, to suit their specific medical requirements 1994 Facilitates patient doctor and patient patient interactions Provides healthcare information on diverse topics NA Provides healthcare information on conditions, medicines and symptoms Helps patients find doctors by specialty and region, free of charge NA Facilitates physician physician collaboration Provides regular news and research studies to its members NA NA Provides consultations and issues private prescriptions online Provides healthcare information on diseases and conditions Provides regular healthcare information on conditions, medicines and symptoms Funded by sponsorships and advertisements Funded by sponsorships and advertisements Funded by sponsorships and advertisements Earns revenue by providing different product solutions to public and private organizations. These include: Communication campaigns Market research studies Recruiting services Earns revenue by providing online consultations and medications at different prices Funded by sponsorships and advertisements Provides several healthcare tools including food-o-meter, fit-o-meter, Personal Diet Evaluator and BMI plus calculator Provides healthcare tracking tools and iphone applications to users Provides healthcare tools including target heart rate calculator, child energy calculator and alcohol calculator Provides innovative services to its members account, forum postings and podcasts Instant consultation and prescriptions are provided. Only available to UK residents. Features WebMD Symptoms Checker tool DoctorScorecard 91 (US) NA Allows users to rate their doctors, based upon their experiences Funded by donations and advertisements Provides free registration
17 Issues Monitor: October 2011, Volume Eight 15 Further Information Visit kpmg.com for the following related publications Taking the Pulse: A Global Study of Mergers and Acquisitions in Healthcare A Better Pill to Swallow: A Global view of what Works in Healthcare The Future of Global Healthcare Delivery and Management How KPMG firms can help Supporting change Working alongside clients, our firms professionals help to streamline processes, to enhance controls and to contain costs and business risks. We look at systems, supply chains, capital structures, contracts with third parties and intellectual property to see how they can best be utilized. We identify areas of weakness that might jeopardize achievement against objectives, as well as, advising on the development and execution of management systems to create sustainable business performance. Developing business online Our firms professionals help companies create new policies, procedures and processes, including internal controls, which are needed when setting up new business areas. We help our firms clients to use technology to drive growth, improve business performance and to safeguard operational integrity, security and continuity. Key contacts Mark Britnell Chairman KPMG's Global Healthcare Practice Tel Gerald Crowell Global Head, Marketing and Communications, Healthcare KPMG Global Resource Centre Tel
18 16 Issues Monitor: October 2011, Volume Eight Companies Mentioned in this Issue. American Well 14 AMN Healthcare 6 Annals of Internal Medicine 10 BootsWebMD 13 Centers for Disease Control and 5 Prevention Children s Hospital Boston 8 Doctor Fox 13 DoctorScorecard 6, 13 Doctors.net.uk 13 Facebook 5, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11 Greystone.net 11, 12 HCA Group 6 Health Dialog 11 Healthcare Magic 3 Healthcare Performance Management 4 Institute Hello Health 2, 3 Henry Ford Healthcare System 8 imedix 6, 14 Indonesian Breastfeeding Mothers 9 Association Inova Health System 10 Kaiser Permanente 10 LinkedIn 6, 7, 8 Max Bupa Health Insurance 2 Mayo Clinic 6, 10 Medeguide 13 MedHelp 14 Medimix International 12 mydr 13 NHS Direct 4 Organizedwisdom 3 Ozmosis 4, 14 PatientsLikeMe 2, 6 Pew Research Center 2 Raritan Bay Medical Center 10 RateMyMD 4, 6 Sermo 3, 4 Teladoc 6, 14 Texas Health Resources 8 The American Cancer Society 8 The American Diabetes Association 8 The American Hospital Association 10 The American Medical Informatics 11 Association The Australian Medical Association 12 Council of Doctors-in-Training The Children's Hospital Boston 11 Informatics Program The Department of Veterans Affairs 4 The Holy Cross Hospital 5 The National Health Service 8 The Ontario Health Coalition 10 The Sarasota Memorial Health Care 8 Tri-City Medical Center 11 Twitter 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10 WebMD 6, 13, 14 Westerly Hospital 11 YouGov Healthcare 7 YouTube 5, 7, 8, 10 ZocDoc 6, 14
19 Issues Monitor: October 2011, Volume Eight 17 Sources. 1 Health 2.0: How Social Media are Transforming Healthcare, Chanet.org, March The Social Life of Health Information, Pew Research Center, May Health on the internet, The Hindustan Times, January 23, Take Two Aspirin And Tweet Me In The Morning: How Twitter, Facebook, And Other Social Media Are Reshaping Health Care, Health Affairs, March/April Website homepage, Hello Health, accessed on 6 How To Use Hello Health, Hello Health, accessed on 7 Take Two Aspirin And Tweet Me In The Morning: How Twitter, Facebook, And Other Social Media Are Reshaping Health Care, Health Affairs, March/April Website homepage, HealthcareMagic, accessed on 9 About HealthcareMagic.com, HealthcareMagic, accessed on 10 Website homepage, OrganizedWisdom, accessed on 11 OrganizedWisdom Helps Doctors Save Time, Grow Their Practice, and Improve Patient Education, OrganizedWisdom, accessed on 12 Website homepage, Sermo, accessed on 13 See what makes Sermo unique, Sermo, accessed on 14 Website homepage, Patientslikeme, accessed on 15 About PatientsLikeMe, Patientslikeme, accessed on 16 FAQ webpage, Patientslikeme, accessed on 17 Website homepage, NHS Direct, accessed on 18 What is NHS Direct?, NHS Direct, accessed on 19 Evaluation of NHS Direct first wave sites first interim report to the Department of Health, Department of Health, December 1, Website homepage, RateMyMD, accessed on 21 Healthcare Performance Management in the Era of Twitter, HPM Institute, October Doctors Use Social Media to Collaborate Online, Ozmosis.com, accessed on 23 H1N1 Web and Social Media Metrics, CDC.gov, January 31, Transforming Healthcare Through Social Media, Wipro Healthcare Services, Hospitals and Candidates Find Ways to Connect Through Social Media, AMN Healthcare, February 10, Transforming Healthcare Through Social Media, Wipro Healthcare Services, MEDICINE; CLICK HERE TO CO-PAY, Los Angeles Times, June 7, How we save your money, Teladoc, accessed on 29 Healthy Eating & Diet, WebMD, accessed on
20 18 Issues Monitor: October 2011, Volume Eight Sources 30 Healthcare Performance Management in the Era of Twitter, HPM Institute, October Website homepage, Zocdoc, accessed on 32 Website homepage, WebMD, accessed on 33 Website homepage, RateMyMD, accessed on 34 Website homepage, DoctorScorecard, accessed on 35 Patients pick hospitals for their social media presence, Fierce Healthcare, June 29, Healthcare Listens To Social Media, InformationWeek, November 20, Hospital Social Network List, ebennett.org, May 8, Hospital Social Network Data & Charts, ebennett.org, September 21, Hospital Social Network Data & Charts, ebennett.org, October 19, Opinion: The Twitter Revolution inside our hospitals, The Tech, February 18, Texas Health Taps Social Media To Promote EHR, InformationWeek, November 1, Childrens Hospital of Boston: A Successful Hospital Social Media Example, Ignite Social Media, March 23, The General Use of Social Media By Healthcare Organizations, The innovation cell, June 21, How NHS Choices makes healthy use of Twitter and Facebook, April 21, Community webpage, Facebook.com, accessed on October 1, European Hospitals, ebennett.org, VCCirlce: Online Health Takes Off: Healthcaremagic. com Adds 1,900 Registered Users A Day, HealthcareMagic, May 4, Social media in civil society citizens The Jakarta Post, April 30, New Study: How U.S. Hospitals Use Social Media, Hivestrategies, June 7, Kaiser Permanente Invites Conversations about Health with New Blog, Kaiser Permanente, September 14, Kaiser Permanente Completes Electronic Health Record Implementation, Kaiser Permanente, March 3, Mayo Clinic launches social network to connect global Mayo Clinic community, Mayo Clinic, July 5, Mayo Clinic looks to train other hospitals in socialmedia use, Medicity news, July 27, Health Coalition Launches ca: Social Media Campaign to Identify Key Health Care Issues in Provincial Election, Globeadvisor, June 7, Follow Live Surgery on RBMC s Twitter Account December 17, Raritan Bay Medical Center, December 17, Inova Health System, Darrell Green Partner to Encourage People to Get Fitter, Stronger, Inova.org, August 15, Social media in healthcare: Who is going beyond the basics?, Medicity News, January 3, Understand the Rules for a HIPAA-Compliant Social Media Strategy, Hive Strategies, February 15, For doctors, social media a tricky case, Boston Globe, April 20, 2011
SOCIAL MEDIA LISTENING AND ANALYSIS Spring 2014 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY In this digital age, social media has quickly become one of the most important communication channels. The shift to online conversation
www.pwc.com/ca/virtualcare Making care mobile Emerging delivery models Emerging delivery models After gauging respondents overall opinions of the general concepts of mobile health solutions, we posed a
Roadmap for Medicare Navigating Medicare Part D A guide for seniors and caregivers Roadmap for Medicare: Getting Oriented This Guide offers information and advice for choosing a Medicare Part D prescription
SOCIAL MEDIA LISTENING AND ANALYSIS Spring 2014 Our Understanding The rise of social media has transformed the way citizens engage with their government. Each day, nearly 2 billion people talk about and
How Healthcare professionals can use online video to engage & help their patients There s been a large shift in the need for healthcare branding including doctors, physicians and other practitioners all
Social Media Marketing for Local Businesses The average number of hours a U.S. consumer spends on social media per week. - PQ Media, 2013 Social is the Norm A lot has changed in the 10 years since Facebook
WHITE PAPER M-Health: Challenges, benefits, and keys to successful implementation Kaushal Modi and Radha Baran Mohanty Abstract The outlook towards healthcare has changed drastically in recent times. Mobile
IBM Global Business Services White Paper Public Sector Consulting Taking Social Media Public: Social Media for Successful Citizen Relationship Management By Tish Falco, Social Media Center of Excellence
The Power of Social Media in Marketing 1 Contents Executive Summary...3 What is Social Media Marketing?...3 Importance of Social Media Marketing...4 Promoting Through Social Media...5 Social Media Channels/
Use of Social Media and Mobile by Healthcare Professionals 2011 Survey Results Use of Social Media and Mobile by Healthcare Professionals 2011 Survey Results: The Use of Social Media and Other Online Resources
expat health insurance news and health tipsthe Insiders' Guide to Expatriate Health Search RSS feed Home Researchers to sniff out tuberculosis using electronic nose By Nick Lewandowski - 8 November 2011
HEALTHCARE IN THE CLOUD SPI Innovations offers cloud computing services to healthcare providers in hopes of providing a breadth of solutions, including increased security, accessibility and productivity.
2015 SMALL BUSINESS HEALTH Colorado Small Business Enrollment Guide A BETTER WAY to take care of business Choose BETTER. 31 Important deadline Open enrollment begins on November 15, 2014 for coverage beginning
www.arisglobal.com A White Paper Presented By ArisGlobal Use of Social Media by Pharmaceutical Medical Information Teams Ome Ogbru, PharmD, Medical Information SME What is Social Media? The Merriam-Webster
Strategic Sourcing Outlook: Emerging Techniques and Media www.chandlermacleod.com Social Media The Future of Strategic Sourcing? It s often tempting to stick with the tried and true and focus simply on
2010 Electronic Medical Records and the perception of the patient Julia Ferry HCA 708 12/3/2010 Electronic Medical Records and the Perception of the Patient Table of Contents 1. Introduction 2. What is
Tapping into the Recruiting Power of Existing Power Employees Tapping into the Recruiting of Existing Employees a Recruiting Trends white paper, sponsored by Tapping into the Recruiting Power of Existing
Social Media The Good, The Bad, The Really Ugly Hospitals Using Social Media No longer a luxury it s a necessity Bottom Line It expands our reach to a broader audience Allows us to disseminate health information
NOTICE OF HEALTH INFORMATION PRIVACY PRACTICES (HIPAA) THIS NOTICE OF PRIVACY PRACTICES DESCRIBES HOW HEALTH INFORMATION ABOUT YOU MAY BE USED AND DISCLOSED AND HOW YOU CAN GET ACCESS TO THIS INFORMATION.
Authors: Lane F. Cooper and Susan Aluise, BizTechReports.com Editorial Review Board: Henry Cha, Healthcare Interactive Scott Haas, Wells Fargo Brian Klepper, Ph. D., Health 2.0 Advisors Bill Lavis, Sitzmann
NOTICE OF PRIVACY PRACTICES University HealthCare Alliance Effective Date: September 23, 2013 THIS NOTICE DESCRIBES HOW HEALTH INFORMATION ABOUT YOU MAY BE USED AND DISCLOSED. PLEASE REVIEW IT CAREFULLY.
Postgraduate Diploma in Digital Marketing Awarded by University of California Irvine Extension 2 Accelerate your Career Improve Your Career Options with a Professional Postgraduate Diploma University of
Engaging E-Patients in Clinical Trials through Social Media Patient Recruitment and the E-Patient: A Survey Analysis Introduction Social media is a powerful medium for reaching patients engaged in their
A healthy dose of social media 2015 checkup How Ohio hospitals use social channels to build relationships Exclusive research by A healthy dose of social media Executive summary When hospitals need to communicate,
Impact Wipro Consulting of Social Services Media in Healthcare Transforming Healthcare through Social Media Introduction... 3 Why is social media important in Healthcare?... 4 Prevalent models of social
Case study: IBM s Journey to Becoming a Social Business Rowan Hetherington, IBM, September 2012 Introduction The corporate world is in the midst of an important transformation: it is witnessing a significant
Social Media Marketing Related Certificate Course ID Audience Social Media Marketing Social Media Marketing Intermediate Hours 45 Overview: Social media remains an evolving aspect of our daily lives in
Product Overview November 21, 2013 Digital Communication Management (DCM) 1 Agenda Why Digital Communication Management Communication Challenges Digital Communication Management Overview How it Works Questions
Telemedicine Offers Growth for Hospitals, Rural Care Opportunities The internet and digital technology have transformed our lives, changing the way we keep in touch with our family and friends, shop, pay
Accenture Life Sciences Rethink Reshape Restructure... for better patient outcomes Great Expectations: Why Pharma Companies Can t Ignore Patient Services Accenture Research Note: Key findings from a survey
JamiQ Social Media Monitoring Software JamiQ's multilingual social media monitoring software helps businesses listen, measure, and gain insights from conversations taking place online. JamiQ makes cutting-edge
Floyd Healthcare Management, Inc. Notice of Privacy Practices THIS NOTICE DESCRIBES HOW MEDICAL INFORMATION ABOUT YOU MAY BE USED AND DISCLOSED AND HOW YOU CAN GET ACCESS TO THIS INFORMATION. PLEASE REVIEW
Engaging Employers and Employees: Exploring how to use social media to improve health and safety communication Liliana Tenney, MPH Mountain and Plains ERC 2015 Rocky Mountain Health & Safety UNIVERSITY
Solution in Detail Healthcare Executive Summary Contact Us Patient Relationship Management 2013 2014 SAP AG or an SAP affiliate company. Attract and Delight the Empowered Patient Engaged Consumers Information
Patient Relationship Management: An Approach that Improves Patient Satisfaction and Health A Healthcare White Paper Table of Contents The Challenge of Reactive, Disconnected Healthcare.................
Compliance TODAY February 2013 a publication of the health care compliance association www.hcca-info.org Meet Lew Morris Senior Counsel with Adelman, Sheff and Smith in Annapolis, Maryland; former Chief
Guide: Social Media Metrics in Government Guide: Social Media Metrics in Government Why Social Media Metrics Matter to Your Agency In a digital strategy, nearly anything can be measured, compiled and analyzed.
MARKETING AND MEDIA RELATIONS Social Media Guidelines Emporia State University Last Updated: July 09, 2011 Introduction What is Social Media? Social media consists of web-based tools used to interact with
Effective Date: September 23, 2013 THIS NOTICE DESCRIBES HOW HEALTH INFORMATION ABOUT YOU MAY BE USED AND DISCLOSED AND HOW YOU CAN GET ACCESS TO THIS INFORMATION. PLEASE REVIEW IT CAREFULLY. OUR PLEDGE
Knowledge Driven Health Unified Communications for Caregiver Collaboration Situation Increasingly mobile and geographically distributed care teams need more effective ways to collaborate and address competing
BOARD of GOVERNORS Health Initiatives Committee Issues in Health Care Delivery Alma B. Littles, M.D. Special Advisor, STEM/Health Initiatives September 17, 2014 www.flbog.edu www.flbog.edu BOARD of GOVERNORS
2015 Benefit Guide Simple. Personal. Empowering. An easy-to-use guide to understanding your UnitedHealthcare benefits offered by the Cook County Pension Fund. Open Enrollment is November 1 - November 30
Social Media Plan Executive Summary Mission Point Health Partners (MPHP) sees Social Media as a business strategy to increasing members participation in their own health (activation level) and reduce healthcare
Preparing for Online Communication with Your Patients A Guide for Providers This easy-to-use, time-saving guide is designed to help medical practices and community clinics prepare for communicating with
Social Media Usage Now Ubiquitous Among US Top Charities, Ahead of All Other Sectors Introduction Conducted by: Nora Ganim Barnes, Ph.D. (firstname.lastname@example.org) The University of Massachusetts Dartmouth Center
Implementing Mobile Health Programs By William Tella, President and Chief Executive Officer, GenerationOne Over a period of just 10 years, people across the globe have changed the basic nature of their
ONLINE & SOCIAL MEDIA Targeted websites to reach State & Local Government and Education Leaders A Highly Targeted State, Local & Education Audience With more than 6.5 million visitors annually to the e.republic
IBM Software Information Management Achieving meaningful use of healthcare information technology A patient registry is key to adoption of EHR 2 Achieving meaningful use of healthcare information technology
Text for a pull out can go heretext for a pull out can go heretext for a pull out can go Text for a pull out can go here Text for a pull out can go here Selecting the Right Call Center Partner Nine Tips
2 Executive Summary The annual global Digital Influence Index takes a look not only at what consumers are doing online but also whom they re interacting with, the transactions they re completing, the technologies
Claim Packet Instructions Your Disability Benefit Claim This packet contains the forms necessary to apply for disability benefits. It also addresses common questions about Disability claims. Please save
Q1 Podcast: IBM Exceptional Web Experience Moderator: Beth McElroy, Worldwide Marketing Manager for IBM Collaboration Solutions Speaker: Gary Dolsen, Director of Exceptional Web Experience Software Hello
BARACK OBAMA S PLAN FOR A HEALTHY AMERICA: Lowering health care costs and ensuring affordable, high-quality health care for all The U.S. spends $2 trillion on health care every year, and offers the best
Effective Date: September 23, 2013 THIS NOTICE DESCRIBES HOW HEALTH INFORMATION ABOUT YOU MAY BE USED AND DISCLOSED AND HOW YOU CAN GET ACCESS TO THIS INFORMATION. PLEASE REVIEW IT CAREFULLY. If you have
Proven Innovations in Primary Care Practice October 14, 2014 The opinions expressed are those of the presenter and do not necessarily state or reflect the views of SHSMD or the AHA. 2014 Society for Healthcare
Module 1 - Introduction Introduction to Internet Brief about World Wide Web and Digital Marketing Basic Description SEM, SEO, SEA, SMM, SMO, SMA, PPC, Affiliate Marketing, Email Marketing, referral marketing,
NOTICE OF PRIVACY PRACTICES In 1996, the U.S. Congress passed the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA). Among others, the Act applies to health care providers and hospitals; it is
Presented by: Social Media: Making it Work for Your Business Presented by: Cheryl Musial Mopdog Creative + Strategy and Bill Musial Mopdog Creative + Strategy Objectives Understand the importance of Social
e-health Code of Ethics 2.0 Japan Internet Medical Association, a specified nonprofit organization Introduction The Internet has dramatically changed the world. Via broadband and improved access from cell
Unlimited No Copay Model Health care made simple. Timely access + Lower costs + Quality care Teladoc was founded in 2002 with the vision of tackling the three biggest issues in health care. Health care
Communications and engagement strategy Appendix 1 Digital marketing strategy: embracing new technologies to broaden participation NHS Northumberland Clinical Commissioning Group (CCG) is keen to develop
What Do Electronic Health Records Mean for Our Practice? What Are Electronic Health Records? Electronic Health Records (EHRs) are computer systems that health & medical practices (including mental health
May 2015 Shaping the Digital Future FLASH INSIGHT Winning with Mobile Health Apps How health insurers can gain a competitive advantage by embracing mobile as a driver for innovation Copyright This document
Claim Packet Instructions Your Disability Benefit Claim This packet contains the forms necessary to apply for disability benefits. It also addresses common questions about Disability claims. Please save
Elinor Larney, Interim Registrar, Ontario CAOT Conference May 30, 2013 SOCIAL MEDIA FOR OCCUPATIONAL THERAPISTS: BALANCING THE RISKS AND BENEFITS Association of Canadian Occupational Therapy Regulatory
Customer Experience Management Best Practices for Voice of the Customer (VoC) Programmes Jörg Höhner Senior Vice President Global Head of Automotive SPA Future Thinking The Evolution of Customer Satisfaction
Making Social Media Work for Advocacy Introductions and capabilities Christian Clymer Twitter: Facebook: YouTube: Blog: @CCatPhRMA @PhRMA PhRMA Christian.Clymer PhRMAPress http://catalyst.phrma.org Did
Social Recruiting How to Effectively Use Social Networks to Recruit Talent Introduction As a recruiter, you want to find the most qualified, talented, and largest pool of applicants. LinkedIn, Facebook,
Accenture Life Sciences Rethink Reshape Restructure...for better patient outcomes Patient Services Pharma s Best Kept Secret Accenture Research Note: Key findings from a survey of 10,000 patients around
Career Opportunities in Healthcare Analytics presented by Kaiser Permanente Northwest Region Friday, May 13 at 1:00 pm Today s Speakers Background Brian Sikora, Director Delilah Moore, Manager Corporate
WHITE PAPER The HIPAA Omnibus Final Rule Four risk exposure events that can uncover compliance issues leading to investigations, potential fines, and damage to your organization s reputation. By Virginia
The British Academy of Management s Website and Social Media Policy The creation of management knowledge through research and its dissemination through teaching and application The British Academy of Management
Introducing UnitedHealthcare North Shore-LIJ Advantage When doctors connect, everyone benefits For New York fully insured employers with 2-50 enrolled employees (Queens, Nassau, Suffolk counties) UnitedHealthcare
The Financial Advisor s Guide to Social Media Regulations For US, UK and Canada With the right preparation and attention to detail, firms should feel confident about their ability to reach out to customers
Claim Packet Instructions Your Disability Benefit Claim This packet contains the forms necessary to apply for disability benefits. It also addresses common questions about Disability claims. Please save
The advent of digital technologies has changed practically every aspect of business operations. From how employees communicate with one another, to how you connect with your buyers and customers, an online
Smart Policing Initiative Website and Social Media Vivian Chu, CNA Research Specialist Iris Gonzalez, CNA Project Manager February 8, 2012 This project was supported by Grant No. 2009-DG-BX-K021 awarded
Engaging the growing Washington, DC Chapter through a dynamic online presence Summary Statement: www.smpsdc.org Objectives As the 2009/2010 year was winding down, SMPS Washington DC was facing an unknown
HOW CAN WE REDUCE OUR HEALTH CARE SPENDING AND STILL GET HIGH QUALITY CARE? A Choicework discussion guide from Public Agenda, developed through a collaborative research project with the Kettering Foundation