1 Institute of Financial Services Zug IFZ Crowdfunding Monitoring Switzerland Authors: Prof Dr Andreas Dietrich, Simon Amrein
2 Contents Contents Preface 1 Authors 2 Key results 3 Crowdfunding a definition 4 Crowdfunding market in Switzerland 7 International comparison 13 Crowdfunding trends for Market participants 15
3 1 Preface Preface Crowdfunding is an alternative form of financing. An important characteristic is the direct communication through the internet between the providers of capital and the fund raisers. Crowdfunding platforms use a large number of people who are willing to support a project with money. Depending on the type of crowdfunding, the compensation for such an investment can be either monetary (e.g. a share in the profits) or non-monetary (e.g. recognition in the case of a donation). Even though the basic idea of raising money with the support of a large number of people is not new, the term crowdfunding as it is currently used is a relatively new phenomenon. In Switzerland, the first classic crowdfunding platform, Cashare, was established in Crowdfunding has been gaining in popularity in Switzerland ever since and the development of the figures mirrors the growing relevance of crowdfunding, as an alternative form of financing for young companies and an alternative to traditional consumer loans. Moreover, many social and cultural projects that would have failed without the support of a large number of supporters (the crowd) have been financed through crowdfunding. To provide some insight into the Swiss crowdfunding market and increase transparency in this still new sector, the Institute of Financial Services Zug IFZ of the Lucerne University of Applied Sciences and Arts is publishing Switzerland s first crowdfunding monitoring. To start with, this paper defines and explains the term crowdfunding. It then charts and discusses the development of this market in Switzerland against a number of indicators. The data for this could be collected because all players in the Swiss crowdfunding market made their data available and permitted us to publish the data in aggregate form. Based on these analyses, the paper ends with several hypotheses for the crowdfunding market in The crowdfunding volume of CHF 11.6 million (funded campaigns) in 2013 is still on a low level. However, the growth rates are impressive, both for the number of platforms and the volume of successfully funded campaigns. When comparing the relevance of crowdfunding in Switzerland to the volumes in the United Kingdom (CHF 1.38 billion) or North America (around CHF 3.3 billion), it is obvious that the Swiss market is still in an early stage. Nevertheless, we expect the crowdfunding market to play a more prominent role in the years to come, also in Switzerland. This publication would have not been able without the work and support of various people. We would like to thank all the crowdfunding platforms for providing access to their data. Also, we would like to thank Swisscom for supporting the Crowdfunding Monitoring. The Institute of Financial Services and Swisscom will continue to cooperate in order to improve the crowdfunding market s transparency. We are very grateful to Sabrina Beckerbauer, research assistant, for editing the manuscript and supporting the project. Finally, we would like to thank the Lucerne University of Applied Sciences and Art for its financial support. Prof Dr Andreas Dietrich Head of the Competence Centre for Financial Services Management, Institute of Financial Services Zug IFZ Simon Amrein Research Assistant Institute of Financial Services Zug IFZ
4 2 Authors Authors Prof Dr Andreas Dietrich Prof Dr Andreas Dietrich (1976) is lecturer, Project Leader, Head of the Master s Programme in Banking and Finance, and Head of the Competence Centre for Financial Services Management at the Institute of Financial Services Zug IFZ. He studied at the University of St. Gallen HSG where he also obtained his doctorate. While working on his doctorate, he was a Research Associate at the University of St. Gallen and spent a research year at DePaul University in Chicago with the financial support of the Swiss National Science Foundation. He has been with the IFZ since Simon Amrein Simon Amrein (1985) has been a Research Assistant at the Institute of Financial Services Zug IFZ of the Lucerne University of Applied Sciences and Arts, Lucerne School of Business, since He holds a Bachelor of Science degree in Business Administration and a Master of Science in Banking and Finance from the Lucerne University of Applied Sciences and Arts. Simon Amrein also obtained a Master of Science in Economic History from the London School of Economics and Political Science. Institute of Financial Services Zug IFZ The Institute of Financial Services Zug IFZ of the Lucerne School of Business is the leading finance institute among the Swiss universities of applied sciences. The IFZ offers continuing and executive education and provides research and advisory services to the financial services sector. The IFZ s courses include, for example, bachelor s and master s degree programmes focusing on Banking and Finance, International Financial Management, or Real Estate Management. The IFZ also offers a large number of recognised executive education courses. The Institute of Financial Services Zug IFZ regularly publishes studies and articles as well as the annual Retail Banking Switzerland study, one of the central reference works for the Swiss banking market. Every week, its Retail Banking Blog reports on developments in the Swiss financial market, including trends in the crowdfunding market. Swisscome Enterprise Customers Swisscom supports the monitoring of crowdfunding activities in Switzerland by the Institute of Financial Services Zug IFZ with its Banking Trends & Innovation team (e-research). Since 2012 it has been observing and analysing trends in the digital ecosystem, anticipating their effects on the banking sector, and formulating recommendations for its clients. The banks are kept up to date with e-commerce trends and market developments by way of newsletters, deep dive studies, and quarterly reports.
5 3 Key results Key results Volume In Switzerland, CHF 11.6 million was collected through crowdfunding in This is more than twice the volume of 2012 (CHF 5.2 million). The biggest growth rate from 2012 to 2013 was reported for crowdinvesting (+192%, to a total of CHF 5.58m), followed by crowdlending (+109%, to CHF 1.78m) and crowdsupporting/crowddonating (+68%, to CHF 4.23m). The average volumes for the successfully financed campaigns in 2013 were: Crowdinvesting: CHF 558,000 Crowdlending: CHF 15,000 Crowdsupporting/crowddonating: CHF 7,000 Success rate In 2013, 720 campaigns were funded out of a total of 1,125 campaigns launched, which results in a success rate of 64%. The success rate is highest for crowdlending, followed by crowdinvesting and crowdsupporting/crowddonating with 66% and 60%, respectively. The Swiss market in comparison The Swiss market is in an early stage, and currently there are only 14 active platforms in Switzerland. Twelve of these platforms have their registered office in Switzerland. If the volume of funds raised through crowdfunding is compared to the funds raised in the relevant business fields for example the venture capital market, charitable donations, or the consumer loan market the crowdfunding model still only accounts for a very small market share. At the same time, however, this confirms that there is great potential for raising funds through crowdfunding. Outlook In 2014, we expect crowdfunding volumes in Switzerland to double on 2013 to CHF 24 million. More players will enter the market in 2014.
6 4 Crowdfunding a definition Crowdfunding a definition Crowdfunding is an alternative form of financing where many people come together to raise funds for cultural, social or commercial projects. Investors and fund raisers communicate through the internet, where a crowdfunding platform takes on the role of the intermediary. The intermediary receives a fee for the transaction. This commission is usually defined as a percentage of the amount that is raised. Depending on the form of crowdfunding, the investors receive monetary or non-monetary compensation. There is still no standard and widely accepted definition for the term crowdfunding, mostly because it is a young field but also because the term is constantly developing. In the literature, the term crowdfunding is often classed as a sub-category of crowdsourcing. The term crowdsourcing is a combination of the words crowd (a large number of people) and outsourcing. In the crowdsourcing context, the crowd represents the mass of internet users and can also be called community. Outsourcing refers to the practice of contracting certain tasks out to external sources. This can take place between private individuals and/or companies. The basic idea of crowdsourcing, therefore, is to arrange for a community to do certain tasks. Within a clearly defined framework (e.g. timeframe, conditions for participation, compensation), the community then generates added value of great diversity for the principal 1. There are four different kinds of crowdsourcing, as shown in Figure 1 below. In an influential article published in 2006, Howe introduced the concepts of crowdcreation, crowdvoting and crowdwisdom 2. These terms were later supplemented by the term crowdfunding, which focuses on the collection of money rather than the aggregation of knowledge, opinions, and creativity. Crowdsourcing Crowdwisdom Crowdcreation Crowdvoting Crowdfunding Figure 1: Overview of the term crowdsourcing (Kaltenbeck, 2011) 1 Kaltenbeck, J. (2011). Crowdfunding und Social Payments. Berlin: epubli. 2 Howe, J. (2006). The Rise of Crowdsourcing. Wired Magazine. Issue
7 5 Crowdfunding a definition Crowdwisdom: Crowdwisdom (swarm intelligence) uses the intelligence of a community. The crowd is asked to activate and reflect on their knowledge. Crowdcreation: The objective of crowdcreation is to use the creative potential of a crowd. The collected ideas of the masses are used, for example in the form of texts, audio files, or illustrations. Crowdvoting: With crowdvoting, the opinions and powers of judgement of the crowd are used to assess ideas or contents. The structured opinions derived from this process then serve as the basis for decisions by the crowd. Crowdvoting can therefore be used, for example, as a forecast tool. Crowdfunding: In crowdfunding, the two central elements are also the use of the internet and the crowd. In contrast to the above categories, however, the focus does not fall on the knowledge and creative potential of the crowd, but rather on the acquisition of capital for all types of projects. The money-raising phase is called a campaign. Definition of crowdfunding compensation as decision criterion With crowdfunding, the internet is used to attract as many potential investors as possible. We identify four different types of crowdfunding. The compensation exchanged between the fundraiser and the crowdfunder is the main criterion for the classification. The compensation can be of a monetary nature: the providers of capital receive a share of the company (crowdinvesting) or interest (crowdlending) on the capital that was provided. The compensation can, however, also be of a non-monetary nature (crowdsupporting: e.g. in the form of products, works of art, services or a meeting with an artist). Money can also be given without any direct and measurable consideration (crowddonating), in which case social or altruistic motives might be important. Such motives are also often very central in the case of crowdsupporting. Here the focus falls on supporting a specific idea, as it is very difficult to objectively measure the compensation in the form of goods or services and the value of the compensation measuered in money terms often only represents a fraction of the investment. These four categories are shown in Figure 2: Crowdfunding Crowdsupporting Crowdlending Crowddonating Crowdinvesting Stocks Interest E.g. goods and services No direct reward Figure 2: Forms of crowdfunding and compensation for the different crowdfunding categories
8 6 Crowdfunding a definition Crowddonating: The contributions are simple donations that usually do not earn any direct measurable compensation. Examples include social, charitable and cultural projects. Crowddonating can also be used to raise funds for political campaigns. For crowddonating to be successful, it is imperative that an emotional bond be established and maintained between the providers of capital and the recipients. Crowdsupporting: The crowdsupporting category usually includes creative and cultural projects as well as sport projects. However, commercial projects can also be subsumed under this category. With this type of financing, the investor typically receives compensation in the form of products, works of art, or services. There are no limits to the creativity of the parties looking for funding. Crowdinvesting: Instead of financing a project, crowdinvesting focuses on acquiring a stake in a young company via equity or mezzanine capital. Crowdinvesting also offers investors with only limited amounts to invest the opportunity to support the growth of a young company. In return, these investors receive shares in the company. These are often silent partnerships where the investors only have limited voting rights. Crowdlending: Crowdlending mainly refers to the financing of companies or private individuals with loans (borrowed capital). These are also called peer-to-peer (P2P) loans. This form of borrowing capital was known as P2P lending even before crowdlending became a popular term. In return for their loan, lenders expect a risk-adjusted return on their investment. As the data provided to us does not allow us to make a clear distinction between crowddonating and crowdsupporting, these two categories are treated as a single category in this paper.
9 7 Crowdfunding market in Switzerland Crowdfunding market in Switzerland In 2008, the first crowdfunding platform (Cashare) in Switzerland was established. Since then the market has seen strong growth. By the end of 2013 there were already 14 active crowdfunding platforms in Switzerland, of which 13 are included in this study (see Figure 3). Unfortunately no data is available for Indiegogo. Broken down to the three categories crowdsupporting/crowddonating, crowdinvesting and crowdlending, the following platforms are active in Switzerland: Crowddonating/crowdsupporting: 100-days, feinfunding, Ibelieveinyou, Indiegogo, Kickstarter, Moboo, ProjektStarter, Sosense, wemakeit. Crowdinvesting: investiere, 7Crowd, c-crowd. Crowdlending: Cashare (since 2013 also active in crowdsupporting), direct-lending Number of platforms Crowdinvesting Crowdsupporting/Crowddonating Crowdlending Figure 3: Number of crowdfunding platforms active in Switzerland (excluding Indiegogo) Data Collection The Institute of Financial Services Zug IFZ of the Lucerne University of Applied Sciences and Arts surveyed the platforms active in Switzerland between February and April With the support of almost all platforms active in Switzerland, a comprehensive set of data could be gathered. This data was obtained from the following 13 platforms: 100-days, feinfunding, Ibelieveinyou, Kickstarter, Moboo, ProjektStarter, Sosense, wemakeit, investiere, 7Crowd, c-crowd, Cashare, and direct-lending. Only Indiegogo did not provide any data. International platforms that only sporadically launch campaigns in Switzerland such as crowdrise and RocketHub were also not included. All 13 of the platforms included in the study can be assigned to either the crowddonating, crowdsupporting, crowdinvesting or crowdlending categories. However, as the data was not gathered at the level of the individual campaigns, a distinction between crowdsupporting and crowddonating cannot be made. This is because some crowdsupporting platforms give donors the option to waive any compensation, in which case the campaigns would have to be classed as crowddonating campaigns.
10 8 Crowdfunding market in Switzerland Heterogeneous business models Most of the crowdfunding platforms active in Switzerland can be assigned to the four crowdfunding sub-groups presented above, even though the business models sometimes differ strongly within these groups. In the crowdinvesting category, for example, there are huge differences between the business models of investiere and c-crowd. While c-crowd allows anybody to invest in a company, investiere operates more like a business angels club where only a qualified crowd may invest in companies. It is therefore not possible for anybody to invest, as investors are screened before being admitted to the group of investors. Minimum contributions also increase entry barriers for a wider public. In the crowdsupporting category, some platforms are very specialised and focused, for example on art and culture (e.g. wemakeit), or sport (Ibelieveinyou). It is not easy to categorise Sosense or feinfunding, who as professional service providers mainly offer their clients crowdfunding knowledge and technologies. Both providers develop crowdfunding platforms that are customized for specific client needs. This can be for individual companies or individual campaigns. As a service provider, feinfunding only offers white label platforms, while Sosense also publishes campaigns on its own website. Strong market growth in Switzerland funding volumes have doubled Both the number and funding volume of successful campaigns 3 grew strongly in the past few years. In 2013, the funding volume increased fourfold on 2011 and more than doubled on However, at CHF 11.6 million, the absolute funding volume for 2013 is still relatively small (cf. Figure 4). The lion s share of this volume was generated in the crowdinvesting and crowdsupporting/crowddonating categories. Although crowdlending reported lower funding volumes, its growth rate of 109% was very impressive. Crowdinvesting saw the strongest growth in terms of volume (+192%), while crowdsupporting/ crowddonating grew by 68% year-on-year in A successfully funded campaign is defined as a campaign where money is transferred from the investors to the borrower. Campaigns with a fixed target amount are only successful if this amount has been raised (all-or-nothing model). If no fixed target was defined but money was still transferred, the campaign is also classed as successful in our survey. The volumes given therefore only shed light on the amount of money that changed hands. The survey does not consider whether the funded campaign can actually be implemented as a successful project.
11 9 Crowdfunding market in Switzerland The number of successfully funded campaigns rose from 399 in 2012 to 720 campaigns in This represents an increase of 80%. Crowdlending reported the biggest growth rate (+90%). Crowdsupporting/crowddonating, which is the biggest category in campaign number terms, grew from 331 to 594 successfully funded campaigns (+79%). Only 10 crowdinvesting campaigns were successfully funded in 2013, but they raised a funding volume of CHF 5.58 million (cf. Figure 5, next page). This ratio of number of campaigns to funding volume shows that there are big differences in the average funding volumes per campaign for the different forms of crowdfunding. In the crowdinvesting category, for example, 1% of the campaigns accounted for 48% of the total crowdfunding volume, resulting in an impressive average funding volume per campaign of CHF 558,000. At CHF 15,000, the average funding volume per crowdlending campaign is considerably lower, while the average volume for crowdsupporting/crowddonating campaigns is only CHF 7,000. A comparison with the average funding per campaign raised in Germany shows a marked similarity for crowdsupporting/crowddonating (CHF 7,150 4 ). At CHF 300,000, the average funding volume for crowdinvesting is considerably lower in Germany 5. Total funding volumes in CHF million m m m m 0.23m 1.73m Number of campaigns Crowdinvesting Crowdlending Crowdsupporting/Crowddonating Number of campaigns Figure 4: Development of successfully funded campaigns by funding volume and number EUR/CHF exchange rate on 31 December 2013: Für-Gründer.de (2013). Crowdfunding und Crowdinvesting Monitor 2013.
12 10 Crowdfunding market in Switzerland 10 campaigns (1%) Number of campaigns 2013: campaigns (83%) 594; 83% Anzahl Kampagnen campaigns (16%) 10; 1% 116; 16% 5.58m (48%) 1.78m (15%) Total funding volumes 2013: CHF 11.59m 4.23m (37%) Crowdlending Crowdsupporting/Crowddonating Crowdinvesting Figure 5: Number of successfully funded campaigns (left) and funding volumes (right) for 2013 High growth rates but small market share Although all crowdfunding categories boast very impressive growth rates, the absolute volumes are still small. The results for crowdinvesting, for example, can be compared to the money raised from venture capital funds in Switzerland. This amounted to CHF million in 2012 (European Private Equity & Venture Capital Association, 2013). Relatively speaking, therefore, the amounts raised through crowdinvesting of CHF 1.91 million in 2012 and even CHF 5.58 million in 2013 are still very small. If the volume raised through crowdlending is compared to the total volume for the Swiss consumer loan market, the market share of the crowdfunding-model is also small: the crowdlending volume of CHF 1.8 million is marginal compared to the total volume of CHF 7.5 billion 6 for the consumer loan market. What is interesting, however, is that the average amount of a consumer loan (CHF 17,700) is similar to the average volume in crowdlending. Compared to the total volumes for donations in Switzerland, crowddonating is also still negligibly small. While the ZEWO-certified organisations received donations totalling CHF 1.04 billion 7 in 2012, only CHF 2.52 million was raised through crowddonating and crowdsupporting. 6 Association of Swiss Credit Banks and Financial Institutions VSKF (2013). Das vierte Jahr in Folge: Abnahme der Konsumkredite. Press release, 27 February ZEWO Foundation. Donation statistics 2012.
13 11 Crowdfunding market in Switzerland The fact that these volumes are still extremely low compared to the relevant markets confirms that the young crowdfunding market is not yet very important. On the other hand, the above figures also point towards the excellent growth potential of crowdfunding. It also seems that crowdfunding can be used as a very flexible instrument for raising funds, whether in the donations segment, for venture capital, or in the consumer loan market. Funding ratios reflect business model The funding ratios of campaigns are expressed as the ratio of the amount paid out compared to the predefined target amount 8. For crowdsupporting/crowddonating, this ratio is consistently above 100% (2013: 107%), as the all-or-nothing principle generally applies to these forms of crowdfunding in Switzerland: the money that is raised is only paid out if the target amount is reached or exceeded. In the crowdsupporting/crowddonating category, 100-days, wemakeit, Ibelieveinyou, Kickstarter and Projekt- Starter follow this approach, while Moboo always pays out the money that is collected. Feinfunding and Sosense who operate in the market more as service providers have different and more flexible models, depending on the clients demands. Because in the crowdlending category (Cashare, direct-lending) the money can be paid out even if the target amount has not been reached, the funding ratio was 84% for Although minimum amounts are often defined for the crowdinvesting segment, different payout mechanisms are applied. The funding ratio of 67% for crowdinvesting is slightly less than for the other forms. High success rates: campaigns in Switzerland are often funded successfully In 2013, campaigns for a total amount of CHF 24.4 million were launched. CHF 11.6 million was successfully funded, which translates into a success rate of 47.5%. The success rate is even higher if we consider the number of campaigns: a money transaction took place for 720 out of a total of 1,125 campaigns. This equals a success rate of 64%. As money is paid out on crowdlending campaigns even if the target amount is not reached, the success rate here is 100%. The success rate is 66% for crowdinvesting and 60% for crowdsupporting/crowddonating. The figures changed very little compared to the previous year. In an international comparison, these success rates are slightly above average. According to a study by massolution 9, the global success rates in 2012 were 91% for crowdlending, around 45% for crowdinvesting, almost 53% for crowdsupporting, and 41% for crowddonating. 8 Funding ratio = amount paid out (without fees)/defined target amount for the campaign 9 massolution (2013). 2013CF The Crowdfunding Industry Report.
14 12 Crowdfunding market in Switzerland Fee models applied by the platforms The fee models applied by the different crowdfunding platforms differ considerably, depending on the business model and form of crowdfunding. The following table provides an overview of the individual fee models applied by the different crowdfunding platforms active in Switzerland. Crowdsupporting/Crowddonating Crowdlending Crowdinvesting Platform Payout model Fee on amount paid out 100-days all-or-nothing 5% Other fee models, further information feinfunding various Selection of different fixed-price packages, additional fee of 0 3% (white label solution) Ibelieveinyou all-or-nothing 9%(5% administrative fee/4% payment transactions) Indiegogo optional Flexible target amount: target not reached, 9% on amounts received; target reached, 4% on amounts received Fixed target amount: 4% on amounts Kickstarter all-or-nothing 5% Moboo keep-it-all 10% ProjektStarter all-or-nothing 8% (5% for junior project) Sosense various 10% wemakeit all-or-nothing 6% commission, 4% transaction fee Cashare (Crowdsupporting) Cashare (Crowdlending) all-or-nothing 5% keep-it-all Borrower: Verification fee CHF 19; platform fee 0.75% of the annual loan amount, compulsory life insurance, voluntary insurance for occupational disability/unemployment Lender: 0.75% of the outstanding loan amount direct-lending keep-it-all Fixed price plus commission of 1 3% 7Crowd all-or-nothing 5 10% c-crowd.com all-or-nothing 10% Entrepreneur defines amount of funding needed as well as minimum funding amount. As soon as the minimum funding amount is reached, the entrepreneur can end the subscription period and request that the payments are being executed. Use of market place CHF 250 (basic) or CHF 400 (premium) for three months. investiere all-or-nothing 6.5% commission on capital raised by investiere, paid by start-up; 4.5% commission for investors, which is reinvested in the start-up by Verve Capital Partners. Table 1: Overview of fee models
15 13 International comparison International comparison According to the massolution study, the global funding volume raised through crowdfunding in 2012 was around CHF 2.46 billion 10 (+81% year-on-year) 11. A total of 1.1 million campaigns were financed. Broken down by region, the lion s share of this volume can be attributed to North America (CHF 1.46 billion, +105% year-on-year) and Europe (CHF 860 million, +65%). The United Kingdom accounts for the largest crowdfunding volume in Europe: at the end of 2012, the crowdfunding volume was around CHF 733 million. 12 In 2013, this increased to CHF 1.38 billion. The crowdlending platform Zopa is one of the most important platforms in the UK market. In 2013, Zopa alone raised an impressive amount of CHF 281 million. 13 In Germany, the annual volumes are much lower than in the UK. The total crowdfunding volume raised in 2013 was CHF 30.8 million. 14 In the crowdinvesting segment, 66 campaigns with a volume of CHF million were funded successfully. In the crowdsupporting and crowddonating segments, a total of 922 campaigns with a volume of CHF 6.6 million were funded successfully. 15 Compared to Switzerland, crowdlending platforms are stronger represented in the UK and in North America. Together, the two largest peer-to-peer lending platforms in the US Lending Club and Prosper raised CHF 2.1 billion in This accounts for a substantial share of the North American crowdfunding market, which is estimated at around CHF 3.3 billion. 17 With a volume of CHF 11.6 million, the Swiss crowdfunding market is small in an international comparison, both in absolute figures as well as relative to the population and the country s economic output. If the crowdfunding volumes for the relevant regions or countries are expressed as a ratio of Gross Domestic Product (GDP) and population, the UK and North American markets are considerably more important than those in Germany and Switzerland. In 2013, CHF per inhabitant was raised via crowdfunding in the UK. In North America, only about half this amount was raised, i.e. CHF 9.35 per inhabitant. These amounts are considerably lower for Germany and Switzerland. A similar picture emerges if we look at crowdfunding volumes as a ratio of GDP for the different countries. Crowdfunding volumes per inhabitant in CHF as % of GDP Germany % Switzerland % North America % United Kingdom % Table 2: Crowdfunding volumes as a ratio of resident population and gross domestic product USD/CHF exchange rate on 31 December 2012: massolution estimates the global funding volume for 2013 at CHF 4.6 billion. 12 GBP/CHF exchange rate on 31 December 2012: Zopa (2014). About Zopa Who we are. Online. 14 EUR/CHF exchange rate on 31 December 2013: Für-Gründer.de (2013). Crowdfunding und Crowdinvesting Monitor The Economist (2014). Peer-to-peer lending. Banking without banks. 01/03/2014, print edition. 17 Estimate, as no concrete data for 2013 is available yet for the North American market. 18 Sources: IMF World Economic Outlook (2014); massolution (2013); Collins, N., Swart, R., & Zhang, B. (2013); IFZ Crowdfunding Database. Estimate of crowdfunding volumes for the US in 2013: USD 3.3 billion
16 14 Crowdfunding trends for 2014 Crowdfunding trends for 2014 Against the background of the above results, the following hypotheses are developed regarding the crowdfunding market in 2014: 1. The crowdfunding market is set to double in 2014 The total crowdfunding market will double from 2013 to 2014, both in terms of volume and the number of successfully funded campaigns, thereby continuing the trend albeit at a higher level of the past few years. Specifically, we expect that around 1,500 campaigns for a total of CHF 24 million will be successfully funded in In terms of volume, crowdinvesting and crowdlending will see the strongest growth in 2014, while crowddonating and crowdsupporting will enjoy the biggest growth with regard to the number of campaigns. We also expect these figures to double (from 594 financed campaigns in 2013 to more than 1,000). 2. The success rate of platform operators and campaign initiators will increase due to learning effects. The success rate for the funding of campaigns is likely to increase slightly due to the following four determinants: firstly, the professionalism and knowledge of the platforms will continue to increase. Secondly, campaign initiators will benefit from learning effects. As far as the professionalisation of campaigns is concerned, the project initiators in particular still have much to learn. Thirdly, we expect the reach of these campaigns to increase, as people will become more aware of crowdfunding as a source of financing. And fourthly, we are likely to see successful initiators with an existing community to ask for another funding which increases the chances for success. 3. Regulation is likely to receive more attention. There will be more focus on regulation. Until now, the Swiss Financial Market Supervisory Authority (FINMA) has entered into separate agreements on regulations and conditions with several crowdfunding providers. It can be assumed that this policy will be continued for as long as regulation of the crowdfunding model has not been standardised. The sector itself is likely to welcome clearly defined ground rules. However, given the size of the market, crowdfunding is not yet important enough for the political agenda in Switzerland. This will change quickly if the growth of the past few years continues. 4. The market is young more competitors will enter the market. The number of crowdfunding platforms in Switzerland has increased rapidly in the past few years. We expect this trend to continue in 2014 and that new competitors with different business models will enter the market. We not only expect the emergence of niche platforms that will focus on specific topics, but also see great potential for websites that are set up for a specific campaign only (e.g. for political campaigns). We also expect the first banks to become active in the crowdfunding market in Generally speaking, the barriers of entry are very low for crowdfunding. The technology is cheap and available ready-made. The main difficulties faced by new platforms include the acquisition of the know-how required for successful operation and the need to reach critical mass. Even large Swiss platforms are currently still trying to operate their business in a manner that covers their costs. These platforms have to successfully master this early phase of business development if they wish to guarantee their long-term survival.
17 15 Market participants Market participants In the following, the platforms active in Switzerland are presented. All data and descriptions were provided by the platforms. Managing Director Other persons involved in the business CEO: Johannes Gees, Co-Manager: Rea Eggli Name Legal owner Address wemakeit wemakeit.ch GmbH Schöneggstrasse 5, 8004 Zurich Jürg Lehni Year of establishment 2012 Telephone - Number of employees (FTEs) Target market company approx. 5 Form Crowdsupporting Switzerland and neighbouring countries (F/D/AT) / culture, creative industries, society, technology, social welfare wemakeit offers individuals, organisations and institutions the opportunity to finance creative projects or products in a short time and present these to its own community and an expanded target group in German, French and English. wemakeit.net consists of a charitable association through which the funding is routed and a GmbH (limited liability company) that handles business operations. The association is registered as a charitable organisation; contributions to projects and associations in Switzerland are generally taxfree. business model Fee model Payout of funds Commission-based service 10% of target amount (6% commission, 4% transaction fee) If target amount is reached (all or nothing) Name Legal owner investiere Verve Capital Partners Ltd. Managing Director Steffen Wagner (CEO) Address Grafenaustrasse 9, 6300 Zug Other persons involved in the business Julien Pache, Lukas Weber Year of establishment 2010 Telephone Number of employees (FTEs) Target market company business model Fee model Payout of funds 8 Form Crowdinvesting Switzerland / high-tech (excluding pharma), medtech, cleantech and ICT investiere is a community of around 4,000 investors and sector specialists who are interested in start-ups and describes itself as one of the leading online start-up investment platforms in Europe. Since 2010, more than 20 start-ups have used investiere. By using the platform, the community can identify promising investment opportunities. After accreditation by the investiere team, an investor can decide to invest directly in a specific start-up and become a shareholder. investiere systematically brings private investors together with selected lead investors and institutional co-investors. investiere is operated by Verve Capital Partners Ltd. domiciled in Switzerland. 6.5% success-based commission paid by start-up; 4.5% commission for investors which is immediately reinvested in the start-up by Verve Capital Partners. If target amount is reached (all or nothing)
18 16 Market participants Name Legal owner Managing Director Philipp Steinberger Address Other persons involved in the business Year of establishment Number of employees (FTEs) Target market M. Bernegger, O. Rappold, Ch. Laib, Centralway Holding 2010 (platform started in April 2011) c-crowd c-crowd Ltd Luegislandstrasse 105, 8051 Zurich Telephone Form Crowdinvesting Switzerland / no sector focus company c-crowd.com is a Swiss online platform that brings entrepreneurs and investors together. c- crowd operates crowdfunding for Swiss public limited companies and also functions as a marketplace for Swiss and international entrepreneurs who cannot or do not want to do crowdfunding. business model Fee model Payout of funds Commission-based Crowdfunding: 10% of capital raised; Market place: CHF 250 (basic) or CHF 400 (premium), depending on functionality 10% of target amount If target amount is reached (all or nothing) Name Legal owner Managing Director Lukas Wullimann Address Other persons involved in the business Sandra Oberoi, Martin Roth, Myriam Wullimann ProjektStarter Designatelier GmbH Weissensteinstrasse 72, 4515 Oberdorf Year of establishment 2011 Telephone Number of employees (FTEs) Target market 1.05 (varies strongly) Form Crowdsupporting Switzerland / creativity, juniors (people younger than 25) company Platform for the documenting and funding of creative projects. business model Fee model Payout of funds Support and exploitation of Swiss inventiveness 8% of target amount, 5% for junior projects If target amount is reached (all or nothing)
19 17 Market participants Name Legal owner Managing Director Michel Grand Address Other persons involved in the business Moboo Michel Grand Ch. Des Rairettes 23, A41, 1997 Haute-Nendaz - Year of establishment 2012 Telephone - Number of employees (FTEs) Target market 1 Form Crowdsupporting Switzerland company Moboo is a global crowdfunding platform for innovative projects. The platform focuses on local projects from French-speaking Switzerland. business model Fee model Payout of funds Commission-based revenue from raising money for projects 10% of target amount Keep it all Name Legal owner 100-DAYS 100-DAYS GmbH Managing Directors Romano Strebel & Christian Klinner Address St. Jakobstrasse 54a, 8004 Zurich Other persons involved in the business None Year of establishment February 2012 Telephone - Number of employees (FTEs) Target market 1 Form Crowdsupporting / crowddonating Switzerland / EU / crowdfunding for all company 100-DAYS is the only crowdfunding platform offering users a fully automated agency with manuals, tips and tricks. 100-DAYS offers the largest number of payment channels (incl. via text message), a social media cockpit, expert support (by telephone and ), templates, tools and publicity in the Ron Orp community. Project initiators can also order free flyers for their projects. business model Fee model Payout of funds Commission-based service 5% of target amount If target amount is reached (all or nothing)
20 18 Market participants Name Legal owner Cashare Cashare AG Managing Director Michael Borter Address Bösch 65, 6331 Hünenberg Other persons involved in the business Roger Müller Year of establishment 2008 Telephone - Number of employees (FTEs) Target market 2 Form Crowdlending and crowdsupporting Switzerland company Cashare is a platform offering alternative investment and financing opportunities via the crowd. This allows private individuals to give loans to one another within a secure framework. It is also possible to finance creative projects through crowdsupporting. business model Fee model Payout of funds Cashare earns a fee on the referral of investment and financing opportunities. Crowdlending: see fee model table; crowdsupporting 5% of the amount raised Crowdlending: Keep it all Crowdsupporting: If target amount is reached (all or nothing) Name Legal owner feinfunding Feinheit GmbH Managing Director Moritz Zumbühl Address Molkenstrasse 21, 8004 Zurich Other persons involved in the business Stefan Reinhard, Stephan Germann Year of establishment 2006 Telephone Number of employees (FTEs) Target market 26 Form Crowdsupporting / crowddonating German-speaking Switzerland / NGOs, start-ups, marketing for SMEs company Feinheit is a digital agency domiciled in Zurich. Its portfolio ranges from simple websites to complex application development to cross-media campaigns. Feinfunding is a 'white label' provider. business model Fee model Payout of funds Digital agency Selection of different fixed-price packages, additional fee of 0-3% If target amount is reached. However, the project operators manage the platform themselves and can also enter payments manually.
C H A R T E R E D A C C O U N T A N T S Digital and Creative Sector: Crowdfunding - a report by Adeoluwa Adeniyi September 2012 F O R W A R D T H I N K I N G P E R S O N A L D I F F E R E N T Crowdfunding
Crowdfunding & Alternative Finance Kieran Garvey 22.7.15 Overview Background What is driving the Rise of Future Finance? Crowdfunding and AltFin models Market size and potential Creating a successful crowdfunding
Investors Day 2015 Swiss Life Asset Managers Stefan Mächler, Group CIO Zurich, 25 November 2015 Swiss Life Asset Managers 2018 Backed by its strong Proprietary Insurance Asset Management, Swiss Life Asset
Page 1 The Young Entrepreneur's guide to starting a business (Part 5) Richard Belsey & Fergal McLoughlin May 2013 A whistle stop tour of alternative funding options for start-ups As part of our Young Entrepreneur
Communications P.O. Box, CH-8022 Zurich Telephone +41 44 631 31 11 firstname.lastname@example.org Zurich, 23 June 2014 Balance of payments and international investment position in Q1 2014 Change to new IMF standard
Press release For business desks 7 November 2013 Commerzbank: operating profit of EUR 103 m in third quarter Revenues before loan loss provisions almost stable at EUR 2.3 bn despite seasonal effects Annual
The Social Impact Investment Ecosystem in Germany Input for the meeting of the Social Impact Investing Taskforce established by the G8 Berlin, 18-19 February 2014 The Social Impact Investment Ecosystem
Alain Schmitt Directorate General for Enterprise October 14 th, 2014 I. Facts and figures about innovation in France II. Startup financing III. Entrepreneurship culture and ecosystems Worldwide ranking
Q1 / 2015: INTERIM REPORT WITHIN THE FIRST HALF-YEAR OF 2015 Berentzen-Gruppe Aktiengesellschaft Haselünne / Germany Securities Identification Number 520 163 International Securities Identification Numbers
RESOURCES AUTHORED BY MICHIGAN COMMUNITY RESOURCES LEGAL TEAM MADE POSSIBLE BY THE GENEROUS SUPPORT OF THE MICHIGAN STATE BAR FOUNDATION SEPTEMBER 2015 FIND GUIDES FOR THE ENTREPRENEUR, INVESTOR, OR NONPROFIT
Analysts and press conference for the financial year 2010 March 16, 2011 Welcome Walter Gränicher Jost Sigrist Werner Schmidli Chairman of the Board of Directors Chief Executive Officer Chief Financial
Press release Sales and profit expectations for 2014 fulfilled Distribution proposed Share buy-back agreed Sales up 4 percent on previous year Gross and EBIT margins reduced by temporary start-up costs
The MLP Group The partner for all financial matters Reinhard Loose, CFO, Roadshow Frankfurt, 5th March 2015 Agenda MLP at a glance Benefits for shareholders Key financials 2014 Impact of regulation Outlook
METRO GROUP increases sales in a challenging consumer environment Sales rose by 1.2% to 66.7 billion (adjusted for portfolio measures: +2.3%); EBIT before special items reached around 2.0 billion Operating
Semi-annual Content Page 1. At a Glance 1 2. The Company 2 3. Business Trends 2 4. Group Profit and Loss 4 5. Group Balance Sheet 5 6. Group Cash Flow Statement 6 7. Development of Shareholders' Equity
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT FINANCE & REGULATION CROWDFUNDING A new capital source for CDFIs and the communities we serve Agenda 1. City First Enterprises 2. What is Crowdfunding? 3. New Access to Capital through
Press release For business desks 7 May 2015 Commerzbank: Operating profit more than doubled to EUR 685 m in the first quarter of 2015 Revenues before loan loss provisions in the Group increased year-on-year
Swiss ETF Event Zurich, 22 October 2014 AGENDA 17.00 17.15 Registration and welcome Drink 17.15 17.30 ishares Switzerland and the future of the Swiss Platform for investors Sven Württemberger Director,
enabling the next generation Exploiting Technology for Better Member Relationships www.uk.logical.com Summary Membership organisations cannot afford to ignore the opportunities for technology to enhance
31 Real Estate Clients HSH Nordbank is one of the most sought-after providers of finance on the German real estate market. Backed by our extensive specialist skills in financial services for all aspects
Proposed acquisition of LGT Asset Management Division and Preliminary Results for the year ended ember 1997 30 January 1998 FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE The Board of AMVESCAP PLC has entered into an agreement
Thomas Kloet Chief Executive Officer TMX Group The Economic Club of Canada May 27, 2014 **CHECK AGAINST DELIVERY** Show Me the Money An Exploration of Capital Raising in Canada Thanks very much, Natasha,
EUROPEAN COMMISSION ENTERPRISE AND INDUSTRY DIRECTORATE-GENERAL Service Industries Key Enabling Technologies and Digital Economy Introduction STRATEGIC POLICY FORUM ON DIGITAL ENTREPRENEURSHIP Fuelling
Deutsche Bank UK Banks Conference 07 April 2011 Chris Lucas, Group Finance Director Slide: Name Slide Thanks very much, it s a great pleasure to be here today and I d like to thank our hosts Deutsche Bank
Goldman Sachs European Financials Conference Improving growth and profitability in life insurance Bruno Pfister, Group CEO Berlin, 11 June 2008 Agenda 1. Profitable growth: strong delivery since 2003 2.
PRESS RELEASE Paris, 18 March 2010 LA BANQUE POSTALE 2009 RESULTS and OUTLOOK FOR 2010 2009 was the best year yet for La Banque Postale 2010 sees the launch of new business lines and the development of
Online Small Business Loans Questions you should ask about online small business loans A few years ago not many Canadian small business owners had heard of online business loans, FinTech (financial technology)
Germany Reports Record High of New Investment Projects Germany is a very attractive location for foreign investors. Germany Trade & Invest (GTAI) and the economic development agencies of the German Federal
REPORT Crowdfunding: beyond the hype, why banks should be serious about it January 2016 Crowdfunding: beyond the hype, why banks should be serious about it Contents 1. Introduction...3 2. What challenges
IR release 2 November 2015 Commerzbank: Operating profit improved after nine months of 2015 to EUR 1.5 bn CET 1 ratio increased to 10.8% Operating profit in Group in third quarter at EUR 429 m (Q3 2014:
BEOS Survey 02: March 2013 Corporate Real Estate: Portfolio & Investment Structures INTRODUCTION The analytic series BEOS Survey has set itself the goal of enhancing the transparency of Germany's commercial
Index Solutions A Matter of Weight Newsletter No. 11 Our current newsletter is about weight, or more precisely the weighting of equities in an index. Non-market capitalization weighted indices are at present
Half Year Report 2009 Oliver Borrmann Andreas van Bon Ralph Günther Dear shareholders and business partners, The second quarter of 2009 failed to bring an upturn in our business of venture capital direct
The MLP Group The partner for all financial matters Dr. Uwe Schroeder-Wildberg, CEO July 2015 Agenda MLP at a glance Benefits for shareholders Key financials 2014 Impact of regulation Outlook MLP 3 7 14
BESPOKE Inheritance Service Reduce your liability to inheritance tax using Business Property Relief February 2014 Rockpool is an independent firm dedicated to creating tax-efficient investment opportunities
IR release 12 February 2016 Commerzbank: Strategy successful net profit of over 1 billion euros and dividend Operating profit in 2015 more than doubled to EUR 1,909 m (2014: EUR 689 m) Operating profit
Strategy / Investment Financial Repression: A Driving Force for Mergers and Acquisitions? International capital markets have seen a growing number of corporate mergers and acquisitions (M&A) over the past
Crowdfunding in the EU Identification First name -open reply-(compulsory) Family name -open reply-(compulsory) What category describes you best? -single choice reply-(compulsory) Organisation's name -open
/08 9-MONTHS REPORT Stable development of business in Q3 Lila Logistik confirms full-year forecast Key figures for the first three quarters of 2008 in accordance with IFRS 01.01. 01.01. Change in Change
Postbank Group Interim Management Statement as of September 30, 2013 Preliminary Remarks Macroeconomic Development Business Performance Preliminary Remarks This document is an interim management statement
Delhi Business Review X Vol. 13, No. 2 (July - December 2012) THE ROLE OF CROWDFUNDING IN ENTREPRENEURIAL FINANCE Devashis Mitra* P URPOSE THIS study seeks to examine the relatively new trend in alternative
1 Depositary Bank Solutions Effective Custody of Fund Assets Depositary Bank Solutions 4 Fund Domiciles 6 A Solution Package with Many Benefits 8 Depositary Bank Services 10 Contractual Settlement 13 Reimbursement
Page 1 of 6 Corporate Structure Capital Structure Legal form: Shares: Swiss corporation, based in Zug. In total, 1,527,510 bearer shares have been issued (see below, capital history). Listing: Listed on
Review of TD s businesses REVIEW OF TD S BUSINESSES PROFILES OF TD S BUSINESSES TODAY IN THIS REVIEW, WE HAVE ARRANGED OUR BUSINESSES AROUND OUR TWO DISTINCT CUSTOMER BASES RETAIL AND WHOLESALE TO SHOW
The digital economy at the heart of the economic and social transition of EU Regions Digital Entrepreneurship: The EU vision, strategy and actions EITO Task Force Meeting, 14th November 2014 Michael Berz
2016 Switzerland and Credit Suisse 160 Years at the Heart of Switzerland & Capital Markets At a Glance How We Contribute to Switzerland s Success Commitment to Our Swiss Home Market 30,000 clients a day
British Business Bank Peter Wilson CEO British Business Bank Investments ABFA Annual Conference 3 June 2015 Contents Overview of the British Business Bank Rationale Business Model Aims Programmes Impact
European private equity investment over 40bn in 2014, exits hit record levels, new EVCA data shows Brussels 12 May 2015 European private equity investment rises 14% to 41.5bn in 2014 Over 5,500 European
Workshop Managing Decisions in the Era of Creativity Nov. 11 and 12, 2010, in Karlsruhe - Micro-Financing of Creative Ventures: Crowdfunding and more - Joachim Hemer Fraunhofer-Institute for Systems und
Research Paper Nr. 3 / 2013 English Translation Asset Manager Selection based on historical performance Management Summary Historical performance is a frequently used criterion to select asset managers.
Fewer net errors and omissions, that is a new format of the balance of payments The size of net errors and omissions in the balance of payments decreased from 4.4% to 2.3% of GDP. This resulted from data
Introduction to mbank Group The most successful organic growth story in Poland August 2015 mbank Group in a snapshot General description Key financial data (PLN M) Set up in 1986, mbank (originally BRE
A Survey of SME Finance and the Emerging Alternatives for Access to Capital Jim Faith Trade and Export Finance Online Global California December 3, 2014 2014 TEFO. All Rights Reserved Agenda Section 1:
The Canada Life Assurance Company 2007 ANNUAL REPORT CAUTIONARY NOTE REGARDING FORWARD-LOOKING INFORMATION This report contains some forward-looking statements about the Company, including its business
1 THE RISE OF CROWDFUNDING Threats and Opportunities for the Global Wealth Management Industry Report Extract Original Report with 159 pages October 2015 MyPrivateBanking Report THE RISE OF CROWDFUNDING
ECONOMIC IMPORTANCE OF CLUBS IN THE RAIFFEISEN SUPER LEAGUE 2013/14 FINAL REPORT REALISED BY SUPPORTED BY ON BEHALF OF EDITORIAL 3 The Raiffeisen Super League consists of myriad companies in Switzerland,
FOSSIL GROUP, INC. REPORTS FOURTH QUARTER AND FISCAL YEAR 2014 RESULTS; Fourth Quarter Net Sales of $1.065 Billion; Diluted EPS Increases 12% to $3.00 Fiscal Year 2014 Net Sales Increase 8% to $3.510 Billion;
UNLEASHING ENTREPRENEURS HOW EASY IS IT TO START A SUCCESSFUL DIGITAL BUSINESS? THE STATUS QUO One of the fascinating elements of entrepreneurs is that they come in all shapes, sizes, ages and can be from
How Big Will the Debt and Equity Crowdfunding Investment Market Be? Comparisons, Assumptions, and Estimates Jason Best Center for Entrepreneurship and Technology UC Berkeley College of Engineering Sherwood
GUTZWILLER ONE Contractual Investment Fund Under Swiss Law (Securities Fund) Simplified Prospectus 30.09.2013 www.swissfunddata.ch: spd-2830_00-20130930-en Fund Manager: Custodian Bank: E. Gutzwiller &
WELCOME DÜRR AKTIENGESELLSCHAFT CONFERENCE CALL PRELIMINARY FIGURES FISCAL YEAR 2014 Ralf W. Dieter, CEO Ralph Heuwing, CFO Bietigheim-Bissingen, March 9, 2015 www.durr.com DISCLAIMER This presentation
Crowdfunding: Game Changer for Small Business? Office of Investment and Innovation Presentation Outline: - Background on crowdfunding to date - Current state of crowdfunding in light of SEC proposed rules
20 IP Finance Toolkit 5. Funding Available for IP-Rich Businesses Introduction As the Banking on IP? report notes; SMEs first port of call for finance is often a bank. Figures quoted in the report show
Finance Initiative Innovative financing for sustainability The Asset Management Working Group What, why, who? Environmental and social issues count. Goldman Sachs Global Investment Research, February 2004.
Contact: Charlene Hamrah (Investment Community) (212) 770-7074 Joe Norton (News Media) (212) 770-3144 AIG REPORTS FIRST QUARTER 2006 NET INCOME OF $3.20 BILLION NEW YORK, NY, May 10, 2006 American International
Your bid for growth funds Supporting your business with financing decisions Contents 3 Introduction 4 Preparing your application 6 Assessing applications 8 What Barclays considers 9 Funding solutions 10
Frequently Asked Questions Q3 2006 1. Were there any unusual or one-time items in your Q3 results? CIBC s reported diluted earnings per share (EPS) for the third quarter were $1.86. Our EPS was increased
P R E S S R E L E A S E 2 0 Ja nua ry 2016 Berenberg reports big profit increase: Net profit more than doubles from last year Net profit for the year jumps from 40 million to record 104 million Gross income
The Economic Significance of the Swiss Financial Sector Executive Summary October 2015 Issued by BAK Basel Economics AG Project Manager Rebekka Rufer, T +41 61 279 97 09 email@example.com Editorial
Case Id: 6793f8c7-c6ef-45dd-8987-665fe5775337 Date: 13/05/2015 23:30:38 Public consultation on Building a Capital Markets Union Fields marked with * are mandatory. Introduction The purpose of the Green
UNDERSTANDING DEBT AND EQUITY CROWDFUNDING FROM A LEGAL PERSPECTIVE What Is Crowdfunding? In today s economy the term crowdfunding can take on many contexts but it is, by definition, the practice of funding
PRIVATE LABEL FUNDS The PLF business is strategically important for GAM, Switzerland s leading PLF provider not tied to a specific bank. 04 YOUR PARTNER FOR PLF SOLUTIONS FOR 20 YEARS 05 CREATE YOUR OWN
Sources of Financing for Innovative SMEs: Public Sector Funds, Banks, Business Angels and Seed Funds, Venture Capitalists, Luigi Amati CEO META Group THIRD WIPO-INSME INTERNATIONAL TRAINING PROGRAM: FINANCING
interim report 2004June 30, 2004 Macroeconomic trends In the first quarter of 2004, the euro-area economy grew 0.6% sequentially. This represented a faster pace of growth than in the previous quarters.
VIRGIN MONEY: Q3 2015 TRADING UPDATE Virgin Money Holdings (UK) plc (the Group ) has delivered a strong trading performance in the third quarter of 2015 as it continues to create Britain s leading challenger
Grow VC Group ++ www.growvc.com ++ @growvc ++ Copyrights Grow VC Group 2014 smart city expo 2014 Valto Loikkanen For twitter @valto #startupecosystem About me As an Entrepreneur 20 years as international
QUARTERLY STATEMENT AS OF MARCH 31, 2015 TO OUR SHAREHOLDERS Patrik Heider, Spokesman of the Executive Board and CFOO The Nemetschek Group has made a dynamic start in the 2015 financial year and continues
Retail Banking: Innovation distinguishes between the leaders and the followers GRANT THORNTON FINANCIAL SERVICES GROUP SEPTEMBER 2013 10-30% of customers make up 90% of profits 1 New entrants Customers
The Value of Consulting An analysis of the tangible benefits of using management consultancy Management Consultancies Association 2010 March 2010 2 The Value of Consulting CONTENTS Foreword 3 Executive