1 AMERICAN JOURNAL OF INDUSTRIAL MEDICINE 9:9 (I 99) Asbestos Exposure and Ovarian Fiber Burden Debra. Heller, MD, Ronald E. Gordon, PhD, Carolyn Westhoff, MD, and Susan Gerber, MD Epidemiologic studies suggest increased risk of epithelial ovarian cancer in female asbestos workers and increased risk of malignancy in general in household contacts of asbestos workers. Ovaries were studied,from women with household contact with men with documented asbestos exposure and from I women undergoing incidental oophorectomv. Ovarian tissue w*as examined by analytic electron microscopy. Significant asbestos fiber burdens were detected in 9 out of women with household asbestos exposure (9.%), and in out of I women who gave no exposure history (%). Three exposed women had asbestos counts over I millioii fibers per gram wet weight (%). but onlv / women without an exposure history had a count that high (%). Although asbestos has been documented as a contaminant of some older cosmetic talc preparations, the chrysotile and cmcidolite types of asbestos we detected are more indicative of background ari&or occupational exposure. This study demonstrates that asbestos can reach the. Although the number of subjects is small, asbestos appears to be present in ovarian tissue niorr,frequently and in higher atnounts in women with a documentable exposure history. 0 I99 WiIevLiss, /nc. KEY WORDS: asbestos,, talc, environmental exposure INTRODUCTION Epidemiologic evidence suggests that there is an increased risk of ovarian carcinoma in female asbestos workers [Acheson et al., 9; Graham and Graham, 9; Keal, 90; Newhouse et al., 9, 9; Wignall and Fox, 9. and animal data show changes resembling early ovarian carcinoma after intraperitoneal injection of asbestos [Graham and Graham, 9. In addition, household contacts of asbestos workers have been shown to be at increased risk of developing asbestosrelated disease [Joubert et al.. 99; Roggli and Longo. 99, so female household contacts of asbestos workers may also be at risk of ovarian exposure to asbestos. There is literature that supports that perineal talc exposure increases the risk of ovarian carcinoma. However, some of these data have been clouded by the fact that cosmetic talc was often contaminated with asbestos in the past, particularly before I9 [Cramer et al., 9. Particulate matter can reach the female peritoneal cavity via the transvaginal route [Egli and Newton, 9; Henderson et al., 9: Joubert et al., 99. A woman exposed to her husband s occupationally contaminated laundry may have asbestos enter the peritoneal cavity by passive transfer, or even by sexual relations. The purpose of this study was to determine whether women exposed to asbestos have a high asbestos fiber burden in their ovaries. MATERIALS AND METHODS College of Physicians and Surgeons, Columbia University, New York, New York (D.S.H., C.W., S.G.). Mount Sinai School of Medicine, New York, New York (R.E.G.). Address reprint requests to Debra S. Heller, M.D., Ob/Gyn PathologyP&S 0, College of Physicians & Surgeons, 0 West th Street, New York, NY 00. Accepted for publication July, 99. Eligible women were contacted by postcard with the assistance of a law firm specializing in asbestosrelated, claims. Women with household contact to asbestos, as documented by interview, and who had themselves previously undergone ovarian surgery, were invited to participate. No women with direct occupational exposure responded WileyLiss, Inc.
2 Heller et al. TABLE. Demographics and Pathologic Findings Among Patients With Household Contacts Evaluated for AsbestosRelated Disease Oophorectomized Between 999, and Oophorectomized Patients With a History of Asbestos Exposure From the Columbia Presbyterian Medical Center Benign Neoplasm Study, Asbestosfibers per gram wet Subject Reason for surgery weight limits of detection Asbestos exposure ga oa lla a a Papillary serous cystadenocarcinoma of Mucinous cystadenocarcinoma of Endometrial adenocarcinoma Atypical hyperplasia of endometrium Endometriosis of Leiomyoma uteri Serous cystadenoma of, fibroma of Endometrial adenocarcinoma Cystadenofibroma of Benign epithelial cyst of Serous cystadenoma of Cystadenofibroma of Cystadenofibroma of 90. chrysotile: crocidolite.,,0 chrysotile: crocidolite :l, chrysotile,9 chwsotile,, chrysotile.,oo chrysotile: tremolite :l 9,0 chrysotile: crocidolite :l 9, chrysotile,00 crocidolite 0,90,,,,,9,9,.,,,0.9 Husbandpipefitter with asbestos Fatherdied of mesothelioma; husbandasbestosis (both insulators) Husbandasbestosis, carpenter in a factory Husbandinsulator, died of lung cancer Father and auntworked in asbestos plant; fatherdied of lung cancer, aunt of asbestosis Fatherasbestosis, asbestos and insulation worker Husbandinsulation worker Husbanddied of asbestosis;a worked as carpenter and with concrete brothersconstruction workers Fathershipyard worker and school engineer Household membershipyard worker x years Fathershipyard worker Household contact construction/insulation x years asubjects from Columbia Presbyterian Medical Center Benign Neoplasm Study Women with both benign and malignant disease responded. Women undergoing oophorectomy for benign ovarian neoplasms at Columbia Presbyterian Medical Center who were interviewed in depth for another study were available as controls and were included after ascertaining asbestos exposure history and availability of nonneoplastic ovarian tissue for analysis. These women were chosen for the availability of interviews as well as tissue. Five of these women were found to have sustained asbestos exposure. There were exposed subjects and women who gave no history of exposure. Tissue from two stillborn ovaries was also analyzed. Tissue blocks of benign adjacent or contralateral ovarian tissue as available were obtained, and analytic electron microscopy was performed according to the subsequent protocol. Hematoxylin and eosin stained sections of ana lyzed tissue were examined. There was no evidence of response to asbestos such as foreign body giant cell reactions or fibrosis in the tissue. Ovarian tissue does not undergo fibrosis as does lung. Analytic Electron Microscopy Protocol Ovarian tissue in blocks was deparaffinized, rehydrated, blotted dry, and weighed. Digestion with % KOH was performed at 0 C for hr. After complete digestion, the tissue was centrifuged at,000 rpm for 0 min. The KOH was removed, leaving a pellet to which approximately 0 ml of distilled water was added. The pellet was resuspended by using a microultrasonic cell disrupter at 0 watts for sec. Centrifugation, distilled water wash, and
3 Ovarian Asbestos Fiber Burden TABLE. Demographics and Pathologic Findings Among Oophorectomized Patients With No History of Asbestos ExposureColumbia Presbyterian Medical Center Benign Neoplasm Study, 9999 Asbestos llbers per Exposure Control Reason lor surgery gram wet weight Llmlts of detection history subjects serous cystadenomas/simple cyst benign cystic teratomdstruma ovarii endometriomdendometriosis fibrothecoma mucinous cystadenoma Endometriosis, benign cystic teratoma Endometrioma of Benign cystic teratoma of Endometrioma of Serous cystadenoma of Benign cystic teratoma of Below detectable limits, chrysotile: crocidolite : 09,09 chrysotile: crocidolite :,9 chrysotile, chrysotile: crocidolite : 9, crocidolite,, chrysotile greater than.,9.,,0,0, microultrasonic cell disrupter were repeated times. The distilled water was removed and the pellet was resuspended in 0 ml of distilled water. Tenpl drops of the final suspension were placed on nickel Formvar and carboncoated locator grids and air dried. Transmission electron microscopy to identify fibers, and their size was performed. The identity of the fibers was determined by energydispersive spectroscopy and confirmed by electron diffraction (SAED). Grids were viewed at both 0,000 and 9,000 diameters. All fibers observed were counted. Routinely, as they are opened or distilled water at each filtering, all solutions are checked for detectable limits of asbestos fibers. All places where asbestos could have contaminated the specimen, such as paraffin, are also controlled for paraffin blocks from each different source. All solutions are checked by passing the fluids through a 0.pm Nucleopore filter to maximize the efficiency of detecting and counting fibers present in these solutions and materials. The solutions that are routinely tested are distilled water, KOH, and xylene. If detectable levels of asbestos fibers exist in the solutions used to initially fix and process the tissue because they came from different hospitals, at which it was not possible to test these solutions directly, they would be detected in the paraffin controls. We have yet to identify detectable levels in any of the solutions or paraffin. RESULTS A summary of the results can be seen in Tables I and. Nine of the women exposed to asbestos had asbestos in their ovarian tissue (9.%), with (%) of them having counts over million fibers per gram of wet weight. Among the controls, / women had detectable asbestos in their ovaries (%), with only (%) patient with a count over million fibers per gram wet weight. In addition, talc was detected in / exposed women (%) and in all controls (00%). No asbestos or talc was detected in the stillborn material. All fibers were counted and analyzed for type and size. The results of that analysis are summarized in Table. In general, the fibers were relatively small with regard to length and narrow in diameter. However, the great majority of fibers were greater than pm with a minimum aspect ratio of 0. Except for one case, in which tremolite was observed, the fibers were either chrysotile or crocidolite, or both. DISCUSSION Epithelial ovarian carcinoma is a major cause of female mortality [Greene et al., 9. Epithelial ovarian cancer
4 Heller et al. TABLE. Asbestos Fibers in Ovarian Tissues: Type, Number, and Dimensions No. of t pm 0 pm >0 pm to.pm 0.0.pm >0.pm Subject fibers Fiber type long long long diameter diameter diameter a ga lla a lb b b b b b Tremolite a 'From Table I. 'From Table II develops from the surface epithelium of the, which is embryologically derived from the same tissue as the mesothelium of the abdominal cavity, the celomic epithelium [Falkson, 9. Thus, ovarian carcinoma and malignant mesothelioma of the peritoneal cavity are believed by some to be related neoplasms [Parmely and Woodruff, 9). Asbestos causes malignant mesothelioma, and there is evidence to support it as an etiology in ovarian carcinoma as well [Acheson et al., 9; Falkson, 9; Graham and Graham, 9; Keal. 90; Newhouse, 99; Newhouse et al., 9, 9; Whittemore et al.. 9; Wignall and Fox, 9. Intraperitoneal injection of tremolite asbestos into guinea pigs and rabbits was shown to cause epithelial changes in their ovaries similar to those seen in early ovarian cancer [Graham and Graham, 9. These investigator$ also found birefiingent crystalline material near these epithelial changes, but no further attempt was made to identify the material. No such material was found in controls. Asbestos fibers have been shown to be cytotoxic to Chinese hamster (CHO) cells, an epithelioid cell culture line [Neugut et al., 9. Several investigators have cited an increased mortality from ovarian cancer in female asbestos workers exposed as gas mask assemblers or other factory workers [Acheson et al., 9; Newhouse, 99; Newhouse et al., 9, 9; Wignall and Fox, 9. In addition, it is known that household contacts of asbestos exposed workers are also at increased risk of developing malignant disease in general [Joubert et al., 99; Roggli and Longo, 99. In a study of histologically confirmed malignant mesotheliomas in women, most with no occupational exposure of their own, a significant number were found to have husbands or fathers who worked in an asbestosrelated industry [Vianna and Polan, 9, and the findings suggested indirect exposure to a husband as the most important factor. The fact that exposure to a husband is more significant than exposure to a father suggests a possible role for sexual contact as a transporting vector for asbestos fibers. Household exposure has been related to the asbestos dust on the workers' clothing, with risk to those who launder the clothing [Joubert et al., 99. While this may be the exposure source in wives as well as in daughters, it is possible that sexual contact with a male contaminated with asbestos fibers introduces those fibers into the vagina of his partner, where they can reach the peritoneal cavity. There is evi
5 Ovarian Asbestos Fiber Burden 9 dence of transport of particulate matter into the female peritoneum by the transvaginal route, in both human and animal studies [Egli and Newton, 9; Henderson et al., 9; Venter and Iturralde, 99. Whittemore et al. [ 9 suggested that vaginal exposure to particulate matter such as asbestos and talc was a potential risk factor for intraperitoneal ovarian exposure. Her conclusion was based on finding that in talcexposed women, a previous history of hysterectomy or tuba ligation, which blocks peritoneal access, was protective against ovarian cancer. Talc has also been implicated as a possible etiologic agent in ovarian cancer [Harlow et al., and this is related to the asbestos problem in several ways. Aside from the chemical similarities between the two, many cosmetic talcs contained significant amounts of asbestos, particularly prior to 9 [Cramer et al., 9. The significance of the detection of talc in the majority of the exposed women and in all women giving no exposure history is unclear, and further studies are under way to further elucidate this association. CONCLUSIONS In our study, the women with a positive exposure history had asbestos detected in their ovaries more frequently, and in higher counts. of the exposed subjects in this study was directly occupationally exposed, but all were passively exposed to a household contact. It is unclear why so many of the women giving no exposure history did have detectable asbestos in their ovaries, although it is known that there is a background level of asbestos in the lung tissue of nonexposed individuals. All our available control patients were selected from a group of extensively interviewed women with benign ovarian neoplasms. Further studies are aimed at women with no ovarian pathology. The significance of the finding of asbestos in ovaries requires further investigation. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS This work was supported by a grant from the Columbia Presbyterian Cancer Center. The authors wish to thank Norman Katz for technical assistance. Acheson ED. Gardner MJ. Pippard EC. Grime LP (9): Mortality of two groups of women who manufactured gas masks from chrysotile and crocidolite asbestos: A 0 year followup. Br J Ind Med 9:. Cramer DW. Welch WR. Scully RE, Wojciechowski CA (9): Ovarian cancer and talca casecontrol study. Cancer 0:. Egli GE, Newton M (9): The transport of carbon particles in the human female reproductive tract. Fertil Steril :. Falkson CI (9): Mesothelioma or ovarian carcinoma: A case report. S Afr Med J :. Graham J, Graham R (9): Ovarian cancer and asbestos. Environ Res I : I. Greene MH, Clark JW, Blayney DW (9): The epidemiology of ovarian cancer. Semin Oncol :09. Harlow BL, Cramer DW, Bell DA. Welch WR (99): Perineal exposure to talc and ovarian cancer risk. Obstet Gynecol 0: 9. Harlow BL, Weiss NS (99): A casecontrol study of borderline ovarian tumors: The influence of perineal exposure to talc. Am J Epidemiol 0: 909. Henderson WJ, Joslin CA, Turnbull AC. Griffiths K (9): Talc and carcinoma of the and cervix. J Obstet Gynaecol Br Commonw :. Henderson WJ, Hamilton TC. Griffiths K (99): Talc in normal and malignant ovarian tissue. Lancet :99. Henderson WJ. Hamilton TC. Baylis MS, Pierrepoint LG, Griftiths K (9): The demonstration of the migration of talc from the vagina and posterior uterus to the in the rat. Environ Res 00. Joubert L. Seidman H, Selikoff IJ (99): Mortality experience of family contacts of asbestos factory workers. Ann NY Acad Sci :. Keal EE ( 90): Asbestosis and abdominal neoplasnis. Lancet :. Longo DL, Young RC (99): Cosmetic talc and ovarian cancer. Lancet :9. Neugut AI, Eisenberg D. Silverstein M. Pulkrabek P, Weinstein IB (9): Effects of asbestos on epithelioid cell lines. Environ Res :. Newhouse M (99): Cosmetic talc and ovarian cancer. Lancet. Newhouse ML, Berry G, Wagner JC. Turok ME (9): A study of mortality of female asbestos workers. Br J Ind Med 9:. Newhouse ML. Berry G. Wagner JC (9): Mortality of factory workers in East London 90. Br J Ind Med : I. Parmely TH, Woodruff JD (9): The ovarian mesothelioma. Am J Obstet Gynecol 0:, Roggli VL. Longo WE (99): Mineral fiber content of lung tissue in patients with environmental exposures: Household contacts vs building occupants. Ann NY Acad Sci. Scully RE (99): Atlas of Tumor Pathology. nd Series, Fascicle : Tumors of the Ovaries and Maldeveloped Gonads. Washington, DC: Armed Forces Institute of Pathology. Venter PF, Iturralde M (99): Migration of a particulate radioactive tracer from the vagina to the peritoneal cavity and ovaries. S Afr Med J :9 99. Vianna NJ, Polan AK (9): Nonoccupational exposure to asbestos and malignant mesothelioma in females. Lancet I: 00. Whittemore AS. Wu ML, Paffenbarger RS. Sarles DL. Kainpert JB. Grosser S, Jung DL, Ballon S, Hendrickson M (9): Personal and environmental characteristics related to epithelial ovarian cancer.. Exposures to talcum powder, tobacco, alcohol, and coffee. Am J Epidemiol : I 0. Wignall BK, Fox AJ (9): Mortality of female gas mask assemblers. Br J Ind Med 9:.
1 Risk Anal. 2004 Jun;24(3):547-52. Related Articles, Links Mesothelioma among brake mechanics: an expanded analysis of a casecontrol study. Hessel PA, Teta MJ, Goodman M, Lau E. Exponent, Wood Dale, IL
Home Search Collections Journals About Contact us My IOPscience Heterogeneity of exposure and attribution of mesothelioma: Trends and strategies in two American counties This content has been downloaded
Fiber Analysis Vignettes An Inconvenient Truth Victor L. Roggli, M.D. Duke University Medical Center PO Box 3712 DUMC Durham, NC 27710 (919) 668-5440 firstname.lastname@example.org Victor L. Roggli, M.D., is a professor
Epidemiology of Mesothelioma and Historical Background Abstract Mesothelioma is a new malignant disease strongly associated with exposure to amphibole asbestos exposure (amosite and crocidolite) environmentally
Ministry of Defence Synopsis of Causation Mesothelioma Author: Dr David Jenkins, Medical Author, Medical Text, Edinburgh Validator: Professor Mark Britton, St Peter s Hospital, Chertsey, Surrey September
Toxicology Page 1 of 6 Asbestos exposure and malignant mesothelioma of the tunica vaginalis testis: and review of the literature C Meisenkothen 1 *, MM Finkelstein 2,3 Abstract Introduction We aim to report
Abuse of Epidemiology: Automobile Manufacturers Manufacture a Defense to Asbestos Liability DAVID S. EGILMAN, MD, MPH, MARION A. BILLINGS, MSC Much of the debate about the relationship between asbestos
Exhibit A Kane Legal Mesothelioma Handbook Volume No. 1 David Kane, R.Ph., J.D. Professor of Pharmacy Law, Rutgers University Table of Contents Section 1 History of Asbestos...2 Section 2 - What is Mesothelioma?...3
A Patient s Guide to Mesothelioma What Is Mesothelioma? Causes and Risk Factors Finding a Specialist Treatment Options Legal Decisions Resources cure C a n c e r U p d at e s, R e s e a r c h & E d u c
6. MODELLING THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN RISK, DOSE AND TIME 6.1 Introduction and rationale 6.2 Dose-time relationships observed in epidemiological studies 6.3 Multistage models of carcinogenesis 6.4 Interpretation
Editorials Radiology Heber MacMahon, MB, BCh, BAO John H. M. Austin, MD Gordon Gamsu, MD Christian J. Herold, MD James R. Jett, MD David P. Naidich, MD Edward F. Patz, Jr, MD Stephen J. Swensen, MD Published
Chapter 2 Measurement of exposures and outcomes 2.1 Introduction Most epidemiological research involves the study of the relationship of one type of event or characteristic to another. Consider the following
What is Mesothelioma? Mesothelioma is a rare type of cancer that develops in the mesothelial cells found in one s body. These cells form membranous linings that surround and protect the body s organs and
Environmental and Occupational Causes of Cancer A Review of Recent Scientific Literature Richard W. Clapp, D.Sc. Genevieve K. Howe, MPH Molly M. Jacobs, MPH Prepared by Boston University School of Public
A Review of the Definition for Multiple Primary Cancers in the United States Workshop Proceedings From December 4-6, 2002, in Princeton, New Jersey Editor: Holly L. Howe, Ph.D. Executive Director NAACCR
This article was downloaded by: [220.127.116.11] On: 17 August 2015, At: 11:03 Publisher: Taylor & Francis Informa Ltd Registered in England and Wales Registered Number: 1072954 Registered office: 5 Howick
KATHERINE M.A. O REILLY, M.D., Southampton General Hospital, Southampton, United Kingdom ANNE MARIE MCLAUGHLIN, M.B., St. Vincent s University Hospital, Dublin, Ireland WILLIAM S. BECKETT, M.D., and PATRICIA
AMERICAN JOURNAL OF INDUSTRIAL MEDICINE (2009) Case Control Study of Pleural Mesothelioma in Workers With Social Security in Mexico Guadalupe Aguilar-Madrid, MD, MSc, PhD, 1 Eduardo Robles-Pérez, MD, MSc,
ENVIRONMENTAL CARCINOGENS Agent Orange and Cancer: An Overview for Clinicians This column is provided to help practitioners discuss potential environmental and workplace carcinogens, offering reassurance
Maturitas 48 (2004) 13 18 Critical comment HRT and gynaecologic cancer after WHI: old stuff or new doubts? Piero Sismondi, Nicoletta Biglia Academic Department of Gynaecological Oncology, Mauriziano Umberto
The new england journal of medicine original article Asbestos Exposure, Pleural Mesothelioma, and Serum Osteopontin Levels Harvey I. Pass, M.D., Dan Lott, B.S., Fulvio Lonardo, M.D., Michael Harbut, M.D.,
Safe Work Practices for Handling Asbestos About WorkSafeBC WorkSafeBC (the Workers Compensation Board) is an independent provincial statutory agency governed by a Board of Directors. It is funded by insurance
Australian participants in British nuclear tests in Australia Vol 2: Mortality and cancer incidence May 2006 Richard Gun, Jacqueline Parsons, Philip Ryan, Philip Crouch and Janet Hiller Discipline of Public
Zabic v Alcan Gove Pty Ltd  NTSC 1 PARTIES: ZABIC, Zorko v ALCAN GOVE PTY LTD (ACN 000 453 663) TITLE OF COURT: JURISDICTION: SUPREME COURT OF THE NORTHERN TERRITORY SUPREME COURT OF THE NORTHERN
December 7, 2006 Where Are Mesothelioma Claims Heading? Paul Hinton, Ron Miller, Faten Sabry, and Fred Dunbar NERA Economic Consulting i Table of Contents I. Introduction...1 II. III. Background...1 Evidence
Asbestosis in Louisiana: A Descriptive Review and Demographic Analysis of Hospitalizations for Asbestosis, 1999-2009 Cassandra Davis, MPH; Jayaprabha Vijaykumar MD, MPH; Michelle Lackovic, MPH; James H.
Preparing an estimate of the national pattern of exposure to asbestos in cases of malignant mesothelioma JULY 2008 Copyright Notice Commonwealth of Australia 2008 ISBN 978 0 642 32792 5 This work is copyright.