1 OVERVIEW OF ACTUARIAL CALCULATIONS IN CONNECTION WITH FATAL ACCIDENT CLAIMS Prepared by Ian M. Karp, F.S.A., F.C.I.A. for June, 2000 Vancouver Meeting of the Canadian Institute Of Actuaries WS - 46 Actuarial Evidence ; Actuarial Calculations in Fatal Accident Cases Introduction This paper, together with the papers prepared for this meeting session by Doug Townsend and Robin Adolphe, serves to start development of Actuarial Evidence Committee ( AEC ) educational resources on fatal accident claims, for eventual dissemination to the C.I.A. membership, perhaps through posting on the C.I.A. website. Please send comments, suggestions for future improvements, or your own papers on this topic, to Doug Poapst of the AEC. Doug Poapst is responsible for the further development of AEC educational papers and similar resources in the injury and fatality areas. Alternatively, comments can be submitted to the act.evidence list. Doug Poapst has also committed to writing a basic paper on injury matters, and it will be discussed at a session at of our Sept. 8/9 AE specialty meeting. Due to time pressure, I have not shown detailed case law citations ; I can discuss with Doug Poapst providing this at a later date. Further extensions would include more detailed comments on other fact patterns (e.g. widow with young children, child(ren) whose single parent has been killed, parents claiming future loss of support and services from a deceased child), and comments from others with differing perspectives and/or working in other parts of Canada. We could also solicit papers from lawyers and/or judges from other parts of Canada. Textbooks For Further Reading Doug Townsend mentions the text written by Christopher Bruce, an Alberta economist. This is a very good text on the quantum aspects of injury / fatality cases. (Assessment Of Personal Injury Damages, Third Edition ; Butterworths). An excellent text, written primarily for lawyers but very useful reading for actuaries, is Personal Injury Damages In Canada, Cooper - Stephenson, Second Edition, Carswell. (Despite the title, the text deals in detail with fatal accident cases as well as injury cases). This Paper Uses Doug Townsend s Fact Pattern, Organization Of Issues Doug Townsend s paper is based on a male deceased, age 54 at death and employed full-
2 - 2 - time, with a 53 year - old wife who did not work outside the home. The children were grown and had left the house. The man earned about $55,000 per annum, working for an established company sponsoring a defined - benefit pension plan, planned to retire at 65, and provided a typical level of household services re snow removal, lawn maintenance, and other household services. Doug s paper describes practices in Ontario, and also in England. I describe below my approach in B.C. to the issues raised by Doug Townsend, using the same fact pattern and organization of issues as Doug Townsend used in his paper. Projected Employment Income (Before Deductions) Of Deceased As Doug mentions, the deceased s earnings rate would be fully projected on a best estimates basis from date of death to calculation date. Calculation date would typically be the first day of a trial, if a trial was scheduled to start in the near future. If there was no trial scheduled, a convenient date in the near future would be used. I m using January 1, 2001 for a couple of cases I m currently working on. It s a handy breakpoint, particularly given all the recent tax changes. Doug s case apparently didn t involve any projection of promotion or other job change between death and retirement. Based upon the lawyer s instruction, usually based in turn on the views of the deceased s supervisor, I sometimes factor in assumed promotions. (As explained later, it s clear that the annual net discount rates applied in B.C. allow only for general pay increases (i.e. pay increases everybody in the labour force can expect to get), not for promotional increases). Projected Pension Income (Before Deductions) Of Deceased Doug points out that projected pension income, after assumed retirement at age 65, would include employment pension income and CPP. The deceased s work history was very likely such that he could have expected to receive the maximum CPP annual benefit, or close to it. To nail this down, I would ask the lawyer for some general information on the deceased s working history, and also suggest that a CPP Contributor Statement be obtained ; I then estimate the portion of full CPP pension to which the individual would be entitled. In B.C., it would be customary to also include Old Age Security ( OAS ) in projected pension income. Deductions From Gross Employment Income, Gross Pension Income As Doug mentions, income tax would typically be deducted, as would CPP contributions and EI premiums. An important exception relates to income earned by aboriginals on reserve; CPP and EI deductions still apply even though the employment income was not
3 - 3 - subject to income tax. (The spouse s income might or might not be taxable, depending upon where it was earned. Further, there would be an income tax gross - up if the widow planned to reside off the reserve). Also, other possible deductions would include employee pension contributions, employee contributions toward group insurance programs, and union (or professional association) dues. Allocation Of Family Take - Home Pay Among Family Members Doug Townsend s Approach Under Ontario law, Doug would assume that 70% of the deceased s income would benefit the widow, but he would reduce the 70% figure if the widow worked outside the home. Doug apparently assumes (as I would, in most cases) that 100% of the deceased s take - home pay would have been spent, and makes no allowance for savings. General Approach In B.C. In B.C., if there is no specific expenditure information on the deceased and on his family, analysis is usually based on Statistics Canada expenditure data. (Family Expenditure in Canada, Statistics Canada Catalogue ). However, I observed that my past analyses based on Statistics Canada data tended to put the percentage spent on common expenses (essentially, those used to maintain the family home) at between 29% and 37% of total expenditures. So I adopted the practice of approximating that figure at one - third of total expenditures. Assuming that remaining ( personal ) expenditures are split equally between husband and wife, expenditures are thus assumed to be split into three equal portions. The law in B.C. makes very clear that the widow would be entitled to claim based on two - thirds of total expenditures; one - third re common expenses and an additional one - third re the widow s personal expenditures. So the final result, assuming zero income on the part of the widow, would be an assumption that the widow s annual loss of support equals two - thirds of the deceased husband s take - home pay. This is exactly the same result as Doug says would apply in England. Case Where The General Approach Would Not Apply, Or Would Be Modified In most cases, there is no detailed expenditure information available. But where there is, it must be analyzed and the population results modified, if appropriate. This does not necessarily mean that such information is assigned full credibility. First, the quality and accuracy of any such information must be carefully scrutinized. (For example, it should cover at least a 12 - month period so that seasonal bias is avoided). Second, the specific information relates to a past period, and may not necessarily be representative of
4 - 4 - expected expenditures during the (future) loss period. In my experience, such specific information usually leads to a final result close to the result under the statistical approach, particularly re families with young children. Thus, whether or not there is specific spending information available, I am normally somewhat hesitant to depart from the statistical average. One exception would be a situation where the deceased was paying child support to children from a previous marriage. I would treat such items as if they were deductions from gross pay (i.e. the same as income tax) and therefore not available for the widow s support. Allowance For Widow s Employment Earnings I would project the widow s income. Even if she had no employment earnings, she would receive OAS. Further, she might be entitled to CPP (based on employment earlier in life) even if she was now not working. Rather than attempt to adjust the two - thirds dependency rate, I would subtract one - third of the widow s projected take - home pay from the annual loss of support. This would allow for the widow s gain attributable to her husband no longer consuming a portion of her take - home pay. Another (mathematically equivalent) way of putting it is that the widow s loss is 2/3 of combined family take - home pay, less her own take - home pay. The English method in effect assumes that the widow has zero earnings, regardless of the widow s actual earnings. This grossly overcompensates widows with substantial earnings of their own. Annual Loss Of Household Services Usually Based On Statistics Canada Information Occasionally, the lawyer retaining me will have a rehabilitation consultant ( cost of care expert) prepare a report on annual loss of household services suffered by the survivor(s). However, usually, the lawyer will instruct me to assume loss of services in line with Statistics Canada averages. In exceptional cases, e.g. deceased was a skilled tradesman engaged in renovation work at home, the lawyer will instruct me to assume services 25%, 50%, or 100% greater than indicated by the Statistics Canada average. An assumption less than the average may be stipulated where the deceased s work took him away from home, and/or he worked such long hours (e.g. lawyer, consulting actuary!) that he did relatively little around the home. If the instruction from the lawyer was to quantify the loss in line with the (unmodified) statistical average:
5 - 5 - i. I would base number of hours worked on Statistics Canada data, as would Doug. ii I would deduct one - third of the hours in i. above, to allow for hours which solely benefit the deceased. ( Own use deduction ; by analogy to expenditures). iii. To allow for the deceased being able to do less as he aged, I would cut off loss of services at about age 75, and I also ignore (re the period after age 65) the greater number of hours spent by retirees, as compared to employed persons. In the case Doug describes, I would calculate an annual loss of $5,230 (July, 1999 dollars), but it would only continue until the deceased s age 75. See Appendices A and B hereto for details. This is higher than the $3,811 per annum Doug obtained. The factor most responsible for the difference in results is the greater hourly rate I use (about $12) ; Doug uses minimum wage, about $7 per hour. Assumed Mortality Default Assumption ; Most Recent Canadian Life Tables I use the same assumptions as Doug ; most recent Canadian Life Tables, separate discounts for widow s mortality and deceased s mortality. Note that this requires a discount for the chance that the deceased might not have survived from date of death to date of valuation. Cases Where There Are Significant Health Problems I always ask for health information. Usually, there are no substantial health problems, and the population table is used without adjustment. If there are serious health / lifestyle problems, these would need to be addressed. This could be done by having the lawyer hire an MD specializing in providing life expectancy opinions, by the actuary arriving at a reduced life expectancy, or simply by report language describing the nature of the health problems, and stressing that the possibility of mortality rates greater than average is a negative contingency affecting results. Cases Of Alleged Medical Negligence Different considerations apply to cases arising out of alleged medical negligence. In a typical case, even had the alleged medical negligence not occurred, the deceased would still have been very sick. In such cases, plaintiff s counsel normally retains a medical expert re causation and liability issues, and I urge the lawyer to have that expert (normally a specialist in the field of medicine corresponding to the deceased s illness) also provide a life expectancy opinion.
6 - 6 - Assumed Annual Net Interest Rates Prescribed Annual Net Discount Rates We use the term annual net discount rate in B.C. In 1981, the (then) Chief Justice of the Supreme Court of British Columbia prescribed, pursuant to Section 51 of the Law and Equity Act, the following rates, which have remained the same since 1981: i. 2.5% per annum rate was prescribed, as the "future difference between the investment rate of interest and the rate of increase of earnings due to inflation and general increases in productivity". ii. 3.5% per annum rate was similarly prescribed as the "future difference between the investment rate of interest and the rate of general price inflation". Appropriate Annual Net Discount Rate Re Various Categories Of Loss Re loss of support from employment income, 2.5% would apply. Re loss of support from CPP benefits, 2.5% would apply until payments started, and 3.5% would apply once payments started. Re loss of support from OAS benefits, 3.5% would apply both before and after payments started. Re loss of support from employment pension, the annual net discount rate would depend on the assumed rate of indexing. If the Plan was final pay and fully indexed, 2.5% would apply until payments started, and 3.5% would apply once payments started. If the Plan benefits were expected never to increase, I would apply an annual net discount rate of 6.605%. The 6.605% rate is based on assumed annual price inflation 3.0% for all future years, and the above described 3.5% annual net discount rate ( = 1.03 x 1.035). For most big private sector plans, I assume annual indexing at 50% of CPI after retirement, so that the annual net discount rate would be the average of 3.5% and 6.605%, or about 5%. Appropriate Rate Re Loss Of Services Is In Dispute The appropriate discount rate re loss of services is in dispute in B.C. My view is that 3.5% should apply, since what is being valued is the cost of hiring a replacement service for a few hours a week. The opposing argument, accepted by the courts in two cases in the mid 's, is that 2.5% is appropriate, on the basis that 2.5% applies to wage - related
7 - 7 - items and what is being costed is the wage of a replacement worker. Using a 3.5% annual net discount rate assumes that the value of services will rise in accordance with price inflation. I think that this is appropriate. The 2.5% and 3.5% rates differ because wage increases are assumed to be 1% higher than price inflation each year. This 1% difference arises because there is an assumed 1% annual improvement in productivity. Thus, in effect, each employee s efforts are assumed to produce 1% more goods or services each year. If lost services are replaced by hiring an individual directly for a few hours per week, the individual s remuneration is a wage which should rise in line with wage increases. But the per - hour cost of hiring the service rises only in line with price increases. This is because the individual can (in theory) do the work with 1% less effort each year and thus charge for 1% less time. Similarly, if the replacement worker is hired through an agency, assumed productivity improvements of 1% per year allow the agency (in theory) to raise its price to clients in line with price increases, while giving 1% per year higher pay increases to its employees. To my knowledge, the above argument has yet to be tested in court. Present Value Of Investment Management Expenses ; Income Tax Gross - Up In B.C. it s customary to calculate both present value of investment management expenses, as well as income tax gross - up. In settlement negotiations, the defence will usually argue that these heads of damage are not needed since the plaintiff can agree to a structured settlement. The calculation of these amounts raises numerous difficult legal and actuarial issues, and I will not attempt to get into them in this brief paper. Various Canadian actuaries have recently mentioned that income tax gross - up is an area needing further discussion. An excellent session on this topic was run by Paul Michaud and Luc Rivest at the November, 1999 Montreal C.I.A. meeting. Contingencies Of Divorce And Remarriage Introductory Comments I always ask for details of any separations the couple had, as well as details of any cohabitation of the widow since the death. I always mention the contingencies of divorce and remarriage in my reports. If requested to do so, I quantify the effects of divorce and/or remarriage on a population averages basis. Contingency Of Divorce This didn t factor into Doug s case. In B.C., it s usually not a major factor. The Court seems reluctant to make any significant discount for the possibility of divorce, where the marriage was relatively happy. Also, any quantification would need to factor in the wife s
8 - 8 - expected proceeds from support payments and/or a matrimonial property settlement (including her share of the husband s pension), as well as a possible future remarriage. I can t think of many cases where a widow suffered a substantial reduction in damages due to allowance for the contingency of divorce, particularly where there had been no history of marital strife. One possible explanation is that widows who have had marital problems would be understandably reluctant to have these matters aired in court, which is of course a public forum, and may therefore settle their claims rather than litigate them. Another possible explanation is that defence counsel may consider it unseemly to ask the widow probing questions about the possibility of marital difficulties. Contingency Of Remarriage If the widow has remarried to someone earning at least as much as the deceased, and just as able as the deceased to provide household services, the plaintiff will sometimes voluntarily limit the claim to amounts lost up to the time of remarriage/cohabitation. However, just because there is a close relationship or cohabitation, does not mean the plaintiff s claim is so drastically limited. In fact, the B.C. courts would be more likely to make only a population averages discount. See Appendix C for details. Source For Population Average Rates Of Divorce And Remarriage As a measure of general population averages, I would apply annual rates derived from The Decline in Marriage in Canada, " (Statistics Canada Catalogue XPB, p. 44). These annual rates are year - by - year probabilities of a widow remarrying, (or a married man or married woman divorcing), varying by attained age, ignoring the possibility of death, and based upon 1991 data. Unusual Fact Situations Which Have Arisen In Practice Doug quite rightly selected a straightforward, typical fact pattern. However, one important role the actuary plays is to help the lawyer make sense of unusual fact patterns. I find that I am increasingly dealing with such unusual fact patterns. This may be because lawyers are sometimes able, based on past cases and legal precedents, to quickly settle cases which do not involve unusual facts. I describe below several unusual situations which have arisen in my practice. A pregnant young woman notified the natural father of her pregnancy. The natural father was killed in a plane crash on his way to meet with the young woman. The young woman gave birth to a daughter. A claim was made on behalf of the daughter (the young woman not having a claim) in respect of the natural father, even though the young woman had formed a new relationship. My report, prepared for plaintiff, quantified the potential loss,
9 - 9 - but spelled out that the calculation made no allowance for support and services provided by the young woman s current husband. A husband and wife with two young children separated. A few months later, the husband was killed in an accident. The husband had a stable, high - paying job. The widow maintained that the couple was about to reconcile; the defence disputed this. I was retained by defence, and asked to prepare a report quantifying a wide range of scenarios. Some scenarios (those assuming that the couple would not have reconciled) involved projecting child support according to Federal Government guidelines. The widow ultimately remarried before the case resolved, and final settlement followed shortly thereafter. The married male deceased spent a lot of time looking after his elderly mother, who lived nearby. I was asked by the plaintiff to assume that the annual loss of services by the mother was equal to that incurred by the widow. The female deceased was a nursery school teacher in a commune. Her own children were among her charges. An issue arose as to a possible overlap between loss of support and loss of services. The male deceased was aged 64 at death, was employed, and very vigorous with no immediate intention of retiring. I was asked by the plaintiff to assume retirement at age 70. The widow had remarried, but her (new) second husband had less earning power than her first husband, and her second husband s ability to support her was lessened by the support payments he made to the children of his first marriage. The plaintiff s claim (re the period after remarriage) was based on the difference between the earning power of the deceased husband, and the earning power of the second husband.
10 APPENDIX A ; DERIVATION OF ANNUAL LOSS OF SERVICES TO WIDOW At the lawyer s instruction, I would assume that the deceased s husband s hours of service to his spouse would have been in line with population averages. As a measure of such population averages, I refer to a Table provided to me by Statistics Canada. This Table is an updating of Table 19, contained in Catalogue E, No. 4 "Where Does Time Go", August,1991. However, the Table on which I have relied is based on more up - to - date time use data (1992 vs. 1986). The deceased would be projected to retire at the end of future year 9, assuming exact age 54 at death, and exact age 56 (had he lived) as of calculation date. Hours of services are greater for retirees than for active employees. However, I would apply the hours of service for an active employee until the end of future year 19 (when he would have been aged 75), with no services thereafter. This allows for a gradual decline in his ability to perform services, as he got older. Male Employed, With partner, No Children Applied For Entire Past And Future Periods Hours Per Day 1. Domestic work Shopping Child care Percentage of Above Hours Assumed To Benefit Widow 4. Re 1. above 66.7% 5. Re 2. above 66.7% 6. Re 3. above not applicable Thus, re 1 and 2, one-third of time spent by the deceased is assumed to benefit only himself, not his spouse. Hours Per Day Benefitting Widow 7. = (1) X (4) + (2) X (5) : 1.20 Hours Per Year Benefitting Widow 8. = X (7) : Hours per year benefitting widow 438 Hourly Value 9. The appropriate hourly value, in July, 1999 dollars, is $11.94, derived in Appendix B Annual Value 10. = (8) X (9) : Annual value benefitting Widow 5230 The $5,230 annual value would be applied in the future period. To allow for past inflation, I would apply a slightly lower figure re the past period.
11 APPENDIX B DERIVATION OF HOURLY VALUE OF THE DECEASED S HOUSEHOLD SERVICES I think that the appropriate hourly value is the cost of hiring a replacement service. The Statistics Canada publication dealing with the issue of hourly value is Catalogue E - Households Unpaid Work: Measurement and Valuation. This publication sets forth two alternative variations of replacement cost ; one is the generalist approach. The other is the specialist approach, resulting in costs 32% higher. The publication (page 25) describes the two approaches as follows: The main variants of the replacement cost method differ in their assumptions regarding the choice of market substitutes. With the market specialist variant, the replacement cost of a given type of unpaid work is imputed on the basis of the hourly earnings of people employed in a similar occupation. The replacement cost for preparing meals or doing laundry for instance is established in relation to the hourly earnings of cooks and chefs or launderers, respectively. The basic premise here is that households can delegate tasks to businesses (and indirectly to their employees). In contrast, with the household generalist variant, the replacement cost for household work is imputed on the basis of the hourly earnings of domestic employees. The basic premise here is that households can delegate tasks directly to paid domestic staff. With either variant, households are assumed to have only one alternative, and household members are deemed as productive as market specialists in one case, or paid domestic staff in the other. The publication presents results according to both approaches. The relative merits of the two approaches are discussed in the following passages taken from the publication:...there are several competing approaches to imputing value, none of which is entirely satisfactory. (p.5). (I restrict my analysis to the replacement cost method which focuses on replacement cost, rather than the opportunity cost method, which focuses on the employment earnings potentially foregone by spending time on household work). The assumption of equal productivity, at least for the market specialist variant [of the replacement cost method], is criticized as being unrealistic. It is emphasized that the work of market specialists is characterized by substantial division of labour, economies of scale and often more capital intensive production, with ensuing productivity gains. The assumption is viewed as more realistic with the household generalist variant, because... domestic employees do not undertake all household tasks... (p.25)....goldschmidt - Clermont [a leading expert], among others, recommends the generalist variant of the replacement cost method, at least for household work, since domestic employees work in a similar setting and under similar conditions as household members. Hawrylyshyn favours this method as well, on the theoretical grounds that valuation ought
12 to reflect the productivity and the wages of efficient workers. [In practice however, given the poor quality of data on earnings of housekeepers, Hawrylyshyn judges the specialist variant the better of the two]. Ferber and Birnbaum argue strongly in favour of the same method because it is simpler to apply and less subject to theoretical problems than other methods. The choice of method is complicated by the fact that estimates of the value of unpaid work can be put to several uses. It is a particularly difficult one for a statistical agency which aims to serve the information needs of a variety of users. Some recommend that estimates be developed according to several methods, in recognition of the diversity of needs and of the lack of agreement on a best (and, at the same time, practical) method. This is the route Statistics Canada has taken, although it favours the replacement cost (generalist) method for national accounting purposes. (p. 28). Thus while there is a recognition that both approaches have strengths and weaknesses, the publication clearly favours the generalist approach over the specialist approach. However, Statistics Canada advised me that they did not endorse any particular approach, in the context of injury or fatality claims. Thus, in the present context, Statistics Canada does not express a preference for one method over the other. Further, I am unable to say that one approach is clearly better than the other. I have therefore applied the average of the results resulting from the application of each method. From pages of the publication, I have derived hourly values of services according to each method, as follows. Hourly Value According To Generalist Approach Value of unpaid work in 1992 in Canada $234,482 million (p. 76) ; women s share 65.0% (p. 76); men s share 100.0% %, equals 35.0% ; men s value 35.0% of $234,482 million equals $82,069 million. Males hours (p.77) 8,751 million. Hourly value of males services $82,069 divided by 8,751, equals $9.38. Hourly Value According To Specialist Approach Value of unpaid work in 1992 in Canada $296,606 million (p. 75) ; women s share 63.4% (p. 75); men s share 100.0% %, equals 36.6% ; men s value 36.6% of $296,606 million equals $108,558 million. Males hours (p.77) 8,751 million. Hourly value of males services $108,558 divided by 8,751, equals $ Average Hourly Value in 1992 Dollars ; Adjustment To 1999 Dollars The average of $9.38 and $12.41 is $10.895, in 1992 dollars. Allowing for price inflation (based on Canadian CPI) to July 1, 1999 (the valuation date) results in the $ value
13 increasing by 9.6% (assuming.9% annual inflation from July 1998 to July 1999), to $11.94.
14 APPENDIX C CASES WHERE WIDOW HAD FORMED A NEW RELATIONSHIP BUT ONLY A POPULATION AVERAGES DISCOUNT FOR REMARRIAGE WAS APPLIED 1. Lake v. Callison Outfitters, 58 BCLR (2d) 99 (SC) ; see p.136 The widow was living with a man. However, the widow gave several reasons why she would not marry him. Further, he had an ex - wife and children in another city, and there was the possibility he would return there to be closer to his children. The Court found that, even if that relationship fell through, the widow might well form another. However, because of the uncertainty re the current relationship, only the population averages discount was applied. 2. Law v. Simice, BCSC, Vancouver A914631, May 3, 1994 (see pp ) ; upheld on appeal 17 BCLR (3d)1. The widow was living with a man by whom she was expecting a child, but she did not plan to stay with him. The Court s assessment of the man s earning / support capacity was not overly flattering. 3. Lowry and Rondeau v. Canadian Mountain Holidays, Ltd., BCSC, Vancouver C831074, Nov. 1, 1985 ; see p. 9. The widow stated that she had no immediate plans to remarry, but acknowledged a close relationship with one man. comm9933.wpd
FATALITY CLAIMS CALCULATION OF DAMAGES Galan T. Lund 1 P a g e FATALITY CLAIMS CALCULATION OF DAMAGES The quantification of fatality claims involves the following types of awards: 1. Damages for bereavement,
OVERVIEW OF ACTUARIAL CALCULATIONS IN CONNECTION WITH PERSONAL INJURY CLAIMS; WITH EMPHASIS ON INFORMATION REQUIRED FROM THE LAWYER RETAINING THE ACTUARY Prepared by Ian M. Karp, F.S.A., F.C.I.A. for posting
Have you or someone you know suffered a personal injury? TIPS TO MAXIMIZE COMPENSATION If you have suffered a personal injury it is important to consider all potential sources of compensation. A personal
PART TWO STATE DIVORCE LAW AND YOUR PENSION RIGHTS: QUESTIONS YOU NEED TO ANSWER Introduction. 15 Marital Property Versus Alimony. 16 Does Your State Law Treat Pensions As Marital Property? 16 Disability
CAR ACCIDENT GUIDE TABLE OF CONTENTS Page Introduction... 1 First Step... 1 Finding and Hiring a Lawyer... 1 Financial Arrangements... 2 Your Claim... 3 Documenting Your Claim... 5 Parties to the Claim...
Tax Planning Opportunities Involving Professional Corporations A Discussion Paper Prepared by: Alan Koop, CA Prepared for: The Saskatchewan Provincial Court Judges Association Table of Contents Executive
Table of Contents Court Ordered Life Insurance 3 Child Support Life Insurance 5 Divorce and Life Insurance 7 Your Rights and Entitlements 9 Important Issues 11 Page 2 Court Ordered Life Insurance Court
A brief guide to the pension provisions of the Family Law Acts www.pensionsauthority.ie The Pensions Authority Verschoyle House 28/30 Lower Mount Street Dublin 2 Tel: (01) 613 1900 Locall: 1890 65 65 65
Assessment of Personal Injury Damages Fifth Edition Christopher J. Bruce, Ph.D. Kelly A. Rathje, M.A. Laura J. Weir, M.A. f LexisNexis* Acknowledgments About the Authors Tables How to Use This Book v vii
TAX GROSS-UP AND FUND MANAGEMENT BACKGROUND, METHODS AND CONTROVERSIES Robert Carson ASSOCIATED ECONOMIC CONSULTANTS LTD. June 12, 2012 1. WHAT DOES A TAX GROSS-UP DO? In family compensation matters, sums
ACTUARIAL CALCULATIONS IN CONNECTION WITH PERSONAL INJURY CLAIMS Prepared by Ian M. Karp, F.S.A., F.C.I.A., March, 2003 for posting to www.karpactuarial.com. The original version of this document was used
ECONOMIC LOSS QUESTIONNAIRE AND CASE BACKGROUND INFORMATION WRONGFUL DEATH Please fill out the information as completely as you can and return it along with supporting documents to my office: Gary Skoog,
CPP benefits: Are you entitled? Survivor s Benefits If your spouse, common-law partner, parent, or guardian dies, you may be entitled to survivor s benefits. What is the Canada Pension Plan? The Canada
APPENDIX B The Firefighters Pension Scheme A Guide To Death Benefits This issue reflects the Scheme rules at 1 October 2001 Written by Eunice Heaney, Pensions Adviser Stoke-on-Trent & Staffordshire Fire
! " #$%&' ( First, an important note from our lawyers. This booklet is intended only as a guide and does not establish any legal rights. It is intended as a summary of the benefits provided at the time
Where to Begin 1 Contents What You Need to Know Once You ve Been Injured 2 The People Playing a Role in Your Recovery 5 Why You Need a Personal Injury Lawyer 8 Frequently Asked Questions 11 Recovery Diary
THE BASICS Getting Spousal Support in New York State In this booklet, we call the person who receives support the wife or ex-wife. And we call the person who pays support the husband or ex-husband. This
FAMILY LAW PRACTICE TIPS ISSUE No. 20 Topic: Opinion by: Pension Division on Marriage Breakdown Justice Doug Campbell Date: February 29, 2016 This memorandum was prepared by Justice Doug Campbell in reply
GETTING TO KNOW THE OGDEN TABLES WHAT ARE THEY? The formal title of the tables is: Actuarial Tables with Explanatory Notes for Use in Personal Injury and Fatal Accident Cases They are admissible in evidence
: A guide to making a claim 2 Our guide to making a clinical negligence claim At Kingsley Napley, our guiding principle is to provide you with a dedicated client service and we aim to make the claims process
THE BASICS Getting a Divorce in New York State Either the wife or the husband can ask a Court for a divorce. In this booklet, we say that the wife is the person who will go to Court to request a divorce
Claim Estimates and WorkSafe Premiums Introduction For employers with annual rateable remuneration of over $200,000 premiums for WorkSafe insurance are calculated taking into account their claims performance
As published in The Advocate, Vol. 53 Part 5 September 1995 "Lost Years" as a Wrongful Death Claim By Geoffrey Young 1 In a recent article in this journal 2 Messrs. Branch and Price point out that a "lost
Divorce Tax Considerations Divorce is a tough process, and one that doesn t end after a court date. Knowing your rights and obligations and understanding tax implications will make the process less difficult.
Discount Rates and Life Tables: A Review Hugh Sarjeant is a consulting actuary and Paul Thomson is an actuarial analyst at Cumpston Sarjeant Pty Ltd Phone: 03 9642 2242 Email: Hugh_Sarjeant@cumsar.com.au
Page 1 of 9 The greater the extent to which the lawyer's office provides all necessary information in a clear & accurate way, the less time our office will spend on sorting through documents and information-gathering.
EXPOSURE DRAFT CONSOLIDATED STANDARDS OF PRACTICE PRACTICE-SPECIFIC STANDARDS FOR POST-EMPLOYMENT BENEFIT PLANS COMMITTEE ON CONSOLIDATED STANDARDS OF PRACTICE MARCH 2002 2002 Canadian Institute of Actuaries
Austria Belgium Temporary disability The insured receives the cash sickness benefit until a decision on permanent disability is made. The employer pays 100% of earnings for up to 12 weeks (plus additional
COUNTY EMPLOYEES' ANNUITY AND BENEFIT FUND OF COOK COUNTY ACTUARIAL VALUATION AS OF DECEMBER 31,2011 GOLDSTEIN & ASSOCIATES Actuaries and Consultants 29 SOUTH LaSALLE STREET CHICAGO, ILLINOIS 60603 PHONE
Divorce in Florida CAN YOUR MARRIAGE BE SAVED? Before you take any legal steps to end your marriage, you should make sure that you have tried all possible ways to save it. Do you want professional help
Preparing for Retirement A Guide for Employees 010 Human Resources Contents Introduction... 3 Canada Pension Plan Retirement Benefits... 4 Old Age Security... 6 Employment Insurance Benefits at Retirement...
Open Your Eyes Wrongful Death and Survival Actions In Maryland & the District of Columbia A Wrongful Death Action What is a wrongful death lawsuit? In the context of a medical malpractice lawsuit, wrongful
The National Insurance Employment Injury Benefits are payable to an insured person who is unable to work because of personal injury caused by an accident, which arises out of and in the course of employment,
Family Law Information Centre Information Booklet GENERAL INFORMATION CHILD SUPPORT Revised December 2012 General Information Child Support CONTENTS Introduction...1 Objectives of the Guidelines...2 When
Session 10- Fatalities, a case study or when it becomes really complex (based on real cases) Luc Rivest, FCIA 1 Case: the basic facts Husband, aged 40 Wife, aged 40 Two children, aged 10 and 15 Accident
Family Law Client Information Package The end of a relationship can be very difficult. In addition to the obvious emotional issues, couples are often faced with challenging financial and legal problems.
Discussion Paper: Guardianship Issues under the Family Law Act August 2016 Introduction: The Family Law Act (FLA), enacted on March 18, 2013, significantly changed the way guardianship and parenting arrangements
from Every Canadian s Guide to the Law (HarperCollins 2005) by Linda Silver Dranoff Planning for a Will A last will and testament, usually called simply a will, is the document of instructions that a mentally
Article from: International News November 2007 Issue No. 43 Actuarial Involvement in Road Accident Fund Claims in South Africa By Greg Whittaker Whilst not required by South African Law, courts in South
How Much Is My ICBC Claim Worth? Each ICBC claim is unique. The value of any ICBC claim will depend on a number of factors including who is at fault, the type of injuries and the effect of the injuries
A note on damages in Personal Injury Cases Contents AnoteonDamagesinPersonalInjuryCases.1 Solatium 1 Whatisneededforaclaimofsolatium? 1 PatrimonialLoss(specialdamages)..1 Pastwageloss..2 Futurewageloss.2
CHAPTER 428 AN ACT concerning retirement benefits for members of the Police and Firemen's Retirement System of New Jersey, amending various parts of the statutory law and supplementing P.L.1944, c.255.
Chapter 16 Fundamentals of Life Insurance Overview This chapter begins a block of material on several important personal risks: premature death, poor health, and excessive longevity. This chapter examines
Discussion Paper Concerning the Cap on Pain and Suffering Awards for Minor Injuries Office of the Superintendent of Insurance January, 2010 Introduction The Province of Nova Scotia regulates automobile
Judicial Mistake in DIY Divorce Settlement Rapidly Corrected Mesothelioma Settlements Not Available Capital Over-Simplistic Approach Produces Challenge Pre-Nup Partially Set Aside as Judge Highlights Uncertainty
U.S. Railroad Retirement Board www.rrb.gov RAILROAD RETIREMENT and SURVIVOR BENEFITS U.S. Railroad Retirement Board MISSION STATEMENT The Railroad Retirement Board s mission is to administer retirement/survivor
Don t Let Divorce Derail Your Retirement Plans Understanding your options before, during, and after your marriage BY ARIN FIFE Retirement is one of those moments for which one spends a lifetime preparing.
How to Save Money on Your Divorce An overview of the Divorce process in California, and how to choose the right Attorney for your budget. Brought to you by: Legal Action Workshop The Law Firm that offers
Research Note: Assessing Household Service Losses with Joint Survival Probabilities Victor A. Matheson and Robert A. Baade December 2006 COLLEGE OF THE HOLY CROSS, DEPARTMENT OF ECONOMICS FACULTY RESEARCH
Summary Plan Description As in effect January 1, 2012 In the event of any conflict between this Summary Plan Description (SPD) and the actual text of the UNO-VEN Retirement Plan, the more detailed provisions
Life Insurance Association Singapore 2012 Protection Gap Study - Singapore End of 2011 Protection Gap 28 August 2012 Life Insurance Association Singapore i Table of Contents Section 1 : Executive Summary...1
CRIMINAL INJURIES COMPENSATION SCHEME: REVISED SCHEME AS ADOPTED BY THE STATES OF JERSEY 14th APRIL 2015 Published by the STATES GREFFE for the HOME AFFAIRS DEPARTMENT Page - 2 CRIMINAL INJURIES COMPENSATION
Deferring your State Pension October 2014 2 Contents 4 Introduction 5 When can I get my State Pension? 6 Putting off claiming your State Pension 8 What are my choices? 9 How much more money could I get?
SMALL BUSINESS OWNERS: OPTING INTO THE SOCIAL SAFETY NET There is a lot of upside to being self-employed as Canadians who choose self-employment generally enjoy more autonomy in their working lives and
The entire Benefits Booklet series can be found at www.archindy.org/intranet/shared/hr/index.html. The Benefits Booklet is an interactive series of three documents: 1. Health Plans. Life Insurance, Disability
A BRIEF INTRODUCTION INTO DIVORCE LAW: THE BASICS OF OHIO DIVORCE LAW By BETH SILVERMAN, J.D. How can a marriage be terminated in Ohio? There are two primary ways to terminate a marriage: Dissolution or
Order Code RS22856 April 3, 2008 Summary Retirement and Survivor Annuities for Former Spouses of Federal Employees Patrick Purcell Specialist in Income Security Domestic Social Policy Division A former
Testimony by the Legal Aid Society before the New York State Senate Judiciary Committee on the Issue of Matrimonial Law Reform and Post-Marital Income Guidelines (PMI) May 6, 2010 Interest and Expertise
District of Columbia Judges Retirement Plan Summary Plan Description 2008 JUDGES_COV_10-5-08.indd 1 10/6/08 7:27:13 AM Summary Plan Description 2008 This booklet is a Summary Plan Description of the benefits
YO U R B E N E F I T S YO U R F U T U R E What you need to know about your CalPERS State Safety Benefits C O N T E N T S Introduction............................................. 2 Your Retirement Benefits.................................
Sustainability, Cost-Effectiveness, Fairness and Value A Primer on Modern Pension Plan Design Dr. Bruce Kennedy, Executive Director BC Public Service Pension Plan May 2013 We all have dreams about retirement.
137-050-0760 Rebuttals (1) The presumption that the guideline support amount as provided in OAR 137-050-0700 through OAR 137-050-0755 is the correct support amount may be rebutted by a finding that sets
Order Code RS21029 Updated April 17, 2008 Survivor Benefits for Families of Civilian Federal Employees and Retirees Summary Patrick Purcell Specialist in Social Legislation Domestic Social Policy Division
Includes Tips & Tricks that could save you substantial $$$ and help make sure your claims get paid. WHAT IS INSURANCE? It s simply the transference of a risk from yourself to the Insurer. By paying the
When to Claim So 16 and How to Optimize cial Security Benefits monthly benefit amount is permanently reduced if they begin before the worker s normal retirement age (NRA). (The fact that these reductions
STATE EMPLOYEES RETIREMENT SYSTEM - DEFINED BENEFIT PLANS - PROCEDURES AND GUIDELINES FOR DETERMINING QUALIFIED STATUS OF A DOMESTIC RELATIONS ORDER I. INTRODUCTION The State Employees Retirement System
A Layman's Guide To ICBC Part 7 Benefits Prepared for MADD Revised January 2015 This guide was initially prepared in February, 2005 at the request of MADD to provide a layman's guide to ICBC No-fault/Part
Rights and Responsibilities Public Legal Education and Information Service of New Brunswick (PLEIS-NB) is a non-profit organization. Its goal is to provide New Brunswickers with information about the law.
DIVORCE GUIDANCE IN HILLSBOROUGH COUNTY, FLORIDA Office of the Staff Judge Advocate, MacDill Air Force Base, Florida (813) 828-4422 ECONOMIC ISSUES REGARDING MARRIAGE AND DISSOLUTION OF MARRIAGE ASSETS
401(k) Retirement Accounts In Texas Divorces A House Divided Property Division Seminar - April 29, 2014 by Greg Enos Retirement accounts, including the most common 401(k) accounts, can be divided in Texas
IBN Glossary - Benefit Definitions Accidental Death and Dismemberment Actuary - (Pension) Added Years Additional Voluntary Contributions (AVC) AVCs in house AVCs - FSAVCs AD&D provides coverage for death
A Member s Guide to Long Term Disability LTD Elementary Teachers Federation of Ontario January 2012 Long Term Disability Whatever entitlement to benefits you have is based on the language of the Long Term
f Canada Pension Plan Retirement, Survivor and Disability Beneficiaries Mortality Study Actuarial Study No. 16 June 2015 Office of the Chief Actuary Office of the Chief Actuary Office of the Superintendent
McKellar Structured Settlements Inc. STRUCTURED SETTLEMENTS 101 WHAT IS A STRUCTURED SETTLEMENT? The structured settlement is a financial package, designed to meet a particular plaintiff s needs. It does
ACTUARIAL REPORT 31 March 1997 Life Insurance Plan Canadian Forces 27 February 1998 The Honourable Marcel Massé, P.C., M.P. President of the Treasury Board Ottawa, Canada K1A 0R5 Dear Minister: Pursuant
IWPR #D488 March 2010 Women and Social Security: Benefit Types and Eligibility Ashley English and Sunhwa Lee Social Security provides monthly benefits to qualified retired and disabled workers, their family
[CH.71 1 CHAPTER 71 ARRANGEMENT OF SECTIONS SECTION 1. Short title. 2. Interpretation. 3. Action maintainable notwithstanding death of person injured. 4. Persons for whose benefit action may be brought.
TO CONTENTS Introduction - What is? Chapter 1 - Know your status Chapter 2 - The cost of non compliance Chapter 3 - Selecting your operating structure Chapter 4 - Investigations Using this guide You can
SETTLEMENT DISCLOSURE NOTICE Final Settlement of a Statutory Accident Benefits Claim Bill 164 (For accidents between January 1, 1994 and October 31, 1996) NOTICE AND CAUTION Your insurer is required to
BRIEFING JUNE 2013 UNITED STATES SUPREME COURT ISSUES RULINGS ON DOMA AND PROPOSITION 8 CASES On June 26, 2013, the United States Supreme Court issued decisions in two cases affecting the legal definition
Women Take the Wheel: Destination Retirement MANAGING RETIREMENT DECISIONS SERIES Women have many Decisions to make when approaching the junction in life called retirement. These are critical decisions
To Wed or Not to Wed By barbara findlay, Q.C. Do you know what it means to be married (legally speaking, that is)? What are the differences in rights and responsibilities between two people living together
Income Protection Disability Protecting loved ones from financial hardship in the event of premature death of a primary income earner is usually a high priority for most Canadians. Unfortunately, while
United States General Accounting Office Testimony For Release on Delivery Expected at 2:00 p.m. EST Wednesday June 22, 1988 Comparison of Amtrak Employee Injury Settlement Costs Under the Federal Employers'
Ministry of Finance General Commission for Taxes Direct Deduction Division Concerning Income Tax Deduction By Direct Deduction Method Article s number subject Page number Article (1) Definitions Article
Business Divorce, Valuation and the Importance of a Buy-Sell Agreement by Gerald A. Shanker Business Divorce, Valuation and the Importance of a Buy-Sell Agreement by Gerald A. Shanker Buy-sell agreements
Pre-retirement workshop March 2014 Shafique Pirani, BA, CRM, EPC, CFP Senior Education Consultant Key Topics What retirement looks like today What does retirement mean to you? Next steps : how to prepare