Online and Traditional Computer Applications Classes

Transcription

1 Linda W. Cooper, Ph.D. A Comparison of Online and Traditional Computer Applications Classes W ith working adults occupying an increasingly large percentage of our college population and with greater numbers of students having computer and Internet experience prior to entering college, opportunities are being made to better meet their needs, interests and work schedules through online classes. In fact, according to International Data, "the e-learning market, which includes Internet and Intranet courses, will grow from $4 billion to $15 billion worldwide [between 1998 and 2002]" (Del 2000). Although students who enroll in online' classes generally like the flexibility and convenience they offer, "there continues to be concern about instriictional quality" (Terry 2000). Many question whether students in online classes learn as much or receive the same quality of instruction as students in the traditional classroom. This study compares online instruction and traditional or inclass instruction in terms of both student perceptions and student performance, as measured by grade distribution. The survey groups for this study consist of 94 students from the traditional classes and 37 students from the online class s. A breakdown of groups by gender, age _ Average Ag-e Traditional CLass OnLine Class., -,, -, -_ -_.,,.. -., Traditional Class ; l- E Mate 36%"l ;39' /o Female 64% 61%/a F EmptQyment Status Fulltime Part-time :Unemployed TraditionaL Class 33% 60%0/ 7% Online CLass 564tQ 28% 16% and employment status, as shown in Tables 1-3, reveals that of the three factors, the biggest difference between the two groups during the academic year was in employment status. Background Since it was first offered in summer quarter 1998, approximately 200 students have completed The Division of Business Administration's online Fundamentals of Computer Applications course (CISM 2201) at Macon State College. The course includes basic computer concepts and terminology, as well as instruction using Microsoft Office application software. Enrollment in the online course requires students to have a 2.5 grade point average, Internet access, and a computer with MS Office software. Online students attend an initial class meeting or orientation session during which they meet the instructor and each other and have the opportunity to ask questions. They are also told about hardware and software requirements, informed of course expectations and the importance of being self-directed, and are provided software training to become familiar with the online course materials and operational mechanics. In addition, they receive information typically provided on the i 52 IH.E.Journal

2 Exclusive PowerPrice technology!e lwhen you need ITnow! 1 l l Technology prices change daily, and you need to know that you are getting the absolute best price when you are ready to buy.with our exclusive PowerPrice technology, price reductions are immediately passed along to our customers.you get instant access to our entire catalog of over $10 billion products from today's top manufacturers; all managed by a dynanmic pricing tool that ensures you will always receive our best price. Call one of our Account Management team members today for complete details. ere me Oust some of this wee's PowerPrce b [ 0 lht I TOSHIBAI* ff00 f; t00 ; NEC _ fx X4=0I SFn f. h CD-Writer 9340i Int CD-RW 22" MultiSync FE1250 Monitor' TLP-671 LCD Projector 128MB CompactFlash Card Burn your own CDs - FAST! Perfectly flat CRT for extreme clarity! I Ultra portable! Weighs 9.9 lbs.! Take more pictures! I OxWrtel4xReWrite/32xRead i 1 920xl 73Hz max. resolution ; 1 024x768 XGA resolution Huge, 128MB capaciyl Intemal EIDE interface Ultra-fine, 0.25mm dot pitch I Super-bright 1300 ANSI lumens Removable & reusable Software includes:adaptec Direct CD Anti-static/dark-tint screen Built-in document camera Great for digital camea & PDAs and HP MusicMaitchJukebox 3-year partsiabor warrntny Includes soft carrying case.jworks wlkodak EPS0N,Canon &ehp Item#SI $ Item#S $ Item#S $ H Item#S $139.99* *Prices effective as of 2/5/01; subject to PowerPrice revisions *After $30 mail-in rebate Over 200 brands in stock and ready to ship! TtoKfE ISOLUTIOMS Experience all we have to offer including: { vsu re - Dedicated Account Management Teams k_com - Academic Discounts 4 * FREE 24-hourTechnical Support Software Licensing Bid Desk look 4 other PowerPrice

3 A Comparison of Onlinae and Traditional Computer Applications Classes t Items The class met my expectations. Traditional Class This teacher is well organized. TraditionaL CLass OnLine Class I received help when I asked for it, Traditional CLass Online CLass ITunderstood the course Layout most of the time. TraditionaL CLass Ontine Class I understood the assessment or grading process. Traditional CLass I was given the opportunityto ask questions. TraditionaL CLass The course schedule/calendar was useful. TraditionaL Class OnLine CLass CLass progressed at a fair pace. TraditionaL Class I. I t.. I. i - Agree Disagree 5trongty Agree 67% 47% 77% 63%/o 69% 67% %lQ 61.5/ 56,lQ 74% 80% 54% 89% 92% % 53% 23% 37% 31% 33% % % 26% 20%o 46% 1 1/o l 8% 5.5 Strongly Disagree first day of traditional classes, such as a syllabus, overview of the textbook, instructor office hours, testing procedures, etc. In the traditional classes, students 'are informed during their first session that online classes are available should they qualify and prefer that instructional format. Course Evaluations In an effort to assess student perceptions of CISM 2201 instruction, as well as increase course effectiveness and student learning, students are asked to evaluate their class experience. At the end of each semester during the academic year, on-campus surveys were administered in class and the online surveys were administered via . As on the traditional class evaluation form, online students are asked to evaluate the course contents, availability of the instructor, their understanding. of the class organization and the grading process. Unlike the traditional form, however, the online evaluation form also asks students to compare the quality of learning in an online class versus that in the traditional class, as well as their reasons for taking the online course. All students in both the online and traditional classes agreed that the class met their expectations; however, a larger percentage of students in the traditional class "strongly agreed" with this statement. Students in the traditional class also "strongly agreed" more often than online students with positive statements relating to teacher organization, pace of instruction, and understanding of course layout and grading process. Interestingly, when asked to rate the statement, "I was given the 54 T.H.E.Journal

4 v - I Thrills are for amusement parks, not retirement plans. When you're investing for your retirement, your stomach shouldn't be tied up in knots. Building the substantial assets you'll need for the future requires careful planning and a partner with the vision to help you look beyond the current ups and downs of the market. In short, you need TIAA-CREF. At TIAA-CREF, retirement investing is our main focus. For over 80 years, our resources have been dedicated to helping people in education and research build a comfortable and secure financial future. We've accomplished this through a combination of exceptionally managed long-term investments, outstanding customer service, and remarkably low expenses that keeps more of your money working for you. There's a lot riding on which retirement company you choose. So call us today at or visit *A l us online at Because while retirement should be exciting, planning for it doesn't have to be. Ensuring the future for those who shape it' ref.arg/ras For more complete information on our securities products, call , ext. 5509, for prospectuses. Read them carefully before you invest. * TIAA-CREF Individual and Institutional Services, Inc. and Teachers Personal Investors Services, Inc. distribute securities products. * Teachers Insurance and Annuity Association (TIAA), New York, NY and TIAA-CREF Life Insurance Co., New York, NY issue insurance and annuities. * TIAA-CREF Trust Company, FSB provides trust services. * Investment products are not FDIC insured, may lose value and are not bank guaranteed. O 2001 Teachers Insurance and Annuity Association-College Retirement Equities Fund, New York, NY 01/26

5 A Comparison of Oinline and Traditional ComputerApplicatio-is Classes i I. Student Perceptions of Online vs. Traditional Instruction I How would you compare the quality of Learning in an online class versus that in a traditiortal class? I Learn significantly more in an online course. I Learn significantly more in a traditional course. Learning is approximately the same. No opinion. 12.5% 31,0%/o 38.0% 19.00/a What advantage(s) do online courses offer you? (You may select more than one answer.) Easier to Learn at self-directed pace. Lowers the indirect cost of education (travel, babysitter, etc.). Makes it easier to manage work and school. No advantages. Other. PLease List. Reasons Students Take es Convenience/fLexibiLity. Course requirement Fits class schedule. Wanted to experience online class. Job-related. Have extensive computer expenence. Students' Desire to Take Additional Online CLasses I think M5C should Discontinue online instruction. Offer both formats, giving students the option of Internet or traditional instruction. Phase out traditional instruction in favor of Internet-based instruction. Yes Was this your first online class? 100% Yes WouLd you take more online classes? 81% opportunity to ask questions,' 80% of online students "strongly agreed," compared to 74% of traditional classroom students. Although small, the difference in responses is most probably attributable to online students' greater need to ask questions, 62.5% 50.00% 81.0% 12.50/ % 0% 12.50/0 6.25% 0% 250/o V - --, % 0 No 0 No 19% as well as their ability to ask questions anonymously. (Their primary mode of communication is .) Understandably, 89% of online students stated that the course schedule was useful, compared to 54% of traditional classroom students. Because online students do not receive frequent oral reminders about test dates or assignments from the instructor, their primary source of information concerning class activities and due dates is the course schedule or calendar. A comparison between traditional and online student perceptions of overall class instruction is shown in' Table 4. When asked to compare the quality of online instruction -with traditional instruction, 38% of online students stated that learning was approximately the same. However, 31% of online students responded that they learned more in a tradi-,tional,class, and 12.5% responded that they learned more in the online class; 19% had no opinion. When asked to comment on the advantages of online classes or the "most helpful feature of online instruction," over 80% of the students stated that online classes enabled them to better manage work and school, and they liked being able to learn at a self-directed pace. As shown in Table 6, the primary reasons they chose to take CISM 2201 online were "convenience" and "flexibility." Many students commented that online instruction enabled them to be personally responsible for their own learning and determine for themselves the amount of time they needed to achieve expected outcomes and meet course requirements. In fact, a majority of students who enrolled in the online class stated that they use computers frequently and did not want to be held back by the pace of traditional class instruction. 56 T.H.E.Journal

6 '',SA Contract -#: is:f-43v7.0 Mic-ron r0commencs Windows'200 Prof essional for,b,usiness! ki Mts, AR rjghts,esed 4orse Eetr, rnt esp N -. smi o r erors in oypog,'or hp - parchases are faueci to avbhsty ffieeszrd spfirfton Y tewtrprces dorhat4 i ps rsob =dfr. 'ipiktoe4y dne not inesud.-rrsturrrdht.and b64;l sh;ppo,and n,9 d'o rettonaro :,nirorn,e da 3prodrrnrs shrcpe stot wia i d.athto ee,ybedroed, s fa rsrntf a piduet Asarn saais are eaoe tro d b.e nerweteterunso aod oar ater* eefsebsort fortrsales rdpeestvss On-rMyt*rr'Is proofed stsouksherresn of MRr,or Computer SehaRes tiadnyrtigr rledt.eirrrrr iuonfr 0 o sr ves tiraytrnst be. rpsde y?;: stbrric-prior t,o r,rvioorn of or,rt9s yti service. Ct4tss Orte o i i d byathid-pdrtyseterve poceder sodr seirte seiusdar3n c atptseeea yor and * seswe prondet let d,the, : i' hettsn use regse red t.rser'osd d4ine d orporatn evandows isa riste'red iradesro r of Mtosoft -oiporatrorr ProJduct nrrres of,mwin& p roducts eraetroderprka;a or te stere&ti f &ctdroz' IhaOtproduct namzes vied srrfes pttctiooabrie'! Gaps u,serl ard snruybetsrademrain rif thea vrssuivsempais'rtcevo am, versrty osoriptis doe f c.reesrsonter thc..rsriofsrriustetrctnfed 5dr n nes ou ' rsrty hn'ouacr ftr' s.r dasbdiprtsoekaut tvport, itufrroe.e THEY WANT THE LATEST TECHNOLOGY. THEY WANT IT YESTERDAY. AND THEY WANT IT FOR NEXT TO NOTHING. (THESE ARE PH.DAS WE'RE TALKING ABOUT.] Even the most intelligent educators would have trouble bringing a department's I.T. allocations in line with its lofty aspirations. Micron Government Computer Systems, Inc. can help. We provide flexible desktop, notebook and server solutions, featuring Intel" processor-based ClientPro@ and TransPort 5 products. Countless customization options and dedicated account representatives let you dream up the systems that meet your unique needs. Online leaming through Micron University* helps educators realize their own noble goals. And online self-help. software self-healing options from Connected Support, and 24x7x365 technical support can free you up to reach for the stars. Let us help you stretch your I.T. budget. Visit micronpc.com/expectations or call pentiumeall It's a smart thing to do. micronpc, com Think beyond the box:

7 A Comparison of Online and Traditional Computer Applications Clas.ses I,I TraditionaL OnLine I I - I - I I I A B 'C F 15.5% 6. 30/ 9 e5 /O 14% 32.4% ). 7 ". /o 21.6% 5. 4%l 5.40/ w 1-1 ~ % 5.4 0/o Not having to spend time commuting, finding bab,ysitters, or actually sitting in class were other significant advantages noted by a number of online students who described themselves as full-time employees or stay-at-home mothers who wanted a college degree but found it difficult to attend classes at a fixed time. When asked if MSC should continue to offer online classes, all of the online students responded that it should; however, the traditional class format should be offered as well. As seen in Table 7, 81% of online students stated that they would like to take additional online classes at MSC. An additional comparison made between the two classes was that of student performance as measured by grade distribution. The same tests were adniinistered to both the online and traditional classes, and students enrolled in online classes came to campus to take the software application exams. Although a much higher percentage of students made A's in the Special Software Resource - /OOO OF NEW4pl/eOUTr' I /at T#f.. Adobe Photoshop 6 $279 Dreamweaver 4 $98 Corel Painter 6.1 $199 Filemaker Pro 5 $148 Corel Draw 10 $139 Microsoft Office $139 School Purchasers: Save even more with our Volume Licensing Programs! online class, a greater number of students in the traditional classes' made the grade of B, and there was little difference in the remaining grade distributions. An interesting statistic is the low percentage of students receiving "W" in the online class, as this is not always typical of online classes. In fact, when this online class was first offered in 1998, the dropout rate was as high as 50%. Factors that most probably attributed to the declining withdrawal rate include a newly required 2.5 grade point average for enrollment, increased student familiarity with the subject matter (computers), better explanation during the orientation session of student expectations and course requirements - and luck. Conclusion Online instruction can offer new challenges and opportunities to both students and instructors: Most students do not view online instruction'as a replacement for traditional classroom instruction. However, with the right subject matter, with It*,', = AM =~~~~~~~~~~ AL. J'h" nnlml the right instructor or facilitator, and for the right student, Internet or online classes can provide an effective educational environment and offer a viable alternative to traditional classroom' instruction. Although the results of the online class evaluation reveal an overall satisfaction of students taking the online CISM 2201, additional research is needed to further assess the effectiveness of online instruction in this and other classes. 0 Linda Cooper is a professor in the Division of Business Administration at Macon State College and has been teaching Computer Foundations courses for nine years. She was the first to offer an online course at MSC and has written numerous articles and made several presentations on the topic of online courses. She earned her doctorate degree at the University of Tennessee in Adult and Technological Education. lcooper@mail.maconstate.edu References Denigris, John and Witchel, Arnie Teaching the Learning Organization with Tomorrow's Tools Today. MA: Pearson Custom Publishing. Jones, Del. "Will Business Schools Go Out of Business? E-Learnng, Corporate Academies Change the Rules." USA Today, May 23, Terry, Neil. "MBA Student'Perceptions about the Effectiveness of Intemet Instruction." Business Education Forum, April 2000: IH.E.Joumal

8 COPYRIGHT INFORMATION TITLE: A comparison of online and traditional computer applications classes SOURCE: T.H.E. Journal 28 no8 Mr 2001 WN: The magazine publisher is the copyright holder of this article and it is reproduced with permission. Further reproduction of this article in violation of the copyright is prohibited. To contact the publisher: Copyright The H.W. Wilson Company. All rights reserved.